Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Extraordinary Jurisdiction)
DATED: 26th September, 2018
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : THE HON’BLE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE, MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
WP(C) No. 60 of 2017
…… Petitioner
Himalaya Distilleries Limited
Versus
State of Sikkim and Others
…... Respondent(s)
Application under Article 226 of the Constitution of India
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance:
Mr. Debashis Baruah, Ms Nirmala Upadhyaya and
Mr. Passang Tshering Bhutia, Advocates for the Petitioner.
Mr. Karma Thinlay, Senior Government Advocate with
Mr. Thinlay Dorjee, Government Advocate, Mr. S.K. Chettri
and Mrs. Pollin Rai, Assistant Government Advocates for
State-Respondents No.1 to 4.
Mr. T.B. Thapa, Senior Advocate with Mr. T.R. Barfungpa,
Advocate for the Respondent No. 5.
Ms Yangchen D. Gyatso and Ms Tshering Palmoo Bhutia,
Advocate for the Respondents No. 6 and 7.
Mr. Sajal Sharma, Advocate for the Respondents No. 8 and
10.
Mr. N. Rai, Senior Advocate with Ms Malati Sharma, Advocate
for the Respondent No. 9.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
JUDGMENT
Meenakshi Madan Rai, ACJ
1.
The Petitioner is a limited company registered
under the provisions of the Registration of Companies Act,
WP(C) No. 60 of 2017
Himalaya Distilleries vs. State of Sikkim & Others
1961 and is in the business of manufacturing and bottling of
liquor at Majitar, Rangpo. The Petitioner‟s case is that one late
Kashi Raj Pradhan and his son, late Bhim Raj Pradhan, agreed
to sell a plot of land situated at Baghey Khola, measuring
5.3160 hectares, recorded in their names as well as that of
Swarup Raj Pradhan (Respondent No.8) and Kishore Raj
Pradhan (Respondent No.9), late Kashi Raj Pradhan being
their guardian. Towards this a Sale Deed was executed on
17.01.1983 between the Petitioner and late Kashi Raj Pradhan
and the land transferred to the Petitioner while the Sale Deed
was
submitted
registration
the
to
the
same
Office
year.
of
the
Sub-Registrar
for
Evidently,
registration
was
completed as a certified copy of the Sale Deed (Annexure P-1)
was furnished to the Petitioner on 5.12.84, in terms of Rule 8
of the Registration of Document Rules, 1930 (hereinafter
„Registration Rules‟). That, the Petitioner has since been in
possession of the land being of the impression that the right,
title and interest thereof stood transferred to it absolutely
unfettered. In the year 2009, however, the Petitioner came to
learn that the land in question stood recorded in the names of
one Sinora Pradhan and the Respondent No.10, Urmila
Pradhan. Vide a letter dated 28.09.2009, the Petitioner
questioned the Respondent No.3 of the above circumstance in
response to which confirmation was received of the fact vide a
communication (Memo No. 1013/DCE) dated 01.02.2013.
That, the Sale Deed (Annexure P-1) according to Respondent
WP(C) No. 60 of 2017
Himalaya Distilleries vs. State of Sikkim & Others
No. 3 had been submitted for registration but could not be
registered by the Authority then, for reasons best known to
them and the Petitioner was requested by the Respondent
No.3 to execute a fresh Sale Deed with the persons in whose
name the land stood mutated as the previous Deed could not
be considered in view of Rule 28 of the Registration Rules. The
Petitioner avers that the ambit of Rule 28 of the Registration
Rules pertains to documents which though registered remain
unclaimed for a period exceeding three years and not with
documents pending registration as in the instant case. In the
meanwhile, the search and enquiries pertaining to mutation of
the properties and land records in regard to Sinora Pradhan
and Respondent No.10 proved futile despite invocation of the
provisions of the Right to Information Act, 2005. Thus
aggrieved, the Petitioner approached this Court in W.P(C) No.
39 of 2013 (M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. State of Sikkim
and Others) which was disposed of vide Judgment and Order
dated 14.11.2013, with a direction that as agreed by the
parties, the petitioner could prefer an appeal before the
Registrar against the Memo dated 01.02.2013. The Registrar
was directed to hear the appeal on merit and the Petitioner
was free to approach this Court in the event of adverse orders
by the Registrar.
2.
Although,
the
Petitioner
complied
with
the
directions and assailed the said Memo dated 01.02.2013 of the
WP(C) No. 60 of 2017
Himalaya Distilleries vs. State of Sikkim & Others
Sub-Divisional Magistrate/Sub-Registrar, East District, before
the Respondent No.2, the matter was kept pending for almost
three years resulting in the Petitioner filing yet another
petition before this Court being WP(C) No. 26 of 2016 (M/s
Himalaya Distilleries Limited vs. State of Sikkim and Others)
complaining of the inaction supra. This Writ Petition was
considered on 12.06.2017 and an Order of the same date
directed the Appellate Authority to dispose of the Appeal not
later
than
(forty-five)
days
from
the
above
date.
