Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU.
Case No: WP(C) No. 2697/2025
CM No.6187/2025
Reserved on: 04.08.2026
Pronounced on:14.08.2026
Uploaded on:14.08.2026
Whether the operative part or full
Judgment is pronounced :Full
M/s Pro Health Scientific Pvt. Ltd.
Srl. No.103/25 & 103/5
Plot No. 79, Ramtekdi Industrial
Estate, Hadapsar, Pune-411 013
through authorised signatory, Mr.
Manoj Kumar Dadge, aged 48 years,
S/O
Shri
Raghunathrao
Ramchandrarao, R/O S.No. 3/12,
Indrasprasta Society, Near Hanuman
Mandir, Gadilal,
Hadapasar City, Pune-411 028.
……Petitioner(s)…..
Through: Mr. Farhan Mirza, Advocate
V/s
1. 1. Union Territory of Jammu &
Kashmir through Principal
Secretary
to
Government,
Health & Medical Education
Department, Civil Secretariat,
Jammu/Srinagarr.
2. 2. Jammu & Kashmir Medical
Supplies Corporation Ltd., Head
Officer, Plot No.58, Friends
Colony, Satyam Road, Triukuta
Nagar, Jammu.
3. 3. Managing Director, Jammu &
Kashmir Medical Supplies
Corporation Ltd., Head Officer,
Plot No.58, Friends Colony,
Satyam Road, Triukuta Nagar,
Jammu.
WP(C) No. 2697/2025
4. 4. General Manager (Adm.)
Jammu & Kashmir Medical
Supplies Corporation Ltd.,
Head Officer, Plot No.58,
Friends Colony, Satyam Road,
Triukuta Nagar, Jammu.
5. M/s Maverick Simulation
Solutions, 12-B, Dwarka, New
Delhi through its authorized
representative namely Shri Atul
Sharma.
Through: Mr. Raman Sharma, AAG with Ms. Saliqa
Sheikh, Advocate for R- 1 to 4.
Mr. Rahul Pant, Sr. Advocate with
Mr. Dhruv Pant, Advocate for R-5.
……Respondent(s)…
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJNESH OSWAL, JUDGE.
JUDGMENT
1. The
petitioner
along
with
others
participated
in
NIT
No.NIT/JKMSCL/M&E/2025/655 dated 28.02.2025 for procurement
of “Machinery & Equipment” (01 Anatomy Virtual Dissection Table).
Along with other technical qualification criteria, the bidder was
required to have average annual turnover for the last three financial
years (2021-2022, 2022-23 and 2023-24) of the Indian Subsidiary of
the Principal Manufacturer/Sole Importer, issued by the Chartered
Accountant/competent authority with UDIN, for Rs. 5 crores and was
also required to submit the copies of the audited balance sheet and
profit loss account for last three financial years certified by Chartered
Accountant of the Importer/Indian Subsidiary for 2021-22, 2022-23
and 2023-124 with UDIN.
2. The
technical
bids
Evaluation/Advisory
infirmities/shortcomings
WP(C) No. 2697/2025
were
evaluated
Committee
noticed
on
by
the
by
the
Technical
18.08.2025
and
Committee
were
communicated to the firms including the petitioner-company whereby
besides other documents, the petitioner-company was asked to submit
turnover for the financial year 2021-2022 and audited balance sheet
for the year financial 2021-2022. Finally, the petitioner-company was
not recommended, and M/S Maverick Simulation Solution Ltd.
instead was recommended vide communication dated 21.08.2025. The
petitioner claims to have approached the respondents on 30.08.2025
requesting them for the relaxation of norms for start-ups and MSMEs
as laid down by the Government of India, Ministry of Micro Small
and Medium Enterprises in accordance with circular dated 10 th March,
2016.
