Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/17
GAHC010242412018
2026:GAU-AS:1776
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : MACApp./180/2019
M/S. BAJAJ ALLIANZ GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED
HAVING ITS REGISTERED AND HEAD OFFICE AT GE PLAZA, AIRPORT
ROAD, NERADA, PUNE- 411006 AND NORTH EASTERN REGIONAL OFFICE
AT SREEJI TOWER, 3RD FLOOR, C/GAUHATI TEA WARE HOUSING PVT.
LTD., ADJACENT TO MAHINDRA SHOWROOM, WALFORD,
CHRISTIANBASTI, GUWAHATI, PIN- 781005, KAMRUP (M) DISTRICT,
ASSAM, (REP. BY ITS LEGAL OFFICER, CLAIMS DEPARTMENT SRI NAYAN
CHOUDHURY, AGED ABOUT 28 YEARS).
VERSUS
SMTI. DHANALATA MECH AND 10 ORS.
W/O- LATE INDRA KANTA MECH
R/O- NO.1 KATHALGURI GAON, P.O.- BOKULONI CHARIALI, PIN- 786191,
P.S. DULIAJAN, DIST.- DIBRUGARH, ASSAM.
2:SRI LALIT MECH
S/O- LATE INDRA KANTA MECH
R/O- NO.1 KATHALGURI GAON
P.O.- BOKULONI CHARIALI
PIN- 786191
P.S. DULIAJAN
DIST.- DIBRUGARH
ASSAM.
3:M/S. NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED
DULIAJAN BRANCH
STATION ROAD
(REP. BY THE BRANCH MANAGER)
P.O. AND P.S. DULIAJAN
PIN- 786602
DIST.- DIBRUGARH
ASSAM. (INSURER OF VEHICLE NO. AS-23/F-2496 (MARUTI ALTO LXI
Page No.# 2/17
BS-3).
4:SRI UZWAL BORAH
S/O- SRI PHULESWAR BORAH
R/O- VILL.- NAHAT GOROIMARI GAON
P.O.- NAHAT
PIN- 785662
P.S. DEMOW
DIST.- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM. (OWNER-CUM-DRIVER OF TATA WINGER VEHICLE NO. AS-03/AC0388).
5:SMTI. NABAMI BASUMATARY
W/O- LATE KAMALA BASUMATARY
LEGAL HEIR OF LATE RAMESH BASUMATARY
THE OWNER-CUM-DRIVER OF AS-23/F-2496 (MARUTI ALTO LXI
BS-3).
R/O- PADUMONI GAON
P.O.- BHADOI PANCHALI
PIN- 786191
P.S. DULIAJAN
DIST.- DIBRUGARH
ASSAM.
6:SMTI. MANJU BASUMATARY
W/O- LATE RAMESH BASUMATARY
LEGAL HEIR OF LATE RAMESH BASUMATARY
THE OWNER-CUM-DRIVER OF AS-23/F-2496 (MARUTI ALTO LXI
BS-3).
R/O- PADUMONI GAON
P.O.- BHADOI PANCHALI
PIN- 786191
P.S. DULIAJAN
DIST.- DIBRUGARH
ASSAM.
7:SRI BHADRA BASUMATARY
S/O- LATE RAMESH BASUMATARY
LEGAL HEIR OF LATE RAMESH BASUMATARY
THE OWNER-CUM-DRIVER OF AS-23/F-2496 (MARUTI ALTO LXI
BS-3).
R/O- PADUMONI GAON
P.O.- BHADOI PANCHALI
PIN- 786191
P.S. DULIAJAN
DIST.- DIBRUGARH
ASSAM.
Page No.# 3/17
8:MS. PRIYANKA BASUMATARY
D/O- LATE RAMESH BASUMATARY
LEGAL HEIR OF LATE RAMESH BASUMATARY
THE OWNER-CUM-DRIVER OF AS-23/F-2496 (MARUTI ALTO LXI
BS-3).
R/O- PADUMONI GAON
P.O.- BHADOI PANCHALI
PIN- 786191
P.S. DULIAJAN
DIST.- DIBRUGARH
ASSAM.