Consequently, on 05.07.2017, the Petitioner was summoned
to appear before the Respondent No.2 (Appellate Authority)
on 10.07.2017, who upon recording that the original Sale
Deed was not before him directed the Respondent No.3 to
locate it and also to produce the original certified copy of the
deed obtained by the Petitioner. On 21.07.2017, when the
matter was heard although the Petitioner furnished the
original certified copy but the Respondent No.3 failed to
furnish the original deed. A written report dated 21.07.2017
(for clarity, Memo No. 484/DCE) submitted by the Respondent
No.3 to the Respondent No.2 (Appellate Authority) was duly
considered sans copy or information being furnished to the
Petitioner. The report informed that the original Sale Deed
document dated 17.01.1983, as well as the entire related
registration proceedings could not be traced in the office of
the Respondent No.3 despite thorough search of the Record
Section contrary to what was stated in the Communication
WP(C) No. 60 of 2017
Himalaya Distilleries vs. State of Sikkim & Others
dated 01.02.2013. That, it would stand to reason therefore,
that
the
Sale
Deed and the
registration records
were
deliberately misplaced/lost to deprive the Petitioner of its
rights in respect of the land. The Order dated 25.07.2017 of
the Respondent No.2, dismissed the Petitioner‟s Appeal, inter
alia, on grounds that the original Sale Deed document could
not be produced by the Respondent No.3, the relevant File
pertaining to the Registration proceedings were not traceable,
the executant of the Sale Deed had passed away and
26(twenty-six) years had elapsed since execution of the Sale
Deed and its submission for registration. It was also held that
insufficient material furnished before the Respondent No.2
disabled it from further investigation into the matter.
That,
the Sale Deed dated 17.01.1983 sought to be registered is no
longer in existence, hence no question of registration arises.
According to the Petitioner, even if the original sale deed
dated 17.01.1983 and the related files are missing, the
contents thereof can easily be traced from the original
certified copies issued by the Respondent No.3. That, as the
execution, presentation and submission of the original sale
deed are undisputed, there ought to be a reconstruction of the
original sale deed by using the original certified copy thereof
and the deed registered if not already completed. In fact, on
due application of Rule 8 of the Registration Rules, the
certified copy should have been treated as sufficient evidence
of the instrument on loss, misplacement or destruction of the
WP(C) No. 60 of 2017
Himalaya Distilleries vs. State of Sikkim & Others
original instrument. That, merely because a delay of 26
(twenty-six) years occurred, the Petitioner cannot be deprived
of its right as the Registering Authority cannot refuse
registration of a deed validly presented before it and accepted.
That, the procedure prescribed in Rule 7 to Rule 54 of the
Registration Rules ought to be observed. The reliefs sought
for, inter alia, are as follows;
(1)
Writ or in the nature of mandamus cancelling or
recalling the impugned Order dated 25.07.2017 of
the Respondent No.2 and Memo dated 01.02.2013
issued by the Respondent No.3.
(2)
Writ or in the nature of certiorari commanding the
Respondents No. 2 and 3 to forward all relevant
records in relation to the instant case.
(3)
Writ in the nature of mandamus or like nature
commanding the Respondent Authorities to forthwith
complete the process of registration of the instrument
dated 17.01.1983, by treating the certified copy
thereof as the original instrument.
(4)
Rule NISI in terms of the prayers.
(5)
In the absence of sufficient cause to make the Rule
NISI absolute.
3.
The Respondents No. 1, 2, 3 and 4 filed a joint
counter-affidavit denying and disputing the allegations and
would specifically aver that the Petition is liable to be
WP(C) No. 60 of 2017
Himalaya Distilleries vs. State of Sikkim & Others
dismissed having been brought after more than 26 (twentysix) years when the executants thereof are no more and there
is a change in ownership, hence the Petitioner‟s remedy lies
before the Civil Court. The Respondents No. 1 to 4 deny that
the Registration Rules indicate that when the original deeds
are not forthcoming, the copies of the deeds shall be received
as evidence of such deeds
and the provisions of the
Registration Rules, being Rule 8 and Rule 28 are being
wrongly interpreted by the Petitioner. Annexure P-1 is an
unregistered certified copy as it
does not contain
the
registration seal with the book number, serial number and
date of registration. While supporting the Order of the
Respondent No.2 dated 25.07.2018, it was averred that it was
a detailed order taking into consideration all aspects placed
before it and that allegations of misplacement of original by
the Registering Authority are bereft of material particulars. On
the failure of the Petitioner to place the Sale Deed for
registration in 1983, they
cannot now allege that the
authorities have in connivance with the private Respondents
purposely misplaced the records pertaining to the registration.
Responsibility
rests
on
the
Petitioner
to
see
that
the
documents so presented receive proper registration, hence the
grounds set out by the Petitioner are not tenable in the eyes
of law.
WP(C) No. 60 of 2017
Himalaya Distilleries vs. State of Sikkim & Others
4.
The Respondents No. 8 and 10 in their joint
counter-affidavit stated that the Petitioner has filed a Civil Suit
being Title Suit No. 11 of 2017 (Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. Vs.
Urmila Pradhan and Ors.) pending disposal before the Court of
the learned District Judge, East Sikkim at Gangtok, praying for
a decree, declaring right, title and interest in his favour in
respect of the “Schedule A” land while in the present Writ
Petition they have prayed for registration of certified copy of
Annexure P-1, hence the prayers are similar. That, execution,
presentation and submission of the original Sale Deed are
disputed
which
only
a
trial
can
determine.