3. It is stated that the petitioner, being a start-up which commenced its
operations only in the year 2022, could not have submitted the annual
turnover for the financial year 2021-22, and as the tender was floated
on 28.02.2025 and the last date for submission of bids/tenders,
initially fixed as 04.04.2025, was subsequently extended up to
26.04.2025, so according to the petitioner, the last date for submission
of the bids fell in the financial year 2025-26, therefore the latest
financial year, i.e. 2024-25, was required to be taken into
consideration. Accordingly, the petitioner submitted the annual
turnover for the financial years 2022-23, 2023-24 and 2024-25, which,
according to it, satisfied the prescribed turnover requirement. It is,
however, alleged that the respondents considered only the annual
turnover for the years 2022-23 and 2023-24 and did not take into
consideration the turnover for the year 2024-25. It is further
WP(C) No. 2697/2025
contended that the respondents failed to respond to the representation
submitted by the petitioner on 30.08.2025.
4. The petitioner has also relied upon a similar instance, i.e., tender
floated
by
JKMCL/respondents
vide
Tender
No.
JKMSCL/Mach/2024/611 dated 04.01.2024, wherein a similar
condition relating to average annual turnover was prescribed for the
financial years 2018-19, 2019-20 and 2020-21. It is contended that,
while finalizing the said tender, the respondents relaxed the said
condition and considered the turnover for the financial years 2020-21,
2021-22 and 2022-23 instead of the years 2018-19, 2019-20 and
2020-21 in respect of certain participating firms, as is evident from the
Minutes of Meeting dated 21.04.2025. Another instance of similar
relaxation has also been cited by the petitioner to seek relaxation of
the turnover criterion.
5. Aggrieved by the decision dated 21.08.2025, whereby the turnover
certificate of the petitioner for the financial year 2024-25 was not
taken into consideration, the petitioner has filed the present petition
seeking, inter alia, quashing of the said decision. The petitioner has
also sought the quashing of the meeting notice dated 20.09.2025,
whereby the financial bids were scheduled to be opened on
22.09.2025 at 2:00 p.m.
6. It needs to be noted that the instant writ petition was filed on
22.09.2025. Thereafter, an application bearing CM No. 6612/2025
came to be filed, which was allowed vide order dated 31.10.2025, and
M/s Maverick Simulation Solution, 12-B, Dwarka, New Delhi, came
to be arrayed as respondent No. 5 in the writ petition.
WP(C) No. 2697/2025
7. The official respondents have filed the response stating therein that
E-bid for the finalization of Rate Contract for the procurement of
“Machinery and Equipments” was uploaded on 28.02.2025 and along
with other technical qualification criteria, the average turnover for the
last three financial years of the Indian subsidiary of the Principal
Manufacturer/Sole
Importer
issued
by
the
Chartered
Accountant/Competent Authority with UDIN (2021-22, 2022-23 and
2023-24) was fixed at Rs.5.00 crores. The petitioner firm participated
as a bidder on behalf of a manufacturer M/s Immersive Vision
Technologies Pvt. Ltd (Pune, Maharashtra) and after evaluation of the
technical documents uploaded by the petitioner firm dated
14.07.2025, the petitioner was asked to provide the documents found
deficient as per the requirement of E-NIT. The petitioner in response
to the notice, submitted the turnover certificate for the financial year
2024-25 instead of the required turnover for the financial year
2021-22 which was not part of the prescribed technical qualification
criteria, and the Technical Evaluation Committee of the JKMSCL
found the document not matching the qualification criteria of NIT and
rejected the bid. The respondents have admitted the decision of the
meeting vide No. JKMSCL/GM/2025/5032-41 dated 21.08.2025. It is
also stated that circular dated 10.03.2016 issued by the Govt. of India,
is merely administrative and advisory in nature and does not have any
statutory force. The said circular does not confer enforceable legal
right upon the petitioner to claim relaxation of tender conditions
relating to prior experience or prior turnover, However, the petitioner
firm is not a manufacturer registered under the MSME category and
WP(C) No. 2697/2025
therefore cannot claim the benefits available to registered MSME on
behalf of another entity as the petitioner has failed to submit the
turnover details for the year 2021-22. It is further submitted that as per
the applicable provisions of the MSME Notification and relevant
guidelines, only manufacturers of goods and service providers
engaged in rendering services are eligible to avail benefits under the
MSME category, whereas the petitioner has not submitted any
document to establish its registration or certification under the
relevant MSME category as manufacturer or service provider. In
absence of such documentary proof, the petitioner is not entitled to
claim any benefit or exemption available under the MSME policy.
