Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 94
Supplementary Cause List-II
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
(i) WP(C) 1624/2025
CM(4183/2025)
M/S VEDA INFRASTRUCTURE
…PETITIONER(S)
Through:
None.
V/s.
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
...RESPONDENT(S)
Through:
Mr. T. M. Shamsi, DSGI with
Mr. Nazir Ahmad, Mr. Mudasir Malik, Mr. Faizan Ahmad Ganai, CGCs.
(ii) OWP 767/2017
CM(4183/2025)
M/S GRANCO INDUSTRIES AND
CONSTRUCTION THROUGH ITS
MANAGINGDIRECTOR GHULAM RASOOL
NAGVI
Through:
Ms. Mehreen Altaf, Advocate.
…PETITIONER(S)
V/s.
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
...RESPONDENT(S)
Through:
Mr. T. M. Shamsi, DSGI with
Mr. Nazir Ahmad, Mr. Mudasir Malik, Mr. Faizan Ahmad Ganai, CGCs.
(iii) CPOWP 232/2018
CM(5771/2020)
CM(5779/2020)
CM(5780/2020)
M/S MPB CONSTRUCTIONS PRIVATE LIMITED
…PETITIONER(S)
Through:
None.
V/s.
LT. COL. VARUN TANDON AND ORS.
...RESPONDENT(S)
Through:
Mr. T. M. Shamsi, DSGI with
Mr. Nazir Ahmad, Mr. Mudasir Malik, Mr. Faizan Ahmad Ganai, CGCs.
WP(C) 1624/2025 along with
c/w matters
(iv) OWP 1409/2018
IA(1/2018)
CM(7323/2019)
M/S MPB CONSTRUCTIONS PVT. LTD.
…PETITIONER(S)
Through:
None.
V/s.
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
...RESPONDENT(S)
Through:
Mr. T. M. Shamsi, DSGI with
Mr. Nazir Ahmad, Mr. Mudasir Malik, Mr. Faizan Ahmad Ganai, CGCs.
(v) WP(C) 2380/2019
CM(1089/2020)
CM(4540/2019)
M/S MPB CONSTRUCTIONS PRIVATE LIMITED
…PETITIONER(S)
Through:
None.
V/s.
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
...RESPONDENT(S)
Through:
Mr. T. M. Shamsi, DSGI with
Mr. Nazir Ahmad, Mr. Mudasir Malik, Mr. Faizan Ahmad Ganai, CGCs.
(vi) WP(C) 388/2022
CM(960/2022)
M/S VALLEY ENTERPRISES CONSTRUCTIONS
COMPANY AND ANR.
Through:
Mr. S. H. Thakur, Advocate.
…PETITIONER(S)
V/s.
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
...RESPONDENT(S)
Through:
Mr. T. M. Shamsi, DSGI with
Mr. Nazir Ahmad, Mr. Mudasir Malik, Mr. Faizan Ahmad Ganai, CGCs.
(vii) WP(C) 3029/2022
CM(7622/2022)
CM(913/2023)
M/S RASHID CONSTRUCTIONS COMPANY
LIMITED AND ANR.
Through:
Mr. S. H. Thakur, Advocate.
…PETITIONER(S)
WP(C) 1624/2025 along with
c/w matters
V/s.
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
...RESPONDENT(S)
Through:
Mr. T. M. Shamsi, DSGI with
Mr. Nazir Ahmad, Mr. Mudasir Malik, Mr. Faizan Ahmad Ganai, CGCs.
(viii) WP(C) 464/2023
CM(1106/2023)
M/S SYED NOOR-ULLAH RIZVI THROUGH ITS
PROP.
…PETITIONER(S)
Through:
None.
V/s.
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
...RESPONDENT(S)
Through:
Mr. T. M. Shamsi, DSGI with
Mr. Nazir Ahmad, Mr. Mudasir Malik, Mr. Faizan Ahmad Ganai, CGCs.
