Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CR-9284-2025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH
289(2)
Date of decision: 07.05.2026
CR-9284-2025 (O&M)
M/s Bioaide Corporation & Anr.
...Petitioner(s)
Vs.
Rajesh Garg
...Respondent(s)
***
COCP-47-2026 (O&M)
Rajesh Garg
...Petitioner(s)
Vs.
Gurjeet Singh Kohli
...Respondent(s)
CORAM:
HON’BLE MS. JUSTICE NIDHI GUPTA
Present:-
Mr. Rakesh Bhatia, Advocate
for the petitioner in CR-9284-2025.
Mr. Rajesh Garg, Senior Advocate with
Ms. Neha Matharoo, Advocate
for the respondent in CR-9284-2025.
***
NIDHI GUPTA, J.
CR-9284-2025
The present revision petition has been filed under Article 227 of
the Constitution of India for setting aside the order dated 17.11.2025
(Annexure P-5) passed by the learned Civil Judge (Jr. Divn.) Chandigarh to an
extent of imposing of the condition to furnish bank guarantee of the principal
SUNENA
2026.05.08 14:43
I agree to specified
portions of this document
CR-9284-2025
amount of Rs.3,86,400/- on the statement of the counsel for the petitioner
without taking any instructions from the petitioner as well as for filing
application for leave to defend.
2.
Brief facts of the case are that respondent–Rajesh Garg instituted
a civil suit under Order XXXVII Rule 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908,
seeking a decree for recovery of ₹4,11,584/- against the present petitioners.
Notices were issued to the petitioners/defendants; however, they failed to
appear and were proceeded against ex parte vide order dated 15.02.2023. The
suit filed by respondent–Rajesh Garg was thereafter decreed ex parte vide
judgment and decree dated 25.04.2025. Subsequently, the present petitioners
filed an application under Order IX Rule 13 CPC for setting aside the ex parte
judgment and decree dated 25.04.2025, and notice of the said application was
issued to the respondent. After hearing learned counsel for the respective
parties, the learned Civil Judge (Junior Division), Chandigarh, vide order dated
17.11.2025, set aside the ex parte judgment and decree dated 25.04.2025,
holding that the petitioner–defendants were not personally served. While
passing the impugned order dated 17.11.2025, it was recorded that the
petitioners/defendants were willing to furnish a bank guarantee to the tune of
₹3,86,400/-, which was stated to be the principal amount. The matter was
thereafter adjourned to 17.12.2025 for filing an application seeking leave to
defend and for furnishing the bank guarantee.
SUNENA
2026.05.08 14:43
I agree to specified
portions of this document
CR-9284-2025
3.
Learned counsel for the petitioners contends that the impugned
order deserves to be set aside, as the condition imposed for furnishing a bank
guarantee of the principal amount of ₹3,86,400/- was based solely on the
statement made by the counsel for the petitioners without any instructions
from the petitioners. It is further submitted that the direction to file an
application for leave to contest the suit is also unsustainable, particularly when
the suit itself does not fall within the ambit of Order XXXVII Rule 2 of the Code
of Civil Procedure, 1908.
4.
It is accordingly prayed that the present Revision Petition be
allowed and the impugned order be set aside to the aforesaid extent.
5.
Learned Senior Counsel for the respondent takes strong exception
to the submissions advanced on behalf of the petitioner and submits that suit
of the respondent/plaintiff was decreed ex parte vide judgment and decree
dated 25.04.2025 (Annexure P3) by the learned Civil Judge (Junior Division),
Chandigarh for recovery of Rs.4,11,584/- from the petitioners/defendants
along with pendente lite interest @ 9% per annum and @ 6% per annum future
interest till its realisation. Upon application dated 01.07.2025, filed by the
petitioners under Order 9 Rule 13 CPC, the said ex parte judgment and decree
dated 25.04.2025 was set aside as above, however, subject to the furnishing
of bank guarantee by the petitioners for an amount of Rs.3,86,400/-.
6.
Learned Senior Counsel submits that the argument on behalf of
the petitioners that learned counsel representing the petitioners before the
SUNENA
2026.05.08 14:43
I agree to specified
portions of this document
CR-9284-2025
learned trial Court had given the undertaking on behalf of the petitioners to
furnish bank guarantee of the principal amount, without instructions from the
petitioners, is misconceived as it is established position in law that in a money
decree, pre-deposit has to be made. As such, even if no undertaking had been
given by the learned counsel representing the petitioners before the trial court,
as per law, petitioners would still be required to make a pre-deposit.
