Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 20
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 456 of 2022
Date of Decision: 15.11.2022
M/S Dharani Geotech Engineers & Anr.
Vs. State of Meghalaya & Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) :
Mr. K. Saha, Adv.
Mr. B. Bora, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
Mr. A. Kumar, AG with
Ms. A. Thungwa, GA
Ms. S. Laloo, GA
Mr. S. Sahay, Adv.
Mr. A.S. Pandey, Adv.
:
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (ORAL)
1.
The writ petitioners herein, are aggrieved with the
disqualification from the tender bidding process under the Request for
Bids (RFB) No. R&I /DAMS/PK-I/DRIP-II/2022-23 dated 6th April,
2022 for the works of Rehabilitation and Improvement of Umiam StageI, Umiam – Umtru Stage – III, Umiam – Umtru Stage – IV Dams in RiBhoi District and Myntdu Leshka Stage-I Dam in West Jaintia Hills
District of Meghalaya, under DRIP-II (Package – I) by virtue of the
notice notification being No. CE/C/HP&HC/DRIP-II/T98(C)/2022/188
dated 20th October, 2022 issued by the Chief Engineer (C), Hydro
Planning & Hydro Construction, Meghalaya Power Generation
Corporation Limited, Shillong, being the Respondent No. 3. The
challenge to disqualification is on the ground that the writ petitioner had
been disqualified from the bidding, without any application of mind and
in an arbitrary manner.
2.
The brief background facts are that, pursuant to a notice inviting
tender dated 05.04.2022, and Request for Bids (RFB) dated 06.04.2022,
the writ petitioners had submitted their bid, which included, response to
queries, bid capacity details, and other materials to substantiate the fact
that, requisite amount of drilling work, had earlier been executed by the
writ petitioner No. 1, which made the writ petitioners technically
qualified and eligible. However, by letter dated 10.10.2022, which is
impugned herein, the petitioners had been informed that, their technical
bid had been found to be non-responsive and technically not qualified,
which has occasioned the instant writ petition.
3.
Mr. K. Saha, learned counsel for the petitioners in his
submissions, had at the initial stage, when the matter was taken up,
stressed on the point that, there was no comprehensible reason for the
technical bid of the petitioners to be rejected, inasmuch as, enough
material in the form of the contracts/work earlier executed by the writ
petitioner No. 1, had been furnished. In this context, the learned counsel
had taken the Court, through the varied documents to substantiate the
contention, as to the petitioners, meeting the qualifying criteria. This
Court, then by order dated 10.11.2022, on the prayer of the Advocate
General appearing on behalf of the respondents, fixed the matter today,
while granting a limited status quo till the next date, on the settlement of
the contract. The respondents were also allowed to bring on record
documents in support of their case.
4.
The respondents have filed an affidavit, today itself, in reply to
the writ petition and have raised objections on the ground of
maintainability, absence of legal right, presence of disputed questions of
facts, amongst others.
5.
The learned counsel for the petitioners, on this affidavit,
submits that a document annexed therein, that is, a letter dated
13.09.2022, (Annexure – R/4 to the Affidavit), has changed the entire
complexion of the matter, as this communication reveals that the
technical bid of the petitioner was rejected, on the inputs by an entity
known as CPMU (Central Project Management Unit), for dam
rehabilitation and improvement. The learned counsel has strenuously
argued that, it is noted in the letter that, the Bid Evaluation Committee
of the respondent No. 3, had found the petitioners’ bid technically
responsive and qualified, as per the requirements and had accordingly
recommended the same for acceptance, but however, on the inputs so
received from the CPMU, which has been noted in the said letter, the bid
was disqualified.
6.
The learned counsel for the petitioners has seriously questioned
the role of the CPMU, in the evaluation process and has taken this Court,
to Clause – 1.8 of the Works Requirements document (Page – 239 of the
writ petition), to demonstrate that the CPMU, has been entrusted as a 3rd
party only for construction supervision, and quality assessment, at the
third level only, that is, after the contract have been awarded and the
work commenced. It is further submitted that, in Clauses – 30 and 31 of
the ITB (Instruction to Bidders), which deals with evaluation of the
technical parts of bids, there is no mention of CPMU, at all, and it is
provided in Clause – 31.3, that it is the Employer, who shall examine the
technical aspects of the bid, and to determine whether the said bid is
responsive or not.
7.
The learned counsel, then refers to the impugned notice dated
20.10.2022, and submits that the said notice has been lifted ad verbatim,
from the contents of the letter dated 13.09.2022, which contains the
inputs of the CPMU, as far as the bid of the petitioners are concerned.
