Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 57
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH AT
SRINAGAR.
WP (C) No. 2430/2026.
CM No. 6591/2026
M/S INCREDIBLE PLACEMENT SERVICES PVT. LTD
through its authorised Signatory
Sameer Ahmad Bhat (Authorised Signatory) aged 40-Years
S/o Ghulam Mohammad Bhat
R/o Dooru, Shabdan, Budgam, J&K.
….. Petitioner(s)
Through: Mr. Naveed Gul, Advocate.
V/s
1. Union of India through the Secretary,
Ministry of Defense, New Delhi, 110011.
2. Station Organization Officer
Air Force Station Srinagar, PIN 190007.
3. Wing Commander, Station Organization Officer,
Air Force Station Srinagar J&K.
….. Respondent(s)
Through:Mr. Faizan Ganai, CGSC.
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE MOHD YOUSUF WANI, JUDGE
(ORDER)
26.09.2026.
( Oral )
1.
Mr. Faizan Ganai, learned CGSC appears and waives
notice in the matter for respondents.
2.
Heard the learned counsel for the petitioner-firm in
respect of the matter. Also heard the appearing counsel
for the respondents in rebuttal.
3.
The case of the petitioner-firm in nutshell is that it has
been providing various services in the form of Cleaning,
Sanitation and Disinfection Service-Outcome BasedOffice/Commercial/Institutions/Residential;
Vegetation
Cutting; Outdoor & also provides security services and
man power to various organizations. That the respondent
No. 3 issued tender in the month of January 2026, bearing Bid No.
GEM/2025/B/6978973 Dated: 08/01/2026 with
respect to providing of services
mentioned Supra to which it participated on GeM Portal/Online
and fulfilled all the terms and conditions as required/envisaged in
the tender notice. That despite being eligible bidder, was
disqualified on the vague reason of non-submission of labour
registration license/certificate for employment of 100 workers in a
day which condition is against law and rules as laid down under
Contract Labour Act 1970 and the rules framed thereunder. That
with regard to the requirement of the aforesaid, certificate Labour
Commissioner J&K vide circular No. LC/Enf/2020/1349-63 dated
20.11.2020, has already impressed upon all the executing agencies,
strictly not to seek registration/license from the contractors. That the
reason quoted by the respondents with regard to its disqualification
is bad in law and therefore, deserves to be quashed/set aside with
the direction to allow it to participate in the tender process.
4.
Learned counsel for the petitioner-firm during the course of his
arguments inter-alia submitted that the petitioner-firm is fully
qualified as per the terms and conditions to participate in the tender
process. That the firm at the time of submission of the technical bid
submitted all the requisite documents as per the NIT. That the
requirement of the Labour license was not at all a pre-requisite as
per the terms and conditions of the NIT. That the said certificate,
even if, required by the tendering authority could have been
requisitioned from the petitioner-firm only after the allotment of the
contract in its favour.
5.
The learned counsel for the petitioner-firm in support of his
contentions placed reliance on the 2003 Supreme (Ori) 894, tiled
as “M/S Trident Softech Pvt. Ltd v. State of Orissa and others”.
He contended that it has been authoritatively laid down in the
judgment (supra) that the decision of the Technical Evaluation
Committee, disqualifying the technical bid of the petitioner was not
just or proper as there was no stipulation in the tender call notice to
furnish Labour contract licence in respect of the previous works.
Learned counsel submits that it has been also observed in the
judgment (supra) that such a licence can only be obtained from the
successful bidder after the entrustment of the work to him.
6.
Learned counsel for the petitioner-firm also invited the attention of
the Court towards the circular dated 20.11.2020, issued by the
Government of Jammu and Kashmir-Office of the Labour
Commissioner under No. LC/Enf/2020/1349-63, whereby it has
been enjoined upon all the Principal Employers not to make a
contract labour licence a pre-requisite document for participation in
tendering process. It has been further stipulated in the said circular
that however, Principal Employer shall seek the registration/licence
from the contractor only after allotment of the work/contract and
shall not release any payment in favour of the contractor in the
absence of the contract labour licence
7.
