Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 13
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 373 of 2023
Date of Decision: 27.02.2024
M/s KBS Motors & Anr.
Vs.
State Bank of India
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) :
Mr. A. Sahu, Adv.
Ms. A. Pradhan, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
Mr. S. Dutta, Adv.
Ms. P. Riahtam, Adv.
i)
:
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc:
Yes/No
ii)
Whether approved for publication
Yes/No
in press:
____________________________________________________________
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (ORAL)
1.
The petitioner No. 2 herein, owned and operated a Tata
Motors Vehicle Dealership known as M/s KBS Motors, (petitioner No.
1). To operate the said business, the petitioner took financial assistance
from the respondent Bank, which had advanced the same, as per the
arrangements and terms as agreed upon. The Tata Motors Dealership
however, ran into huge financial losses and its operations, closed down
in the year 2015. Due to the non-payment of the loan amount, the
respondent Bank filed an Original Application being O.A. No. 78 of
2017, before the Debt Recovery Tribunal, at Guwahati on 14.03.2017.
The said O.A. was then heard and final orders were passed on
30.08.2022, allowing the application of the respondent Bank. Sum and
substance of the order was that, the petitioners/defendants therein, were
held jointly and severally liable to pay the respondent Bank, a sum of
Rs.8,39,81,509.10 (Rupees Eight Crores Thirty-Nine Lakhs Eighty-One
Thousand Five Hundred Nine and Ten Paise) only, with pendente lite
and future interest @ 14.80% with monthly interest from 08.03.2017,
till the date of full payment/realization and also cost of the application.
A Recovery Certificate for the said sum was then issued on 12.10.2022.
2.
As per the order dated 30.08.2022, and Recovery Certificate
dated 12.10.2022, 3(three) properties of the petitioner were sold on
auction, and the total recoveries made by the Bank stood at
Rs.8,6900000 (Rupees Eight Crores and Sixty-Nine Lakhs) only, and
certificates of Sale all dated 03.10.2023, were issued to the Successful
Auction Purchasers. However, as the total dues with pendente lite
interest, for an amount of Rs.13,30,41,076.16 (Rupees Thirteen Crores
Thirty Lakhs Forty-One Thousand Seventy-Six and Sixteen Paise)
only, remained outstanding, the respondent Bank initiated the sale of
the remaining mortgaged properties of the petitioner No. 2. The
petitioners on the ground that, the amounts due of Rs.8,39,81,509.10
(Rupees Eight Crores Thirty-Nine Lakhs Eighty-One Thousand Five
Hundred Nine and Ten Paise) only, as per the Recovery Certificate
having been satisfied with the earlier sale of the three properties, are
before this Court alleging that the respondent Bank has acted arbitrarily
and illegally in proceeding for further realization of the amounts as
claimed.
3.
Mr. A. Sahu, learned counsel for the petitioners has drawn the
attention of this Court to the Recovery Certificate dated 12.10.2022,
and submits that the amounts indicated therein is of Rs.8,39,81,509.10
(Rupees Eight Crores Thirty-Nine Lakhs Eighty-One Thousand Five
Hundred Nine and Ten Paise) only, which have since been satisfied
with the sale of the three properties. He further submits that in the table
of dues as shown in the Recovery Certificate, the amount of interest
due is not indicated anywhere, and that if the remaining two plots of the
petitioners are also auctioned, the petitioners and the family will have
nowhere to live. It is also contended that the amounts already received
by the respondent Bank is more than one and a half times of the loan
amount, and as such, any further recovery will be unjust, arbitrary and
discriminatory. The learned counsel then lastly submits that, the
petitioners are seeking relief under Article 226 of the Constitution,
inspite of the availability of statutory appeal due to the gross illegality,
which has been committed in violation of fundamental and other rights.
Learned counsel has placed reliance on a judgment of a Division Bench
of the High Court of Madhya Pradesh, in the case of Mani Sharma vs.
Bank of India & Anr. in Writ Petition No. 2285 of 2022, decided on
22.06.2022, to advance his arguments, that powers under Article 226
can be invoked in certain cases.
4.
Mr. S. Dutta, learned counsel for the respondent Bank has at
the outset submitted that, the writ petition is not maintainable on the
ground that, there is a specific efficacious and alternate remedy
available to the petitioners under Section 30 of the Recovery of Debts
and Bankruptcy Act, 1993, whereby any person aggrieved by an order
of the Recovery Officer made under the Act, within 30(thirty) days
from the date on which a copy of the order is issued to him, could
prefer an appeal to the tribunal. He therefore submits that, on this
ground alone the writ petition deserves no consideration.
