Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 34e1 I
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
TUESDAY, THE FOURTH DAY OF AUGUST
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MOUSHUMI BHATTACHARYA
AND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE GADI PRAVEEN KUMAR
l.A.No.1 of 2025
IN/AND
COMMERCIAL COU RT APPEAL NO: 27 OF 2025
Appeal under Section 13 of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015 Fyw Section 37
of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 against the order dated 05-12-2019
passed in C.O.P.No.38 of 2017 on the file of the Court of the Judge, Commercial
Court-cum-XXIV Additional Chief Judge, City Civil Court, Hyderabad.
Between:
1. M/s.Century 21, a registered Partnership firm, rep. by its Partner:
2. Shri Syed Khaja Abdul Hameed, S/o.Syed Anwarullah Hussaini, Muslim, aged
about 55 years, Occupation. Business, Resident of H.No.8-1-33213142' f ol
Chowki, Golconda, Hyderabad.
3. Smt. Basheerunnisa Begum, Wo. Syed Anwarullah Hussaini
(Died as per L.R. - Appellant No. 2)
...Appel lants/Petitioners
AND
1. Mohammed Khaleel, Mohd.Mehtab, Muslim, aged about 43 years, Occ:
Business, R/o.H.No.1 9-2-36'1, Kamatipura, Hyderabad.
2. Mohd Aijaz, S/o.Mohammed Mehtab, Muslim, aged about 42 years, Occ:
Business, Rl/o.H.No.19-2-361, Kamatipura, Hyderabad.
3. Syed Ali Akbar, S/o.Mohd.Akbar, Muslim, aged about 54 years Occ.
Business, R/o.H.No.16-8-725,94-A, Class New Malakpet, Hyderabad, rep. by
his GPA Holder Mohammed Khaleel, S/o.Mohd Mehtab, Muslim, aged about
43 years, Occ. Business, H.No.19-2-361 , Kamatipura, Hyderabad.
... Respondents/Claimants
4. Shri.M.Bhaskar, Sole Arbitrator, H.No.16-2-753lCl'1, Flal No.30, Revenue
Board Colony, Malakpet, Hyderabad- 500036.
...Respondent No.4/Sole Arbitrator
f!@fE7
l.A. NO: 1 OF 2025
Petition under Section 5 of Limitation Act praying that in the circumstances
stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
to condone the delay ol 1373 days in filing the present COM.C.A. No.27 ol 2025
against the judgment and Decree daled 05.12.2019 passed by the Hon'ble
Commercial Court-cum-XXIV Additional Chief Judge, City Civil Court, Hyderabad in
C.O.P. No. 38 of 2077.
Counsel for the Appellants: Mr. P.S. Rajashekar, counsel representing
Mr. A.P. Reddy
Counsel for the Respondents No.1 & 2: Mr. K. Arun Kumar, counsel
representing Mr. R.A. Achuthanand
The Court made the following: COMMON ORDER
-
THE HON'BLE JUSTICE MOUSHUMI BHATTACHARYA
AND
THE HON'BLE JUSTICE GADI PRAVEEN KUMAR
I.A.No. 1 of 2o25
INf N-D
COMMERCIAL CO URT APPEAL No.27 of 2025
DATE OF O RDER: O4.Oa.2O26
Be tween
M/s. Century 21, a registered Partnership Firm,
Rep. by its Partner and 'I'wo Olhers
[)eti lroners / A ppellants
ANI)
Mohammecl Khaleel and Three Others
Rcspondcnts/ Respondents
Mr 1'S R.rtashckiu. lLarrr€'d (otlrrs( L r( l)r.\,':ltlrL;1 vI A I' l(dcl\, lcarnc'(l (()unscl apl)carrrrll
lor the apprllarrs
Mr. K Anrn Kumar, learned counsel reprcsentrng Mr R.A. Achuthanand. lcarned coLlnscl
appcarinB lor rhe rcspondent Nos.I and .2
COMMON -QRDER: @er I lor ble Jusli(.' l4onshumi BlLattachqrlld)
I
LA.No.1 ol 2025 is an application filed by the appelJants
rr>r condonation of delaSr of 1373 tlays in filing of the Commercial
Oouru A ppcal
2.
