Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/22
GAHC010240442022
2026:GAU-AS:6324
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/7584/2022
M/S GAURIPUR COOP FISHERY SOCIETY LTD
REP. BY ITS PRESIDENT, SRI SHIBEN NAMASUDRA, AGED ABOUT 60
YEARS, R/O- VILL- GAURIPUR, P.O. GAURIPUR, DIST.- DHUBRI, ASSAM,
PIN- 783331
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND 7 ORS
REP. BY THE COMM. AND SECY. TO THE GOVT. OF ASSAM, FISHERY
DEPTT., DISPUR, GHY-06
2:THE COMM. AND SECY. TO THE GOVT. OF ASSAM
FISHERY DEPTT.
DISPUR
GHY-06
3:THE JOINT SECRETARY TO THE GOVT. OF ASSAM
FISHERY DEPTT.
DISPUR
GHY-06
4:THE REGISTRAR OF COOPERATIVE SOCIETIES
ASSAM
KHANAPARA
GHY-22
5:THE DY. COMMISSIONER
DHUBRI
DHUBRI DISTRICT
ASSAM
PIN- 783301
Page No.# 2/22
6:THE ADDL. DY. COMMISSIONER (FISHERY)
DHUBRI
DHUBRI DISTRICT
ASSAM
PIN- 783301
7:THE CIRCLE OFFICER
GAURIPUR REVENUE CIRCLE
DISTRICT DHUBRI
PIN- 783331
ASSAM
8:M/S GERAMARI GAON PANCHAYAT MIN SAMABAY SAMITY LTD.
VILL- BAGURAPARA
P.O. ASHARIKANDI
DIST.- DHUBRI
ASSAM
PIN- 78333
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE DEVASHIS BARUAH
For the Petitioner(s)
: Mr. M. K. Choudhury, Advocate
: Mr. D. J. Medhi, Advocate
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. K. N. Choudhury, Sr. Advocate
: Mr. U. Goswami, Advocate
: Mr. G. Bordoloi, Standing Counsel
: Mr. K. Gogoi. Addl. Sr. GA, Assam
·
Date on which Judgment was reserved
: N/A
·
Date of Pronouncement of Judgment
: 05.05.2026
·
Whether the pronouncement is of
the Operative Part of the Judgment
: No
Whether the full Judgment has been
Pronounced
: Yes
·
Page No.# 3/22
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (ORAL)
Heard Mr. M. K. Choudhury, the learned Senior counsel
assisted by Mr. D. J. Medhi, the learned counsel appearing on
behalf of the Petitioner and Mr. K. Gogoi, the learned Additional
Senior
Government
Advocate
appearing
on
behalf
of the
Respondent Nos. 1, 2, 3, 5, 6 and 7. I have also heard Mr. G.
Bordoloi, the learned Standing counsel appearing on behalf of the
Respondent No.4 as well as Mr. K. N. Choudhury, the learned
Senior counsel assisted by Mr. U. Goswami, the learned counsel
appearing on behalf of the Respondent No.8.
PREFACE:
2.
The present writ petition has been filed by the Petitioner
challenging various reports as well as orders passed which led to
the order dated 15.11.2022 and further seeking a direction that the
Group No.1/87 Dharnad Brahmaputra Part-I and Satkuri Nadi
Fishery be settled with the Petitioner for a period of 7 (seven)
years as the Petitioner was the valid highest bidder.
3.
At the outset, it is very pertinent to take note of that the
impugned order dated 17.10.2022 passed by the Respondent No.3,
Page No.# 4/22
the Letter/Report No.DRF.5/2020/441-42 dated 29.09.2020 of the
Deputy Commissioner, Dhubri, the Speaking Order No.DRF5/2020
dated 14.09.2020 of the Additional Deputy Commissioner, Dhubri,
Report No.GRP(s)3/2019/339 dated 28.08.2020 have merged with
the impugned order dated 15.11.2022. Under such circumstances,
the issue involved in the present proceedings is as to whether this
Court is required to interfere with the impugned order dated
15.11.2022 passed by the Respondent No.2.
