Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
I3,189 I
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR TI{E STATE OF TELANGANA
AT
WEDNESDAY, THE.SEVENTH DAY OF JANUMY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE P.SAM KOSHY
AND
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE SUDOALA CHALAPATHI RAO
TAX REVIS
CASE Nos: 38.43
55 ot 2O11
Case No.38 of 201
Tax Revision Case under Section 22{1) (see rule of 40) of the APGST Act'
1957 to revise the order dated O2-12-2O1O passbd in T.A.No.204 d 2OO7 on the file
of the Sales Tax Appellate Tribunal, (STAT), Hyderabad.
M/s. K.Kantha Reddy & Co., PWD (R & B) Contractors 4-1-100, Attapur,
Bahadurpura, Hyderabad 5OO 264.
...AppellanUAppel{ant
AND
State of AP rep. by SR before STAT ll Floor, Commercial Taxes Complex
Nampally, Hyderabad.
...RespondenURespondent
Counsel for the Petitioner: Mr. S.R.R. Viswanath
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr. Swaroop Oorilla,
Special Government Pleader for State Tax
Tax Retision Case No-43 of 2O11
Tax Revision Case under Section 22(1) (see rule of 4O) of the APGST Act'
1957 to revise the order dald 20-C,r',-ZJ'10 passed in T.A.No.166 ot 2OO7 on the file
of the Sales Tax Appellate Tribunal, (STAT), Hyderabad.
Between:
M/s. K.Kantha Reddy & Co., PWD (R & B) Contractors 4-1-1OO' Attapur,
Bahadurpura, Hyderabad 5O0 264.
...AppellanUAppellant
AND
State of AP rep. by SR before STAT ll Flnor, Commercial Taxes Complex
...RespondenURespondent
Nampally, Hyderabad.
Counsel for the Petitioner: Mr. S.R.R. Viswanath
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr. Swaroop Oorilla,
Special Gdvernment pleader for State Tax
.t
No.
Tax Revision Case under Section 22(1) (see rule of 40) of the APGST Act,
1957 to revise the order dated o2-12-2o1o passed in T.A.No.740 of 2007 on the file
of the Sales Tax Appellate Tribunal, (STAI), Hyderabad.
M/s. K.Kantha Reddy & Co., PWD (R & B) Contractors 4-1-100, Attapur,
Bahadurpura, Hyderabad 500 264.
D
.AppellanUAppellant
9tate of l\P rep. by .SR before STAT ll Floor, Commercial Taxes Complex
Nampally, Hyderabad.
...RespondenURespond€nt
Counsel for tfie Petitioner: Mr. S.R:R. Viswanath
Counsel for t:he Respondent Mr. Swaroop Oorilla,
Special Government pleader for State Tax
The Court made the fotlowing: COMMON ORDER
i'i..
IN THE HIGH COI]RT FOR tHE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT YDERABAI)
j
ii
axo
THE, IIONOT'RABLE SRI.TUSTICE P.SAIVI KOSHY
i:
THE HONOT'RABLE SRI JUSTICE
SUDDALA CHALAPATHI RAO
,!
Dated: 0.7,01.2026
I
TREVC No.38 of 2011:
Between:
Co.
'
IWs.K.Kantha ReddY &
PWD (R&B) Contractors,
4-1-100, Attapur, BahadurPura, ,
Hyderabad - 500
,
:
264.
:
Petitioner
,
i
And
:
I
The State of Andhra Pradesh
Rep by SR before STAT,
II Floor, Commercial Taxes ComPlex,
.Respondent
COMNION OINDDY ber Hon'bte Sri lustice P'SAM KoSHYt:
,:
Heard Mr.s-R.R.Viswanath, learned counsel for the
petitioner and Mr.Swaroop Ooril'la, leamed Special Governrnent
,1
Pleader for State Tax in all the three Tax Revision Cases' Perused
the record.