The Appcal arises out ol an ordcr dated 05.12.)O19
passecl by the Commercial Court at I'lvderabad dismlssing COP
Iir,.ll8 ol 20 l7 l-ilcd br th< appcilr'rnl.s f()r sctring asidc ttrc Au'ard
.-
)
dat<'d 1r.03 2O I .3 passccl tx rhc lcarncd Arbitrator. 'l'hc
CcrnrmcTrlal lloLrn clrsmissed thc CC)P, inter alia, on the ground
thal the appellants u'cre nnable to establish any patent ilk:galitv
rrr pen,crsilr, in the Au,arcl and therc \\'as t1o meLtcrial on r-ccord
l.o loncltrc.lr: t:lat thc Ar.r'ard u,:rs unfair. urrreasonable or that thc
At :rrd shockcd the c'onscience of the Court.
'l'hr'apl)ell:ints havc filcd lh(' prcscnt Appetrl undcr scctior.r
l.
I 3 of 'l'hc C,rnmcrci:rl Corrrts Act. 2015 ('CCAI ri,ad q'irh scclion
37 of l'he Ar bitration and Conciliation Act. 1996 ('A&C Ac1')
IIou cve r. lhc rssue belore this Court is ,"r hc'ther thc delav ol
13711 davs in lllirrg ol' thc prcsi'nt ,\ppcai shor.rlcl bc condoned or
n01
'+.
.-')
I-car-rld counsr'l appc:rring for the appellants has placcd
thc Alfrdtrr it in srrppon oi rlrc pctiLion iilcd ft)r conclonatrrtn oI
delr r and tht: rcasons stated thcreln explaining the delay of
13i.3 davs ln liling the present Appeal. Colrnsel submits that
seclion 5 ol 'l'hc l-inritertion Act, 1963 ('l,rmitatiln Act') r,rould
appl\ to arr Aopr:a1 lllccl uncler sc<:tiotr 37 of rhc. A&(l Act and
also that t1-rr' :rppellants have shown sufficient causc for
, np,ii,n jng -lt e rll la r
5.
l,carned counsci appcanng lor the respondents subrnits
that the Appeal should be dismissed on the ground of inordinate
delay. . Counsel further submits that the appellants have failed
to tr)rovrde sul'l-tcrcnI rcasons lbr condoning the delay.
6.
We have heard learned counsel for the parties. Counsel
for the respondent takes strong objection to the delay bcing
condoncd. We proposc to bncfly outlinc the relcvant reasons
stated in the Affidavit for condoning the dclay in lhe form of a
sequence o[ even ts.
05 12 2019
lmpugncd ordcr. passcd by the Comrncrcia)
Court at llyderabad dismissing the appellart [s'
COP No.38 of 2017
29 .O3.2020
"
Limitation under section t 3(1A) of The
Commercial Courts Act, 2015 expired.
t 5.041.2020 ro
24.o2.2022
Pcri.--rd ercludt:d fr>r computatron ol limitation
b\ virtue of the Supreme Coult jrrdgment rn
Cogni-z,ance Jor Extension, in Re, (2022) 3 SCC
I 17 given in the wake of pandemic.
23.O3.2022
The appellant No.3 was unable to travel to
lndra and haci to rcturn to thc USA and vyas
admitted rn a hospital.
24.O4.2022
'1'he appcllant No 3 passed away in the USA.
30.o5.2022
Look Ou t Noticc was issued aga.rn st the
appellant No.2 on a complaint lodged by the
respon dertts.
07 06.2022
'l'hc appcllant No.2 rvas detained by the
Inim i gratr on Au thorities a t RGIA. Llyclcrabad.
.-
t3 1C -)O.t.l
'l'he respondents lik:d Flrecution petrtion
for
cxe,cuting thc Arltitr.al Atetrcl ancl for
,:I-, IrlTl, ril ,,1 'h, a|:'r,ll;- tts l)t.opcflir,\
02.1t 20 ), ),
'I'he appcilanrs
13 12 20i,..)-
The appellanrs rcceived the Cert.ihecl Copl of
thc impugnecl order.
l.elrru:Ln. l02il
l'he appcllanL lio.2 nret rtith an accidcnr.
t7 .a4 . 202.1
'l he appcllant
hled arr applicatron lor Certtlied
Copr of the rmpr.rgnect r:rder dated OS.l2.2O 19.
No.2 filcd \\'.P.No. 10647 of )O23
berforc this Court for setting aside the I.ookout
\ otice
.lunc, 202 I
l'hc appellants consulted an A(l\.ocate for filing
an Appeal against thc lmpugne,l order.
,lui\. .)() 2:
l hc
rcsponLle nLs lt:ri c
rl)p, ll.rnl\ l,'1,,)rnprLrinrs(
ap,proat:hccl thc
.
