Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Extra Ordinary Jurisdiction)
DATED : 29.11.2018
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
W.P. (C) No. 51 of 2018
Petitioners
:
M/s Pan India Network Limited and Anr.
versus
Respondents
:
The State of Sikkim & Anr.
An application under Article 226
of the Constitution of India
----------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance:
Mr. Zangpo Sherpa, Mr. Passang T. Bhutia and Mr.
Sushant Subba, Advocates.
Mr. J.B. Pradhan, Additional Advocate General with Mr.
Karma Thinlay, Senior Government Advocate, Mr.
Thinlay Dorjee Bhutia, Government Advocate, Mr. S.K.
Chettri and Ms. Pollin Rai, Assistant Government
Advocates.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
JUDGMENT
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
The Petitioners are before this Court praying that the
letter dated 27.10.2018 issued by the Respondent No. 2 as
well as the invitation for Expression of Interest/Tender dated
W.P. (C) No. 51 of 2018
M/s Pan India Network Ltd. and Anr.
Vs. The State of Sikkim and Anr.
29.10.2018 be set aside and the Respondents be directed to
abide by the correspondence dated 12.10.2017 and the letter
dated 24.09.2018 with the revised revenue. The Petitioners, in
terms thereof, be permitted to continue as Marketing Agents
for the Sikkim State Online Lotteries for 3 (three) years or till
notification of the
Home Affairs,
amended Lottery Rules by the Ministry of
Government of India („MHA, GOI‟ for short
hereinafter respectively) whichever is earlier.
2.
Learned Counsel for the Petitioners requested for urgent
hearing of the matter in view of the date of opening of
Invitation for Expression of Interest/Tender (Annexure-3) for
marketing and sale of 5 (five) Online Weekly Lotteries per day
(Part A) being 30.11.2018 for Technical Bid and 05.12.2018
for the Financial Bid. Thus, the instant matter was taken up
for hearing on 28.11.2018 along with I.A. No. 01 of 2018
which is an application seeking stay of the impugned letter
dated
27.10.2018
and
the
invitation
for
Expression
of
Interest/Tender issued by the Respondent No. 2 dated
29.10.2018.
3.
The Petitioners being Marketing Agents for 8 (eight)
Online Lotteries of the State Respondents vide the extension
letter
of the
Respondent No. 2
dated 12.10.2017
are
aggrieved by the invitation for Expression of Interest/Tender
(Part A) floated by the Respondent No. 2, on 29.10.2018. The
Petitioners contend that subsequent to the correspondence of
W.P. (C) No. 51 of 2018
M/s Pan India Network Ltd. and Anr.
Vs. The State of Sikkim and Anr.
the
Respondent
No.
dated
12.10.2017
another
correspondence was issued on 24.09.2018 vide which the
Respondent No. 2 offered continuation of distributorship of 5
(five) out of the 8 (eight) Online Lotteries per day allotted to
them, for another period of 3 (three) years or till notification
of the amended Lottery Rules by the MHA, GOI. The
Petitioners vide their letter dated 05.10.2018 accepted the
offer of the Respondent No. 2. Following this correspondence,
a letter dated 27.10.2018 was issued by the Respondent No. 2
stating
that
the
State
Government
had
approved
for
continuation of distributorship of the Petitioners for 8 (eight)
(sic) weekly Online Lotteries per day at the revised draw rate
of Rs.52,000/- (Rupees fifty two thousand) only, and draw
expenses of Rs.3,000/- (Rupees three thousand) only, per
draw, as interim arrangement till such time a new Marketing
Agent was finalized. That, in the event of the Petitioners
accepting the terms set out in the letter dated 27.10.2018
they were to send a confirmation letter to the Respondent No.
2. On 30.10.2018 the Petitioners apprehending discontinuation
of their agency confirmed acceptance of the terms and
conditions laid out in the letter supra dated 27.10.2018.
Meanwhile
on
29.10.2018,
invitation
for
Expression
of
Interest/Tender (Part A) for marketing and sale of 5 (five)
Online Weekly Lotteries per day was floated by Respondent
No. 2. Vide letter dated 02.11.2018 the Respondent No. 2
confirmed the acceptance of the Petitioners as the Marketing
W.P. (C) No. 51 of 2018
M/s Pan India Network Ltd. and Anr.
