The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
12. For what have been discussed above, the impugned order dated 27- 05-2020, insofar as it relates to banning and debarring the petitioner from entering into any business dealing with Assam Rifles is concerned, cannot be sustained in law and the same is set aside to that extent.
13. It is made clear that the observation and finding recorded hereinabove shall not have any bearing on the merits of any claim and counter-claim between the parties which may arise out of the events taken P a g e 11 | 12 place during the subsistence of the contract entered into between the petitioner and the respondents.
14. The writ petition stands disposed of in the aforesaid terms.
15. There will be no order as to costs. Judge Meghalaya
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No.01
Supple List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No.123 of 2020
Date of Decision: 01.12.2023
____________________________________________________________
Ms. La Monte Enterprise Represented Vs.
Union of India & Ors.
by Shri Bhupinder Singh.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice B. Bhattacharjee, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) : Mr. S. Dey, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
i)
ii)
: Dr. N. Mozika, DSGI with
Ms. A. Pradhan, Adv.
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc:
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
This application under Article 226 has been filed by the petitioner
challenging the impugned order dated 27-05-2020 issued by the respondent
No.2 by which the contract awarded to the petitioner against the Tender
Notice No. iv. 18081/2018-19/Ord/M&E/Mod-iii/CISR dated 26 Sep 2018
and Corrigendum dated 26 Oct 2018 and 12 Nov 2018 stood terminated
with immediate effect and the petitioner was banned from business and
debarred from entering into any business dealings with the Assam Rifles.
The impugned order also directed for filing of a criminal complaint with
P a g e 1 | 12
the jurisdictional police station against the petitioner for committing fraud
against the Assam Rifles.
1.
The brief fact of the case is that an open tender was floated on 26-09-
2018 by the respondent authority for online tender under two bid system
(technical & financial bid) for purchase of the store of Composite Indore
Shooting Range (CISR). The petitioner participated in the said tender
process and submitted his bid along with all relevant documents on 18-112018. Apart from the petitioner, three other firms participated in the said
tender process, namely, (i) M/s Paramahansa Technologies Ltd., (ii) M/s
GSG Associates and (iii) M/s Lotus Machines Pvt. Ltd. After technical
evaluation, the M/s Lotus Machines Pvt. Ltd. was disqualified. Thereafter,
the remaining three firms submitted their Detailed Project Report (DPR)
and at that stage M/s Paramahansa Technologies Ltd. was disqualified for
non-compliance of detailed technical parameters leaving the petitioner and
M/s GSG Associates as qualified bidders for financial evaluation. After
financial evaluation, the Tender Committee headed by the respondent No.2
recommended awarding of contract to the petitioner being the lowest (L1)
bidder on 18-02-2019. Thereafter, an offer letter dated 20-02-2019 was
issued to the petitioner and the petitioner was asked to furnish security
deposit. The petitioner furnished security deposit on 21-02-2019 and on 2202-2019 the petitioner was issued with the supply order requiring the
work/delivery to be completed by 22-08-2019. By a subsequent order
dated 21-10-2019, the time for completion of the work/delivery was
extended till 31-03-2020. On 11-11-2019, the petitioner submitted final
drawing of CISR to the respondent for approval and thereafter the site was
handed over on 03-12-2019 to him and the work started immediately.
P a g e 2 | 12
2.
On 25-02-2020, a notice was issued by the respondent on the ground
of violation of Code of Integrity for Public Procurement (CIPP) asking the
petitioner to confirm his spousal relationship with the proprietor of M/s
GSG Associates. The petitioner confirmed his spousal relationship with
the proprietor of M/s GSG Associates and further by a letter dated 02-032020 clarified that he and his wife are separate business entity having no
business transaction whatsoever between them.
On 17-03-2020, the
petitioner received a show-cause notice for termination of the contract for
alleged violation of clause (iii) “Anti-Competitive Practice” and clause (v)
“Conflict of Interest” of the Appendix – L of the tender document which
was submitted by the petitioner along with his bid as certificate for
abiding by the Code of Integrity for Public Procurement. The petitioner
submitted a detailed reply to the show-cause on 24-05-2020 and denied
that there was any violation or breach of any condition and no false
declaration or suppression was ever made by him while taking part in the
tender process.
The impugned order dated 27-05-2020 was passed
thereafter by the respondent No.2 terminating the contract awarded in
favour of the petitioner and debarring him from taking part in any
business dealings with the Assam Rifles.
The impugned order also
directed for filing of criminal complaint against the petitioner for
committing fraud.