Augusl.2Cr23
L)isputes arose betu.een the appellants ancl the
rcspondents r.vith regard to the properties at
Chevclla resulLing in failure of the compromise
ta
lks.
( )c I o bc:. 2O23
'l Irc appcllants
30. r 0.202:
'l'hc appellants submitted the
+
)
.). 3
t() O().2 ( ) l5
consultccl er nc.,r Aclr.ocalt, fr_.r
liirng thc AppcaJ agarnst the impugned ordt:r
required
documents to their new AdYocate.
-l'l.re
appellants liled CNIA No.614 of 2023
bclorc this Court against the imltugned rtrdcr
'l lrc
tlr,
Court p(,rmtttcd thL. appcllants to converr
1 111.1 Itlcd undcr s(..t rorr J; ul lhr
Arbitratlon and Conciliatron Act, 1996. to a
COMCA under section 13(1A) of the CCA.
7.
Thc rcas,tns slltccl br thc appcJlanrs in rhc.ir AfficLavit
togcLher ri]rh the relevant daLes have been set out solely for the
plrrp()se of denronstrating the gaps between
the relevan t ClateS
and the corresponding rcason providcd for thc delay. This
Court is bound b-l' t hc ordcr passe d by the Supremc Court
excluding the period of limrtation from 15-O3.2020 to
28.O2.2022. However, despite excluding the aforesaid period,
thc facts staled boLh bcforc: as well as post COVID- 19 would
show that the appellants seek to loist the entire laches on thc
appellant No.3 (the deceased mother of the appellant No.2).
8.
The inabilitr o1' thc appcllant No.3 1o travcl to India in
I.-ebruary ancl March, 2O2Lr ancl in March, 2022 and hcr
subsequent death in Apil, 2022 may be tragic, but does not
absolvc the appcllant No.2 fronr l.hktng steps to challenge the
imp.-gnecl order q hicl-r r,ras passtd rn t)eccmber, 2019. The
appellants themselves state that the limitation for challenging
the impugned Order, i.e., sixty days, expired on 29.O3.2O2O
uncler scction I3(1A) ol thc (lCA. I{encc, thc span of time from
29.O3.2O2O Lo 24.04.2022 (exprry ol the limrtarion undcr thc
CCA till the death of the appellant No.3) would itself be two
years 26 da1,s.
9.
The appellant No.2 failcd to take any steps even after tht:
death of the appellant No. 3. This would be evident from the
t-
se(luencc of ,,vcnts bcl,"r'ccn 30.05.2022 and 02.11.2022, during
w.hrc;h the appellants shouid have explained the delay,
parl icular-l\
n
light ol thc [,ook Our Notice issued against
Appellant N, r. 2 and thc lixecution Petition lilcd bv the
respondents on 13.1O 20)2 lor the enforcemen-- of the Arbitral
Anard
10. l'hc hrsr stcp takcn bv thc appcll.lnls fc) r challcnging the
impugned orrler uas in November, 2022, 1.e
t
three years after
hc impr..rgnccJ ordcr. 'l'hr,' appcllants' Ia-xitl r:ontrnued even after
recciving thr' Ce rtilicd Copl ol the impr-rgned order on
13. | 2.'2022. Tl-rc appcllants statc that the appr:llant No.2 met
rtith an ac cicl:nt rn Fcbruan'. 2023 and filed a Writ Petition on
17.O4.2O2.'-' lor r:hallenging the Look Out Noticc. 1'he appellants
consulted thcir Arlroc'att' ir.r ,Junr:, 20.23 lor challenging the
impugned order. IIence, there is no explanation for the period
bc-tu<:cn April
,lune, 2023 in [(]rms of r:xpcditing the challenge
to thc tmpugnr,'d orri e r
i.
The appellants take the ground of iln atteripted
cornl-rr<rmise bctlr'ecn thc Partics in ..lul-r - At-rgust, 2023 as a
rcaso1t to explilin tlte dclar. Fio'"r'cvcr, the lact ol compromise,
per se, cannot b'"' itscll be a ground lor delay in filing of the
Appeal. The steps laken by the appellants contin ued to be in
slow-motion even after failure of the compromise talks. The
appellants consultr:d lheir ncu Advocal.e in OcLobcr, 2023. The
appcilants filed the CMA onll in November, 2023 which is four
years after the impugned order o[ dated 05. 12.2019. Later, the
appellants sought leave of the Court to convert the Civil
Mjscellancous Appcal to a Commercial Court Appeal in June,
2025 which is almost r\.,".o vcars from the date of (rling ol the
CMA.
