Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
CRM-M-72640--2025 (O&M)
IN THE
T
HIGH COURT OF PUNJA
UNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGAR
IGARH
-.CRM
CRM-M-72640-2025 (O&M)
Date of Decision : 02.02.2026
M/s Guru Ram
am Dass
Da Ji and Another
....Petitioners
VERSUS
Nanak Chand and Another
....Respondents
HON'
MS. JUSTICE MANDEE
NDEEP PANNU
CORAM : HON'BLE
Present:
Mr. S.S.Sahu,
S
Advocate for the petitio
petitioners.
-.-
MANDEEP PANNU
PAN
J. (Oral)
1.
The present petition has been filed uunder Section 528 of the Bharatiy
haratiya
Nagarik Suraksha
raksha Sanhita, 2023, praying forr quas
quashing of the impugned order
er dated
date
13.08.2025 (Annexure
(Anne
P-3) passed by the learne
learned Judicial Magistrate First
st Class,
Clas
Fazilka, in Complaint
Com
No. NACT-443-2025,
2025, along with all consequenti
quential
proceedingss arisin
arising therefrom, whereby thee learn
learned trial Court has summoned
ned the
th
petitioners to face trial under Section 138 off the N
Negotiable Instruments Act.
2.
Brief the facts of the case are th
Briefly,
that the respondents/complainant
lainants,
namely Nanak
nak Chand
Ch
and his wife Renu Bala,
ala, fil
filed a complaint under Section
tion 138
of the Negotiable
otiable Instruments Act against the pe
petitioners alleging that, on account
accou
of cordial relations,
relatio
they had advanced various
arious amounts to the petitioners
rs from
fro
time to time,
e, wh
which in total came to ₹14,10,0
4,10,000/-. It is alleged that towards
toward
discharge off the ssaid liability, the petitioners
rs issu
issued a cheque bearing No. 001011
00101
dated 25.06.2025
6.2025 for a sum of ₹14,00,000/- dra
drawn on ICICI Bank, Ratia.
a. Upon
Upo
presentation,
n, the cheque was returned unpaid
aid wit
with the remarks “Payment Stopped
Stoppe
TRIPTI SAINI
2026.02.03 11:17
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRM-M-72640--2025 (O&M)
-2-
by Drawer”” vide return memo dated 07.07.20
.07.2025. Thereafter, a statutory
ry legal
leg
notice dated
d 17.
17.07.2025 was issued to the ppetitioners, which was alleged
llegedly
received by
y them
them, however, no payment was m
made within the stipulated period.
perio
Consequently,
tly, th
the respondents/complainants
ants ffiled the complaint within
hin the
th
prescribed limita
limitation. On the basis of prelim
preliminary evidence and documen
cuments
produced, the
he learned
lear
Judicial Magistrate First
irst Cl
Class, Fazilka, vide impugned
ed order
ord
dated 13.08.2025
.2025, summoned the petitioners
rs to fa
face trial under Section 138
8 of the
th
Negotiable Instruments
Instru
Act, which order iss the ssubject matter of challengee in the
th
present petition.
ition.
3.
The petitioners contend that thee imp
impugned summoning order has
as been
bee
passed in a mech
mechanical manner, without proper
oper aapplication of judicial mind
d and in
utter disregard
ard of the material placed on record.
ecord. It is vehemently argued that the
th
alleged cheque
que b
bearing No. 001011 dated 25.06
25.06.2025 for a sum of ₹14,00,000
00,000/does not bear
ear th
the signature of petitioner No.2 Hakiqat Singh, who is the sole
so
proprietor of pet
petitioner No.1 firm, M/s Guru R
Ram Dass Ji Trading Compan
ompany.
According to the petitioners, the said cheque
ue has been fraudulently issued by one
on
Deepak, son
n of Satnam
S
Chand, who was a silent partner in the petitioner-firm,
irm, and
an
who forged
d and fabricated the signature of pe
petitioner No.2 on the cheque
eque in
question. Itt is ffurther contended that thee resp
respondents/complainants are close
clos
relatives of the sa
said Deepak and had financial
cial de
dealings with him, and not with the
th
petitioners. There
Therefore, neither petitioner No.1
o.1 firm nor petitioner No.2 can be held
he
liable for the
he alleged
alle
amount, as the cheque
ue in qquestion is forged, fabricated
ted and
an
not issued in d
discharge of any legally enfor
enforceable debt or liability of the
th
petitioners. The p
petitioners submit that these
ese vi
vital aspects go to the roott of the
th
TRIPTI SAINI
2026.02.03 11:17
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRM-M-72640--2025 (O&M)
-3-
matter, yet the llearned Trial Court failedd to cconsider them while issuing
ing the
th
summoning order,
order rendering the same illegal,
al, arbi
arbitrary and liable to be quashed.
