Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
TUESDAY,THE SIXTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE T,MADHAVI DEVI
CIVIL REVISION PETITION NO: 2582 OF 202s
I
Petition Under Article 227 of the Constitution of lndia against the order
dated 01-07-2025 in l.A.No. 14 ot 2O25 in O.S.No. 81 of 20'18 on the file of the
Hon'ble Principal District Judge, Khammam
Between
1. M/s New Era Educational Society, Represented by its Secretary and
Correspondent, New Era High School, Mamata Hospital Road, Khammam
Dist. Telangana.
2. L V. Ramana Rao, S/o late l. Sitaramaiah Aged about 63 years, Secretary
and Correspondent New Era High School, Mamata Hospital Road, Khammam
Dist. Telangana.
I
... Revision Petitioners/ Defendants No. 1 & 3
AND
1. Smt. V. Saraswathi, d/o late V. Venkateswar Rao, Aged 78 years, Occ: Retd.
Govt. Lecturer, R/ o Cheruvu Bazar, Khammam Town{hammffis};ict
2. Mr. lnjam Sitaramaiah (died)
3. Smt. l. Seetharavamma, W/o late l. Sitaramaiah, Aged about 76 years,
Member, New Era Educational Society, New Era High School, Mamata
Hospital Road, Khammam Dist. Telangana.
4. Kancheti Narsimha Rao, S/o K. Venkateshwarlu, Aged about 65 years, Joint
Secretary, New Era Educational Society, New Era High School, Mamata
Hospital Road, Khammam Dist. Telangana.
5. Kancheti Srinivasa Rao, S/o K. Venkateshwarlu, Aged 65 years, Occ: Vice
President, New Era Educational Society, New Era High School, Mamata
Hospital Road, Khammam Dist. Telangana.
6. Smt- lnjam Krishnaveni, w/o Y. Laxminarayana, Aged 61 years, Occ
Household, Rl/o D. No. 4- 2- 624, Rotary Nagar, Khammam Urban, Khammam
District, Telangana.
( Respondent No. 2, 4 to 6 are not necessary parties in the present CRP)
...RESPONDENTS/ Defendants No. 2, 4,5,6,7
I
lA NO: 1 OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to stay
all further proceedings in OS No. 81 of 2018 on the file of the Hon'ble Principal
District Judge, Khammam.
Counsel for the Petitioner: M/S JURISLIT LAW LLP
Counsel for the Respondent No.1 : SRI RAVULA RAJASHEKAR
Counsel for the Respondent No, 3 : -The Court made the following ORDER:
IN TTIT] HIGH COUR'I'FOR T'HI' S1'ATI' ()F TT]LANGANA
A'I- HYDI.]RABAI)
1'I{E IIONOIiRABLE SM'I.. JUSTICT] 1" MADIIAVI I)EVI
ctrVlr- R[.vrsroN pEl'n'toN N0.2582 ()t'2025
DAl'Et) . & .01.2026
Between:
M/s New llra Educational Society rep. by its
Sccretary and Correspondent, New Era High
School, Marnata Hospital Road, Khammam
District and another
... Petitioners
AND
Smt. V. Saraswathi and 5 others
... Respondents
ORDT]R
'I'his Civil Revision Petition (CRP) is filed against the order ol'the
Principal Disrrict Judge at Khammarn dt.01.07.2025 in I.A.No.l4 ol202-5 in O.S.No.8l ol20l8.
U
2.
The suit was filed for recovery of an amount of Rs.5,00,76,000/-
'fhe petitioners herein are defendants I and 3 in the suit.'l'he delendants
filcd I.A.No. I ol-2021 in O.S.No.t3 I of 2018 lor sending the signatures
C.R.P.No.2582 of2025
of thc petitioncrs to a [Jandwriting Expert to form an opinion. The
plaintiltTl" responclent opposed the same by Iiling a counter stating that
lt
is necessaly that the signatures contemporaneous to the disputed
signatures be sent for comparison and that the petition is vague and
superfluous anrl that thc' rvhole exercise is of'no avail in view of the
inconclus iveness of' such e'u'idence and it only leads to wastage of the
precious tirnc c,f the ('our1. Howc'ver, the trial Court allowed the said
petition and challenginq thc sanle. the petitioners herein along with
others flled C.R.l'.No.1426 ol 2022. This Court, vrTe its order
dt.25.09.2023 . obscrved that the Court below has to direct to send the
signatures in t:x.A.2 and Ex.A.3 along with the contemporaneous
I
signatures of the parties but not thc present signatures for comparison.