BRIEF FACTS:
4.
A Notice Inviting Tender was issued on 27.02.2020 for
settlement of Group No.1/87 Dharnad Brahmaputra Part-I and
Satkuri Nadi Fishery (hereinafter referred to as the “fishery in
question”) for the period from 2019-20 to 2025-26. The said Notice
Inviting Tender stipulated various terms and conditions including
the necessity of Bakijai Clearance Certificate to be obtained from
the concerned Office of the Deputy Commissioner distinctly in the
name of the society or self-help group.
5.
The records further reveal that there were various litigations
as regards the settlement in respect to the fishery in question.
Pursuant to the various orders passed by the learned Coordinate
Benches as well as the learned Division Bench of this Court, an
Page No.# 5/22
order was passed on 17.10.2022 by the Joint Secretary to the
Government
of
Assam,
Fishery
Department
whereby
the
Respondent No.8 society was offered the fishery in question for
settlement
at
Rs.1,90,05,000/-
for
(seven)
years
at
Rs.27,15,000/- per annum. Pursuant to the said order passed by
the Joint Secretary to the Government of Assam, Fishery
Department, a writ petition was filed by the Petitioner which was
registered and numbered as WP(C) No.6885/2012 challenging the
settlement so made in favour of the Respondent No.8.
6.
It is further relevant to take note of that another writ petition
was filed by the Respondent No.8 before this Court wherein the
Petitioner herein was the Respondent No.3 in the said writ petition.
The said writ petition was registered and numbered as WP(C)
No.7056/2022.
7.
The case of the Respondent No.8 in WP(C) No.7056/2022
appears to be on account of the writ petition filed by the writ
petitioner i.e. WP(C) No.6885/2022 challenging the order dated
17.10.2022. It was the case of the Respondent No.8 in WP(C)
No.7056/2022 that the Bakijai Clearance Certificate which was
issued dated 12.03.2020 ought to have been issued in the name of
Respondent
No.8
society
but
the
Office
of
the
Deputy
Page No.# 6/22
Commissioner, Dhubri had issued in favour of the Secretary of the
Respondent No.8 society. The learned Coordinate Bench of this
Court
vide
an
order
dated
04.11.2022
passed
in
WP(C)
No.7056/2022 disposed of the said writ petition thereby holding
that the Certificate dated 12.03.2020 to be untenable in law and
the Deputy Commissioner, Dhubri was directed to give due
consideration to the application dated 02.03.2020 submitted by the
Secretary of the Respondent No.8 society and pass a fresh order
on the claim for the Bakijai Certificate in the name of the society.
The Coordinate Bench further directed that the Certificate in the
correct manner as per law, be issued within three days from the
date of receipt of the certified copy of the order. Paragraph Nos. 5
to 9 of the order dated 04.11.2022 in WP(C) No.7056/2022 being
relevant are reproduced herein under:
“5.
But the settlement is assailed by the respondent No. 3 M/s Gauripur
FCS Ltd. One of the grounds taken by the respondent No. 3 M/s Gauripur FCS
Ltd is that the Bakijai certificate issued by the authorities is in the name of the
Secretary of the society namely Anil Chandra Barman whereas as per the
notification dated 18.01.2018 of the Fisheries Department of the Government
of Assam, the Bakijai certificate invariably has to be in the name of the society
and not its Secretary.
6.
By referring to the provisions of the said notification, it is the contention
of the respondent No. 3 in their writ petition that the Bakijai certificate issued
to the Secretary of Geramari Gaon Panchayat Meen Samabay Samity Ltd is
Page No.# 7/22
unacceptable in law.
7.
We are not expressing any view on the said contention of the
respondent No. 3 in the said writ petition as it is a subject matter of the other
writ petition. In this writ petition, the petitioner assails the Bakijai certificate
dated 12.03.2020 issued by the office of the Deputy Commissioner, Dhubri
pursuant to the application of the Secretary of the petitioner society made on
02.03.2020. A reading of the certificate itself goes to show that the deceased
father of the Secretary of the society late Mukunda Barman had been certified
that there is no Bakijai proceeding pending against him, whereas the
application made by the Secretary of the petitioner society was for a certificate
in the name of the society.