Per-contra, it was submitted by the learned CGSC , appearing for the
respondents that the requirement of submission of the contract
labour licence was a pre-requisite in terms of the terms and
conditions of the NIT. The learned CGSC during the course of his
submissions has invited the attention of the Court towards the
paragraph-9 of the NIT under Sub-head-Certificates, revealing that
bidders Offer is liable to be rejected if they don’t upload any of the
certificates/documents sought in the bid document, ATC and
Corrigendum if any.
He further submitted that the document
required from the seller made mention of experience criteria, bidder
turnover certificate (requested in ATC).
8.
In the facts and circumstances of the case, the Court is of the opinion
that the matter can be disposed of even at this initial stage by
passing of appropriate directions which are not likely to prejudice
the interests of any of the parties and which otherwise are meant to
be complied with by the respondents as being with legal
justification.
9.
The petitioner-firm appears to have been disqualified for nonsubmission of labour registration licence/certificate for employing
100 workers in a day. Such a stipulation as a pre-requisite does not
appear to be specific either from the terms and conditions of the
contract or from the tender documents. Such a requirement cannot
be insisted upon as a pre-condition for submission of the bid
document, such requirement can however, be insisted by the
Principal Employer/executing agency after the allotment of the
contract work and before any payment is released.
10.
The facts of the case law relied upon by the learned counsel for the
petitioner-firm squarely resemble with the facts of the instant case
and, as such, this Court is in full agreement with the law laid-down
in the said case. It is profitable to reproduce the paragraphs 12, 13
and 14 of the judgment (supra).
12. The only question which needs to be considered in the
present case is whether making such a stipulation in the
Tender document was a pre-condition for adjudging the
proven experience of a firm. It is found from he
documents submitted by the petitioner that it had enclosed
a list with its technical bid indicating the clients to whom
manpower had been supplied by it. Be that as it may, not
having proven experience was not the ground on which
the petitioner’s technical bid was rejected or the
petitioner was found disqualified, as would be evident
from Annexure-C to the counter-affidavit. The only
ground on which the petitioner was found disqualified by
the Technical Evaluation Committee, as would be evident
from Annexure-C, was its non-submission of labour
contract licence.
It also appears from the order of rejection that
opportunity had
been given to one of the bidders being M/s. Chancellor
Infotech, Bhubaneswar to prove its experience. Such
opportunity could have
been given to the petitioner. Thus the order of
disqualification
suffers from the vice of discrimination.
13. Law is well settled that whatever procedure be
followed while
inviting tenders, the terms which need to be complied with
by an applicant must be clearly, specifically and
unambiguously stated in the Tender Call Notice to avoid a
bona fide error by an applicant.
14. After patiently hearing the learned counsel for the
parties, meticulously examining the documents produced
by either side and diligently considering the submissions
made, we find that in the absence of any specific
stipulation made in the Tender Call Notice or tender
documents, clearly and unambiguously stating therein
that an applicant should furnish the labour contract
licence in respect of its previous works, the opposite
party-authorities could not have rejected the technical bid
of the petitioner on that score. As has been held earlier, a
labour contract licence cannot be obtained in respect of
the particular work and can only be obtained after
entrustment of the work as has been held in 1997 (II) OLR
284 (supra). In view of the aforesaid facts, we have no
hesitation to hold that the decision of the Technical
Evaluation Committee disqualifying the technical bid of
the petitioner only on the ground of non-submission of
labour contract licence was not just or proper and the
order/letter dated 29.9.2003 issued to the petitioner vide
Annex¬ure-2 is to be quashed”.
11.
The circular issued by the Government of Jammu and Kashmir
through the Office of Labour Commissioner dated 20.11.2020, also
clarifies the issue.
12.
For the foregoing, discussion, the instant petition is disposed off, at
this stage with the direction to the respondents to allow technical
bid of the petitioner-firm without insisting it for submission of
labour registration licence at pre-allotment stage and to accordingly,
consider his bid along with other received bids for comparative
analysis provided the other requirements are complied with by it
and subject that the tender process has not already been finalized
with the issuance of the contract work.
13.
14.
The writ petition is disposed of along with connected CM(s).
(Mohd Yousuf Wani)
Judge
SRINAGAR
26.09.2026.
“Abdul Rashid”
Whether the order is speaking;
Whether the order is reportable:
Yes
Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review