(ix) WP(C) 3020/2023
CM(7204/2023)
M/S A. A. A. CONSTRUCTIONS
…PETITIONER(S)
Through:
None.
V/s.
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
...RESPONDENT(S)
Through:
Mr. T. M. Shamsi, DSGI with
Mr. Nazir Ahmad, Mr. Mudasir Malik, Mr. Faizan Ahmad Ganai, CGCs.
(x) WP(C) 724/2024
CM(1924/2024)
SHOWKAT AHMAD WANI AND SONS
…PETITIONER(S)
Through:
None.
V/s.
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
...RESPONDENT(S)
Through:
Mr. T. M. Shamsi, DSGI with
Mr. Nazir Ahmad, Mr. Mudasir Malik, Mr. Faizan Ahmad Ganai, CGCs.
WP(C) 1624/2025 along with
c/w matters
(xi) WP(C) 1091/2024
CM(1751/2026)
CM(2989/2024)
M/S GRNACO INDUSTRIES AND
CONSTRUCTIONS LIMITED AND ANR.
…PETITIONER(S)
Through:
Ms. Mehreen Altaf, Advocate.
V/s.
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
...RESPONDENT(S)
Through
Mr. T. M. Shamsi, DSGI with
Mr. Nazir Ahmad, Mr. Mudasir Malik, Mr. Faizan Ahmad Ganai, CGCs.
(xii) WP(C) 2912/2024
CM(7958/2024)
ABDUL HAMEED GEELANI
…PETITIONER(S)
Through:
Mr. Aushaq Hussain Shah, Advocate with
Mr. Asif Ali, Advocate.
V/s.
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
...RESPONDENT(S)
Through:
Mr. T. M. Shamsi, DSGI with
Mr. Nazir Ahmad, Mr. Mudasir Malik, Mr. Faizan Ahmad Ganai, CGCs.
(xiii) WP(C) 48/2025
CM(111/2025)
ABDUL RASHID NAJAR
…PETITIONER(S)
Through:
Mr. Aushaq Hussain Shah, Advocate with
Mr. Asif Ali, Advocate.
V/s.
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
...RESPONDENT(S)
Through:
Mr. T. M. Shamsi, DSGI with
Mr. Nazir Ahmad, Mr. Mudasir Malik, Mr. Faizan Ahmad Ganai, CGCs.
(xiv) WP(C) 433/2025
CM(1013/2025)
M/S SMYLE AND CO.
…PETITIONER(S)
Through:
Mr. Aushaq Hussain Shah, Advocate with
Mr. Asif Ali, Advocate.
WP(C) 1624/2025 along with
c/w matters
V/s.
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
...RESPONDENT(S)
Through:
Mr. T. M. Shamsi, DSGI with
Mr. Nazir Ahmad, Mr. Mudasir Malik, Mr. Faizan Ahmad Ganai, CGCs.
(xv) WP(C) 510/2025
CM(1239/2025)
M/S GRANCO INDUSTRIES AND
CONSTRUCTION LIMITED.
…PETITIONER(S)
Through:
None.
V/s.
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
...RESPONDENT(S)
Through:
Mr. T. M. Shamsi, DSGI with
Mr. Nazir Ahmad, Mr. Mudasir Malik, Mr. Faizan Ahmad Ganai, CGCs.
(xvi) WP(C) 624/2025
CM(1536/2025)
M/S GRNACO INDUSTRIES AND
CONSTRUCTION LIMITED.
…PETITIONER(S)
Through:
Ms. Moneesa Manzoor, Advocate vice
Mr. A. M. Dar, Senior Advocate.
V/s.
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
...RESPONDENT(S)
Through:
Mr. T. M. Shamsi, DSGI with
Mr. Nazir Ahmad, Mr. Mudasir Malik, Mr. Faizan Ahmad Ganai, CGCs.