8.
The very reading of the certificate makes it a case of non application of
mind. Firstly, the Deputy Commissioner ought to have taken note that this is
an application made by the Secretary of a society for issuing a Bakijai
certificate in the name of the society. So, therefore, the certificate ought to
have been either in the name of the society or it ought to have been refused if
the facts and circumstance so required. Further, under no circumstance, a
certificate can be issued in the name of the deceased father of the Secretary
of the society as made in the instant case.
9.
Accordingly, the certificate dated 12.03.2020 is declared to be
untenable in law and the Deputy Commissioner, Dhubri is directed to give a
due consideration to the application dated 02.03.2020 of the Secretary of the
petitioner society and pass a fresh order on the claim of a Bakijai certificate in
the name of the society. The certificate in the correct manner as per law be
issued within a period of three days from the date of receipt of a certified copy
of this order.
Page No.# 8/22
The writ petition is allowed in the above terms.”
8.
Pursuant thereto, the Deputy Commissioner, Dhubri passed an
order on 09.11.2022 thereby directing the E-Governance Authority
to issue the Bakijai Clearance Certificate afresh forthwith in the
name of the Respondent No.8 represented by its Secretary in
compliance to the order dated 04.11.2022 passed in WP(C)
No.7056/2022. Accordingly, on 10.11.2022, a Bakijai Clearance
Certificate was issued.
9.
The records further reveal that on 11.11.2022, the writ
petition which was filed by the writ petitioner herein being WP(C)
No.6885/2022, wherein the order dated 17.10.2022 was put to
challenge, was taken up for hearing and the Respondent No.8
herein who was also a party in the said writ proceedings placed the
fresh Bakijai Clearance Certificate dated 10.11.2022 before the
learned Coordinate Bench of this Court. The learned Coordinate
Bench of this Court vide an order dated 11.11.2022 disposed of the
said writ petition holding inter alia that the Certificate dated
10.11.2022 can be taken into consideration for the purpose of the
tender process and further held that the earlier incorrect certificate
would be in the nature of curable defect which is an acceptable
proposition of law in a tender process. The learned Coordinate
Bench
of
this
Court
further
observed
that
under
such
Page No.# 9/22
circumstances, there was a necessity on the part of the Joint
Secretary to the Government of Assam, Fishery Department to
pass a fresh order on the acceptance of the corrected Bakijai
Clearance Certificate. The learned Coordinate Bench directed that
the said order be passed by the Fishery Department within a
period of 7 (seven) days from the date a certified copy of the said
order was served. Paragraph Nos. 5 to 8 of the said order
11.11.2022 being relevant are reproduced herein under:
“5.
Considering the provisions of Clause 4 of the Notification dated
18.01.2018, we are in agreement with Mr. MK Choudhury, learned senior
counsel for the petitioner that the aforesaid conclusion arrived at by the Joint
Secretary would be contrary to the provisions of Clause 4 of the Notification
dated 18.01.2018.
6.
But, in the meantime, Mr. KN Choudhury, learned senior counsel for the
respondent No.8 has produced a fresh certificate issued by the appropriate
authority in the office of the Deputy Commissioner, Dhubri wherein a certificate
had been issued in the name of the respondent No.8 Society. We also have to
take note that the certificate dated 12.03.2020 which was earlier in the name
of the Secretary of the respondent No.8 Society was assailed by the
respondent No.8 in WP(C)No.7056/2022 wherein by the order dated
04.11.2022 it had been judicially accepted that the certificate was incorrectly
issued in the name of the Secretary, although the original application remained
an application for a certificate to be issued in the name of the Society
concerned. Further no material is also made available to the Court that at the
relevant point of time when the application was made by the respondent No.8
Society for issuing the Bakijai Clearance Certificate, there was any pending
Page No.# 10/22
dues of the Society to the authorities.
7.
