The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
12. Considering the provisions of law that various statutory remedial provisions have been inserted in the statute and also statutory remedy of appeal is available as provided under the GST Act, and the circumstances referred in the case of The Assistant Commissioner State Tax (Supra) is not available to the present facts and circumstances of the case, therefore, the writ petitions are not maintainable in view of the statutory remedies available to him. Even otherwise, from the rules, it is quite vivid even after the intimation issued by the proper officer in DRC-01, the right of the petitioner is not adversely affected as according to the provisions of Section 74(5) of the GST Act, the proper officer will issue a show cause notice, where the petitioner can make his submission and take all his defense which are available to him under the law, as such, the right of the petitioner is not being adversely affected, therefore, the writ petitions deserve to be dismissed in view of availability of various opportunities to put forward his case as discussed above.
13. Accordingly, bunch of these writ petitions are dismissed. However, it is directed that before assessing the tax liability of the petitioner, the respondent will comply with the provisions of the GST Act in its letter and spirit giving all the opportunity of hearing will be extended to the petitioner. It is also directed that the petitioner will also cooperate with the proceeding and will not try to delay the proceeding pending before the authority in view of the fact that the proceedings are pending before this Court since 07.11.2024. It is also directed that the petitioner shall not take unnecessary adjournment and will cooperate with the authorities for early disposal of the matter.
14. Consequently, the writ petitions are dismissed with aforesaid liberty granted in favour of the petitioner.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CGHC010381132024
2026:CGHC:40981
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
WPT No. 194 of 2024
M/s Jai Ambey Road Lines (A Proprietorship) Having Its Reg. Office
At I-37, Jai Ambey Road Lines, Shankar Nagar, Anupam Nagar,
Raipur, District Raipur, Chhattisgarh, Through Its Proprietor Namely
Jogendra Singh, S/o Shri Pradeep Singh, Presently Aged About 42
Years, R/o Ward No. 19, Clubpara, District Mahasamund,
Chhattisgarh- 493445
--- Petitioner
versus
1. State Of Chhattisgarh Through The Secretary, Department Of State
Tax Chhattisgarh (S.G.S.T.), Mantralaya, At Mahanadi Bhawan, Atal
Nagar, Naya Raipur, Raipur, Commercial Tax, Raipur, Chhattisgarh.
2. Joint Commissioner Of State Tax Chhattisgarh (S.G.S.T.) Office Of
Joint Commissioner (State Tax), Division- 2, Civil Lines, Behind Raj
Bhawan, District Raipur, Chhattisgarh.
3. The Deputy Commissioner Of State Tax Office Of Joint
Commissioner (State Tax), Division- 2, Civil Lines, Behind Raj
Bhawan, District Raipur, Chhattisgarh.
--- Respondent(s)
WPT No. 196 of 2024
M/s Jai Ambey Road Lines (A Proprietorship ) Having Its Registered
Office At I-37, Jai Ambey Road Lines, Shankar Nagar, Anupam
Nagar, Raipur, District- Raipur ( C.G.). Through- Its Proprietor
Namely Jogendra Singh, S/o Shri Pradeep Singh, Presently Aged
About 42 Years, R/o Ward No. 19, Club Para, District- Mahasamund,
( C.G.).
---Petitioner
Versus
MANISH
YADAV
Digitally
signed by
MANISH
YADAV
Date:
2026.10.01
18:19:13
+0530
1. State Of Chhattisgarh Through- The Secretary, Department Of State
Tax Chhattisgarh ( Sgst ), Mantralaya At Mahanadi Bhawan, Atal
Nagar, Naya Raipur, Raipur, Commercial Tax, Raipur ( C.G.).
2. Joint Commissioner Of State Tax Chhattisgarh ( Sgst ) Office Of
Joint Commissioner ( State Tax ), Division- 2, Civil Lines, Behind Raj
Bhawan, District- Raipur ( C.G.).
