Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Date of reserved for judgments: 13.07.2026
Date of pronouncement
:
29.07.2026
Date of uploading
:
29.07.2026
APHC010347162017
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
Bench Sr.No:[3584]
WRIT APPEAL Nos: 978 of 2017; 1422 of 2016 &
977 of 2018
W.P.No.978 of 2017:
...Appellant(s)
M/s. Gurubani Security Pvt. Ltd., Secunderabad and
Others
Vs.
The Oil Natural Gas Corp Ltd, Rajahmundry & Ors. ...Respondent(s)
**********
Advocate for Appellants:
MR. M A ALEEM MAJID (in WA
No.978 of 2017);
MR. D.S.SIVADARSHAN (in WA
No.1422 of 2016;
MR. C.SUMAN (in W.A.No.977 of
2018)
Advocate(s) for Respondent(s):
MR.V HARI HARAN,
MR.T. NIRANJAN, Deputy
Solicitor General of India,
MRS. M.UMA DEVI, CENTRAL
GOVT. COUNSEL;
MR. T KOTESWARA RAO; MR.
D.S.SIVADARSHAN (IN WA 977
OF 2018)
CORAM : THE CHIEF JUSTICE LISA GILL
SRI JUSTICE CHALLA GUNARANJAN
DATE
: 29th July, 2026.
HCJ & CGR, J.
W.A.Nos.978 of 2017;
1422 of 2016; & 977 of 2018
COMMON JUDGMENT: (per Hon’ble Sri Justice Challa Gunaranjan)
All these three writ appeals preferred under Clause 15 of the
Letters Patent since assail the order, dated 19.09.2016, in
W.P.No.31608 of 2016, the same are heard together and disposed
of by this common judgment.
2.
W.A.No.1422 of 2016 has been preferred by ONGC Limited
(“ONGC”) dissatisfied by the portion of the order to the extent it was
directed to pay two times of wages towards compensation for the
subject period. W.A.No.977 of 2017 has been preferred by ONGC
Krishna Godavari Contract Workers Union (“Union”) to the extent of
reducing the compensation from five times of differential wages to
two times for the default in payment of wages to its members.
W.A.No.978 of 2017 has been preferred by M/s.Gurbani Security
Private Limited (“Contractor”), to the extent whereby the payment of
compensation of two times of differential wages has been directed
to be recovered from it upon discharging the liability by ONGC.
3.
Brief facts of the case are as stated below:
(a) ONGC by way of service agreement, dated 21.10.2010,
entrusted the contract of loss prevention and safety services for its
Rajahmundry asset. The duration of contract was from 08.08.2010
HCJ & CGR, J.
W.A.Nos.978 of 2017;
1422 of 2016; & 977 of 2018
to 07.08.2013. Under the agreement, the Contractor was required
to supply trained, experienced and competent personnel for
undertaking specified and assigned jobs at various locations. The
same also included supply of personnel for the duties of watch and
ward, in effect, the Contractor was mandated to supply semi-skilled
and skilled personnel for respective positions. The contract also
envisaged the commercial terms on account of the wages payable
to aforesaid personnel. As per special conditions of contract, the
Contractor at its own costs was required to be in compliance with
the provisions of the Minimum Wages Act, 1948 (for short, “the
M.W. Act”), and the Contract Labour (Regulation and Abolition) Act,
1970, (for short, “the C.L. (R&A) Act”) besides various other Laws
relevant on the subject. The contract has also envisaged that in
case the Contractor commits any default in timely payment of wages
or fails to discharge its obligations emanating from aforesaid
enactments, ONGC, as principal employer, would make good the
default or breach and shall recover the amounts paid, if any, from
the Contractor by deducting in its invoices.
(b) A claim petition came to be preferred by about 208
employees working as Security Guards and Security Supervisors
through their Union alleging short payment of the minimum wages
HCJ & CGR, J.
W.A.Nos.978 of 2017;
1422 of 2016; & 977 of 2018
for the period from 01.10.2011 to 31.03.2013, which culminated into
enquiry before the Authority under the Minimum Wages Act,1948,
Hyderabad (for short, “the Authority”). ONGC, as opposite party
No.1, contested the claim on the grounds that the rates of minimum
wages prescribed by the State Government would have no
application to it as it was governed by the rates those determined by
the Central Government, being appropriate Government and further
that under the service agreement, any revision of pay over and
above agreed under the contract has to be discharged by the
Contractor (Opposite Party No.2). The Authority, while negativing
the stand pleaded by ONGC, vide order, dated 10.10.2013, directed
ONGC to pay the minimum wages as determined therein.