8. The respondent No. 5 has also filed its response, broadly on the same
lines as the response submitted by the official respondents. It is stated
that respondent No. 5 is the direct importer of the machines in
question from M/s Anatomage Inc., USA, and that the machine in
question, namely, the “Anatomy Virtual Dissection Table”, is a
time-tested machine. It is further stated that the petitioner had
participated in the tendering process initiated by Shri Mata Vaishno
Devi Shrine Board; however, the technical bid submitted by the
petitioner was rejected. It is stated that in the NIT issued on
04.01.2024, the last three financial years would be 2020-21, 2021-22
and 2022-23 and it was because of the mistake annual turnover for the
years
2018-19,
2019-20
and
2020-21
was
mentioned,
but
subsequently rectified by the respondents. In the NIT dated
17.05.2023 also inadvertently the annual turnover of the financial
WP(C) No. 2697/2025
years was mentioned as 2019-20 2020-21 and 2021-22 which was
subsequently rectified by the respondents.
9. Learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted that, in terms of the
circular dated 10.03.2016, the petitioner is entitled to relaxation in the
requirement relating to prior annual turnover. He has further
submitted that, with the exclusion of the petitioner from the tender
process, only one bidder would remain in the fray, thereby defeating
the objective of ensuring healthy competition. He has further
contended that, in the NITs referred to in paragraphs 11 and 12 of the
writ petition, the respondents had relaxed the condition relating to the
average annual turnover and, therefore, the petitioner is also entitled
to similar relaxation on the principle of parity.
10.Per contra, Mr. Raman Sharma, learned AAG appearing for the
official respondents has stated that as per the tender conditions, the
average annual turnover statement for the last three financial years
i.e., 2021-22, 2022-23 and 2023-24 was required of Indian subsidiary
of the Principal Manufacturer/Sole Importer issued by the Chartered
Accountant/Competent Authority with UDIN and also the copies of
audited balance sheets and profit and loss account statements for the
above years were required. When this mandatory condition was not
complied with by the petitioner, the petitioner was not further
recommended. He has further argued that once the petitioner had
participated in the tendering process, being aware of the essential
terms and conditions, the petitioner cannot subsequently file the writ
petition seeking relaxation of the conditions.
WP(C) No. 2697/2025
11.Learned Senior counsel, Mr. Rahul Pant, appearing for the private
respondent has reiterated the submission made by Mr. Raman Sharma,
learned AAG.
12.Heard learned counsel appearing for the parties and perused the
record.
13.The requirements contained in Clauses 12 and 13 of the Technical Bid
Submission Sheet are extracted hereunder:-
Technical Bid Submission Sheeet
S.No.
Item
12.
Average
Annual
Turnover AnnexureStatement for last 3 financial years VII
of the Indian Subsidiary of
Principal
Manufacturer/Sole
Importer issued by Chartered
Accountant/competent
authority
with UDIN (2021-22, 2022-23 and
2023-24).
13.
Particular
In case of foreign manufacturer
the
turnover
of
Indian
Subsidiary/Sole Importer only
shall be considered and not of the
original manufacturer.
Copies of audited balance sheet and
profit loss account for last three
financial
years
certified
by
Chartered Accountant of the
Importer/India Subsidiary for 202122, 2022-23 and 2023-124 with
UDIN.
In case of foreign manufacturer
the balance sheets of Indian
Subsidiary/Sole Importer only
shall be considered.
14.Thus, in terms of the Clauses 12 and 13(supra), the bidder was
required to submit the average annual turnover statement for last 3
financial
years
Manufacturer/Sole
WP(C) No. 2697/2025
of
the
Indian
Importer
Subsidiary
of
issued
by
the
Principal
Chartered
Accountant/Competent Authority with UDIN and the copies of
audited balance sheet and profit loss account for last three financial
years as mentioned above.
