Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
434421
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
SUNDAY, THE SIXTEENTH DAY OF MARCH
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY FIVE
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE RENUKA YARA
CIVIL REVISION PETITION NO: 3679 OF 2024
Petition under Arlicle 227 of the Constitution of lndia aggrieved by the Order
dated 23.08.2024 passed in lA No. 356 of 2023 in OS No. 82 ol 2024 by the
XXIV Additional Chief Judge, City Civil Courts at Hyderabad.
Between:
'l
. Mis. Anirudh Agro Farms Ltd., rep. by its Director [Vlr. K. Ravinder Reddy S/o
Late Sri. K. Yella Reddy, having its office at 3 Floor, Aparna Crest, Road No
2, Banjata, Hyderabad 500 034.
2. K Ravinder Reddy S/o. Late Sri K. Yella Reddy, aged about 60 years, Occ
Business, R/o Plot No 545, Road No 28, Jubliee Hills, Hyderabad - 500034
...Petitioners/ Petitioners/Plaintiffs
AND
'l
. Mr. Garlapati Srikanth Reddy S/o Mr. G Surender Reddy, Aged 34 years,
Occ: Business, R/o. Plot No 439, Road No 20, Jubliee Hills, Hyderabad.
2. Mr. Nishant Raj Sio. Sri. Govind Prasad Rajgarhia, Aged 40 years, Occ:
Business, Rlo. J-24, Bharani Complex. lvlinister Road, Secunderabad500003
3. Smt.Jagarlamudi Usha Lavanya W/o. Sri J. Praveen Chowdary, Aged about
40 years, Occ: Housewife, R/o Flat No. '1202 A-Block, Fortune Towers,
[\/adhapur, Seerilingampa lly, Hyderabad- 500081 .
...Respondents/ Respondents/Petitioners
l.A. NO: 1OF 2024
Petition under Section 151 of CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavrt filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to stay all
further proceedings in OS No. 82 of 2021 on the file of XXIV Additional Chief Judge,
City Civil Courts at Hyderabad, pending disposal of the present Revision.
Counsel for the Petitioners: Sri. N. pavan Krishna Reddy
Counsel for the Respondent Nos.2 & 3: Sri. p. Sridhar Recr y,
The Court made the following: ORDER
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT
HYDIiRAIIAT)
THE HONOURABLE SMT. JUSTICE RENUKA YARA
CIVIL IIEVISI ON PETITION No.-1679 ot 21J21
I6tI, DAY oF MAIi,CH, 2026
Bctw'cen:
M/s. Anirudh Agro Farms Lirnited arrd anorhe r
... Petitioners
AND
Gallapati Srikanth Reddy and trvo others
...Rcspondcnts
OITDER
I{eatd Sri N. Pavan Klishna Rccldy. lcarnr'rl counsel lirr the
pctitioncrs ar-rd Sri P. Sridhar Reddy, learned counsel fbr respondent Nos.2
and 3.
2.
The Civil Rcvision r,etition is flled by rhe pe titioncr.slp laintiffs
agglievcd by the order dated 13.08.2011 in LA.No.-i5(r ol l02j in
O.S.No.8l of 202 I passed by the learned XXIV Addirional ('hief Judge,
City Ci'il Court at Hyderabad, ('trial Court), ri,hcrei, a Pe.riri., fl lecl r-rnder.
Orcler XVI Rulcs I and 5 rcad vn.ith Scction l5l ol CpC. ro clircct
lc'spondcnt Nos.2 and 3idef'cndant Nos.2 and 3. to proclucc Mcniorandum
ol'LJnderstanding ('MOU'), dated i I .01.202 I . has been clismissed.
3.
Thc case of thc pctitionels is that they have frled a suit tbr specific
pellbrrnarrce on the basis of an oral agreelncnt ol. sale betrvecn the
R\'..I
( ttP -1679 t0t..l
petrtioners on one hand and respondcnt
No. r o, the otrr r lia,d, rvherei, the
total sale consideratiorr n'as Rs. l5 cl'o.es
to be paid ftrr rurchasing. thc suit
scheciule propcrty consisting of housc
293/li2iA/4j9 and g-l-193/ii2/All3g/A.
second lloors irr old Sv.No.403/1.