Vs. The State of Sikkim and Anr.
Agent as agreed in the Petitioners’ letter dated 30.10.2018, till
the appointment of a new Marketing Agent was finalized. On
12.11.2018, the Petitioners made a representation to the
Respondents submitting that they were aggrieved by the
issuance of Tender as the Respondent No. 2 had already
extended their distributorship for 5 (five) Online Lotteries. The
Petitioners also requested the Respondent No. 2 to consider
their request for extension at the revised revenue or till
notification of the amended Lottery Rules. As there was no
response to this correspondence the Petitioners are before this
Court with the prayers as aforestated.
4.
The Respondents No. 1 and 2 appeared on advance
notice and waived formal notice.
5.
Learned Counsel for the Petitioners would urge in the
first
instance
that
there
was
no
revocation
of
the
communication dated 12.10.2017 and the offer letter dated
24.09.2018 or termination of the agreement entered into
between the Petitioners and the Respondent No. 2. In such a
circumstance, the Respondents ought not to have floated the
impugned
invitation
for
Expression
of
Interest
dated
29.10.2018 for bids of Online Lotteries, contrary to the terms
in the letter dated 24.09.2018. The Respondents cannot be
permitted to resile from their own correspondence which is in
the nature of extension of contract as neither has 3 (three)
years elapsed from the date of extension of the contract being
W.P. (C) No. 51 of 2018
M/s Pan India Network Ltd. and Anr.
Vs. The State of Sikkim and Anr.
12.10.2017 nor has the MHA, GOI notified amendments of the
Lottery
Rules.
distributorship
That
and
creation
marketing
of
has
infrastructure
involved
for
substantial
expenditure and the sudden announcement of inviting Tenders
has seriously prejudiced the rights and interests of the
Petitioners which is not only violative of Article 14, Article 19
(1)(g), Article 300 (A) and Articles 301 to 304 of the
Constitution of India but also is completely contrary to the
specific contract entered into between the parties hence the
prayers in the instant petition and the I.A. be granted.
6.
Mr. J.B. Pradhan, Additional Advocate General, making
submissions for the Respondents No. 1 and 2 argued that
admittedly the letter dated 27.10.2018 specified that the
Petitioners were to continue distributorship of 8 (eight) weekly
Online Lotteries as an “interim arrangement” till such time the
appointment of a new Marketing Agent was finalized. The
letter also specified that in the event of acceptance of the
terms, a confirmation letter was to be sent by the Petitioners
on or before 01.11.2018 (4 p.m.) failing which continuation of
the distributorship would be terminated summarily. The
Petitioners, vide response dated 30.10.2018 categorically
accepted the terms by stating inter alia that they accept the
offer of the Respondents for continuation of 8 (eight) Weekly
Online Lotteries and accepted all terms and procedures
mentioned in the communication thereby in categorical terms
W.P. (C) No. 51 of 2018
M/s Pan India Network Ltd. and Anr.
Vs. The State of Sikkim and Anr.
accepted the interim arrangement as spelt out by the
Respondent No. 2 till such time the appointment of a new
Marketing Agent is finalized. This fact is also evident from the
contents of the letter dated 12.11.2018 addressed to the
Respondent No. 2 where the Petitioners have stated that they
have given their acceptance for continuation of distributorship
of draws with a request to review the same for continuation of
distributorship in terms of the letter dated 24.09.2018. In light
of such awareness and acceptance of terms of the Respondent
No. 2, the Petitioners cannot now turn back and state that the
decision of the Respondents was arbitrary or irrational or claim
violation
of
their
fundamental
rights.
That
despite
the
Petitioners’ awareness of Tenders being floated on 09.07.2018
and 17.07.2018, no protest was put forth by them at the
relevant time or at any subsequent time thereto. The
Respondent No. 2 was constrained to withdraw the said
Tenders when certain contingencies arose and admittedly
offered the Petitioners continuity of agency but this in no
manner tantamounts to allowing the Petitioners to continue in
perpetuity.
7.
