Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
?4
t 3488 l
,
rN rHE
Fo$"ttr^:JfJE
HrGH couRr
oF rELAuamu
FEBRU ARY
r H u R s DAY'If,.HEXII il$J i'?al',i't
PRESENT
SINGH
THE
Preferred Against
igh Court'
Order
B',:1t"1',s);t1Tflilr'J"'J#:?'h?'LT[i?[i|fi"$
Between:
"g;f':'"?'fr Jgfl :lRti^T".[.Fef$f
;ffitl#:,!}i'ffi
1M/srndian,?Jffi 'f*?'"ll"Jl'\[f
Secundera
Eli"jibign Moosapet
KUKatuat':v
AND
fl
:
.'srt',xtl
rrreY-
..-APPELLANTS
n^oA Tlvears occ Retired from
business
l*:.[ti,,#m$:*;#ir,:-,1#-;s:"-#i',,si.'.r:1
:ffif
#,ifl
^vsrr"'No
Flat
from
, ^a ,,^6ro ot"'8oEi'
clcc Retired
"s]oo
19^i.,,.t-'*nlrPrrya
SiddiPet.District
3 (, dxminflil"ft.' 3/?o)"8,[?3iiH,SP"$.:,.6'€,?.rrin
"tflB[ttttris
iput
Business R/o
-'^^ o^"n 55 vears occ
H No 806
occ Busness R/o H No
iv' fi*il#"ffiilx",,*'fHif,?.!ffihd."{fl.,ears
i+ioz
6:'!'*'T;;
qisr$irydgrygr
'z' ffi,$:#illei-,r,3fu,
ot t;3'Ti!"'a,nt?t'J; Cco to*d,r'"iiJJao
i
in. ti"pltv"'
ParuPalli Street Siddtl
-
'
db-qe^Ctoi
Se-cunderabad
i
:
t
I
I
"
ig ud
Oigan-lzition PESO Room
"'RESP.NDENTS
lA NO: 1 OF 202Q
Petition under section
il:::tll:]:.
2o2s,in
151 cPc praying
in supporr of the petition,
that in the circumstances
the Hish court may
davs in rilins the writ
the,r,"rllIffil
stated
be preased to
Appear in wp.No.824
oF
lA NO: 2 OF 20;?6
Petition ttnder section
in the affidavit filed in
151 cPc praying that
support of the petition,
suspend the order dared
Hon'ble Single Judge of
14_o?
this Court
counser for the ,{pperant:
in the circumstances
2;;;;ff,
ffJ;:::;t.:"r:::;;r,J
sRr- yoGESH KUMAR HEROOR
counser for the Respondent
Nos. 1]l!,
counser for the Responae;i
lRr r BALA MOHAN REDD'
6&7: sRr rv.inu.lnNcA RAo,
DY.SOLICITOR GENERAL OF INDIA
The Court made the following: ORDER
il.
stated
the Hir
il
I
i
i
rN rHB HrcH
couRH8$ffiilf;'
OF TELANGANA
AND
DATED: 26'02'2026
Between:
;
r n.,h
&
mi**,t*":;l,,,ffi
n'p'1i i;;;;;;tive '=I
Director
q
another
APPeIlants
Hyderabaa,
AND
K.Shekaraiah
S/o' Late Rajesham
& 6 others
ResPondents
rvtr' rugccrr '---^HeardlMr.YogeshKumarHeroor,learnedcounselappearingforthe
for
rr^rr"
counse 1 appearing
learned
'
Reddy'
T'Bala Mohan
appellants and Mr'
respondent Nos't to 5/writ
petitioners'
2.Theinstantwritappealispreferredagainsttheorderdated|4.07.2025
passed by the leamed
writ Court in W'P'No'824 of
2025'
t
\
3.
Learned counsel for the
parties, during the
/1
course of hearing' fairly submit
writ appear has arready been
this
in
involved
issue
the
that
considered by this
l
{
I
I
t-
I
*
€
I
I
I
Coun in V/.A.Nos.97,
16.02.2026, and
I05 and I88 of-
the said judgment
well.
4'
The relevant portion
W.A.Nos. 97, 105
2026, vide cotnmon
squarely covers
of the said judgmenr
and I gg of 2026
judgmenr dated
the present
writ appeal as
dared 16.02.20215
passed in
reads as under:
"6.