(xvii) WP(C) 1838/2025
CM(4829/2025)
M/S SUHEEL CONSTRUCTIONS TH.HIS
PARTNER
…PETITIONER(S)
Through:
None.
V/s.
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
...RESPONDENT(S)
WP(C) 1624/2025 along with
c/w matters
Through:
Mr. T. M. Shamsi, DSGI with
Mr. Nazir Ahmad, Mr. Mudasir Malik, Mr. Faizan Ahmad Ganai, CGCs.
(xviii) WP(C) 2530/2025
CM(6715/2025)
M/S ZEA CONSTRUCTIONS TH PROP
…PETITIONER(S)
Through:
Mr. Aushaq Hussain Shah, Advocate with
Mr. Asif Ali, Advocate.
V/s.
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
...RESPONDENT(S)
Through:
Mr. T. M. Shamsi, DSGI with
Mr. Nazir Ahmad, Mr. Mudasir Malik, Mr. Faizan Ahmad Ganai, CGCs.
(xix) WP(C) 2893/2025
CM(7665/2025)
M/S EVERGREEN GROUP OF INDUSTRIES
…PETITIONER(S)
Through:
None.
V/s.
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
...RESPONDENT(S)
Through:
Mr. T. M. Shamsi, DSGI with
Mr. Nazir Ahmad, Mr. Mudasir Malik, Mr. Faizan Ahmad Ganai, CGCs
(xx) WP(C) 3094/2025
CM(3060/2026)
CM(8270/2025)
M/S EVERGREEN GROUP OF INDUSTRIES
TH.ITS PROP
…PETITIONER(S)
Through:
None.
V/s.
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
...RESPONDENT(S)
Through:
Mr. T. M. Shamsi, DSGI with
Mr. Nazir Ahmad, Mr. Mudasir Malik, Mr. Faizan Ahmad Ganai, CGCs.
WP(C) 1624/2025 along with
c/w matters
(xxi) WP(C) 336/2026
CM(834/2026)
MS RIYAZ AHMAD QADRI TH.ITS
PROPRIETOR
…PETITIONER(S)
Through:
None.
V/s.
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
...RESPONDENT(S)
Through:
Mr. T. M. Shamsi, DSGI with
Mr. Nazir Ahmad, Mr. Mudasir Malik, Mr. Faizan Ahmad Ganai, CGCs.
(xxii) WP(C) 368/2026
CM(943/2026)
M/S DFA ENTERPRISES
…PETITIONER(S)
Through:
None.
V/s.
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
...RESPONDENT(S)
Through:
Mr. T. M. Shamsi, DSGI with
Mr. Nazir Ahmad, Mr. Mudasir Malik, Mr. Faizan Ahmad Ganai, CGCs.
(xxiii) WP(C) 635/2026
CM(1625/2026)
M/S GASSI BROTHERS.
…PETITIONER(S)
Through:
Mr. Aushaq Hussain Shah, Advocate with
Mr. Asif Ali, Advocate.
V/s.
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
...RESPONDENT(S)
Through:
Mr. T. M. Shamsi, DSGI with
Mr. Nazir Ahmad, Mr. Mudasir Malik, Mr. Faizan Ahmad Ganai, CGCs.
(xxiv) WP(C) 637/2026
CM(1627/2026)
M/S MEHAK STEEL INDUSTRIES
TH.PROPRIETOR
…PETITIONER(S)
Through:
Mr. Aushaq Hussain Shah, Advocate with
Mr. Asif Ali, Advocate.
WP(C) 1624/2025 along with
c/w matters
V/s.
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
...RESPONDENT(S)
Through:
Mr. T. M. Shamsi, DSGI with
Mr. Nazir Ahmad, Mr. Mudasir Malik, Mr. Faizan Ahmad Ganai, CGCs.
(xxv) WP(C) 1060/2026
CM(2761/2026)
M/S M A CONSTRUCTIONS
…PETITIONER(S)
Through:
Mr. Aushaq Hussain Shah, Advocate with
Mr. Asif Ali, Advocate.
