The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
19. In view of the above, we do not find the present case to be a fit case for interference. In any case, the scope of interference in an intra-court appeal is limited and unless the view of the learned Single Judge is so unreasonable or perverse, the same should not be disturbed. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Management of Narendra & Company Private Ltd. Vs. Workmen of Narendra and Company reported in (2016) 3 SCC 340, has laid down as follows:“4……….Be that as it may, in an intra-court appeal, on a finding of fact, unless the appellate Bench reaches a conclusion that the finding of the Single Bench is perverse, it shall not disturb the same. Merely because another view or a better view is possible, there should be no interference with or disturbance of the order passed by the Single Judge, unless both sides agree for a fairer approach on relief.”
20. In view of the above, the writ appeal stands dismissed. The embargo put by this Court in the order dated 26.05.2026 is removed. The respondent authorities would be at the liberty to go ahead and finalise the Page No.# 11/11 new tender process in accordance with law. Comparing Assistant
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/11
GAHC040019512025
undefined
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WA/46/2025
M/s Papu Hote Multipurpose Cooperative Society Ltd
Papu Hote Village, PO and PS Pakke Kessang, District Pakke Kessang, Arunachal
Pradesh represented through its Chairman Shri Tana Naya, APM, Village Papu Hote,
PO and PS Pakke Kessang, District Pakke Kessang, Arunachal Pradesh.
VERSUS
The State of AP and 9 Ors
represented by the Chief Secretary, Govt of Arunachal Pradesh.
2:The Commissioner Food and Civil Supplies
Age: 0
Occupation :
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar.
3:The Director Food and Civil Supplies
Age: 0
Occupation :
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar.
4:The Deputy Commissioner
Age: 0
Occupation :
Pakke Kessang District
Lemmi
Arunachal Pradesh.
5:The Tender Evaluation Board/ Committee
Age: 0
Occupation :
Page No.# 2/11
with regard to NIT No. PK/SUP/PDS-01/2021 dated 10.12.2024 held on 23.12.2024
represented through its Chairman
Shri Kamin Darang
the Additional Deputy Commissioner
Pakke Kessang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
6:The District Food and Civil Supplies Officer cum Member Secretary
Age: 0
Occupation :
Tender Evaluation Board /Committee with retard to NIT No. PK/SUP/PDS-01/2021
dated 10.12.2024 held on 23.12.2024
Pakke Kessang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
7:M/s Nangnyo Nampin Multi Purpose Cooperative Society Ltd
Age: 0
Occupation :
Nangnyo Village
PO Pijirang
PS Pakke Kessang
District Pakke Kessang
Arunachal Pradesh a registered Cooperative Society under the Arunachal Pradesh
Cooperatives Societies Act 1978 represented through its Chairman Shri Ravindra
Tana Tara
8:Ravindra Tana Tara
Age: 0
Occupation :
Son of Late Nerba Tana
Village Nangnyo
PO Pijirang
PS Pakke Kessang
Pakke Kessang District
Arunachal Pradesh 790103
9:M/s Papu Pani Multipurpose Cooperative Society Ltd
Age: 0
Occupation :
Village Guntung
PO Pijirang
PS Pakke Kessang
District Pakke Kessang
Arunachal Pradesh.
10:M/s Baadhane Anne Multipurpose Cooperative Society Ltd
Age: 0
Occupation :
Page No.# 3/11
Pakke Kessang Town
PO
PS and District Pakke Kessang
Arunachal Pradesh.
Advocate for the petitioner
:Ms Padmini Barua
Advocate for the respondents
: Mr. R. H. Nabam, AAG
:::BEFORE:::
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY KUMAR MEDHI
HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MITALI THAKURIA
Date on which judgment is reserved
: N/A
Date of pronouncement of judgment
: 02.06.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of the
Operative part of the judgment
: N/A
Whether the full judgment has been
Pronounced
: Yes
Judgment & Order (Oral)
(S. K. Medhi, J.)
The instant intra-court appeal has been filed against a judgment
dated 11.11.2025, passed in WP(C) No.111(AP)/2025, whereby, the writ
petition has been allowed. The present appellant was the respondent No.
7 in the said writ petition.
Page No.# 4/11
2.
The case has a chequered history. The issue has emanated from an
NIT dated 10.12.2024 issued by the Deputy Commissioner, Pakke Kessang
District for carriage of PDS by land route in which the present appellant
(respondent No.7) and the writ petitioner had participated. The evaluation
was made on 10.01.2025, when the petitioner was selected and
recommended. The said recommendation was, however, the subject
matter of challenge in WP(C) No. 95(AP)/2025 filed by the writ petitioner.
In the meantime, on 12.02.2025, the approval in favour of the present
appellant was granted. Accordingly, on 28.07.2025, when WP(C) No.