7.
Ld. Senior counsel further submits that in fact, if a party denies
undertaking given by a counsel on a point of law, then action under the
Contempt of Courts Act is liable to be taken against the party. In support of his
contentions, learned Senior Counsel has relied upon various judgements. It is
accordingly prayed that the present revision petition be dismissed.
8.
No other argument is made on behalf of the parties. I have heard
learned counsel for the parties and perused the case file in detail. I find no
merit in the submissions of the petitioners.
9.
Present Revision Petition has been filed by the defendants for
partly setting aside order dated 17.11.2025 (Annexure P5) passed by learned
Civil Judge (Junior Division), Chandigarh whereby application filed by the
petitioners under Order 9 Rule 13 CPC for setting aside ex parte judgment and
decree dated 25.04.2025 was conditionally allowed as follows: “4. After hearing the learned counsel for the applicants and
respondent, this Court perused that the exparte Judgment and
Decree dated 25.04.2025 was passed in CS 1960/2022 and further
perusal of case file reflected that the notice was not personally
SUNENA
2026.05.08 14:43
I agree to specified
portions of this document
CR-9284-2025
served upon the defendants/applicants and notice was published
in newspaper Chardikalan and the defendants were proceeded
exparte vide Order dated 15.02.2023. So perusal of Order dated
09.12.2023 reflected that notices issued to defendants were
received back with the report that no such person resides on the
given address, so, this Court is of the considered view that this is
a fit case to set aside the exparte Judgment and Decree dated
25.04.2025 as the defendants were not personally served and
moreover, defendants/applicants are also ready to furnish the
bank guarantee to the amount to Rs.3,86,400/- which is alleged
principal amount, accordingly, this Court finds it justifiable to
allow the present application under Order 9 Rule13 of CPC, subject
to furnishing of bank guarantee to the principal amount of
Rs.3,86,400/-by the applicant/defendant and in case the
defendant/applicant failed to furnish the bank guarantee on the
adjourned date of the civil suit then the present application would
be treated as dismissed and the Judgment and Decree dated
25.04.2025 would be treated as not set aside. This Court is hereby
ordered to restore the Original Civil Suit titled as "Rajesh Garg Vs.
M/s Bioaide Corporation and Another" bearing No. 1960 of 2022
on its original number and the present application alongwith
record be attached with the main file.”
10.
By way of the present Revision Petition, the petitioner is seeking
setting aside of the aforesaid order to the extent that condition has been
imposed upon the petitioner to furnish bank guarantee of the principal
amount of Rs.3,86,400/-; as the said undertaking to make the deposit is stated
SUNENA
2026.05.08 14:43
I agree to specified
portions of this document
CR-9284-2025
to have been given by the learned counsel representing the petitioner before
the trial court, without instructions from the petitioner.
11.
However, ld. counsel for the petitioners is unable to dispute the
position in law as stated by learned Senior Counsel for the respondent that in
a money decree, a pre-deposit is liable to be made even without an
undertaking in this behalf by the counsel representing the said party. It is not
disputed that in a money decree, it is a mandatory pre-condition to pre-deposit
the amount. In this regard, reference may be made to judgment of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in “Mahesh Kumar Joshi Vs. Madan Singh Negi” (2015) 2 SCC
254, where it is held that:“10. After due consideration, we are of the view that a debatable
issue does arise for consideration and it will be fair and just to give
the appellant an opportunity to contest the suit subject to the
appellant depositing the entire amount claimed in the suit but
without interest or costs i.e. Rs 3 lakhs. In pursuance of the interim
order dated 8-3-2013, the appellant claims to have deposited 50%
of the decretal amount before the trial court. On depositing the
rest of the amount to make up the deficit of Rs 3 lakhs within six
weeks from today, the decree will stand set aside and the
appellant will be entitled to leave to defend. The deposit will abide
by further order of the trial court.
11. We are conscious of the fact that setting aside of ex parte
decree under Order 37 Rule 4 of the Code cannot be allowed in
routine and special circumstances are required to be established.
However, the expression "special circumstances" has to be
construed having regard to the individual fact situations. The
SUNENA
2026.05.08 14:43
I agree to specified
portions of this document
CR-9284-2025
court has to balance the equities and while safeguarding the
interest of the plaintiff, appropriate conditions can be laid down if
the defendant makes out a debatable case which may prime facie
show injustice if the ex parte decree was not set aside.