Accordingly, the ordc,r dt.30.08.2022 passed in I.A.No. 1 of 2021 in
O.S.No.81 ol 20ltt was set aside and thc Principal District Judge,
Khammam was directe,cl to send the signanrres ol Ex.A.2 and Ex.A.3
along rvith the c()ntemporaneous signatures of the defendants to a
Handwriting [:xper1 for conrparison ol thc signatures. It is stated that in
compliance thcrrwith, the leamcd l,rincipal District Judge, Kiammam
was supposcd to se nd the original documents of Ex.A.2 dt. 10.06.2013
and Ex.A.3 dt. lti.0l .20l3 along with contemporaneous admitted
C.R.P.No.2582 of 2025
signatures to a l{andwriting Expeft. lnstead, he has sent Exs.A.2 and A.3
dt. 10.06.2013 and 18.01.2013 respectively along with the present day
signatures, i.e., 09.01.2025 ol' thc revision petitioner No.2 obtained in
the open Court arrd the photocopies of' the signatures of respondent
I
No.2/defendant No.2 (died) to the Handwriting lJxpert and the
Handwriting lrxpert has given opinion in File No.DCV/09/2025
dt.07.02.2025, against which the revision petitioners have taken
objcction by tiling I.A.No. l4 ol 2025. The said petition has been
disnrissed vide orders dt.01.07.2025 and against the same, the present
CI{P is flled.
l
3.
Learned Senior Counsel appearing for the petitioners subn.ritted
that the siqnatures obtaincd by the leamed Principal District Judge,
Kharnrnam lor conrparison are not contemporaneous signatures to
Ir.xs.A.2 and A.3, but arc the current signatures and tl'rerelore, the
opinion of the l{andwriting Expert on such evidence should not be
considered and that the impugned order passed by the Principal District
t;
Judgc, Kharnmam is against the spirit and object of the order of this
Court in C.l{.P.No.2426 of 2022 dr.25.09.2023.It is lurther submitted
that instead of sending the original documents of Exs.Al and r\4 for
cornparison, the photocopies were sent, which is not permissible in law.
\t?
C.R.P.No.2582 o1 2025
It is fi.rrtlrer subnlitted thirt irr terms of Scctions 45 and 73 of the Indian
Evidenct- Act (Sections .19( I ) and 72 ol Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam,
202-i ), dispLrteil signatures shouk[ not only be comparecl with the
conternporaneous signaturcs but those contemporaneous signatures
should be admitted signatures ol'the concerned party as well, and unless
the signatures are adnritted signatures, they cannot be allowed to be
compared. lt is subrnitted that the trial (lourt failcd to consider the
material produced by the rcvision petitioners, i.e., the report issued by
thc'lruth Labs dt.15.05.2025 in f ilc No.'l-LlllQDl10612025, wherein it
is clearly stated that Exs.A.2 and A.3 are forged documents and that the
sarne are not tallying with the admitted signatures of the def-endant.
'lhereflore, it is prayed that the irnl'rugned order be set aside and the
original documents of Exs.A.2 and A.3 be sent to the Handwriting
Expert lor second opinion along with the contemporaneous signatures.
{
4.