9:MS. NIHA BASUMATARY
D/O- LATE RAMESH BASUMATARY
LEGAL HEIR OF LATE RAMESH BASUMATARY
THE OWNER-CUM-DRIVER OF AS-23/F-2496 (MARUTI ALTO LXI
BS-3).
R/O- PADUMONI GAON
P.O.- BHADOI PANCHALI
PIN- 786191
P.S. DULIAJAN
DIST.- DIBRUGARH
ASSAM.
10:SMTI. MIRA MECH BONIA
W/O- SRI BISHNU PRASAD BONIA
D/O- LATE INDRA KANTA MECH
R/O- VILL.- NO. 2 BOKULONI
P.O.- BOKULONI CHARIALI
PIN- 786191
P.S. DULIAJAN
DIST.- DIBRUGARH
ASSAM
11:SMTI. TARAMONI MECH GOGOI
W/O- SRI NILA GOGOI
D/O- LATE INDRA KANTA MECH
R/O- VILL. NO. 1 NAOHOLIA MAZGAON
P.O.- NAOHOLIA
PIN- 786191
P.S. DULIAJAN
DIST.- DIBRUGARH
ASSA
Advocate for the Petitioner
: MR. P HAZARIKA, MR. H S BORAH,MR D SAIKIA
Advocate for the Respondent : MR. P J SAIKIA, FOR CAVEATOR,MR. S P SHARMA,MS. C
Page No.# 4/17
MOZUMDAR,MS. R D MOZUMDAR
Linked Case : MACApp./10/2019
M/S BAJAJ ALLIANZ GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED
HAVING ITS REGISTERED AND HEAD OFFICE AT GE PLAZA
AIRPORT ROAD
NERADA
PUNE 411006 AND NORTH EASTERN REGIONAL OFFICE AT SREEJI TOWER
3RD FLOOR
C/GAUHATI TEA WARE HOUSING PVT. LTD.
ADJACENT TO MAHINDRA SHOWROOM
WALFORD
CHRISTIANBASTI
GUWAHATI
PIN 781005
KAMRUP (M) DIST.
ASSAM (REPRESENTED BY ITS LEGAL OFFICER
CLAIMS DEPTT. SRI NAYAN CHOUDHURY (AGED ABOUT 28 YEARS)
VERSUS
SMTI NABAMI BASUMATARY AND 6 ORS
W/O LATE KAMALA BASUMATARY
R/O NO. 1 KATHALGURI GAON
P.O. BOKULONI CHARIALI
PIN 786191
P.S. DULIAJAN
DIST. DIBRUGARH
ASSAM.
2:SMTI MANJU BASUMATARY
W/O LATE RAMESH BASUMATARY
R/O NO. 1 KATHALGURI GAON
P.O. BOKULONI CHARIALI
PIN 786191
P.S. DULIAJAN
DIST. DIBRUGARH
ASSAM.
3:BHADRA BASUMATARY
S/O LATE RAMESH BASUMATARY
R/O NO. 1 KATHALGURI GAON
P.O. BOKULONI CHARIALI
PIN 786191
P.S. DULIAJAN
DIST. DIBRUGARH
Page No.# 5/17
ASSAM.
4:MS. PRIYANKA BASUMATARY
D/O LATE RAMESH BASUMATARY
R/O NO. 1 KATHALGURI GAON
P.O. BOKULONI CHARIALI
PIN 786191
P.S. DULIAJAN
DIST. DIBRUGARH
ASSAM.
5:NIHA BASUMATARY
D/O LATE RAMESH BASUMATARY
R/O NO. 1 KATHALGURI GAON
P.O. BOKULONI CHARIALI
PIN 786191
P.S. DULIAJAN
DIST. DIBRUGARH
ASSAM.
6:M/S NATIONAL INSURANCE CO. LTD.
DULIAJAN BRANCH
STATION ROAD
(REPRESENTED BY THE BRANCH MANAGER)
P.O. AND P.S. DULIAJAN
PIN 786602
DIST. DIBRUGARH
ASSAM (INSURER OF VEHICLE NO. AS-23/F-2496 (MARUTI ALTO LXI
BS-3)
7:UZWAL BORAH
S/O SRI PHULESWAR BORAH
R/O VILL. NAHAT GOROIMARI GAON
P.O. NAHAT
PIN 785662
P.S. DEMOW
DIST. SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
(OWNER CUM DRIVER OF TARA WINGER VEHICLE NO. AS-03/AC-0388)
-----------Advocate for : MR. P HAZARIKA
Advocate for : MR. P J SAIKIA appearing for SMTI NABAMI BASUMATARY AND
6 ORS
Page No.# 6/17
BEFORE
HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MITALI THAKURIA
Advocate for the Appellants
:- Mr. P. Hazarika.