This shows, he submits that the disqualification of the petitioners, is
based on an extraneous factor, foreign to the Bid Evaluation Process,
which violates the conditions laid down in the tender documents. It is
further submitted that, CPMU may be a stake holder, but nowhere does
it come, within the definition of Employer. The learned counsel has also
contended that, the records reflect the undisputed position of the
petitioners being found eligible and qualified by the prescribed Bid
Evaluation Process, but however, have been ousted from contention,
simply on the basis of the inputs of the CPMU, which is not part of the
said process. It is further argued that, the observation of the CPMU, that
the petitioners lack drilling capability and are only qualified for grouting
work is misplaced, inasmuch as, the earlier project executed by the
petitioner No. 1, in association with a certain M/S APC, Drilling and
Construction, comprised both Drilling and Grouting work, for which a
certificate dated 29.06.2022, had been issued by the NTPC Ltd., showing
successful completion of the project.
8.
Mr. K. Saha, learned counsel then submits that, the instant case
is a fit case for judicial review of the decision making process, as severe
injustice has been caused, which militates against the settled position of
law as laid down, by various judicial pronouncements of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court, in such leading cases as, the Tata Cellular case (1994)
6 SCC 651. The learned counsel has also sought the distinguish, the
decision rendered in the case of N.G. Projects Limited vs. Vinod Kumar
Jain reported in (2022) 6 SCC 127, and submits that, when there is
arbitrary exercise of power, or violation of the Principles of Natural
Justice, a tender process can be interfered with. In support of this
contention, learned counsel has placed reliance on the judgment dated
18.05.2022, passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Jai
Bholenath Construction vs. The Chief Executive Officer, Zilla
Parishad, Nanded & Ors. (Civil Appeal No. 4140 of 2022), by the same
Bench, that had passed the order in N.G. Projects Limited vs. Vinod
Kumar Jain (supra). Learned counsel then closes his submissions, by
maintaining that the instant case is a fit case for interference by this
Court.
9.
The learned Advocate General appearing for the respondents,
in reply to the submissions of the learned counsel for the petitioner, has
firstly, submitted that the invocation of writ jurisdiction, in such matters,
is of limited scope, as it is well settled that, the High Court is not sitting
in appeal, or in substitution of the wisdom of the Employer. He submits
that the work in question being of extreme public interest, judicial review
will not be available or permitted to be invoked to protect private interest,
at the cost of public interest, or to decide contractual disputes. On the
specific challenge of the petitioners, to disqualification which was solely
based on the findings of the CPMU, the learned AG has submitted that
the tender evaluation has been done, as per the Instructions to Bidders
(ITB), which allows the Employer at Clause – 31.3 and 32.1, to examine
the technical aspects of the bids and to determine, whether the eligible
bidders have submitted responsive bids, apart from the Employers right
to accept or to reject any bid.
10.
The learned Advocate General then submits that the evaluation
and qualification criteria as prescribed, has been applied to assess the
bids and submits that as per Clause 4.2 (a) of the said criteria specific
experience has been laid down. Taking this clause into consideration he
submits, for contracts which the bidder has participated in a joint venture,
only the bidder share by value shall be considered to meet this
requirement, which stipulates that similar work such as Drilling Grouting
should have been satisfactorily and substantially completed. The learned
AG has also referred to Clause 4.2 (b) of the criteria wherein he points
out, demands that a minimum construction experience in Drilling of
10,000 Rmt; Grouting of 1130 MT and Concrete Works of 880 Cum,
should have been completed in the earlier contract. With regard to the
input as received from CPMU, the learned AG submits that CPMU
which is a stake holder, saddled with the responsibility of construction
supervision and the said organization, under the Government of India in
the Ministry of Jal Shakti, Department of Water Resources has a major
role to play. The entire project he submits, is under the Dam
Rehabilitation and Improvement Project being implemented by the
Ministry of Water Resources with assistance from the World Bank and
accordingly, the inputs and expertise of the Central Government is also
being taken at each stage. He therefore submits that such consultation
cannot operate as a bar as CPMU, is not an external agency.
11.