15.The petitioner admittedly entered into the business in the year 2022
and as such does not possess the requisite qualification to participate
in the tendering process and despite being aware of the terms and
conditions of the bid sheet, the petitioner participated in the tendering
process. The petitioner, despite being aware of its lack of
qualification, still took a chance to participate in the bidding process.
It is a settled proposition of law that where a bidder fails to satisfy any
of the essential conditions stipulated in the tender floated by the
employer, the bid is liable to be rejected. In “Silppi Construction
Contractors Vs. Union Of India”, AIROnline 2019 SC 2430, the
Hon’ble Apex Court has held as under:
19. This Court being the guardian of fundamental rights is
duty bound to interfere when there is arbitrariness,
irrationality, mala fides and bias. However, this Court in all
the aforesaid decisions has cautioned time and again that
courts should exercise a lot of restraint while exercising
their powers of judicial review in contractual or commercial
matters. This Court is normally loathe to interfere in
contractual matters unless a clearcut case of arbitrariness or
mala fides or bias or irrationality is made out. One must
remember that today many public sector undertakings
compete with the private industry. The contracts entered
into between private parties are not subject to scrutiny under
writ jurisdiction. No doubt, the bodies which are State
within the meaning of Article 12 of the Constitution are
bound to act fairly and are amenable to the writ jurisdiction
of superior courts but this discretionary power must be
exercised with a great deal of restraint and caution. The
Courts must realise their limitations and the havoc
which needless interference in commercial matters can
cause. In contracts involving technical issues the courts
should be even more reluctant because most of us in
judges' robes do not have the necessary expertise to
adjudicate upon technical issues beyond our domain. As
WP(C) No. 2697/2025
laid down in the judgments cited above the courts should
not use a magnifying glass while scanning the tenders
and make every small mistake appear like a big blunder.
In fact, the courts must give "fair play in the joints" to
the government and public sector undertakings in
matters of contract. Courts must also not interfere
where such interference will cause unnecessary loss to
the public exchequer.
20. The essence of the law laid down in the judgments
referred to above is the exercise of restraint and caution;
the need for overwhelming public interest to justify
judicial intervention in matters of contract involving the
state instrumentalities; the courts should give way to the
opinion of the experts unless the decision is totally
arbitrary or unreasonable; the court does not sit like a
court of appeal over the appropriate authority; the court
must realise that the authority floating the tender is the
best judge of its requirements and, therefore, the court's
interference should be minimal. The authority which
floats the contract or tender, and has authored the
tender documents is the best judge as to how the
documents have to be interpreted. If two interpretations
are possible then the interpretation of the author must
be accepted. The courts will only interfere to prevent
arbitrariness, irrationality, bias, mala fides or
perversity. With this approach in mind we shall deal
with the present case.
(emphasis added)
16. If the contention of the petitioner that the respondents ought to have
considered its bid for the annual turnover
for the financial year
2024-25 then this Court would be rewriting the terms and conditions
of the tender, which is beyond the scope of power of judicial review
under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, therefore, there is no
force in this contention of the petitioner that the respondents ought to
have considered the average annual turnover for the financial year
2024-25 for the purpose of evaluating the technical bid of the
petitioner instead of financial year 2020-21. Needless to say, the
employer is the best judge to determine the responsiveness of the
bidder and the courts should be loath to interfere with the decision of
WP(C) No. 2697/2025
employer until or unless it suffers from the vice of arbitrariness, bias
and mala fides. Accordingly, this contention is rejected.