3. The Deputy Commissioner Of State Tax Office Of Joint
Commissioner ( State Tax ), Division- 2, Civil Lines, Behind Raj
Bhawan, District- Raipur ( C.G.).
--- Respondent(s)
WPT No. 197 of 2024
M/s Jai Ambey Road Lines (A Proprietorship ) Having Its Registered
Office At I-37, Jai Ambey Road Lines, Shankar Nagar, Anupam
Nagar, Raipur, District- Raipur ( C.G.). Through- Its Proprietor
Namely Jogendra Singh, S/o Shri Pradeep Singh, Presently Aged
About 42 Years, R/o Ward No. 19, Club Para, District- Mahasamund,
( C.G.).
---Petitioner
Versus
1. State Of Chhattisgarh Through- The Secretary, Department Of State
Tax Chhattisgarh (Sgst), Mantralaya At Mahanadi Bhawan, Atal
Nagar, Naya Raipur, Raipur, Commercial Tax, Raipur ( C.G.).
2. Joint Commissioner Of State Tax Chhattisgarh ( Sgst ) Office Of
Joint Commissioner (State Tax), Division- 2, Civil Lines, Behind Raj
Bhawan, District- Raipur ( C.G.).
3. The Deputy Commissioner Of State Tax Office Of Joint
Commissioner (State Tax), Division- 2, Civil Lines, Behind Raj
Bhawan, District- Raipur ( C.G.).
--- Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. Hari Agrawal, Advocate
For Respondent(s)
:
Ms. Anuradha Jain, Dy. Government Advocate
Hon'ble Shri Justice Narendra Kumar Vyas
Order on Board
21.09.2026
1.
Since common question of law and facts are involved in the bunch
of these writ petitions, they are heard analogously and are being
disposed of by this common order. The Court while adjudicating the
issue raised in these petitions, is taking into consideration the facts
of WP(T) No. 194/2024 as lead case.
2.
The petitioner has filed this writ petition under Article 226 of
Constitution of India assailing the show cause notice under Section
74 of the SGST, 2017 read with CGST, 2017 and integrated Goods
and Services Tax, 2017 DRC-01A/BOGUS PURCHASE/20-21/2024
dated 22.08.2024 wherein it has been mentioned that the Office of
Commissioner State Tax and Joint Commissioner Enforcement
while examining the GSTR 2A and 2B that the trader has done the
transaction with non-existence traders and claim bogus Input Tax
Credit (ITC) for the year 2020-21, rejected the claim and issued
DRC-01A.
3.
Learned counsel for the petitioner would submit that the impugned
intimation dated 22.08.2024 is not in-conformity with the provisions
of Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 (in short “GST Act”) as by
impugned notice the petitioner has been directed to pay a total
liability of Rs. 6,91,02,062/- only. It has been further contended that
the said notice has been issued without any notice in this regard
including ASMT-10, without giving any opportunity to reply including
ASMT-11. It has been further submitted that the allegations of
claiming bogus ITC was ever communicated to the petitioner,
therefore, the imposition of such tax liability without giving any
opportunity of proper hearing is wholly unlawful and against the
principle of natural justice.
4.
It has been further contended that intimation under form DRC-01A
and show cause notice under DRC-01A are different and it is not
permissible under the law. It has also been contended that without
any valid reason the rejection of the ITC alleging that R.A.
Corporation and Star Traders are bogus/non-existence traders is
illegal and liable to be quashed by this Court. It has been further
contended that once the law provides something to be done in a
certain manner then it must be done in the same manner as
provided under the statute, failing which the action taken by the
authorities are per-se illegal and would pray for quashing of the
show cause notice.
5.