That,
the
Government Respondents have rightly rejected the request of
the Petitioner for registration, as it is invalid in the eyes of law
sans the Sale Deed signed by late Kashi Raj Pradhan. That,
the purported Sale Deed, Annexure P-1, clearly suggests that
the property was not transferred to the Petitioner and neither
was consideration value or advance, paid. Hence, the Orders
dated 01.02.2013 of the Registering Authority and 25.07.2017
of the Appellate Authority were passed considering all relevant
facts and records. In fact, late Kashi Raj Pradhan had no right,
title and authority over the portion of the suit property
recorded in the name of the said Respondents and any
statement contrary to this fact is denied by the answering
Respondents. That, late Bhim Raj Pradhan in his written
statement in Title Suit No. 6 of 2014 (Himalaya Distilleries
Limited vs. Smt. Urmila Pradhan & Others) before the Court of
WP(C) No. 60 of 2017
Himalaya Distilleries vs. State of Sikkim & Others
the learned Principal District Judge, East Sikkim at Gangtok,
had categorically
denied the
averments
of the
Plaintiff
pertaining to sale of the property in question, execution of
sale deed and transferring the possession of the property to
the Petitioner. The Respondents also referred to Rule 8 and
Rule 28 of the Registration Rules and averred that both were
inapplicable to the instant matter. As per Registration Rules,
two sets of signed sale deeds are presented for registration
and one original sale deed is returned to the purchaser with
certification of the registering authority but the Petitioner in all
Fora is relying upon Annexure P-1, a copy, while interpreting
the rules as per their convenience. That, the question of the
Petitioner having a prima facie good case or suffering loss and
injury does not arise. The instant Writ Petition besides being
inordinately delayed, lacks in merit and considering that a
Title
Suit is pending, this Petition
thereby
deserves a
dismissal.
5.
Respondent
No.10,
Urmila
Pradhan,
the
constituted attorney of the Respondent No.9, in her counteraffidavit on her son‟s behalf while denying and disputing the
allegations in the Petition averred that simply obtaining a
certified copy from the Registrar of documents will not confer
rights on the Petitioner over the property/land of the parties.
It is the duty of the Registrar to issue the certified copy from
the records maintained by him if a party applies for such
WP(C) No. 60 of 2017
Himalaya Distilleries vs. State of Sikkim & Others
copies and unless the document is registered as per the
Registration Rules and in consonance with the Transfer of
Property Act, 1881, the Petitioner has no case, moreover the
disputed property is still in the possession of the original
owner. Besides, Annexure P-1 is not an original document and
the Registering Authority is not bound to put forth an
explanation
for
an
unregistered
document.
That,
the
possession of two plots of land was with the Respondent No.9
till 2005 and thereafter has been transferred in the name of
Respondent No.10 which is now in her possession. That, the
names of Sinora Pradhan and the Respondent No.10 were
recorded after observing due formalities and the very fact that
the Petitioner came to learn of this in the year 2009 indicates
that their claims are illegal. The Respondent also raised
questions about the interpretation of Rule 8, Rule 20 and Rule
28 of the Registration Rules and submitted that the instant
Petition is not an efficacious method for obtaining the reliefs
by the Petitioner. The response of this Respondent largely
reiterated
what
the
submitted
that
as
other
the
respondents
Petitioner
has
had
stated
filed
the
and
instant
misconceived Writ Petition devoid of merits, it deserves to be
dismissed.
6.
In the Rejoinder to the counter-affidavit of the
Respondents No. 1 to 4, the Petitioner would, inter alia, state
that it is the duty of the Registering Office being the custodian
WP(C) No. 60 of 2017
Himalaya Distilleries vs. State of Sikkim & Others
of the said document to preserve and maintain safe custody of
the document. Under no circumstances, the document could
have been destroyed in violation of Rule 34 of the Registration
Rules. The invocation of Rule 28 of the Registration Rules in
the impugned Order/Memo dated 01.02.2013 is testament to
the fact that the said document was destroyed by the
Registration Office. The Appellate Authority could not find any
records
justifying
or
showing
that
the
document
was
destroyed. In such circumstances, the rights of the Petitioner
cannot be annulled as it was dereliction and abdication of the
duties by the statutory authorities. The statement that there
has been change of ownership of the land during the
interregnum and as such the said document cannot be taken
up for registration is totally misconceived. The Registering
Authority is to look into the title as on the date of presentation
and the presence of the executants or the person claiming
under the document is not required for registration as evident
from the Registration Rules. That, the burden lies upon the
Registering Office to show as to what the Registration Office
did to the duly executed Sale Deed dated 17.01.1983.
7.
In the Rejoinder affidavit to the counter-affidavit
of the Respondents No.8 and 10, the Petitioner would, inter
alia, contend that the cause of action for filing of Civil Suit is
completely different to the cause of action for filing the instant
Writ Petition as the challenge in the Writ Petition is to the
WP(C) No. 60 of 2017
Himalaya Distilleries vs. State of Sikkim & Others
Memo dated 01.02.2013 and Order dated 25.07.2017, on the
grounds of abuse of power by the statutory authority and that
the impugned Orders suffer from malice in law and fact. The
suit filed by the Petitioner as Plaintiff is concerned with the
Petitioner‟s rights over the Schedule lands mentioned in the
Plaint, clouded by the action of the private Respondents herein
and seeks confirmation of possession and restoration of the
concerned property from the Respondents No. 8 to 10. That,
the statement to the effect that late Kashi Raj Pradhan had
no right, title and authority over the land recorded in the
names of the Respondents No. 8, 9 and 10 is misconceived
since acting as karta he had duly executed the deed of sale
dated 17.01.1983. The written statement of late Bhim Raj
Pradhan in Title Suit No. 6/2014 is only pleadings, not proof.
