Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:MHC:520
W.P.Nos.29468 of 2018 and 21613 of 2019
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
Orders reserved on : 20.01.2026
Orders pronounced on : 10.02.2026
CORAM :
THE HON’BLE MR.JUSTICE D.BHARATHA CHAKRAVARTHY
W.P.Nos.29468 of 2018 and 21613 of 2019
and W.M.P.Nos.34434 of 2018 and 20833 of 2019
In W.P.No.29468 of 2018:M/s.Jyothy Laboratories Limited
Represented by its Chairman-cum-Managing Director,
Ujala House, Ram Krishna Mandir Road,
Kondivita, Andheri (East),
Mumbai, India – 400 059.
.. Petitioner
Versus
1. R.Rajendiran
2. S.Devarajalu
3. V.Gurukumar
4. G.Agoramurthy
5.V.Jaganathan
6. S.Sarathirajan
.. Respondents
In W.P.No.21613 of 2019:M/s.Jyothy Laboratories Limited
Represented by its Chairman-cum-Managing Director,
Ujala House, Ram Krishna Mandir Road,
Kondivita, Andheri (East),
Mumbai, India – 400 059.
.. Petitioner
Versus
1/15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.29468 of 2018 and 21613 of 2019
1. Henkel India Limited
Rep. By its Factory Manager (Finance),
No.131, Peralam Main Road,
Thirunallar, Karaikal – 609 607,
Puducherry Union Territory.
2. T.Murugan
.. Respondents
Prayer in W.P.No.29468 of 2018 : Writ Petition filed under Article 226
of the Constitution of India seeking a Writ of Certiorari, to call for the
records connected with C.P.No.71 of 2003 on the file of the Industrial
Tribunal-cum-Labour Court, Puducherry and to quash the order, dated
20.03.2018.
Prayer in W.P.No.21613 of 2019 : Writ Petition filed under Article 226
of the Constitution of India seeking a Writ of Certiorari, to call for the
records connected with C.P.No.105 of 2014 on the file of the Industrial
Tribunal-cum-Labour Court, Puducherry and quash the order, dated
13.03.2019.
2/15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
For Petitioner
(in both the cases)
: Mr.S.Ravindran, Senior Counsel,
Asstd. by Mr.P.John Zachariah
For Respondents
(in both the cases)
: Mr.P.R.Thiruneelakandan,
W.P.Nos.29468 of 2018 and 21613 of 2019
ORDER
These two Writ Petitions are filed by the management, Jyothy
Laboratories Limited, the second respondent before the Labour Court,
challenging the award of the Industrial Tribunal-cum-Labour Court,
Puducherry, made in C.P.No.71 of 2013, dated 20.03.2018, and
C.P.No.105 of 2014, dated 13.03.2019. In this judgment, the petitioner,
Jyothy Laboratories Limited, is referred to as JLL. The first respondent
before the Labour Court, i.e., the first respondent in W.P.No.21613 of
2019, Henkel India Limited, will be referred to as Henkel.
The six
workmen, R.Rajendiran, S.Devarajalu, V.Gurukumar, G.Agoramurthy,
V.Jaganathan and S.Sarathirajan, who filed C.P.No.71 of 2013, and
respondents 1 to 6 in W.P.No.29468 of 2018, shall be referred to as
workmen Nos.1 to 6, respectively. T.Murugan, petitioner in C.P.No.105 of
2014 and second respondent in W.P.No.21613 of 2019, is referred to as
workman No.7.
2. Workmen Nos.1 to 6 jointly filed C.P.No.71 of 2013, praying
for computation of severance compensation and terminal benefits as per
the settlement under Section 18(1) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947,
dated 28.07.2012, which was converted into a settlement under Section
3/15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.29468 of 2018 and 21613 of 2019
12(3), dated 10.08.2012, and for directing the respondents, namely Henkel
India Limited and Jyothy Laboratories Limited, to pay the amounts prayed
for in respect of each of the petitioners. Workman No.7 filed C.P.No.105
of 2014 with the same prayer.