V/s.
UNION OF INDA AND ORS
...RESPONDENT(S)
Through:
Mr. T. M. Shamsi, DSGI with
Mr. Nazir Ahmad, Mr. Mudasir Malik, Mr. Faizan Ahmad Ganai, CGCs.
(xxvi) WP(C) 1061/2026
CM(2764/2026)
M/S M.A. CONSTRUCTIONS TH. PROPRIETOR.
…PETITIONER(S)
Through:
Mr. Aushaq Hussain Shah, Advocate with
Mr. Asif Ali, Advocate.
V/s.
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
...RESPONDENT(S)
Through:
Mr. T. M. Shamsi, DSGI with
Mr. Nazir Ahmad, Mr. Mudasir Malik, Mr. Faizan Ahmad Ganai, CGCs.
(xxvii) WP(C) 1135/2026
CM(2967/2026)
M/S (MESSRS) U.K. ENTERPRISES TH.ITS PROP
…PETITIONER(S)
Through:
None.
V/s.
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
...RESPONDENT(S)
Through:
Mr. T. M. Shamsi, DSGI with
Mr. Nazir Ahmad, Mr. Mudasir Malik, Mr. Faizan Ahmad Ganai, CGCs.
WP(C) 1624/2025 along with
c/w matters
(xxviii) WP(C) 1529/2026
CM(3983/2026)
CM(5428/2026)
M/S MEGA CONCRETE CONSTRUCTIONS
ENGINEERS AND CONTRACTORS
…PETITIONER(S)
Through:
None.
V/s.
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
...RESPONDENT(S)
Through:
Mr. T. M. Shamsi, DSGI with
Mr. Nazir Ahmad, Mr. Mudasir Malik, Mr. Faizan Ahmad Ganai, CGCs.
(xxix) WP(C) 1999/2026
CM(5427/2026)
M/S SUMEET TRADING CORPORATION TH.ITS
PROPRIETOR
…PETITIONER(S)
Through:
None.
V/s.
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
...RESPONDENT(S)
Through:
Mr. T. M. Shamsi, DSGI with
Mr. Nazir Ahmad, Mr. Mudasir Malik, Mr. Faizan Ahmad Ganai, CGCs.
(xxx) WP(C) 2020/2026
CM(5469/2026)
M/S LONE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY TH.ITS
PROP
…PETITIONER(S)
Through:
None.
V/s.
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
...RESPONDENT(S)
Through:
Mr. T. M. Shamsi, DSGI with
Mr. Nazir Ahmad, Mr. Mudasir Malik, Mr. Faizan Ahmad Ganai, CGCs.
(xxxi) WP(C) 2081/2026
CM(5628/2026)
M/S MAUROOF AHMAD MIR
…PETITIONER(S)
Through:
WP(C) 1624/2025 along with
c/w matters
Mr. Aushaq Hussain Shah, Advocate with
Mr. Asif Ali, Advocate.
V/s.
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
...RESPONDENT(S)
Through:
Mr. T. M. Shamsi, DSGI with
Mr. Nazir Ahmad, Mr. Mudasir Malik, Mr. Faizan Ahmad Ganai, CGCs.
(xxxii) WP(C) 2448/2026
CM(6622/2026)
CM(6730/2026)
M/S ELECTROMECH
…PETITIONER(S)
Through:
Mr. Aushaq Hussain Shah, Advocate with
Mr. Asif Ali, Advocate.
V/s.
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
...RESPONDENT(S)
Through:
Mr. T. M. Shamsi, DSGI with
Mr. Nazir Ahmad, Mr. Mudasir Malik, Mr. Faizan Ahmad Ganai, CGCs.
CORAM:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Wasim Sadiq Nargal, Judge.
JUDGMENT (ORAL)
01.
Since the grievance projected and the relief claimed in
all these petitions are almost identical, the petitions have,
therefore, been heard together and taken up for disposal by
virtue of this common judgment.