In the circumstance, although the reasoning of the Joint Secretary in
the impugned order dated 17.10.2022 is contrary to the provisions of Clause 4
of the Notification dated 18.01.2018, but in view of the fact that subsequently,
a corrected certificate had been issued and also the earlier certificate which
was incorrectly issued was not because of any fault on the part of the
respondent No.8 Society and further that at the relevant point of time when
the Bakijai Clearance Certificate was applied for there was no Bakijai
proceeding pending against the respondent No.8 Society, we are of the view
that the corrected certificate issued to the respondent No.8 Society may be
taken as the appropriate material in the tender process by the Settling
Authority. We observe as such in view of the fact that the circumstance in
which the incorrect certificate dated 12.03.2020 was issued to the respondent
No.8 Society and also the fact that at the relevant point of time when the
application for obtaining the certificate was made there was no Bakijai
proceeding pending against the respondent No.8 Society, it would be
permissible under the law to take into consideration the corrected certificate
for the purpose of the tender process, inasmuch as, the earlier incorrect
certificate would be in the nature of a curable defect, which is an acceptable
proposition of law in a tender process.
8.
Accordingly, although we are not interfering with the settlement made
with the respondent No.8 on the merit of the settlement, but a limited
interference is made as regards the reasoning of the Joint Secretary that the
Bakijai Clearance Certificate issued in the name of the Secretary of the Society
concerned can be construed to be also a certificate issued in the name of the
Society. But in view corrected certificate subsequently issued which also can be
taken as a part of the material on record, we direct the Joint Secretary to the
Government of Assam in the Fishery Department to pass a fresh order on the
Page No.# 11/22
issue of the acceptance of the Bakijai Clearance Certificate of the respondent
No.8 Society. The fresh order be passed within a period of seven days from the
date of receipt of a certified copy of this order.”
10. This Court before further proceeding with the narration of the
facts, finds it pertinent to observe that vide the above quoted
order, the learned Coordinate Bench of this Court had clearly
observed that the certificate which was issued in the name of the
Secretary of the Respondent No.8 dated 12.03.2020 was a mistake
committed by the authorities concerned and therefore the
corrected
certificate
dated
10.11.2022
can
be
taken
into
consideration for the purpose of the tender process.
11. The record further reveals that in pursuance to the order
passed by this Court dated 11.11.2022 in WP(C) No.6885/2022,
the impugned order was issued on 15.11.2022 holding inter alia
that the Petitioner herein was not qualified taking into account that
the Petitioner would not fall within the neighbourhood and also the
Distance Certificate could not be taken into consideration. The
reason assigned therein is on account of a proceeding being
pending before the Registrar of Cooperative Societies against an
order of ARCS, Dhubri dated 07.07.2020 wherein it was held that
the Petitioner society did not have any jurisdiction over the village
Madaikhali which is included in the area of operation of Geramari
Page No.# 12/22
GP MSS Ltd. under the local name Asharikandi (Bagurapara) and
Asharikandi (Chikasipara) at the time of Registration in the year
1982. In addition to that, it was also a subject matter of challenge
before the Registrar of Cooperative Societies that the list of
members drawn from village Madaikhali in respect of the Petitioner
Society out of the total 75 members is not valid which is now under
the jurisdiction of the Respondent No.8 Society. It is under such
circumstances, the Petitioner’s bid was rejected.
12.
The Commissioner and Secretary to the Government of
Assam, Fishery Department further taking into account the order
passed by the learned Coordinate Bench of this Court dated
11.11.2022 passed in WP(C) No.6885/2022 took into consideration
the fresh Bakijai Certificate and thereby held that the Respondent
No.8’s bid was a valid bid and awarded the settlement at
Rs.1,90,05,000/- for 7 years.
13. Being aggrieved, the Petitioner had challenged the order dated
15.11.2022 before this Court by filing the present writ petition.
14. Before adjudicating the dispute involved in respect to the
order dated 15.11.2022, it is apposite herein to mention another
subsequent event which took place pursuant to the filing of the
Page No.# 13/22
present writ petition. The order dated 11.11.2022 passed in WP(C)
No.6885/2022 was put to challenge before the learned Division
Bench of this Court in WA No.361/2022. The said Writ Appeal was
dismissed vide a judgment and order dated 19.09.2024 thereby
affirming the order passed by the learned Coordinate Bench dated
11.11.2022. Paragraph Nos. 4, 5 and 6 of the judgment and order
dated 19.09.2024 passed in WA No.361/2022 being relevant are
reproduced herein under:
“4.