Respondents No. 5, 6 and 7, who are the successors in
interest of late Bhim Raj Pradhan, have admitted the fact of
sale in their statements filed in Title Suit No. 11/2017, and
thus waived their right to contest the suit filed by the
Petitioner by filing written statement. That, the attempts by
the Respondents to dispute the existence, contents and
execution of Annexure P-1 amounts to a clear ruse of the
Respondents to mislead this Court from the dispute involved in
the present proceedings and the counter-affidavit ought to be
rejected.
WP(C) No. 60 of 2017
Himalaya Distilleries vs. State of Sikkim & Others
8.
The Rejoinder of the Petitioner to the counter-
affidavit filed by the Respondent No.9, inter alia, averred that
the Respondent No. 9 having been divested of his rights in
respect of the land in question vide a Deed of Sale dated
17.01.1983 could not have transferred the said land by any
means to the Respondent No.10. That, when the Deed of Sale
was executed on 17.01.1983, the Respondent No. 9 appears
to have been 9 years old and attained majority in the year
1992, however, despite knowledge of the Document he
neither challenged it nor did he have possession of any portion
of the land mentioned in the said Deed until 24.04.2014, when
the Respondents No. 8, 9 and 10 along with one Sinora
Pradhan forcefully took possession of an area measuring 2.52
hectares of land. However, recording of the name of Sinora
Pradhan could not have been done in accordance with law as
the Respondents No. 8 and 9 had no authority whatsoever to
transfer the land after the Sale Deed, Annexure P-1. It is for
this reason that the Petitioner has filed a suit for recovery of
possession of that land. This however is not relevant for
determination
of
the
issues
involved
in
the
instant
proceedings. That, Rule 20 of the Registration Rules is not
applicable to the present facts as admittedly Annexure P-1
was duly submitted after being executed in the year 1983 and
the Registering Office never intimated the Petitioner or the
executant who presented the Deed of Sale for registration that
WP(C) No. 60 of 2017
Himalaya Distilleries vs. State of Sikkim & Others
it was barred by the said provision, hence the counter-affidavit
ought not to be acted upon.
9.
Learned Counsel for the Petitioner while advancing
his arguments reiterated the facts put forth in his pleadings
and contended that till the year 2009 the Petitioner was of the
belief that the land in question was registered in the name of
the Company in view of Annexure P-1. However, when the
Petitioner sought to deposit tax for the land in question in
2009, they came to learn that it was registered in the name of
one Sinora Pradhan and another. That, mere records of rights
in the names of the aforestated persons do not create title
over immovable property. Besides, the Respondent No.3 is not
required to look into the title or beyond the Sale Deed
document for its registration. On this count, reliance was
placed on the ratio of the High Court of Bombay in
Chairman/Secretary, Deep Apartment CHS Ltd. vs. The State of
Maharashtra & Ors
and Satya Pal Anand vs. State of Madhya
That, to the contrary, Annexure P-1 is
Pradesh and Others .
proof of sale of the property in question between Kashi Raj
Pradhan
and
the
Petitioner.
Drawing
attention
to
the
impugned Memo of Respondent No.3, it was argued that Rule
21 of the Registration Rules stipulates that a document
required to be registered shall be presented either by the
2013 (1) Bom CR 663
(2016) 10 SCC 767
WP(C) No. 60 of 2017
Himalaya Distilleries vs. State of Sikkim & Others
person executing it or by the person claiming under it after
which the Registering Authority ought to take needful steps in
terms thereof. Neither the presence of the executants nor the
person claiming under the said document are required
thereafter. That, the Registration Rules do not indicate that
the copies of such deeds should bear the serial number, book
number or date of registration as averred by the Respondents.
The issuance of a copy coupled with the clear admission on
the part of the Registering Authority in the impugned Memo
that the deed of sale after execution was presented for
registration, indicates that the Sale Deed was duly registered.
That,
Rule
of
the
Registration
Rules
provide
that
documents other than Wills remaining unclaimed in any
Register for a period extending three years may be destroyed
but in the instant case, the original deed in question was
pending registration therefore the document being unclaimed
does not arise. That, application of the provisions of Rule 28
requires compliance of procedure envisaged in Rule 32 to Rule
34 of the Registration Rules. It was further contended that the
Respondent No.2 failed to exercise its lawful authority under
law by not setting aside the impugned Memo and directing the
Respondent No.3 to comply with the process of registration if
it had not already been done. The question of executing a new
Sale Deed between Respondent No.10, Sinora Pradhan and
the Petitioner does not arise as the original of Annexure P-1 is
with the Respondent No.3. Thus, the Registering Authority
WP(C) No. 60 of 2017
Himalaya Distilleries vs. State of Sikkim & Others
ought to have viewed the claim of the Petitioner based on
Annexure P-1 filed on the date of execution of the document
and
not
on
a
document
created
subsequently.
That,
inconsistencies in the impugned Memo and Order of the
Respondent Authorities provide reasons to believe that the
loss/misplacement of Sale Deed was deliberate to deny and
frustrate the Petitioner‟s claim over the land in question.
Relying on Rule 8 of the Registration Rules, it was contended
that
the
registration
proceedings
ought
to
have
been
reconstructed and registration process completed, failure
thereof calls for interference by this Court and the actions of
the Respondent Authorities violates the mandate of Article
300A of the Constitution of India. Calling attention to Rule 7 of
the Registration Rules, it was put forth that in compliance
thereof it is the duty of the Registering Authority after
completing registration to hand back the original document to
the Appellant, which admittedly has not been done thereby
constituting dereliction of duties. Strength was also drawn
from Rule 26 of the Registration Rules and contended that
when the Registrar finds that the document has been duly
executed, the applicants are entitled to registration and the
document shall be ordered to be registered compulsorily.
