Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2024:MLHC:650
Serial No. 01
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 401 of 2022
Date of Decision: 23.07.2024
M/s Marbaniang Enterprise
Having its registered office at Springside,
Jingkieng, Nongthymmai, Shillong, East
Khasi Hills District, Meghalaya represented
by Mayven T. Marbaniang, Proprietor of
M/s Marbaniang Enterprise, Resident of
Lower New Colony, Laitumkhrah,
Shillong, Meghalaya
:::Petitioner
-Vs1.Meghalaya Power Distribution
Corporation Limited
Represented by its Director
Shillong, Meghalaya
2.The Chief Engineer (RE),
Meghalaya Power Distribution
Corporation Limited,
Lumjingshai, Shillong,
East Khasi Hills, Meghalaya
3.The Chief Engineer (Distribution)
Meghalaya Power Distribution Corporation
Limited, Lumjingshai, Shillong,
East Khasi Hills, Meghalaya
2024:MLHC:650
4.The Company Secretary
Meghalaya Power Distribution Corporation
Limited, Lumjingshai, Shillong,
East Khasi Hills, Meghalaya
5.Superintending Engineer (RE)
Meghalaya Power Distribution
Corporation Limited, Lumjingshai,
Shillong, East Khasi Hills, Meghalaya
6.Executive Engineer (RE)
Meghalaya Power Distribution
Corporation Limited,
Lumjingshai, Shillong,
East Khasi Hills, Meghalaya
:::Respondents
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. K. Paul, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. S. Thapa, Adv.
Ms. B. Kharwanlang, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. A. Kumar, AG with
Mr. A.S. Pandey, Adv.
Ms. R. Colney, GA
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
2024:MLHC:650
1.
The petitioner by this application under Article 226 is before this
Court with a prayer for directions to issue to the Respondent
Corporation for release of outstanding bills of the Petitioner Enterprise
amounting to Rs.1,80,24,719/- (Rupees One Crore Eighty Lakhs
Twenty-Four Thousand Seven Hundred and Nineteen) only and
Rs.1,02,36,278 (Rupees One Crore Two Lakhs Thirty-Six Thousand
Two Hundred and Seventy-Eight) only with regard to service charges
on successful completion of the contract work with the respondent.
2.
The brief facts are that the Petitioner Enterprise in the year
2006, was awarded with a contract by the Respondent Corporation
under the APDRP Project for reconductoring, feeder bifurcation and
construction of new feeders, Package-C in the Eastern Circle (Supply
and Erection contract) in Jaintia Hills District, and that the said project
was completed in the year 2008. A completion certificate was issued
by the Respondent Corporation after payment of outstanding dues.
Apart from this contract, the Respondent Corporation had also
awarded contracts to the Petitioner Enterprise for supply of various
materials required for implementing the Rajiv Gandhi Grameen
Vidyutikaran Yojna(RGGVY) Scheme at the cost of Rs.27,00,07,294/-
2024:MLHC:650
(Rupees Twenty-Seven Crores Seven Thousand Two Hundred and
Ninety-Four) only referred to as the first contract or Supply contract.
By another letter dated 16.07.2007, the Petitioner Enterprise was
awarded a contract for all services including inland transportation
insurance,
handling,
storage
at
site,
erection,
testing
and
commissioning of all equipment for supply of service connections to
BPL consumers at a cost of Rs.2,00,54,100/- (Rupees Two Crores
Fifty-Four Thousand and One Hundred) only referred to as the second
contract or Erection contract. A formal contract was then executed on
25.10.2007 between the parties.
3.
Thereafter, in the course of the work and other developments,
the Petitioner Enterprise by a letter dated 06.06.2013, while
acknowledging receipt of certain payments, had requested for release
of Rs.1,02,36,278/- (Rupees One Crores Two Lakhs Thirty-Six
Thousand Two Hundred Seventy-Eight) only which he alleged had
been erroneously withheld against the excess payment of service tax,
inasmuch as, while quoting the rate for Supply and Erection, the rate
quoted had been quoted inclusive of all taxes and duties, and as such
there was no question of excess payment. Further claims were also
made from the Respondent Corporation in relation to return of surplus
2024:MLHC:650
materials which were not utilized for the project and as per the
statement of the Petitioner Enterprise on this account, the balance due
from the Respondent Corporation stood at Rs.1,95,15,528/- (Rupees
One Crore Ninety-Five Lakhs Fifteen Thousand Five Hundred and
Twenty-Eight) only. Further communications on this aspect with
regard to payment of balance amount due and return of surplus
materials continued between the Petitioner Enterprise and the
Respondent Corporation.