Learned Additional Advocate General would further
canvass
that
nothing
prevented
the
Petitioners
from
participating in the bids dated 09.07.2018 and 17.07.2018
when the Tenders were floated as admittedly they had
purchased Tender Forms thereby indicating intention to
W.P. (C) No. 51 of 2018
M/s Pan India Network Ltd. and Anr.
Vs. The State of Sikkim and Anr.
participate in the said bids. That, the Tenders have been
floated in larger public interest as there cannot be a loss of
public revenue and the distributorship cannot be granted by
extension of agreement. Hence, in view of the facts and
circumstances brought to the notice of this Court, it is
apparent that the petition is a chance petition. Moreover as
the Petitioners contend that the contract between the parties
have been violated no remedy obtains to them under Article
226 of the Constitution. It is prayed that the petition deserves
no consideration and be dismissed with exemplary costs.
8.
I have heard at length and considered carefully the
submissions put forth by the parties. Documents relied on by
the Petitioners have been meticulously examined by me.
9.
The genesis of this petition is an agreement dated
07.11.2012
whereby
the
Petitioners
were
appointed
as
Marketing Agent for distributing and marketing 8 (eight)
Online Lottery Schemes for 5 (five) years till 06.11.2017. Prior
to the expiry of the said agreement vide communication dated
12.10.2017, the Respondent No. 2 intimated to the Petitioners
its decision to extend the distributorship of the Petitioners on
grounds that the proposal to invite Expression of Interest for
appointment of Marketing Agents/Distributors failed to fructify
due to imposition of the code of conduct for Panchayat
Election and the likelihood of amendment to the Lotteries
(Regulation) Act, 2016 by the MHA, GOI. The extension vide
W.P. (C) No. 51 of 2018
M/s Pan India Network Ltd. and Anr.
Vs. The State of Sikkim and Anr.
the said letter is clearly upto 06.02.2018. On 27.10.2018, the
Respondents issued the impugned letter to the Petitioners
stating that their distributorship was an interim arrangement
till such time a new Marketing Agent was appointed and
finalized. The Petitioners were required to submit their
acceptance to the terms specified in the letter on or before
01.11.2018 (4 p.m.) failing which the distributorship would be
terminated summarily. Apprehending such termination, the
Petitioners
vide
their
communication
dated
accepted the offer while at the same time
30.10.2018
requesting the
Government to review their decision and continue their
distributorship in terms of the letter of the Respondent No. 2
dated 24.09.2018. The Petitioners despite having accepted the
terms as set out in the letter dated 27.10.2018 are now crying
foul as the agreement between the Petitioners and the
Respondents was subsisting when the impugned Tender was
floated. It would be apposite at this stage to refer to the
relevant portion of the letter of the Respondent No. 2 dated
27.10.2018. The correspondence states as follows;
“...Further, the State Government has
also approved for continuation of distributorship
of the 08 (Eight) weekly Online Lotteries per day
at the revised rate of ₹52,000/- per draw and
draw expenses of ₹3,000/- per draw, as an
interim arrangement, till such time the
appointment of a new Marketing Agent is
finalized. ...”
In response thereto, it is admitted that the Petitioners
accepted the terms, vide communication dated 30.10.2018 as
follows;
W.P. (C) No. 51 of 2018
M/s Pan India Network Ltd. and Anr.
Vs. The State of Sikkim and Anr.
“...Reference:
Your
Letter
dated
24/10/2018(sic 27.10.2018) bearing Letter
No:789/FIN/ DSSL/III/2018-19/359.
....................................................................
....................................................................
We here by confirm the acceptance all
the terms & procedures mentioned in this
communication. We request you to please issue
us a letter for extension of 08 (Eight) online
weekly lotteries on receipt of this acceptance
letter. ...”
10.
In my considered opinion it is understandably an open
and shut case. Once the Petitioners have accepted the terms
and conditions as specifically reflected in the correspondence
dated 30.10.2018 are they in a position to now reprobate and
state that it was due to apprehension of their distributorship
being discontinued that they responded in the manner as
stated above. The reply would obviously have to be in the
negative. In Shyam Telelink Ltd. Vs. Union of India (UOI) 1 the
Hon'ble Supreme Court while deciding a matter under the
Telecom Regulatory Authority of India Act, 1997 considered
the question as to whether the Appellant was entitled to
question
the
terms
of
the
Migration
Package
after
unconditionally accepting and acting upon the same and held
as follows;
“...13. The unconditional acceptance of
the terms of the package and the benefit which
the appellant derived under the same will estop
the appellant from challenging the recovery of
the dues under the package or the process of its
determination.
