Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:809-DB
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
WPC No. 6625 of 2025
M/s. Awadhesh Singh Gautam Place Of Business At Village- Nakulnar,
District South Bastar- Dantewada, Chhattisgarh- 494552, Through Its
Authorized Partner, Mr. Abhishek Singh Gautam, S/o Mr. Awadhesh
Singh Gautam.
... Petitioner(s)
versus
1.
State of Chhattisgarh Through Its Secretary, Panchayat and Rural
Development Department, Vikas Bhawan, Ground Floor, Sector
19, North Block, Atal Nagar, Nawa Raipur, Raipur C.G. 492102.
2.
The Chief Engineer, Chhattisgarh Rural Road Development
Agency (Cgrrda), Vikas Bhawan, Civil Lines, District Raipur C.G.
492001
3.
The Executive Engineer Cum Member Secretary, Project
Implementation
Unit
(Piu)-
01,
Chhattisgarh
Rural
Road
Development Agency (Cgrrda), District South Bastar Dantewada
(C.G.)
4.
The Superintending Engineer, Project Implementation Unit (Piu)01, Bastar, Chhattisgarh Rural Road Development Agency
(Cgrrda), District Bastar C.G.
5.
The Nodal Officer, Jila Nirman Samiti Dantewada, District South
Bastar Dantewada (C.G.)
...Respondent(s)
Digitally
signed by
BRIJMOHAN
BRIJMOHAN MORLE
MORLE
Date:
2026.01.08
10:37:36
+0530
(Cause-title taken from Case Information System)
For Petitioner
For Respondent/State
:
:
Mr. Harshwardhan Parganiha, Advocate.
Mr. Praveen Das, Additional Advocate
General.
Hon'ble Shri Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
Hon'ble Shri Arvind Kumar Verma, Judge
Order on Board
Per Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
07.01.2026
1.
Heard Mr. Harshwardhan Parganiha, learned counsel for the
petitioner. Also heard Mr. Praveen Das, learned Additional Advocate
General, appearing for the State.
2.
The present petition has been filed by the petitioner under Article
226 of the Constitution of India, seeking following reliefs :“10.1 Quash and set aside the order dated 27.09.2025
issued by the respondent No. 3;
10.2 Direct the respondent authorities to forthwith
initiate the refund/release of Rs. 38,00,000/- to the
designated bank account of the petitioner firm, along
with interest till date of realization of amount by the
petitioner firm;
10.3 Pass any other order or issue such directions as
this Hon’ble Court may deem fit in light of the facts
and circumstances of the present case, in the interest
of justice.”
3.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the petitioner is a
Partnership Firm duly registered with the Public Works Department,
Chhattisgarh, as a Class-A Contractor bearing Unique Identification
Number (UIN) CGeR17944, and is engaged in the execution of largescale and complex construction projects. The petitioner firm is duly
authorized to institute and prosecute the present writ petition through its
competent partner. He further submits that Respondent No. 3 issued a
Notice Inviting Tender (NIT) bearing Reference No. 961 / Tech. /
CGRRDA / 2024 dated 20.08.2024, inviting bids from eligible bidders for
execution of Package No. CG-03-163 (Balance Work), namely PalnarPermapara Road (24.00 Km) to Mirchipara under the Pradhan Mantri
Gram Sadak Yojana (PMGSY).
4.
It is further contended by learned counsel for the petitioner that
the petitioner firm, having fulfilled all eligibility criteria, submitted its bid
at 12.10% above the PMGSY Schedule of Rates (effective from
22.02.2018), which was duly accepted by the respondent authorities.
The acceptance of the bid was communicated vide Letter of Acceptance
dated 18.10.2024, followed by issuance of a Work Order dated
05.11.2024 in favour of the petitioner firm. He further submits that
pursuant to issuance of the said Work Order, the petitioner firm promptly
mobilized men, machinery, and materials at the site and commenced
execution of the work without any delay. Upon completion of
approximately 40% of the work, the petitioner firm raised its second
running bill amounting to Rs. 45,62,000/- in accordance with the
contractual terms.
5.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that despite completion
of substantial work, the respondent authorities failed to release payment
of the said running bill within a reasonable period. Owing to the
inordinate delay, the petitioner firm addressed reminder communications
dated 22.09.2025 and 25.09.2025 requesting release of the pending
payment; however, no action was taken by the respondents. He further
submits that instead of settling the legitimate dues of the petitioner firm,
Respondent No. 3 issued an order dated 27.09.2025 intimating
deduction of a total sum of Rs. 84,17,003/- from the running bills
payable to the petitioner firm under various packages, including a sum
of ₹38,00,000/- from Package No. CG-03-163. The said deduction has
purportedly been made on the basis of an inspection report prepared by
Respondent No. 4 in respect of two distinct and completed works
executed under Work Orders dated 03.01.2023, pertaining to
construction of roads from Madkamiras to Hiroli Health Centre and from
Hiroli Health Centre to Dokapara.