The learned AG’s next limb of submission, is that the
petitioners do not meet the specifications as prescribed and the materials
placed, would go to show that the petitioner No. 1 has not completed any
Drilling Work of 10,000 Rmt. Reference is then made to a Deed of Joint
Undertaking executed by the petitioner No. 1 along with M/S APC,
Drilling and Construction in favour of NTPC Limited, wherein he
submits the role of the petitioner No. 1, as seen in the said Undertaking
is only for Grouting works. He next refers to a Labour License issued on
12.04.2021 to the petitioner No. 1 and submits that the license so issued
is specific only to Grouting of Rock Mass and does not speak about any
Drilling work. He further submits that even by a communication dated
27.06.2022 from the respondent No. 3 to the petitioner No. 1, specific
information has been sought, as to in what capacity, the petitioner had
executed the work with M/S APC, Drilling and Construction, whether it
was in the capacity of prime contractor, joint venture or sub-contractor.
The learned AG submits that the clear requirement of Drilling experience
had not been furnished by the petitioners and moreover this entire
assessment, was completed before the communication of the
disqualification of the technical bid of the petitioners. He submits that
there is no manifest arbitrariness, and in the impugned notice itself, it has
been clearly spelt out that the Technical Evaluation Committee and
CPMU, had evaluated the bids for the said work and found the bid to be
technically not qualified, due to the lack of the key activity of having
executed Drilling work.
12.
Passing submissions have also been advanced by the learned
AG, by referring to Annexure-16 of the writ petition to show that the
petitioner No. 1, was not the sole executant of all works in the earlier
Project with the NTPC, but that was only an invoicing party for the said
work.
13.
In support of his submissions, the learned AG has placed
reliance on the judgment of N.G. Projects Ltd. (supra), and submits, that
it rests upon the authority concerned, to assess as to whether a bidder
satisfied the tender conditions. He submits that, in the absence of any
illegality or arbitrariness, a project which is urgently required and in
public interest, the role of the Court is to interfere to the minimum extent,
so that public works projects will not be impeded or stalled. Reliance has
also been placed on the following judgments;
i)
Galaxy Transport Agencies v. New J.K. Roadways
(2021) 16 SCC 808
ii)
Uflex Ltd. v. State of T.N. (2022) 1 SCC 165
iii)
Jagdish Mandal v. State of Orissa (2007) 14 SCC 517
iv)
Bareily Development Authority v. Ajai Pal Singh (1989)
2 SCC 116
v)
Sanjay Kumar Jha v. Prakash Chandra Chaudhary
(2019) 2 SCC 499
vi)
World Tel Inc. v. Union of India (2001) 10 SCC 513.
The above noted decisions it is noted, cover cases concerning
the eligibility of the tenderer, public interest to be given primacy,
maintainability of writs in commercial matters, amongst others.
14.
I have heard learned counsels for the parties. This Court notes
the fact that, judicial review in such commercial matters is to be sparingly
exercised, and this position, as has been held in several judgments is to
be confined to the questions of legality, as has been held in the case of
Tata Cellular (supra), wherein the salient aspects have been enunciated.
In the instant case, as observed earlier, the petitioners have alleged,
firstly, that their bid has not been given due consideration and secondly,
the rejection was solely on the basis of an opinion of an entity, which did
not form part of the Bid Evaluation Committee of the respondent No. 3.
Accordingly, in the light of these two aspects, this Court is to examine
the matter, as to whether, the decision arrived at is vitiated by
arbitrariness, illegality and by non-application of mind.
15.
A perusal of the eligibility and qualification criteria, at Clauses
4.2(a) and 4.2(b) [Page – 92, 93 and 94 of the writ petition] shows the
stipulations as follows, a scanned copy of which is appended, is
reproduced herein below:
16.
A perusal of the eligibility criteria, clearly reflects that a bidder
must meet the requirement of having completed the work prescribed
therein, in this case Drilling of 10,000 Rmt, Grouting of 1130 MT and
Concrete Works of 880 Cum, jointly or singly to qualify for
consideration. The reasons ascribed for rejection of the bid, as detailed
in the impugned notice dated 20.10.2022, specifically found the
petitioner No. 1, to not meet the requirement of 4.2(b). The impugned
letter for the sake of convenience is scanned and reproduced herein
below:
17.
This finding it appears has become the main bone of contention
in the instant matter, inasmuch as, as disclosed by letter dated 13.09.2022
(Annexure R/4 to the affidavit-in-opposition) is the view expressed by
the CPMU, when the matter regarding the bid evaluation had been
submitted for concurrence. This finding, resulted in the rejection of the
Technical Bid of the petitioners, as in the same letter itself, it has been
indicated that the Bid Evaluation Committee of the respondent No. 3,
had found the petitioner No. 1 to be technically qualified. It is necessary
therefore, to examine as to whether the decision making process is
vitiated due to this input of the CPMU, which did not form part of the
Bid Evaluation Committee, and whether the role the CPMU can be said
to be beyond the conditions of the ITB in the process of Bid Evaluation,
which would amount to the rejection being driven by extraneous
considerations.
