Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 17-18
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 345 of 2021 with
WP(C) No. 346 of 2021
M/S Meghalaya Feed Products
M/S Meghalaya Feed Products
Date of Decision: 07.08.2023
Vs.
Vs.
Union of India & Ors.
Union of India & Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) : Dr. B.P. Todi, Sr. Adv. with
Dr. A. Todi, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
: Dr. N. Mozika, DSGI with
Ms. S. Rumthao, Adv. (For R 1)
Ms. S. Ain, GA (For R 2-4)
Mr. B.A. Wanswett, Adv. vice
Mrs. P.D.Bujarbaruah, Sr. Adv. (For R 5).
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (ORAL)
1.
The writ petitioner is before this Court in a second round of
litigation by way of these two writ petitions, and as they are similar are
being disposed of by this common order and judgment. These matters
concern the grant of subsidy on the transport of raw materials and
finished products, under the Transport Subsidy Scheme, 1971, from
selected areas to promote industries which includes the State of
Meghalaya of which the petitioner firm is a beneficiary.
2.
By these writ petitions, the writ petitioner firm is aggrieved
with the non-disbursement of the complete amount of transport subsidy,
which it claims has been allowed by this Court by order dated
03.05.2019, passed in WP(C) No. 389 and 390 of 2014, wherein, it was
held that the requirement for payment by cheque of the expenditure
incurred, would not be applicable for the period 01.10.2008 to
31.12.2008 and 01.01.2009 to 31.03.2009, the period for which the
subsidy had been claimed. It has been contended by the writ petitioner
that, the order dated 03.05.2019, had directed the respondents to reconsider the claim, in the light of the observations made therein, for
disbursement of the subsidy amount for the period 01.10.2008 to
31.12.2008 and 01.01.2009 to 31.03.2009, which however the
respondents by the impugned order dated 02.08.2019, though releasing
certain amounts, fell short of the amount as claimed by the writ
petitioner.
3.
In this context, as the matter had been dealt with by this Court
in the earlier writ petitions namely WP(C) No. 389 and 390 of 2014,
which were disposed of by order dated 03.05.2019, it would be useful to
reproduce the same below, for easy reference:
Serial No. 03
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 389 of 2014
With WP(C) No. 390 of 2014
Date of order: 03.05.2019
The Union of India & Ors.
4.
M/S Meghalaya Feed Products Vs.
Coram:
Hon‟ble Mr. Justice Mohammad Yaqoob Mir, Chief Justice
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) :Dr. B.P. Todi, Sr. Adv. with
Dr. A. Todi, Adv.
Ms. P. Agarwal, Adv.
For the Respondent(s) : Mr. R. Debnath, CGC (For R 1)
Mr. S. Sengupta, Addl.Sr.GA (For R 2- 4)
Ms. B. Ghosh, Adv.
Vice Mrs. P.D.B. Baruah, Adv. (For R 5)
i)Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
Yes/No
ii)Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Oral:1.
The scheme called the „Transport Subsidy Scheme, 1971‟ has
been formulated and notified for grant of subsidy on the transport
of raw materials and finished goods to and from the selected areas
with a view to promote growth of industries. The State of
Meghalaya falls within the selected area „A‟ of the scheme. In the
said area petitioner M/S Meghalaya Feed Products has an
industrial unit. Vide letter dated 12.05.2009 issued by the
respondent Director of Industries to the petitioner, it has been
conveyed that the subsidies had been sanctioned against the claim
of the petitioner by the State Level Committee in its 58 th meeting
held on 07.05.2009 as such, has been advised to contact the North
Eastern
Development
Finance,
Guwahati
for
necessary
disbursement. The types of subsidy, period and amount sanctioned
are as under:
“
Sl.
No.
1.
2.
2.
Types of Subsidy
Period
Central Interest Subsidy
Central
Transport
Subsidy
- do - do - do Total :
01.09.05 to 31.03.09
01.04.08 to 30.06.08
01.07.08 to 30.09.08
01.10.08 to 31.12.08
01.01.09 to 31.03.09
Amount
Sanctioned
(Rs)
24,56,615.00
68,12,316.00
66,43,080.00
94,74,928.00
1,38,69,552.00
3,92,56,491.00
”
So far as the subsidy for the periods of 01.09.2005 to
31.03.2009, 01.04.2008 to 30.06.2008 and 01.07.2008 to 30.09.2008
are concerned same have been disbursed in favour of the petitioner
whereas, regarding the Central Transport Subsidy for the periods of
01.10.2008 to 31.12.2008 and 01.01.2009 to 31.03.2009, amounting
to Rs. 2,33,44,480/- has not been disbursed same has been conveyed
to the respondent No. 5 by the Under Secretary to the Govt. of India
vide letter dated 02.09.2014 because the expenditure incurred by
cash on transportation of raw materials/finished goods is not
permissible as per the existing policy.
