Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2024:MLHC:1135
Serial No. 01
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 178 of 2022
Date of Decision: 06.12.2024
M/s Marbaniang Projects Private Limited
Having its registered office at Springside,
Jingkieng, Nongthymmai, Shillong,
East Khasi Hills District, Meghalaya
Represented by Mahendra Jain, Finance
and Accounts Manager, M/s Marbaniang
Projects Private Limited, Resident of
Lamavilla, Shillong, Meghalaya
:::Petitioner
-Vs1.Punjab National Bank (United Bank of India),
regulated by the Reserve Bank of India Act, 1934
and Banking Regulation Act, 1949 having its
registered office at Dwarka, New Delhi and also
having one its branches at G.S. Road, Shillong, Meghalaya
2.The Chief Manager,
Punjab National Bank,
Shillong Branch,
Shillong – 793001
East Khasi Hills, Meghalaya
3.The General Manager
Punjab National Bank,
Shillong Branch,
Shillong – 793001
East Khasi Hills, Meghalaya
2024:MLHC:1135
4. The Assistant General Manager,
Punjab National Bank,
Shillong Branch,
Shillong- 793001
East Khasi Hills, Meghalaya
:::Respondents
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) :
Mr. K. Paul, Sr. Adv. with
Ms. B. Kharwanlang, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
Mr. S. Dutta, Adv.
Ms. P. Riahtam, Adv.
:
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
The writ petitioner by this instant petition impugns the action of the
respondent Bank in not releasing the amounts which is deposited in an
Escrow Account, for payment of statutory liabilities including GST from
the year 2017 onwards till date.
2.
The brief facts are that the petitioner Company had approached the
respondent Bank for financial assistance, for construction of a hotel -cum-
2024:MLHC:1135
commercial complex, which was approved and a term loan of Rs. 22
Crores was sanctioned. Thereafter, in order to meet the business expansion,
an additional term loan of Rs. 8 Crore was sought, which was agreed to by
the Bank with the terms and conditions that all cash flows of the business
was to be routed through a designated account such as revenue
receipts/receivables from the project including deposits, service charges,
equity/shareholders contribution and deposited into the Project Escrow
Account. Accordingly, an Escrow Agreement was executed on 20.02.2015,
by the parties with the condition that further withdrawals from the Escrow
Account upto the final settlement under the financing agreements, shall be
permitted for the purposes of taxes and statutory requirements. However,
the petitioner Company received an email dated 05.11.2020 from one of its
tenants, informing that the GST amount had not been paid to the concerned
authorities, whereafter it was discovered that the respondent Bank despite
the stipulated conditions had adjusted the entire funds towards its debt
repayment. Hence the writ petition.
3.
Mr. K. Paul, learned Senior counsel assisted by Ms. B. Kharwanlang,
learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted that under the Escrow
Agreement, it had been specifically provided that withdrawals from the
Escrow Account upto the final settlement was that taxes and statutory
payments would take first precedence over other dues such as project
2024:MLHC:1135
expenses, payment interest, debt service reserve account and debt
repayment. However, he submits the respondent Bank without any
intimation, had wrongly adjusted all the rental deposits towards the loan
repayment, which is in absolute violation of the said Escrow Agreement.
The action of the Bank he contends despite the stipulated conditions, in
adjusting the entire funds including its debt repayment, has led to a
cascading effect, whereby the Escrow Agreement stood frustrated leading
to the non-payment of taxes further compounding the petitioner’s GST
liabilities. He then submits that with the input tax credit not being passed
down the same has resulted in the non-payment of rent by the tenants of the
petitioner Company, which led to the petitioner Company being classified
as NPA in 2019.
4.
The learned Senior counsel then submits that admittedly the
petitioner Company, does not operate or have control over the Escrow
Account, and the respondent Bank has been adjusting amounts since 2017
from the receivables deposited in the Escrow Account, and that any
statutory payments can only be paid by the respondent Bank on the
standing instructions/mandate of the account holder i.e. the petitioner
Company. The learned Senior counsel has then referred to the additional
affidavit filed by the respondent Bank on 01.08.2023, to support his
contention and has also placed reliance on 2(two) letters of the petitioner
2024:MLHC:1135
Company on this point, wherein request for Viewing Rights and request for
Permission to Operate had been made.
5.