Tlre question before
us is whethe the
learned writ cor
rocl ro vaoare tn. ;;":,';:l':J'on"r
Learned cou,rser
fa*s in Nafionar
P ar
a 29o f rh : a
r
"o-.,,_
foresr,,
:"':""1t.*':ssors
1""1," ; :
"29. As observed by the
continuing with the
*.,.J,,'" ;:l'J:ffi::
have placed decis'
;;;' ;;:::;:f ,*II
:::":: ;:::il;'
High Court, the conduct
of Respondent
I BpCL in
"."
occupation of the said nrcmiooo ...r,
3 I - r 2 -2cog is un becom
in* o, u
meaning of Articre 12
'
or rhe rease
.,;:T;:;H:"":;::iry
*u*jl'"ffffi ,: ;:I T:tffi :fi:
0f the Constitution of India.
we therefore find that whire
directing the respondents to
vacate the said premises
and hand over peaceful and
vacant possession to the
appellant, it wiil arso be necessary
in the interests ofjustice
to direct l(espondent l BpcL
to pay arrears of market rent
from 3r_r2_20og,ti, the
date of delivery of possession
at the
market rate.,,
They have also placed reliance
on decision rendered by
w.p.No.25779 0f 2024 dared 13. tt.2024,which
7'
a single Bench of this Courtin
became final.
In the light of the decision referred to hereinabove
company (supra), we are of the view that
in the case of Nationat
the issue whether a writ court can direct
tocl or a Petroleum company to vacate the premises upon expiry
ttot is not open tc be raised specifically u'hen the
of the lease period or
facts are not in dispute. The lease with
IOCL has admittedly expired.
i'
S.lnviewoftheabovefactsandcircumstancesandtlredecisionsreferredto
as per trre rentar
rent
above.\\,eatetrftheconsideredviewthattlreappellants-IoCLslrouldvacatethesubject
ut.o puy trr; aamissiure
should
They
ro.oe .zoza.
\atest by
premises
r
12or\)
t3 SCC
12I
J
as revised
agreemenr,
the r'vrit p"tition"o
periodically.
tilr the date
and their legal
tn"tt
the
of their vacaring
heirs)' without
subject premises
to
fail'
)osts'"
g.Withtheseobservations,theinstantWritAppealsstanddisposedof.Noc
5.
In view of the
consensus arrived
common
rerms of the
judgment dated
The appellant
and 188 of 2026'
and pay the
30.06.2026
periodicarly, ti*
petitioners
Appeal is dso
at, this Writ
pasled in w'A'Nos'97'
16'02'2026
should
admissibre
the date of their
However
Miscellaneous
premises
vacate the subject
rental
rent as per the
in
latest by
agreement' as
premises
vacating the subject
tegal heirs)'
(lessors and their
shalt be no order
) there
disposed of
revised
to the writ
without fait'
as to costs'
pending, if anY'
aPPlications
shall stand closed.
,,TRUE COPY'I
SECTION OFFICER
Gas MinistrY of
To,
2.
"ffi,'3'Iffi".:el,?Y
3.
OF INDIA
4.
5.
roPucl
6. two CD CoPies
16'02'2026
the order dated
in W'A'Nos' 97'105
&188
$'i38.'l':t,i,J:PJ"?l
BM
w
ri
I
HIGH COURT
)
DATED :it6tO2t2OZ6
THE S
JUDGITIENT
WA.No.7G of 2026
? 5 IIAR
*
DISPOSINIS OF THE WRIT APPEAL
WITHOUT COSTS
I
i
I
i
i
%
,{$
tr*-
2rl7fi
*
//.rIN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
The Hon'ble The Chief Justice Sri Aoaresh Kumar Sineh
and
The Hon'ble Sri Justice G.M.Mohiuddin
Writ Appeal Nos.97. 105 and 188 of 2026
Datedz 16.02.2026
W.A.No.97 of 2026
Between:
M/s. Indian Oil Corporation Limited
Rep. by its Executive Director,
office at Indian Oil Bhavan, Fateh Bagh'
Moosapet, Kukatpally lndustrial Estate,
Sanathnagar, Hyderabad and 2 others
...Appellants
and
Mujeebuddin Khan and 6 others
Respondents
W.A.No.l05 of 2026
Between:
M/s. Indian Oil Corporation Limited
Rep. by its Managing Director
Office at Indian Oil Bhavan' Fateh Bagh,
Moosapet, Kukatpally Industrial Estate,
Sanathnagar, Hyderabad and another
...Appellants
and
Mohammed Khaled Hussain and 4 others
.Respondents
W.A.No.l88 of 2026
Between:
lndian Oil Corporation Limited
Having its Regd. Office at
Indian Oil Bhavan, G-9, Ali Yavar Jung Marg,
Bandra (East) Mumbai and 2 others
...Appellants
and
Smt. Koushar Jahan Begum and another
Respondents
Comm,on Judgment:
i\{r. Srikanth Kaveti, learned counsel appears for the appellants
in w.A No.97 of 2026; Mr. yogesh Kumar Heroor, learned counsel
appears for the appellanrs in w.A.Nos.l05 -and l gg of 2026:
Mr. T.Bala Mohan Reddy, learned counsel appears for r-espondents
No.l anc 2 i, w.A.No.97 of 2026; Ms. K.Hima Bindu, learned counsel
appears lor Mr. v.Murali Manohar, learned counsel for respondent
No.l in 'w.A.No.l05 of 2026; Mr. Bharath chandra Madas, learned
counsel al)pears for Mr. B.Srinivas Rao, learned counsel for respondept
No.l in w.A.No.l88 of 2026; Mr. B.Mukherjee, learned counsel
appears f,cr Mr. N.Bhujanga Rao, learned Deputy Solicitor General of
tndia for rospondent No.3 in w.A.No.97 of 2026 and respondent No.2
in w.A.No.l05 of 2026 and Mr. Mahesh Raje, learned Government
Pleader fbr Horne appears lor respondent No.6 in w.A.N o.97 of 2026.