3.
It appears that for ensuring that the object for grant of
subsidy is not misused, the checklists for scrutiny of claims under
the Transport Subsidy Scheme has been formulated as Annexures
„A‟ and „B‟ to the letter dated 20.11.2009 issued from the Ministry
of Commerce and Industry, Department of Industrial Policy &
Promotion which inter alia provides that all claims arising from
transportation of raw materials and finished goods prior to
10.09.2009 will be examined/re-audited as per checklist „A‟ of 44
points. Point No. 35 which is relevant provides as under, Bank
statement for payment made to Transporters during the period
(payment only by cheque).
4.
Precisely, the point for consideration is as to whether Point
No. 35 for the periods of 01.10.2008 to 31.12.2008 and 01.01.2009
to 31.03.2009 will apply viz-a-viz payment to Transporters by
cheque, the answer has to be no. The notification has been issued
on 20.11.2009, the periods of claim of the petitioner is 01.10.2008 to
31.12.2008 and 01.01.2009 to 31.03.2009, during that period he had
no idea that he has to satisfy the condition of making the payment
of the transportation by cheque, as usual he has claim to have made
the payment by cash, same he had done in case of the other three
claims for the periods of 01.09.2005 to 31.03.2009, 01.04.2008 to
30.06.2008 and 01.07.2008 to 30.09.2008, the amount of those
claims has been disbursed. To abruptly say that the petitioner did
not make the payment by cheque for the periods when the
notification dated 20.11.2009 was not in place shall be illogical even
though in the notification the condition has been incorporated that
all claims arising for transportation of raw materials and finished
goods prior to 10.09.2009 will be examined/pre-audited as per
checklist „A‟ of 44 points. Point 35 providing for payment by cheque
is introduced in the month of November 2009, petitioner claim to
have made the payment by cash during the relevant quarter on
31.03.2009, as such the condition, if applied retrospective will
totally be illogical.
5.
Now, the question is as to whether the claim of the petitioner
is genuine or not, same position is clarified by respondent No. 5 in
the affidavit-in-opposition by annexing pre-audit report in respect
of the Transport Subsidy Scheme sent by the Under Secretary to the
Government of India to the Chairman cum Managing Director,
North East Development Finance Corporation Ltd. The pre-audit
team during its visit from 19.01.2012 to 28.01.2012 of 64 th SLC
dated 30.05.2011 had at paragraphs 67 to 68 dealt with the claim of
the petitioner for the aforesaid periods. In the remarks column it is
recorded as under:
“
CENTRAL TRANSPORT SUBSIDY CLAIMS OF MEGHALAYA PRE-AUDITED BY PRE
AUDIT TEAM during its visit from 19-01-2012 to 28-01-2012 OF 64TH SLC Dated 30-52011
Sl.
Name &
Period of
Amount
Amount
Amount
Remarks
No. address of
claim
approved recommended disallowed
the
by the
by Pre Audit
by Pre
Company
SLC
Audit by if
any
M/S
01-10-2008 to 9474928
9474928
Sanctioned by the
Meghalay 31-12-2008
58th SLC held on
a
Feed
07-05-2009 but not
Products
Audited, the present
team Audited the
case on request of
Directorate as no
such guide line was
provided by DIPP
before issuance of 44
points guide lines
about cash payment.
Hence
the
cash
payment made to the
transporters by the
units have been
allowed.
Sl.
No.
CENTRAL TRANSPORT SUBSIDY CLAIMS OF MEGHALAYA PRE-AUDITED BY PRE
AUDIT TEAM during its visit from 19-01-2012 to 28-01-2012 OF 64TH SLC Dated 30-5-2011
Name &
Period of
Amount
Amount
Amount
Remarks
address of
claim
approved recommended disallowed
the
by the
by Pre Audit
by Pre
Company
SLC
Audit by if
any
M/S
01-01-2009 to 13869552
13869552
Sanctioned by the
Meghalay 31-03-2009
58th SLC held on 07a
Feed
05-2009 but not
Products
Audited, the preset
team Audited the
case on request by
Directorate as no
such guide line was
provided by DIPP
before issuance of
44/45 points guide
lines about cash
payment. Hence the
cash payment made
to the transporters by
the unit have been
0 allowed.
6.
”
The object of avoiding misuse of the subsidy is achieved
because the claim of the petitioner has been audited by the Pay and
Accounts Officer, Pay & Accounts Office, Ministry of MSMF,
therefore, there could be no reason for the respondents to deny the
claim of the petitioner. That apart, it shall be open for the
respondents, if they so choose, to re-verify, in case they have any
doubt about the audit conducted by the Pay and Accounts Officer,
Pay & Accounts Office, Ministry of MSMF otherwise, the amount
shall be disbursed subject to adherence to the norms.