5.
The learned counsel on the issues raised by the petitioners, has
submitted that, there is no illegality or arbitrariness in the amounts
arrived at which are payable by the petitioners. He submits that the
same is as per the judgment and order dated 30.08.2022, and Recovery
Certificate No. 114/2022, passed by the learned Debt Recovery
Tribunal in O.A. No. 78/2017, wherein an outstanding amount of
Rs.8,39,81,509.10 (Rupees Eight Crores Thirty-Nine Lakhs Eighty-One
Thousand Five Hundred Nine and Ten Paise) only, w.e.f. 08.03.2017,
till realization along with interest @ 14.80% per annum was payable.
He submits that the respondent Bank had calculated the interest portion,
which came to Rs.13,85,06,365.06 (Rupees Thirteen Crores EightyFive Lakhs Six Thousand Three Hundred Sixty-Five and Six Paise)
only, as on 19.12.2023 and after deduction of Rs.8,94,46,798.00
(Rupees Eight Crores Ninety-Four Lakhs Forty-Six Thousand Seven
Hundred and Ninety-Eight) only, including the sale proceeds of three
properties, the total outstanding dues as on 19.12.2023, stood at
Rs.13,30,41,076.16 (Rupees Thirteen Crores Thirty Thousand FortyOne Thousand Seventy Six and Sixteen Paise) only, which the
petitioners in terms of the judgment and order dated 30.08.2022, were
liable to pay. As such, he submits apart from there being efficacious
and alternative remedy available to the petitioner, under Section 30 of
the Recovery of Debts and Bankruptcy Act, 1993, there has been no
discrepancy in the computation of the amounts due or any illegality in
the actions of the respondent Bank.
6.
Having heard the learned counsel for the parties, and perused
the materials on record. It is noted that the entire proceedings before the
Debt Recovery Tribunal were conducted in accordance with the
provisions contained in the Recovery of Debts and Bankruptcy Act,
1993, and no irregularity in this regard has been alleged or is present.
The objection therefore, by the respondent Bank as to the
maintainability of the writ petition, carries great weightage as in
accordance with the Act itself, the petitioners are not left remedy less,
and have recourse to an appeal to the Tribunal under Section 30 of the
Recovery of Debts and Bankruptcy Act, 1993, which reads as follows.
“30. Appeal against the order of Recovery Officer.- (1)
Notwithstanding anything contained in section 29, any
person aggrieved by an order of the Recovery Officer made
under this Act may, within thirty days from the date on
which a copy of the order is issued to him, prefer an appeal
to the Tribunal.
(2) On receipt of an appeal under sub-section (1), the
Tribunal may, after giving an opportunity to the appellant to
be heard, and after making such inquiry as it deems fit,
confirm, modify or set aside the order made by the Recovery
Officer in exercise of his powers under sections 25 to 28
(both inclusive).”
7.
A perusal of the Recovery Certificate RC No. 114-2022,
wherein the petitioners have maintained that, the dues payable as
recorded therein is only for Rs.8,39,81,509.10 (Rupees Eight Crores
Thirty-Nine Lakhs Eighty-One Thousand Five Hundred Nine and Ten
Paise) only, however, does not support their contentions, inasmuch as,
the amount recoverable as stated therein is with pendente lite and future
interest @ 14.80% per annum, from 08.03.2017. The amounts
demanded therefore, being as per the Recovery Certificate and order
dated 30.08.2022, passed by the Tribunal, which have remained
unchallenged, no materials exist to warrant interference under Article
226 of the Constitution of India, by this Court.
8.
In such matters, where alternative remedy is available, the
exercise of powers under Article 226 of the Constitution by the High
Courts, as held in the judgment of the Supreme Court in Harbanslal
Sahnia & Anr. vs. Indian Oil Corpn. Ltd. & Ors. reported in (2003) 2
SCC 107, is one of discretion and not of compulsion. The said
judgment has in Para – 7 held as follows.
“7. So far as the view taken by the High Court that the
remedy by way of recourse to arbitration clause was
available to the appellants and therefore the writ petition
filed by the appellants was liable to be dismissed is
concerned, suffice it to observe that the rule of exclusion of
writ jurisdiction by availability of an alternative remedy is a
rule of discretion and not one of compulsion. In an
appropriate case, in spite of availability of the alternative
remedy, the High Court may still exercise its writ jurisdiction
in at least three contingencies: (i) where the writ petition
seeks enforcement of any of the fundamental rights; (ii)
where there is failure of principles of natural justice; or (iii)
where the orders or proceedings are wholly without
jurisdiction or the vires of an Act
is challenged
(See Whirlpool Corpn. v. Registrar of Trade Marks.) The
present
case attracts
contingencies.
applicability of
Moreover,
as
noted,
the
first
two
the
petitioners'
dealership, which is their bread and butter, came to be
terminated for an irrelevant and non-existent cause. In such
circumstances, we feel that the appellants should have been
allowed relief by the High Court itself instead of driving
them to the need of initiating arbitration proceedings.”