2-
Thes,: three writ Appeals arise out of separate orders
dated 23.09.2025, 20.08.2025 and 17.t2.2025, passed by the learned
writ court in w.P.Nos.97, 105 and 188 of 2026 respectivery.
3.
In these three writ Appeals, cornmon issue is involved. Hence,
they are beirLg heard and disposed of together.
4-
The leasc granted in favour of the appellants-tndian oil
corporation Limited (locl) by the writ petitioners (lessors) expired.
::3::
Writ petitioners approached the learned Writ Court against the action
of IOCL in unlawfully occupying the lease premises after expiry of the
lease period. The learned Writ Court, following the decisions rendered
in similar matters, one of them being W P.No.22224 of 2025
dated 20.08.2025, disposed of the aforesaid writ Petitions with a
direction to IOCL to vacate and hand over the peaceful possession of
the subject premises to the lessors within a period of three months from
the date of receipt of a copy of the order in w.P.Nos.l7236 and 20918
of 2025 and within a period of two months from the date of receipt of a
copy of the order in W.P.No.37277 of 2025. Being aggrieved, IOCL
has preferred the instant Writ Appeals.
5.
Earlier when w.A.No.91 of 2026 was taken up, learned counsel
for IOCL has brought to the notice of the Court that a similar challenge
is pending in SLP(C).No.1638 of 2026 [Indian Oil Corporation
Limited rep. by its Senior Regional Manager v. Satyanarayana
Lahoti and othersl. order dated 30.01 .2026, passed by rhe Hon'ble
Supreme court in the said SLP, has been produced today during the
course of hearing. The apex court has refused to exercise discretionary
jurisdiction under Article 136 of the Constitution of tndia and
dismissed the SLP. However, on the request of the petitioner-IoCl, the
apex court permitted it to vacate the subject premises by 3l .05.2026
subject o payment of enhanced lease rent to the respondent provided it
submits an undertaking on affidavit within two weeks before the trial
court that it will vacate the subject premises within the aforesaid time
frame. [l was, however, rnade clear that the view taken by the High
Court shall not be treated as precedent.
6.
Th: question before us is whether the learned Writ Court was
right in directing IOCL to vacate the subject land aflter expiry of the
lease period in a writ proceeding. Learned counsel for the writ
petitionerr;/lessors have placed decision rendered on similar facts in
National ,Company v. Bharat Petroleum Corporation Limited and
othersr. Para29 of the aforesaid decision is extracted hereunder:
"29. As observed by the High Court, the conduct of Respondent I
BPClt. in continuing with the occupation of the said premises without
payirrg any rcnt fionr 3l-12-2009 is unbecoming of a statutory
corporatiou, which is a State within the meaning of Article 12 of the
Conr;titutron of India. We therefore find that while directing the
rcsprlndents to vacate the said premises and hand over peaceful and
vacant possession to the appellant, it will also be necessary in the
intcr,:sts of justice to direct Respondent I BPCL to pay arrears of
rnarket rent fiom 3l-12-2009, till the date of delivery of possession at
the nmrket ratc."
They have also placed reliance on decision rendered by a Single
Bench of this Courl in W.P.No.25779 of 2024 dated 13.11 .2024, which
becarne final.
'(zozt) 13 scc 121
..(..
.
[n the light of the decision referred to hereinabove in the case of
National Company (supra), we are of the view that the issue whether a
writ Court can direct IOCL or a Petroleum Company to vacate the
premises upon expiry of the lease period or not is not open to be raised
specifically when the facts are not in dispute. The lease with IoCL has
admittedly expired.
8.
[n view of the above facts and circumstances and the decisions
referred to above, we are of the considered view that the appellants-
IocL should vacate the subjecr premises latest by 30.06.2026. They
should also pay the admissible rent as per the rental pgreement, as
revised periodically, till the date of their vacating the subject premises
to the writ petitioners (lessors and their legal heirs), without
g.
fail.
with these observations, the instant writ Appeals stand disposed
ofl. No costs.
As a sequel, miscelraneous petitions, pending
if any, stand
closed.
APARESH KUMAR SING H, CJ
Date:1G.02.2026
LUR
G.M.MO HIUD DIN, J
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review