Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010758512016
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
[3239]
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
FRIDAY, THE TENTH DAY OF APRIL
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K SURESH REDDY
CRIMINAL PETITION NO: 6749/2016
Between:
1. M/S. PEPSICO INDIA HOLDING PVT. LTD & ANOTHER, 3B,
DLF, CORPORATE PARK, S BLOCK, QUTAB ENCLAVE,
PHASE-III, GURGAON - 122002 REP. BY RAMAN VAKS
(ACCUSED NO. 2)
2. RAMAN VAKS, REGIONAL LOGISTICS MANAGER AND
NOMINEE, M/S. PEPSI CO INDIA HOLDINGS PVT. LTD. C/O.
ANNAVARAPU AGENCIES, GODOWN 8,9 & 10, JANAKI
RAMAIAH
ESTATES,
VIJAYAWADA,
GANGURU,
PENAMALURU MANDAL, KRISHNA DISTRICT - 521139
...PETITIONER/ACCUSED(S)
AND
1. STATE OF A P REP BY FOOD SAFETY OFFICER, Rep. by Food
Safety Officer, Prakasam District, Ontgole, Through its P.P. High
Court of Judicature at Hyderabad.
...RESPONDENT/COMPLAINANT
Counsel for the Petitioner/accused(S):
1. SAI SANJAY SURANENI
Counsel for the Respondent/complainant:
1. PUBLIC PROSECUTOR (AP)
CRIMINAL PETITION NO: 7011/2017
Between:
1. M/S.CHRISTY QUALITY FOODS PVT LTD & ANOTHER,
SURVEY
NO.335/16A,
NH-7,
POLUPALLI
VILLAGE,
PITANAKUPPAM POST - 635115, KRISHNAGIRI TALUK,
KRISHNAGIRI DISTRICT, TAMIL NADU, REPRESENTED BY ITS
AUTHORISED REPRESENTATIVE RIJISH MON GOVIANDAN.
2. RIJISH MON GOVAINDAN,, NOMINEE, M/S. CHRISTY QUALITY
FOODS PVT. LTD., SURVEY NO.335/16A, NH-7, POLUPALLI
VILLAGE, PITANAKUPPAM POST - 635115, KRISHNAGIRI
TALUK, KRISHNAGIRI DISTRICT, TAMIL NADU.
...PETITIONER/ACCUSED(S)
AND
1. STATE OF A P THRO P P, represented by Food Safety Officer,
Div-I, Chittoor District, through its Public Prosecutor, High Court of
Judicature at Hyderabad.
...RESPONDENT/COMPLAINANT
Counsel for the Petitioner/accused(S):
1. SAI SANJAY SURANENI
Counsel for the Respondent/complainant:
1. PUBLIC PROSECUTOR (AP)
CRIMINAL PETITION NO: 10639/2017
Between:
1. M/S.HEEMANAKSHI BAKERS PVT. LTD.,, SURVEY NO.709,
MEKAGUDA,
KOTHUR
MANDAL,
MAHABUBNAGAR,
TELANGANA-509228, REPRESENTED BY ITS AUTHORISED
REPRESENTATAIVE SNEHIT UPPULURI S/O. U.V.DATHADRI
...PETITIONER/ACCUSED
AND
1. STATE OF ANDHRA PRADESH REP BY P P, Represented by
Food Safety Officer, Prakasam District, through its Public
Prosecutor, High Court of Judicature at Hyderabad
...RESPONDENT/COMPLAINANT
Counsel for the Petitioner/accused:
1. SAI SANJAY SURANENI
Counsel for the Respondent/complainant:
1. PUBLIC PROSECUTOR (AP)
CRIMINAL PETITION NO: 3523/2018
Between:
1. M/S. PEPSICO INDIA HOLDINGS PVT LTD, LEVEL 3-6,
PIONEER SQUARE, SECTOR-62, GURUGRAM, HARYANA 122001 REP. BY ITS AUTHORISED REPRESENTATIVE
2. RAMAN VAKS, LICENSEE, M/S. PEPSICO INDIA HOLDINGS
PVT. LTD., LEVEL 3-6, PIONEER SQUARE, SECTOR-62,
GURUGRAM, HARYANA - 122001
3. RIJISH MON GOVINDAN, NOMINEE, M/S. PEPSICO INDIA
HOLDINGS PVT. LTD.,
SURVEY NO. 335/16A, NH-7,
POLUPALLI VILLAGE, KRISHNAGIRI, TAMIL NADU-635115.