Sy No' 102/l of I lakeerrpct
bearing fz Lrnicipai Nos.g_l_
consisring o sroLrncl. flrsr and
nerv Sy.No.l20 of.SI aikpet village and
'illage,
situated withi. thc r
Jubilce Hills Co-operarivc House Building
Jubilee Ilills. FI-r derabad l'he petitioners
Sociery Lir.r rcd, Road No.20.
have paitr parr ;.re c.rsicrtratio,
ol Rs-l'00,00,000/- ancr trre barance amount was
regist'ation' Iror trie sakc of caution,
l'-,,curnbrancc cenificate ('EC')
of sare ancr therr. rrihe,n the
I to appear Lrefor... the Registration
Autho'ir--r on 0 t 0r.202 r lbr execution
ilppea. on sart dar. and tirnc- In the
t. be r rid at trre tir,e trr-
the petitionc's c0r. l)an' rrad issLr.,cr
paper publicatio. aborrr the agrecnrent
petitioncrs rcqucstcd respondent No.
of sale, rcsrlon(r(,r t No. i rairecJ to
circunrsta,ces, the pcl ti..cr.s otrtaincci
and carne to know, thar i:sp.rrdenL
executed an al]l.eetnent ol- sale_cum_Ceneral power
i' fi'our of
'csponcrent
specific pcrtbr,raucc. respondent No.
contains ref'erence to the ag.eernent
r t. suit 1lrcd rirr
l fred rvritten slate, t ,t aIegini_r trrat
I 5.0 I .202 r, there u,as
bctu'ee. hirn and .es,onclcnt Nos.2
No. I
of Al , rner, (.ACilrA.)
N.s.2 ana i on r 5.0 r.201 r . L
befo.e cxccuting the AGpA crated
1-,r..vccl ra,r,out .f.
.r \ro[ ] execurcd
an. 3 on r l.0 r .202 r :rre said lvr( )U
of sare existing betrvee r the pctiti.rers
It \'..r
c RP .1679 2024
and rcspondent No. I . [n order to pt'ove the knorvledge of rcspondent Nos.2
ar-rd 3 about the existence of oral agreement of sale bctrvecu thc petitioners
aud tcspondent No. I , it is necessary to direct thetn to produce said cop1,' of
MOU dated 11.0 1.2021 arrd thercfbre, the petition has beerr liled invokirrg
Order XVI Rules I and 5 ol-the CPC
1.
Respondcnt No. I
in his written statclneltt adrnitted both the
cxecution of agreernent ol-sale betrveen l'rimsclf ancl the. pelitioucrs as u,ell
as thc IVIOU betwccn hirnself and responclent Nos.2 and i.
Irurther',
rcspondent No. I pleaded that the copy rvhich is in his custodv is produced
hefblc tlre CotLrt and theleflore, there is no necd lbr prorluction ol'original
MOU which is in tlrc custody of respondcnt Nos.2 and 3
5.
Respondent Nos.2 and 3 filed counter denvinq knou lcdge about the
oral agrecrncnt of sale between the petitioners and rcsponclcnt No. I and
execution ol' MOtl dated I 1.0 I .102 I u,ith rcle rencc to the allcged oral
agreerncnt of sale betrveen the petit.iorrers and respondent No.l. The,v
denied having possession of original ol MOU clated I l.() l.l0l t and
thcrc{ble. dcrried any question of producing the sante lre lorc. thc Courl
6.
The lcarned trial Couft, upon considering the conrentions ol'all the
respective parlies, came to a conclusion that in r,iew of thc spccitic def-ence
taker"r by rcspondent No.2 about non-existcnce of thc IvIOLJ dated
I{Y.]
cr{P 3679 102,1
I 1.0 1.202 l, resp()ndents Nos.2 and 3 cannot be compt I c.d to produce t[-re
satre belirrc tht- ('our1, as such the petition r,,,as dismii r:d. Aggriei,ed br
the sarnc. tlle prescnt rcr ision is preferred.
l.
ln grounds ol- r'cvision. thc petitioners conlcnd
irt thc trial Couft
failcd to consider the lact that the original of MOU r in possession ot'
respondcr.rt Nos.2 and i, whereas the trial Coufl has .onte to a wrong
couclusion about rror-r-e x istencc ol said MOU. Ttre MC)(i dated I 1.0 I .l0l I
is a kc1, docurnent necossary fbr understanding the agler rrent bct.wccn the
partics and neccssil'\' to clalify that rcspondent Nos.2 r rl i tlo not have
lau,lul clainr to thc suit propert\,. According to the p: itioncr.s, thcr.c is
['ailurc on thc part ol rltc irial ('ourt in making pr-opct r]nquit.r, into thc
existcnce and posscssion of MOIi and exercising jurisd , Lion under Order.
XVI ltute l4 ol'('l'(' colrectly. which gr.ants author.ity tt, lrc [r.ial Courr tbr
ordcling protiuctiorr of'clucial docurnents. The trial Co r .t Iailcd to apply
the pro',,ision i.c. Ordcr XVI Rules I and 5 of CPC ancl j:ctions l0I and
l0i ol' the lndiarr lrvidcncc Act, 1872 and has erroneotr 11,. dismissccl the
interlocutor'), application. Therelble, rt is urged that thc r tpugnccl ordcr is
liable to be sct asitlc
8.