(c) Yet again, another complaint came to be made by the
remaining Security Guards/Security Supervisors, who were not paid
minimum wages for aforesaid period and the same came to be
allowed by order, dated 20.01.2014, following the earlier order.
ONGC had complied with aforesaid orders. The Union had later
come up with another claim for subsequent period i.e., from
01.04.2013 to 07.08.2013. In this application, it has been claimed
that as ONGC has paid the revised wages in terms of the earlier
orders, it was expected that even for subsequent period, the revised
HCJ & CGR, J.
W.A.Nos.978 of 2017;
1422 of 2016; & 977 of 2018
wages would be paid, however, there has been deliberate default.
That being so, during the pendency of the proceedings, ONGC paid
the differential wages. However, the Authority, having found that
there was deliberate default in payment of wages, by its order,
dated 27.07.2016, awarded compensation of five times of the
differential wages and directed ONGC to pay the same. Assailing
the same, ONGC preferred W.P.No.31608 of 2016.
4.
The learned Single Judge allowed the writ petition in-part by
reducing the compensation from five times to two times of
differential wages and further, petitioner-ONGC was permitted to
recover the said amount from the Contractor.
Being dissatisfied
with the said order, all the three parties preferred present writ
appeals, as mentioned supra.
5.
Heard Mr.D.S. Sivadarshan, learned counsel for the ONGC
and Mr.C.Sumon, learned counsel for the Union. None appeared
for the Contractor.
6.
Learned counsel for the ONGC raised the following
contentions:
(i) Since there is no employer and employee relationship
between ONGC and the service personnel deployed to work at its
HCJ & CGR, J.
W.A.Nos.978 of 2017;
1422 of 2016; & 977 of 2018
Rajahmundry asset through the Contractor, it would not qualify to be
an employer within the meaning of Section 20 of the M.W. Act,
therefore, the impugned order passed by the Authority directing
ONGC to pay compensation is without jurisdiction;
(ii) ONGC is liable only to the extent of payment of wages, in
the event there is breach at the instance of Contractor, in view of
Section 21 of the C.L.(R&A) Act, and that the wages as envisaged
under the said provision do not encompass within itself any sort of
penalty or compensation;
(iii) Claim for minimum wages though is a statutory right
guaranteed under the statute, awarding of compensation in terms of
Section 20 of the M.W. Act is not automatic and since the same
being in the nature of penalty, the Authority ought to have given
specific reasons while imposing five times of differential wages as
compensation; and
(iv) To buttress the contention that there is no employer and
employee relationship between the ONGC and service personnel,
and the test one should apply to discern whether such relationship
exists or not, reliance has been placed on the following judgments:
HCJ & CGR, J.
W.A.Nos.978 of 2017;
1422 of 2016; & 977 of 2018
(i)
Balwant Rai Saluja v. Air India Ltd.1;
(ii)
International
Airport
Authority
of
India
v.
Ltd.
v.
International Air Cargo Workers Union2;
(iii)
Hindustan
Steelworks
Construction
Commissioner of Labour3.
(v)
With regard to liability of principal employer, qua the
compensation under Section 20 of the M.W.Act, learned counsel
has placed reliance on the judgment of the Orissa High Court in
Industrial Security & Allied Services v. Labour Enforcement
Officer (C), Bhubaneswar4.
7.
Opposing aforesaid submissions, learned counsel for the
Union supported the order of learned Single Judge to the extent of
fastening the liability of compensation on ONGC, however, he
contended that learned Single Judge ought not to have interfered
with the well-reasoned order of the Authority, which determined the
compensation of five times of differential wages.
He further
contended that ONGC had committed default not once, but on
multiple times, which is very much evident from the orders, dated
10.10.2013, 20.01.2014 and 27.07.2016 passed by the Authority; in
that view of the same, the Authority was absolutely justified in
(2014) 9 SCC 407
(2009) 13 SCC 374
(1996) 10 SCC 599
2023 (1) CLR 629 = 2022 (174) FLR 138 (Orissa High Court)
HCJ & CGR, J.
