Keep judgments in folders, mark the paragraphs you rely on, and print a compilation with an index.
It comes with the Research and Advocate Pro judgment plans and with a campus licence.
Sign in · See the plans
Cite the court's own record or the law report in court filings.
The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
19. 08.2017 passed by the learned District Judge to the extent it closes the Petitioners evidence and drops Shri Govind Mohan as a witness is set aside and it is directed that the learned District Judge, Special Division I, shall take necessary steps to examine the said Shri Govind Mohan as the Petitioner’s witness for the just decision of the case.
15. The Petitioner who is appearing in person further submits that the concerned documents sought to be relied upon by the Petitioner in the Trial not being available he would have difficulties. The said issue is not before this Court in the present Writ Petition. The Petitioner may file appropriate application before the Trial Court as advised for the said purpose. Nothing further remains to be examined.
16. The Writ Petition is disposed of in the above terms. Court No.3 Record of Proceedings
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
WP(C) No.50/2017
……. Petitioners.
M/S NAURATANMAL ASHOK KUMAR & ANOTHER
VERSUS
……. Respondents.
YANGZILA BHUTIANI & ANOTHER
Date: 01/06/2018
CORAM :
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BHASKAR RAJ PRADHAN, J.
For Petitioners
:
Petitioner No.2 in person.
For Respondent No.1
:
Mr. Sudipto Mazumdar, Advocate.
For Respondent No.2
:
Mr. S.K Chhetri,
Advocate.
Assistant
Government
………
O R D E R (O R A L)
1.
Heard.
2.
The present Writ Petition invoking the powers under Article
227 of the Constitution of India seeks to assail two orders
passed by the learned District Judge dated 02.06.2017 and
19.08.2017 in Title Suit (Declaratory) No.01/2012. The Writ
Petition was filed on 29.08.2017. The learned District Judge
vide the impugned order dated 02.06.2017 opined that given
the nature of the litigation and the issues involved in it 20
witnesses named in the list of Plaintiff’s witnesses were found
to be relevant out of the 52 witnesses sought to be examined
by the Petitioner herein as the Plaintiff. The learned District
Judge was of the view that in determining the number of
witnesses the Court should take into account the nature of
litigation, nature and number of issues required to be proved
and the fact on whom onus has to be laid. The learned
District Judge was also of the view that it has also to take into
Court No.3
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM
Record of Proceedings
account the specified purpose for which the particular
witnesses is required to be produced.
3.
The impugned order dated 02.06.2017 records that the
Petitioner had submitted considering the nature of the case it
would not be possible for him to produce the 20 witnesses on
his own and prayed for issuing summons to the concerned
witnesses at his expense. Accordingly, as desired by the
Petitioner summons were issued to the said witnesses for
various dates.
4.
The impugned order dated 02.06.2017 also records that
the Petitioner desired to file his evidence on affidavit by
12.06.2017. A perusal of the records thereafter reflects that
the said suit proceeded through trial. The records also reveal
that the learned District Judge was conscious of the fact that
the Petitioner was not represented by a lawyer and therefore
full and adequate opportunity was given to the Petitioner to
present his case. Documents which were not filed originally
were also permitted to be filed by the Petitioner.
5.
On 12.06.2017 the Petitioner confirmed and authenticated
his evidence on affidavit before the Trial Court on oath. On
13.06.2017
the
Petitioner
was
cross-examined
by
the
Respondents herein. The Petitioner’s witnesses who were
summoned as desired by the Petitioner were examined on
various dates till 19.08.2017. Admittedly out of 20 witnesses
16 witnesses have already been examined.
Court No.3
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM
Record of Proceedings
6.
Vide the impugned order dated 19.08.2017 it is recorded
that the date was fixed for examination of Shri Phuchung
Tshering Bhutia, Shri Govind Mohan and Shri C.M Sharma.
Since Shri Phuchung Tshering Bhutia was present he was
examined and
his
statement was
recorded. The
other
witnesses were absent. Summons issued to Shri C.M Sharma
had returned unserved with the report that he was not found
in the given address.
7.
The Petitioner submitted before the Trial Court that he
was unaware of the present address of Shri C.M Sharma and
accordingly, prayed to drop Shri CM Sharma on the said
ground. The said impugned order dated 19.08.2017 also
records that according to the Petitioner the facts required to
be proved by the said witnesses were already in his notings
which are there before the Trial Court. As prayed for by the
Petitioner Shri C.M Sharma was dropped as the Petitioners
witnesses.
8.
Summons issued to Shri Govind Mohan had however,
returned unserved with the report that he had already been
transferred on deputation outside the state for a period of five
year.
9.