[.earned couusel lbl the petitiollers argued that lrele: is arr oral
agreeurcnt of salc bctu,cen the pe titioncrs and r.espondcnt i.lo.l lbr sale ol
R\"J
ct{t, 1679 102{
the suit schedule property for a sale consideration of Rs.l5 crores. Out of
the total consideration the petitior-rers have paid Rs.3 crores and thc balance
salc corrsideration is to be paid to lcspondent No. I at thc time ol'
legistration. Meanrvhile when EC is obtained, it is notcci that there is a
a,qreemcnt of sale-cunr-GPA executed bctrveen respondcnt. No. I on onc
hand and respondent Nos.2 and 3 on the other hand on 15.0 l.l0l I . Er cn
belbre thc AGPA r.vas executed betu.ecn the respondents, thcle \\'as arl
MOU cxecutcd bctu'een thern on I l.0l .2021 by re l-erling lo the oral
agleenrcrlt ol'salc betrveen the petitioners and respondent No. l. It is allcgeci
that said MOI.J is a crucial document which is necessar), lbr thc purposc of
proving the kno*ledge ol respondent Nos.2 and --l about existcr.rcc of
agreeulcnt of sale betrveeu the petilioners and lespondcnt No.I. The said
M()ti is crucial lbr proving that the rights of petitioncm .u c supcriol to thc
lights of respondent Nos.2 and 3 over thc' suit schedule propcrt-r'. It is
allegcd tl.rat a copy of said MOU is produced by respondcnt No. I
.
Iloucrcr'. cxistcucc ol'said NIOU is denied bl. respondent Nos.l and i arrd
thcrclirrc. thele is a need to cornpel them to produce the oliginal MO[-I.
9.
Irr that contcxt, reliance is based on judgn'rent irt the case of K.
Krishna Kumari v. Drapaneni Krishna Kumarr, rvhcrein it is held that
when an interlocutory application is filed to dircct a party to liu'r'rislr a
'rualtuTneTotszT2ot:
I{Y..1
ct{1, 1679 2024
docurnent statirg that it is in the custody of the other yrr rty, the lrial
c]orrt
cannot issue a dir.-'ctiou rvho is not a pafty to the suit.,\. lre sarne Lime.
tlre lesl-ronsibilirv ot'rhc par1),
'',ho
it is
appr-oaches the ccr r.r to prorluce said
docurle.t ard i. casc of lhirure to pr.duce anv strch dct:rrnent, an ad'ersc
i,f-ere.ce has t. be rlacle. .l'hetefbre, rvhene'er a
Part_\, ( C,Cs not produCe a
docuurc.t. an adversc infe.ence has to be dr.arvn that aid party c.lid
deri'e anv
'alid
ri.-eht vis-zi-vis the property which is sr r
not
icct matter of the
docuurcn i.
10. o, the trasis ol' alb'crnentioned .iudgment, the l,r r)ed counscl firr
r
pctitioncrs argucd that llre'c is a ncecl to direct rcspor-rdr: rl Nos.2
prodr-rce the MotJ ciatcd rr 0r 202r ard in case
ard 3 to
ol fbitri: o, thcir parr t.
produce the sanrc. an adrcrsc i,li:rence rras to bc d'i rvn
against saicr
paltres
I I.
L.carned coLrrser Ib' r.c:;poncrcrt Nos.l ar-rd 3 subnr r ; that
MOLJ i, cristc.ce bctr,,een .cspor.rdcr.rt No. I and respoi.r,! .rrr
therc is rrt.r
Nos.2 ard --i
Accordi'e to thc learncd c.unser rbr respo^de,t Nos.r i.cr 3, trrere
collusio. between respondenl No. r on one rrand and the r :titioner-s
othe. hand to carse loss to rc'sponderl Nos.2 and 3, wrr. rrave
the propc.tv .rrdc'r' trre AGI'}u\ datcd l 5 0l .202 I . It is
is a
on thc
purchascd
thc c;r r. of resp.rr<ient
Nos.2 and 3 that a firkc docurnent is creatcd b1, responrl
rr1 No.l :Itd is
Rt...r
cRP 1679 2024
produced befbre the Court in collusion
with the petitioners to deny the
I'ights ol-respondent Nos.2 and j over the
suit schedule propefty.
l2
lrl t'at corltext, thc learnc, counser fo'respondc.t
upon -iudgrric.t o. this courr
Nos.2 a,d
l relicd
i. M/s. Jaradhija Educationar Society v.