Advocate for the Respondent/
Claimants
:- Mr. Mr. A. K. Gupta.
Advocate for the Respondent/
Insurance Company
:- Ms. R. D. Mazumdar.
Date on which judgment is reserved
: 06.01.2026
Date of pronouncement of judgment
: 10-02-2026
Whether the Pronouncement is of the
operative part of the judgment?
: ___N/A_____
Whether the full judgment has been
pronounced?
: ___Yes_____
JUDGMENT & ORDER (CAV)
Heard Mr. P. Hazarika, learned counsel for the appellants in both the appeals
and Mr. A. K. Gupta, learned counsel for the respondent Nos. 1 and 2 in MAC APP No.
180/2019 and for the respondent Nos. 1 to 5 in MAC APP No. 10/2019 as well as Ms.
R. D. Mozumdar, learned counsel for the respondent No.3 in MAC APP No. 180/2019
Page No.# 7/17
as well as for the respondent No. 6 in MAC APP No. 10/2019.
2.
Both the applications filed under Section 173 of the M.V. Act, against the
common judgment and award dated 30.07.2018, passed by the Court of learned
Additional District Judge, Dibrugarh in MACT Case No. 38/2010 and MACT Case No.
39/2010.
3.
The brief facts of the case is that the respondent/claimants Nos. 1 and 2 as
claimants filed an application being MAC Case No. 39/2010 under Section 166 of the
MV Act before the Court of learned Member, MACT, Dibrugarh claiming compensation
for the death of her husband/father, namely, Indra Kanta Mech in a motor accident.
The claimant/respondent Nos. 1 to 5 of the connected MAC App No. 10/2019 also filed
an application being MAC Case No. 38/2010 claiming compensation for the death of
her son/husband/father, namely, Ramesh Basumatary in a motor accident.
4.
On 02.03.2010, the deceased Indra Kanta Mech and 3 others were returning
from Demow under Sivasagar District to Duliajan by a Maruti Alto Car bearing
Registration No. AS-23/F-2496 and when they reached Jollom under Moranhat Police
Station at about 05:30 pm the said car met with an accident with a TATA Winger
bearing Registration No.AS-03-AC-0388, which was coming from the opposite
direction. In the said accident, the owner/driver of the Maruti Alto Car, namely,
Ramesh Basumatary and one occupant, namely, Indra Kanta Mech died. In the said
accident the occupant Indra Kanta Mech died on the spot and the owner/driver of the
Maruti Alto Car died on his way to Sivasagar Civil Hospital.
5.
The owner/driver of the TATA Winger vehicle also lodged an FIR before the
Moranhat Police Station, which was accordingly, registered and investigated by
Moranhat Police and it was registered under Section 279/337/338/427 IPC. However, it
is the case of the claimants that due to rash and negligent driving of the offending
vehicle bearing Registration No.AS-03-AC-0388, TATA Winger, is responsible for the
accident, as it hit the other vehicle coming from the opposite direction in a rash and
Page No.# 8/17
negligent manner.
6.
The claimants accordingly impleaded the owner/driver as well as the insurer of
the offending vehicle TATA Winger and also impleaded the insurer of the Maruti Alto
Vehicle as opposite parties in the said claim petitions. The legal heirs of the deceased
owner/driver of the Maruti Car bearing Registration No. AS-23/F-2496 were also
arrayed as a proforma opposite parties for the said claim petition.
7.
On receipt of the notices all the opposite parties appeared before the Court of
learned Member, MACT and the owner/driver of the TATA Winger as well as the
insurer of both TATA Winger and Maruti Alto Car also contested their case by filing
their Written Statements.
8.