W.A.Nos.978 of 2017;
1422 of 2016; & 977 of 2018
granting compensation.
It is further contended that ONGC has
taken a clear stand before the Authority that it is the principal
employer and that it did not specifically plead that as a principal
employer, its liability merely confines to the payment of minimum
wages, but not the compensation in terms of Section 20 of the
M.W.Act.
8.
We have perused the record and considered the respective
submissions made by the learned counsels appearing for the
parties.
9.
The undisputed facts emanating from the record are that,
ONGC, as a principal employer, engaged the services of Contractor
for hiring skilled and semi-skilled personnel to work at one of its
assets at Rajahmundry. Service agreement, dated 21.10.2010, has
been executed between the parties for the period from 08.08.2010
to 07.08.2013. The Contractor paid the wages as per the
agreement, however, the workmen have claimed for the higher
wages on account of revised wages being notified by the State
Government from time to time. Eventually, the workers either by
themselves or through the Union approached the Authority raising a
dispute. In the first round, the claim came to be allowed vide order,
dated 10.10.2013. ONGC has specifically pleaded that it was not
HCJ & CGR, J.
W.A.Nos.978 of 2017;
1422 of 2016; & 977 of 2018
liable to pay the differential wages as it is not bound by the wages
as determined by the State Government, rather, the wages fixed by
the Central Government were applicable to it, and further that, at
any rate, as per contract, the liability, if any, would be only on the
Contractor. The same came to be negatived by the Authority and
eventually, as per the directions issued, ONGC has paid the
differential wages. Same was the case in second round also. Even
after two successive enquiries resulting in liability being fastened on
ONGC, as the differential wages were not paid for the subsequent
periods, during the third round of proceedings, though ONGC has
paid the differential wages after initiation of proceedings, the
Authority found that the conduct and the manner in which ONGC
conducted itself in paying the wages called for awarding
compensation.
10.
As could be seen from the records, we also noticed that
ONGC has pleaded before the Authority that it is the principal
employer and if in case the Contractor does not pay the wages, it
would discharge the liability. That apart, it is also to be noted that
ONGC has never raised plea that it merely is liable for payment of
wages in terms of Section 21(4) of the C.L. (R&A) Act, but not for
HCJ & CGR, J.
W.A.Nos.978 of 2017;
1422 of 2016; & 977 of 2018
the compensation to be determined under Section 20 of the M.W.
Act.
11.
Nonetheless, we will proceed to examine whether at all
ONGC is liable for compensation in terms of Section 20 of the M.W.
Act.
12.
The relevant provisions of M.W. Act, and as well as the C.L.
(R&A) Act, germane for the present purpose, are extracted
hereunder:
“(a) M.W. Act:
“Section 2(e): Interpretation. In this Act, unless there is
anything repugnant in the subject or context,(e) "employer" means any person who employs, whether
directly or through another person, or whether on behalf of
himself or any other person, one or more employees in any
scheduled employment in respect of which minimum rates of
wages have been fixed under this Act, and includes, except in
sub-section (3) of section 26,(i) …
(ii) ….
(iii)
(iv) …”
Section 2(h) "wages" means all remuneration, capable of
being expressed in terms of money, which would, if the terms of
the contract of employment, express or implied, were fulfilled, be
payable to a person employed in respect of his employment or of
work done in such employment, and includes house rent
allowance but does not include:
HCJ & CGR, J.
W.A.Nos.978 of 2017;
1422 of 2016; & 977 of 2018
(i) the value of - (a) any house- accommodation, supply of
light, water, medical attendance, or (b) any other amenity or any
service excluded by general or special order of the appropriate
Government;
(ii) any contribution paid by the employer to any Pension
Fund or Provident Fund or under any scheme of social insurance;
(iii) any travelling allowance or the value of any travelling
concession;
(iv) any sum paid to the person employed to defray special
expenses entailed on him by the nature of his employment; or
(v) any gratuity payable on discharge;
***
Section 20: Claims. (1) …..
(2) Where an employee has any claim of the nature
referred to in sub-section (1) the employee himself, or any legal
practitioner or any official of a registered trade union authorized in
writing to act on his behalf, or any Inspector, or any person acting
with the permission of the Authority appointed under subsection
(1), may apply to such Authority for a direction under sub-section
(3):
….