l'2. The appe llant.s' cntire c:rst-- is'lhar the beneht oI sectron 5
of the Limitation Act is availablc to them in an Appeal under
sectlon 37 of the A&C Act. This argument takes the appellants
out of the stricter limitation of section 13(1A) of rhc CCA which
provides, lnter alia, that a pcrson aggrieved by a judgment or
order ol a Commercial Court/ Commercial Division ol a High
Court may appeal to the Commercial Appellate Division of that
High Court within a pcnod ol sixt1, days from the date oi the
.;udgment or order. 'lhe proviso to section l3(1A) clarifies that
Appeals from section 37 of the A&C Act also fall within the
Appeals as providcd undcr se.ction I 3(ln) ol thc CCA.
!-
13. 'l'hc rrppcllants' argumcnl r"r<rulci also explain the
appellanrs filing the CMA from thc impugned order instcad ol a
Commercial Court Appeal under section 13 o1' the CCA. The
Appeal undr r tht, (lCA r,voukl bt: regulared bv the limitation
under st:r:rion l3( lA) rvhich is morc stringcnt thzrn tht:
discretionan reltr-xa tion avarlable under section 5 of the
Linritalion AcL.
I4
Sr:ction 5 ol the l,imitation -qct pcr:n1ts admittrng
Applications r>r Appc.:ils br.ing filecl bevond the plescnbcd pcrrod
of limrtat ion subjcct Lo thc appellanl / applicant show-tng
sulf icient car.tsc tor not prt,li.inng rltc Appeal/making the
Applcatiorr r,r'rrhin the prcscnbed pcnod o1-limitation. Section
37 ( I ) and (.2) oi t hc A&C Acr enumerate thr: categorics of
appciriablt: orclcrs 1o thc CourL authoriscd br lau to herar
Appeals from onginal dccrees of the Clolrrts. Unlike section
34(3). u,hich prcscribcs a u,atcr-tight timeline of thrce months
lrom thc datc on u,hich thc partv making that application had
receir ed thl ArlriLral r\rl'ard, and :irr zrdditionai [hi:t]r d6y5 1.,,r6".
the proviso t(r secLion 34(3), no such limitation period is
prcscnbed tbr ir n Appeai under section 37 ol the A,i,C Act.
15. Tl-re absence of a timolinr: f<rr prcferring Appeals would
conse quently direct the Court to Article 1 16(a) of the Schedule
to the Limilation Act which provides for a limitation period of
ninety dal's from thc datc ol'thc dccrcc/order for an Appeal
under The Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 to the l{igh Court and
Article 1 t 6(b) provides for a limitation period of thirty days from
thc date of t.he decree/order to any oLher Court from any decree
or ordcr.
16. ln the present case, an Appeal under section 37 of the
A&C Act u,ould hencc fall under Article I l6(a) r.e., ninety days
lrom the date of lhc dccrcc/orclcr. 'l'hc abscncc of an_r pt:riod ol
limitation prescribed under the A&C Act in Appeals under
section 37 was considcred bv t.he Supreme Court in Gouemment
of Moharashtra Vs. Ilorse llrothers Engineers and Controctors
Priuate Limitedt wherein it rr, as held that section 37 of the A&C
Act v,'ould have to be read wi th Art.icle I 6 or 1 1 7 of the
l,irnrtation Act or scct.ion 13(l A) of the CCA and that Appeals
u ndcr section
37 ol thc A&C Act would be amenable to thc
discreLionary powers of lhe Court under section 5 of the
Limitation Act.