95(AP)/2025 was listed, the learned Senior Counsel for the writ petitioner
had submitted that the cause of action had become infructuous and
accordingly, the writ petition was closed. Thereafter, the present writ
petition was filed being WP(C) No. 111(AP)/2025.
3.
We have heard Ms Padmini Barua, learned counsel for the appellant.
We have also heard Shri R.H. Nabam, the learned Additional Advocate
General for the State.
4.
So far as the writ petitioner is concerned who has been arrayed as
respondent No.7 in this appeal, it is seen that in spite of the service of
notice, the writ petitioner has chosen not to contest the appeal. In fact,
there is an order dated 14.05.2026, passed by this Court, wherein the
service upon the private respondents, including the writ petitioner has
been held to be complete.
5.
Ms Barua, the learned counsel for the appellant has, at the outset,
submitted that the writ petitioner did not have the locus to institute the
Page No.# 5/11
challenge. She has submitted that the writ petitioner was an unsuccessful
bidder and accordingly, could not have challenged the process in which
her client was evaluated to be the suitable party. She has submitted that
this aspect has not been properly considered by the learned Single Judge.
She has also submitted that though various grounds of challenge were
taken, the principal ground was in the aspect of the Bank Guarantee and
the Earnest Money Deposit, pertaining to her client. It was the case of the
writ petitioner that the Bank Guarantee was not from a nationalised bank
in terms of the standard condition of the tender, but from the Arunachal
Pradesh Co-operative Apex Bank. As regard the Earnest Money Deposit,
she has clarified that though the deposit was not from the account of her
client but from one entity of which the Chairman was also the Chairman of
the appellant cooperative society. She has submitted that in the evaluation
conducted on 10.01.2025, all the relevant factors were taken into
consideration. Emphasis has been drawn to the note where there is a
consideration on the numbers of godowns and vehicles and it is submitted
that on these relevant considerations, the recommendation in favour of
her client was given. She has further submitted that, though after the
judgement dated 11.01.2025, a new process was initiated, there is an
order passed in an appeal not to finalise the same.
6.
The learned counsel for the appellant, in support of her submissions,
has relied upon the following judgments:1.
Poddar Steel Corporation Vs. Ganesh Engineering
Works& Ors, reported in (1991) 3 SCC 273;
2.
Central Coalfields Limited and Another Vs. SLL-SML
Page No.# 6/11
(Joint Venture Consortium) & Ors, reported in (2016) 8
SCC 622; and
3.
N.G. Projects Limited Vs. Vinod Kumar Jain & Ors
reported in (2022) 6 SCC 127.
7.
The aforesaid cases have been cited primarily to impress upon the
Court that interpretation of the terms of the tender lies within the
discretion of the tendering authority and the scope of judicial review is
minimal. She also submits that the respondent authorities had filed an
affidavit-in-opposition, wherein they have given the justification for
recommending her client.
8.
Shri R. H. Nabam, learned AAG, has submitted that the impugned
decision was sought to be justified in the affidavit-in-opposition filed by
the respondent No.4. However, as a matter of fact, after passing of the
judgment dated 11.11.2025, a new process has been initiated which is
almost complete. He has also submitted that the new process has not
been put challenge, and therefore, the embargo put by this Court on
26.05.2026 be removed as there is urgency in the matter as it relates to
Public Distribution System.
9.
The rival submissions have been duly considered, and the materials
placed before this Court, including the pleadings before the learned Single
Judge have been carefully perused.
10. At the outset, we are reminded of the settled position of law that in
the matters of tender, the discretion of the tendering authority has to be
Page No.# 7/11
given importance, unless such discretion appears to have been exercised
in illegal and unreasonable manner.
11.
The initial recommendation dated 10.01.2025, as a matter of fact,
was a subject of challenge in WP(C) No. 95(AP)/2025. However, the said
writ petition was submitted to be infructuous and in the meantime, the
approval was granted on 12.02.2025. Accordingly, the earlier writ petition
being WP(C) No.95 (AP)/2025 was closed as infructuous on the
submission of the learned counsel for the writ petitioner on 28.07.2025. It
is also contended by the learned counsel for the appellant that after such
dismissal, the petitioner had started the work and was continuing. Be that
as it may, the subsequent writ petition being WP(C) No. 111(AP)/2025
was instituted challenging the grant of approval dated 12.02.2025.
12.
We have, however, noted that though in the evaluation dated
10.01.2025, the writ petitioner was held to be not eligible, such decision
was not per se put to challenge in the present writ petition. On the other
hand, the petition has been instituted, mainly challenging the allotment of
the work to the appellant, in spite of the fact that the bid of the appellant
had suffered from major defects.