(3) When any application under sub-section (2) is
entertained, the Authority shall hear the applicant and the
employer, or give them an opportunity of being heard, and after
such further inquiry, if any, as it may consider necessary, may,
without prejudice to any other penalty to which the employer may
be liable under this Act, direct- (i) in the case of a claim arising out
of payment of less than the minimum rates of wages, the payment
to the employee of the amount by which the minimum wages
payable to him exceed the amount actually paid, together with the
payment of such compensation as the Authority may think fit, not
exceeding ten times the amount of such excess;
(ii) …
(4) …
HCJ & CGR, J.
W.A.Nos.978 of 2017;
1422 of 2016; & 977 of 2018
(5) ….
(6) ….”
***
(b) C.L. (R&A) Act:
Sec.2. Definitions.-(1) In this Act, unless the context
otherwise requires,“2(h) "wages" shall have the meaning assigned to it in
clause (vi) of Section 2 of the Payment of Wages Act, 1936 (4 of
1936);
21. Responsibility for payment of wages.(1) …
(2) …
(3) …
(4) In case the contractor fails to make payment of wages
within the prescribed period or makes short payment, then the
principal employer shall be liable to make payment of wages in
full or the unpaid balance due, as the case may be, to the
contract labour employed by the contractor and recover the
amount so paid from the contractor either by deduction from any
amount payable to the contractor any contract as a debt payable
by the contractor.”
13.
Learned counsel appearing for the ONGC mainly contended
that it would not fall within the ambit of definition of “employer” in
terms of Section 2(e) of the M.W. Act, inasmuch as, the tests, as
propounded by the Hon’ble Apex Court in International Airport
Authority of India case2, are not met. He tries to emphasise the
expression “who employs” in the definition of “employer”, to contend
that such employment should be in any of the following forms i.e.,
HCJ & CGR, J.
W.A.Nos.978 of 2017;
1422 of 2016; & 977 of 2018
directly, through another person on behalf of himself, on behalf of
any other person, and in present case, none of the scenarios
mentioned are attracted. Therefore, the Authority has misconstrued
ONGC to be “employer” and thereby fastened liability of
compensation, rather, it is the Contractor, who otherwise would be
liable for the same. To buttress the aforesaid submissions, heavy
reliance has been placed on the judgments of the Hon’ble Apex
Court in Balwant Rai Saluja case1 and International Airport
Authority of India case2.
14.
We would first like to deal with the judgments sought to be
relied on by the learned counsel for the ONGC. In Balwant Rai
Saluja case1, the Hon’ble Apex Court was dealing with the issue as
to whether workers engaged on casual or temporary basis by a
contractor to operate and run a statutory canteen, under the
provisions of 1948 Act, on the premises of a factory of Air India, can
be said to be the workmen of the said factory or corporation.
The
Hon’ble Apex Court was, therefore, essentially dealing with the
scheme of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1948 and the definition of
“workmen”. In that context, it has been viewed that workers
engaged by a contractor to work in the statutory canteen of a factory
would be the workers of the said factory, but, however, only for the
HCJ & CGR, J.
W.A.Nos.978 of 2017;
1422 of 2016; & 977 of 2018
purpose of the 1948 Act, and not for other purposes, and for other
purposes, they need to satisfy the test of employer-employee
relationship and it must be shown that the employer exercises
absolute and effective control over the said workers.
15.
In International Airport Authority case2, the Hon’ble Apex
Court was examining the issues emanating from the provisions of
C.L (R&A) Act, in particular, whether agreement between the
contractor Society and International Airport Authority of India in
regard to cargo handling work was sham and nominal and
consequently, the workers engaged as contract labour in regard to
cargo handling work, were the direct employees of IAAI. In that
context, the propounded test of discerning whether there exists
employer and employee relationship has been explained more
elucidately.
In the aforesaid context, while testing scenario of
contract for supply of labour, it has been observed that the principal
employer only controls and directs the work to be done by contract
labour, when such labour is assigned or allotted.
But it is the
contractor as employer, who chooses whether the worker is to be
assigned/allotted to the principal employer or used otherwise,
therefore, the worker being the employee of contractor, the ultimate
subversion and control lies with the Contractor, as he decides where
HCJ & CGR, J.
