Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Crl.A.No.733 of 2018
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATED: 05-02-2026
CORAM
THE HONOURABLE MR JUSTICE M. NIRMAL KUMAR
CRL A No. 733 of 2018
M/s.Lambodhara Textiles Ltd.,
Rep. By its Accountant,
Mr.T.G.Manoharan,
S/o.T.Gangadharan,
Having its Registered Office At,
3A, B-Block, 3rd Floor,
Pioneer Apartments, 1075 B,
Avinashi Road, Coimbatore-641 018.
Appellant/Complainant
Vs
1. M/s.Akul Textiles,
Rep By Its Partner,
Mr.K.Mahamuni,
2, Kavya Complex,
Mannan Kadu, AMR Road,
Kangampalayam, Somanur-641 668.
2.K.Mahamuni
Partner, Akul Textiles,
2, Kavya Complex,
Mannan Kadu, AMR Road,
Kangampalayam, Somanur-641 668.
3.Nagaraj
Partner, Akul Textiles,
2, Kavya Complex,
Mannan Kadu, AMR Road,
Kangampalayam, Somanur-641 668.
Respondents/Accused
1/16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Crl.A.No.733 of 2018
Prayer: The Criminal Appeal filed under Section 378 of Cr.P.C. praying to
set aside the judgment dated 13.12.2017 made in Crl.A.No.137 of 2016 on
the file of the V Additional District and Sessions Court, Coimbatore
acquitting the respondents and consequently convict the respondent under
Section 138 and 142 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 and also direct
the respondent to pay compensation to the appellant.
For Appellant :
Mr.K.S.Karthik Raja
For Respondents :
Ms.P.Suganthi
Legal Aid Counsel
JUDGMENT
The appellant as complainant filed a private complaint in C.C.No.130
of 2013 for offence under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act,
1881 (in short ‘N.I. Act’) against the respondents/accused. The trial Court, by
judgment dated 13.10.2016, convicted the respondents and sentenced to
undergo six months simple imprisonment and to pay the cheque amount of
Rs.28,61,100/- jointly by respondents 1 to 3 as compensation. Aggrieved by
the same, the respondents/accused preferred an appeal in Crl.A.No.137 of
2016 before the V Additional District and Sessions Judge, Coimbatore. The
learned Sessions Judge, by the judgment dated 13.12.2017, allowed the
appeal setting aside the conviction and sentence passed by the trial Court,
against which, the complainant had preferred the present appeal.
2/16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Crl.A.No.733 of 2018
2.The case of the appellant/complainant is that the complainant is a
limited Textile company authorised one Manoharan by Board Resolution
dated 19.07.2010 to institute this complaint and prosecute the respondents.
The first respondent is a partnership firm and respondents 2 and 3 are its
partners. The first respondent placed orders with the appellant for purchase of
power loom grey cloth on various dates and the appellant supplied the goods
and raised four invoices. Invoice No.12 dated 18.03.2010 for Rs.8,32,143/-,
Invoice No.13 dated 19.03.2010 for Rs.8,04,674/-, Invoice No.14 dated
22.03.2010 for Rs.8,84,575/- and Invoice No.15 dated 25.03.2010 for
Rs.7,46,208, in total, the grey cloth to the value of Rs.32,67,600/- supplied.
After repeated request by the appellant, the respondents issued nine cheques
signed by the second and third respondents on behalf of first respondent
drawn on IDBI Bank, Tiruppur, which are as follows:
S.No.
3/16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Cheque Nos.
581691
581692
581693
581694
581695
581696
581697
581698
581699
Total
Amount in Rs.
3,10,000/3,05,000/3,00,000/2,90,000/2,85,000/3,15,000/3,20,000/3,61,100/3,75,000/28,61,100/-
Crl.A.No.733 of 2018
3.The above nine cheques when presented for collection through the
appellant’s bank, State Bank of India, Red Fields, Coimbatore on 28.06.2010.
The cheques not honoured and returned for the reason ‘Funds Insufficient’
with a bank memo dated 30.06.2010. Thereafter, statutory notice issued on
21.07.2010 calling the respondents to pay the amount of Rs.28,61,100/- being
the amount covered by nine cheques. The first and third respondents received
notice on 26.07.2010 and the second respondent received on 28.07.2010 and
they not repaid the amount but sent reply notice dated 31.07.2010 with false
averments. Hence, ignoring the same, complaint filed.
4.During trial, on the side of the complainant, PW1 to PW4 examined.
PW1, Accountant of the complainant company, PW2, Bank Manager of
complainant’s bank, namely, State Bank of India, PW3, Bank Manager of the
Accused, namely, IDBI Bank and PW4, Manager-Accounts in the
complainant company. Through them Exs.P1 to P31 marked. On the side of
the accused, no witnesses examined and no documents marked. On
conclusion of trial, the trial Court convicted the respondents. The Lower
Appellate Court allowed the appeal setting aside the conviction and sentence.