13. The learned Single Judge had considered the aspect of locus and has
held that the petitioner had the locus. Having gone through the
discussion, we do not find that there is any reason of taking a different
view and therefore, the petition is held to be maintainable as the
petitioner had, in fact, participated in the bidding process and was not
recommended vide the Minutes of meeting dated 10.01.2025. We have
Page No.# 8/11
also taken note of the fact that the initial evaluation dated 10.01.2025 was
indeed the subject matter of challenge in the first writ petition being
WP(C) No.95(AP)/2025 which was, however, withdrawn as infructuous.
14.
As regards the primarily grounds of challenge, we have noted that
the two grounds revolves around the Bank Guarantee and EMD. So far as
the Bank Guarantee is concerned, there is a stipulation in the tender
condition that such Bank Guarantee has to be from a nationalised bank.
The Tender Committee had, however, accepted the Bank Guarantee of the
appellant which was from the Arunachal Pradesh Co-operative Apex Bank.
We are of the view that the discretion exercised by the Tender Committee
so far as the Bank Guarantee is concerned may not be held to be so
glaringly illegal, which would require an interference in exercise of the
powers of judicial review. After all, the objective is to secure the work is
completed by the party. There is, however, a different issue so far as EMD
is concerned. The EMD has been deposited from the account of one M/s
HT Enterprise.
15. The learned counsel for the appellant has strenuously argued that
the Chairman of M/s HT Enterprise is also the Chairman of the appellant.
Though the aforesaid averment may be correct as a matter of fact, M/s HT
Enterprise is a different entity altogether. The respondent No.4, in its
affidavit filed on 20.06.2025 had dealt with the issue in paragraph-8(i).For
the sake of clarity, the said averments are extracted herein below:“8(i) The earnest money Rs.2,00,000/- (Rupees two lakhs) only of
private respondent No. was deposited in form of Deposit at receipt/
fixed deposit in favour of the Deputy Commissioner, Pakke Kessang
Page No.# 9/11
District through the account of M/s HT Enterprise and submitted to
the tendering authorities as his earnest money. There is no clause
specified that earnest money ought to be submitted from the Bank
account of Bidder in the terms and condition of tender. The clause
4(i) of terms and conditions of tender, it has been only mentioned
that "Earnest Money of Rs 2,00,000/-only in form of Deposit at call
receipt/Fixed Deposit receipt in favour of the Deputy Commissioner,
Pakke Kessang District. Therefore, the tendering authorities have
accepted the EMD of private respondent No.6.”
16. Though the settled law is that the tendering authority should be left
to exercise their discretion, the discretion exercised, so far as interpreting
the EMD deposited in the name of another entity to be in consonance with
the Clause 4(i) does not appear to be reasonable at all. The same would
lead to an absurd situation wherein any other entity would deposit the
EMD which would open a floodgate, wherein the works would be done in
the name of somebody else, which is not the purpose of the present
scheme. The scheme is mainly for cooperative society and both the
appellant and the respondent No.7 are, in fact, cooperative societies.
17. The interference by the Hon’ble Single Judge on this aspect is found
in paragraph-28 of the judgment, the relevant part of which reads as
follows:“28. It is also seen from Information obtained through RTI, that there
were other shortfalls in the tender bid of the respondent No. 7, which
were not highlighted in the Board proceeding. This court finds that there
are two deficiencies in the bld of respondent No. 7, which are most
noticeable. The first noticeable defect in the tender is that the respondent
Page No.# 10/11
no.7 did not deposit the Earnest Money Deposit under its own name but
that the earnest money was deposited by a M/s HT Enterprises. This
court finds it hard to accept the explanation that the earnest money was
deposited on behalf of respondent No. 7 (M/s Papu Hote MPCS) when no
nexus is shown between M/s HT Enterprises and respondent No. 7 (M/s
Papu Hote MPCS)...”
18.
We are of the opinion that the conclusion reached by the learned
Single Judge, on this aspect, is in the right direction and we concur with
the same.
19. In view of the above, we do not find the present case to be a fit case
for interference. In any case, the scope of interference in an intra-court
appeal is limited and unless the view of the learned Single Judge is so
unreasonable or perverse, the same should not be disturbed. The Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the case of Management of Narendra & Company
Private Ltd. Vs. Workmen of Narendra and Company reported in (2016)
3 SCC 340, has laid down as follows:“4……….Be that as it may, in an intra-court appeal, on a finding of fact,
unless the appellate Bench reaches a conclusion that the finding of the
Single Bench is perverse, it shall not disturb the same. Merely because
another view or a better view is possible, there should be no interference
with or disturbance of the order passed by the Single Judge, unless both
sides agree for a fairer approach on relief.”
20. In view of the above, the writ appeal stands dismissed. The embargo
put by this Court in the order dated 26.05.2026 is removed. The
respondent authorities would be at the liberty to go ahead and finalise the
Page No.# 11/11
new tender process in accordance with law.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review