The legal heirs of the other deceased Ramesh Basumatary also filed their claim
petition which is also registered as MAC Case No. 38/2010 before the learned Member,
MACT, Dibrugarh and the claim petition filed by the legal heirs of the deceased Indra
Kanta Mech was registered as MAC Case No. 39/2010 before the same Court at
Dibrugarh.
9.
After recording the evidences of the witnesses and also the witnesses of CWs as
well as 2 DWs, the learned Member MACT had passed the common impugned
judgment and award dated 30.07.2018 and awarded the compensation of
Rs.44,61,820/- along with interest @ 6% per annum to the claimants of MAC Case No.
39/2010 as well as Rs. 69,89,692/- along with interest @ 6% per annum to the
claimants of MAC Case No. 38/2010 and directed the present appellant to satisfy the
award to the claimants within a period of sixty days from the date of judgment.
10. On being aggrieved and dissatisfied with the said common judgment and award
passed by the learned Member, MACT, Dibrugarh, the present appeals have been
preferred by the insurance company of TATA Winger Vehicle.
11.
It is submitted by Mr. Hazarika, learned counsel that the present appeals are
Page No.# 9/17
basically filed on the ground that the learned Tribunal did not consider the vital aspect
of the matter of contributory negligence on the part of the driver/owner of the Maruti
Alto Car bearing Registration No. AS-23/F-2496, though it was the case of the
claimants that there was a head on collision between the two vehicles and the
claimants side also did not lodge any Ejahar alleging rash and negligent driving of the
driver of the TATA Winger Vehicle, rather, the driver of the TATA Winger vehicle lodged
an Ejahar complaining rash and negligent driving of the driver/owner of the Maruti
Alto Car, which was responsible for the said accident.
12. Mr. Hazarika, learned counsel further submitted that during the investigation, the
Investigating Officer of the case found that the driver of the Maruti Alto Car had drove
the vehicle in rash and negligent manner causing the alleged accident. The DW 2 Sri
Nabakanta Buragohain, the I.O. of the case also exhibited the Final Report of the case
wherein it is stated that during investigation, a case under Sections 279/337/338/427
IPC was established against the driver of the Maruti Alto Car, but the Final Report has
to be submitted as the driver of the Maruti Alto Car also died in the said accident.
Thus from the prima facie investigation conducted by the I.O. it was established that
the accident took place only due to rash and negligent driving of the driver of the
Maruti Alto Car. But inspite of the evidence of the DW-2 and the investigation done by
him, the learned Member, MACT did not consider the aspect that the accident occurred
due to head on collision and there was contributory negligence on the part of the
driver of both the vehicles and without considering this aspect of the case, the
appellant was directed to satisfy the award being the insurer of the TATA Winger
vehicle.
13. Mr. Hazarika, learned counsel further submitted that from the deposition of CW3, who was also a co-passenger of the Maruti Alto car at the time of alleged accident,
it is seen that he could not say that due to whose fault the accident took place. But
the learned Member, MACT, Dibrugarh without considering this aspect of the case
made the present appellant solely responsible for the payment/satisfaction of the
Page No.# 10/17
award.
14.
Mr. Hazarika, also submitted that there are other defects also in the judgment
passed by the learned Member, MACT wherein the salary certificates exhibited by CW4 is accepted without any proper verification though the CW-4 was not authorised by
the employer for issuing or exhibiting the salary certificates for the deceased. But the
learned Trial Court also did not consider this aspect of the matter and granted
compensation to the claimants on the basis of the last salary certificates of the
deceased inspite of the fact that the CW-4 had not issued the salary certificates, nor
he was authorized to exhibit the said salary certificates. More so, the learned Member,
MACT had erroneously assessed the award of compensation on the basis of the said
salary certificates with a direction to the present appellant to satisfy the award.
Further, the learned Member, MACT also awarded the interest on the future prospect
which is not entitled by claimants. In this context also he relied on a decision of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Oriental Insurance Company Ltd., Vs.