12. As already observed, in the present case, it will be in the
interests of justice that the ex parte decree is set aside but the
interest of the plaintiff is safeguarded by the deposit of the
amount in question by the defendant as a condition precedent for
setting aside the decree.”
12.
As regards, assertion of the petitioner that the said undertaking
was given by the ld. Counsel without instructions from the petitioner, the same
is also liable to be rejected in view of case Law on this issue. The Hon’ble
Supreme Court in “Balwantbhai Somabhai Bhandari Vs. Hiralal Somabhai
contractor (Deceased) represented by LRs & Others” (2023) 17 SCC 545, has
held that: “B. Contempt of Court - Civil Contempt - Breach of undertaking
- Wilful breach of an assurance in form of an undertaking given by
a counsel/advocate on behalf of his client to court, held, would
amount to civil contempt" as defined under S. 2(b) of the 1971 Act
— Law clarified
XXX XXX XXX
117.1. We hold that an assurance in the form of an undertaking
given by a counsel/advocate on behalf of his client to the court;
the wilful breach or disobedience of the same would amount to
"civil contempt" as defined under Section 2(b) of the 1971 Act.
XXX XXX XXX
SUNENA
2026.05.08 14:43
I agree to specified
portions of this document
CR-9284-2025
117.5. The apology tendered should not be accepted as a matter
of course and the court is not bound to accept the same. The
apology may be unconditional, unqualified and bona fide, still if
the conduct is serious, which has caused damage to the dignity of
the institution, the same should not be accepted. There ought not
to be a tendency by courts, to show compassion when
disobedience of an undertaking or an order is with impunity and
with total consciousness.”
13.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in “Indian Medical Association &
Another Vs. Union of India & Others” (2024) 19 SCC 193, has held that:“In Balwantbhai Somabhai Bhandari, the Court further observed
as under: (SCC pp. 587-88, para 74)
"74. An undertaking or an assurance given by a lawyer based upon
which the court decides upon a particular course of action would
definitely fall within the confines of "undertaking" as stipulated
under Section 2(b) of the Act, 1971 and the breach of which would
constitute "civil contempt" As held in M.v. Home Office relied upon
by this Court in Rama Narang that if a party or solicitor or counsel
on his behalf, so as to convey to the court a firm conviction that
an undertaking is being given, that party will be bound and it will
be no answer that he did not think that he was giving it or that he
was misunderstood. The breach of an undertaking given to a court
by a person in a pending proceeding on the faith of which the
court sanctions a particular course of action is misconduct
amounting to contempt."”
14.
Our own Court in “Ankit Rawal Vs. State of Haryana” CRM-8361-
2026 and CRM-9472-2026 in CRM-M-4433-2026, has held that:“9. There is another aspect nay vital aspect of the matter which
SUNENA
2026.05.08 14:43
I agree to specified
portions of this document
CR-9284-2025
deserves to be addressed by this Court.
9.1 The judicial process operates on the foundational presumption
that statements made by a counsel at the Bar are made with full
authority and reflect the true intent of the litigant concerned. This
principle ensures that the Court can effectively adjudicate without
being compelled to verify the internal communications between a
lawyer and the client at every state of proceedings. By executing
a Vaqalatnama, a litigant clothes the counsel engaged with
express as well as implied authority to plead, act and appear in
the best interest of the client. If a litigant were permitted to resile
from
an
adjudication/order
made
premised
upon
the
statement/argument advanced by his/her counsel, it would
render every court proceeding tentative and every judicial order
vulnerable to being reopened, simply because the litigant has had
a change of heart or has engaged a new counsel. Pertinently,
entertaining such a plea would pave the way for a dangerous
precedent, effectively allowing a second bite at the apple. It is to
be borne in mind that a counsel is an officer of the court and not
merely a mechanical agent of the litigant; and owes a duty to the
court to ensure the smooth administration of justice. If an act,
conduct or concession given by a counsel is not deemed to be
authorized by the litigant, the entire adjudicatory framework
would stall, as no opposing party or presiding officer could ever
rely upon a statement made by a legal representative.
