Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
+
Date of Decision : 26.05.2026
FAO (COMM) 122/2026
M/S QUALITY ENGINEERS AND
CONTRACTORS
.....Appellant
Through: Mr. Vishwendra Verma, Advocate.
versus
M/S DISTRIBUTION LOGISTICS
INFRASTRUCTURE PRIVATE LTD
.....Respondents
Through: None.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V. KAMESWAR RAO
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA
V. KAMESWAR RAO, J. (ORAL)
CM APPL No. 28130/2026 (condonation of delay in refiling)
1.
For the reasons stated in the application, the delay of 146 days in re-
filing the appeal is condoned.
2.
The application stands disposed of.
CM APPL No. 28131/2026 (condonation of delay in filing)
3.
For the reasons stated in the application, the delay of 5 days in filing
the appeal is condoned.
4.
The application stands disposed of.
FAO (COMM) 122/2026 and CM APPL. 28128/2026(Stay)
5.
This is an appeal filed by the appellant under Section 37 of the
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (the Act) challenging the order dated
15.09.2025 passed by the learned District Judge (Commercial Court-01),
Patiala House Courts, New Delhi (learned District Judge) in OMP (COMM)
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
17:01:59
FAO (COMM) 122/2026
No.25/2020 whereby the learned District Judge has dismissed the petition
filed by the appellant under Section 34 of the Act challenging the interim
award (award) dated 09.01.2020 passed by the learned Arbitrator whereby
the learned Arbitrator has allowed the application filed by the respondent
under Order VII Rule 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC) by
stating in paragraph no.9 onwards as under:“9. For the purpose of deciding the application under O.VII
R.11 CPC, the Tribunal has to confine itself only to the
Statement of Claim and the averments made therein along
with the annexed documents. From the respective stands
taken by the parties, it would be seen that there is no dispute
with the proposition that the limitation period would be 3
years from the date when the work is completed in terms of
Article 18 of Limitation Act; the right to get payment begins
upon completion of work. Therefore, the crucial date to
decide as to when the period of limitation would start to
run, would be the date when as per the claimant, the work
was completed
10. Ld. counsel for the respondent referred to Para 25 of the
Statement of Claim where the claimant averred that after
completion of the work on 20.08.2015, various invoices
were raised. The details of the invoices have been given in
Para No.25 of the Statement of Claim and the last one is
20th August, 2015. These final invoices were sent vide email
dated 22.08.2015. There is nothing in the Statement of
Claim to show that any work was done subsequently to infer
that the period of limitation would start from any such
subsequent date. Therefore, even considering 22.08.2015 to
be the starting point of limitation period, the claim could
have been raised till 21.08.2018 Thus, the present claim
would be certainly barred by limitation.
11. The claimant has relied upon various communications
between the parties to urge that limitation period got
extended as there was no denial of deb payable by the
respondent and in fact, there had been admissions/
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
17:01:59
FAO (COMM) 122/2026
acknowledgment made by the respondent to the extent of
Rs.16,75,128/-. It is contended that such admission of debt
would amount to valid acknowledgement within the
meaning of section 18 of the Limitation Ac to extend the
period of limitation and start it afresh.
12. However, this Tribunal does not find itself in agreement
with the said contention of the claimant. For the purpose of
Section 18 of the Limitation Act, there has to an
unequivocal and express acknowledgement of liability
before expiration of limitation period, which should be in
writing and signed by the respondent. It is also trite that this
acknowledgement may omit to specify the exact nature of
property or right or refusal to pay or to perform.
