Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/14
GAHC040008822025
2026:GAU-AP:15
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
WP(C)/243(AP)/2025
M/s L.Y. Enterprises,
Village- Sikarijo,
PO/PS_ Daporijo,
Dist.: Uppere Subansiri,
Arunachal Pradesh,
Pin791122
………………Petitioner
-Versus-
(i) The State of Arunachal Pradesh,
Represent by Secretary,
Department of Rurual Development,
Gogernment of Arunachal Pradesh,
Itanagar- 791111.
(ii) The Director,
Dpeartment of Rural Development,
Government of Arunachal Pradesh,
Itanagar.
(iii) The Joint Director (RE)
Department of Rural Development,
Government of Arunachal Pradesh,
Itanagar.
(iv) The Project Director,
Department of Rural Development,
Upper Subansiri
Page No.# 2/14
Dist.: Daporijo
(v) M/s RRR Enterprise
Proprietor- Shri Bimbo Notum Raji,
S/o Sarnu Raji,
Vill.: Battak,
PO/PS: Daporijo,
Dist.: Upper Subansiri,
Arunachal Pradesh,
Pin- 791122.
……………Respondents
- BEFORE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE PRANJAL DAS
For the Petitioner
: Mr. P.D. Nair
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. N. Ratan, Additional Advocate General
and Mr. D. Soki.
Date on which judgment was reserved :03.11.2025
Date of pronouncement of judgment
:09.01.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of the
Operative part of the judgment?
:No
Whether the full judgment has been
pronounced?
: NA
(Pranjal Das, J)
Heard Mr. P.D. Nair, learned counsel for the petitioner. Also heard
Mr. N. Ratan, learned Additional Advocate General for the State of
Arunachal Pradesh/respondent Nos. 1 to 4 and Mr. D. Soki, learned
counsel for the respondent No. 5.
Page No.# 3/14
2.
The instant writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India has been filed by the petitioner firm, being aggrieved, by the
order dated 02-05-2025 passed by the respondent authorities with
regard to NIT dated 11-04-2025, whereby the bid of the petitioner firm
was rejected and that of the respondent No. 5/private respondent was
accepted. The petitioner firm, after passing the technical evaluation,
emerged as the lowest bidder during the financial evaluation; but its
bid was rejected as the bid amount was stated to be a minus 10
percent, which was above the justified rate fixed at 7.31%. It is stated
that the petitioner firm is a registered Class-II contractor under the
Arunachal Pradesh Enlistment of Contractors in Works Department
Rules, 2008 and that it has a valid trading license as well as GST
registration.
3.
It is further stated that the respondent No. 4, being Project
Director, Rural Development Department issued a notice inviting tender
NIT dated 11-04-2025 inviting bids from eligible Class-II contractors
for the supply and procurement of materials under MGNREGA 2025-26
in respect of CD Block Chetam, Upper Subansiri district /district:
Daporijo. The estimated cost of the work was Rs. 5,36,45,700/- and
period of completion was 12 months.
4.
It is stated that the bids were to be submitted online by 4 p.m.
on 29-04-2025 and technical bids were to be opened and evaluated on
30-04-2025 at 10 a.m. and the financial bids of the technically
qualified bidders were to be opened on 01-05-2025. It was also
provided that the last date of bid validity was 06-06-2025. The
Page No.# 4/14
petitioner further stated that being interested in the contract, it
participated in the tender process and 3 bidders including the
petitioner submitted their bids and all of them were found to be
technically qualified upon opening the technical bids on 30-04-2025.
5.
It is further stated that on 01-05-2025, the financial bids of the 3
technically qualified bidders were opened and the petitioner firm was
found to be the lowest bidder with a bid value of Rs. 4,82,81,129.93.
The bid value of the second lowest bidder being of firm RRR
Enterprises, respondent No. 5, was found to be Rs. 4,97,22,889.85.
The petitioner further states that as the lowest bidder, it was in
expectation of being issued the work order and the award of contract.
But surprisingly, the respondents/authorities issued the impugned
order dated 02-05-2025, whereby the bid of the petitioner was
rejected for being 10% below the justified rate, whereas the rate
quoted by the respondent No. 5 was approved as it was 7.31% below
the justified rate. It is contended by the writ petitioner that the tender
conditions did not provide for resorting to any justified rates and
therefore, rejection of the petitioner's lowest bid on the ground of
being lower than the justified rate amounted to resorting to a hidden
criterion in the tender process and was therefore, arbitrary in nature
and violative of Article 14 of the Constitution of India. It is contended
that the CPWD manuals of 2014, 2019 and 2024, specifically provided
that variations up to 10% of the justified rates can be accepted and
only variations above 10% cannot be accepted and therefore, as the
variation of the petitioner's bid was within the said 10%, it could not
have been rejected on the stated ground.