3. The case of the workmen is that they were appointed in
various categories which fell within the definition of workmen during the
year 1991-92 or thereafter, with Henkel at its Karaikal factory, and had
been in regular service for about 20 years.
Henkel, a multinational
company, sold its assets, including the Karaikal factory, to JLL in the year
2011. However, JLL did not agree to any tripartite settlement, and after
some litigation, Henkel entered into a settlement under Section 18(1) of the
Act, which was later converted into a 12(3) settlement, under which it paid
severance compensation to all the employees at the rate of 90 days' wages
per year of service.
4. Workmen No.1 to 5 were denied the benefit on the ground
that they had already submitted their resignations and were not in service
as on the date of the settlement. Workman No.6 was denied the benefit on
the ground that he failed to sign the settlement.
4/15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Even though the
W.P.Nos.29468 of 2018 and 21613 of 2019
management obtained a signature on blank paper for settling the benefits to
workman No.7, no benefits were settled on him. Hence the Computation
Petitions.
5. JLL resisted the Claim Petition. All the shares of Henkel were
transferred to JLL. Thereafter, Henkel was also amalgamated with JLL.
The Karaikal factory was incurring losses due to the non-cooperative
attitude of the employees. Therefore, steps were taken to revive the unit.
A settlement was given to the employees in the year 2012, initially under
Section 18(1) of the Act, which was later converted to a settlement under
Section 12(3) of the Act. Workmen Nos.1 to 5 had resigned prior to this
and were also paid gratuity on their resignation. They were also working
in managerial positions and are not workmen within the definition of the
Industrial Disputes Act, 1947. Workman No.6 did not sign the settlement
and had abandoned the job, and it was suspected that he had gone abroad
for work. Workman No.7 was unauthorisedly absent. When a show-cause
notice was issued to him on 13.07.2011, he voluntarily resigned on
19.07.2011 and joined work elsewhere. He is also suspected to have left
for abroad. He was also not a party to the settlement.
5/15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.29468 of 2018 and 21613 of 2019
6. In C.P.No.71 of 2013, workmen Nos.1 and 3 were examined
as P.W.1 and P.W.2, and Ex.P-1 to Ex.P-43 were marked. One Babu
Chowallor was examined as R.W.1, and Ex.R-1 to Ex.R-23 were marked.
In C.P.No.105 of 2014, M.Jayabharathi, the Power Agent of the workman
No.7 was examined as P.W.1, and Ex.P-1 to Ex.P-35 were marked. Babu
Chowallor was examined as R.W.1, and Ex.R-1 to Ex.R-8 were marked.
7. The Labour Court found that, from the pleadings and
evidence, the workmen had joined Henkel and had rendered about 20 years
of service, as proved. It further found from the very promotion orders that
despite the terminology such as Manager, they performed the same job and
as such, the management had failed to prove that they were not workmen.
It was further found that workmen Nos.1 and 2 had prayed to consider
their long service of 20 years and 19 ½ years and to relieve them in their
resignation letters.
Workmen Nos.3, 4 and 5 prayed for severance
compensation. Workman No.6 was given notice for his absence when
settlement under Section 12(3) settlement was entered on 09.05.2011,
under Section 18(1) on 28.07.2012 and under Section 12(3) on 10.08.2012.
As a matter of fact, the management had sent cheques for settlement,
which the workmen had returned seeking re-employment. It was further
6/15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.29468 of 2018 and 21613 of 2019
found that as per the settlement under Section 12(3) entered pursuant to an
appeal before the Deputy Commissioner of Labour, the management had
agreed to pay 90 days’ wages for every year of completed service as
severance compensation. From the management's evidence, it was found
that the workmen did not receive any severance compensation. In the
resignation letters, they had prayed for severance compensation.
The
management had not let any evidence that it had accepted the resignation.
The case of the workmen is that they submitted those letters on the
promise of severance compensation. Workman No.6 was not terminated
and he is also entitled to the same.