13. In the present matter, none of the correspondences
between the parties, would show any such unequivocal
acknowledgement of liability towards any amount over and
above Rs.16,75,128/-. There has been no admission or
acceptance of any liability over this amount by the
respondent in any of letters/emails written by it. There is not
even a single correspondence in which the respondent had
accepted that it was liable to pay a sum of Rs.84,04,943/- to
the claimant. It is also well settled that mere
correspondence between the patties whereby continuous
demands are made by a claimant, would not extend the
period of limitation. A person cannot postpone the accrual
of cause of action or extend the period of limitation by
repeatedly writing letters or sending reminders. No fresh
period of limitation can arise simply because letters and
reminders are written time and again attempting to keep the
claim alive. Reliance can be placed on the Judgements titled
as Municipal Corporation of Delhi v. M/s. Gurbachan Singh
& Sons [208 (2014) DLT 177] and Geo Miller & Co. Pvt.
Ltd. v. Chairman, Rajasthan Vidyut Utpadan Nigam Ltd.
[2019 SCC Online 1137 (SC)). Therefore, even if it is
considered that the claimant had been repeatedly asking for
its payments but the respondent kept on raising objections
or demanding more documents or assuring to make the
balance payments or disputing the correctness of
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
17:01:59
FAO (COMM) 122/2026
outstanding amount or denying making the payments,
verbally or in writing, that would not amount to
acknowledgement of liability so as to extend the period of
limitation. Most of the correspondences relied upon by the
claimant are one-sided written by it to the respondent which
would obviously not amount to admission of debt or
liability. As far as replies of the respondent are concerned,
there has been no admission or acknowledgement of any
amount, whatsoever other than Rs.16,75,128/-.
14. At the same time, the Tribunal cannot ignore the e-mail
dated 19.07.2018 in which there has been a clear,
categorical, unconditional, unequivocal and unambiguous
admission of liability to the tune of Rs.16,75,128/- by the
respondent. This admission of liability in writing has been
made by the respondent before expiry of limitation period
and has been reiterated even in its reply dated 08.10.2018
to the claimant's legal notice dated 10.09.2018. There is no
reason for this Tribunal to exclude these admissions from
the purview of Section 18 of Limitation Act. Such
acceptance of liability would not only amount to
acknowledgement of liability so as to extend the period of
limitation but also would amount to admission of debt of
this amount.
15. This Tribunal is of the view that the legal proposition
would remain that acknowledgement of this portion of claim
i.e Rs.16,75,128/- would not amount to acknowledgement of
entire claim of Rs.84,04,943/- raised by the claimant, so as
to extend the period of limitation. The law laid down in
various judicial pronouncements as relied upon by the
respondent, K. M. Muhammed Sultan Rowther v. K. S. M.
Muhamed Nurdin [(1963) 1 MLJ 300], Mohammad Dalil
Khan v. State of Hyderabad [AIR 1963 AP 216],
Bindeshwari Prasad v. District Board of Saran (AIR 1964
Pat 134), S. P. Moldu v. Kerala State Electricity Board [ILR
1980(2) Kerala 499] is that the limitation would be saved
only with respect to the definite sum that had been
acknowledged and not of the amount, of which there has
been no clear acknowledgement. Similar view has been
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
17:01:59
FAO (COMM) 122/2026
taken in the judgment titled Vijayalaksmi Art Productions v.
Vijaya Productions Pvt Ltd. (1996 (2) CTC 396, 1995 SCC
Online Mad 498). No contrary view has been pointed out to
have been taken by any court by the claimant. Hence,
admission of its liability towards the claimant by the
respondent to the tune of Rs.16,75,128/- would extend the
period of limitation qua this amount and nothing beyond.
Therefore, the entire claim of the claimant over and above
this amount would certainly be barred by limitation and the
claim would therefore be liable to be rejected on this
ground.
16. At the same time, in the correspondence between the
parties prior to filing of the Statement of Claim, admission
of liability of Rs.16,75,128/- has been certainly unequivocal
and unconditional. The stand taken by the respondent in its
reply before this forum, asserting that the said amount is the
5% retention amount that was payable to the claimant only
if and when certain conditions were satisfied which
remained unsatisfied and thus amount was not payable, was
never taken by the respondent in any of its previous
communications including the email dated 19.07.2018 and
the reply dated 08.10.2018 to the claimant's legal notice.