4. M/S. CHRISTY QUALITY FOODS PVT.LTD.,, SURVEY
NO.335/16A, NH-7,
POLUPALLI VILLAGE, KRISHNAGIRI,
TAMIL NADU-635115.
REP. BY ITS AUTHORISED
REPRESENTATIVE.
...PETITIONER/ACCUSED(S)
AND
1. THE STATE OF A P, Rep by Food Safety Officer, Srikakulam
District, Through its Public Prosecutor, High Court of Judicature
at Hyderabad.
...RESPONDENT/COMPLAINANT
Counsel for the Petitioner/accused(S):
1. JYOTHI RATNA ANUMOLU
2. SAI SANJAY SURANENI
Counsel for the Respondent/complainant:
1. PUBLIC PROSECUTOR (AP)
CRIMINAL PETITION NO: 3536/2018
Between:
1. M/S. PEPSICO INDIA HOLDINGS PVT LTD, R/O. LEVEL 3-6,
PIONEER SQUARE, SECTOR-62., GURGRAM, HARYANA
2. RAM VIKAS LICENSEE, R/O. LEVEL 3-6, PIONEER SQUARE,
SECTOR-62., GURGRAM, HARYANA
3. RIJISH MON GIVINDAN, R/O. 335/16A.,
VILLAGE., KRISHNAGIRI, TAMILANADU
NH-7., POLUPALLI
4. CHRISTY QUALITY FOODS PVT.LTD, R/O. 335/16A, NH-7.,
POPUPALLI VILLAGE., KRISHNAGIRI, TAMILANADU
...PETITIONER/ACCUSED(S)
AND
1. THE STATE OF A P, Rep. by its Public Prosecutor High Court at
Hyderabad
...RESPONDENT/COMPLAINANT
Counsel for the Petitioner/accused(S):
1. SAI SANJAY SURANENI
Counsel for the Respondent/complainant:
1. PUBLIC PROSECUTOR (AP)
CRIMINAL PETITION NO: 2611/2022
Between:
1. M/S. PEPSICO INDIA HOLDINGS PVT. LTD.,, FRITO LAY
DIVISION, C-5, MIDC, RANJANGAON, TALUKA SHIRUR, PUNE412220, MAHARASHTRA, HAVING ITS REGISTERED OFFICE
AT-LEVEL 3-6, PIONEER SQUARE, SECTOR 62, NEAR GOLF
COURSE EXTENSION ROAD, GURUGRAM -122101, HARYANA
REPRESENTED BY ITS AUTHORISED REPRESENTATIVE K.
SUNIL REDDY, S/O K. BUCHI REDDY AGED ABT- 35YRS R/O
31-3-1411, SURENDRAPURI COLONY, HANUMAKAONDA,
WARANGAL, TELANGANA-506370.