5.The learned counsel for the appellant/complainant submitted that in
this case the respondents neither denied nine cheques/Exs.P6 to P14 nor the
4/16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Crl.A.No.733 of 2018
signature found in Exs.P6 to P14. Thus the statutory presumption under
Sections 118 and 139 comes into play. Further it is a business transaction,
goods supplied by the appellant covered by invoices/Exs.P2 to P5 and hence
the cheques issued in discharge of the liability proved. After dishonour of the
cheques, statutory notice/Ex.P24 issued on 21.07.2010. The reply
notice/Ex.P28 sent by the respondents with false averment but not denied
issuance of the cheques or their signature in cheques, but takes a stand that
cheques issued to one Rajendran of M/s.KGR Textiles and the said Rajendran
passed on the cheques to the appellant. Further for the liability with
Rajendran, the sister of the second respondent executed a sale deed, for a
property situated at Thirubuvanam village favouring Rajendran during the
year 2010, who in turn, executed a sale deed in favour of one Balu, a close
associate of appellant. Thus the liability cleared is the defence taken, but
neither the said Rajendran nor the second respondent’s sister examined or any
document in support of the respondents’ contention produced. Considering all
these aspects, the trial Court finding that the appellant proved the case against
the respondents had rightly convicted the respondents.
6.On the contrary, the Lower Appellate Court set aside the conviction
on the reason that Exs.P2 to P5/invoices are though serially numbered and the
5/16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Crl.A.No.733 of 2018
bill numbers both in seriatim, but dates varies. The first invoice is dated
18.03.2010, second invoice is dated 19.03.2010, third invoice is dated
22.03.2010 and the fourth invoice is dated 25.03.2010 and in the invoices
there is a specific column for buyers/brokers signature confirming receipt of
goods. In this case, except signature of the authorised signatory of the
appellant company, there is no signature by the respondents to prove that
goods were really supplied and received. Further gave a finding that invoices
ought to be covered by purchase order. Hence, doubted genuineness of
Exs.P2 to P5, failing to look into the fact that nine cheques issued, had
handwriting and signature, all identical, not seriously disputed by the
respondents. The only defence taken is that cheques were given to one
Rajendran of M/s.KGR Textiles. Except such reference made in the reply
notice/Ex.P28, there is nothing further. Neither the Rajendran nor the second
respondent’s sister examined in this case and no sale deed documents
produced. Hence, the finding of the Lower Appellate Court is perverse.
7.He further submitted that in this case PW1 is the Accountant and
PW4 is the Accounts Manager both clearly deposed the business done by the
appellant with the respondents, supply of grey cloth, raising of invoices and
receipt of cheques. PW1 confirmed Sales Tax Returns filed and sale between
6/16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Crl.A.No.733 of 2018
the appellant and the respondents disclosed. PW4 was questioned on the same
line who corroborated PW1. Further Exs.P29 and P30 marked through PW2
and PW3, the Bank Managers, not cross-examined. Exs.P29 and
P30/Statement of Accounts confirm presentation of the cheques and
dishonour of the cheques. Ex.P31 is Ledger Account, spoken by PW4. Thus
the appellant proved respondents issued the cheques in discharge of liability
for the business transaction, the trial Court rightly considered and convicted
the respondents. But the Lower Appellate Court allowed the appeal setting
aside the conviction on the ground that Exs.P2 to P5 not signed by the
respondents and supply of goods not proved, discarding other evidence, is not
proper, the appellant proved that the cheques/Exs.P6 to P14 issued in
discharge of liability.
8.In support of his contention, the learned counsel relied on the
decision of the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of Rohitbhai Jivanlal Patel
vs. State of Gujarat and another reported in (2019) 18 SCC 106 for the point
that mere denial or mere creation of doubt, would not rebut presumption
under Section 139 of N.I. Act and after drawing the presumption under
Section 139 of N.I. Act, onus shifted to the accused unless he discharged onus
by bringing on record such facts and circumstances as to show preponderance
7/16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Crl.A.No.733 of 2018
of probabilities tilting in his favour, causing doubt in the case of the
complainant. Then only the accused can be discharged. In this case, the
appellant produced sufficient materials and evidence to prove that
cheques/Exs.P6 to P14 issued in discharge of the liability. Hence, prayed for
setting aside the judgment of acquittal rendered by the Lower Appellate Court
and consequently confirm the conviction of the respondents by the trial
Court.