....................................................................
Allowing the appellant at this stage to question
the demand raised under the Migration Package
(2010) 10 SCC 165
W.P. (C) No. 51 of 2018
M/s Pan India Network Ltd. and Anr.
Vs. The State of Sikkim and Anr.
would amount to permitting the appellant to
accept what was favourable to it and reject what
was not. The appellant cannot approbate and
reprobate. The maxim qui approbat non reprobat
(one who approbates cannot reprobate) is firmly
embodied in English Common Law and often
applied by Courts in this country. It is akin to the
doctrine of benefits and burdens which at its
most basic level provides that a person taking
advantage under an instrument which both
grants a benefit and imposes a burden cannot
take the former without complying with the
latter. A person cannot approbate and reprobate
or accept and reject the same instrument. ...”
11.
In City Montessori School v. State of Uttar Pradesh and Ors. 2
the Hon'ble Supreme Court observed that it is a fundamental
principle of general application that if a person of his own
accord, accepts a contract on certain terms and works out the
contract, he cannot be allowed to adhere to and abide by
some of the terms of the contract which prove advantageous
to him and repudiate the other terms of the same contract
which might be disadvantageous to him. Thus when a person
knowingly accepts the benefits of a contract he is estopped
from denying the validity or binding effect on him of such
contract. In the instant case, the Petitioners have accepted
the terms and procedures mentioned in the impugned letter
dated
27.10.2018
in
categorical
terms
as
extracted
hereinabove. It is not the Petitioners case that the Expression
of Interest was issued behind their back and caught them
unawares, they were indeed seized of the fact of the Tender
floated not only vide the impugned Expression of Interest
(2009) 14 SCC 253
W.P. (C) No. 51 of 2018
M/s Pan India Network Ltd. and Anr.
Vs. The State of Sikkim and Anr.
dated 29.10.2018 but also of the earlier Expressions of
Interest dated 09.07.2018 and 17.07.2018. It is relevant to
note at this point that vide letter dated 12.10.2017 the
marketing and sale of 8 (eight) Online Lotteries to the
Petitioners was in fact extended by 3 (three) months upto
06.02.2018. It was the specific argument of the Counsel for
the Petitioners that there was no revocation of the extension
letter dated 12.10.2017. On this count it is worth noticing that
vide letter dated 12.10.2017 the extension for marketing
lotteries
was
upto
06.02.2018.
From
06.02.2018
upto
23.09.2018 as per documents relied on by the Petitioners
before this Court evidently no communication ensued from the
Respondent No. 2 extending the contract of the Petitioners
from 06.02.2018 thereby indicating that the Petitioners were
functioning in limbo without any renewal of contract from the
said
date.
Strangely
enough
again
on
24.09.2018
the
Respondent No. 2 offered continuation of distributorship of 5
(five) out of the 8 (eight) Online Lotteries per day for 3
(three) years or till notification of the amended Lottery Rules
by the MHA, GOI whichever is earlier. It is relevant to point
out that this fact was not raised by the Respondents but is
being highlighted herein to indicate the apparent carelessness
in the functioning of the Department as also the tangential
magnanimity
meted
revocation
the
of
out
to
the
communication
Petitioners.
dated
So
far
as
24.09.2018
is
concerned whereby the Petitioners were offered continuation
W.P. (C) No. 51 of 2018
M/s Pan India Network Ltd. and Anr.
Vs. The State of Sikkim and Anr.
of distributorship, the contents of this letter is obviously
overruled by the contents of the letter dated 27.10.2018 the
terms
of
which
were
accepted
unequivocally
by
the
Petitioners.
12.
While adverting to the communication dated 12.10.2018
the relevant portion of the contents is extracted hereinbelow
for easy reference;
“...The State Government also reserves
the right to discontinue this arrangement at any
time without assigning any reason thereof. ...”