W.A.Nos.978 of 2017;
1422 of 2016; & 977 of 2018
the employee will work and how long he will work and subject to
what conditions. Only when the contractor assigns the worker to
work under the principal employer, the worker works under the
supervision and control of principal employer, which is secondary
control, but primary control remains with the contractor.
16.
These two judgments, which dealt with the provisions of the
I.D. Act, 1948 and the C.L.(R&A) Act, in our considered view, would
have no bearing on the issues falling for consideration in the present
appeals.
17.
We have come across the judgment of the Hon’ble Apex
Court in Hindustan Sanitaryware and Industries Ltd. v. State of
Haryana 5 , in which the Hon’ble Apex Court had an occasion to
consider the definition of the word “employee” in Section 2(i) of the
M.W. Act, and in the said context, explained the meaning
surrounding the expression “person employed”. In the said case,
the notification issued by Government of Haryana revising minimum
rates of wages for different scheduled employees came to be
challenged.
In the said context, dealing with an argument that
concept of principal employer and contractor is foreign to M.W. Act
and occupier/ principal employer cannot be made responsible for
(2019) 15 SCC 774
HCJ & CGR, J.
W.A.Nos.978 of 2017;
1422 of 2016; & 977 of 2018
payment of minimum rate of wages to a contract labour, negativing
the said contention, it has been held as follows:
“15. The word “employee” as defined in the Act means any
person who is employed for hire or reward in a scheduled
employment. There is no distinction made between a person
employed by the principal employer and a person employed
through a contractor. Any person who employs, whether directly
or through any other person, one or more employees in a
scheduled employment falls within the definition of an “employer”.
[ Section 2(e), Minimum Wages Act, 1948.] A close scrutiny of the
definitions of the employer and the employee would bring the
workmen employed through the contractors within the purview of
the Act. We reject the submission made on behalf of the
appellants that the contract workmen are not covered under the
Act.”
18.
Even in the present case, ONGC precisely has raised the
very same contention that the provisions of the M.W. Act do not
envisage the concept of principal employer, rather, such concept is
discernible only under the provisions of the C.L. (R&A) Act. When
once the Hon’ble Apex Court had emphatically laid down that there
is no distinction made between a person employed by a principal
employer and a person employed through a contractor, the principal
employer, as a corollary, would not only be liable for the payment of
the wages, but also the compensation as may be determined under
Section 20 of the M.W. Act. It is axiomatic that if one accepts the
HCJ & CGR, J.
W.A.Nos.978 of 2017;
1422 of 2016; & 977 of 2018
liability of wages under the provisions of M.W. Act, equally will be
liable for compensation too. It is somewhat odd for one to say the
expression employer, meaning any person who employs, partakes
within it the principal employer for the purpose of wages and not
compensation.
19.
In the judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court in Hindustan
Steelworkers Construction Ltd. case3, relied on by the learned
counsel for the ONGC, it was dealing with an issue as to whether
principal employer is liable to pay to the contract workers any
amount which constitutes the difference between the wages payable
to the contract labourer by the contractor and wages paid by the
principal employer to its own employees doing similar work.
Interpreting Section 21(4) of the C.L. (R&A) Act r/w. definition of
wages in Section 2(vi) of the Payment of Wages Act, it has been
held that, the liability of principal employer can be confined only to
the extent of default committed by the contractor in regard to
payment of contractual wages and that any other amounts, which
otherwise do not qualify to fall within the definition of wages, cannot
be imposed on the principal employer.
Since ONGC itself has
accepted that it is liable for payment of differential wages being
principal employer, this judgment would not help it in any way.
HCJ & CGR, J.
W.A.Nos.978 of 2017;
1422 of 2016; & 977 of 2018
20.
In Industrial Security and Allied Services case4, the Orissa
High Court dealt with the liability of payment of differential minimum
wages qua the principal employer.
The said judgment did not
consider the issue regarding the liability of compensation qua the
principal employer under the provisions of the M. W. Act. In the
facts and circumstances of that particular case, based on the tender
call notice conditions, it was held that the liability to pay differential
minimum wages was on the service providing contractor, but not the
principal employer. Inasmuch as in the present case, ONGC itself
has taken upon itself the liability to pay the differential minimum
wages and since the same is not subject matter of challenge in the
present proceedings, the said judgment also does not in any way
come up to the aid of ONGC.