9.The learned counsel for the respondents submitted that in this case
the trial Court merely gone by the statutory presumption under Sections 118
and 139 of N.I. Act finding that issuance of cheques and signature not denied
and convicting the respondents is not proper. During trial, the respondents
questioned the veracity and genuineness of Exs.P2 to P5, the invoices
produced by the appellant to show grey cloth supplied. On bare perusal of
Exs.P2 to P5, it is seen that all the four invoices are in seriatim, but drawn on
different dates. Likewise, the bills are also in serial. The value of the goods
supplied through the invoices is around Rs.32,67,600/-. On the contrary, the
cheques/Exs.P6 to P14, said to have been given in discharge of this liability is
only for Rs.28,61,100/-. There is no correlation between the cheques and the
invoices, which the trial Court failed to consider. Further in the
8/16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Crl.A.No.733 of 2018
invoices/Exs.P2 to P5, there is particulars with regard to the vehicle number,
by which the goods transported. All invoices carry vehicle number but in
none of the vehicle trip sheets and details of the driver of the vehicle
mentioned or any other supporting documents produced to confirm that goods
really transported from the appellant company delivered to the respondents.
10.Likewise there is a column for delivery of goods. In respect of four
invoices, there is nothing to show that goods delivered and respondents
acknowledged the delivery. During cross-examination, specific question put
to PW1 and PW4 questioning purchase order, both admit, only on purchase
order goods will be supplied. Despite specific question, no purchase order
produced. Further PW4 admits that for the first time the respondents had
business with the appellant in the year 2010 and the appellant case is that
goods were supplied on credit basis. When there is no other business
relationship, it is highly improbable to supply the goods on credit basis and
that too, when cheques issued three months after the supply of goods. The
other document Ex.P31-Ledger Account of the appellant conveniently
produced only from 01.06.2010 to 01.09.2010. The ledger account
maintained in the normal course of business can be considered. The appellant
ought to have produced the ledger account pertaining to the month of March,
9/16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Crl.A.No.733 of 2018
2010 to show that there was supply of goods on credit basis and the same is
reflected in the ledger account.
11.He further submitted that in the reply notice/Ex.P28 the specific
denial of liability raised by the respondents stating that there was some dues
with one Rajendran of M/s.KGR Textiles, and sale deed executed and the
liability discharged. Using the cheque given to Rajendran, the above case
projected against the respondents. In this case second respondent’s sister
Tirupathi executed a sale deed in favour of Rajendran in Doc.No.1403/2010.
The said Rajendran executed the same in favour of one Balu, who is
employed in the appellant’s company. Appellant neither examined Rajendran
nor Balu. PW1 admits that Balu is the Factory Manager. The Lower Appellate
Court found that Exs.P2 to P5 is to the tune of Rs.32,67,600/- but the
cheques/Exs.P6 to P14 issued in discharge of supply of goods is only for
Rs.28,61,100/-. There is no one to one correlation. Further, Exs.P6 to P14 all
cheques are dated 28.06.2010 presented on the same day. There is no proper
reason given as to how and why nine cheques given in one day.
12.Further it had also given a finding that in Exs.P2 to P5, there is no
authentication to confirm Exs.P2 to P5 are covered with any purchase order.
10/16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Crl.A.No.733 of 2018
Though Exs.P2 to P5/invoices are for various dates for a period of one week,
the invoices are serially numbered and bills also serially numbered and it is
highly improbable that for one week there is no other business by the
appellant, hence, Exs.P2 to P5 becomes highly doubtful and these documents
not in corroboratory to Exs.P6 to P14. Likewise Ex.P31 produced in part
deducting deposit and return of the cheques/Exs.P6 to P14. The Lower
Appellate Court found that the stand taken by the respondents in their reply
notice that the cheques were given in security to one Rajendran of M/s.KGR
Textiles, thereafter not produced any materials in support of the said
contention. Considering the same, in conjunction with the primary contention
that no goods or materials supplied to the respondents gains significance. In
such circumstances, the burden shifts on the appellant to prove that the goods
supplied and cheques issued in discharge of the said liability. Considering all
these aspects, finding that the judgment of the trial Court is without proper
reasoning, the Lower Appellate Court set aside the conviction and acquitted
the respondents and the same to be confirmed.
13.In support of his contention, the learned counsel relied upon the
decision of Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of Jay Ambe Industries
Proprietor Shri Dineshkumar Bajranglal Somani vs. Garnet Specialty Paper
11/16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Crl.A.No.733 of 2018
Ltd. reported in 2022 SCC OnLine Guj 2258 for the point that ledger by itself
may not be the proof of transaction and no liability can be fastened on the
basis of an entry in the ledger alone unless it is corroborated by some other
evidence. He further relied upon the judgment of Manipur High Court in the
case of Shri Manoj Kumar Jain vs. Shri Mahendra Kumar Jain in
Cril.Appeal No.24 of 2023 for the point that mere admission of signature of
the accused on the cheque will not attract the presumption under Section 139
of N.I. Act. It is for the complainant who is, at first instance, to establish the
existence of debt or liability and the statutory presumption will operate only
after such establishment. Hence, prayed for dismissal of the appeal.