The categorical intention of the Respondent No. 2 has been
spelt out in the correspondence and no protest rears its head
from the Petitioners on this specific count.
13.
Although it was vehemently argued by learned Counsel
for the Petitioners that there was an existing contract between
the Respondents and the Petitioners which therefore cannot be
breached, in this context we may refer to the ratiocination in
State of U.P. and Others v. Bridge & Roof Company (India) Ltd. 3
wherein the Hon’ble Supreme Court pronounced as follows;
“...16. Firstly, the contract between the
parties is a contract in the realm of private law.
It is not a statutory contract. It is governed by
the provisions of the Contract Act or, maybe,
also by certain provisions of the Sale of Goods
Act. Any dispute relating to interpretation of the
terms and conditions of such a contract cannot
be agitated, and could not have been agitated,
in a writ petition. That is a matter either for
(1996) 6 SCC 22
W.P. (C) No. 51 of 2018
M/s Pan India Network Ltd. and Anr.
Vs. The State of Sikkim and Anr.
arbitration as provided by the contract or for the
civil court, as the case may be. Whether any
amount is due to the respondent from the
appellant-Government under the contract and, if
so, how much and the further question whether
retention or refusal to pay any amount by the
Government is justified, or not, are all matters
which cannot be agitated in or adjudicated upon
in a writ petition. The prayer in the writ petition,
viz., to restrain the Government from deducting
a particular amount from the writ petitioner‟s
bill(s) was not a prayer which could be granted
by the high Court under Article 226. Indeed, the
High Court has not granted the said prayer.
....................................................................
18. Accordingly, it must be held that the
writ petition filed by the respondent for the
issuance of a writ of mandamus restraining the
Government from deducting or withholding a
particular sum, which according to the
respondent is payable to it under the contract,
was
wholly
misconceived
and
was not
maintainable in law. ...”
The ratio lucidly explains the legal position and requires no
elucidation.
14.
On the question of promissory estoppel raised by the
Petitioners, the doctrine is an equitable doctrine evolved by
equity in order to prevent injustice when a promise is made by
a person knowing that it would be acted on by the person to
whom it was made and in fact has so acted on it. It would in
such a circumstance be inequitable to allow the party making
the promise to go back upon it. As earlier pointed out, the
Government has set out unequivocally in its letter dated
12.10.2017 that it could discontinue the agreement at any
time without assigning any reason. It is asserted
that the
Petitioners have been in the business since 2012 hence it can
safely be assumed that logistics were in place and
any
W.P. (C) No. 51 of 2018
M/s Pan India Network Ltd. and Anr.
Vs. The State of Sikkim and Anr.
additional
expenditure
incurred
subsequently
cannot
be
termed as loss making or inequitable. What looms large of
course is the fact of acceptance of conditions by the
Petitioners as laid down by the Respondent No. 2 in the
impugned letter dated 27.10.2018.
15.
In view of the aforestated facts and circumstances that
have emerged and also bearing in mind the well-established
principles of law governing the grant of stay, I am of the
opinion that no case is made out for stay of the impugned
letter dated 27.10.2018. No grounds also emanate for setting
aside the letter dated 27.10.2018 and the invitation for
Expression of Interest/Tender dated 29.10.2018 and in view of
the acceptance of the terms and conditions set forth in the
impugned letter dated 27.10.2018, the question of directing
the Respondents to abide by the correspondence dated
24.09.2018 does not arise. While the contents of the letter
dated
12.10.2017
extracted
hereinabove
empowers
the
Respondents to discontinue the arrangement at any time
without assigning reasons, hence the Petitioners are not
entitled to any of the reliefs claimed.
16.
The petition hereby stands rejected and W.P. (C) No. 51
of 2018 is disposed of accordingly as also the I.A. No. 01 of
2018.
W.P. (C) No. 51 of 2018
M/s Pan India Network Ltd. and Anr.
Vs. The State of Sikkim and Anr.
17.
Certified copies be made available to the parties, as per
Rules.
(Meenakshi Madan Rai)
Judge
29.11.2018
Approved for reporting: Yes
Internet: Yes
ml
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review