02.
The fulcrum of the case set up by the petitioners, who
are registered contractors/firms supplying services to the
respondents-Military Engineering Services (MES), is that they
have been carrying out contract works for the respondents for
several years and have, throughout, rendered satisfactory
services. The petitioners have challenged the communications
/orders issued by the respondents whereby they have been
rendered ineligible for participation in the tendering process
WP(C) 1624/2025 along with
c/w matters
on the ground that certain works allotted to them were shown
as being in “slow progress” in the relevant Work Load Returns
(WLRs). It is the case of the petitioners that the said entries do
not reflect the actual position, as the works in question had
either been substantially/completely executed, or their
execution was delayed for reasons beyond the control of the
petitioners, including restrictions on access to the sites,
circumstances prevailing during the COVID-19 pandemic and
the period following the constitutional changes of August,
2019, besides other circumstances, including personal/family
difficulties and health-related issues.
03.
It is further averred that, in certain cases, works were
cancelled by the respondents despite substantial completion
thereof, without release of the amounts claimed by the
petitioners. The petitioners accordingly contend that they
cannot be held responsible for delays attributable to
circumstances beyond their control or to acts/omissions on
the part of the respondents or their concerned units. It is also
the case of the petitioners that they have subsequently
completed the works which were earlier shown as being in
slow progress and that the impugned entries in the relevant
WLRs as on date, therefore, unjustified and ought not to
constitute a basis for debarring or rendering them ineligible
from participating in the tendering process. On these grounds,
the
petitioners
seek
quashing
of
the
impugned
communications/ orders to the extent they affect their
eligibility and a direction to the respondents to permit them to
participate in the tendering/allotment process in accordance
with the applicable rules and conditions.
04.
The record reveals that this Court, after feeling prima
facie satisfied, has stayed the impugned orders in almost all
the cases and given liberty to the petitioners to participate in
WP(C) 1624/2025 along with
c/w matters
the various tenders irrespective of the impediment projected
by the respondents through the medium of the impugned
communications, and the participation of the petitioners in
the fresh tenders, however, is subject to the final orders to be
passed in these writ petitions.
05.
Since the relief sought by the petitioners has been
granted by this Court on the very first day of hearing, whereby
the various petitioners have been allowed to participate in the
tenders, however, the final veil/impediment pointed out by the
respondents has not been finally removed/corrected, despite
the change of circumstances, which could only be removed if
the matter is heard and decided finally.
06.
Mr. T. M. Shamsi, learned Deputy Solicitor General of
India submits that these writ petitions can be disposed at this
stage with a direction to the Chief Engineer Command to treat
these writ petitions as representations and to accord
consideration to the same, within some reasonable time by
taking into consideration the aforesaid developments as also
the policy and the guidelines framed by the respondents in
this regard, which find mention in the communication
produced by Mr. Shamsi, learned Deputy Solicitor General of
India, which is taken on record.
07.
A bare perusal of the aforesaid communication
reveals that the respondents have formulated a policy, which
for facility of reference is reproduced as under:
“(iv) Zonal CEs while forwarding reports to CE
Commands in respect of Contractors having work
load more than Rs 50 lakhs will not endorse copy to
CsWE and E in-C's Branch. MES website.
(v) Zonal CE will compile and forward his report to
CE Command for uploading in website.
WP(C) 1624/2025 along with
c/w matters
(vi) Commands CE will compile and circulate his
report and get it uploaded in MES website
(vii) Show cause notices for proposed adverse
remarks in work load returns shall be served by the
Accepting Officer of Contracts latest by 10th of the
last month of the quarter and copy of the same
alongwith reply of Contractors shall be enclosed with
WLR by GE/CWE, while forwarding report to CE
Zone, and by CE Zone to CE Command.