The said communications point towards unconditional
acknowledgement of liability to this extent, without any
further qualification or compliance. It had been
categorically admitted by the respondent that this amount
was reflected in their account books to be payable to the
claimant. Therefore, such correspondence would certainly
amount to admission of liability to this extent, for which the
claimant would be entitled to get an Award forthwith in its
favour without further evidence.
17. In view of above discussion, the second application
moved by the claimant under O.XII R.6 CPC is allowed and
the claimant shall be entitled to recover Rs.16,75,128/- from
the respondent.
18. The first application moved by the respondent under O.
VII R. 11 CPC is allowed and the claim of the claimant over
and above the sum of Rs. 16,75,128/- is held to be barred by
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
17:01:59
FAO (COMM) 122/2026
limitation and liable to be dismissed.
19. Both the applications stand disposed of accordingly.
INTERIM AWARD
1. Claimant's claim for recovery of Rs.67,29,815/(84,04,943-16,75,128) is rejected being barred by
limitation.
2 The claimant is entitled to recover Rs. 16,75,328/- from
the respondent.
3. The respondent is directed to pay Rs.16,75,128/- within
one month from the date of the order falling which it would
attract interest @ 9% per annum from the date of Interim
Award till its realization.
4. DIAC Signed copy of the Interim Award be given to both
the parties and DIAC.”
6.
The learned Arbitrator vide the impugned order has allowed the claim
of the appellant only to the extent of Rs.16,75,128/- against the respondent,
on an application filed under Order XII Rule 6 CPC, and by accepting the
plea of limitation of the respondent, for the claim over and above Rs.
16,75,128/-.
7.
The facts to be noted from the record are that the appellant filed the
claim against the respondent for recovery of Rs.84,04,943/- with interest @
24% per annum. It was the case of the appellant that the respondent had,
assigned the work to the appellant for a sum of Rs.2,28,13,193/- which was
completed by the appellant, but the respondent did not make the due
payments.
8.
It was the case of the appellant that it had completed the original work
and also the additional work assigned to it from time to time by the
respondent and raised the final bill for payment to the tune of
Rs.2,98,41,535/- against which, it received an amount of Rs.2,14,36,592/-,
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
17:01:59
FAO (COMM) 122/2026
but an amount of Rs.84,04,943/- was outstanding, for which the appellant
raised a dispute, which was referred to the arbitration. In the claim petition,
the appellant relied upon the invoices dated 20.08.2015, 19.02.2015 and
12.07.2014. It was the case of the appellant that the respondent had admitted
that a sum of Rs.5,99,927/- was unpaid. It was also stated that, on
31.07.2018, the respondent categorically admitted that, as per the books of
account, the balance amount of Rs.16,75,128/- is payable to the appellant. A
legal notice dated 10.09.2018 was sent by the appellant, which was duly
replied to by the respondent on 08.10.2018.
9.
The case of the appellant before the learned Arbitrator was that,
whenever it demanded the payment from the respondent, it raised various
objections and asked to furnish various documents. It was also stated that the
appellant had completed all the work. He also relied upon the email dated
09.11.2016 wherein the respondent has admitted that some amount has to be
paid. The appellant had also relied upon various communications including
the documents, viz bank details/cancelled cheque, request for no claim
certificate,
legal
notice
etc.,
to
contend,
the
same
constitute
acknowledgment.
10.
During the Arbitral Proceedings, the appellant relied upon the reply
dated 08.10.2018 to the legal notice of the appellant wherein the respondent
had admitted its liability to pay Rs.16,75,128/-. It was in this context, an
application under Order XII Rule 6 of the CPC was filed seeking the
judgment/award to the tune of Rs.16,75,128/-.
11.