4.
It appears thereafter, the Respondent Corporation by a letter
dated 07.08.2014, called the petitioner for a meeting with regard to the
payment of service tax on the RGGVY Scheme and the petitioner was
asked to bring all supporting documents. The said meeting took place
on 26.08.2014, and as per the minutes generated which have been
placed on record, it was observed by the Chief Engineer of the
Respondent Corporation that outstanding bills of the Petitioner’s
Enterprise be processed for payment, with due compliance of audit
observation in that aspect. Thereafter, vide letter dated 17.08.2015
addressed to the Respondent Corporation, the Petitioner Enterprise
acknowledged receipt the payment of Rs.14,19,809/- (Rupees Fourteen
2024:MLHC:650
Lakhs Nineteen Thousand Eight Hundred and Nine) only to its Bank
account.
5.
Mr. K. Paul, learned Senior counsel assisted by Mr. S. Thapa,
learned counsel on behalf of the petitioner submits that even though
the work had been completed, the Respondent Corporation paid no
heed to the request made by the petitioner with regard to the extra
materials utilized for the RGGVY Scheme, and that the petitioner was
not supplied with a detailed statement, item wise showing the details of
deduction made on both Supply and Erection contract, at which the
amount paid to the petitioner was arrived at.
6.
It is to be noted at this juncture that from the part of the
Respondent Corporation, Mr. A. Kumar, learned Advocate General
assisted by Mr. S. Sahay, learned counsel has raised issues with regard
to the maintainability and the merit of the writ petition. It has been
submitted that the petitioner is seeking to recover alleged dues for
work which were awarded on 16.07.2007, and executed under a
contract dated 25.10.2007, and that further the petitioner’s own case, is
that the financial claims agitated in these writ proceedings pertain to
2024:MLHC:650
dues that became payable in the year 2013-2015. It has been also
pointed out that the petitioner has deliberately omitted to mention in its
petition, that the said agreement contains an arbitration clause, which
therefore ousts the jurisdiction of the writ court, as also any other civil
court.
7.
The learned Senior counsel has then submitted that the instant
writ application is an abuse of the process of law, as the petitioner has
come forward with claims that are time barred, and are therefore liable
to be rejected in view of Section 3 of the Limitation Act. It is further
submitted that in such commercial matters, a writ petition seeking
enforcement of contractual obligations against the State or its
instrumentalities is not maintainable, inasmuch as, the same are
matters of private law arising purely out of a contract. In support of
this contention, the learned Senior counsel has placed the following
decisions: i)
M/s Radhakrishna Agarwal & Ors. vs. State of Bihar &
Ors. reported in (1977) 3 SCC 457
ii)
Premji Bhai Parmar & Ors. vs. Delhi Development
Authority & Ors. reported in (1980) 2 SCC 129
2024:MLHC:650
iii)
Divisional Forest Officer vs. Bishwanath Tea Co. Ltd.
reported in (1981) 3 SCC 238
iv)
Joshi Technologies International Inc. vs. Union of India &
Ors. reported in (2015) 7 SCC 728
v)
Bareilly Development Authority & Anr. vs. Ajai Pal Singh
& Ors. reported in (1989) 2 SCC 116
vi)
Kerala State Electricity Board & Anr. vs. Kurien E.
Kalathil & Ors. reported in (2000) 6 SCC 293
vii)
Union of India & Ors. vs. Puna Hinda reported in (2021)
10 SCC 690
8.
It has also been contended by the learned Senior counsel that the
writ petition is not maintainable in view of the existence of alternative
remedy, and has drawn the attention of the Court to clause 48 of the
contract, wherein an arbitration clause has been provided, and in this
regard has placed reliance on the following judgments:i)
M/s Titagarh Paper Mills Ltd vs. Orissa State Electricity
Board & Anr. reported in (1975) 2 SCC 436
ii)
State of U.P. & Ors. vs. Bridge & Rood Company (India)
Ltd. reported in (1996) 6 SCC 22
iii)
Kerala State Electricity Board & Anr. vs. Kurien E.