17.It was next contended that the petitioner was entitled to relaxation in
terms of Circular dated 10.03.2016. A perusal of the said Circular
reveals
that
it
has
been
addressed
to
all
Central
Ministries/Departments/CPSUs/All concerned, wherein it has been
stated that the Central Ministries/Departments/Central Public Sector
Undertakings may relax the conditions relating to prior turnover and
prior experience in respect of Micro and Small Enterprises in all
public procurements, subject to fulfilment of the prescribed quality
and technical specifications. The said Circular has been issued by the
Government of India, Ministry of Micro, Small and Medium
Enterprises,
and
is
applicable
to
Central
Ministries/
Departments/CPSUs and other concerned entities and, therefore,
cannot be said to be applicable to the Union Territory of Jammu and
Kashmir or its authorities. Moreover, the Circular (supra) merely
enables and confers discretion upon the concerned procuring entities
to relax the conditions relating to prior turnover and prior experience
in respect of Micro and Small Enterprises. It does not create or vest
any enforceable right in the petitioner to claim such relaxation from
the official respondents. The petitioner, therefore, cannot seek
issuance of a writ commanding the respondents to exercise such
discretion in its favour. Apart from the above, having participated in
the tendering process and having been declared technically nonresponsive, the petitioner cannot, at this stage, seek a direction for
extending to it the benefit of relaxation under the Circular (supra),
WP(C) No. 2697/2025
particularly when no such relaxation is contemplated or envisaged
under the terms and conditions of the NIT. The plea raised by the
petitioner, therefore, is devoid of merit and is accordingly rejected.
Reliance is placed upon the decision of Hon’ble Apex Court in
“Jagdish Mandal vs. State of Orissa and Others, (2007) 14 SCC
517, where in it has been held as under:
“22. Judicial review of administrative action is intended to
prevent arbitrariness, irrationality, unreasonableness, bias and
mala fides. Its purpose is to check whether choice or decision is
made “lawfully” and not to check whether choice or decision is
“sound”. When the power of judicial review is invoked in
matters relating to tenders or award of contracts, certain special
features should be borne in mind. A contract is a commercial
transaction. Evaluating tenders and awarding contracts are
essentially commercial functions. Principles of equity and
natural justice stay at a distance. If the decision relating to
award of contract is bona fide and is in public interest, courts
will not, in exercise of power of judicial review, interfere even
if a procedural aberration or error in assessment or prejudice to
a tenderer, is made out. The power of judicial review will not be
permitted to be invoked to protect private interest at the cost of
public interest, or to decide contractual disputes. The tenderer
or contractor with a grievance can always seek damages in a
civil court. Attempts by unsuccessful tenderers with
imaginary grievances, wounded pride and business rivalry,
to make mountains out of molehills of some
technical/procedural violation or some prejudice to self, and
persuade courts to interfere by exercising power of judicial
review, should be resisted. Such interferences, either interim
or final, may hold up public works for years, or delay relief and
succour to thousands and millions and may increase the project
cost manifold…………”
18.Lastly, it was contended by the petitioner that, in two earlier tenders,
as referred to in paragraphs 11 and 12 of the writ petition, the
respondents had granted relaxation in respect of the requirement of
average annual turnover. The private respondent, in its response, has
stated that the said tenders were issued in January, 2024 and May,
2023, respectively, and due to mistake, reference therein was made to
WP(C) No. 2697/2025
the earlier financial years, which was subsequently rectified by the
official respondents. The petitioner cannot claim parity with the said
instances for the purpose of seeking relaxation. The circumstances
relied upon by the petitioner are evidently distinguishable, inasmuch
as the reference to the earlier financial years in the said tenders was an
apparent inadvertent error on the part of the official respondents,
which was subsequently rectified. The correction of such an error
cannot be construed as a relaxation of the tender condition so as to
confer a corresponding right upon the petitioner to seek similar
relaxation in the present tendering process. The contention, therefore,
is devoid of merit and is accordingly rejected.
19.In view of the foregoing discussion, this petition is found to be devoid
of merit and is, accordingly, dismissed. The connected CM(s), if any,
shall also stand dismissed.
(Rajnesh Oswal)
Judge
Jammu
14.08.2026
Madan Verma-Secy
Whether order is speaking?
Whether order is reportable?
MADAN LAL VERMA
2026.08.14 13:33
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
WP(C) No. 2697/2025
Yes.
No.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review