10. Adverting to the factual milieu of the instant case, the attempt
by the applicant-petitioner to disavow the withdrawal of petition
under the guise of 'lack of instructions', amounts to a procedural
heresy striking at the very root of the advocate-client relationship,
as also an affront to the adjudicatory process, where an advocate
SUNENA
2026.05.08 14:43
I agree to specified
portions of this document
CR-9284-2025
plays pivotal role of assisting the court. In the earlier round, when
this Court expressed a clear disinclination to grant the relief
prayed for, the decision of the counsel (appearing for the
applicant-petitioner) to withdraw the petition, in order to shield
the applicant-petitioner from an adverse order on merit, which
might have prejudiced the future remedies, is an exhibit of
professional diligence and prudence. To allow the applicantpetitioner, at this stage, to characterise it as an unauthorized act
is to undermine the very purpose of legal representation. The
averment that the previous counsel was 'not properly instructed',
stands in the face of the integrity of the legal profession. The
applicant-petitioner having put his signature on the Vaqalatnama,
cannot be permitted to act as a stranger to the actions taken by
his earlier counsel in open court, especially when such action was
intended to mitigate a legal damage. To accept this plea would
virtually allow the applicant-petitioner to abuse the process of law
by turning this Court into a laboratory for experimental litigation.
It is necessary to detest such vexatious and virulent attempts) by
unscrupulous elements, aimed at misusing the process of law and
Courts. The sanctity of the judicial process will be seriously eroded
if such attempts) is not responded with necessary firmness. A
litigant who misuses the process of law or take liberties with the
truth should be left in no doubt about the consequences to follow.
Others should be discouraged not to venture along the same path
in the hope or on a misplaced expectation of judicial leniency or
indulgence. Exemplary costs, in such a situation are inevitable and
necessary, so as to ensure that in litigation, as in the law which is
rather practiced in our Country, there is no premium on the truth.
SUNENA
2026.05.08 14:43
I agree to specified
portions of this document
CR-9284-2025
Such misleading pleas which are deficient in any reasonability,
have to be construed as trifling with the Courts and the process of
justice.
11. In view of the prevenient ratiocination, it is ordained thus:
(i) The application in hand is devoid of merits and is hereby
dismissed with costs of ₹20,000/-, which shall be deposited by the
petitioner with Chief Judicial Magistrate (CJM), Panipat within
four weeks from today. In case such costs are deposited; CJM,
Panipat shall have the same remitted to Haryana State Legal
Services Authority, Panchkula. In case, the said costs are not
deposited by the petitioner as directed for; the CJM, Panipat is
directed to intimate the Deputy Commissioner, Panipat who shall
have such costs recovered from the petitioner as arrears of land
revenue and upon realization thereof, the Deputy Commissioner,
Panipat shall have the same submitted to CJM, Panipat, for
further remittance thereof to Haryana State Legal Services
Authority, Panchkula. A compliance report be sent by CJM,
Panipat as also Deputy Commissioner, Panipat to this Court
accordingly.”
15.
Again in “Bank of Baroda Vs. Sadruddin Hasan Daya & Another”
(2004) 1 SCC 360, Hon’ble Supreme Court held that:“The submission that the Supreme Court having passed a consent
decree, the remedy of the petitioner lay in executing the same and
there was no occasion for initiating contempt proceedings against
the respondents has hardly any merit. The wilful breach of an
undertaking given to a court amounts to "civil contempt" within
the meaning of Section 2(b) of the Contempt of Courts Act. The
respondents having committed breach of the undertaking given
SUNENA
2026.05.08 14:43
I agree to specified
portions of this document
CR-9284-2025
to the Supreme Court in the consent terms they are clearly liable
for having committed contempt of court. The fact that the
petitioner can execute the decree can have no bearing on the
contempt committed by the respondents. The law in England on
the subject of breach of undertaking given to court is same. The
Supreme Court had put its imprimatur upon the consent terms
and made it a decree of the court. The violation or breach of the
undertaking which became part of the decree of the court
certainly amounts to contempt of court, irrespective of the fact
that it is open to the decree-holder to execute the decree.
Contempt is a matter between the court and the alleged
contemner and is not affected in any manner by the rights or
obligations of the parties to the litigation inter se.”