Champabati Ray reported in 2019 0 Supreme (Gau) 896 and emphasized on
paragraph 21 of the said judgment, which read as under:“21. Another ground of challenge to the impugned judgment is that the learned Tribunal had
awarded interest on future prospects, which could not be done. In the case of Khusboo Chirania
@ Kanta Chirania v. Kamal Kumar Sovasaria , reported in 2018 0 Supreme(Gau) 966 and in
the case of Nasima Begum v. Keramat Ali, reported in 2019 0 Supreme(Gau) 507, this Court has
stated no interest on future prospects should be given. Though no reasons have been enunciated
in the above judgments, the reason for the same seems to be due to the fact that future prospects
is relatable to an income to be received in the future and as such, there could not be any loss to
the claimants for the payment of future prospects, at the time the deceased met with the
accident. The reason for awarding interest on the compensation amount, minus the future
prospects is due to the fact that though the loss of dependency starts from the date of the
accident and the compensation amount is computed on the date of the Award of the Tribunal,
interest is awarded to compensate the loss of money value on account of lapse of time, such as
time taken for the legal proceedings and for the denial of right to utilize the money when due.
However, future prospects is with regard to the probable income to be received in the future and
as such there is no requirement to compensate the claimant by way of future interest, for the loss
that is to occur in the future, as the future is yet to happen. Further, future prospects is given for
the entire future and as such, the claimant is getting compensation in a lumpsum under future
prospects prior to the occurrence of future event/s. Thus, with regard to future prospects, this
Court is also of the view that there cannot be any interest on future prospects, as the same
Page No.# 11/17
relates to an income to be given in the future.”
15. Mr. Hazarika, learned counsel accordingly submitted that the award given by the
learned Member, MACT in MAC Case No. 39/2010 is accordingly liable to be set aside
and quashed and at the same time considering the fact of contributory negligence, the
necessary direction may be passed to the owner/insurer of Maruti Alto Car bearing
Registration No. AS-23/F-2496 to pay the compensation to the claimants exempting
the present appellant from paying the compensation.
16.
Mr. Hazarika, learned counsel also cited the following decisions of the Hon’ble
Apex Court to substantiate the plea of contributory negligence as well as for proper
assessment of the compensation:
(i) Mangla Ram Vs. Oriental Insurance Company Limited and others reported in (2018) 5
SCC 656;
(ii) Sarla Verma (SMT) and others Vs. Delhi Transport Corporation and another reported
in (2009) 6 SCC 121 and
(iii) Dulcina Fernandes and others Vs. Joaquim Xavier Cruz and another reported in
(2013) 10 SCC 646
17. Ms. R. D. Mozumdar, learned counsel for the respondent No. 3 submitted in this
regard that the learned Trial Court had rightly assessed the compensation and had
rightly passed the order directing the present appellant to satisfy the award with the
observation that the accident occurred only due to rash and negligent driving of the
driver of the offending vehicle i.e., the TATA Winger vehicle. She further submitted
that the respondent No.3 Insurance Company also cannot be made liable to pay any
compensation for the death of the driver/owner of the Alto Vehicle and it does not
cover the policy condition. She accordingly submitted that there is no need of any
interference in the judgment passed by the learned Member, MACT. She cited the
decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of New India Assurance Copan ltd.
Vs. Prabha Devi and others reported in (2013) 14 SCC 719 and basically relied
Page No.# 12/17
on paragraphs 8 and 9 of the said judgment wherein it has been observed by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court that Section 147 of the M.V. Act does not require an insurance
company to assume risk for death or bodily injury to the owner of the vehicle.
Paragraphs 8 and 9 of the said judgment read as under:"8. Thus, an insurance policy covers the liability incurred by the insured in respect of death of
or bodily injury to any person (including an owner of the goods or his authorised
representative) carried in the vehicle or damage to any property of a third party caused by or
arising out of the use of the vehicle. Section 147 does not require an insurance company to
assume risk for death or bodily injury to the owner of the vehicle.
9.In the case of Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. versus Sunita Rathi it has been held that the
liability of an insurance company is only for the purpose of indemnifying the insured against
liabilities incurred towards a third person or in respect of damages to property. Thus, where the
insured i.e. an owner of the vehicle has no liability to a third party the insurance company has
no liability also.”
18. She further submitted that there is no contributory negligence on the part of the
Maruti Alto Car for the said accident, the Insurance Company is also not liable to pay
any compensation for the death of the other occupant, namely Indra Kanta Mech.