Page No.# 5/14
6.
It is contended by the writ petitioner that the impugned action of
the respondent authorities in rejecting the lowest bid of the petitioner
and awarding the contract to respondent No. 5 was arbitrary and
biased and influenced by political considerations and therefore, in
exercise of judicial review, the petitioner seeks interference with the
impugned order by this Court in exercise of the writ jurisdiction under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India. It is contended that in terms of
Clause 14 (II) of the Special Conditions of the NIT, the contract has to
be awarded to the lowest bidder as L1 and therefore by bypassing the
petitioner's bid, the respondent authorities have violated the terms of
the NIT and therefore, the same requires interference by this Court in
this writ petition.
7.
The respondent Nos. 1 to 4 i.e. the State respondents have filed
a joint affidavit-in-opposition contesting the claim of the petitioner. It is
contended that the NIT has two clauses being Clause 20 and Clause
25 of the special conditions of the additional conditions. It is
contended by the respondent authorities that the department has to
prepare the justified rate in terms of Clause 20 and thereby evaluate
the financial bids of the parties and only in the event of failing to
prepare a justified rate in terms of Clause 20, that the Clause 25 of the
additional conditions come into operation - wherein a variation of 5%
or 10% can be applicable. It is contended by the respondent
authorities that the said clauses 20 and 25 of the additional conditions
of the NIT do not run parallelly and that they are alternate to each
other.
Page No.# 6/14
8.
The respondents denied that there were any hidden criteria
applied as the same was already mentioned in these additional
conditions of the NIT. It is stated that the Project Director of three
districts being Papum Pare, Kamle and Upper Subansiri prepared
justified rates and for this reason, only in these three districts, the
justified rate has been applied. It is further contended and stated by
the respondent authorities that the justified rates are prepared based
on the market value of each item and the Project Director in terms of
Clause 20 of the additional conditions prepared justified rates for
Chetam CD Block, Upper Subansiri district and submitted the justified
rate before the Joint Director for approval on 11.04.2025 and the Joint
Director approved the same on 21.04.2025 and the justified amount
was fixed at Rs. 4,97,24,886.96/- and the percentage of the justified
rate was fixed as at 7.31% vis-a-vis the value of the tender which is Rs
5,36,45,700/-.
9.
It is stated by the respondent authorities that the bid of LY
Enterprises was found to be 10% lower than the justified rate amount.
The bid value of M/s Salo Enterprise, one of the three bidders who had
passed the technical evaluation, was 7.23% which is 2/3% lower than
the justified rate amount and the bid value of M/s RRR enterprises,
found to be - 7.31% which is exactly the justified value rate.
Accordingly, the bid of respondent No. 5 was accepted and that of the
petitioner rejected and it is contended that there is no infirmity in the
said decision making process.
10.
The petitioner firm filed an affidavit-in-reply to the affidavit-in-
Page No.# 7/14
opposition of the respondent authorities in which the petitioner denied
that Clauses 20 and 25 of the special conditions of the NIAP are
mutually exclusive. The writ petitioner contended in the affidavit reply
that Clause 20 specifically stated that the tender shall be governed by
Clause 20.4.3 of the CPWD Works Manual and that, in terms of the
said Clause 20.4.3 of the CPWD Manual variations are permissible over
justified rates, as provided in Clause 20.4.3.2. It is stated that in terms
of the said Clause 20.4.3.2, variations up to 5% can be ignored and
variations up to 10% can be allowed for peculiar situations and
circumstances. The writ petitioner contended that the justified rate
value arrived at by the authorities was Rs. 4,97,24,886396/- and the
bid value of the petitioner firm was Rs. 4,82,81,129.93 and that the
same was 2.9% below the justified rate and therefore, the bid value
was within the permissible limit as per Clause 20.4.3.2 of the CPWD
manual applicable to the tender process in question.
11.
In this context, it is further contended that as the lowest bid of
the petitioner was within the permissible range therefore, the
respondent authorities could not have rejected the bid of the
petitioner. The petitioner also contended that respondent authorities
were wrong in holding that only a bid which is equal to the justified
rate of percentage of minus 7.31% has to be accepted and contends
that it is an erroneous interpretation of the terms of processing the
bids. The petitioner has also filed an additional affidavit taking
recourse to certain guidelines issued by the Central Vigilance
Commission about acceptance of lowest bids in government contracts.