The case of the respondent before the learned Arbitrator was that the
appellant is not entitled to the sum of Rs.16,75,128/- which happens to be
5% of the retention amount, which was payable to the appellant only when
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
17:01:59
FAO (COMM) 122/2026
the conditions as mentioned in the letter of intent to provide the bank
guarantee for defect liability period is satisfied. Since, the said condition
was never satisfied by the appellant, as such there is no unequivocal
admission on the part of the respondent acknowledging the payment as
sought in the claim.
12.
The learned Arbitrator in the order dated 09.01.2020 also considered
the application under Order VII Rule 11 of the CPC filed by the respondent
seeking dismissal of the claim petition on the ground of limitation. The
learned Arbitrator while considering the application of the respondent under
Order VII Rule 11 of the CPC also considered the application under Order
XII Rule 6 of the CPC. The Arbitrator held that the limitation period would
be three years from the date of completion of work in view of Article 18 of
the Schedule of the Limitation Act, 1963. The learned Arbitrator held that
the right to get the payment upon completion of the work exist, as the
respondent has unequivocally acknowledged its liability towards the amount
of Rs.16,75,128/-.
13.
The learned Arbitrator rejected the claim of the appellant, over and
above the amount of Rs.16,75,128/- on the ground that the same shall be
barred by limitation, primarily by not accepting the stand of the appellant
that the respondent has acknowledged the liability as is contemplated in
Section 18 of the Limitation Act, 1963. This can be seen from paragraph
no.13 onwards of the Award dated 09.01.2020 wherein the learned
Arbitrator held that there is no correspondence wherein the respondent had
accepted that it is liable to pay Rs.84,04,943/- to the appellant.
14.
The submission of Mr. Vishwendra Verma is that the learned District
Judge has not considered the factual matrix involved in the matter in right
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
17:01:59
FAO (COMM) 122/2026
perspective.
15.
According to him, the cause of action to claim the amount of
Rs.84,04,943/- has arisen only when the respondent denied the payment to
the appellant. He stated that, if the liability is admitted, the limitation gets
extended for initiating the action for recovery. The limitation period for total
outstanding shall start on the date when the cause of action has arisen, which
according to him, was on 01.09.2016. His submission is also that while
considering the application under Order VII Rule 11 CPC, the learned
Arbitrator is only required to see the claim and the documents filed by the
appellant/claimant and not the stand/case set up by the respondent that the
claim is barred by limitation, which is a mixed question of law and facts.
16.
In support of his submissions, Mr Verma has relied upon the
following decisions:a) Popat and Kotecha Property v. State Bank of India Staff
Association, (2005) 7 SCC 510;
b) Balasaria Construction (P) Limited v. Hanuman Seva Trust &
Another, (2006) 5 SCC 658;
c) Madanuri Sri Ram Chandra Murthy v. Syed Jalal, (2017) 13
SCC 174; and
d) Daliben Bailjibhai & Others v. Prajapati Kodarbhai Kachrabhai
& Another, 2024 SCC OnLine SC 4105.
17.
The submissions made by Mr Verma are not persuasive. This we say
so, for the reasons given by the learned District Judge both on the scope of
the judicial review in a petition under Section 34 of the Act and also on the
merits of the claim made by the appellant before the learned Arbitrator,
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
17:01:59
FAO (COMM) 122/2026
more specifically in the context of Section 18 and Article 18 of the Schedule
of the Limitation Act, 1963.
18.
Before we refer to the scope of the judicial review in a petition under
Section 34 of the Act, the issue that needs to be decided is whether the
learned Arbitrator and the learned District Judge were right in dismissing the
claim over and above Rs. 16,75,128/- as being barred by limitation.
19.