':.2
l'"r
2' These are the three r*
petitioner assailing the
i':.
n"rririon cases fired by the same
r,i:
-;j
three orders passed uv fir"
t
T'A'No'204 of zoo. for the
hamed srAT in
*u"i**t year
' ,rnrr-rrdecided on
i:
-
- M IZS0J0++.ANo.740 of 20Ql:for tfe-assEsTment
:l' ji
decirled on 02. r2.zoto
year l99g:99
and T.A.No;.r66 of zool for
the assessmenr
, ;:
year 1999-2OOO decided on
questions of law contended
i
'.,'
substantial
by thq pedtioner in alt these three
Revision cases been identi"u
yearri and three independent
learned STAT, rhese three
zOrOq.2OlO. Since, the
J*""pt ro, tt
"
[r;;r,
Tax
assessrnenr
oiders having been passed by the
."uirioi petitions stands decided by this
comrnon order
3. The question of law to
facts and law upholding of
considerediwas wtrether on the
of turnover tax under Section
the
5-A of APGST Acr by the
is proper, Iegal and justified.
Today, when the maffer is
up for hearing, learned Special
Govemment pleader for
pnoduced before this Bench a
.t
Division Bench decision of this;:Courr
question of law involved
,'i
directly dealing with the
-t ':
in tne
itnstant Tax Revision Cases
.L
,ii
Special Appeal No.9 of 2004
i
wtribh stood decided b):tnE
:i,
!
::
: .i
.ir
i ii.
' :ii
,ii
'l'
iii
:l'
i:
i.e.,
Division
_
Benctr of this Court on 30.04.2015. The Division Borch dealing
with the statutory pmvision particularly Section 5-A of the APGST
Act answEred the question of law in favour of Revenue. While
dealing with the question, the Division Bench held as under:
7. (a) There is no dispute with ke faca, whic*
are narrated supra. The AC (nt) who had initially
made a provisianal assratsment had assessd the
assessee
for the year 1997-98 under the Act and hd
levied tumover tax under Section 5-A of the Act on rte
purchase htrnover of milk vtde his proceedings dated
26-06.1999. The aggrieved assess@ had preferred an
appeal before the ADC disputing that the turnover
sabjected to tax under Section 6-A is not tiable to
turnover tax under Section 5-A. The ADC had allowed
the appeal of the assessee upholding the said
contention of the assessee. The CTO had passed the.
consequential Jinal assessment orders of the assessee
following the orders of the ADC and had thus not
levied turnover tax on the purchase turnover of milk
Finding the said orders of the ADC and the
consequential final orders of the CTO prejudicial to
the interests of the revenue of the Snte, the
Commissioner having entertained a suo motu revision
had issued a show cause notice and an opportunity of
hearing and had finalty confirmed the proSal fn the
.chow cause notice and had auordingly set aside the
,ord*s of the ADC and revtsd theJinal ansquential
asiesisment ordeis of tie CfO 7o, the year lggT-ga
under the Act and had levied turaover tax at the rate of
l% on purchase turnover of milk i.e.,
Rs.15,84,00,140/-. Ihus, the Commissioner had
rearded a finding that turnover tax under Section 5-A
is leviable and payable on taxable filmover under the
charging Section 6A.
7. (b) lYe have given earnest consideration to
the facx and the submissions. In view of the
fac* and
the contentions, it is necessary ta refer to infra, the
provisions of law namely Sections 6A and 5A of the Act
dealing respectively with leuy of tax on turnover
relating to purchases of certain goods and l"uy of
turnover tax.
6A Leuy of tax on turnover relating to purchase
of certain goods:
Every dealer, who in the course ofbusiness:
i. purchases any goods (the sale or purchase of
which is liable to tax under this Ac| from a registered
dealer in circutnstances in which no tax is payable
under Section 5 or under Section 6, as the case may be,
or
ii- Purchases any goods (rte sale or purdtase of
which is liable n ux under this Aa) fun a Person
orter than a registerd detler;-snd
c. @nsum6 such goods in any manufrcure of
other goods for sale or consumes them otherwise, or;
a- disposes of such goods in the manner other
than by way ofsale in the State, or
b. despatches them to a pl.ace outside the Sute
except as a direct result of sale or purchase in the
course of inter-State trade or commerce, shall pay nx
on the turnover relating to purchase aforesaid at the
same rate at which but for the existence of the
aforementioned circamstances, the tax wouW have
been leviable (on such goods under Section 5 or
Section 6.
