The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
21. Therefore I am of the view that the proposed amendment is liable to be allowed and the defendant will have no cause to prejudice, if he is given liberty to file additional written statement. The impugned order by which the court below has allowed the prayer for amendment does not suffer from perversity or impropriety nor court below has committed gross error while allowing the prayer for amendment with cost and therefore the order impugned does not call for interference.
22. C.O. 3895 of 2024 thus stands dismissed. The plaintiff shall file amended plaint along with cost awarded by the court below within a period of three weeks from the date of communication of this order and the liberty is also given to the defendant to file additional written statement if any, within a period of three weeks thereafter. Urgent photostat certified copy of this order, if applied for, be supplied to the parties, on priority basis on compliance of all usual formalities. (Dr. AJOY KUMAR MUKHERJEE, J.)
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CIVIL REVISIONAL JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
PRESENT:
THE HON’BLE DR. JUSTICE AJOY KUMAR MUKHERJEE
C.O. 3895 of 2024
M/S. Karnani Properties limited & Ors.
Vs.
Harrow Hall
For the Petitioner
:
Mr. Shounak Mondal
Mr. Anuradha Poddar
For the Opposite Party
:
Mrs. Sohini Chakraborty
Ms. Prajaaini Das
Heard on
:
28.11.2025
Judgment on
:
29.01.2026
Dr. Ajoy Kumar Mukherjee, J.
1.
Order allowing amendment of the plaint by the court below dated 17th
September, 2024 passed in Title Suit no. 414 of 2015 is under challenge in
the instant Application.
2.
The brief background is that the opposite party (in short OP) herein as
plaintiff filed a suit interalia praying for declaration with regard to the
easementary right of the plaintiff to use the schedule mentioned property to
the plaint inter alia as playground and for a further declaration that the
plaintiff is a licensee under defendant no.1/petitioner herein for using the
said schedule property as lawn/playground and also for permanent
injunction, being said Title Suit no.414 of 2015. In connection with the said
suit, an interim injunction application was also filed praying therein to
restrain defendant/petitioner from interfering/restraining the student and
teachers of the plaintiff school from using the said playground. Learned trial
Judge by an order dated 2nd April 2015 was pleased to reject the said
prayer for ex parte ad interim order of injunction observing that OP had
failed to prove prima facie case.
3.
Being aggrieved by the said order OP herein preferred an appeal before
this Court being FMA no. 1906 of 2015 and this High Court affirmed the
order of the trial court and held that they did not find it an appropriate case,
where ad interim order of injunction should be passed, but directed the Trial
Court to dispose of the temporary injunction application on merit.
Thereafter Trial court after hearing the parties has been pleased to reject the
application for temporary injunction vide order dated 17.11.2016, observing
that plaintiff failed to show any document that they are in possession of the
said lawn on the date of filing of the suit or when they sought for such ad
interim order of injunction. The OP herein thereafter again filed an
application for reconsideration of the said order dated 17.11.2016 but it was
again rejected.
4.
The opposite party herein thereafter filed the subsequent suit being
T.S. no. 972 of 2021 against the petitioner herein interalia praying therein
for a declaration that the OP herein have the easement right and he is
entitled to enjoy the free light and air through and from the said lawn
described in the plaint. In the said suit for the year 2021 the OP however
obtained an order of injunction against the petitioner vide order dated
13.09.2021 in aforesaid T.S. no. 972 of 2021. After receiving notice the
petitioner herein filed an application under Order XXXIX
Rule 4 CPC
interalia praying for setting aside of the said order of injunction. Learned
Court below rejected the said prayer for setting aside the order of injunction.
Being aggrieved by the said order petitioner herein had preferred an appeal
before this Court being FMAT 542 of 2023. Said appeal came up before a
Division Bench of this Court, when Their Lordship allowed the said appeal
on contest on the ground that OP herein failed to show any document
relating to its physical possession of the said schedule property.
5.
In the above background the opposite party herein being the plaintiff
of the suit filed an application for amendment of the plaint of T.S 414 of
2015 on 15.03.24 whereby the opposite party as plaintiff had sought to
incorporate certain events to establish that the petitioner had granted
permission for using the said lawn cum playground as the playground of the
students of the OP school and said permission was never withdrawn by the
defendant no.1 as they continued regular physical activities of the
children/students of the school and such permission was granted time to
time to use the said playground for the welfare and benefit of the students of
the school which is continuing. By the impugned order learned court below
allowed plaintiffs aforesaid prayer for amendment of plaint.
6.
Being aggrieved by the aforesaid order, learned counsel for the
petitioner
Mr.