19. Mr. Gupta, learned counsel for the claimant/respondent Nos. 1 and 2 submitted
that the offending vehicle was the TATA Winger Vehicle for whose rash and negligent
driving the accident occurred. He further submitted that the eye witness or one of the
injured who was also examined by the claimants has clearly submitted that the car
which they were travelling i.e., the Maruti Alto Car was not in a high speed and it is
the TATA Winger vehicle coming from the opposite direction had hit the vehicle for
which the accident had occurred.
20. He further submitted that in the present case, the deceased was the passenger
and 3rd party for the other vehicle, i.e., the TATA Winger and hence, as per the policy
condition also the present appellant is liable to pay the compensation for the death of
the driver of the Maruti Alto Car.
21. He further submitted that CW-4 who was examined as an Accounts Officer of the
company and accordingly he exhibited the salary certificate and thus there cannot be
Page No.# 13/17
any bar to exhibit the salary certificate by the Accounts Officer and accordingly, he
exhibited the same.
22. Mr. Gupta, learned counsel further submitted that the investigation report on the
basis of which it is submitted by the learned counsel for the appellant that it is the
Maruti Alto car who is responsible for the alleged accident, but he failed to produce
the original Final Report and the report which was exhibited by the DW-2 was under
objection and the original copy could not be produced by the appellant. More so, as
the driver of the Maruti Alto Car had already died, the I.O. could not investigate the
case properly and only on the basis of some preliminary report, the Final Report was
submitted by the I.O. and hence, that cannot be the sole basis to held that the Maruti
Alto car was also responsible for the alleged accident. The two eye witnesses were
also examined i.e., CW-2 and CW-3 who categorically adduced their evidence that the
accident occurred only due to rash and negligent driving of the TATA Winger Vehicle.
23.
Mr. Gupta, learned counsel accordingly submitted that a reasoned order has
been passed by the learned Trial Court and hence, there is no need of any
interference in the judgment and award passed by the learned Member, MACT,
Diburgarh and the award was also assessed with proper calculation and also
considering all aspects of the case. However, he agreed that interest may not be
granted for the future prospect.
24. I have heard the learned counsel for both sides and I have also perused the case
record, the judgment passed by the learned Member, MACT as well as the evidence on
record.
25. There is no dispute in regards to the accident that occurred on the relevant date
and it is also not disputed that out of the said road traffic accident two persons died
and the claim petitions were filed by the legal heirs of the deceased Indra Kanta Mech
and Ramesh Basumatary. Thus, there is no dispute in regards to the accident as well
as the death of the deceased, namely, Indra Kant Mech and owner/driver of the Maruti
Page No.# 14/17
Alto Car, namely Ramesh Basumatary.
26. It is also an admitted fact that said Ramesh Basumatary, who also expired in the
said accident, was the owner/driver of the other vehicle, i.e., Maruti Alto Car which
was also involved in the said accident. But as per the claimant, the accident occurred
only due to rash and negligent driving of the driver of the offending vehicle TATA
Winger which was coming from the opposite direction had hit the other vehicle and for
which, the said accident occurred.
27. The learned counsel for the appellants mainly stressed on the point that there
was a head on collision between the two vehicles and the driver of the Maruti Alto Car
i.e., the deceased Ramesh Basumatary was responsible for the said accident and for
his rash and negligent driving only the accident occurred. The owner/driver of the
TATA Winger vehicle also lodged an FIR before the Moranhat Police Station which was
accordingly registered and investigated by Moranhat Police. However, the Final Report
was submitted in the said case as the owner/driver of the Maruti Alto Car, namely
Ramesh Basumatary also died in the said accident.
28.
Mr. Hazarika, learned counsel for the appellants basically emphasised on the
investigation of the I.O. who also adduced evidence and exhibited the Final Report of
the case, wherein, it is stated that during the investigation, a case under Sections
279/337/338/427 IPC was established against the deceased Ramesh Basumatary, but
the Final Report had to be submitted only for the death of the owner/driver of the said
vehicle. But the I.O. could not produce the original of the Final Report and a
photocopy of the said report was exhibited only under objection. More so, there is also
no evidence or statement produced by the I.O. while adducing his evidence that on
what basis he arrived at a conclusion that the driver/owner of the Maruti Alto Car was
responsible for the accident and the accident occurred only due to rash and negligent
driving of the deceased owner/driver.