7.
Petition is disposed of with a direction to the respondents that
they shall re-consider the claim of the petitioner, in the light of the
aforesaid observations, for
disbursement
of
the
subsidy
amounting to Rs. 94,74,928/- and Rs. 1,38,69,552/- for the periods
of 01.10.2008 to 31.12.2008 and 01.01.2009 to 31.03.2009
respectively along with interest from the date of Pre-Audit report
and to pass appropriate order thereon whatever permissible under
rules within a period of four weeks.
8.
4.
Disposed of as above.
The directions of this Court, as contained in Para – 6 and 7 as
quoted above, had left it open for the respondents if they chose, to reverify the claim amount of the writ petitioner and had disposed of the
writ petitions, with the direction that the claims be re-considered. It was
in this backdrop that, the respondent particularly the respondent No. 1,
while re-verifying the claim of the petitioner by the impugned order
dated 02.08.2019, released most of the claim amount, but not the full
amount as claimed by observing therein ‘inter alia’ as follows.
“AND WHEREAS, the claim denied is for the period
1.10.2008 to 31.3.2009 which the Hon‟ble High Court has
ordered to review, reconsider and pay. Since the subsidy
claimed during second half of 2008-09 is significantly higher
than that paid in the first half of 2008-09 which has been
denied on account of cash payment, DPIIT reviewed the
denial order and agreed to pay as much subsidy as was paid
in the first half of 2008-09 i.e. Rs.1,34,55,396/-. Under the
given circumstances, this should be considered fair and
reasonable because DPIIT don‟t trust the cash payments.
Based on subsidy claims of 1st half of 2008-09 made by
cheque i.e. Rs.1,34,55,396/- plus simple interest @ 8% per
annum amounting to Rs.63,96,658/- (Total amounting to
Rs.1,98,52,054/-) has been released in settlement of subsidy
claims for the 2nd half of 2008-09 (copy of sanction letter No.
17(2)/2015-DBA-II/NER dated 26/06/2019 is enclosed). This
rate of interest of 8% per annum was the rate as decided by
the Hon. Supreme Court in a case of settlement of dues of
State Trading Corporation (copy enclosed). This payment of
Rs.1,98,52,054/- is in order, since the checklist of Transport
Subsidy Scheme provides for payment to transporters only by
cheque. Payments made in cash are ineligible for
reimbursement. It is further stated that under Transport
Subsidy Scheme, 1971, there is no provision for payment of
interest on delayed payment.
NOW, THEREFORE, the matter of pending claims of
M/s. Meghalaya Feed Product has been examined in
accordance with directions of Hon‟ble High Court of
Meghalaya and total amount of Rs. 1,98,52,054/- [Rs.
1,34,55,396/- + Rs. 63,96,658/- (as 8% interest)] released.
This issue with the approval of Secretary, DPIIT.”
5.
Dr. B.P. Todi, learned Senior counsel assisted by Dr. A. Todi,
learned counsel for the petitioner, has submitted that by the impugned
order, the respondent No. 1 has not complied with the directions
contained in the order of this Court dated 03.05.2019, inasmuch as, the
respondent’s action in the non-release of the subsidy as claimed, was on
an altogether new ground that the amount claimed during the second
half of 2008-09, is significantly higher than that paid in the first half of
2008-09. He contends that the fixation of the amount payable on the
basis of the amount claimed for the first half of 2008-09, is arbitrary and
illegal. He further submits that the claim as submitted under the scheme,
had been approved by the State Level Committee, and had also been
pre-audited for the amounts of Rs.94,74,928/- (Rupees Ninety Four
Lakhs Seventy Four Thousand Nine Hundred Twenty-Nine only) and
Rs.1,38,69,552/- (Rupees One Crore Thirty Eight Lakhs Sixty Nine
Thousand Five Hundred and Fifty-Two only) for the period 01.10.2008
to 31.12.2008 and 01.01.2009 to 31.03.2009 respectively, which totals
to Rs.2,33,44,480/- (Rupees Two Crores Thirty Three Lakhs Forty Four
Thousand Four Hundred and Eighty only). However, he submits by the
impugned order, an amount of only Rs.1,98,52,054/- (Rupees One Crore
Ninety Eight Lakhs Fifty Two Thousand and Fifty Four only) including
interest, has been released, which he contends is in violation of the
orders of this Court, inasmuch as, re-verification can be only with
regard to the audit, and not for re-fixation of the claim amount.
6.
Dr. N. Mozika, learned DSGI assisted by Ms. S. Rumthao,
learned counsel for the respondent No. 1 has submitted that, the earlier
order dated 03.05.2019, had been carried on appeal before the Division
Bench of this Court, but the same was closed by order dated 24.02.2022
passed in WA No. 3 of 2022 along with MC(WA) No. 39 of 2019 and
MC(WA) No. 40 of 2019, as it was accepted that the order had been
given effect to by the respondents, and that further with regard to full
compliance, the writ petitioner had already instituted the present
proceedings.
