Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[2026:RJ-JP:31554-DB]
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN
BENCH AT JAIPUR
D.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 178/2026
CNR: RJHC021148472025 | URN: CW / 382U / 2026
1.
2.
1.
2.
3.
M/s. Hotel Red Fort, At Opp. Jaipur Golden Petrol Pump,
Piliwalon Ki Dhani, Delhi Road, Jaipur, Rajasthan 302028,
Through Its Authorized Representative / Partner Ravi Tak.
Ravi Tak S/o Shri Prakash Chand Tak, Aged About 47
Years, R/o Village - Tankrala Ki Dhani, Lalwas Near Nai
Mata Mandir, Delhi Road, Amber, P.o. - Amer, District
Jaipur, Rajasthan 302028, Authorized Representative
/partner M/s Hotel Red Fort.
----Petitioners
Versus
Union Of India, Through Secretary, Ministry Of Finance,
North Block, Cabinet Secretariat, Raisina Hill, New Delhi110001.
State Of Rajasthan, Commercial Taxes Department, O/o
Commissioner Jurisdiction, Circle-J, Jaipur-I, Ward-Ii,
Circle-J, Jaipur I, Rajasthan.
Office Of Assistant Commissioner, State Tax, Ward-Ii,
Circle-J, Zone-Jaipur-I, O/o Room No. 504, 4Th Floor, Kar
Bhawan, Jhalana Institutional Area, Jaipur.
----Respondents
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. Naqvi Sehban Najib Sabiha
Mr. Sehban Naqvi
Ms. Rabiya Mateen
Mr. Sahil Khan
For Respondent(s)
:
Ms. Mahi Yadav, AAG
Ms. Chelsi Agarwal
Mr. Pawan Pareek
Mr. Manish Acharya
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ARUN MONGA
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ASHUTOSH KUMAR
Order (Oral)
11/08/2026
Per: Arun Monga, J.
1.
By this writ petition, the petitioners seek quashing of the Show
Cause Notice dated 01.08.2024 and the consequential Order in Original
dated 22.01.2025. Both were issued by the Assistant Commissioner,
State Tax, Ward II, Circle J, Zone Jaipur I. By the impugned order, a
GST demand of Rs. 49,45,053/-, has been raised on the ground of
alleged non payment of tax liability.
(2 of 5)
[2026:RJ-JP:31554-DB]
2.
[CW-178/2026]
The petitioners assert that neither the impugned show case notice
nor the order was served upon them through any formal mode. They
learnt of the proceedings only about two months prior to approaching
this court. A caller claiming to be from the GST Department asked them
to deposit the penalty and directed them to the "Additional Notices and
Orders" tab on the GST common portal. On accessing the portal, the
petitioners located the Show Cause Notice. They then discovered that it
stood adjudicated by the order dated 22.01.2025. Both documents were
downloaded from the portal.
2.1
Until then, the petitioners had no knowledge of the proceedings.
They were therefore never heard and never had occasion to reply to the
allegations. Hence the instant petition.
3.
Learned counsel for the petitioners argues that the impugned
Show Cause Notice dated 01.08.2024 and the consequential Order-inOriginal dated 22.01.2025 are non-est and void ab initio, as the
petitioners were never effectively served with the Show Cause Notice or
the order and was not afforded any meaningful opportunity to file a
reply or of personal hearing. He contends that mere uploading of the
documents under the “Additional Notices and Orders” tab of the GST
portal does not constitute effective service, particularly when the
petitioners have no knowledge of the proceedings. He further states
that
the
summons
dated
16.07.2024
could
not
substitute
an
opportunity of hearing in respect of a Show Cause Notice subsequently
issued on 01.08.2024, and that the relied-upon documents forming the
basis of the alleged liability were also not supplied, resulting in violation
of the principles of natural justice and Sections 75(4) and 169 of the
RGST Act, 2017.
3.1
He further contends that the proceedings are otherwise vitiated by
limitation and non-compliance with mandatory statutory procedure. He
(3 of 5)
[2026:RJ-JP:31554-DB]
submits
that
the
Show
Cause
Notice
[CW-178/2026]
pertaining
to
the
period
01.04.2019 to 31.12.2019 was issued beyond the prescribed period
under Section 73, and that the extended period under Section 74 could
not be invoked merely by using expressions such as “wilfully and
knowingly”. He further points out that the proceedings were initiated in
the name of the partnership firm without impleading its partners as
contemplated under Section 137, and that the requisite pre-SCN under
Rule 142(1A) was not issued. He submits that the respondents, being
creatures of statute, were bound to act strictly in accordance with the
statutory mandate.
4.
Per contra, Ms. Mahi Yadav, AAG, learned counsel for the
respondents opposes the petition. She submits that the Show Cause
Notice dated 01.08.2024 and the Order in Original dated 22.01.2025
each carried a unique reference ID and were uploaded on the GST
common portal. Section 169 of the RGST Act, 2017 expressly
recognises making a communication available on the common portal as
a valid mode of service. Once the statute treats portal upload as
sufficient, service cannot be defeated by the assessee's own failure to
monitor the portal. A registered person is expected to access the portal
in the ordinary course of compliance. Petition be thus dismissed
5.
In the aforesaid backdrop, we have heard learned counsel for the
parties and perused the case file.