While Rule 20 of the said Rules is not applicable to the instant
facts. Claiming that there was no wilful delay or laches in
presenting the instant Petition and hence, the reliefs as prayed
WP(C) No. 60 of 2017
Himalaya Distilleries vs. State of Sikkim & Others
be granted. Succour was also garnered from the decision in
Commissioner of Police, Bombay vs. Gordhandas Bhanji .
10.
Learned Senior Government Advocate for the
State-Respondents No. 1 to 4, while also relying on the
averments made in the pleadings would contend the purported
Sale Deed suggests that the property has not been transferred
to the Petitioner neither has consideration amount been paid
thereby proving that the Petitioner‟s prayer is not valid. That,
due procedure prescribed for registration not having been
followed at the relevant time, it cannot be done now and the
only possibility for registration is on a new deed being
executed between the registered owners and the Petitioner. It
was also contended that the Petitioner has raised disputed
questions of fact which cannot be adjudicated in a petition
under Article 226 of the Constitution.
11.
Learned Counsel for the Respondents No. 5, 6 and
7, would submit that a response has been filed by the
Respondents in Title Suit No. 11 of 2017, wherein they have
stated that they were given to understand that the suit
property had subsequently been sold but they have no further
knowledge as to the manner, extent and circumstance in
which such sale was carried out. Consequently, he has no
further submissions to make in this matter.
AIR 1952 SC 16
WP(C) No. 60 of 2017
Himalaya Distilleries vs. State of Sikkim & Others
12.
Learned
Counsel
for
the
Respondent
No.
submitted that if the Petitioner was of the belief that the
certified copy was proof of registration then its rights are
secured and it is incomprehensible as to why the Petitioner is
before this Court. To the contrary, a perusal of Annexure P-1
would reveal that although consideration value has been
reflected therein, no date of payment of the consideration
value issues therein and neither is there indication of payment
of money. The date of execution of the deed is blank, as also
the names of the witnesses and hence, cannot be said to be a
registered deed. The Petitioner is therefore required to prove
the document. Reliance was placed on K. Nanjappa (dead) by
Legal Representatives vs. R.A. Hameed alias Ameersab (dead) by
Legal Representatives and Another . It is his contention that Rule
38 and Rule 43 of the Registration Rules have not been
complied with. Besides, the Petition suffers from delay and
laches as the purported sale was of 1983 and the registration
is being sought in 2009. That, the Writ Petition deserves a
dismissal.
13.
Learned Counsel for the Respondents No.8 and 10
would point to Rule 7, Rule 22, Rule 38 and Rule 43 of the
Registration Rules and argue that none of the Rules have been
complied with by the Petitioner. Over and above this was the
fact that the Petitioner is before the Court after a period of
(2016) 1 SCC 762
WP(C) No. 60 of 2017
Himalaya Distilleries vs. State of Sikkim & Others
26(twenty-six) years and hence being guilty of delay and
laches, the Petition ought to be dismissed. To fortify his
submissions, reliance was placed on Shankara Cooperative
Housing Society Limited vs. M. Prabhakar and Others , State of
Maharashtra vs. Digambar . That, the Respondents No.2 and 3
have issued correct orders and this Court exercising powers
under Article 226 of the Constitution ought not to sit as a
Court of Appeal to substitute its own judgment for that of the
Statutory Authorities. In this context, reliance was placed on
Beant Singh vs. Union of India and Others .
14.
parties
The rival contentions of learned Counsel for all
were
heard
in
extenso
and
the
pleadings
and
documents carefully perused as also citations made at the Bar.
The relevant Registration Rules relied on by the parties have
also been carefully examined by me.
15.
It is now to be determined whether the Petitioner
is entitled to the reliefs claimed.
16.
While addressing the grievances and arguments of
the Petitioner, it would be apposite to first refer to the “Sikkim
State Rules Registration of Document Rules, 1930” to have an
understanding thereof. The said Rules, inter alia, provides for
2011) 5 SCC 607
(1995) 4 SCC 683
AIR 1977 SC 388
WP(C) No. 60 of 2017
Himalaya Distilleries vs. State of Sikkim & Others
the head registry Office in Sikkim at Gangtok where the
registering Officer shall be known as Registrar. Sub-offices of
the registry of deeds were established in 12(twelve) places in
the erstwhile Kingdom of Sikkim and the registering Officers at
the said places were to be known as Sub-Registrars. Rule 2
makes
provisions
for
maintaining
registers
for
absolute
transfer of property, other transfer of immovable property i.e.
mortgage, etc., register of decrees and orders of court and
award of arbitrators and a general register. Rules 3 and 4
enumerate details of other registers to be maintained. Rule 5
requires the Sub-Registrar to perform his duties under the
superintendence and control of the Gangtok Registrar. Rule 6
empowers the Registrar to revise or alter any order of any
Sub-Registrar refusing to admit a document if an appeal
against such orders was presented to the Registrar within a
month from the date of order. The procedure to be observed
in the “Registry of Deeds” is enumerated in Rule 7 to Rule 54
of the said Rules.
17.
In this milieu, while addressing the contention of
the Petitioner that the Rules do not provide that the Sale Deed
document should bear serial number, book number or date of
registration, we may usefully refer to Rule 7 which is
reproduced herein below;
“7.