Mr Verma has not contested that the issue of limitation has to be
looked from the prospective of the Article 18 of the schedule of the
Limitation Act, 1963. The limitation period fixed for making a claim for the
work done when no time has been fixed for payment in the contract, is three
years from the date when the work was completed. If that be so, there is no
dispute that the work was completed on 20.08.2015 and various invoices
dated 20.08.2015 and 22.08.2015 were raised. So, it follows that limitation
expired on 19.08.2018. The notice invoking arbitration was issued by the
appellant on 10.09.2018, to which a reply was sent by the respondent on
08.10.2018. Hence, in that sense, the claim petition was required to be filed
within three years, w.e.f. 20.08.2015.
20.
But we note the appellant had invoked the arbitration clause beyond
the period of limitation of three years effective from 20.08.2015. The
learned Arbitrator was justified in dismissing the claim petition of the
appellant for a sum over and above Rs.16,75,128/-, being barred by
limitation. The learned Arbitrator has awarded the amount of Rs.
16,75,128/- to the appellant as the amount has been acknowledged by the
respondent vide email dated 19.07.2018, wherein, the respondent has in the
draft copy of No Claim Certificate stated that they have no financial or any
claim what so ever other than Rs.16,75,128/- as on 18.07.2018. If the
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
17:01:59
FAO (COMM) 122/2026
Section 18 of the Limitation Act is seen, there is no acknowledgment by the
respondent accepting the liability over and above Rs. 16,75,128/-.
21.
We are of the view that, in the facts of this case, the conclusions
drawn by the learned Arbitrator and the learned District Judge needs no
interference.
22.
In so far as the decision relied upon by Mr Verma in the case of
Madanuri Sri Ram Chandra Murthy (supra) is concerned, the ratio of the
judgment is primarily that the plea of limitation is a mixed question of law
and facts and as such the issue of limitation could not have been decided on
an application filed under Order VII Rule 11 CPC.
We are not in agreement with such a plea, when facts are admitted,
which conclusively prove the claim is beyond limitation. Suffice to state, the
learned District Judge has held that the decision given by learned Arbitrator
is based on the plea taken by appellant itself including the date of final bill
raised by the appellant. It is not necessary that in all the cases, question of
limitation involves question of law and facts. In the present case, the facts as
disclosed by appellant were taken on their face value for deciding the
question of limitation. Those facts were assessed on the parameters of
declared law of limitation, which were applicable to the facts of this case.
Hence, the reliance on the above judgment is misplaced.
23.
Further the averments in the claim and the documents attached thereto
read as a whole discloses that the claim is beyond limitation. Even on this
ground, the Arbitrator has rightly held that the claim over and above
Rs.16,75,128/- is barred by time.
24.
Similarly, in the case of Popat and Kotecha Property (supra), which
has been relied upon by Mr Verma for identical proposition is concerned,
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
17:01:59
FAO (COMM) 122/2026
the same shall not help his case, in view of the order passed by the learned
Arbitrator, more specifically, paragraphs 9 and 10 of the Award, which we
have already reproduced above.
25.
Insofar as the decision in the case of Daliben Bailjibhai & Others
(supra) is concerned, the Supreme Court in the facts has held that, there is
no justification for the High Court to allow the application under Order VII
Rule 11 of the CPC as it is not evident from the averments made in the
plaint that the limitation commenced from the date of the registration itself.
So, the facts having been disputed, the application under Order VII Rule 11
CPC could not have been allowed. The said judgment is distinguishable on
facts.
26.
Lastly, Balasaria Construction (P) Limited (supra) is relied upon for
a similar proposition, wherein the Supreme Court held that the suit cannot be
dismissed as barred by limitation without proper pleadings, framing of issue
of limitation and taking of evidence. The ratio of the said judgment shall not
be applicable in the facts of this case, more particularly, in view of the
findings of the learned Arbitrator / learned District Judge and our findings
above.
27.
The present appeal filed by the appellant is devoid of merits.
Accordingly, the appeal along with pending application is dismissed at the
admission stage. No costs.
V. KAMESWAR RAO, J
MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA, J
MAY 26, 2026
M
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
17:01:59
FAO (COMM) 122/2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review