7.
The Learned DSGI then submits that the order dated
03.05.2019, granted liberty to the respondents if they chose, to re-verify
the claims and that during this exercise, as the amount for the quarter
01.01.2009 to 31.03.2009, was found unusually high, the amount
payable to the petitioner was rationalised based on the claim amounts of
the first and second quarter, that is, 01.04.2008 to 30.06.2008 and
01.07.2008 to 30.09.2008. It is further submitted that, to avoid the
misuse of subsidy, a decision of introducing checklists in the Transport
Subsidy Scheme, 1971, was introduced vide notification dated
20.11.2009, stressing upon only cheque transactions, while considering
subsidy claims. He submits that though the notification as observed by
order dated 03.05.2019, would not apply to the case of the writ
petitioner, who had submitted the claims prior to this date, the
notification dated 20.11.2009, is not a change in policy and does not
extinguish or create new rights, but was made with a view to check false
claims.
8.
The learned DSGI, has also referred to a CAG report of 2010-
11, wherein at Para – 3.4.4.2, the issue of insufficient documentation in
support of subsidy claims has been flagged and discussed, especially
with regard to the extent of checks exercised at different levels, by the
implementing and monitoring agencies regarding the correctness and
genuineness of the subsidy claims. He therefore submits that, there was
no mala fide involved in the entire process and even though cash
payment as done by the petitioner was not admissible, an equitable way
out was devised and the eligible amount was paid to the petitioner.
9.
The other counsels appearing for the other respondents have
not tendered any submissions, as they have no role to play, as far as,
fixation and release of the claimed amount is concerned.
10.
Having heard the learned counsels for the parties, it is noted
that the claim of the writ petitioner is based solely on cash transactions
incurred in expenditure for transport of goods, which was permitted
prior to the issuance of the notification dated 20.11.2009. This Court
while disposing of the earlier writ petitions, while holding that the writ
petitioner was not bound to satisfy the condition of making the payment
of the cost of transportation by cheque, however, had left it open to the
respondents to re-verify, in case there was doubts about the pre-audit
and had further directed for re-consideration of the claim of the writ
petitioner.
11.
It appears on not being satisfied or convinced with the extent
and amount of the claim, the method of re-verifying or re-consideration
adopted by the respondents pursuant to the order dated 03.05.2019, was
to rationalize the claim by arriving at the amount payable, based on the
average of the first two quarters, that is, 01.04.2008 to 30.06.2008 and
01.07.2008 to 30.09.2008, and thus denied the full claim amount of the
petitioner for the two periods of 01.10.2008 to 31.12.2008 and
01.01.2009 to 31.03.2009, as they were found to be significantly higher.
By the impugned order as has been quoted earlier, the respondents as
per the reasons contained therein, deemed it fit to release to the
petitioner a total amount of Rs.1,98,52,054/- (Rupees One Crore Ninety
Eight Lakhs Fifty Two Thousand and Fifty Four only) along with
interest of 8%, instead of the total amount which was in excess of Rs.
2.33 crores.
12.
While examining the action of the respondent No.1, this Court
cannot ignore a basic fact that, when claims are made for reimbursement
based on cash transactions, sufficient materials to substantiate the claim
are necessary to be provided, which would not be required if payments
are made through bank transactions. The notification dated 20.11.2009
therefore, as submitted by the respondents was introduced to discourage
such cash transactions, as the source and flow of such transactions could
not be easily ascertained or tracked, thereby leading to a detrimental
impact on the economy.
13.
In the opinion of this Court, in this scenario therefore, the
burden of substantiating the claim made on the basis of cash
transactions, would squarely lie upon the writ petitioner, subject to
verification thereof of the claim by the respondents. The respondents
therefore, on not being satisfied with the clearance of the State Level
Committee of the claim, as well as the pre-audit report, on being
permitted by this Court, had by their re-verification exercise, reconsidered and allowed payment by the impugned order, to the extent
they deemed admissible.
14.
This Court, in these circumstances therefore, while sitting in
writ jurisdiction, cannot and is not in a position to render any conclusive
finding on the claim of the petitioner, as surely this will fall within the
realm of disputed facts which has to be proven. The question therefore
of determining the legitimate dues of the petitioner by this Court, or to
endorse the claims as made and to direct for payment as claimed for
which a mandamus is sought, at this stage is well-nigh impossible.
15.
In this view of the matter therefore, these writ petitions are
closed and disposed of leaving the writ petitioner to take recourse to
appropriate civil proceedings for the reliefs claimed, if so advised.
Judge
Meghalaya
07.08.2023
“D.Thabah-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review