Accordingly, the Labour Court
computed the sum payable to workman No.1 as Rs.17,60,560/-, workman
No.2 as Rs.17,60,560/-, workman No.3 as Rs.16,72,532/-, workman No.4
as Rs.17,60,560/-, workman No.5 as Rs.17,60,560/- and workmen No.6 as
Rs.4,40,140/-. In respect of workman No.7 also, it was found that he had
submitted registration only on the announcement of compensation, and
Rs.19,84,168/- was computed in his case.
8. Mr.S.Ravindran, the learned Senior Counsel for JLL, would
submit that he is not raising the point as to whether these seven employees
are workmen or not. Assuming they are workmen, it requires findings of
7/15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.29468 of 2018 and 21613 of 2019
fact as to whether they have resigned or not and whether they were on the
rolls of JLL or not, and this cannot be done in a Computation Petition. The
workmen ought to have raised an Industrial Dispute. There is no question
of pre-existing liability. Further, the applicability of the settlement is also
a disputed question of fact and law, which cannot be gone into in the
Computation Petition. Even in respect of workmen Nos.6 and 7, they had
voluntarily abandoned service, and in fact, for workman No.7, even the
Computation Petition was conducted by his wife as the Power Agent, as he
was abroad.
9. The learned Senior Counsel, would rely upon the judgment of
the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in Vijay Kumar and Ors. Vs.
Whirpool of India Ltd., and Ors.1, more specifically relying upon
paragraph Nos.6, 7 and 14 to press home the distinction between what is
considered fair and what is considered a pre-existing right, and to submit
that only matters relating to pre-existing right fell within Section 33C(2) of
the Act.
10. Opposing the above, Mr.P.R.Thiruneelakandan, learned
(2008) 1 SCC 119
8/15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.29468 of 2018 and 21613 of 2019
Counsel for the workmen, would submit that when there is a settlement
under Section 12(3) of the Act, it applies to all the workmen irrespective of
whether they sign or not, and would rely upon the judgment of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court of India in P.Virudhachalam and Ors. Vs. Management
of Louts Mills and Anr.2, more specifically relying upon paragraph No.11.
The claim was for a pre-existing right under the 12(3) settlement, where
the benefit to the workmen, that is, 90 days’ wages per completed year of
service, had already fructified and whether the settlement is applicable to
the workmen is only an incidental question which can be gone into in the
computation proceedings. It need not be confined to admitted claims
alone. He would place reliance on the judgment of the Constitution Bench
of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in the Central Bank of India Ltd.
Vs. P.S.Rajagopalan etc.3, more specifically relying upon paragraph
Nos.16 and 17.
11. Upon considering the rival submissions, the first question in
the instant case is whether the factors to be determined in the instant case
fall beyond the remit of Section 33C(2) of the Act/computational
jurisdiction.
In this case, the primary and substantial claim of the
CDJ 1997 SC 745
AIR 1964 SC 743
9/15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.29468 of 2018 and 21613 of 2019
workman is 90 days’ wages per completed year of service as severance
compensation. It is not for determination how many days a year can be
granted as compensation, or whether the workman’s claim is fair or not.
On the other hand, it is claimed as pre-existing, having crystallised in the
form of a 12(3) Settlement. Whether the employees are workmen or not,
and whether the 12(3) is applicable to them, are only incidental questions.
In paragraph No.16 of the judgment of Central Bank of India Ltd. (cited
supra), the Hon’ble Supreme Court held as follows:
“16. ….. The Clause “Where any workman is
entitled to receive from the employer any benefit” does
not mean “where such workman is admittedly, or
admitted to be, entitled to receive such benefit”. The
appellant’s construction would necessarily introduce the
addition of the words “admittedly, or admitted to be” in
that clause, and that clearly is not permissible. Besides, it
seems to us that if the appellant’s construction is
accepted, it would necessarily mean that it would be at
the option of the employer to allow the workman to avail
himself of the remedy provided by sub-s. (2), because he
has merely to raise an objection on the ground that the
right claimed by the workman is not admitted to oust the
jurisdiction of the Labour Court to entertain the
workman’s application. The claim under Section 33C(2)
clearly postulates that the determination of the question
about computing the benefit in terms of money may, in
some cases, have to be preceded by an enquiry into the
existence of the right and such an enquiry must be held to
be incidental to the main determination which has been
assigned to the Labour Court by sub-sec. (2). As
Maxwell has observd “where an Act confers a
jurisdiction, it impliedly also grants the powers of doing
all such acts, or employing such means, as are essentially
necessary to its execution”. We must accordingly hold
that S. 33C92) takes within its purview cases of workmen
10/15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.29468 of 2018 and 21613 of 2019
who claimed that the benefit to which they are entitled
should be computed in terms of money, even though the
right to the benefit on which their claim is basesd is
disputed by their employers.”