The person or persons executing the deed
or his or their authorised representative with one
or more witnesses to the execution of it, shall
attend at the Registrar‟s office and prove by
solemn affirmation before the Registrar the due
WP(C) No. 60 of 2017
Himalaya Distilleries vs. State of Sikkim & Others
execution of deeds upon which the Registrar
shall cause an exact copy of the deed to be
entered in the proper register and after having
caused it to be carefully compared with the
original shall attest the copy with his
signature and shall also cause the parties
or their authorised representative in
attendance to subscribe their signatures to
the copy and shall then return the original with
a certificate under his signature endorsed
thereto specifying the date on which such deed
was so registered with REFERENCE to the book
containing the registry thereof and the page and
number under which the same shall have been
entered therein.”
18.
The Rule may be elucidated thus;
(1)
On execution of deeds, the person or persons
executing the deed or his or their authorised
representative with one or more witnesses to
the execution of the deed is to attend the
Registrar‟s Office.
(2)
These persons are required to prove by solemn
affirmation before the Registrar the due
execution of the deed.
(3)
Upon such affirmation the Registrar shall cause
an exact copy of the deed to be entered in the
proper register, viz., registers as detailed at
Rule 2 supra.
(4)
After the copy is carefully compared with the
original, the Registrar shall attest the copy
with his signature.
(5)
He shall also cause the parties or their
representatives in attendance to subscribe
their signatures to the copy.
(6)
The Registrar shall then return the original with
a certificate under his signature endorsed
therein specifying the date on which such deed
was so registered.
(7)
For this purpose reference has to be made to
the book containing the registration thereof,
and the page and number under which the
same shall have been entered therein.
WP(C) No. 60 of 2017
Himalaya Distilleries vs. State of Sikkim & Others
19.
Rule 7 of the Registration Rules is fortified by Rule
21, which provides that;
“21. A document required to be registered shall
be presented either by the person executing it or
by the person claiming under it.”
20.
It has to be agreed, as pointed out by the
Petitioner that Rule 7 nowhere prescribes that the copies of
the deed shall contain the aforestated details, viz., serial
number, book number or date of registration, those details are
to be entered in the original Deed. At the same time, it is
relevant to consider the other aspect of Rule 7, which
mandates that the copy is to be attested by the Registrar with
his signature. He
is required to
cause
the
parties
or
representatives to subscribe their signatures on the copy. On
the touchstone of these requirements, we may usefully refer
to Annexure P-1 which is admittedly a „certified to be true
copy‟ of the original Sale Deed. The original is allegedly
untraceable. The reverse of the document records “CERTIFIED
TO BE TRUE COPY”, below which an illegible signature appears
and bears the stamp of the “Registration Clerk” and the date
5.12.84. The specific requirement of Rule 7 pertaining to
copies of deeds is that the Registrar shall attest the copy with
his signature and not that of the “Registration Clerk” as
appears to have been done in the instant matter. In absence
of the Registrar‟s signature, a niggling doubt ensues as to the
authenticity of the document. The document also ought to
bear
the
signature
of
the
parties
or
their
authorised
WP(C) No. 60 of 2017
Himalaya Distilleries vs. State of Sikkim & Others
representative(s) which are non-existent on Annexure P-1. It
is evident that Annexure P-1 does not fulfil any of the
requirements as envisaged by Rule 7 of the Registration Rules.
21.
We may now relevantly look to the decision of the
Hon‟ble Supreme Court in Satya Pal Anand (supra), wherein it
was, inter alia, held that;
“41. Section 35 of the Act does not confer
a quasi-judicial power on the Registering
Authority. The Registering Officer is expected to
reassure that the document to be registered is
accompanied by supporting documents. He is
not expected to evaluate the title or irregularity
in the document as such. The examination to be
done by him is incidental, to ascertain that there
is no violation of provisions of the Act of 1908.
In the case of Park View Enterprises (supra) it
has been observed that the function of the
Registering Officer is purely administrative and
not quasi-judicial. He cannot decide as to
whether a document presented for registration is
executed by person having title, as mentioned in
the instrument. We agree with that exposition.”
22.
The
ratio
explains the
role
assigned to
the
Registering Authority as provided under the Registration Act
1908. It exposits that Authority cannot decide whether a
document presented for registration is executed by person
having title as mentioned in the instrument. For the purposes
of the matter at hand, the Registration of Document Rules,
are
relevant
which
make
express
provisions
for
registration of documents in the State of Sikkim. Here too, the
Registering Authority is debarred from making an enquiry into
title, this falls in the domain of the Civil Courts. Respondent
No.3 has not refused registration on the basis of Title but as
WP(C) No. 60 of 2017
Himalaya Distilleries vs. State of Sikkim & Others
evident from the impugned Memo has invoked Rule 28 of the
Registration Rules, which provides that Documents (other than
wills) remaining unclaimed in any registration office for a
period exceeding three years may be destroyed. In other
words, it can be culled out that the assumption of Respondent
No.3 was that considering the lapse of 26 years since the
alleged initial process, the document in all probability was
destroyed/untraceable. It is but trite to mention that the
Registering Authority does require to satisfy himself that the
persons before him are the persons to have executed the
deed. Rule 7 of the Registration Rules demands much the
same along with Rule 21 already extracted hereinabove for
reference. It is thereafter that the process of registration
commences. In the instant matter, the Petitioner who sought
registration of Annexure P-1 in 2009 has „sent‟ the document
to the Respondent No.3 and not appeared before the
Respondent No.3 as would be evident from the impugned
Memo dated 01.02.2013. Secondly, even assuming that a
personal appearance was made before the Respondent No.3
with Annexure P-1, it is no one‟s case that the presenter was
the party to the execution of Annexure P-1 or the person
claiming under it. The identity of the person who presented
Annexure P-1 in 2009 has not been disclosed by the Petitioner
while on the other hand the executant of the purported Sale
Deed has since passed away and the execution of the
document, if at all was done 26(twenty-six) years ago.