On the other hand, learned State counsel opposing the submission
made by the counsel for the petitioner would submit that the writ
petition is premature as no decision has been taken by the authority
and any decision will be taken by them after giving opportunity of
hearing to the petitioner as per the procedure prescribed under the
GST Act before assessing the tax liability upon the petitioner. She
would further submit that as per Section 75 of the GST Act which
provides General Provisions relating to determination of tax and
sub-Section 4 of this Section provides an opportunity of hearing to
the person chargeable with tax or penalty where a request is
received in writing from him or where any decision is contemplated
against such person. Section 75(4) of the GST Act is reproduced
below as under:
“75(4) An opportunity of hearing shall be granted where a
request is received in writing from the person chargeable
with tax or penalty, or where any adverse decision is
contemplated against such person.”
6.
She would further elaborate her submission by contending that as
per Section 75(5) of the GST Act, if sufficient cause is shown by the
person chargeable with tax grant time to the said person, however,
as per proviso of this Section not more than 3 adjournments can be
granted. Thus, petitioner can very well raise objection regarding the
contentions of the department referred in the DRC-01A (Annexure
P/1) regarding non-existence traders and claim bogus Input Tax
Credit. She would further submit that as per Rule 142(1) of Goods
and Services Tax Rules, 2017 (in short “Rules, 2017”) the proper
officer shall serve along with the (a) notice issued under Section 52
and 73 or Section 74 or Section 74(a) or Section 76 or Section 122
of Section 124 or Section 125 or Section 127, 129 and 130 of GST
Act, a summary thereof has to be electronically informed in DRC01A. She would further submit that Rule 142(1)(A) which have been
inserted on 09.10.2019 clearly provides that proper Officer may
before service of notice to the person chargeable with the tax
interest and penalty under Sub-Section 1 of Section 73 or Subsection 1 Section 74 or Sub-section 1 of Section 74(a) communicate
(the details) of any tax interest or penalty as assessed by the
Officer.
7.
It has also been contended that ASMT-10 is not a mandatory
requirement, therefore, proper Officer was justified in issuing DRC01A without issuing ASMT-10 as Section 61 of the GST Act provides
for scrutiny of the return and Rule 99 of the Rules, 2017 provides
scrutiny of returns and for that ASMT-10 can be issued and if the
registered person pays the tax interest and any other amount
arising from such discrepancy and inform the same or furnish an
explanation for the discrepancy inform GST ASMT-11 to the proper
officer.
8.
Section 61 of the GST Act, provides that proper Officer may
scrutinize the return and related particulars furnished by the
registered person to verify the correctness of the return and inform
him of discrepancies noticed and for that ASMT-10 is issued
whereas the DRC-01A is issued under Section 74 of the GST Act for
determination of tax pertaining to the period upto the financial year
2023-24 not paid or short paid or erroneously refunded or Input Tax
Credit wrongly availed or utilized by reasons of fraud or any willful
misstatement or suppression of facts. Thus, both the Acts work in a
different sphere and Section 61(3) the GST Act cannot be
considered as a pre-condition for initiation of any action under
Section 73 or 74 of the GST Act. Thus, she would pray for dismissal
of the petition.
9.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record
and provisions of GST Act.
10.
From perusal of Section 74 of the GST Act and the Rules made
therein as well as DRC-01A which have been issued under Rule
142(1)(1A) of the Rules, 2017, it is quite vivid that form DRC-01A
only talks about the ascertaining of the facts in terms of available
information and it also advices to pay the amount of tax as ascertain
along with the application of interest in full, failing which show cause
notice shall be issued under Section 73(1) of the GST Act or also
advised to pay the amount of tax as ascertain along with the
amount of interest and penalty under Section 74(5) of the GST Act,
failing which show cause notice will be issued under Section 74(1)
or show cause notice will be issued under Section 74(a)(1) read
with Clause (i) of sub-Section 5 of the Section 74(a)(5) or a show
cause notice will be issued under sub-Section 1 of Section 74(a)
read with Clause (ii) of the said Section, as such, the petitioner has
various opportunities where he can make a representation as
provided in sub-Section 9 of Section 3 or sub-Section 9 of the
Section 74 or sub-Section 6 of Section 74(a) or sub-Section 3 of
Section 76 or the reply to any notice issued under any Section
whose summary has been uploaded electronically in form GST
DRC-01 under sub-Rule 1.