[.t'arned t:oLrrrsel or the rL'spondent No. I /plaintill' suppofted the
i
I
impugned order and subnritted that pursuant to the directions of this
Corrrt in Cl.lt.P.No.2426 ol 2022 dt.25.09.2023, the trial Court has sent
Exs.A.2 and A..l to Telangana Forensic Laboratory for opinion, who
havc given thcil opinion in favour of the plaintiff and conflrmed the
signatures of def-endants 2 and I as original signatures and not being
I
C.R.P.No.2582 of2025
I
satisficd with the said opinion, delendant No.3 without obtaining
permission liom the lJon'ble Court, has sent his own signatures to 'I'ruth
Labs, I{yderabad and rcceivcd opinion on 15.05.2025 and that this
evidence is inadmissible in law. lt is submitted that the l'ruth Labs is a
private organisation and that the docurrents marked in the Court cannot
be sent fbr cornparison without the pernrission ol the Court. It is lurther
statcd that thc'fruth I-aboratorics has given two opinions, one in fbvour
of the plaintifl'and the second in lavour ol del-endants 2 and 3 and that
delendant No.3 has to ohtain perrnission to cross-examine the
I{andwriting Expert on lris report, but they have not prelcrred to do so
and therefote, the I.A. was not maintainable and the trial Court, after
corisidering the sanre, has observed that the Handwriting Expert's
opinion dt.07.02.2025 ls not proved by exarnining the Handwriting
Expert and unless and until it is proved to be correct or not, the question
of consideratior-r ol obtaining second opinion does not arise and
j
therefole, the present petition is premature and he thus support the order
of the trial Court.
5.
I{aving regard to the rival contentions and the n-raterial on record,
this Court firrds that in earlier CRP, i.e., C.R.P.No.2426 of 2022, this
i
Court had directed the trial Couft to obtain contemporaneous signatures
C.R.P.No.2582 of 2025
ol' thc dct'endants and send the sarne to tlie Handwriting Expert lbr
comparison. But, as pointed out by the learnecl counsel for the revsion
pctitioners, the signatures ol tl-re defcndants werc taken in open Court on
09.01.2015 and rherefbre, it cannot be considered as contemporaneous
signatures. lrxs.A.2 and A.3 are o1' the ycar 20 l3 and thcrelore, the
contL-nr poran eous signatures would be of the relevant year, i.e., 201 3
ancl thc atilnitted signature s of defenilant No.3 during the relcvant period
can be obtainecl and the originals of such documents should be sent litr
comparison and lbr the opinion ol the Handwriting Expert, particularly
since defendant No.3 is alleging that the documents Exs.A.2 and A.3 are
torged and fabricated. The defendants, however, have not tnentioned as
to.whethcr they possess any contemporaneous documents such as
rcgislered sale deeds or the specimen signatures lrom a bank or any
docunrents submitted be fbrc statutory authorities of the years 20i2,
2013 and 20 14.
f
6.
The leamed counsel for respondent No.l/plaintiff placed reliance
upon the judgment of the Andhra Pradesh Fligh Court in C.R.P.No.4l I
ol'2024 dt.28.11.2024 in support of his contention that when expert
opiniou can be called for and the contemporaneous signatures/
handwritings are not readily available, then the Court may require the
*-.'.
I
./
C.R.P.No 2582 of2025
parly or iurpress the petitioning pafiy that the comparison of disputed
handwritingsisignatures with adrnitted handwritings/signatures separated
by a timc lag ol 2 to 3 ycars *,ould be desirable so as to facilitate the
Expert to give satislactory opinion and it is at the discretion of the Courl
to pass such an order.
7.
Therefore, tl.re impugned order dt.01.07.2025 in I.A.No. l4 of
2025 in O.S.No.8l ol'2018 on tl.re file of the Principal District Judge at
Kliarnrnanr is sct asidc and the trial Court is dirccted to obtain
contenr poraneous docur.ncnts containirrg the signatures
of petitioner
No.2 herein and send thcrrr to the Handwriting Experl along with the
original docurnents of Exs.A.2 and A.3 wl.rich are filed into the Court tbr
companson.
8.
The Civil Revision Petition is accordingly allowed. No order as to
costs.
9.
Pending miscellaneous petitions, if any, in this Civil Revision
Petition shalI sland closed.
sd/ . MOMINA MEHAR
IST ANT REGISTRAR
A
//TRUE COPY//
\
To,
Khammam
The PrinciPa I District Jdug e,
UC]
LAW LLP Advocate
ISLIT
2 One CC to S RI. M/S JUR
RAJASHEKAR Advocate loPucl
3 One CC to SRI' RAVULA
4 . Two CD CoPies
ku1/kam
Yv
CTTON OFFICER
,
/
HIGH COURT
DATED:06/01/2026
HE S
ORDER
o
0 2 r[B 2026
CRP.No.2582 ot 2025
*
*
n
,,\I,I,O\\'ING 1'HT] CRP
wI'tHou't c()s1's
\
C co\'
\q -,
d(flI'
€
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review