On another limb of submission i.e. the impact on GST compliance, it
is submitted that the Company had filed GSTR-1 returns and as the Escrow
Agreement had been violated by the respondent Bank by the wrongful
adjustments made towards debt repayment, and consequently, the nonrelease of the statutory payments towards the GST Department, the
petitioner Company could not file its GSTR-3B returns, which fell foul of
Rule 59(5)(a) of the Central Goods and Services Tax Rules, 2017, as
amended. This Rule it is submitted provides that a registered person shall
not be allowed to furnish the details of outward supplies of goods and
services or both under Section 37 in Form GSTR-1, if he has not furnished
the return in Form GSTR-3B.
6.
With regard to the respondent Bank’s contention, as to set off being
provided under Section 19(8) of the Recovery of Debts and Bankruptcy
Act, 1993, the learned Senior counsel submits that the same is of no
relevance, and is immaterial in the instant case, as the relief of prayer
sought for by the petitioner Company is towards making good of the
payments wrongfully and illegally adjusted by the Bank towards debt
repayment. Apart from submitting that the said payments of dues towards
GST must be made from the Bank itself, it is contended that the said
2024:MLHC:1135
Section 19(8) as referred to above, is not applicable, as there is no counter
claim being made by the petitioner, and no monetary relief is being sought
directly from the respondent Bank. In support of his arguments, reliance
has been placed in the case of Employees Provident Fund Commissioner
vs. Official Liquidator of Esskay Pharmaceuticals Ltd. reported in (2011)
10 SCC 727, wherein he submits it has been held that all revenues, taxes,
cesses and rates due from a Company to the Central or the State
Government as also wages, gratuity etc. are payable in priority to all other
debts. As such, he submits, the respondent Bank cannot as a defence, state
that GST compliance and liability is the responsibility of the petitioner
Company, when the admitted position states otherwise. He therefore prays
that a writ mandamus be issued directing the respondent Bank to make
good of payment of the entire amount adjusted from the Escrow Account to
the extent of statutory liabilities/taxes including GST from the year 2017
onwards till date.
7.
Mr. S. Dutta, learned counsel with Ms. P. Riahtam, learned counsel
appearing on behalf of the respondent, has raised questions of
maintainability of the writ petition, first on the ground that the GST
Authority has not been made party respondent, inasmuch as, the prayer
sought is to make good of payment adjusted from the Escrow Account of
the GST amount, and that the petitioner had also impugned the notice dated
2024:MLHC:1135
14.06.2021, issued by the GST authorities. Secondly, a ground has also
been taken that the petitioner Company had converted the Escrow Account,
as if the same was specifically designated and earmarked for the purpose of
payment of statutory dues and to ensure timely payments thereof, which is
incorrect, inasmuch as, it is mandatory that an Escrow Agreement be
executed, so that all receipts, in whatever form be routed through the said
account. This he submits is to maintain transparency by the borrowers, so
far as routing of proceeds are concerned and also to keep an accounting tab
on the cash flow, with regard to the project finance and to this end the
Escrow Agreement had been executed, which was to continue through the
currency of the loan till the final settlement under the agreement. He
therefore submits that the Escrow Agreement is an integral part of a
financial contract and commercial arrangement between the creditor
(respondents) and the writ petitioner (borrower).
8.
The learned counsel then submits that both the term loan accounts
were classified as NPAs on 31.03.2019, meaning thereby no outward
transactions could be allowed from any accounts, which are a part of the
financial agreement and the respondent Bank is at liberty to adjust any
amount out of the receipts to bring down the outstanding debts/dues. The
amounts from the Escrow Account it is contended, have not been used for
2024:MLHC:1135
any other purpose, but for adjustment in the loan accounts in terms of the
Escrow Agreement.
9.
It is also contended that the writ petitioner as reflected from the
notice dated 14.06.2021 (Annexure – 9 to the writ petition), which required
the submission of 9(nine) documents by the petitioner to the GST
authorities, which was a pre-condition to the final quantification of GST
amount was not complied with by the petitioner, as it failed to file a single
GSTR-3B, since the roll out of GST w.e.f. July, 2017. The petitioner he
asserts, cannot hold the respondent Bank responsible as the petitioner did
not produce any GSTR-3B filings that had been submitted to enable the
Bank to take required steps, and further merely on the basis of letters to
release the GST amount without providing the actual amount to be
released, cannot be permitted. He submits that the petitioner having failed
to submit the required documents which are mandatory in nature, the claim
against the Bank is nothing but a tactic to avoid the payment of the
outstanding dues of both the Bank and the GST. The petitioner Company
he submits, did not maintain proper communication with the tenants who
had deposited their share of GST amount in the Escrow Account, and did
not inform the Bank also in this regard.
10.