9.
In the present case however, the three contingencies as given
in the above noted judgment are however absent. Furthermore, in
matters involving Debt, Financial and Monetary Laws, as has been held
by the Supreme Court in many decisions the High Courts should not
under Article 226 of the Constitution grant stay, except when the writ
petitioner is able to show, that the case falls within any of the
exceptions carved out in judgments of the Supreme Court, and that
High Courts should be more careful and circumspect in this regard. A
noted case on this aspect, is that of United Bank of India vs. Satyawati
Tondon & Ors. reported in (2010) 8 SCC 110, wherein in Paragraphs –
43, 44, 45 and 46 it has been held as follows.
“43. Unfortunately, the High Court overlooked the settled
law that the High Court will ordinarily not entertain
a petition under Article 226 of the Constitution if an effective
remedy is available to the aggrieved person and that this rule
applies with greater rigour in matters involving recovery of
taxes, cess, fees, other types of public money and the dues of
banks and other financial institutions. In our view, while
dealing with the petitions involving challenge to the action
taken for recovery of the public dues, etc., the High Court
must keep in mind that the legislations enacted by
Parliament and State Legislatures for recovery of such dues
are a code unto themselves inasmuch as they not only
contain comprehensive procedure for recovery of the dues
but also envisage constitution of quasi-judicial bodies for
redressal of the grievance of any aggrieved person.
Therefore, in all such cases, the High Court must insist that
before availing remedy under Article 226 of the Constitution,
a person must exhaust the remedies available under the
relevant statute.
44. While expressing the aforesaid view, we are conscious
that the powers conferred upon the High Court under Article
226 of the Constitution to issue to any person or authority,
including in appropriate cases, any Government, directions,
orders or writs including the five prerogative writs for the
enforcement of any of the rights conferred by Part III or for
any other purpose are very wide and there is no express
limitation on exercise of that power but, at the same time, we
cannot be oblivious of the rules of self-imposed restraint
evolved by this Court, which every High Court is bound to
keep in view while exercising power under Article 226 of the
Constitution.
45. It is true that the rule of exhaustion of alternative remedy
is a rule of discretion and not one of compulsion, but it is
difficult to fathom any reason why the High Court should
entertain
a
petition
filed
under Article
226 of
the
Constitution and pass interim order ignoring the fact that the
petitioner can avail effective alternative remedy by filing
application, appeal, revision, etc. and the particular
legislation contains a detailed mechanism for redressal of
his grievance.
46. It must be remembered that stay of an action initiated by
the State and/or its agencies/instrumentalities for recovery of
taxes, cess, fees, etc. seriously impedes execution of projects
of public importance and disables them from discharging
their constitutional and legal obligations towards the
citizens. In cases relating to recovery of the dues of banks,
financial institutions and secured creditors, stay granted by
the High Court would have serious adverse impact on the
financial health of such bodies/institutions, which (sic will)
ultimately prove detrimental to the economy of the nation.
Therefore, the High Court should be extremely careful and
circumspect in exercising its discretion to grant stay in such
matters. Of course, if the petitioner is able to show that its
case falls within any of the exceptions carved out
in Baburam Prakash Chandra Maheshwari v. Antarim Zila
Parishad, Whirlpool Corpn. v. Registrar of Trade Marks and
Harbanslal Sahnia v. Indian Oil Corpn. Ltd. and some other
judgments, then the High Court may, after considering all
the relevant parameters and public interest, pass an
appropriate interim order.”
10.
The judgment placed by the learned counsel for the petitioner
of the High Court of Madhya Pradesh is noted, but the same will have
no application in the instant case, as it is on a different set of facts and
circumstances altogether.
11.
The instant writ petition therefore fails and no interference is
called for under Article 226 of the Constitution. The writ petitioners,
will be at liberty to pursue alternate remedy as provided under the
Recovery of Debts and Bankruptcy Act, 1993. Needless to add, on such
remedy being availed of, the Tribunal shall also consider condoning the
delay favourably.
12.
With the above directions, the writ petition is accordingly
closed and disposed of, however, with no order as to costs.
Judge
Meghalaya
27.02.2024
“D.Thabah-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review