Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
WP(C) No. 1635/2023
CM No. 3845/2023
Reserved on: 10.08.2026
Pronounced on: 14.08.2026
Uploaded on: 14.08.2026
Whether the operative part or full judgment
is pronounced: Full judgment.
M/s Jai Laxmi Road Builders, NH1, Raya Morh Samba Through its
Proprietor Sh. Atul Sharma S/o Sh.
Parladh Kumar Sharma R/o NH-1A,
Raya Morh, Patti District Samba.
…..Appellant(s)/Petitioner(s)
Through: Mr. R. K. Gupta, Sr. Advocate with
Mr. Udhay Bhaskar, Advocate
1.
2.
3.
4.
Vs
Union Territory of J&K
Through Commissioner Secretary
Public
Works
(R&B),
Department, Civil Secretariat,
Jammu.
Chief Engineer, Public Works
(R&B), Department, Jammu.
Superintendent Engineer, PWD
(R&B), Jammu-Kathua Circle,
Jammu.
Executive Engineer Public
Works Department (R&B),
Division-Samba
.…. Respondent(s)
Through: Mr. Ravinder Gupta, AAG with
Ms. Pallavi Sharma, Advocate
Coram: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJNESH OSWAL, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1.
The petitioner was allotted the contract for up-gradation of road surface by
way of P/L Wet Mix Macadam and 30 mm thick SDBC on link road GhoBrahmana to Kothey Pathania by the Executive Engineer PWD (R&B)
Division, Samba vide communication dated 07.11.2019 for an amount of
WP(C) No. 1635/2023
Rs. 21,17,000/-, pursuant to which, an agreement dated 13.12.2019 also
came to be executed between the employer and the petitioner. The
petitioner claims to have commenced the work on 12.11.2019/14.11.2019
and completed the work within stipulated period i.e. 13.12.2019 to the
entire satisfaction of the department. After completion of the contract, two
payments were made to the petitioner viz CC-1st for an amount of Rs.
6,50,000/- on 14.01.2020 and CC-2nd for an amount of Rs. 8,00,000/- on
30.03.2020. It is stated that CC-2nd was prepared by the department itself
for an amount of Rs. 16,21,000/- in the month of March, 2020, out of
which, Rs. 8,00,000/- only was paid to the petitioner but the rest of the
payment could not be released on account of paucity of funds. It is further
stated that the petitioner made numerous representations to the respondents
for release of the admitted outstanding balance amount of Rs. 8,21,000/-. It
is further stated that, vide communication dated 28.01.2023, the office of
the Chief Engineer, PWD (R&B) Department, proposed to convene a
meeting for the purpose of settling the issues relating to clearance of the
liability towards the work executed and, accordingly, requested respondent
Nos. 3 and 4, as well as the representative of the petitioner-firm, to attend
the said meeting. When, despite the aforesaid meeting, no amount was
released in favour of the petitioner, the petitioner submitted several
representations to the respondents, but to no avail. Consequently, the
petitioner filed the present petition seeking a direction to the respondents to
release the admitted outstanding liability of Rs. 8,21,000/- in its favour,
along with interest @ 18% per annum from the date the said amount
became due, i.e., March 2020, till the date of its actual payment.
WP(C) No. 1635/2023
2.
The respondents have filed response, stating therein that there is no
administrative approval for the excess work allegedly executed by the
petitioner and the writ petition suffers from the vice of delay and laches as
the same was filed on 14.06.2023, whereas the amount became due only on
13.12.2019. It is admitted by the respondents that the allotment order has
been issued to the petitioner for an amount of Rs. 21,17,000/- only. It is
contended that the petitioner, however, executed work in excess of the
allotted amount without obtaining the requisite approval from the
competent authority.
3.
Mr. R. K. Gupta, learned Senior counsel for the petitioner has drawn the
attention of this Court towards Clause 8 of the allotment letter dated
07.11.2019, which provides that any item found necessary during the
execution shall be paid on SSR-2012 with overall appreciation/depreciation
of allotment of the contract. He has further argued that despite numerous
representations, the amount was not released in favour of the petitioner, and
the petition does not suffer from the vice of delay and laches because in
terms of communication dated 28.01.2023, the Chief Engineer concerned
convened a meeting for the purpose of issues of clearance of work done
liability. He has placed reliance upon the judgment rendered by the Hon‟ble
Supreme Court of India in case titled, ‘M/s Surya Constructions vs. State
of Uttar Pradesh & Ors.’ reported in (2019) 16 SCC 794 and the
judgments passed by the Division Bench of this Court in case titled, ‘Union
Territory of J&K and ors’ vs. Sanjeev Kumar’ as well as this court in
‘Rattan Singh Parmar vs. Union Territory of Jammu & Kashmir and
WP(C) No. 1635/2023
ors.’ and ‘M/s Cube Construction Engineering vs. UT of J&K and
ors.’.
4.