21.
ONGC at one breath has conceded that it is liable to pay the
differential wages and at another breath, disputed the liability
towards compensation. The said stand is sought to be justified with
reference to Section 21(4) of the C.L. (R&A) Act.
Both these
legislations i.e., M.W. Act and C.L. (R&A) Act, being beneficial
legislations aiming to protect the interests of workmen, and that the
definition of “wages” under both these enactments being one and
the same, there is no reason for us to accede to the contention of
HCJ & CGR, J.
W.A.Nos.978 of 2017;
1422 of 2016; & 977 of 2018
the ONGC that being a principal employer, it is merely responsible
or liable for the minimum wages and not for any other
consequences, in particular, the compensation component.
We,
therefore, are of the view that ONGC as a principal employer is not
only liable for payment of wages, but also the compensation as well.
22.
Now coming to the aspect of determining the compensation,
learned counsel for ONGC contended that there are no reasons
assigned
by
the
Authority
for
justifying
determination
of
compensation of five times of differential wages and the learned
Single Judge being oblivious to the same, merely reduced the
compensation to two times of differential wages, rather than setting
aside in entirety.
23.
On the other hand, learned counsel for the Union contended
that the Authority had rightly determined the compensation of five
times, but, learned Single Judge reduced the same to two times, for
no reason, therefore, urged to restore the order of the Authority.
24.
On the aforesaid aspect, learned Single Judge, after referring
to the judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court in Prerna Sahygo v.
Authority under Minimum Wages 6 , and further considering the
facts and circumstances of the case, in particular, that ONGC earlier
(2001) 9 SCC 247
HCJ & CGR, J.
W.A.Nos.978 of 2017;
1422 of 2016; & 977 of 2018
also defaulted in making the payment of wages for the period from
01.10.2011 to 31.03.2013, on two occasions and further defaulted
again for the period from 01.04.2013 to 07.08.2013, decided to
reduce the compensation and ordered to pay the same by two times
of the differential wages. In fact, the order also goes to show that
ONGC had pleaded that one-time compensation to be ordered
considering the judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court in Prerna
Sahygo case6.
25.
For the purpose of determining the compensation, the
authority is required to satisfy itself that the employer was indulging
in malicious and vexatious acts.
If the employer’s acts are
distressing, the authority will be well justified in imposing
compensation. In the present case, as can be seen from the order,
dated 10.10.2013, though ONGC had initially tried to contest the
liability of payment of differential wages, the same came to be
rejected, and eventually, it had paid the amounts as directed. In the
said order, it is also recorded that ONGC had submitted that fair
wage policy is going to be implemented soon inasmuch as the same
has already been implemented in the western section of ONGC
after a Memorandum of Settlement under Section 12(2) of the I.D.
Act, and the same too is being contemplated even at the
HCJ & CGR, J.
W.A.Nos.978 of 2017;
1422 of 2016; & 977 of 2018
Rajahmundry asset. In those circumstances, the Authority decided
not to impose any compensation for delayed payment of minimum
wages.
Despite the same, there was another default which
culminated into second round of proceedings followed by order,
dated 20.01.2014, and a further proceeding culminating into order,
dated 27.07.2016. ONGC had been consistently in default of
payment of differential wages. Therefore, the authority did arrive
the satisfaction for the purpose of imposing compensation.
26.
Learned Single Judge, while reducing the compensation,
directed ONGC to pay the same, in turn, permitted it to recover the
same from the Contractor. As could be seen from the terms of the
service agreement, it is agreed between the parties therein that any
liability per se over and above what has been agreed under the
contract shall have to be borne by the Contractor alone. Therefore,
learned Single Judge rightly has permitted the ONGC to recover the
same from the Contractor. The learned Single Judge, after
considering all the aforesaid aspects, has rightly determined the
compensation of two times of differential wages, which is absolutely
justified and does not call for any interference.
HCJ & CGR, J.
W.A.Nos.978 of 2017;
1422 of 2016; & 977 of 2018
27.
For the foregoing reasons, we do not find any merit in these
appeals, and accordingly, the same stand dismissed. No order as
to costs.
As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions pending consideration, if
any, in these appeals shall stand closed.
LISA GILL, CJ
CHALLA GUNARANJAN, J.
cs
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review