2. VAISHALI ASHISH KHARE,, NOMINEE M/S. PEPSICO INDIA
HOLDINGS PVT. LTD. FRITO LAY DIVISION, C-5, MIDC,
RANJANGAON,
TALUKA
SHIRUR,
PUNE-412220,
MAHARASHTRA
...PETITIONER/ACCUSED(S)
AND
1. STATE OF ANDHRA PRADESH, Represented by Food Safety
Officer, 0/o Gazetted Food Inspector and Food Safety Designated
Officer D.No. 26-2-1586, Vedayapalem, SPS Nellore Dist., Nellore
Through its Public Prosecutor, High Court of Judicature at
Amravati
...RESPONDENT/COMPLAINANT
Counsel for the Petitioner/accused(S):
1. JYOTHI RATNA ANUMOLU
2. SAI SANJAY SURANENI
Counsel for the Respondent/complainant:
1. PUBLIC PROSECUTOR (AP)
CRIMINAL PETITION NO: 2614/2022
Between:
1. M/S PEPSI CO INDIA HOLDINGS PVT LTD, (FRITO-LAY
DIVISION), C-5, MIDC, RANJANGAON, TALUKASHIRUR, PUNE
-412220, MAHARASTRA HAVING ITS REGISTERED OFFICE AT
LEVEL 3-6, PIONEER SQUARE, SECTOR 62, NEAR GOLF
COURSE EXTENSION ROAD, GURUGRAM - 122101,
HARYANA
REPRESENTED
BY
ITS
AUTHORISED
REPRESENTATIVE K. SUNIL REDDY, S/O K. BUCHI REDDY
AGED ABT. 35YRS R/O 31-3-1411, SURENDRAPURI COLONY,
HANUMAKAONDA, WARANGAL, TELANGANA-506370.
2. SHAILENDRA BHARADWAJ, S/O BHARADWAJ, QUALITY
ASSURANCE - MANAGER AND NOMINEE, M/S PEPSICO
INDIA HOLDING PVT. LTD., (FRITO-LAY DIVISION), C-5, MIDC,
RANJANGAON,
TALUKA
SHIRUR,
PUNE-412220,
MAHARASTRA.
...PETITIONER/ACCUSED(S)
AND
1. THE STATE OF ANDHRA PRADESH, Represented by Food
Safety Officer, GVMC area, Visakhapatnam District.
...RESPONDENT/COMPLAINANT
Counsel for the Petitioner/accused(S):
1. JYOTHI RATNA ANUMOLU
2. SAI SANJAY SURANENI
Counsel for the Respondent/complainant:
1. PUBLIC PROSECUTOR (AP)
CRIMINAL PETITION NO: 4508/2022
Between:
1. M/S. PEPSICO INDIA HOLDINGS PVT. LTD, ., HAVING ITS
REGISTERED OFFICE AT- LEVEL 3-6, PIONEER SQUARE,
SECTOR- 62. GURUGRAM HARYANA-122101 ALSO ATGOWDOWN NO- 8, 9, AND 10, J ANAKI RAMAIAH ESTATE,
GANGURU, PENAMALURU MANDAL, KRISHNA DISTRICT
REPRESENTED BY ITS AUTHORISED REPRESENTATIVE K.
SWILL REDDY, S/O K. BUCHI REDDY AGED ABT- 35YRS R/O
31-3-1411, SURENDRAPURI COLONY, HANUMAKAONDA,
WARANGAL, TELANGANA-506370.
2. RAVAPATI SRINATH REDDY, UNIT SUPPLY CHAIN MANAGER
AND NOMINEE OF NI/S. PEPSICO INDIA HOLDING PVT. LTD.
GOWDOWN NO- 8, 9, AND 10, JANAKI RAMAIAH ESTATE,
ANGUNI, PENAMALURU NLANDO.1, KRISHNA DISTRICT.
...PETITIONER/ACCUSED(S)
AND
1. STATE OF ANDHRA PRADESH, Rep by P.P.High Court of AP.,
at Amaravathi, through Represented by Food Safety Officer, O/o.
Gazetted Food Inspector and Food Safety Designated Officer,
D.No. 26-2-1586, Venkat Reddy Nagar, Gandhi Nagar Road,
Vedayapalem, Nellore -524004, SPS Nellore District Nellore
...RESPONDENT/COMPLAINANT
Counsel for the Petitioner/accused(S):
1. JYOTHI RATNA ANUMOLU
2. SAI SANJAY SURANENI
Counsel for the Respondent/complainant:
1. PUBLIC PROSECUTOR (AP)
CRIMINAL PETITION NO: 1647/2023
Between:
1. DEVISETTY VENKATA SURESH BABU@ SURESH BABU, AGE
58 YEARS, S/O SUBBAIAH, SALES IN-CHARGE OF M/S
KUMAR AGENCIES,
18/393, LANGARKHAN STREET,
BIZBAZAR, NELLORE, SPSR NELLORE DISTRICT.