5-A Leuy of nx on tur over: (l) Notwith*anding
anything contained in this Act, tax shall be levied at
the rate of [one paise in every rupee ofa turnover ofa
duler, other than the dealers mentiond in sub-sqtion
(I-A)J whose total turnovq in a year exceeds ntpees
ten lakhs;
Providd that the tax shall not be levid under
this section on that part of the turnover of any dealer
on which the dealer is liable to Pay tax at the point of
lery tspeAlied in the First Schedule, acept petrol,
dicsel oil, aviation turbine fuel, engine oils, lubri@ting
r7\
oils, greases bratre Jruids,
furnace otr and ail kinds of
motor vehiclesJ Second Schedule, Fifth
Schedule and
Seventh Schedule to the Act:
Provided further that no tax under thts
shall be payable on that part of turnover
section
which relatq
to;
i. sale or purchase of goods specified in third
Schedule;
it. sale or purchase of gotods
specified in Fourth
Schedule;
iii. sale or purchase of goods specified in Sixth
Schedule;
iv. sale or purchase of goods in the course
of
inter-State trade or commerce;
v. sole or purchase of goods in the course
export out of the territory of India or sa.le
of
or purchase
in the course of tmport into the territory oflndia;
vi. sale or purchase of goods exempt
gmerally under sub-section (I) of section
from tax
9 of the satd
Act;
vii- ail amounts corected-b1tw-ayof tcix
provisions of the Central Sales Tax Act,
underthe
tg\6.
The turnover of the present assessee
Rs.l0 lakhs during the subject year is not
exceeded
in dtspute.
section 5A' which storts wtth a non-abstante
clearly says that tav shall be levied at the
\
\
crantse,
rote of loh in
\
every rury of a turnover of a dealer orter thur the
dealers mentioned in sub-sution l'A whose nnl
turnover in theyear exceeds Rs-10 taklts' Iltus' futton
5A specificatly mentions the turnovers which are not
liable n tux and in that turrpvers mentioned therein'
the transactions under Section 6A are not specifically
mentiond. Further' the purchase of mtlk from
unregistered dellers dles wt come under the points of
is also
leuy mentioned in the provision of low'
It
pertinent to note that by an amendment to Section 6A
the words 'or Section 5A' were omitted from Sution
6A by Act 22 of 1995 with efea fron 0I'04'1995'
Therefore, on a plain and harmonious reading ofboth
the proisions, it appears that there is no prohibition
the
from leuying turnover tax under Section 5A on
transactions covered by Sqtion 6A. Since the purchase
turnover which is disputd turnover relatd n
purchase of nitk made from unregisterd dealers' the
same is not eltgible for uemption as no exemption was
granted by the Govemment under Section 9(l) of the
Act in respect of such turt overs- It is not in disputc that
leuy of tax under Section 9(I) on sale of fresh milh
curd and butter milk sold by the dealers exclusively
dealing in them and also their products are uentPt
from tax. Therefore, on a plain consideration of
the
provisions of law, we are ol the considered view that
the orders of the Cbmmissioner
tne
leuytng tu of Ig4 on
$lgyg! _t_yru_ouer tnvolvgt! _in _fke ruafier_ on .-a_
finding that turnover tax under Sectton 5A. is
on taxable turnover under charging
correct. Potnt is accordingly
also considered and reried
finding of the Division
from the two decisions which were
upon by the Tribunal while dearing
the appeals, where under the Tribunal
judgrnents of this High
Section 6A js
answerd.
4- Further it is refleted that the
Benc.h stands further fortified
payable
with
has reproduced the
court in, the case of rw/s.spectro Bouring
coru'oany Limited, Mourari
Pradeshtand arso ws-Nauyuga
& others u state of Andhra
Engineering company Limited
state of Andhra pradesh2 wherein
up ftrr consideration and High
turnover leviable under section
again similar issues were taken
court has categorica,y held the
5-A of the APGST Act. It would
relev.nt at this juncture to reproduce
Tribunal's order with regard to
u
be
the rerevant portion of the
these two aforesaid judgments
concerned:
I tzoocl 38 ApsrJ 6
'1zooty45 ApsrJ pag
\
are
:rDl D oaln! ol Papafqns aq Pu pfoqs auos a,fl
nt p ua1 alsDq o? yalca[qns s! raAou,n, aqt araqn
s! xq ra^ount ary to a1mollor aqt Pt1l (!!)