18.
The process of evaluation of the technical parts of the bid, have
been laid out at Clauses 30, 31 and 32 of the ITB, (Page – 70 and 71 of
the writ petition). Clause 30.1 has stipulated that the criteria and
methodology for evaluating the technical bids, would be as per the ITB,
Clause 31.3 stipulates that, the Employer shall examine the technical
aspects of the bid, and that the same should meet all the requirements as
specified in the Work Requirements, and by Clause 32 the Employer is
to determine to its satisfaction, whether the eligible bidders meet the
qualifying criteria as specified in the Evaluation and Qualification
criteria.
19.
Clause 1.8 of the Works Requirements (Page – 239 of the writ
petition), speaks of the role of CPMU, which as observed earlier
functions under the Government of India in the Ministry of Jal Shakti,
Department of Water Resources which is the parent department, funding
the entire project. As such, it can be easily inferred, that the CPMU is an
important constituent, as it has been given a third-party interest to ensure
maintenance of standard and quality in the execution of the project. It is
noted that the letter of rejection has also made a clear reference to the
CPMU, indicating that the decision arrived at, was after inputs from this
agency. The duty of this Court at this juncture therefore, is to examine,
as to whether this decision can be said to be vitiated, as the same was
also based on the input and assessment of the CPMU. It is relevant to
notice that, the input as to the non-responsiveness of the technical bid of
the petitioners had been communicated on 13.09.2022, by the Deputy
Director of the Central Water Commission, and the impugned letter
rejecting the bid of the petitioners as non-responsive and technically not
qualified was issued on 20.10.2022. It is important to note that, in the
impugned letter itself, which had been reproduced above, clear reference
has been made that, the Technical Evaluation Committee and the CPMU,
had evaluated the bid of the petitioners, and declared the same as
unresponsive.
20.
No materials have been brought at this juncture, to show as to
who were the constituents of the Bid Evaluation Committee, and
whether, in the said evaluation, such consultation in hyper technical
matters with other stake holders is barred. Clause 1.8 referred to above,
clearly reflects that CPMU is not an external agency, and being in charge
of Construction Supervision and Quality Assessment, is therefore, vitally
interested in the successful execution of the project. The fact that it is an
agency directly under the control of the Department of the Water
Resources, which is funding the project, also cannot be ignored. Though
in the letter dated 13.09.2022, it has been stated that the bid of the
petitioners had been found responsive by the Bid Evaluation Committee,
however, the very fact that, concurrence was sought from CPMU, points
to the fact that, the consultation may perhaps be a part of the entire
evaluation process, in arriving at a correct conclusion.
21.
This Court sitting in writ jurisdiction, will not enter into the
factual aspects, that is, to examine the bid in detail, to ascertain as to
whether, the eligibility of the petitioners, as this will be in the realm of
adjudicating upon competing claims based on disputed facts. For the
present, it is only to discern, as to whether, the impugned order is
irrational, perverse, arbitrary or made with an intention to favour another
party. From the above discussions and observations, this Court finds that
no overwhelming materials exist to hold, that the decision making
process is vitiated on the counts as aforementioned. As noted in various
rulings of the Hon’ble Supreme Court, a government must also have the
freedom of contract and be given fair play in the joints, as these are
sometimes necessary to arrive at a particular decision, which however,
should meet the test of reasonableness. In the instant case, no element of
arbitrariness or mala fide is present in the said process to warrant any
interference at this stage, moreso, in view of the fact, that the rejection
of the bid of the writ petitioners was on the basis of the opinion of
experts.
22.
Though in the entire process, there might be just a hint of
irregularity, however, in the considered view of this Court, this will not
tantamount to an irregularity that will disable the entire tender process,
especially taking into account, the nature of the project and the larger
public interest at hand. The non-joinder of necessary parties, that is, the
Department of the Water Resources and the CPMU, who are the project
proponents and who have clearly been reflected in the impugned order,
has also watered down the scope of relief, if any available to the writ
petitioners, apart from the fact, that the Financial Bids were scheduled to
be opened on 25th October, 2022.
23.
Taking into account the totality of the facts and circumstances,
no interference is warranted by this Court at this stage, and the writ
petition is accordingly dismissed.
24.
Parties to bear their own costs.
Judge
Meghalaya
15.11.2022
“D.Thabah-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review