29. Thus, without any statements of the witnesses it cannot be held that the Maruti
Page No.# 15/17
Alto Car was also responsible for the said accident, when there are available evidence
on record as discussed above, wherefrom it is seen that the other occupant of the
Maruti Alto Car had adduced the evidence claiming that the offending vehicle i.e., the
TATA Winger is solely responsible for the alleged accident. To come to a conclusion of
contributory negligence there has to be some evidence or statements to prove that
the other vehicle was also responsible for the accident and merely the head on
collision of the two vehicles, cannot be held that the two vehicles are equally
responsible or the accident occurred due to contributory negligence of both the
vehicles in absence of any evidence to that effect. In that regard the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in the case of Khenyei Vs. New India Assurance Company Ltd. & Ors,
(2015) 9 SCC 273 have held that there cannot be any automatic inference of
contributory negligence by the deceased, only because the accident took place
because of the head on collision, in absence of any evidence to that effect.
30.
Further, it is rightly submitted by the learned counsel for the respondent
Insurance Company, Ms. Mozumdar that the respondent/insurance company cannot be
made liable to pay any compensation for the death of the driver/owner of the Maruti
Alto Car as it does not cover the policy condition and in that regard she already cited a
decision of the Hon’ble Apex Cout, wherein it is also observed by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court that Section 147 of the M. V. Act, does not require an insurance company to
assume risk for death or bodily injury to the owner of the vehicle.
31. However, it is seen that the other deceased Indra Kanta Mech was the occupant
of the Maruti Alto Vehicle and hence, the submission in regards to policy coverage will
not apply for the said deceased. But from the discussion made above, it is seen that
no evidence could be adduced/produced by the appellants to substantiate the plea
that the Maruti Alto Car was also responsible for contributory negligence for the
alleged accident. Thus, unless the contributory negligence on the part of the Maruti
Alto Car is established, the respondent M/s National Insurance Company Limited
cannot be held liable for payment of compensation or to satisfy 50% of the awarded
Page No.# 16/17
compensation as claimed by the appellant.
32. Coming to the issue raised by the learned counsel for the appellant in regards to
the salary certificate, it is seen that though CW-4 through whom the salary certificates
were exhibited, is not the person who issued the certificates but it cannot be denied
that he is the person authorised by the company to exhibit the said salary certificates
of the deceased.
33.
Further from the judgment it is seen that the learned Member, MACT had
assessed the income of both the deceased persons not totally basing on the salary
certificates issued by the company, but properly assessed the income after deduction
of all the over time allowance, LTC allowance and the amount of leave encashment
amount etc.
34. Thus, this Court finds no irregularity in calculating/assessing the compensation.
However, it is the observation of the Hon’ble Apex Court to which the learned counsel
for the claimant also agreed that there should not be any interest on the future
prospect which has been assessed by the learned Member, MACT and the interest
portion from the future prospect may be deducted accordingly.
35. Considering the discussion above, it is seen that the learned Member, MACT had
rightly passed the judgment and award holding that the offending vehicle i.e., the
TATA Winger vehicle is solely responsible for the said accident wherein two persons
died and the assessment is also made properly by the learned Member, MACT.
Further, from the discussion it is seen that due to absence of any evidence or
statement, it also cannot be held that Insurance Company for the Maruti Alto Car is
also equally liable for the payment of 50% of the awarded compensation for the for
the contributory negligence.
36. In view of the above, this Court is of the opinion that the judgment and award
dated 30.07.2018, passed by the Court of learned Additional District Judge, Dibrugarh
in MACT Case No. 39/2010 and MACT Case No. 38/2010 do not suffer from any
Page No.# 17/17
infirmity.
37.
However, considering the submissions made by the learned counsel for both
sides as well as from the observation made by the Hon’ble Supreme Court, this Court
is of the opinion that interest to be accrued upon the future prospect as assessed by
the learned Member, MACT may be deducted at the time of satisfying the award.
38. Accordingly, both the MAC APP No. 180/2019 as well as MAC APP No. 10/2019
are hereby stands dismissed.
39. Return the TCRs forthwith.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
Rupam
Das
Digitally signed
by Rupam Das
Date: 2026.02.12
13:26:28 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review