Mr. Ravinder Gupta, learned AAG claims that the present petition is
hopelessly time barred. He further submitted that there exists an Arbitration
clause, therefore, the writ petition cannot be entertained and further that
excess work for an amount of Rs. 1,54,000/- was executed without approval
from the competent authority. He has placed reliance upon the judgments of
the Hon‟ble Supreme Court of India in cases titled, ‘The National Textile
Corporation Ltd. vs. Nareshkumar Badrikumar Jagad & Ors.’ 2012
AIR (SC) 264, ‘Kerala State Electricity Board vs. Kurien E. Kalathil’,
2000(6) SCC 293, ‘Joshi Technologies International Inc. Vs. Union of
India and ors.’ 2015 (7) SCC 728, ‘State of M.P. vs. Bhailal Bhai’, 1964
AIR (Supreme Court) 1006 and the judgments passed by the Coordinate
Bench of Sringar Wing of this Court in WP(C) No. 2179/2022, titled,
‘Zaman Construction Company vs. Union Territory of J&K and ors.’
and in WP(C) No. 553/2023, titled, ‘Abdul Majid Bhat vs. Government
of J&K and ors.’
5.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
6.
Although no objection with regard to the entertainability of the writ petition
on the ground of availability of an alternative remedy of arbitration has
been raised in the response, learned counsel for the respondents has sought
to raise the said objection only during the course of arguments.
7.
Hon‟ble the Supreme Court of India in case titled, ‘Uttar Pradesh Power
Transmission Corporation Ltd. and anr. Vs. CG Power and Industrial
Solutions Limited and anr.’ reported in AIR ONLINE 2021 SC 243 has
WP(C) No. 1635/2023
held that the presence of an Arbitration Clause within a contract between
the State and Instrumentality and a private party is not an absolute bar for
entertaining the writ petition. Therefore, there is no force in this contention,
as such, the same is rejected.
8.
The next contention of the respondent is that the writ petition is hopelessly
time barred as the cause of action accrued to the petitioner on 13.12.2019.
This Court in WP(C) No. 804/2021, titled, ‘Rattan Singh Parmar vs.
Union Territory of Jammu & Kashmir and ors.’ has observed as under:“8. The respondents are objecting to the claim of the petitioner by
submitting that the petition has been filed after 10 years of the accrual
of cause of action.
9. The only issue that requires consideration is as to whether the
respondents can take plea of delay and laches to object the claim of
the petitioner, once they are admitting that the balance amount of Rs.
22.74 lacs is payable to the petitioner.
10. India is a welfare State and is 5thlargest economy of the world. The
Government, in order to develop infrastructure to ease the life of the
residents of this country, has been collaborating with the private
sector. A Contractor may be a man of means or a small contractor,
who executes the work, often after borrowing loan from Financial
Institutions, with a hope that the amount due to him would be released
in his favour after the completion of work or as per the terms and
conditions of agreement. The delay in releasing payment for one
reason or another for the work carried out by the small contractor
often puts the small contractor in financial doldrums and may result
into bankruptcy bringing the contractor and his family to the brink of
starvation and vagrancy. The Government must put in place the
mechanism in place so that the situation that has arisen in this case
does not arise in future.
11. So far as the present case is concerned, the petitioner has
represented with the respondents for the release of amount umpteen
times, but the representations submitted by the petitioner resulted into
generation of reports from one officer to another, though admitting the
balance amount payable to the petitioner. Once the respondents admit
the payment due to the petitioner but request the release of funds from
the officers higher in the hierarchy of the administrative set up, the
respondents cannot take the refuge under the „delay and laches' to
deny the justified and admitted claim of the petitioner. The
Government cannot act as an ordinary litigant to deny the monetary
claim just on technical grounds and to enrich itself in an unjust
manner. Rather this court finds the respondents guilty of delay and
laches in releasing the balance amount in favour of the petitioner.
WP(C) No. 1635/2023
12. In terms of Article 300A of the Constitution of India, no person
can be deprived of his property save by authority of law. When a
contractor executes work to the satisfaction of the Government, more
particularly when there is admission on the part of the respondent with
regard to the completion of the work by the petitioner, non- payment
of the same cannot be denied only on the ground that the petition has
been filed after an inordinate delay.
13. In Madras Port Trust v. Hymanshu International, (1979) 4
SCC 176 the Hon'ble Supreme Court has held as follows:
"2. We do not think that this is a fit case where we should proceed to
determine whether the claim of the respondent was barred by
Section 110 of the Madras Port Trust Act (II of 1905).
The plea of limitation based on this section is one which the court
always looks upon with disfavour and it is unfortunate that a public
authority like the Port Trust should, in all morality and justice, take
up such a plea to defeat a just claim of the citizen. It is high time
that governments and public authorities adopt the practice of not
relying upon technical pleas for the purpose of defeating legitimate
claims of citizens and do what is fair and just to the citizens. Of
course, if a government or a public authority takes up a technical
plea, the Court has to decide it and if the plea is well-founded, it
has to be upheld by the court, but what we feel is that such a plea
should not ordinarily be taken up by a government or a public
authority, unless of course the claim is not well-founded and by
reason of delay in filing it, the evidence for the purpose of resisting
such a claim has become unavailable. Here, it is obvious that the
claim of the respondent was a just claim supported as it was by the
recommendation of the Assistant Collector of Customs and hence
in the exercise of our discretion under Article 136 of the
Constitution, we do not see any reason why we should proceed to
hear this appeal and adjudicate upon the plea of the appellant
based on Section 110 of the Madras Port Trust Act (II of 1905)
3. We accordingly revoke the special leave granted to the appellant,
and direct that the appellant do pay the cost of the respondents."