Page No.# 8/14
12.
It is contended by the petitioner that for tender works under
Arunachal PWD and in terms of clause 20.4.3.2 of CPWD Works
Manual 2014, the lowest tenderer within a variation of 5% over the
justified rate have to be considered for award of work.
13.
I have perused the pleadings and the relevant documents
annexed with this writ petition.
14. The Learned Counsel for the writ petitioner submits that as the
lowest bidder and having passed the technical evaluation, the
petitioner firm was entitled in law to have been awarded the contract.
Referring to the pleadings in this regard, it is submitted and contended
that awarding the contract on the basis of justified rates amounted to
resorting to a hidden criterion, which was outside the ambit of the NIT
and therefore the same is arbitrary. It is submitted that awarding of
the contract to respondent No. 5 was driven by extraneous
considerations and also untenable in law. It is further submitted by the
Learned Counsel for the writ petitioner that even going by the justified
rate, the bid value of the petitioner firm was within the permissible
range of justified rate and therefore, even applying the said justified
rates, the petitioner firm was entitled to be awarded the contract. It is
submitted by referring to pleadings in this regard that the respondent
authorities made an error in its interpretation of the way the justified
rates had to be applied in the instant case and as a result of such error
also, the respondent authorities incorrectly awarded the contract in
favour of respondent No. 5, instead of the petitioner firm. Seeking
interference with the impugned order, the learned counsel for writ
Page No.# 9/14
petitioner submits that the impugned order should be set aside and
the contract awarded in favour of the petitioner firm.
15.
On the other hand, the learned counsel for the respondent
authorities submits that the process of awarding the tender has been
carried out within the ambit of law and due procedure and that there
is no error in the said decision-making process. It is further submitted
that there is no error in the awarding of the contract to the respondent
No. 5 as the said firm was found eligible to be awarded the contract. It
is submitted that there are absolutely no political or extraneous
considerations involved in awarding of the contract in favor of the
respondent No. 5. It is submitted that the justified rates were drawn
up by following the proper procedure and process and bid of the
petitioner firm was beyond the permissible range of the justified rate
and therefore, the contract could not have been awarded in favor of
the petitioner firm. The bid of respondent No. 5 was found to be
technically qualified and as per the justified rate determined and
hence, there is no infirmity in awarding of the contract in favor of the
respondent No. 5. The Learned Counsel for the respondent No.
5/private respondent - supporting the submissions of the Learned
Counsel for the Respondent Authorities - contends and submits that
only the bid of respondent No. 5 was as per justified rates and
therefore, it is the respondent No. 5 alone, who was eligible in law to
be awarded the contract. It is contended and submitted that though
the petitioner firm passed the technical evaluation and was the lowest
bidder, but in terms of justified rates determined after following due
process, the bid of petitioner firm was found to be beyond the
Page No.# 10/14
permissible range of justified rates. And hence, contract was rightfully
awarded to respondent No. 5. It is also submitted on behalf of the
respondent authorities as well as the private respondent that the writ
petition is devoid of merits and should be dismissed.
16.
I have considered the submissions of the learned counsel for the
petitioner and the learned Additional Advocate General for the State
respondents and the learned counsel for the responding No. 5.
17.
As per the NIT dated 11-04-2025, the value of the tender was
quantified at Rs 5,36,45,700/-. The respondent authorities prepared
justified rates which was quantified at Rs 4,97,24,886.96 and in
percentage terms it was - 7.31% below the value of the tender.
18.
Before proceeding further, the additional conditions of the NIT
may be seen, especially Clause 20 which states that this tender shall
be governed by Clause 20.4.3 under Section 20 of the CPWD Works
Manual for reasonability and competitiveness of rates.
19.
The aforementioned Clause 20 may be reproduced herein below
–
Clause 20: This tender shall be governed by Clause 20.4.3 under
Section
of
the
CPWD
Works
Manual
for
reasonability
and
competitiveness of rates.
20.
Next, I take up the CPWD Works Manual 2014 and go through
the aforementioned Clause 20.4.3 which appears under the heading
“reasonability and competitiveness of rates .” Thus, it follows from
Clause 20.4.3 of section 20 of CPWD Works Manual 2014 that the
Page No.# 11/14
reasonableness of the rates has to be seen before acceptance of the
tenders.
21.