:sD^ouJnl qcns uo alqD! al
s! xtl .o ouru ou 'm, pata[ns spoo8 gg uolroas PUD
flg uopcas "DPun \floq aculs Puo r0o1to tulod o11toa
tfuo to xtt paasns 4ou sDrl qztqtt't ralourt'l atltto Ttod
tDW uo Quo a1qo1,o1 s, ml ta^ou)nt lo,tl (l)
:?aPuaruoc sot^ 7t's1uo11addo ary lo t1oqaq
uO 'uoaoraplsuoc n! dn auo) saq gS uolQas puD
gg uollrllas Dpun xDt o7 pa\ca[qns sratourn, aqt uo
salyoqtno puolswy/saltttoqlno Sulssassv a4l ,(q xol
ntounl lo thal aq, 'qoaddo to qqDq slttt uI
'd9 wD
gg suolcas u1 patolndl1s sta ou)n! aqt ub apo1rc1 s1
n)t JiriouJry 'antataql 'suolsqcra aql u! PqDraunua
uaaq ,ou
"
oq 19 Puo gs uoltzas 'soslaotd
arlt u! ,no qads tQ\ocyo*a\o" a D'l sl,/o!s?ll!cx,' Dq,o
lll WD ralourrt, a1qoa&mtlc atq to uoltofidwoc tot
rapl,to,td oqD flq aSnqc aql satDarz tluo lou t1c14ttt
uolps &u1fuoqc patot&atut uo s! YS uolrns,
:saqlot
so Wq
W p rasqo g tJSdY 8E (t00d u1 paltodat
ttraryd ottlpuyto entg 'A eaqlo T 1PPoN 'PaUu!7
tuodtttoS t41nog o4tads's/n u! Punq14 s'W
v
i
\)
uolrcas {o.uoltDtatdra?u, tol g
sD m, fo apt lrs-Dq puo ha1
aqt Uodul ot t"artoc
uo11c)g u1 patoslaua
lo 7u1od lo tdaaua
tou atolatarll n ry .p?ag[ pauhlsso
q u1 to\d pnl uortcas olo yod Buucoua aql
os asnDlo aluolsqo_uou
aalg o7 so
lo uolt"nporru, ,tq fio pauon
uaag sDl auos aq, ,raqtouo tltltt
Suolrcas asaq|
to sl.tod Sutcoua aql aaaa4J"q plbfuoc
s! ararfi .ta^oraq puo atn|op&zT
lo tuo
,uatoddo awos
atg t(g paToaullap
so sp|agftuata[tp q arD]?do
lg puo gg ,yg ,g uoucaS
'ttod Suncoua
lo uoltotado aqt uto{ suol1dacra fio
Salatoc suqslaotd uolto1ndwoc so
aq, Woq not stt a!.filttl szlot
apoc a|aldutoc D s! t! lDW
lla.A so BwL.totlc
,! sollcnu so u1fiasg u1
raMasqo puo lg puo gg ,ys
'S uoltcas Sutztotlc atll pazeouo
uolrcas ut p|o1dua|uoc )aloutn,
s! xDl ra^outt4 atotataql puD yS
lDunqyJ a%[
ds PUD gs
ary uo a1qoalnqc
uogcag lo uolgotado
arfl wott woucas ayarfi pa?nqco {isnoosuoc
tou sDq arryqqtql aqt puo
looq afipts
u!-a.bq,
"rl,
tryaqD 2ra04 ls puD gg aolpas ,uolrcnpo4u,
sl,
aup
aq,
pao
lo
,o
apoc faulntuoc
o s1
yS aolroas
1[7as
lor0 faPualuor satt4 t!