In the facts and circumstances of the case, he contends the
respondent Bank cannot be faulted on the issue of non-release of GST
2024:MLHC:1135
amounts, but at the same time, it had even allowed the withdrawal of a sum
of Rs.23,53,507/- (Rupees Twenty Three Lakhs Fifty-Three Thousand Five
Hundred and Seven only) on 06.03.2020, from the Escrow Account
through RTGS transfer in the account of one Smti. K.S. Kharkongor. It is
also submitted that the Escrow Agreement entails payment in the order of;
(i) taxes and statutory payments (ii) project expenses etc. (iii) payment of
interest (iv) debt service reserve account and (v) debt repayment, and that
apart from Serial No. 1, all other heads of payments relate to the financial
agreement and transaction pertaining to the project finance under which
term loan facilities was sanctioned. In this context he submits that, it is
settled law that blanket priority is towards payment of debt and interest
payment to financial creditors, and the reference can be drawn from
Section 26-E of the SARFAESI Act 2002, and Section 31-B of the RD & B
Act 1993, with the only exception being the statutory dues under the
Employees Provident Fund Act, 1952.
11.
It is also further contended that the whole dispute has arisen from a
commercial contract and the disputes being before the Debts Recovery
Tribunal in O.A. No. 103/2023, the said transactions and the Escrow
Agreement being part and parcel of the financial arrangements and the
subject matter of commercial dispute pending adjudication, the same
should be dealt with before the Debts Recovery Tribunal. The validity or
2024:MLHC:1135
invalidity of the Escrow Agreement, it is argued cannot be decided by a
writ court, as the said document is part of the entire financial agreement. It
is lastly prayed that the writ petition be dismissed as not maintainable in
law and facts, and that the petitioner has a remedy before the Debts
Recovery Tribunal by raising all pertinent issues.
12.
Heard learned counsel for the parties. On considering the
submissions and on perusal of the materials on record, three issues have
arisen that are to be considered and adjudicated. They are:(i)
Whether the writ petition is maintainable considering that on
other disputes arising from the projects, the matter is pending
adjudication before the Debts Recovery Tribunal.
(ii)
Whether the adjustments made by the respondent Bank to the
receivables deposited in the Escrow Account, constitute a
breach of the Escrow Agreement.
(iii)
Whether the petitioner Company had control or the right to
operate the Escrow Account.
13.
On the first issue, as can be seen from the submissions recorded
above, no doubt proceedings instituted by the respondent Bank, are
pending before the Debts Recovery Tribunal in the form of O.A. No.
103/2023, wherein the relief sought for as given in the prayer, is for
recovery of the amounts release under 2(two) term loans, and for order of
2024:MLHC:1135
attachment and sale of hypothecated properties and mortgage properties
given in the schedule thereto. However, in the considered opinion of this
Court, the issue raised in the instant petition is different and distinct,
inasmuch as, the issue herein is regarding payment of debt, which was
adjusted by the respondent Bank, leading to non-payment of GST by the
petitioner, which is alleged, is contrary to the Escrow Agreement. On the
aspect of non-joinder of the GST authorities as necessary party, again as the
sole issue stems from the violation of the Escrow Agreement, the nonimpleadment will not disable the instant writ petition. The Escrow
Agreement also does not relate to any monetary claim by either of the
parties, but is an agreement that was to govern all the cash flow of the
business to be routed through the said account in the order agreed to. The
grievance of the writ petitioner shorn of all other accompanying
circumstances, incidents and details is basically with the action and
conduct of the Bank in not adhering to the agreed order of withdrawals to
satisfy payments for different purposes enumerated therein.
Further, the pointed defence taken by the respondent Bank that as the
proceedings are pending before the Debts Recovery Tribunal, the writ
petition will not be sustainable, is disregarded. This is in view of the fact
that the instant writ petition had been instituted against the breach of the
Escrow Agreement, as far back as on 13.05.2022, whereas the Original
2024:MLHC:1135
Application No. 103/2023, before the Debts Recovery Tribunal was filed
only on 11.03.2023. Therefore, the instant writ petition having been
entertained by this Court much prior to the institution of the recovery
proceedings by the Bank against the petitioner, it is held that the same is
maintainable in its present form.
14.
On the second issue i.e. whether the adjustments made by the
respondent Bank to the receivables deposited in the Escrow Account,
constitute a breach of the Escrow Agreement, for the sake of convenience,
the Escrow Agreement dated 20.02.2015, is reproduced herein below.
ESCROW AGREEMENT
This Escrow Agreement made on this the 20.02.2015
between United Bank of India, having its head office at 11,
Hemanta Basu Sarani, Kolkata, 700001 and Branches all over
India, including its Shillong Branch represented by AGM,
Shillong Branch, Shillong, herein after called the first party (the
said Bank) and M/s Marbaniang Project Pvt. Ltd. Having Regd.