Kalathil & Ors. reported in (2000) 6 SCC 293
2024:MLHC:650
iv)
9.
State of Gujarat & Ors. vs. Meghji Pethraj Shah Charitable
Trust & Ors. reported in (1994) 3 SCC 552
The dispute raised by the petitioner, it also has been submitted
by the learned Senior counsel, makes the writ petition not maintainable
as it relates to the adjudication of disputed questions of fact, which in
the instant case, concerns amounts billed towards the contract works in
the years past, which have to be examined from old records. On this
point, reliance has been placed on the following decisions: -
10.
i)
Sanjay Kumar Jha vs. Prakash Chandra Chaudhary &
Ors. reported in (2019) 2 SCC 499
ii)
World Tel Inc. & Anr. vs. Union of India & Ors. reported in
(2001) 10 SCC 513
It is lastly submitted that for the dues of 2015, the writ petition
had been preferred only in the year 2022, which renders the claim of
the petitioner a stale claim, especially after final payment for the
contract had been acknowledged vide letter dated 17.08.2015. Further,
the learned Senior counsel submits that in the meeting dated
26.08.2014, there was no computation of the liability, nor any
admission of debt, and as such the same cannot vest any right or any
actionable claim upon the petitioner. As such, therefore it is submitted
2024:MLHC:650
that the writ petition being hopelessly delayed, the same is liable to be
dismissed on this ground alone, apart from the other grounds of
maintainability as set forth.
11.
Mr. K. Paul, learned Senior counsel in reply to the challenge to
maintainability and other grounds submits that there is no denial of the
existing claims of the writ petitioner as the meeting dated 26.08.2014
has recognised this fact. He further submits that there is no question of
invoking arbitration, inasmuch as, the dispute that is present, does not
arise from the contract nor there is dispute as to the entitlement, but it
is only with regard to non-settlement of dues by the Respondent
Corporation. Accordingly, he submits as there is no dispute, the instant
case cannot be classified as commercial matter that will bar this Court
from exercising jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution. It is
further submitted that the writ petition is not hit by delay and laches,
inasmuch as, the dues of the writ petitioner till the settlement thereof,
is a continuing wrong. In support of the submissions, the learned
Senior counsel has placed reliance on the following cases:i)
Smt. Maya Rani Punj vs. Commissioner of Income Tax,
Delhi reported in (1986) 1 SCC 445
2024:MLHC:650
12.
ii)
M. Siddiq (Dead) Through Legal Representatives (Ram
Janmabhumi Temple Case) vs. Mahant Suresh Das & Ors.
reported in (2020) 1 SCC 1
iii)
ABL International Ltd & Anr. vs. Export Credit Guarantee
Corporation of India Ltd. & Ors. reported in (2004) 3 SCC
He therefore prays that appropriate directions be issued for
clearance of outstanding dues within a timeframe and that interest be
allowed at 24% to be calculated from the date of completion of the
work till the date the said payments are made by the respondents.
13.
Heard learned counsel for the parties. This Court notes at the
outset that the writ petitioner is before this Court, after a lapse of many
years for recovery of dues that were allegedly payable in the years
2014-2015. Further, no recourse was taken for invocation of arbitration
in spite of the presence of arbitration clause, and though arguments
have been advanced that the dispute does not arise from the contract
agreement, the same in the view of this Court is incorrect as it is
related to payments and adjustments that have arisen from the
execution of the contract. Even if the argument is accepted that there is
no arbitrable dispute, for the recovery of the dues as alleged, no suit
2024:MLHC:650
for recovery for the same was ever instituted by the petitioner. Further,
the case as presented before this Court contains questions of disputed
facts, as it relates to alleged unpaid amounts, which if is to be
adjudicated, will involve the examination of old records that have to be
authenticated and the veracity thereof ascertained.
14.
In this scenario, the question before this Court is therefore,
whether the petitioner will be entitled to claim any relief by way of the
instant writ petition. This Court apart from the other materials placed,
while perusing the minutes of the meeting held on 26.08.2014,
(Annexure-16) on which heavy reliance has been placed by the
petitioner to make out the case, notes that outstanding dues have been
acknowledged by the respondents which was directed to be processed.