3.
At the outset, before the matter is taken up for consideration on
merit, learned DSGI submits that the respondents have taken a decision not
to initiate or file any criminal complaint against the petitioner. He further
submits that during the pendency of this writ petition, the competent
authority of Assam Rifles has also taken a decision to cancel the entire
project of CSIR for which the petitioner was awarded the contract. In view
of the above, the learned Counsel appearing for the petitioner submits that
P a g e 3 | 12
the petitioner will not press the aforesaid two issues and challenge to the
impugned order dated 27-05-2020 in the present writ petition be confined
and limited only to the issue of banning and debarring the petitioner from
entering into any business dealings with the Assam Rifles.
4.
Mr. S. Dey, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner submits that
the issuance of the impugned order solely on the basis of the existence of
the spousal relationship between the petitioner and the proprietor of M/s
GSG Associates is totally arbitrary and illegal. He submits that the very
basis of issuing the show-cause notice and finding arrived at the impugned
order is not tenable in law, inasmuch as, the Certificate of the Code of
Integrity for Public Procurement (CIPP) as per Appendix – L of the tender
document nowhere lay down any disqualification criteria for participating
in tender by husband and wife or by any family member. He submits that
the terms and conditions stipulated in the tender document nowhere
mandate disclosure of existence of spousal relationship or family
relationship between the different participating bidders. Referring to the
show-cause notice, the learned counsel submits that the same has been
based on the code of integrity made in the Appendix – L and the petitioner
was asked to reply on violation of codes under two headings, namely,
clause (iii) “Anti-competitive Practice” and clause (v) “Conflict of
Interest”.
He submits that there is no material on record to indicate or
remotely suggest that the petitioner has given indulgence in “Anticompetitive Practice” while taking part in the tender process inasmuch as
there is no evidence of collusion, bid rigging or anti-competitive
arrangement. With regard to the “Conflict of Interest”, he submits that
there is also no allegation of his having relationship or financial or business
transaction with any officials of the tendering authority. He further submits
that finding recorded in the impugned order by the respondent No.2 is
P a g e 4 | 12
totally misconceived and not founded on the requirements of the clauses
(iii) & (v) of the code of integrity mentioned in the Appendix – L of the
tender document. He submits that the show-cause notice reveals that the
same was based upon a complaint of another bidder which prompted the
concerned authority to call for the reply from the petitioner, but the details
of the said complaint was never made available to the petitioner. He
contends that the impugned order does not in anywhere disclose as to how
the existence of the matrimonial relationship between the petitioner and the
proprietor of M/s GSG Associates has breached any of the code of conduct
specified in the Appendix – L of the tender document and thus, the entire
process of disqualification is misconceived and unwarranted in law. He
submits that the terms and conditions stipulated in the tender document and
the related provisions contained in Section 3 of the Competition Act, 2002
do not prohibit close relatives having separate business identity from taking
part in any tender process. He contends that the respondent authority has
no power to ban the petitioner for an indefinite period and the entire action
of the respondent is liable to be interfered with by this Court. In support of
his submission, the learned counsel for the petitioner placed reliance on a
decision of the Competition Commission of India rendered in case No. 09
of 2021 (para - 17).
5.
Per contra, Dr. N. Mozika, learned DSGI appearing for the
respondent submits that the petitioner at the time of taking part in the tender
process did not make any disclosure with regard to his relationship with the
proprietor of M/s GSG Associates.
He submits that the existence of
relationship of husband and wife between the petitioner and the proprietor
of M/s GSG Associates is sufficient to draw adverse inference of existence
of collusion, bid rigging and anti-competitive arrangement against the
petitioner. He submits that when there exists close relationship between
P a g e 5 | 12
two bidders in a tender process, it puts them in a position to have access to
information about each other and in that view of the matter the impugned
order blacklisting the petitioner suffers from no infirmity.
He further
submits that if the petitioner had divulged the fact of his spousal
relationship with the proprietor of M/s GSG Associates, his tender would
have been rejected summarily. He submits that the petitioner should have
maintained highest standard of business ethics and honesty while
participating in the tender process and his failure to do so lead the
respondent authority to come to an adverse finding against the petitioner.