16.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in “Om Prakash Vs. Suresh Kumar”
(2020) 13 SCC 188, wherein it is held that:“- Landlord filing suit for eviction on ground of requirement of
premises for reconstruction — During revision before High Court,
tenant urging that he was ready and willing to hand over
possession of suit premises subject to landlord agreeing to
reinduct him as tenant in equivalent area occupied by him
— In response thereto, counsel for landlord stating that landlord
was not averse to that offer - Said statement of counsel was in
relation to commitment of landlord qua the subject-matter of the
proceedings in which the counsel was engaged and instructed to
appear — No case of landlord that he had expressly instructed his
counsel not to make such a statement
— Landlord in such a case, held, could not be allowed to resile
from the statement made before High Court — High Court rightly
SUNENA
2026.05.08 14:43
I agree to specified
portions of this document
CR-9284-2025
declined to undo the same in review petition filed by landlord for
that purpose — Statement of counsel, thus, binding on landlord
— Landlord obliged to provide tenant with area which was being
used by him earlier — However, in the fact situation of the present
case, to do complete justice to parties, an equitable arrangement
was provided herein — Under that arrangement, though the area
which was to be provided to tenant after reconstruction of
building was less than the area which was earlier in his possession,
landlord directed to compensate tenant for the said loss of area
by paying Rs 74,000 to tenant - Decree passed by High Court
modified accordingly, issuing other necessary directions
XXX XXX XXX
High Court in present matter disposing of revision petition, which
was filed by tenant, on basis of certain statement made to that
court by counsel of landlord — However, subsequently, landlord
changing his advocate and filing review petition before High Court,
asserting that he had never instructed his counsel to make such
statement before court — Conduct of review petitioner, held,
liable to be deprecated — Such review petition should not be
encouraged and was therefore rightly dismissed - Practice and
Procedure - Review/ Recall - Abuse of Process of Court/Law/Fraud
on Court — Approbation and reprobation”
17.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in Patanjali Ayurved Limited through
Its Managing Director, Acharya Balkrishna and Baba Ramdev v. Union of India
(SC) : Law Finder Doc Id # 2632960, has held that: “If an undertaking is being
given regardless of the fact that the word "undertaking" has not been
SUNENA
2026.05.08 14:43
I agree to specified
portions of this document
CR-9284-2025
specifically mentioned, that party will be bound down and it will be no answer
that he did not think that he was giving it or that he was misunderstood.” Court
proceedings carry sanctity which cannot be discarded at the sweet desire of
the applicant.
18.
Again, the Hon’ble Supreme Court in a recent judgment in
Lavanya C. v. Vittal Gurudas Pai Since Deseased, (SC) : Law Finder Doc Id #
2701936 has held that “any undertaking given by counsel, once recorded or
incorporated into a court order, remains operative unless promptly challenged
or withdrawn. Crucially, the subsequent dismissal of the suit or alleged
deficiencies in the property description do not absolve a party from liability if
the undertaking is later violated.” In terms of the above said judgment, the
petitioner cannot be permitted to resile and renege from the undertaking
given. An undertaking given to a Court is a solemn commitment that carries
the same force as a Court order, and a wilful breach thereof, constitutes
contempt of court. Subsequent actions, developments, thoughts, and feelings
do not absolve a party from an undertaking given during the proceedings.
19.
This Court is constrained to observe that it has become an
increasingly disturbing trend to resile on statements made and undertakings
given before the Court. Such a practice needs to be contained and condemned
most strongly as it blasphemies the sanctity of Court proceedings.
20.
Furthermore, learned counsel for the petitioner has been unable
to make out as to how partial challenge to the impugned order qua only
SUNENA
2026.05.08 14:43
I agree to specified
portions of this document
CR-9284-2025
condition of pre-deposit is maintainable. In effect, the petitioners are stating
that insofar as application of the petitioners under Order 9 Rule 13 CPC was
allowed, the learned counsel had instructions from the petitioners. However,
so far as condition of pre-deposit is imposed the same is without instructions
and the petitioners are not bound. Such a position is unacceptable. Needless
to say, such a partial reliance upon counsel is unacceptable.
21.
Learned counsel for the petitioners is unable to dispute or
controvert the above said factual and legal position.
Accordingly, present Revision Petition is dismissed.
22.
COCP-47-2026
23.
Present Contempt Petition has been filed by the decree holder for
violation of undertaking given to the Civil Court at Chandigarh on 17.11.2025
(Annexure P1) in Civil Misc.278/2025, “Rajesh Garg Vs. M/s Bioaide
Corporation” and also for misusing the process of law.
24.
At the very outset, learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner has
submitted that the Present Contempt Petition is not pressed.
In view of the above, the present Revision Petition is dismissed;
25.
and Contempt Petition stands dismissed being not pressed.
26.
Pending application(s) if any also stand(s) disposed of.
(Nidhi Gupta)
Judge
07.05.2026
Sunena
Whether speaking/reasoned:
Whether reportable:
SUNENA
2026.05.08 14:43
I agree to specified
portions of this document
Yes/No
Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review