However, in a subsequent letter dated 17.08.2015, from the Petitioner
Enterprise addressed to the respondent No. 6 under the caption ‘Final
Payment
of
Supply
and
Erection
bills
under
RGGVY’
acknowledgement is given of the receipt of payment by the petitioner
of Rs.14,19,809/- (Rupees Fourteen Lakhs Nineteen Thousand Eight
Hundred and Nine) only. This letter on a plain reading, apart from
requesting the respondents to furnish the details statement-wise, is
2024:MLHC:650
silent on any other or further claim of outstanding dues. As such, this
letter which comes after the acknowledgement given in the meeting
dated 26.08.2014, makes it a difficult task to discern or to come any
clear finding, as to whether the petitioner’s dues had been finally
settled by the respondents after adjustments to the service charges as
claimed, or whether other amounts remain unpaid. The pleadings in the
writ petition on this aspect, also are vague and are of no assistance in
assisting this Court to come to any conclusion.
15.
This Court therefore in order to fully understand and appreciate
the claim of the writ petitioner, and whether inspite of the delay and
the question of disputed facts, the matter could be effectively
adjudicated under writ jurisdiction, had called for the records to be
produced by the respondents. From the records, it is noted that
approval for closure of the RGGVY Project, Jaintia Hills, was given on
27.03.2014, by the Chief Project Manager, Rural Electrification
Cooperation Limited to the respondent Corporation. It is noteworthy to
mention that by a letter dated 04.11.2014, from the respondent No. 5
addressed to the respondent No. 6, request was made that necessary
action may immediately be taken to process all pending bills of the
2024:MLHC:650
Petitioner’s Enterprise in line with the closure approval. The records
also contain a statement dated 06.08.2015, showing final payment
made to the petitioner, under various heads, which however is not clear
on the component of service tax, although payment made to the
Department of Income Tax, and the Tax Department on account of
royalty have been indicated. However, as aforementioned the final
payment under the RGGVY scheme, had been acknowledged by the
petitioner vide its letter dated 17.08.2015. The records as produced
however, do not reveal whether the petitioner had raised any claim
thereafter, after acknowledging the receipt of the payment vide the said
letter dated 17.08.2015.
16.
Though a case of continuing wrong has been sought to be made
out by the petitioner and judgments placed in support thereof, in the
facts of the present case where even the petitioner has not been able
even to clearly establish the existence of any outstanding dues, the
same are of no assistance to the petitioner and accordingly are not
discussed. The judgments placed by the respondents being on aspects
of settled law, are also not elaborated upon.
2024:MLHC:650
17.
It is also interesting to note that the petitioner has also sought to
link the alleged outstanding dues to a disconnection notice dated
13.10.2014, served on the petitioner’s concern, a commercial
establishment, for unpaid bills, making the payment of the same
thereof to the respondents, contingent upon the release of the alleged
outstanding dues. This in the considered view of this Court is of no
relevance and the pleadings made in this regard are rejected.
18.
As such, looking into the totality of the facts and circumstances
of the case, this Court notes that the petitioner failed to avail of
arbitration, which had been provided in the contract agreement itself,
which at this belated stage, by operation of law, cannot be taken
recourse to. Further, no civil proceedings for recovery of any alleged
dues had been instituted within three years of the acknowledged
receipt of final payment, which also effectively bars recourse to a
money suit, except under exceptional circumstances which the
petitioner would have to demonstrate. The other factors of delay,
disputed facts and absence of any clear outstanding dues, also come in
the way of this Court, exercising its jurisdiction or discretionary
powers under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
2024:MLHC:650
19.
As such, in view of the reasons and discussions herein above,
the instant writ petition cannot be entertained by this Court, and is
accordingly dismissed, leaving the petitioner to seek other alternative
remedy, if available.
20.
Writ Petition accordingly stands closed and disposed of.
21.
Records to be returned to the learned counsel for the Respondent
Corporation.
Judge
Meghalaya
23.07.2024
“D.Thabah-PS”
THABAH
Date: 2024.07.23 15:08:42 IST
Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review