14.Considering the submissions made and on perusal of the materials,
it is seen that the admitted position of the appellant/complainant is that the
appellant supplied grey cloth covered under Invoices/Exs.P2 to P5 to the
respondents and Exs.P2 to P5 are for a period of one week, i.e., Invoice
No.12 dated 18.03.2010 for Rs.8,32,143/-, Invoice No.13 dated 19.03.2010
for Rs.8,04,674/-, Invoice No.14 dated 22.03.2010 for Rs.8,84,575/- and
Invoice No.15 dated 25.03.2010 for Rs.7,46,208/-. The serial number and bill
number are consecutive. For one week no other invoices raised and no goods
supplied by the appellant, which is highly doubtful. Further in Exs.P2 to P5,
12/16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Crl.A.No.733 of 2018
vehicle number recorded. When the appellant was questioned with regard to
genuineness of the supply of grey cloth, appellant ought to have examined or
produced any materials to show the vehicle details and its driver. Though the
appellant took a stand that vehicle was sent by the respondents to collect
goods, in any event, based on the vehicle number further details can be
collected from transport department but the appellant failed to do so.
15.Further Exs.P6 to P14/cheques said to be issued in discharge of the
liability for receipt of grey cloth covered under Exs.P2 to P5. In this case, all
the cheques dated 28.06.2010. There is no correlation or reason given as to
how these cheques were issued. In the invoices, there is a specific column for
the buyer receiving goods and space for acknowledgement. In this case, the
said column is left blank. PW1 and PW4 admit that goods supplied only
against purchase orders, however, no purchase orders produced. Further, PW4
admits that respondents is known to him only from the year, 2010. In this
case, the goods supplied during March, 2010, whereas the cheques issued in
June, 2020. It is highly improbable, for a new business proposal such credit
will be given, without any security or supporting materials, which further
causes serious doubt with regard to the genuineness of Exs.P2 to P5. The
respondents sent a reply to the statutory notice even as early as on
13/16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Crl.A.No.733 of 2018
31.07.2010, in which it is clearly stated that there was business transaction
between the respondents with one Rajendran of M/s.KGR Textiles and the
property of second respondents’ sister settled in favour of Rajendran in
Doc.No.1403/2010, who in turn settled the same to one Balu, Factory
Manager employed in the appellants factory, confirmed by PW1. No reason
or clarification given by the complainant.
16.The Lower Appellate Court finding that the foundational fact is that,
appellant supplied grey cloths, covered by Exs.P2 to P5 which is highly
doubtful, since Exs.P2 to P5 are not covered with any purchase order and
there is no signature of the buyer and the particulars recorded in invoices are
doubtful. The cheques Exs.P6 to P14 are said to have been issued in
discharge of the liability. When the foundational fact becomes highly
doubtful and issuance of cheques becomes questionable. When the basic fact
is disputed, then the onus shifted back to the appellant to prove that Exs.P6 to
P14/cheques were issued in discharge of legally enforceable liability. In this
case Exs.P2 to P5, the invoices but the appellant not produced any materials
on record to establish the same. Thus the respondents rebutted the
presumption and probabilised their defence. The Lower Appellate Court
considering the same rightly acquitted the respondents. In view of the above,
14/16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Crl.A.No.733 of 2018
this Court finds no reason to interfere with the well reasoned judgment of the
Lower Appellate Court.
17.In view of the same, the Criminal Appeal stands dismissed. The
judgment of acquittal of the respondents passed by the learned V Additional
District and Sessions Judge, Coimbatore in Crl.A.No.137 of 2016 dated
13.12.2017, is hereby confirmed.
18. This Court appreciates the service rendered by Ms.P.Suganthi,
learned Legal Aid Counsel for the respondents. The Tamil Nadu State Legal
Services Authority shall pay the remuneration to Ms.P.Suganthi, Legal Aid
Counsel.
05.02.2026
Index : Yes / No
Internet : Yes/No
Speaking / Non-speaking order
rsi
15/16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Crl.A.No.733 of 2018
M.NIRMAL KUMAR, J.
rsi
To
1.The V Additional District and Sessions Judge,
Coimbatore.
2.The Judicial Magistrate,
Fast Tract Court No.I @ Magisterial Level,
Coimbatore.
CRL A No.733 of 2018
05.02.2026
16/16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review