He submits that the impugned order has been passed keeping in view the
mandate of law as enshrined in the Competition Act, 2002 and all other
provisions of General Financial Rules, 2017 and also as per the terms and
conditions stipulated in the standard document and Manual for Procurement
of Goods, 2017 to ensure observance of the high standard of ethics. The
learned DSGI draws attention of this Court to Rule 175 (1) (ii) of the
General Financial Rules, 2017 and Clause 5.1.4 (ix) (d) of the Manual for
Procurement of Good, 2017 and submits that petitioner has contravened the
disclosure clause of “Conflict of Interest” and “Anti-Competitive Practice”
by not furnishing the details of his relationship with the proprietor of M/s
GSG Associates and, as such, there is no infirmity or illegality in the
passing of the impugned order. He, however, fairly submits that as per
Rule 151 (iii) of the General Financial Rules, 2017, the respondent
authority has the power to debar a bidder for a period not exceeding two
years only and the impugned order is incorrect only to the extent it refers to
the period of debarment or blacklisting of the petitioner.
He further
submits that the period of two years has since lapsed from the date of the
impugned order and at present there remains nothing to be decided in the
writ petition and the same may be dismissed.
P a g e 6 | 12
6.
The submissions made by the rival parties are given careful
consideration. For better appreciation of the matter in hand, it would be
apposite to refer to the Appendix – L, particularly clauses (iii) & (v), of the
related tender document which reads as follows: CHAPTER-VI
Appendix-L
CERTIFICATE FOR ABIDING BY CODE OF INTEGRITY FOR
PUBLIC PROCUREMENT (CIPP)
1. I/We______________ (Name of Prop & Firm) hereby
solemnly affirm and certify that we will observe the
highest standard of ethics and will not indulge in the
following prohibited practices, either directly or
indirectly, at any stage during the procurement process
or during execution of resultant contracts: (i) ………………………
(ii) ……………………...
(iii) "Anti-competitive Practice". Any collusion, bid
rigging or anti-competitive arrangement, or any other
practice coming under the purview of The Competition
Act, 2002, between two or more bidders, with or without
the knowledge of the Procuring Entity, that may impair
the transparency, fairness and the progress of the
procurement process or to establish bid prices at
artificial, non-competitive levels.
(iv)…………………………
(V) "Conflict of interest". Participation by a bidding
firm or any of its affiliates that are either involved in the
consultancy contract to which this procurement is
linked, or if they are part of more than one bid in the
procurement, or if the bidding firm or their personnel
have relationships or financial or business transactions
with any official of Procuring Entity who are directly or
indirectly related to tender or execution process of
contract, or improper use of information obtained by the
(prospective) bidder from the Procuring Entity with an
intent to gain unfair advantage in the procurement
process or for personal gain, and
P a g e 7 | 12
(vi) …………………………
2.
At any stage if we am/are found in case of any
transgression of this CODE OF INTEGRITY FOR
PUBLIC PROCUREMENT (CIPP) as mentioned above
I/we shall be not only liable to be removed from the list
of registered suppliers, but would be liable for other
punitive actions such as cancellation of contracts,
banning and blacklisting or action in Competition
Commission of India, and so on. (Rule 175 of GFR
2017).
Signature of the tenderer & Stamp
(Authorized signatory of
company)
7.
A perusal of the above clauses (iii) & (v), of the code of integrity for
public procurement, breach of which has been alleged against the
petitioner, do not indicate that the petitioner was required to disclose about
existence of his spousal relationship with any other participating bidder.
Clause (v) of the aforementioned code requires disclosure in the event of
the bidding firm or their personnel have relationship or financial or
business transaction with any official of procuring entity who are directly
or indirectly related to tender or execution process of contract. In the
present matter, it is not the case of the respondent that the petitioner is
having any kind of relationship or business or financial transaction with any
of the officials of the tendering authority.
The non-disclosure of the
existence of spousal relationship between the petitioner and the proprietor
of M/s GSG Associates, as such, cannot be taken as a violation of the said
code. In addition, the stipulated terms and conditions of the relevant tender
process nowhere prohibits or forbids participation of close relatives or
members of a family including husband and wife in the bidding process.
Thus, the petitioner could not have been disqualified on the pretext of
violation of the clause (v) of the aforesaid code of integrity.
P a g e 8 | 12
8.
The clause (iii) of the aforesaid code lays down that any collusion,
bid rigging or anti-competitive arrangement or other practice coming under
the purview of the Competition Act, 2002 between two or more bidders,
that may impair the transparency, fairness and progress of the procurement
process or to establish bid prices at artificial, non-competitive levels shall
be regarded as prohibited practice. The said code does not say that just
because there exists a spousal relationship between two bidders, the
presumption of existence of collusion, bid rigging or anti-competitive
arrangement will be automatic. The provisions of the Competition Act,
2002 also do not contain any provision by which members of a family
including husband and wife or any other close relative are barred from
taking part in a tender process for advancing their business interest.