,anua^ay
at17lofioqaq ug
.tcy
"loqtrr
aq| to daaas n41c
o a^Drt touuac ,, atotataql puD ary)aio
1! ,12!qt^ uoltcas .m\nc1yod rfuo ol olat
-S uogras u! asnop aruotDqD_uou atfi
\-'l
OI
o, spualal
,oq saop y
Dql 6!l)
5E and 5F which are indeperdent charging sections.
Sntion 5 spealrs about leuy of tax on sale or purchase
ofgoods", wheieas Sectioi 5A speala about "leuy of
tax on htmover". The field of operation of both
srctions is diferent and it is not correct a hod rtat
where basic tax is levied under Section 5 there could
be no leuy of turnover tax as a general proposition
applicable to all transactions. Since the turnover
contemplated by Sution SE and 5F are special class
by themselves, the concept of basic leuy on sale or
purchase as per Schdules under Sution 5 cannot be
imported and applied for levy of fiirnover tali on these
lurnovers under Section 5A except those indicated in
the first proviso for the scheduled goods. Accordingly
held:
"There is nothing in Section 5A to remotely
indicate or even suggest that the charging section 54,
although all other exclusions have categoricaAy spelt
out in the provisos- On the fact of the clear langmge
of Section 5A, it is not permissible to excfude the
turnover pertaining to lease rental and worlcs
antractfrom the purview of TOT by any implication
or presumption".
Dealtng with tle non-abstante clause in
Section 5A, the Tribunal held that although Section
5A star* with a non-abstante clause, it was engrafted
in the section by the legislature as a measure of
abundant precaution so as to avoid any conJlict which
may ensue while giving efect n the provistons of
enacting part ofSection 54.
L?
r)
.. The sanc view was expressd by this Tribunaf
in Ws Nawyuga Engineering Crglt_tpany Limited
State ol Andhra pradqh reported in
V*
e007) 45
APSTI page I, which was affirmed by the Htgh
Court
of Atdhra Pradesh, wherein the High Court of
Andhra Pradesh hetd asfollows:
t|ft" Division Bench endorsed the decision
of
.
_
the tulq TaxAppettate
Tribunal that Sectioi-S)-i o,
integrated charying section, untaining
ade whic*
not onb creot* the charge but also- provides
for
'the
comtrrutation of the chargeable turniver
for
p:rl:t"
iuThe
turnovers
peraining
to
W.are also
-{ and 5F
Section 5E
exigible ti the saita*.
5A_x specifrcitty **ot 1or--to,y o7
f:,!h:J,.Sectbn
ror urat came on Stante later than Section 5E and
SF which were already in the statute Ooo,t.
f,ni ,oia
Plluision reflects the latest will of l*gislature to leuy
TOT even on turnovers under Seition'SE oni
si".5. The aforesaid judicial precedents of
same question of law has not been disputed
this Court on the very
by the teamed counsel
for the petitioner and he fairly concedes to the
fact that the
aforesaid judgments squarely answers the questions
of raw raised
by the petitioner in these three Tax Revision
Cases as well.
6. For the aforesaid rcasons, we do not find
present Tax Revision Cases filed
by the petitioner. The questions of
Iaw as has been decided by the judicial
\
\
any merits in the
precedents stands answered
in favourof revenue holding that the tur-novertax would be leviable
on thecharges in terms of Section 5(0 as well.
7. Accordingly, these Tax Revisions Cases stand dismissed.
There shall be no order as to costs.
Consequently, miscellaneous petitions pending, if any; shalt
stand closed.
-+/
SD/. K. SRINIVASA RAO
JOINT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
To,
SECTION OFFICER
1. The Sales Tax Appellate Tribunal, ( STAT), Hyderabad
2. One CC to Mr S.R.R. Viswanath, Advocate
[OP UC]
3. Two CCs to G P FOR STATE TAX, High Court
for the State
I
I
of Telangana at
HIGH COURT
DATED:07101t2O26
Ti"rE s
Y
o
()
COMMON ORDER
TREVC.Nos.38, 43 and 55 of 2011
@
I rt8
*
.5 ,oArc
DISMISSING THE TAX REVISION CASES
h
2S1$
*
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review