2. DEVISETTY VENKATA SUBBAIAH @ SUBBAIAH, AGE 84
YEARS, S/O SUBRAMANYAM, PROPRIETOR OF M/S KUMAR
AGENCIES,
18/393, LANGARKHAN STREET, BIZBAZAR,
NELLORE, SPSR NELLORE DISTRICT.
...PETITIONER/ACCUSED(S)
AND
1. THE STATE OF ANDHRA PRADESH, Represented byFood
Safety Officer, O/o Gazetted Food Inspector and Food Safety
Designated Officer D.No. 26-2-1586, Vedayapalem, SPS Nellore
Dist., Nellore Through its Public Prosecutor, High Court of
Judicature at Amravati
...RESPONDENT/COMPLAINANT
Counsel for the Petitioner/accused(S):
1. SAI SANJAY SURANENI
Counsel for the Respondent/complainant:
1. PUBLIC PROSECUTOR (AP)
HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE K.SURESH REDDY
CRIMINAL PETITION Nos. 6749 of 2016, 7011 of 2017, 10639 of 2017,
3523 of 2018, 3536 of 2018, 2611 of 2022, 2614 of 2022, 4508 of 2022 and
1647 of 2023
COMMON ORDER:
As the issue involved in all these Criminal Petitions is one and the
same, they are heard together and are being disposed of by this
common order.
2. Details of the Criminal Petitions are as follows:
(i)
Criminal Petition No. 6749 of 2016 is filed by the petitioners/A2
and A3, under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure,
1973, seeking to quash the proceedings initiated against them in
C.C.No.1193 of 2015 on the file of the Court of the learned II
Additional Munsif Magistrate, Ongole, Prakasam District, for the
offences alleged under Sections 3(i)(zz)(iii) and 26(2)(i) of the
Food Safety and Standards Act, 2006 (for short, “the FSS Act”),
punishable under Section 59(i) thereof.
(ii)
Criminal Petition No.7011 of 2017 is filed by the petitioners/A2
and A3 under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure,
1973, seeking to quash the proceedings initiated against them in
S.T.C. No.637 of 2016 on the file of the Court of the II Additional
Judicial First Class Magistrate, Tirupati, Chittoor District, for the
offences alleged under Sections 3(i)(zz)(iii), 26(2)(i) and 27 (1) of
the Food Safety and Standards Act, 2006 (for short, “the FSS
Act”), punishable under Section 59(i) thereof.
(iii) Criminal Petition No.10639 of 2017 is filed by the petitioner/A4
under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973,
seeking to quash the proceedings initiated against him in C.C.
No.509 of 2016 on the file of the Court of the learned Judicial
Magistrate of First Class, Kandukur, Prakasam District, for the
offences alleged under Sections 3(i)(zz)(iii) and 26(2)(i) of the
Food Safety and Standards Act, 2006 (for short, “the FSS Act”),
punishable under Section 59(i) thereof.
(iv)
Criminal
Petition
No.3523
of
is
filed
by
the
petitioners/Accused Nos.3, 4, 5 and 6, under Section 482 of the
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, seeking to quash the
proceedings initiated against them, in C.C. No.330 of 2017 on the
file of the Court of the Judicial Magistrate of First Class,
Srikakulam, for the offences alleged under Sections 3(i)(zz)(iii),
26(2)(i) and 27 (1) of the Food Safety and Standards Act, 2006
(for short, “the FSS Act”), punishable under Section 59(i) thereof.