Therefore, the Clause (iii) of the aforesaid code cannot be interpreted in a
way to curtail rights of two individuals on the basis of existence of spousal
relation between them.
9.
Coming to Rule 175 (1) (ii) of the General Financial Rules, 2017 and
Clause 5.1.4 (ix) (d) of the Manual for Procurement of Good, 2017 on
which reliance has been placed by the learned DSGI to support the
impugned order, it is seen that the aforesaid rules/guidelines are framed in
the line of the mandate of law contained in the Competition Act, 2002. The
very interpretation of the said rules/guidelines, as such, also will have to be
within the framework of the provisions of the Companies Act, 2002. The
reference of term “relationship” in Clause 5.1.4 (ix) (d) of the Manual for
Procurement of Good, 2017 has to be taken as business relationship and not
personnel relationship or social relationship. Business relationship in a
commercial transaction would mean connection between stake-holders in
the process of business and, therefore, mere presence of existence of
personal relation or social relation between two bidders cannot be termed as
P a g e 9 | 12
“relationship” in a commercial process so as to attract the violation of the
Integrity Code of “Conflict of Interest” and “Anti-Competitive Practice”.
10.
The finding recorded in the impugned order dated 27-05-2020
indicates that the same is based only on the fact of existence of spousal
relationship between the petitioner and the proprietor of M/s GSG
Associates and also for the reason of non-disclosure of the said fact by the
petitioner at the time of taking part in the tender process. The petitioner’s
role in indulging in violation of clause (iii) “Anti-competitive Practice” and
clause (v) “Conflict of Interest” is also judged on surmises and conjectures
surrounding the fact of the existence of the spousal relationship between the
petitioner and the proprietor of M/s GSG Associates. The respondent No.2
while passing the impugned order did not even bother to discuss and take
into consideration the very words of the clause (iii) “Anti-competitive
Practice” and clause (v) “Conflict of Interest” of the Appendix – L and in
the process failed to appreciate that the aforesaid clauses did not make it
mandatory for the petitioner to disclose about existence of personal
relationship with the proprietor of M/s GSG Associates at the time of
taking part in the tender process. The respondent No.2 also did not refer
and rely on any materials on record to determine whether there was
existence of close business relationship between the aforesaid two bidders
and whether the petitioner was directly or indirectly controlling the
business of M/s GSG Associates and also invoked doctrine of Alter-Ego
without recording a finding that any of the firms lack separate business
identity. The impugned order was also passed on the premises that had
there been disclosure of existence of spousal relationship by the petitioner
at the time of taking part in the tender process, it would have resulted in
rejection of petitioner’s bid summarily in view of the terms of the tender
offer; whereas, in reality there exists no such terms and conditions in the
P a g e 10 | 12
tender document. The impugned order does not show that the respondent
No.2 have even bothered to take into consideration the details of the offer
made by the petitioner and the proprietor of M/s GSG Associates in the
bidding process in order to determine existence of business relations
between them. There is no reference of existence of any stipulation in the
tender document which debar or prohibit married couple from taking part in
the tender process in the name of their individual business identity.
11.
Husband and wife are two different identities in law and the same
relationship cannot lead to any disqualification in a tender process until and
unless there exist a specific restriction incorporated in the related terms and
conditions. No law has been placed before this Court which can permit any
restriction on two separate business establishments irrespective of the fact
of being they relate two each other as husband and wife. The provision of
Section 3 of the Competition Act, 2002 also nowhere in specific term
restricts participation of husband and wife as two separate business identity
in a bidding process.
There is also no allegation of petitioner having an
agreement, express or implied, with the proprietor of M/s GSG Associates
or they have formed a cartel to create non-competitive levels in the bidding
process.
12.
For what have been discussed above, the impugned order dated 27-
05-2020, insofar as it relates to banning and debarring the petitioner from
entering into any business dealing with Assam Rifles is concerned, cannot
be sustained in law and the same is set aside to that extent.
13.
It is made clear that the observation and finding recorded
hereinabove shall not have any bearing on the merits of any claim and
counter-claim between the parties which may arise out of the events taken
P a g e 11 | 12
place during the subsistence of the contract entered into between the
petitioner and the respondents.
14.
The writ petition stands disposed of in the aforesaid terms.
15.
There will be no order as to costs.
Judge
Meghalaya
01.12.2023
“Biswarup PS”
P a g e 12 | 12
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review