Mondal
argued
that
from
the
aforesaid
facts
and
circumstances, it is clear that inspite of getting opportunity, the OP herein
in their affidavit dated 26.11.2015 could not produce a single scrap of
evidence to show their possession over the schedule mentioned suit property
and for which learned Trial Judge was pleased to reject the application for
injunction. Thereafter OP again prayed for reconsideration of the said order
passed by learned trial judge but again it was rejected, since the OP herein
could not produce any document to establish their possession over the lawn
in question in the said earlier suit being T.S. no. 414 of 2015. As such in the
subsequent suit the OP herein had voluntarily waived his claim of licensee
although they were successful in obtaining an exparte adinterim order of
injunction but the same was ultimately vacated by this High Court in
aforesaid FMAT no. 542 of 2023, since the OP herein could not produce any
document to show their possession.
7.
Therefore Mr. Mondal strenuously argued that the issue relating to
possession of the said lawn had been put to rest, since all along the OP
herein could not produce any document showing their possession. Mr.
Mondal further submits that it appears that the OP herein had sought to
implead a letter dated 12.09.2000 written by OP to the petitioner and the
reply to the same dated 16.09.2000 written by the petitioner was given to
the OP whereby it is alleged that the petitioner had given permission to the
OP herein to use the suit property on that date also. From the said schedule
of amendment it further appears that OP herein intends to incorporate that
after obtaining the said permission from the petitioner it was never
withdrawn by the petitioner.
8.
Mr. Mondal in this context argued that it is trite law that the merits of
the amendment could not be looked into at the time of hearing of the
amendment application but the case in hand carves out an exception to the
same because in the instant case the conduct of
OP herein had to be
thoroughly examined. OP did not make out any case that they obtained or
got letters subsequent to the order of injunction i.e. in the year 2018 or
afterwards but the OP seeks to implead two letters of the year 2000,
wherefrom it cannot be said that it is a subsequent event which prompted
the OP to file the instant application for amendment, claiming that the
license is still continuing. In this context he further argued that an
amendment which is malafide and for which the adversary loses a valid
defence should not be allowed. It is true that if the proposed amendment
does not result in irreparable prejudice to the adversary or divest the
adversary of an advantage which it had secured as a result of an admission
by the party seeking amendment, the amendment is required to be allowed,
but the instant case does not fall within the scope and ambit as above and
as such the proposed amendment ought not to have allowed by the Court
below. In this context he relied upon the judgment reported in (2022) 16
SCC 1, (Life Insurance Corporation of India Vs. Sanjeev Builders
Private Limited & Another).
9.
Learned counsel for the petitioner in reply to the argument advanced
by the OP submitted that it is not the case of subsequent event but the OP
herein had the document in his possession and choose not to produce the
same. As such he has waived his right to show the said documents and
presently he should be debarred to incorporate the same document in his
pleading. Learned court below failed to consider that the pleading which has
been sought to be brought in by way of amendment by the plaintiff/OP is
repetition and reiteration of the facts already pleaded in the plaint and the
same has been made only to protract the litigation after almost 10 years
from the date of filing of the plaint and the application does not disclose that
inspite of due diligence there was no scope to incorporate the proposed
amendment with the plaint for last 10 years. Therefore the impugned order
is liable to be set aside.
10.
Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the OP submits that the OP is
an educational society and is running a school which is affiliated to the
Counsel for the Indian School Certificate Examination. The said Educational
Society used the Suit property/Lawn/playground for the students studying
at such institution, which is close to the suit premises. Said lawn is also
used for assembly, sports and physical training since the year 1975 on the
basis of the permission given by the Karnani’s Property Ltd. On 29th
September, 2014 and thereafter the students and the teachers of the school
were stopped from using the said lawn by the men and agents of the
petitioners, for which OP herein filed aforesaid suit for declaration and
injunction being T.S. 414 of 2015 though plaintiff’s prayer for injunction
was rejected. Thereafter the OP filed the subsequent suit wherein an order of
injunction has been passed to maintain status quo regarding the nature and
character of the suit lawn so that the easementary right of the OP herein
may not be disturbed. Thereafter, said order of injunction got vacated by an
order passed by a Division Bench of this court, which gives rise to the
instant prayer for amendment of the plaint, which the court below allowed
subject to payment of cost of Rs. 1000/-.
11.
In this context Mrs. Chakraborty on behalf of the OP further argued
that it is well settled that res judicata can apply in different stages of the
same proceeding but in order to attract such principle it is required that
there should be a conscious adjudication of such issue on merit. In the
present case the observation of the trial court in its order dated November,
17, 2016 was solely based on the written objection filed by the defendants in
connection with the injunction application and failure to file any document
by the plaintiff at that stage. Therefore, there was no adjudication on merit
regarding such issue at that stage. The scope of adjudication in an
injunction application is different from adjudication during trial of a suit.