(v) Criminal
Petition
No.3536
of
is
filed
by
the
petitioners/Accused Nos.3,4,5 and 6, under Section 482 of the
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, seeking to quash the
proceedings initiated against them in C.C. No.603 of 2017 on the
file of the Court of the Judicial Magistrate of First Class,
Srikakulam, for the offences alleged under Sections 3(i)(zz)(iii),
26(2)(i) and 27 (1) of the Food Safety and Standards Act, 2006
(for short, “the FSS Act”), punishable under Section 59(i) thereof.
(vi) Criminal
Petition
No.2611
of
is
filed
by
the
petitioners/Accused Nos.3 and 4 under Section 482 of the Code
of Criminal Procedure, 1973, seeking to quash the proceedings
initiated against them in C.C. No.119 of 2017 on the file of the
Court of the Judicial Magistrate of First Class, Nellore, SPSR
Nellore District, for the offences alleged under Sections
3(i)(zz)(iii), 26(2)(i) and 27 (2) (c) of the Food Safety and
Standards Act, 2006 (for short, “the FSS Act”), punishable under
Section 59(i) thereof.
(vii) Criminal
Petition
No.2614
of
is
filed
by
the
petitioners/Accused Nos.6 and 7 under Section 482 of the Code
of Criminal Procedure, 1973, seeking to quash the proceedings
initiated against them in C.C. No.1154 of 2016 on the file of the
Court
of
the
Visakhapatnam
I
Additional
for
the
Chief
offences
Metropolitan
alleged
Magistrate,
under
Sections
3(i)(zz)(iii), 26(2)(i) and 27 (1) of the Food Safety and Standards
Act, 2006 (for short, “the FSS Act”), punishable under Section
59(i) thereof.
(viii)
Criminal Petition No.4508 of 2022 is filed by the
petitioners/Accused Nos.3 and 4 under Section 482 of the Code
of Criminal Procedure, 1973, seeking to quash the proceedings
initiated against them in C.C. No.675 of 2016 on the file of the
Court of the Judicial Magistrate of First Class, Kavali, SPSR
Nellore District for the offences alleged under Sections 3(i)(zz)(iii),
26(2)(i) of the Food Safety and Standards Act, 2006 (for short,
“the FSS Act”), punishable under Section 59(i) thereof.
(ix)
Criminal
Petition
No.1647
of
is
filed
by
the
petitioners/Accused Nos.1 and 2 under Section 482 of the Code
of Criminal Procedure, 1973, seeking to quash the proceedings
initiated against them in C.C. No.119 of 2017 on the file of the
Court of the II Additional Judicial Magistrate of First Class,
Nellore, SPSR Nellore District for the offences alleged under
Sections 3(i)(zz)(iii), 26(2)(i), 27 (2) (c) of the Food Safety and
Standards Act, 2006 (for short, “the FSS Act”), punishable under
Section 59(i) thereof.
3.
Case of the prosecution, in brief, is that the Food Safety
Officer conducted inspection of the premises of Accused No.1 and
purchased certain food products manufactured by one of the accused
companies, suspecting the same to be adulterated. Samples of the said
products were collected in the presence of mediators, upon due
payment of cost, in accordance with the prescribed procedure.
4. It is further case of the prosecution that, on the basis of the
invoices produced by Accused No.1, the present petitioners were also
arrayed as accused. The samples so collected were forwarded to the
State Food Laboratory, Nacharam, Hyderabad, for analysis. The Food
Analyst, upon examination, opined that the samples contained
pathogens, namely Salmonella/Bacillus cereus, which are injurious to
health, and consequently declared the samples as “unsafe”.
5. Basing on the said report of the Food Analyst, the competent
authority set the criminal law into motion by filing complaints before the
Jurisdictional Courts. The learned trial Courts, upon perusal of the
material placed on record, have taken cognizance of the offences
alleged and issued process against the accused.
6. Heard Sri Rajesh Batra, learned counsel representing Sri Sanjay
Suraneni, learned counsel for the petitioners, and Sri G. Neelothpal,
learned Assistant Public Prosecutor for the respondents.