Office at spring side Road, Jingkieng, Nongthymmai, Shillong
793014 represented by its Directors Shri. Mayven Taurus
Marbaniang and Mrs. Eva Daritee Bareh herein after called the
second party (the borrower).
2024:MLHC:1135
Whereas M/s Marbaniang Project Pvt. Ltd. has been
sanctioned overall Term Loan limit of Rs.22.00 crore by Head
Office.
Whereas M/s Marbaniang Project Pvt. Ltd. has
approached the bank for enhancement of limit to Rs.30.00 crore
and to which the Head Office of the bank has agreed to enhance
and enhanced the limit to Rs.30.00 crore vide sanction letter
No.SH/BR/ADV/MPPL/5515/2014-15 dated 03.02.2015 on the
following terms and conditions, voluntarily agreed upon by and
between both the parties and set forth herein below.
Now this Escrow agreement Witnessth as follows:All the cash flows of the business shall be routed through
designated
account
is
to
be
executed.
All
revenue
receipts/receivables of the project including deposits, service
charges etc. drawdown under the facility and equity/shareholders
contribution relating to the project, shall be deposited into
designated Project Escrow Account, up to final settlement under
the Financing Agreement shall be permitted for the following
purposes of the project and in the following order:
1. Taxes & Statutory payments
2024:MLHC:1135
2. Project expenses including fees and other dues payable
under the agreement related to the project and
Operational Expenses
3. Payment of interest
4. Debt service Reserve Account
5. Debt Repayment
In Witness whereof both the parties set and subscribed their
respective hands along seal on the day, month and year first above
written.
15.
From the table given in the said Agreement as quoted above, taxes
and statutory payments are placed at Serial No. 1, meaning thereby priority
be given to this payment, whereas, debt repayment is at Serial No. 5.
Before proceeding further in the discussion, it would be pertinent to
mention herein that there has been sweeping changes in many Acts that
govern commercial transactions such as the SARFAESI Act and the
Recovery of Debts due to Banks and Financial Institutions Act, 1993,
aimed at faster recovery and resolution of bad debts by banks and financial
institutions. These changes, accord priority to secured creditors to be paid
in priority to over all other debts, taxes, cesses and other rates payable to
the Central Government or State Government or local authorities. As such,
there is statutory recognition of priority claim of secured creditors because
2024:MLHC:1135
of these amendments. The respondents have relied upon decisions, wherein
Government
dues with statutory charges remain categorized as
Government dues treated at lower priority compared to secured creditors
such as in the following cases:
(i)
Paschimanchal Vidyut Vitran Nigam Limited vs.
Raman Ispat Private Ltd. reported in (2023) 10 SCC
(ii)
ICICI Bank Ltd. vs. Sidco Leathers Ltd. reported in
(2006) 10 SCC 452
(iii)
Andhra Bank vs. Official Liquidator & Anr. reported
in (2005) 5 SCC 75.
16.
However, coming back to the issue in question, it can be clearly seen
that the dispute of the petitioner with the Bank is not on monetary claims or
counter claims, but is with regard to the non-adherence to the Escrow
Agreement, and to the priorities of payment contained therein, and is not a
case where it concerns the apportionment of assets on liquidation to the
various entities that hold charges, or claims on the same. The recovery
proceedings initiated by the Bank before the Debt Recovery Tribunal is
distinct from the dispute stemming from the Escrow Agreement and that
too, the recovery proceedings were initiated as recently as in 2023,
whereas, the instant dispute had arisen since 2020. What can be gathered
from the submissions is that though the Escrow Agreement had specifically
2024:MLHC:1135
provided that first priority be given to taxes and statutory payments, which
includes GST, the inaction of the respondent Bank in not processing and
provisioning for the same, had resulted in the petitioner not being able to
comply with the requirement of payment of GST, which has had an adverse
impact on the tenants who remitted rental amounts, as the input tax credit
was not being passed down. The cascading effect that resulted in not
provisioning for payment of statutory dues/GST component by the Bank, it
appears resulted in the non-payment of rent by the tenants of the petitioner,
which also significantly contributed to the petitioner being classified as a
NPA in 2019. Paragraph – 3 of the affidavit filed by the respondent Bank
on 01.08.2023, has infact, also substantiated this position, wherein it is
acknowledged that the receivables in the Escrow Account had stopped
since 24.07.2021, and that there were no credit deposits from any of the
tenants thereafter.
17.