This is because at the time of disposal of injunction application, the court is
only required to see whether there is a prima facie case to go on for trial and
does not hold a mini trial and for which any finding/observation made
therein cannot be said to be finally decided on merit, unless the court
specifically records so. The observation made in connection with the
injunction application are designated to preserve the status quo, pending
litigation and to ensure that the parties might not be prejudiced by the
normal delay occurred during trial before a court. As the observation made
therein does not decide the legal rights of the parties to the litigation nor
decide any matter in merits of the controversy, the principle of res judicata
does not apply to the findings on which these orders are based. Therefore by
no stretch of imagination it can be said that the proposed amendment is in
connection with the same relief which has been rejected earlier. In this
context she relied upon judgment of Erach Boman Khavar Vs. Tukaram
Shridhar Bhat and Ors. reported in AIR 2014 SC 544 (para 27& 34).
12.
She further argued that it is an admitted position that recording of
evidence has not been commenced in the suit and therefore, the embargo
created in the proviso to order VI rule 17 does not apply in the instant case.
At this stage the court is only required to consider, whether the proposed
amendment is required for proper adjudication of the lis between the
parties. The proposed amendment sought to be incorporated, if allowed will
not change the nature or the character of the suit but is essential for
complete and effective adjudication of dispute between the parties. She
further argued that while deciding an application for amendment, court
should not go into the merits of such amendment. The documents based on
which the proposed amendment is sought for have been produced by the OP
in their affidavit in opposition. In this Context she relied upon judgment of
Rajesh Kumar Aggarwal and others Vs. K.K. Modi and others reported
in (2006) 4 SCC 385 (para 19). Therefore she contended that the learned
Trial Judge was absolutely correct in passing the order impugned and
therefore the instant Revisional Application is liable to be dismissed with
cost.
13.
I have gone through the plaint filed by the plaintiff as well as the
proposed amendment. From the plaint it appears that plaintiff has
specifically averred that pursuant to the letter dated 19.12.1973 issued by
the then principal of Harrow Hall school addressed to the defendant, the
defendant by its letter dated 21.01.1974 granted permission to the plaintiff
society to use the said compound and or lawn for the children of the school.
It is further averred since the year 1974 when the permission as above has
been accorded to the said principal, the students of the plaintiff’s society
and the school have been using the said lawn. It is further stated that the
plaintiff/ school using and enjoying the said lawn as easement attached to
the said premises where the school situates by dint of the permission
accorded by the defendant no.1, Karnani Properties Ltd. Now by way of
amendment plaintiff sought to incorporate in para 6(a) and 6(b) that the
permission granted by the competent person in the year 1974 was extended
from time to time. In 6(b) they further sought to incorporate that since the
school and the students were facing difficulties in performing their physical
activities, the school again wrote a letter on 12.09.2000 addressed to the
defendant no.1 with a request to allow the school children to play in the said
lawn-cum-playground as usual and upon receiving the said letter dated
12.09.2000, one of the directors of the defendant no.1 by consent letter
dated 16.09.2000 again granted permission to use the said playground for
the purpose of physical activities of the school children during school hours
and they further sought to incorporate that the permission that was granted
in 1974 for the welfare and benefit of the students of the school was never
withdrawn and is still continuing.
14.
Therefore, the proposed amendment sought to be incorporated is
merely elaboration of plaint case as mentioned in para 4 onwards in the
plaint. It further appears that in the plaint the plaintiff has categorically
stated that the cause of action of the suit arose on or about March, 2014,
March 16, 2015 at said lawn and it is continuing day by day.
15.
Therefore, if the proposed amendment is allowed it would not make
out a new cause of action nor it would alter the existing cause of action. In
fact in the instant suit the plaintiff by way of proposed amendment has not
sought for any additional relief in the plaint. The suit remains as it was
before i.e. for a declaration that plaintiffs have the easement right to enjoy
and for injunction restraining defendants/petitioner from using the said
lawn by the plaintiff. The statement of the plaintiff that the permission
granted in 1974 was renewed in the year 2000 is required to be included in
the plaint to adjudicate the matter completely because this might have an
impact over the main relief sought for in the suit.
16.
In
Laxmidas
Dayabhai
Kabrawala
Vs.