12. Following excerpts from paragraph No.17 of the said
judgment is to be adverted to :“17. …. Therefore, we feel no difficulty in
holding that for the purpose of making the necessary
determination under S. 33C(2), it would, in appropriate
cases, be open to the Labour Court to interpret the award
or settlement on which the workman’s right rests”.
13. Thus, the law laid down by the Constitution Bench clearly
explains the position that merely because the Labour Court decided
whether the settlement created rights for the workmen and whether the
workmen were entitled to the benefit, it did not travel beyond its
jurisdiction. In the conspectus of facts, it was within its jurisdiction to
decide the same.
14. The second question that arises is whether the resignation
disentitles the workmen to the benefit under the settlement. I am unable to
agree with the learned Senior counsel for the Management for the
following reasons:
(a) Even before this Court, no answer was forthcoming from the
11/15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.29468 of 2018 and 21613 of 2019
management as to whether the relieving orders were issued after duly
accepting the resignation, though a mere endorsement in some of the
letters is relied upon. The Labour Court’s finding is after due appreciation
of the evidence.
(b) On reading the resignation letters, they cannot be treated as
resignation letters, as they pray for severance compensation. A useful
reference in this regard is made to the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court of India in Shashikala Devi Vs. Central Bank of India and Ors.4.
(c) The management themselves treated the settlement as
applicable to all the workmen and sent them the cheques for severance
compensation, and it was the fault of the workmen for not accepting the
same at the relevant point in time.
As such, I hold that the alleged resignations will not disentitle
workmen Nos.1 to 5 from the benefit. As rightly pointed out by the
Labour Court, workmen Nos.6 and 7 were not terminated and were on the
rolls, and as such would be entitled to the benefit.
15. The third question that arises is whether the 12(3) settlement
benefits can be denied merely because these workmen were not parties to
(2014) 16 SCC 260
12/15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.29468 of 2018 and 21613 of 2019
the settlement. Firstly, it can be seen that it is not even the case of the
management that the settlement benefits cannot be extended to nonsignatories. As a matter of fact, it was their contention before the Labour
Court that the workmen were not on rolls as on the date of the settlement.
Once it is found that the finding of the Labour Court that there was no
evidence as to the acceptance of resignation in respect of workmen Nos.1
to 5 and there was no termination or punishment order that was passed
with reference to the workmen Nos.6 and 7, they remained on rolls, there
cannot be any difficulty in holding that the benefits of settlement would
also applied to them. Useful reference in this regard can be made to the
judgments of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in Barauni Refinery
Pragatisheel Shramik Parishad Vs. Indian Oil Corporation Ltd. 5,
P.Virudhachalam Vs. Lotus Mills6. As a matter of fact, in the judgment
of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in Punjab National Bank and Ors.
Vs. Manjeet Singh and Anr.7, it was held to be an obligation on the part of
the management to implement the settlement. In view thereof, the said
question is also to be answered in favour of the workmen.
(1991) 1 SCC 4
(1998) 1 SCC 650
(2006) 8 SCC 647
13/15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.29468 of 2018 and 21613 of 2019
16. Accordingly, these Writ Petitions fail and are dismissed.
There shall be no order as to costs.
Consequently, connected
miscellaneous petitions are closed.
10.02.2026
grs
14/15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
: yes
W.P.Nos.29468 of 2018 and 21613 of 2019
D.BHARATHA CHAKRAVARTHY, J.
grs
W.P.Nos.29468 of 2018 and 21613 of 2019
and W.M.P.Nos.34434 of 2018 and 20833 of 2019
10.02.2026
15/15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review