This is with a view to ensure that in the process of competitive
bidding, unrealistic rates are not quoted by the bidders just to secure
the contract. Clause 20.4.3 also provides that reasonableness of rates
has to be assessed on the basis of justified rates and the mode of
preparation of such justified rates has been laid down in detail in
Clause 20.4.3.1.
22.
For the purpose of the present adjudication, it is important to
note that permissible variations over the justified rates are given in
Clause 20.4.3.2, which may be reproduced herein below:20.4.3.2 Acceptance of tenders at justified rates with allowable
variations Apropos provisions under para 20.4.3 variation up to 5% over the
justified rates may be ignored. Variation up to 10% may be allowed for
peculiar situations and in special circumstances. Reasons for doing so shall
be placed on record. Tenders above this limit should not be accepted.
23.
Thus, I find that variation of 5% vis-à-vis the justified rates are
allowed to be ignored and variations above 10% are held to be not
acceptable and such bids have to be rejected. It is also provided that
variations up to 10% can be allowed, but for peculiar situations and
special circumstances and reasons for doing so have to be placed on
record.
24.
The whole objective behind this exercise, as mentioned earlier, is
to ensure that uncompetitive bids are not accepted which can
compromise the work. When other things are equal, the authorities
Page No.# 12/14
are encouraged to accept the lowest bidder in public works involving
public money.
25.
Now, I come back again to the facts of the instant case. As
already stated, in terms of NIT dated 11-04-2025, the tender value is
Rs.5,36,45,700/-. The justified rate is quantified at Rs.4,97,24,886/and in percentage terms i.e. 7.21%. In monetary terms, the
petitioner's bid was quantified at Rs. 4,82,81,129.93/- and in
percentage terms, the said bid had a variation of 2.9% vis-à-vis the
justified rate.
26.
The respondent authorities have held that the bid of the
petitioner firm was 10% below the justified rate and therefore, not
acceptable in terms of the applicable guidelines. However, I find that
the petitioner firm in its affidavit-in-reply has contended that the
variation of the petitioner firm is 2.9% below the justified rate and
therefore, was within the permissible limit as per Clause 20.4.3.2. It is
an admitted position that the bid value of the petitioner firm was the
lowest financial bid within bracket L1 vis-à-vis the bid of the
respondent No. 5 which was Rs. 4,97,22,889.85/-.
27.
Upon giving my consideration to the entire matter in the context
of the applicable guidelines of the CPWD manual and the additional
conditions of the NIT - I come to the considered opinion that the
respondent authorities made an error in holding that the bid of the
petitioner was 10% below the justified rate; whereas, in fact, it was
2.9% below the justified rate and within the permissible variation
bracket of 5% in terms of Clause 20.4.3.2 of the CPWD Works Manual
Page No.# 13/14
2014.
28.
Further, I also find force in the contention of the petitioner firm
made through its affidavit in reply that the respondent authorities
perhaps erred in holding the view that a firm whose bid value is equal
to the justified rate percentage only has to be accepted. In the tender
process - the petitioner firm was the L1 lowest bidder in financial terms and
its bid value of Rs. 4,82,81,129.93/- was approximately 2.9% below the
justified rate (Rs. 4,97,22,889.85/-) and in terms of the applicable guidelines
of the CPWD manual (Clause 20.4.3.2) – was within permissible range.
29.
The bid of the petitioner was thus within the permissible
variation range in terms of the guidelines. Hence, the respondent
authorities were obligated in law and in terms of the tender conditions
to accept the bid of the petitioner firm, rather than that of the
respondent No. 5.
30.
It is well settled that evaluation of tender involves certain
technical and financial expertise as well and the courts in exercise of
judicial review do not and should not easily substitute its views for the
views of the authorities who might be having technical expertise.
However, in exercise of such judicial review, if examination of the
decision-making process and its legal dimensions reveals errors and
arbitrariness, the same is required to be interfered with in exercise of
writ jurisdiction. Otherwise, the same would be violative of Article 14
of the Constitution of India.
31.
Consequently, the writ petition is allowed and the following
Page No.# 14/14
directions are issued :(i) The order dated 02-05-2025 passed by the respondent
authorities awarding the contract in favor of respondent no. 5
vis-a-vis the NIT dated 11-04-2025 is hereby set aside.
(ii) The respondent authority shall award the contract - in terms
of NIT dated 11-04-2025 – in favor of the petitioner firm, as it
has been found to be lawfully entitled to be awarded the
contract.
32.
The writ petition stands allowed and disposed of.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review