WP(C) No. 60 of 2017
Himalaya Distilleries vs. State of Sikkim & Others
23.
The Hon‟ble Supreme Court in the matter of Satya
Pal Anand
(supra) referring to the decision in Thota Ganga
Laxmi vs. State of A.P , held as follows;
“46. In our considered view, the decision
in the case of Thota Ganga Laxmi (supra) was
dealing with an express provision, as applicable
to the State of Andhra Pradesh and in particular
with regard to the registration of an
Extinguishment Deed. In absence of such an
express provision, in other State legislations, the
Registering Officer would be governed by the
provisions in the Act of 1908. Going by the said
provisions, there is nothing to indicate that the
Registering Officer is required to undertake a
quasi judicial enquiry regarding the veracity of
the factual position stated in the document
presented for registration or its legality, if the
tenor of the document suggests that it requires
to be registered. The validity of such registered
document can, indeed, be put in issue before a
Court of competent jurisdiction.”
The above ratio would indicate that where express
provision is made for registration of a particular deed, the
provisions have necessarily to be adhered to. The Registration
Rules in the instant matter are to be duly complied with. As
already discussed, the document Annexure P-1 is lacking in
material details under the specific provision of the Rules
referred to.
24.
Rule 8 of the Registration Rules provides that the
Registrar shall on application being made to him, allow all
persons to inspect the Register books as well as grant copies
of all deeds registered by him to persons whom they may
concern and such copies in the event of original being lost,
(2010) 15 SCC 207
WP(C) No. 60 of 2017
Himalaya Distilleries vs. State of Sikkim & Others
destroyed or not forthcoming, shall be received as sufficient
evidence of such deeds. Pausing here for a moment, no prayer
appears to have been made by the Petitioner for inspection of
the Registers in the Office of the Respondent No.3 as provided
by the Rule. While considering the argument of learned
Counsel for the Petitioner that Annexure P-1 ought to have
been received as sufficient evidence of execution of the Sale
Deed as the original as well as its records have evidently been
lost or are untraceable in the concerned Office, it may be
essential once more to revisit Rule 7 of the Registration Rules
and reiterate that Annexure P-1 is lacking in material
particulars in terms of the requirements thereof. In such a
circumstance, it stands to reason that the contents therein
cannot be relied upon.
25.
Although, Rule 22 of the Registration Rules was
alluded to by the Respondents No.8 and 10, it evidently has
no bearing to the matter at hand as it provides that the
registration Officer after satisfying himself that the contents of
the document do not conflict with the existing land laws and
rules regarding the holding of immovable property in Sikkim
shall proceed with the registering of the document in
accordance with procedure specified in Paragraph (7) of the
Rules.
WP(C) No. 60 of 2017
Himalaya Distilleries vs. State of Sikkim & Others
26.
As per the Petitioner, the application of Rule 28 is
contingent upon compliance of Rule 32, Rule 33 and Rule 34
of the Registration Rules. The said Rules read as follows;
“32. The
following
records
shall
be
permanently preserved in the Registrar‟s Office
whether they are already there or whether they
are transferred thereto from the sub-Registering
Office.
(i)
Register of documents and their
indexes.
(ii)
Register of power of attorney.
(iii)
Reports of destruction of records
and lists of papers destroyed.
33. Every
Registering
Officer
shall
be
responsible for the preservation and safe
custody of all registration records, including
those of previous years which have accumulated
in or been transferred to his office.
34. No documents, books or papers whatever
shall be destroyed at any registration office
within the previous sanction of the Darbar.
Before any document is destroyed, an
endeavour must always be made by the
Registering Officer in whose Office the document
is kept to induce the presentant thereof to take
it back.”
27.
A reading of the Rules do not indicate what
punitive action the erring official would be subjected to, this of
course is a rhetorical statement. Rule 28 of the Registration
Rules have already been discussed. The Petitioner was before
the Registering Authority after a substantial lapse of time not
three years as anticipated in Rule 28. The Rules extracted
above do not lack lucidity. There is, thus, legitimate reason to
believe that if the original document existed the Registry was
not in folly for its misplacement or destruction. It is not the
WP(C) No. 60 of 2017
Himalaya Distilleries vs. State of Sikkim & Others
Petitioner‟s case that no endeavour was made by the
Registering Officer requesting the presentant to take back the
original. In fact, no light can be shed on this facet in the
nebulous circumstances of who went to present Annexure P-1
to Respondent No.3. Besides, the Respondent No.3 has
categorically stated in the impugned Memo dated 01.02.2013
that;
“…………………………………………………..
You had submitted a copy of sale deed executed
with a request to register the same in the year
1983. The said documents have been examined
as follows;
1)
That the sale deed was submitted
to the office in the year 1983.
2)
The deed could not be registered
then for the reason best known to
them.
3)
The sale deed was executed by 1)
Kashi Raj Pradhan, S/o Lt. Kalu Ram
Pradhan, 2) Bhim Raj Pradhan, S/o
Kashi Raj Pradhan, 3) Master Swarup
Raj Pradhan, S/o Chet Raj Pradhan, 4)
Master Kishor Raj Pradhan, S/o Lt.
Khagendra Raj Pradhan.