However, taking into consideration the fact that the respondent No.8
society filed a writ petition, being, WP(C) 7056/2022 alleging that though the
Secretary of the respondent No.8 society applied for issuance of Bakijai
Clearance Certificate in the name of the society but the authorities concerned
erroneously issued the said certificate in the name of the Secretary of the
respondent No.8 society, therefore, the authorities concerned be directed to
issue correct Bakijai Clearance Certificate in the name of the Society.
The learned Single Judge has further observed that WP(C) 7056/2022
came to be disposed by this Court vide order dated 04.11.2022 directing the
Deputy Commissioner, Dhubri to issue a Bakijai Clearance Certificate in the
name of the respondent No.8 society. It is further observed that pursuant to
the said order dated 04.11.2022 passed in WP(C) 7056/2022, a Bakijai
Clearance Certificate was issued in the name of the respondent No.8 society
and as such, although the reasoning of the Joint Secretary, whereby the
fishery in question was settled in favour of the respondent No.8 society, is
contrary to the provisions of clause 4 of the tender notification but, since
subsequently a corrected certificate was issued in favour of the respondent
No.8 society pursuant to the direction of this Court, the said decision of the
Page No.# 14/22
Joint Secretary to the Government of Assam in the Fishery Department is not
liable to be interfered with.
The writ petition [WP(C) 6885/2022] was disposed of by the learned
Single Judge with a limited interference by directing the Joint Secretary to the
Government of Assam in the Fishery Department to pass a fresh order on the
issue of acceptance of Bakijai Clearance Certificate of the respondent No.8
society.
5.
Having heard the learned counsel appearing for the parties and after
going through the material available on record, particularly, taking into
consideration the fact that a Bakijai Clearance Certificate was issued in the
name of the respondent No.8 society pursuant to the direction given by this
Court on 04.11.2022 in WP(C) 7056/2022, we do not find any illegality in the
conclusion arrived at by the learned Single Judge in the impugned judgment
and order.
6.
It is also to be noted that the appellant was one of the respondents in
WP(C) 7056/2022 but it did not challenge the order dated 04.11.2022 passed
in the said writ petition and, on this ground also, we do not find any case for
interference in this writ appeal.
Hence, this writ appeal is dismissed being devoid of merit.”
15. In the backdrop of the above, let this Court take note of the
submissions made by the learned counsels appearing on behalf of
the parties.
Page No.# 15/22
SUBMISSIONS MADE BY THE LEARNED COUNSELS FOR THE
PARTIES:
16. Mr. M. K. Choudhury, the learned Senior counsel appearing on
behalf of the Petitioner submitted that the Distance Certificate
which was issued in favour of the Respondent No.8 was cancelled
on 23.06.2020 and as such, on the basis of the said Certificate, the
Respondent No.8 was not eligible to be granted the settlement. In
addition to that, the learned Senior counsel had also submitted
that the Bakijai Certificate with which the Respondent No.8
submitted the bid was an invalid Certificate and the fresh Bakijai
Certificate dated 10.11.2022 could not have been taken into
consideration for granting the settlement in favour of the
Respondent No.8 inasmuch as the fresh Bakijai Certificate came
into existence much later.
17. Mr. K. N. Choudhury, the learned Senior counsel appearing on
behalf of the Respondent No.8 on the other hand submitted that
the issue as regards the Distance Certificate cannot be raised in
the instant proceedings inasmuch as the principles of constructive
res-judicata would bar the Petitioner from raising such disputes.
The learned Senior counsel in that regard referred to the judgment
of the Supreme Court in the case of Shiv Chander More and Others
Vs. Lieutenant Governor and Others reported in (2014) 11 SCC 744
Page No.# 16/22
whereby the Supreme Court had categorically observed that the
principles of constructive res-judicata are applicable in the writ
proceedings.