7. The main contention of the learned counsel for the petitioners is
that the State Food Laboratory, Nacharam, Hyderabad, was not
recognized/notified under Section 43 of the FSS Act and, therefore, the
Analyst’s report is invalid.
For better appreciation, Section 43 of the FSS Act is
extracted hereunder:
“43. Recognition and accreditation of laboratories,
research institutions and referral food laboratory.—
(1) The Food Authority may notify food laboratories and
research institutions accredited by National Accreditation
Board for Testing and Calibration Laboratories or any
other accreditation agency for the purposes of carrying
out analysis of samples by the Food Analysts under this
Act.
(2) The Food Authority shall establish or recognise by
notification one or more referral food laboratory or
laboratories to carry out the functions entrusted to the
referral food laboratory by this Act or any rules and
regulations made thereunder.
(3) The Food Authority may frame regulations
specifying—
(a) the functions of food laboratory and referral food
laboratory and the local area or areas within which such
functions may be carried out;
(b) the procedure for submission to the said
laboratory of samples of articles of food for analysis or
tests, the forms of the laboratory’s reports thereon and
the fees payable in respect of such reports; and
(c) such other matters as may be necessary or
expedient to enable the said laboratory to carry out its
functions effectively.”
Further, Section 3(p) of the FSS Act defines “Food
Laboratory” as follows:
“Food laboratory” means any food laboratory or
institute established by the Central or a State Government
or
any
other
Accreditation
agency
Board
and
for
accredited
Testing
and
by
National
Calibration
Laboratories or an equivalent accreditation agency and
recognised by the Food Authority under Section 43.”
8. On the other hand, the learned Assistant Public Prosecutor
contends that the petitioners did not avail the remedy under Section
46(4) of the FSS Act and, therefore, they cannot question the Analyst’s
report at this stage. However, he does not dispute that the said
laboratory was not notified under Section 43 of the Act.
9. In reply, learned counsel for the petitioners submits that nonrecognition of the laboratory goes to the root of the matter and vitiates
the entire prosecution, and such a defect cannot be cured by invoking
Section 46(4) of the Act.
10. This Court has carefully considered the rival submissions and
perused the entire material on record.
11. On a conjoint reading of the provisions extracted above, it is
manifest that Section 3(p) of the Food Safety and Standards Act, 2006
defines a “Food Laboratory” as a laboratory established by the Central
Government or the State Government, or any other laboratory, which is
duly accredited by the National Accreditation Board for Testing and
Calibration Laboratories (NABL) and recognized/notified by the Food
Authority under Section 43 of the Act.
12. A harmonious construction of Sections 3(p) and 43 of the Act
makes it abundantly clear that a laboratory must satisfy both the
requirements of accreditation and recognition by the Food Authority, and
that accreditation alone does not fulfill the statutory mandate. In the
absence of such recognition and notification, the report issued by the
laboratory cannot be treated as a valid statutory report in the eye of law.
13. In the present cases, admittedly, the State Food Laboratory,
Nacharam, Hyderabad, was not notified under Section 43 of the Act.
Therefore, the Analyst’s report is vitiated.
14. Learned counsel for the petitioners relied on the judgment of
the Bombay High Court reported in Nestle India Limited VS. Food
Safety and Standards Authority of India1. After evaluating Section
3(p) and Section 43 of FSS Act and also referring to the Judgment of
the Hon’ble Apex Court reported in Pepsico India Holdings Pvt. Ltd.,
Vs. Food Inspector and Another2, the Bombay High Court held as
follows;
“Upon conjoint reading of both these sections quoted
hereinabove, it is clear that under section 3(p), "food
laboratory" is a laboratory which is either State or
Central laboratory or any other allied laboratory which is
accredited and recognized by NABL and by the Food
Authority under section 43 of the Act. The laboratory,
therefore, has to pass twin test before it can be said to
be a recognized laboratory viz (i) it has to be accredited
by NABL and over and above that (ii) it has also to be
recognized by the Food Authority under section 43 of
the Act. Sub-section (1) of section 43 makes it
abundantly clear that only in that laboratory which is
recognized by the Food Authority by Notification, food
can be sent for analysis by the Food Analyst. Upon
conjoint reading of the said two provisions, it is clear
that the submission made by Mr. Khambata, the learned
Senior Counsel for Respondent Nos. 3 and 4 is without
any substance. Section 43(1) mandates that the Food
Analyst WPL/1688/2015 has to analyse the food in a
laboratory accredited by NABL and also recognized by
the Food Authority and notified by it. It is apparent that
therefore if there is non-compliance of the said
[(2015) SCC OnLine Bom 4713].