(2021) 6 SCC 460
\-
l0
'I'he Suprcme (lourt further held that condonation ol delar'
in ,\ppcals r.Lnric'r sccLton ll7 ol thc A&(l i\ct u',)Llld hav(r lo b(l
considcrecl u iti'rin the parameters of scction 5 of the l.imitation
Aci. r,r hilr' .1r thc samc time preserving the object of speedlr
clisposal of ihe arhitral disputes. 'l')'re S.lprctnt: (lourt cautioncd
against irczlling 'sul{lctcnt cause' r.tndcr sectiort 5 oi the
Limitation Ac1 as a panacea for negligent and stale claims and
concluded that a dr'lav bevond 90 da]'s, 30 davs or 60 davs
unclcr [ht' AE'C ,\ct and tht CCA mulst bc condoncd b-v u a) ol
exct:p[ion anc not b1 \ta1' of Rule
I8. l'hus. si'ctio:.t 5 ol rhc I-imiLatlon Act cannot be Prcssed
intlr sr:n'icc as arl zlutomatlc zlntldote to cLlre delays in liLrng of
appcals rtndet'section 37 of the A&C Act
i9. 'lhc cases citcci on bchall oi Lhcr lrppellants are
clrsringuishab c on l'acts. Sheo Raj Singh u Llnion of lndia'' u as
concerned s-t.h a challcnge to arr ordcr passed b5 the High
Cor r rt bl ri'l'rich lhc f ligh Court allou'ed an application filcd by
the Union ol IIrdi:r undcr se(ltion 5 of ttrc l'imitation Act
condoning the delav of '179 dals tn presenting an Appcal from
120;i,l lC SCC 5
li
the decision of the Reference Court under section of The Land
Acquisition Act, 1894. The Supreme Court called for a liberal
a pproach b)'
thc Courts ancl a cr:rta in lee wa1' to be provtded Lo
thc StaLe/Union of India.
20. Mool Chandra u. [Jnion of Indias reinforced the settled
principlc that th(' t-'aus<: lor dclal' should iall within the four
corners of 'sufficient causc' regardiess of the length ol delay.
The Supreme Court reiterated that the High Courts should not
condone the delal' u,hcre negligcncc can b(l attribulablc to the
appellan t.
2l .
In Kandla Export Corporation u. OCI Corporationa, the
Supremc' Court held that scclion 50 ol the A&C Act enumerates
th<: appcllablc ordcrs undcr
[)arl. of the A&C Act i.e., relating
to enforcement of Foreign Awards. The Supreme Court further
held that Appeals under sccl.ion 13(1) of the CCA, being a
gcneral pmvision ui.s-a-rrr-s arbitral.i<>n r<:lating to Appeals arising
out of commercial disputes, wouid not apply to cases covercd by
section 50 of the A&C Act.
(202s) i SCC 62s
(2018) 14 SCC 71s
\-
t2
22 The sr.Lm a nd substance of the above cases, even if
iactuall\ rlistrngurshablc. is that section 5 ol the Limllation Act
u'or-rld applr' ',o .{ppcals lilcd Lrndcr scctiorl 37 rf tltc A&C Ac:t.
Con sequenth . thc (lourt lr,ould be authoriserl to invoke its
discretionarl po\i('rs 1o assess u'hether lhc appellant has shor'vn
sulf icic'nt caust' [or t]'re dola-r in liling rri the Appcal, I Iot'r:ver,
riespitc sur:1- mitigarion of Ltn-relines. condolllng tho dela-v
berond the lilrritation prescribed under Arti(r1e 116 of the
l,inrirarion ,\cr shoulcl br: trealccl as mor(' ol an erceptton than
th<' r-ul<:i. lr orhct ur)rds, cvclt it thc appcllarll c:laims tmmunitr
frorn the abs(tnce of rigorous timelines under se ction 37 of the
A&,(l Act. thc paltr u'ould still have [o cross the hurcile of
cstablishrng slrllicicl'rr causc lor bcirlg pcrmitlr:d to filc an
Appeal bevonC thc prescribed pi:riod of limitation undcr Article
1 1tr of
)3
the l,intitation Ac1.
CottscqLtr:ttlh . thc dcc'isioll tls L() s hethcr thc instant
Appeal shotLltl bc p<'rmrtted to surmount the substantial dela,'.-
v[ould rest er.Lireh' on thc causes stated in th(] Affidavit filed
:rlong sith tire petili()n for conclonation o1'dcla-r
.
l3
24. The counter filed by the respondents must also be looked
at. The respondents have strongly opposed condonation of
dcla_y of L 373 da_vs in filing of the COMCA. The respondents
have raised several lactual objections in their counter including
that the appellants filed A.S.No.2 of 2023 in the Court of rhe
learned X Additional Chicf .Iudgc, Oity Civil Court at Hyderabad,
from a decree passcd in O.S.No. 1167 ol 20 17. A.S.No.2 ol 2023
was lrled on 28.O4.2022 and was registered on 06.01 .2023. The
respondents question as to whv. the appellants chose to be
diiigcnt onlv in rhe Appcal Suit but laik:d to show equal
diligence in challenging the impugned order dated OS.12.2Olg.
25. The respondents also denv the fact that the appellants
approachcd them for :: compromise and subsequent failure of
the compromisc. Thc rcspondcnts also say that thr: appcllanr
No.2 is the Managing Director of the appellant No. 1/partnership
Firm and has the necessarv- authorization to represent the Firm.