18.
In addition to that, the learned Senior counsel for the
Respondent No.8 submitted that the issue as regards the Bakijai
Certificate cannot also be raised by the Petitioner herein on the
ground that in the order dated 11.11.2022 passed in WP(C)
No.6885/2022, the learned Coordinate Bench of this Court had
categorically held that the said corrected Bakijai Certificate could
be taken for the purpose of the tender process and this finding had
attained finality by the learned Division Bench affirming the order
dated 11.11.2022 passed in WP(C) No.6885/2022.
19.
This Court had duly heard the learned Senior counsels
appearing on behalf of the Petitioner and the Respondent No.8 as
well as the learned counsels for the State Respondents and
perused the materials on record.
ANALYSIS AND DETERMINATION:
20. Let this Court first take up the issue as to whether the
Petitioner can raise issue pertaining to the Distance Certificate of
the Respondent No.8 being cancelled on 23.06.2020, in the
Page No.# 17/22
present writ proceedings. It is relevant to take note of that in the
earlier round of litigation, which the Petitioner filed being WP(C)
No.6885/2022, the Petitioner did not raise the said issue as regards
the cancellation of the Distance Certificate that too when the said
writ petition was filed much after the alleged cancellation of the
Distance Certificate which as per the Petitioner happened on
23.06.2020. In this regard, this Court finds it pertinent to take note
of Explanation-IV to Section 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure,
1908 which is based upon the principles of constructive resjudicata. Explanation-IV stipulates that any matter which might and
ought to have been made ground of defence or attack in such
former suit shall be deemed to have been a matter directly and
substantially in issue in such suit.
21. It is the opinion of this Court that the issue of the cancellation
of the Distance Certificate which ought to have been taken but not
taken in WP(C) No.6885/2022, the said issue cannot be raised in
the present proceedings inasmuch as the said aspect would be
barred by principle of constructive res-judicata. The above opinion
of this Court finds support in the judgment of the Supreme Court
rendered in the case of Shiv Chander More (supra). Paragraph
Nos.21 to 24 of the said judgment being relevant are quoted
herein under:
Page No.# 18/22
“21. We may briefly refer to some of those decisions which elaborate the
principle and extend their application to proceedings before a writ court. But
before we do so, we need to say what is trite, namely, the doctrine of res
judicata being one of the most fundamental and well-settled rules of
jurisprudence. The doctrine is found in all legal systems of civilised society in
the world. It is founded on a twofold logic, namely, (1) that there must be
finality to adjudication by the competent court; and (2) no man should be
vexed twice for the same cause. These two principles attract the doctrine of
res judicata even to inter partes decisions that may be erroneous on a
question of law. That the doctrine is applicable even to writ jurisdiction
exercised by the superior courts in this country is settled by a Constitution
Bench decision of this Court in Amalgamated Coalfields Ltd. v. Janapada Sabha
Chhindwara wherein this Court observed: (AIR p. 1018, para 17)
“17. … Therefore, there can be no doubt that the general principle of
res judicata applies to writ petitions filed under Article 32 or Article 226.
It is necessary to emphasise that the application of the doctrine of res
judicata to the petitions filed under Article 32 does not in any way
impair or affect the content of the fundamental rights guaranteed to the
citizens of India. It only seeks to regulate the manner in which the said
rights could be successfully asserted and vindicated in courts of law.”
22.
The principles of constructive res judicata which are also a part of the
very same doctrine have been held to be applicable to writ proceedings, by
another Constitution Bench decision of this Court in Devilal Modi v. STO
wherein this Court observed: (AIR p. 1152, para 8)
“8. It may be conceded in favour of Mr Trivedi that the rule of
constructive res judicata which is pleaded against him in the present
appeal is in a sense a somewhat technical or artificial rule prescribed
by the Code of Civil Procedure. This rule postulates that if a plea could
have been taken by a party in a proceeding between him and his
Page No.# 19/22
opponent, he would not be permitted to take that plea against the
same party in a subsequent proceeding which is based on the same
cause of action; but basically, even this view is founded on the same
considerations of public policy, because if the doctrine of constructive
res judicata is not applied to writ proceedings, it would be open to the
party to take one proceeding after another and urge new grounds
every time; and that plainly is inconsistent with considerations of public
policy to which we have just referred.”