6.
Learned counsel for the petitioner further submits that the said
inspection report is patently illegal and has been prepared in gross
violation of the terms and conditions of the NIT and the Conditions of
Contract governing the said works. He submits that no reasonable
notice of inspection was ever issued to the petitioner firm or its partners,
as mandatorily required under Clause 16 of the Conditions of Contract,
which stipulates that the contractor or its authorized representative must
be present at the time of inspection. He further submits that Clause 36
of the Conditions of Contract, which permits audit and technical
examination by the State, specifically mandates that an opportunity be
afforded to the contractor to explain its position before any adverse
action is taken; however, no such opportunity was granted to the
petitioner firm in the present case. It is further submitted that as per the
Special Conditions of Contract, which prevail over the general
conditions of the NIT, Clause 4(ii) requires that defects, if any, must first
be notified to the contractor and reasonable time be granted for
rectification, and only upon failure thereof can recovery proceedings be
initiated. Admittedly, no defect was ever communicated to the petitioner
firm.
7.
Learned counsel for the petitioner would submit that in respect of
the works executed under the work orders dated 03.01.2023,
substantial amounts towards security deposit and performance
guarantee are already lying with the respondent authorities, and further,
payment towards the pending bitumen work bill remains unpaid. In such
circumstances, the respondents acted wholly arbitrarily and without
jurisdiction in effecting recovery from the running bills pertaining to an
entirely separate and independent contract. Thus, being aggrieved by
the arbitrary, unilateral, and high-handed action of the respondent
authorities, the petitioner firm submitted a detailed representation dated
09.10.2025 before Respondents No. 2 to 4; however, the said
representation has neither been acknowledged nor decided till date,
compelling the petitioner to invoke the extraordinary jurisdiction of this
Hon’ble Court.
8.
On the other hand, learned State counsel opposes the
submissions made by the learned counsel for the petitioner and submits
that the writ petition as framed and filed are not maintainable as the
disputed question of facts cannot be adjudicated in writ petition under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
9.
We have learned counsel for the parties, perused the impugned
order and other documents appended with writ petition.
10.
It is settled law that the High Court should not exercise its
jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India when it raises
disputed question of facts.
11.
The Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Chairman, Grid
Corpornation of Orissa Ltd. (GRIDCO) & Others v. Sukamani Das
(Smt.) & Another, reported in (1999) 7 SCC 298 was dealing with the
question of whether the High Court had made an error in entertaining a
writ petition filed seeking compensation for the death of a person due to
electrocution, which had allegedly been caused due to the negligence of
the authorities. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the said case observed
as under:
“6. In our opinion, the High Court committed an error in
entertaining the writ petitions even though they were
not fit cases for exercising power under Article 226 of
the Constitution. The High Court went wrong in
proceeding on the basis that as the deaths had taken
place because of electrocution as a result of the
deceased coming into contact with snapped live wires
of the electric transmission lines of the appellants, that
"admittedly/prima facie amounted to negligence on the
part of the appellants". The High Court failed to
appreciate that all these cases were actions in tort and
negligence was required to be established firstly by the
claimants. The mere fact that the wire of the electric
transmission line belonging to Appellant 1 had
snapped and the deceased had come in contact with it
and had died was not by itself sufficient for awarding
compensation. It also required to be examined whether
the wire had snapped as a result of any negligence of
the appellants and under which circumstances the
deceased had come in contact with the wire. In view of
the specific defences raised by the appellants in each
of these cases they deserved an opportunity to prove
that proper care and precautions were taken in
maintaining the transmission lines and yet the wires
had snapped because of circumstances beyond their
control or unauthorised intervention of third parties or
that the deceased had not died in the manner stated
by the petitioners. These questions could not have
been decided properly on the basis of affidavits only. It
is the settled legal position that where disputed
questions of facts are involved a petition under Article
226 of the Constitution is not a proper remedy. The
High Court has not and could not have held that the
disputes in these cases were raised for the sake of
raising them and that there was no substance therein.
The High Court should have directed the writ
petitioners to approach the civil court as it was done in
OJC No. 5229 of 1995."
(emphasis supplied)
12.
The aforesaid judgment has been relied/ reiterated by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in S.P.S. Rathore v. State of Haryana & Others,
reported in (2005) 10 SCC 1 wherein it observed as follows:
“16. In Chairman, Grid Corpn. of Orissa Ltd. (Gridco) v.