As per record, the land has already been
transferred and mutated in the name of Sinora
Pradhan & Urmila Pradhan. Since the land in
question has been recorded in the name of
Sinora Pradhan, W/o Lt. Chet Raj Pradhan and
Urmila Pradhan, W/o Lt. Khagendra Raj Pradhan
as per the records, you are requested to execute
a fresh set of sale deed for taking necessary
action as per standing Government norms.
............................................................”
28.
The Memo hereinabove does not indicate that the
document was destroyed and it appears to be an assumption
drawn by the Petitioner. The assumption of the official that the
WP(C) No. 60 of 2017
Himalaya Distilleries vs. State of Sikkim & Others
Sale Deed was submitted for registration is based on details
entered in Annexure P-1. There is no other document for
Respondent No.3 to draw such conclusions from. It may be
pointed out that Rule 20 of the Registration Rules is germane
to the issue contrary to the submissions of the Petitioner and
reads as follows;
“20. All instruments required to be registered
(Excepting a will) shall be produced within four
months from the date of execution thereof, but if
any instrument owing to unavoidable for the
Registrar in cases where the delay in
presentation has not exceeded six months to
direct that on payment of a penalty not
exceeding ten times the amount of the proper
registration fee such instrument may be
accepted for registration.”
29.
The above extracted Rule specifically lays down
that the period of limitation within which the document is to
be produced for registration is four months from the date of
execution thereof and six months at the maximum, this too
subject to deposit of penalty as prescribed in the Rules. The
original document is alleged to have been presented in 1983,
sans proof. The Petitioner has approached the Sub-Divisional
Magistrate/Sub-Registrar in the year 2009, no reasons have
been given for the delay in approaching the Registering
Authority. No explanation issues on what transpired between
1983 to 2009 and why necessary steps as envisaged by Rule
20 were not taken up by the Petitioner. The argument that the
Petitioner learnt of the transfer of land to other persons in
2009 when they went to pay land taxes is rather frail apart
WP(C) No. 60 of 2017
Himalaya Distilleries vs. State of Sikkim & Others
from the argument of payment of taxes being non-existent in
the pleadings. One would thereby mull over whether land tax
was not paid for the other years.
30.
The Appellate Authority in its impugned Order
would observe as follows;
“25/07/2017
.............................................................
Taken up for hearing on 21.07.2017
..................................................................
6. Since the original copy of the Sale Deed dated
17/01/1983 and the relevant file(s) pertaining to
the registration proceedings are missing and not
traceable in the Office of the Sub-Registrar and
in the interim period the executants of the Sale
Deed is also deceased and in view of the fact
that more than 26 years have lapsed since the
Sale deed in question was submitted for
registration, I find that there is insufficient
material evidence before me to further
investigate into the matter and to question the
findings of the Sub-Registrar as per his Order No
1013/DCE dated 01/02/2013 at this very late
stage.
7. Furthermore, the Sale Deed dated 17/01/1983
that is sought to be registered is no longer in
existence and hence there is no question of its
registration in any case.
8. Consequently,
for
the
reasons
stated
hereinabove, the Appeal stands dismissed.
Sd/25/7/2017
(Tsegyal Tashi), IAS
Appellate Authority
Land Revenue & D.M. Department”
31.
The Order succinctly spells out reasons for refusal
to register Annexure P-1, which on examination would also
reveal that details in the dotted lines are blank thereby
rendering the document speculative and incomplete. At this
WP(C) No. 60 of 2017
Himalaya Distilleries vs. State of Sikkim & Others
juncture relevant reference may be made to Rule 44 of the
Registration Rules which reads as follows;
“44. When a document occupies more than
one sheet of paper, the seal and signature of the
Registering Officer shall be attached to every
sheet.”
This Rule has to be read in conjunction with Rule 7 and
the requirements of which, as evident, are devoid in Annexure
P-1.
32.
That having been stated, it would be apposite to
consider the pleadings of the Petitioner at Paragraph 5, which
reads as follows;
“5.
That the Petitioner states that on
05.12.1984 a certified copy of the Deed of Sale
dated 17.01.1983 was furnished to the Petitioner
Company. It may be relevant herein to mention
that a perusal of the Registration of Documents
Rules, 1930 (hereinafter for short referred to as
the „Registration Rules‟) would go to show that
copies of Deeds which are registered can only be
furnished by the Registrar on an Application
being made to him and in the event of the
original being destroyed/lost or not forthcoming,
the said copies of the Deeds shall be received as
sufficient evidence of such Deeds. The furnishing
of the certified copy presupposes that the
Registration process was duly completed. ...”
The Petitioner seeks to exposit by this pleading that
Annexure P-1 indicates that the registration process was duly
completed. If that be so, it is indeed unfathomable as to why
the Petitioner would be before this Court or before the
Respondent
No.2
and
the
registration of Annexure P-1.
Respondent
No.3
seeking
WP(C) No. 60 of 2017
Himalaya Distilleries vs. State of Sikkim & Others
33.
Hence, in view of the shortcomings in Annexure
P-1 discussed above which flies in the face of the Registration
Rules, the question of application of Rule 8, I am afraid does
not arise, as Annexure P-1 cannot be received as evidence. On
the anvil of the discussions that have ensued hereinabove, it is
evident that the reliefs as prayed for cannot be granted.
34.
The
Writ
Petition
fails
and
is
accordingly
dismissed.
35.
No order as to costs.
36.
Records of the Respondent No.2 be transmitted
forthwith.
Sd/( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Acting Chief Justice
26.09.2018
Approved for reporting : Yes
Internet : Yes
bp
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review