11.
From perusal of the above stated provisions of the GST Act, it is
quite vivid that the petitioner has to submit reply to DRC-01 which
has to be considered by the respondent after giving the opportunity
of hearing to the petitioner and thereafter, DRC-01 also provides
ample opportunity of hearing to the petitioner to put forward his
case and if the petitioner is aggrieved with any order passed in
DRC-07, after hearing the petitioner, remedy of appeal is available
as per Section 107 of the GST Act. As such, the petitioner’s petition
is premature and without exhausting the remedy available to him
under the GST Act. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in case of The Assistant Commissioner of State Tax and Others vs. M/s Commercial Steel Limited reported in (2022) 16 SCC 447 has held in paragraphs 11 to 13 as under:
“11. The respondent had a statutory remedy under section
107. Instead of availing of the remedy, the respondent instituted a petition under Article 226. The existence of an alternate remedy is not an absolute bar to the maintainability of
a writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution. But a
writ petition can be entertained in exceptional circumstances
where there is:
(i) a breach of fundamental rights;
(ii) a violation of the principles of natural justice;
(iii) an excess of jurisdiction; or
(iv) a challenge to the vires of the statute or delegated legislation.
12 In the present case, none of the above exceptions was
established. There was, in fact, no violation of the principles of natural justice since a notice was served on the person in charge of the conveyance. In this backdrop, it was
not appropriate for the High Court to entertain a writ petition. The assessment of facts would have to be carried out
by the appellate authority. As a matter of fact, the High
Court has while doing this exercise proceeded on the basis
of surmises. However, since we are inclined to relegate the
respondent to the pursuit of the alternate statutory remedy
under Section 107, this Court makes no observation on the
merits of the case of the respondent.
13 For the above reasons, we allow the appeal and set
aside the impugned order of the High Court. The writ petition filed by the respondent shall stand dismissed. However, this shall not preclude the respondent from taking recourse to appropriate remedies which are available in
terms of Section 107 of the CGST Act to pursue the grievance in regard to the action which has been adopted by the
state in the present case.”
12.
Considering the provisions of law that various statutory remedial
provisions have been inserted in the statute and also statutory
remedy of appeal is available as provided under the GST Act, and
the circumstances referred in the case of The Assistant
Commissioner State Tax (Supra) is not available to the present
facts and circumstances of the case, therefore, the writ petitions are
not maintainable in view of the statutory remedies available to him.
Even otherwise, from the rules, it is quite vivid even after the
intimation issued by the proper officer in DRC-01, the right of the
petitioner is not adversely affected as according to the provisions of
Section 74(5) of the GST Act, the proper officer will issue a show
cause notice, where the petitioner can make his submission and
take all his defense which are available to him under the law, as
such, the right of the petitioner is not being adversely affected,
therefore, the writ petitions deserve to be dismissed in view of
availability of various opportunities to put forward his case as
discussed above.
13.
Accordingly, bunch of these writ petitions are dismissed. However, it
is directed that before assessing the tax liability of the petitioner, the
respondent will comply with the provisions of the GST Act in its
letter and spirit giving all the opportunity of hearing will be extended
to the petitioner. It is also directed that the petitioner will also
cooperate with the proceeding and will not try to delay the
proceeding pending before the authority in view of the fact that the
proceedings are pending before this Court since 07.11.2024. It is
also directed that the petitioner shall not take unnecessary
adjournment and will cooperate with the authorities for early
disposal of the matter.
14.
Consequently, the writ petitions are dismissed with aforesaid liberty
granted in favour of the petitioner.
15.
The interim orders dated 07.11.2024 passed by this Court in all
these three writ petitions stand vacated.
Sd/(Narendra Kumar Vyas)
Judge
Manish
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review