Sukamani Das [(1999) 7 SCC 298] the question which
arose for consideration was, can the High Court under
Article 226 of the Constitution award compensation for
death caused due to electrocution on account of
negligence, when the liability was emphatically denied
on the ground that the death had not occurred as a
result of negligence, but because of an act of God or of
acts of some other persons. The Court held that it is
the settled legal position that where disputed questions
of facts are involved, a petition under Article 226 of the
Constitution is not a proper remedy. Therefore,
questions as to whether death occurred due to
negligence or due to act of God or of some third
person could not be decided properly on the basis of
affidavits only, but should be decided by the civil court
after appreciating the evidence adduced by the parties.
In T.N. Electricity Board v. Sumathi [(2000) 4 SCC 543]
it was held that when a disputed question of fact arises
and there is clear denial of any tortious liability, remedy
under Article 226 of the Constitution may not be
proper. The Court carved out exception to this general
rule by observing that, it should not be understood that
in every case of tortious liability, recourse must be had
to a suit. When there is negligence on the face of it
and infringement of Article 21 is there, it cannot be
said that there will be any bar to proceed under Article
226 of the Constitution."
(emphasis supplied)
13.
Similarly, the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Shubhas Jain v.
Rajeshwari Shivam, reported in 2021 SCC OnLine SC 562 has held
as under:
“26. It is well settled that the High Court exercising its
extraordinary writ jurisdiction under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India, does not adjudicate hotly
disputed questions of facts. It is not for the High Court
to make a comparative assessment of conflicting
technical reports and decide which one is acceptable."
14.
Subsequently, in Union of India vs. Puna Hinda, reported in
(2021) 10 SCC 690, the Hon'ble Supreme Court has observed:
“24. Therefore, the dispute could not be raised by way
of a writ petition on the disputed questions of fact.
Though, the jurisdiction of the High Court is wide but in
respect of pure contractual matters in the field of
private law, having no statutory flavour, are better
adjudicated upon by the forum agreed to by the
parties. The dispute as to whether the amount is
payable or not and/or how much amount is payable
are disputed questions of facts. There is no admission
on the part of the appellants to infer that the amount
stands crystallised. Therefore, in the absence of any
acceptance of joint survey report by the competent
authority, no right would accrue to the writ petitioner
only because measurements cannot be undertaken
after passage of time. Maybe, the resurvey cannot
take place but the measurement books of the work
executed from time to time would form a reasonable
basis for assessing the amount due and payable to the
writ petitioner, but such process could be undertaken
only by the agreed forum i.e. arbitration and not by the
writ court as it does not have the expertise in respect
of measurements or construction of roads.”
15.
Recently, the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of M.P. Power
Management Co. Ltd. v. Sky Power Southeast Solar India (P) Ltd.,
reported in (2023) 2 SCC 703, while dealing with the issue of exercise
of writ jurisdiction by a Court in matters arising out of a contract, has
stated:
“82.7. The existence of an alternate remedy, is,
undoubtedly, a matter to be borne in mind in declining
relief in a writ petition in a contractual matter. Again,
the question as to whether the writ petitioner must be
told off the gates, would depend upon the nature of the
claim and relief sought by the petitioner, the questions,
which
would
have
to
be
decided,
and,
most
importantly, whether there are disputed questions of
fact,
resolution
of
which
is
necessary,
as
an
indispensable prelude to the grant of the relief sought.
Undoubtedly, while there is no prohibition, in the writ
court even deciding disputed questions of fact,
particularly when the dispute surrounds demystifying of
documents only, the Court may relegate the party to
the
remedy
by
way
of
a
civil
suit.”
(emphasis supplied)
16.
A reading of the aforesaid judgments makes it clear that it is well
settled proposition of law that when there are disputed question of facts
involved in a case, the High Court should not exercise its jurisdiction
under Article 226 of the Constitution of India. It has been held that the
remedy under Article 226 of the Constitution of India may not be proper.
17.
In the present cases, the relief of compensations sought by the
petitioner is contingent upon the resolution of the disputed question of
facts raised, and these questions cannot be adjudicated under Article
226 of the Constitution of India. In view of the aforesaid, it would not be
appropriate for this Court to entertain the present writ petitions as there
are disputed questions of fact involved.
18.
Considering the submissions advanced by learned counsel for the
parties, further considering the disputed questions of fact involved in
this writ petition, the reliefs sought by the petitioner and in view of law
laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the above-stated judgments
(supra), we do not find any good ground to entertain this writ petition.
19.
Accordingly, the present writ petition being devoid of merit is liable
to be and is hereby dismissed. However, liberty is reserved in favour of
the petitioner to take recourse to other alternate remedies available to
him under the law. No cost(s).
Sd/(Arvind Kumar Verma)
Judge
Brijmohan
Sd/(Ramesh Sinha)
Chief Justice
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review