(vii) In the forwarding letter of the WLR to higher
formation, there shall be specific mention that
against the contractor who have then adversely
remarked, necessary Show Cause Notices (SCNs)
have been issued to the contractors, replies received
from contractors and replies analysed before putting
the adverse remark.”
08.
Thus, from a bare perusal of the policy framed by the
respondents, a complete mechanism has been provided in the
aforesaid policy, which is required to be followed by the Chief
Engineer while according consideration to the case of the
petitioners individually by treating these writ petitions as
representations within some reasonable period, to which the
learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioners are not
averse.
09.
For the foregoing discussion, this Court is of the
considered opinion that no fruitful purpose would be served
to keep these petitions alive, and accordingly, the same are
disposed of by virtue of this common judgment, with the
consent of the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
petitioners and the respondents with a direction to the
concerned Chief Engineer (Command) to treat each writ
petition separately as representation on behalf of respective
WP(C) 1624/2025 along with
c/w matters
petitioners and take a final call thereon in accordance with
law and pass a detailed speaking order with respect to each
and every petitioner separately, by taking note of the workload
strictly in the light of the policy so framed by the respondents
mentioned supra, expeditiously, within a period of four weeks
from the date of receipt of copy of this order. It is further made
clear that in case the decision of the concerned Chief Engineer
(Command), after taking into consideration all the relevant
facts and the subsequent developments in the light of the
contemporaneous official record, goes against the petitioners,
the petitioners shall be at liberty to seek appropriate remedy
under law by way of appropriate proceedings, if so advised.
10.
Before parting, this Court would like to make it clear
that till the fresh decision is taken by the Chief Engineer
(Command) in terms of this order, the interim orders passed
by this Court in each and every case, if the same are
subsisting as on date, shall remain in operation till a decision
is taken by the Chief Engineer (Command) in conformity with
the directions passed by this Court today.
11.
All the writ petitions except WP(C) 1091/2024 shall
stand disposed of along with connected CM(s)/contempt
petitions in the manner indicated above.
CM No. 6730/2026 In WP(C) No. 2448/2026:
Mr. Aushaq Hussain Shah, Advocate with Mr. Asif Ali, Advocate for Petitioner.
12.
This is an application preferred by the applicant/
petitioner seeking rectification of typographical error that has
crept in the cause title of the order dated 26.09.2026 passed
in WP(C) 2448/2026, wherein the name of the petitioner has
been mentioned as “M/s Electromechnic Th. Partner” instead
of “M/s Electromech Engineers.”
WP(C) 1624/2025 along with
c/w matters
13.
For the reasons stated in the application, coupled
with submissions made at the Bar, the same is allowed and
the title of the case in the order dated 26.09.2026, shall be
read as “M/s Electromech Engineers” instead of “M/s
Electromechnic.” This order shall be read in continuation to
Order dated 26.09.2026.
14.
CM is accordingly disposed of.
15.
Main writ petition (WP(C) No. 2448/2026 shall stand
disposed of in the light of the detailed order passed
hereinabove, in the connected matters and shall be governed
by the directions passed therein.
WP(C) No. 1091/2024:
Ms. Mehreen Altaf, Advocate for Petitioner.
16.
Learned counsel for the petitioner makes a categoric
statement at the Bar that with the efflux of time, the instant
writ petition has been rendered infructuous, as such, she does
not want to pursue the same any further. Statement of the
learned counsel is taken on record.
17.
Writ petition is accordingly dismissed as having been
rendered infructuous. Interim direction, if any, shall stand
vacated.
18.
Registry to place a copy of this Judgment on the
record of each file.
SRINAGAR:
(WASIM SADIQ NARGAL)
JUDGE
29.09.2026
“Hamid”
❖ Whether the Judgment is Reportable?
Yes/No
❖ Whether the Judgment is Speaking?
Yes/No
Abdul Hamid Bhat
I attest to the accuracy
and
Page
15 of 15
authenticity of this
document
WP(C) 1624/2025 along with
c/w matters
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review