23.
Reference may also be made to the Constitution Bench decision in Direct
Recruit Class II Engg. Officers’ Assn. v. State of Maharashtra wherein this
Court once again reiterated that the principles of constructive res judicata
apply not only to what is actually adjudicated or determined in a case but
every other matter which the parties might and ought to have litigated or
which was incidental to or essentially connected with the subject-matter of the
litigation. This Court observed: (SCC p. 741, para 35)
“35. … an adjudication is conclusive and final not only as to the actual
matter determined but as to every other matter which the parties
might and ought to have litigated and have had decided as incidental
to or essentially connected with the subject-matter of the litigation and
every matter coming into the legitimate purview of the original action
both in respect of the matters of claim and defence. Thus, the principle
of constructive res judicata underlying Explanation IV of Section 11 of
the Civil Procedure Code was applied to writ case. We, accordingly hold
that the writ case is fit to be dismissed on the ground of res judicata.”
24.
It is in the light of the above authoritative decisions of this Court no
longer open to the appellants to contend that the principles of constructive res
judicata would not debar them from raising the question which, as observed
earlier, could and indeed ought to have been raised by them in the previous
round of litigation. The High Court was, in that view of the matter, perfectly
Page No.# 20/22
justified in holding that the plea sought to be raised by the appellants in the
purported exercise of liberty given to them by the orders of this Court dated 94-2008 in Lt. Governor v. Shiv Chander More was not legally open and should
not be allowed to be urged.”
22. Under such circumstances, the first contention so raised by
the Petitioner stands rejected.
23. As regards the second contention, as to whether the fresh
Bakijai Certificate dated 10.11.2022 could have been taken in the
tender process pertaining to the settlement of the fishery in
question. It is the opinion of this Court that the said aspect have
already been dealt with and settled by the learned Coordinate
Bench
in
the
No.6885/2022
categorically
order
dated
11.11.2022
whereby
the
learned
the
fresh
held
that
passed
in
WP(C)
Coordinate Bench
Bakijai
Certificate
had
dated
10.11.2022 could be taken for the purpose of tender process
inasmuch as it was a curable defect. It is also pertinent to mention
that though there was a challenge to the said judgment and order
dated
11.11.2022
passed
in
WP(C)
No.6885/2022
in
WA
No.361/2022, the learned Division Bench of this Court vide the
judgment and order dated 19.09.2024 rejected the said Writ
Appeal.
Page No.# 21/22
24. Consequently, it is the opinion of this Court that the second
contention so raised is misconceived and accordingly stands
rejected.
CONCLUSION:
25. Accordingly, this Court does not find any merit in the present
petition for which the instant writ petition stands dismissed.
26. Before parting with the records, this Court also finds it very
pertinent to take note of the submission made by Mr. M. K.
Choudhury,
the
learned
Senior
counsel
pertaining
to
the
observations made in respect to the Petitioner Society in the
impugned order dated 15.11.2022. The learned Senior counsel
submitted that though the Appeal was pending before the Registrar
of Cooperative Societies at the time of passing of the impugned
order dated 15.11.2022, but the said Appeal was subsequently
dismissed and a writ petition thereagainst had been filed which
have been registered and numbered as WP(C) No.6505/2021. The
said writ petition is presently pending.
This Court observes that the observations so made in the
impugned order dated 15.11.2022 as regards the neighbourhood
distance as well as the members of the Petitioner society shall be
Page No.# 22/22
subject to the outcome of the writ petition filed by the Petitioner.
However, for the sake of clarity, it is observed that any decision
made in WP(C) No.6505/2021 would not affect the impugned order
dated 15.11.2022 by which the Respondent No.8 was awarded the
settlement.
Bijoy
Saha
Bijoy Saha
Date: 2026.05.12
17:28:39 +05'30'
Comparing Assistant
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review