(emphasis added)
14. In Vidya Devi v. State of H. P. [(2020) 2 SCC 569],
Hon'ble Supreme Court of India has held under:
"12.12. The contention advanced by the State of delay and laches of
the appellant in moving the Court is also liable to be rejected.
Delay and laches cannot be raised in a case of a continuing cause
of action, or if the circumstances shock the judicial conscience of
the Court. Condonation of delay is a matter of judicial discretion,
which must be exercised judiciously and reasonably in the facts
and circumstances of a case. It will depend upon the breach of
fundamental rights, and the remedy claimed, and when and how the
delay arose. There is no period of limitation prescribed for the
courts to exercise their constitutional jurisdiction to do substantial
justice."
WP(C) No. 1635/2023
9.
So far as the claim of the petitioner in the present petition is concerned, the
petitioner has been continuously representing with the respondents for
release of the amount and respondent No. 2 in the year 2023, convened the
meeting so as to settle the claim of the petitioner, but despite that the claim
was not settled, which prompted the petitioner to file this writ petition on
14.06.2023. The claim of the petitioner by no stretch of imagination can be
considered as time barred particularly when an amount of Rs. 6,50,000/was released in favour of the petitioner in terms of CC-1st and another
amount of Rs. 8,00,000/- was released in favour of the petitioner on
30.03.2020 in terms of CC-2nd, showing the balance amount as outstanding,
as such, there is no force in the contention raised by the respondents that
the claim of the petitioner is time barred. Accordingly, this contention of
the respondents is also rejected.
10.
It is also urged by the respondents that excess work was executed by the
petitioner without following the requisite codal formalities. In this context,
reference is made to Clause 8 of the allotment order, which provides that
any item found necessary during execution shall be paid as per SSR-2012
with overall appreciation/depreciation of allotment of the contract. Thus,
the petitioner could have executed the additional work in terms of Clause 8,
if the same was found necessary during execution of the work. Otherwise
also, the contention of the respondents that the excess work was executed
by the petitioner in utter disregard of the codal formalities is misconceived
as the Division Bench of this Court in LPA No. 137/2020 titled ‘Union
Territory of J&K and ors. vs. Sanjeev Kumar’ has observed as under:“9. The enquiry reports mentioned above on which the appellants
seek to place reliance today was never placed before the writ Court
WP(C) No. 1635/2023
and was not a part of the writ Court record. Even the objections filed
by the Planning Department as also the J&K Housing Board do not
suggest that there was any apprehension in the mind of the Planning
Department or the Housing Board with regard to the manner in
which the contracts stood allotted to the petitioner/respondent herein.
While it may be true that certain codal formalities might not have
been followed before the allotment of the contract in favour of the
respondent herein, yet the Government as also the Housing Board
permitted not only the allotment of contract but also its completion at
the relevant point of time.
10. The petitioner who was allotted the contract by the Housing
Board cannot be expected to first verify as to whether the contract
that has been allotted to him was being executed within the territorial
jurisdiction of the Housing Board or not, nor was he expected to
refuse the execution of the work simply because the subject matter of
the work was not put to open tendering system. Needless to say that
the contractor did execute the works upon being allotted to him for
which some amount is certainly due to him.”
11.
Otherwise also, the compliance with the codal formalities is required to be
undertaken by the respondents and non-compliance thereof cannot be
attributed to the petitioner.
12.
Lastly, it was contended by the respondents that there was no admission on
their part with regard to payment due to the petitioner. However, the
Running Accounts Bill dated 30.03.2020 placed on record by the petitioner
has not been disputed by the respondents and in the said bill, an amount of
Rs. 8,21,000/- has been shown outstanding payable to the petitioner. Thus,
there is admission on the part of respondents regarding the amount due to
the petitioner.
13.
Thus, this Court is of the considered view that the petitioner is entitled to
the sum of Rs. 8,21,000/- on account of outstanding balance payment due
to him in lieu of the work executed by the petitioner as mentioned above.
14.
In view of the foregoing discussion, the present writ petition is disposed of
with a direction to the respondents to release the outstanding amount of Rs.
8,21,000/- in favour of the petitioner, along with interest @ 6% per annum
WP(C) No. 1635/2023
from the date of filing of this writ petition till the date of actual payment.
The entire exercise shall be completed within a period of three months from
the date of receipt of a copy of this order.
15.
Disposed of.
(RAJNESH OSWAL)
JUDGE
Jammu
14.08.2026
Neha-II
Whether the order is speaking:
Whether the order is reportable:
WP(C) No. 1635/2023
NEHA KUMARI
2026.08.14 13:28
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Yes/No.
Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review