Though it has been argued that the Bank on its own cannot calculate
or quantify the amount of GST/statutory dues against a particular head or
any transaction by a third party, from the Index of Disbursement of Funds
and letters from the petitioner to the respondent Bank regarding release of
GST, a compilation of which has been filed before the Court, it is noted
that requests had been made since the year 2017, and invoices submitted to
the respondent to enable them to comply with the filing of returns, which
2024:MLHC:1135
however appears went unheeded. Compliance with GST requirements i.e.
GSTR-1, which is a monthly or quarterly return that captures the details or
outward supplies or sales made by a tax payer, and GSTR-3B which is a
self-declared summary return that businesses must file monthly includes
details of sales, input tax credit claims and tax liability for the reporting
period, is essential for paying GST, as tax payers calculate the tax liability
and pay it with this filing. Further, GSTR-3B is a summarized return and
does not provide itemized invoice details, but is essential for finalizing
monthly tax payments and compliance, and the failure to file GSTR-3B for
two consecutive tax periods, can lead to a restriction on filing of GSTR 1,
impacting compliance and input tax credit for buyers. In the considered
opinion of this Court, the GST liabilities arising from the Banks adjustment
to loan repayment have resulted in the non-compliance of the statutory
requirements, and apart from worsening the financial challenges faced by
the petitioner, has also led to the initiation of proceedings against the
petitioner by the GST authorities on the non-filing of GSTR-3B and nonpayment of GST under Section 70 of the Central Goods and Services Tax
Act, 2017. As such therefore, the action of the respondent Bank in not
adhering to the order of payment or withdrawal, as given in the Escrow
Agreement is clearly a breach of the same, and the Bank is held liable.
2024:MLHC:1135
18.
On the third issue i.e. whether the petitioner Company had control or
the right to operate the Escrow Account, it is seen that the respondent Bank
had been adjusting amounts since 2017, from the receivables deposited in
the Escrow Account, and also from the statement of the Bank itself on
affidavit, whereby it has maintained that the Bank was well within its right
to adjust any reasonable amount as deemed fit and proper towards debt
repayment. Further, the Escrow Agreement having provided for the Escrow
Account to be operated by the respondent Bank, which was required to pay
such statutory dues is confirmed by the Bank itself in Para – 8 of its
affidavit filed on 01.08.2023, wherein it has been stated as follows:
“8. That the Deponent submits that the Respondent Bank
had been adjusting amounts since 2017 from the receivables
deposited in the Escrow Account and the Respondent bank is
well within its right to adjust any reasonable amount as
deem fit and proper at the relevant time towards service and
debt and repayment as is stated in the said Escrow
Agreement entered into and executed between and by the
Petitioner Company and Respondent Bank and it is clarified
that the said Escrow Account is maintained and operated by
the Respondent Bank and any statutory payments i.e. taxes if
required to be paid to such Statutory Authorities, the same
can only be paid by the Respondent Bank on the basis of
standing instruction/mandate by the Escrow Account holder
2024:MLHC:1135
i.e. the Petitioner Company and on receipt of connected
invoices, tax returns and amounts etc. for proper
provisioning and appropriation under appropriate head of
the tax in connection thereof……...”
19.
Though an affidavit has been filed at the hearing stage by the
respondent bringing on record an instance where there has been a
transaction through the Escrow Account for third party payment through an
account payee cheque for RTGS payment, on examining the same
especially the cheque and the payment slip thereof, this appears to be only
an aberration from the established process. This observation is made in
view of the fact that as in the compilation of the Index of Disbursement of
Funds as supplied to this Court, it is seen that on 11.06.2019, a request has
been made by the petitioner for grant or permission to operate the account,
and even as far back as on 22.06.2015, the petitioner had requested the
respondent Bank for permission for viewing the account, in order to enable
the petitioner to keep track of the accounts and amounts, which have been
credited. As such, there is no doubt that the petitioner Company had no
control or any right to operate the Escrow Account.
20.
As such, in view of the discussions and findings made herein above,
the contentions as put forward by the petitioner are accepted, but however,
to the full relief claimed in the writ petition, the fact that the issue also
2024:MLHC:1135
involves the GST authorities who have not been made party in the instant
proceedings, the same cannot be granted, but is limited only to directing the
respondent Bank to redeem the matter by taking corrective measures with
regard to the facilitation of filing of GST returns, payable by the petitioner
Company from the year 2017 onwards, as mandated by law.
21.
Accordingly, the writ petition is allowed to the extent indicated
above and is disposed of.
Judge
Meghalaya
06.12.2024
“D.Thabah-PS”
THABAH
Date: 2024.12.06 16:42:29 IST
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review