Ilcncc, thc dcla_v shovu,n on t hc grou nd of the appellant No.3 (the
mother of the respondent No.2) being unable to fly to India
during the COVID period and her subsequent death cannot be
sufhcient (--auses to allou, thr: applicat ion of condonation. The
respondents also contend that thc.,tppcllants have not filed any
.-
document to corroborate the causes of illness and accident
sulfcred bv tl- e appe llant No.2 as contained in the Affidavit
26. Wc find sttbstancc in thc objcction takcn by thc
responclents. As stitted above, the sufhciencl of cause shor''"'n
must rcflc c1 cliiigt:nce and a gcnuit-te t:lfort to cxplain thc dela-r'
rn liling ol t ht' Appcal or applicatiorl bc) ond thc pre scribr:d
period of lim:tzrtion. The absence of particulars / corroborative
cviclr:nc:e irt sLtpport of ttrc grounds becomcs significant as the
dclav is s r-Lbstzrntial
27 Al rhc cost oi repetition, cvgn if the appellants seek refuge
in section 3l of the A&C nct not being constricted with a
timcframc. lhc appeliants r'rould sti1l have lo negotiat(' the
ninctl, davs l'mitation under Article 115(a) ol tl-re Schedr.rle to
the l-imilation Act. The delav in the present case is of 1373
davs r,",hich is nc::rrlr' foltr \ cars'l'hc AlfLdaVit iails to cxplain as
to rt,hy the appcllant No,2 chose to exclude himself from the
process of c}'ra llenging to the impugned order and depend on his
nrother/appe1 ant. No 3 to do thc needful' The Affidavit also fails
to cxplain as to u ht thc .lppcilarll No 2 sclc<:ttvely pursucd tlther
proceedings, i e., Appcal Suit and the Writ Petition agatnst the
--
l5
Look Out Notice, in the High Court, but completely ignored and
overlooked the challenge to the dismissal of section 34 Petition.
'lhc grounds of accid<:nt and illncss are not supportcd with any
evidence.
28. We also deem it fit to reitcrate l.hal tsorse Brothers (supra)
ma,u- givc the appcllan ts
.t rl
op portun it]'
to invokc thc
discret.ionary pol\'ers of thc Court under section 5 of the
Limitation Act, but does not give the Court a free hand lo
condonc thc dela]' r,r'hr:re thr'rc is an apparen t lack of bona fides.
I3orse l3rothers (supra) in I'ac1 <::rutronr;d that thc Courts should
be doubly-cautious ln condonin'g delays where the avowed
object of the A&C Act read r.r,ith CCA is to expedite disposal of
Arbrtratron and CornnrerTr-iai i)isputcs. Wc ma1' also add that a
lcngthy statcmenl containing numerous reasons for the delay
ra,ill not save the appellants. Listing of twenty causes would not
automaticallv l ranslatc to sufficiencv. In contrast, even a few.
CALISCS
cxplaincd r.iLh prcclslon and with corroborating
evidence, wherever required, would satisfy the test
Unfortunately, the present casc lalls under the former
t6
29 Thlrs. u'e are constrained to hold that the appellanls have
lailed to sho'* sulftr:icnt caLtse for condoning tLLe delay ol I373
dai s irt l'rJlng rt :irc ilrcscnt Appcerl
.30 I.A.\o. L oi 2025 is accordingly dismissed. As a
(ronsc(lu( ncc thcrr'to. CIOMCA No.27 oi 2025 is also dismissed
Misr:cllanr:ous aoplicatrons ptrncltng, il an1 . shall starld closcd
No co sts.
SD/. K. SRINIVASA RAO
OINT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
U
To,
The Judge, Commercial Court-cum-XXIV Additional Chief Judge'
Court, HYderabad
2. One CCio Mr. A.P Reddy, Advocate [OPUC]
5. On" CC to Mr R.A. Achuthanand, Advocate [OPUC]
4. Two CD CoPies
KAIV/GNK
M
CTION OFFICER
City Civil
HIGH COURT
DATED: 0410812026
COMMON ORDER
l.A.No.1 o12025
IN/AND
COMCA.No.27 of 2025
DISMISSING COMCA AND I.A.
l)'' "ti
t!1i
\
--1i.
c \. lr'
1 HE SI4
.i({'
,2$
D
U
>
z
Z O AUE 2O2O
* d,
fsparcH
6!
*
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review