Nanabhai
Chunilal
Kabarwala and others reported in AIR 1964 SC 11 the Apex Court
reiterates the view that it is no doubt true that save in exceptional cases
leave to amend under Order VI rule 17 of the Code will ordinarily be refused
where the effect of the amendment would be to take away from a party a
legal right which had accrued to him by lapse of time but this rule can apply
only when either fresh allegations are added or fresh reliefs are sought by
way of amendment. Here the amendment is sought, which merely clarifies
the existing pleading that the permission to use the lawn/play ground by
the plaintiff/school was never withdrawn and still continuing. The proposed
amendment does not in substance add to or alter it and therefore the
question as to what prevented the plaintiff in producing the said document
earlier is not material for adjudication of present Application.
17.
It further appears from the order impugned that when the amendment
petition was filed, the suit was posted for peremptory hearing though no
deposition was recorded. The supreme Court in Baldev Singh and others
Vs. Manohar Singh and another reported in (2006) 6 SCC 498 has made
it clear that commencement of trial as used in proviso to order VI rule 17 of
the Code must be understood in the limited sense as meaning the final
hearing of the suit, examination of witnesses, filing of documents and
addressing of arguments. Subsequently this High Court in the case of Shree
Shree Iswar Radha Bihari Jew and Shree Shree Iswar Salgram Jew
Vs. Malati P.Sony reported in AIR 2019 Cal 131 has made clear
observation that ordinarily the trial stage commences in a suit immediately
upon issues being determined. However, it is not immediately thereupon
that the trial in a suit commences in right earnest and the commencement
of the trial is only when any witness takes to the box whether to prove its
affidavit of evidence or to prove any documents to be tendered into evidence
or to face any cross examination, for it is at this stage that the court applies
its judicial mind to examine the evidence or to consider whether a particular
document is to be received in evidence or to consider the permissibility of
the question put in cross examination. In the instant case admittedly that
stage had not come when the prayer for amendment was made and therefore
the proviso to order VI rule 17 of CPC does not have any application in the
present context.
18.
Needless to reiterate that circumstances in which amendment of
pleading is not permissible has been well settled and it states that
amendment that would render suit infructuous or amendment that would
introduce a totally different, new and inconsistent case or challenges
fundamental character of the suit, the amendment should not be allowed.
(State of M.P. Vs. Union of India and another, reported in (2011) 12
SCC 268). It is equally well settled that the dominant purpose of allowing
the amendment is to minimize the litigation. Therefore, the plea that the
issue sought to be incorporated by way of amendment is whether barred by
res judicata is arguable at the appropriate stage of the hearing of the suit.
But I feel that in the circumstances of the case the plea of res judicata or
other issues being disputed question of fact could be made subject matter
while framing the issues, after allowing the amendment as sought for.
19.
Though learned counsel for the petitioner strenuously argued that
inspite of getting several opportunities the plaintiff did not produce any
evidence that the permission granted in favour of the plaintiff was
subsequently extended in the year 2000 and now by way of proposed
amendment at a belated stage, they sought to incorporate said document,
which cannot be allowed. Here I am of the view that even if such prayer has
been made at a belated stage then also the question that needs to be
considered is whether by allowing the amendment, the real controversy
between the parties may be resolved or not. A belated amendment prayer to
incorporate that the permission was renewed at a subsequent stage also,
cannot be refused in the present context, as it is found that for deciding the
real controversy between the parties and for doing full and complete justice
in the case, the proposed amendment is required to be allowed, on payment
of costs, as has been imposed by the court below.
20.
In this context it is also to be kept in mind that real controversy tests
is the basic and cardinal test. Therefore, whether the plaintiffs averment
made in the proposed amendment is correct or not and thereby whether
plaintiffs have acquired any right over the suit property by way of casement
or otherwise or not, cannot be considered at the stage of disposal of the
amendment application. On the contrary in cases like this, the court should
also take notice of all the relevant documents in order to shorten the
litigation and to preserve and safeguard the rights of the both the parties in
order of sub serve the ends of justice.
21.
Therefore I am of the view that the proposed amendment is liable to be
allowed and the defendant will have no cause to prejudice, if he is given
liberty to file additional written statement. The impugned order by which the
court below has allowed the prayer for amendment does not suffer from
perversity or impropriety nor court below has committed gross error while
allowing the prayer for amendment with cost and therefore the order
impugned does not call for interference.
22.
C.O. 3895 of 2024 thus stands dismissed. The plaintiff shall file
amended plaint along with cost awarded by the court below within a period
of three weeks from the date of communication of this order and the liberty
is also given to the defendant to file additional written statement if any,
within a period of three weeks thereafter.
Urgent photostat certified copy of this order, if applied for, be supplied to the
parties, on priority basis on compliance of all usual formalities.
(Dr. AJOY KUMAR MUKHERJEE, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review