6.
In the petition it is specifically pleaded that the impugned Show
Cause Notice dated 01.08.2024 and the Order-in-Original dated
22.01.2025 were not served upon the petitioners. The relevant
paragraph of the petition are reproduced hereinbelow:"4.
That the petitioners do hereby states and submits at about two
months back, some person claiming from the GST department, called up
the petitioner and informed them to deposit the penalty, hearing the same
the petitioner, was surprised, as they were never delivered with any SCN
or Order. Thereupon it was informed to the petitioner, that, they need to
check the common portal online under the "Tab of Additional Notice and
[2026:RJ-JP:31554-DB]
(4 of 5)
[CW-178/2026]
Orders", Then upon the deep scrutiny, the petitioner saw the the "Tab of
Additional Notice and Orders", and then only they came to know about
the subject SCN.
x-x-x-x-x
C.
FOR THAT, the petitioners have never been served with the
subject SCN, and they only came to know about the SCN, and order in
original when they saw the subject SCN being uploaded on the G.S.T,
Common portal. This marks the violation of principles of natural justice,
as the petitioners were never afforded with the opportunity to contest the
subject SCN. Even otherwise also, from the order in original dated
22.01.2025 vide para 10, it verbatim came out as "Opportunity provided
to the Taxpayer to produce relevant evidences through SCN Reference
No. 95 dated 01.08.2024 but taxpayer did not produce the any
documents/reply in compliances of the SCN." Contending from the same,
it is submitted that even the subject order in original does not speaks
about as to how the subject SCN was delivered to the petitioners.
Meaning thereby at the relevant point of time, the subject SCN was never
delivered to the petitioners. On this account itself, the subject SCN and
order in original demands to be quashed and set aside.
D.
FOR THAT, even if one sees the subject SCN, then vide para 10,
it verbatim came out as "Opportunity provided to the Taxpayer to
produce relevant evidences through Summon Reference No. 91 dated
16.07.2024, but taxpayer did not produce the any documents in
compliances of the Summon".
In this regard, it is submitted that a Summon under Section 70 RGST Act,
2017, can never be substituted as an opportunity of hearing, for an
adjudication of a Show cause notice. Suffice to state here that the so
called Summon dated 16.07.2024, never apprised about the subject SCN
and even otherwise also, the subject summons called for the presence on
22.07.2024. The how come a Summon having the date of 16.07.2024,
requiring presence for 22.07.2024, can take a substitute for a hearing of
a show cause notice dated 01.08.2024. A copy of the Summon dated
16.07.2024 is submitted herewith and marked as Annexure- "з".
E.
FOR THAT, the department has not given an opportunity to the
petitioners, to file the reply to show cause notice, even apart from that, if
it is assumed that a reply is not considered, then at least an opportunity
of hearing has to be given before the adjudication of the subject SCN,
vide order in original. The order in original doesn't even have the
mention of an opportunity of hearing being given to the petitioners."
7.
In response to above, in the corresponding paragraphs of the
reply, following stand has been taken :"44. That the contents of para (4) to (6) are not admitted as stated in the
light of additional factual matrix and preliminary objections stated
hereinabove and same are not reproduced hereinafter for the sake of
brevity. Additionally, the answering respondent humbly submits that
Show cause notice dated 01.08.2024 Order-In-Original dated
22.01.2025, having a unique reference ID, being uploaded on portal, was
duly communicated to the petitioners as per mandate of Section 169 of
RGST Act, 2017.
x-x-x-x-x
47. The contents of Ground (C) are not admitted as stated and denied in
light of preliminary objection stated hereinabove, However, additionally,
the answering respondent humbly submits that Show cause notice dated
01.08.2024 Order-In-Original dated 22.01.2025, having a unique
reference ID, being uploaded on portal, was duly communicated to the
petitioners as per mandate of Section 169 of RGST Act, 2017.
[2026:RJ-JP:31554-DB]
(5 of 5)
[CW-178/2026]
48. The contents of Ground (D) to (G) are not admitted as stated and
denied in light of preliminary objection stated hereinabove, However,
additionally, the answering respondent humbly submits that Vide Show
Cause notice, the petitioner was duly provided with opportunity to file
reply, however, petitioner did not submit any response to the Show cause
notice and hence, the principles of natural justice were duly followed."
8.
The reply thus proceeds on the sole footing of uploading (that too
under a wrong tab/folder). Read as a whole, it amounts to a tacit
admission that the notice was placed in the wrong folder on the web
portal. The petitioners consequently had no occasion to notice or have
knowledge of it amounting to causing of service within the meaning of
section 169 of the Act. Their absence followed from that, and so did the
denial of personal hearing. The impugned Order in Original dated
22.01.2025 was passed in such state of affairs.
9.
In the premise, we are of the view that the petitioners are entitled
to be heard before any demand is confirmed. The writ petition is
accordingly disposed of with liberty to the respondents to pass fresh
orders after affording an opportunity of hearing in accordance with law
by issuing show cause notice afresh. Since fresh orders have been
directed, the impugned order dated 22.01.2025 the earlier notice dated
01.08.2024, both stand quashed. All pending applications stand
disposed of.
(ASHUTOSH KUMAR),J
46/Aman/Shivam
(ARUN MONGA),J
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review