The Respondents submitted before the Trial Court that the
notings required to be proved by Shri Govind Mohan were
already before the Trial Court and as such, summoning him,
which was not possible without incurring considerable delay
and inconvenience could be a futile exercise. The Petitioner
conceded that the noting of Shri Govind Mohan were already
Court No.3
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM
Record of Proceedings
before the Trial Court and that he was only required to prove
the said notings. The learned District Judge thus opined that
since the concerned notings were made by Shri Govind Mohan
in his capacity as public servant summoning him to merely
identify the same that too at the cost of undue delay would be
a futile exercise, more so when the said notings are already
before the Trial Court.
10.
The impugned order dated 19.08.2017 also records that
the Petitioner had not taken any steps with regard to his
witness Shri B.K Naug despite direction of the Trial Court in
this regard given vide order dated 14.07.2017. The Petitioner
submitted before the Trial Court that the said witness was
required to be examined in connection with the entries
(particularly thumb impressions) in the Volume Book (No.1)
which was supposed to be produced by the Respondent No.2.
It is also recorded that unfortunately the said volume book
was not traceable in the concerned office and the said fact
was also affirmed on oath by the Respondent No. 2 vide
affidavit dated 26.07.2017 and as such, summoning the said
witness would be a futile exercise. Thus, the District Judge
vide impugned order dated 19.08.2017 closed the Plaintiff’s
evidence and directed the Respondent No.1 to file her as well
as her witnesses evidence on affidavit by 01.09.2017.
Aggrieved thereby the Petitioner has preferred the present
Writ Petition.
11.
A perusal of the impugned order dated 02.06.2017
makes it evident that the learned Trial Court had infact
Court No.3
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM
Record of Proceedings
examined the nature of the litigation and passed the reasoned
impugned order directing the examination of 20 witnesses
named therein by the Petitioner out of the 53. The records
also reveal that pursuant to the said impugned order dated
02.06.2017 the Trial has proceeded and 16 witnesses have
already been examined. The Petitioner did not assail the said
impugned order dated 02.06.2017 until the impugned order
dated 19.08.2017 was passed by the learned District Judge.
In fact the records reveal that the impugned order dated
02.06.2017 was accepted by the Petitioner and steps taken
by him as directed.
[
12.
The impugned order dated 02.06.2017 had come to a
firm conclusion that the examination of the 20 witnesses
including Shri B.K Naug, Shri Govind Mohan and Shri C.M
Sharma were relevant for the purpose of the Trial. The
records reveal the examination of Shri B.K Naug was not
pursued by the Petitioner himself and Shri C.M Sharma was
dropped at the instance of the Petitioner.
13.
The only question which therefore remains to be
answered by this Court in the present Writ Petition is whether
the impugned order dated 19.08.2017 dropping Shri Govind
Mohan
as
a
witness
was
correct
in
the
facts
and
circumstances of the present case. It is trite that documents
are required to be proved by the maker thereof. Admittedly,
Shri Govind Mohan has been named as the concerned official
who has made the notings sought to be relied upon by the
Petitioner. The learned District Judge had already come to the
Court No.3
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM
Record of Proceedings
conclusion that Shri Govind Mohan was a relevant witness.
The only reason assigned for dropping Shri Govind Mohan by
the learned District Judge is that since the said notings have
been made by Shri Govind Mohan in his capacity as a public
servant summoning him to merely identify it that too at the
cost of undue delay would be a futile exercise. The learned
District
Judge
having
first
come
to
a
conclusion
vide
impugned order dated 02.06.2017 that the said Shri Govind
Mohan was a relevant witness and thereafter having issued
summons was not correct in dropping the said Shri Govind
Mohan as a witness on the ground adverted to above.
14.
In view of the aforesaid the impugned order dated
19.08.2017 passed by the learned District Judge to the extent
it closes the Petitioners evidence and drops Shri Govind
Mohan as a witness is set aside and it is directed that the
learned District Judge, Special Division I, shall take necessary
steps to examine the said Shri Govind Mohan as the
Petitioner’s witness for the just decision of the case.
15.
The Petitioner who is appearing in person further
submits that the concerned documents sought to be relied
upon by the Petitioner in the Trial not being available he
would have difficulties. The said issue is not before this Court
in
the
present
Writ
Petition.
The
Petitioner
may
file
appropriate application before the Trial Court as advised for
the said purpose. Nothing further remains to be examined.
16.
The Writ Petition is disposed of in the above terms.
Court No.3
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM
Record of Proceedings
17.
The Interim order passed by this Court on 01.09.2017 is
vacated. Let the parties appear before the Court of learned
District Judge, Special Division-I, East Sikkim at Gangtok on
18.06.2018.
18.
The lower Court records shall be remitted forthwith.
Judge
01-06-2018
avi/
Index : Yes / No
Internet : Yes / No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review
Advocates who handle your kind of matter will see your enquiry.
Your enquiry goes to advocates and law firms on LegalFirms.in who handle this kind of matter. Your phone number and email are shown only to those who open it.
✓
Enquiry Submitted!
Reference:
✓ Your enquiry has been sent to advocates who handle this kind of matter.