[(2011) 1 Supreme Court Cases 176]
provisions and if the food is tested in a laboratory which
does not fall within the definition of section 3(p) and not
recognized by the Food Authority, the analysis made in
such laboratory cannot be relied upon. The Apex Court
in Pepsico India Holdings Private Limited vs. Food
Inspector and Another has observed that the provisions
are under section mandatory. The Apex Court in this
case held that provisions 23(1-A)(ee) of the Prevention of
Food Adulteration Act, 1954 for testing the food
samples/adulteration are mandatory and not directory.
Though the said observation is made in respect of
provisions of the Prevention of Food Adulteration Act,
1954 (which has now been repealed by FSS Act, 2006),
even under the new Act, the provisions of section 43(1)
will have to be held mandatory and not directory. This is
more so when Section 43(1) is read with the definition of
the words "food laboratory" in Section 3(p) of the FSS
Act, 2006. The Apex Court in Pepsico India Holding
Private Limited (supra) has observed in para 44 as
under:"44. The High Court also misconstrued the provisions of
Sections 23(1-A)(ee) and (hh) in holding that the same
were basically enabling provisions and were 1 (2011) 1
SCC 176 WPL/1688/2015 not mandatory and could, in
any event, be solved by the Central Government by
framing the Rules thereunder, by which specified tests
to be held in designated laboratories could be spelt out.
Consequently, the High Court also erred in holding that
the non formulation of rules under the aforesaid
provisions of the 1954 Act could not be said to be fatal
for the prosecution."
94. Further, if the provisions of sections 43 and 47 are
considered, it can be seen that notified laboratories
which are referred to in section 47(5) for analysing
imported food are laboratories which are separately
notified for testing imported food articles as can be seen
from the Food Safety and Standards (Laboratory and
Samples Analysis) Regulations, 2011. The contention of
Mr. Khambatta, the learned Senior Counsel appearing on
behalf of Respondent Nos. 3 and 4 that only imported
food could be tested in the notified laboratories
therefore cannot be accepted.”
15. The ratio laid down in the aforesaid judgment, in essence, is
that in the absence of duly prescribed and notified laboratories and
validated methods of analysis, the report of the Public Analyst cannot be
relied on, as such deficiencies go to the root of the prosecution and
render the proceedings unsustainable.
16. In view of the foregoing discussion and the settled position, this
Court is of the considered opinion that the very foundation of the
prosecution, namely, the Analyst’s report, is invalid for non-compliance
with Sections 3(p) and 43 of the FSS Act. Consequently, continuation of
the proceedings would amount to abuse of process of law.
17. Accordingly, all the Criminal Petitions are allowed and the
proceedings against the petitioners/accused in all the above Cases are
hereby quashed.
Pending miscellaneous applications, if any, shall
stand closed.
_______________________
JUSTICE K.SURESH REDDY
Date: 10.4.2026
GR
HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE K.SURESH REDDY
CRIMINAL PETITION Nos. 6749 of 2016, 7011 of 2017, 10639 of 2017,
3523 of 2018, 3536 of 2018, 2611 of 2022, 2614 of 2022, 4508 of 2022 and
1647 of 2023
DATE: 10th April, 2026
GR
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review