Poloju Lakshmi2, rvherein it is hetd that rvhen a pafiy
withholds a docuure.t, an application can
intentionally
be made undcr order XI o| cpc
fbr disco'",err, and inspection. and the opposing par.ty
on t,c grounds of p.iviregc and irrerevance. A party
l.ras a right to ob.ject
who <.renies existeuce
ofsuch docurnent cann.t be co,pe,ed to produce
trre documents.,1ore so
in casc- said doculrcnts are incriminat.ing or against
their.own interests.
lS on the basis of atbre.rentioned judgrne,t, it is arguecr that the triar
Court did not cou,)lit arly elrof in dismissi.g the inter.locutory
apprication.
It is argued that r-espo,dent Nos.2 and 3 are not de,ying the
existence or-
the docuurcnt as the contents therein are incrirninating,
is rrr such Mo[ ] exccr'rtcd betq'een respo.dent No.
but denl,ing as ther.c
l and resporrdent Nos.2
ancl 3. It is ar.gued tlrat only to cause loss to respoltdcnt
fabricated docurnent is subrnitted by responder-rt
No. I bclbr.e the Court. and
a ntola./ide attempt is nrade by the petitioners by filing
seeking direction to produce a non_existing MO[J.
' n-s. No.168 of 2022 , dated 23.1,0.2024
Nos.? and 3. a
this application
I{Y..I
cR.P,,.:i679 2024
14. For the pulpose of convenience, Order XI I.: LIc 14 ol' CPC is
extracted and produced bciow
"ORDER Xl : Discovcrv and Inspection:
ltulc l-i. Pnrtltrctron ol'docuurcnts. [t shall be la\\litl rr thc Court. at
I
arrv tinre dtrrinq thc pendcncl ol'an1, suit. to ordcr tht prodtrction b1
arl\, part! thorcto. upon oath. ()l such of thc dol rrrrcnts in his
p()sSr'sSi()n ol-11()\\cr. tclatittU lo at)\ lnatlCr irt qttesli,,rr
rr s uch suit. as
the C ourl slrall think right: and the Court rnar' .i :ir I rrith such
"
docunrcnts. s lren produccd. in such rnanner as shall a1'1 i ar
.iust.
15. As per abor c pt'or.,ision, the Court, at auv timr. r rrinq pendency ol'
the suit, order production o1- any docuntent in the pcs i,jssion of a party
relating to any rrattel which is in qucstion in the suit r rcl rvhile ordering
production ol- docurncnts. the ('ourt has to balance tl r rival inter.csts of
disclosure and non-disclosrrrc to satisty itsell' dS [o r',,nflclentialitv of- a
doclrnrent as it sccrIs.iusL.
16. [n thc instant case, on onc hand thc petitioner.s u r I rcspondent No. i
are vouchirrg lor cristencc ol' MOtJ dated t I .01 .-:r -l I . u,her.cas the
respondent Nos.l arrd 3 are denying the sarne. Such .,'ing the case, the
burden of';-l'oof'ol'cxistcnce of such MOU rvould bc , rr the peritioners.
who are clairninq its existence arrd respondent No. l, u I r is suppor.tinr:. thc
satle. [n casc respondcnt Nos.2 and -] are denying its r:r r;lcncc, as held b1,
the rrial Coun, they canltor be compelled to pr-oduce l!, sarne. It is r-rot
RY.J
cRP i679 202,+
possible fbr the trial Court to inlcr existerrce of the document u,hich the
respondent Nos.2 and 3 are dcnying. When there is a disputed question of
lact as to existencc ol' MOL.I dated I I .01 .2021, the bulden of plool' u,ould
be on tlie party rvhich is clainring it
17. At this.iuncture. in view of categorical denial of the existcnce of such
a doctrment by rcspondent Nos.2 and i, the trial Coum did ttot comntit any
error in letusing to grant relicl'to the pc-titioners i.e. refirsing to direct the
rcsponderrt Nos.l and -3 to producc the document. In
the clrcutlstanccs,
the present revision lacks rncrits and is liable to bc dismissed.
I8. In ttre result, the Civil l{evision Petition is dismisscd contirnring thc
order daled 2-.1.08.202:1 passcd by the learned ttial Court in I.A.No.356 of
2023 in O.S.No.82 ot' 202[. There shalt be no order as to costs
Miscellaneous applications, il'any, pcnding shall stand closcd.
SD/. N.CHANDRA SEKHAR
RAR
DEPUTY RE
//TRUE COPY//
TION OFFICER
To,
The XXIV Additional Chief Judge, City Civil Court t
2 One CC to Sri N. Pavan Krishna Reddy' Advocate
3 One CC to Sri. P. Sridhar Reddy, Advocate [OPUC]
4 Two CD Copies
\'y"
NK'PSL
yderabad
UC]
HIGH COURT
DATED: 1610312025
c o
.(
.Y
o
l!
lo
ORDER
n
s*
.|n
H 9rH , ,
CRP.No.3679 of 2024
DISMISSING THE CRP WITHOUT COS-'S
t
I
:
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review