4.
The matter being short and lying in a narrow compass, and the
th
controversy involved
invol
being capable of adjudicat
udication on the basis of the pleading
leadings
and documents
ents already
a
available on record,
d, th
this Court is of the considered
ed view
vie
that issuance
ce of notice
n
to the respondents iss not rrequired at this stage. The present
prese
petition, therefore
erefore, is taken up for final disposal
posal aat the threshold itself, on the
he basis
bas
of the material
terial placed on record, without
out ca
calling for a response from
om the
th
respondents.
5.
Havi heard learned counsel for th
Having
the petitioners and having perused
peruse
the record, this Court
C
is of the considered opinio
opinion that no ground is made out for
fo
exercising the inh
inherent jurisdiction to quash the im
impugned summoning order.
6.
The principal contention raisedd on bbehalf of the petitioners is that the
th
cheque in questio
uestion does not bear the genuine
ne sign
signatures of petitioner No.2 and that
th
the same has
as bee
been forged and fabricated byy a th
third person. This Court finds
nds that
th
such pleas squarely
square pertain to the defence of the accused. Whether the signature
gnatures
on the disputed
uted ccheque are genuine or forged,
ed, wh
whether the cheque was issued
ed with
wi
the consent or authority
aut
of the petitioners, and
nd wh
whether the petitioners are liable
iable for
fo
the offence alleged,
alleg
are all questions of fact which cannot be adjudicated
cated in
proceedingss unde
under Section 528 of the BNSS
S at th
this stage. These issues necessari
essarily
require appreciati
reciation of evidence, including oral aand documentary evidence,, which
whic
falls within the exclusive
ex
domain of the triall court
court.
7.
Muc emphasis has been laid by lear
Much
learned counsel for the petitioners
oners on
o
the submission
sion th
that the petitioners would bee able to establish the alleged forgery
rgery by
b
examining a han
handwriting or forensic expert.
ert. Th
There can be no quarrel with
ith the
th
TRIPTI SAINI
2026.02.03 11:17
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRM-M-72640--2025 (O&M)
-4-
proposition that the
t petitioners are at liberty
ty to ttake all permissible pleas in their
the
defence and
nd to lead appropriate evidence,
ence, including expert evidence,
nce, to
substantiate their stand. However, the stagee for ddoing so would arise only during
duri
the course of tria
trial. The inherent jurisdiction
on of this Court cannot be invoked
oked to
conduct a mini-tri
trial or to record findings onn dispu
disputed questions of fact, particular
ticularly
when the same
me ar
are yet to be tested by evidence.
8.
At the
th stage of summoning, the lear
earned trial court is only required
uired to
see whetherr a pri
prima facie case is made out
ut on the basis of the averments
ts in the
th
complaint and th
the preliminary evidence ledd by tthe complainant. A perusall of the
th
impugned order sshows that the learned Magistra
agistrate has considered the complain
mplaint,
the supporting
ing documents,
do
and the preliminary
nary eevidence and, upon being satisfied
satisfie
that the essentia
ssential ingredients of the offence
fence are prima facie disclosed,
ed, has
ha
summoned the petitioners. This Court does not find any patent illegalit
legality,
perversity, or jurisdictional
juris
error in the said appro
approach warranting interference.
9.
It is well settled that the powerr to qu
quash criminal proceedings is to be
b
exercised sparing
paringly and with great caution, and oonly in cases where the allegation
egations
do not disclose
close the commission of any offenc
offence or where the proceedings
ings are
a
manifestly an abuse
abu of the process of law. In the present case, the pleas raised
aised by
b
the petitioners
ers do not demolish the complainant’
inant’s case at the threshold, butt rather
rath
raise a defence
nce which
wh requires adjudication after eevidence is led by both the parties
partie
In view of the above
ab
discussion, this Court
rt hold
holds that the grounds urged by the
th
petitioners are premature
pre
and are matters too be cconsidered by the trial court
rt at the
th
appropriate stage. At this juncture, no case is mad
made out for quashing the complai
mplaint
or the summoning
oning order.
TRIPTI SAINI
2026.02.03 11:17
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRM-M-72640--2025 (O&M)
10.
-5-
Cons
Consequently,
the present petition
tition is dismissed, with liberty
y to the
th
petitioners to raise
rais all their pleas, including the pplea of forgery and fabrication
tion and
an
to seek examinati
mination of an expert, in accordance
dance with law, before the learned
ned trial
tri
court.
11.
All pending
p
miscellaneous applicatio
lication(s), if any, stands disposed
ed of.
February 02,, 2026
(MANDEEP PANNU)
tripti
JUDGE
Whether
ether speaking/non-speaking
s
: Speakin
peaking
Whether
ether reportable
r
: Yes/No
es/No
TRIPTI SAINI
2026.02.03 11:17
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review