Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:1797-DB
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
WPC No. 87 of 2026
M/s. Anil Buildcon (India) Private Limited (C I N - U 45200 C T 2011 P T C
022277), 104, Lovina Courts, Mungeli Naka, Bilaspur, Chhattisgarh. EmailAccbilaspur @Gamil.Com Through Its Authorised Director Mr. Anil Kumar
Verma S/o Late Jagdish Verma, Aged About 66 Years, R/o House No. 14 /
1152, Talapara Road, Vinoba Nagar, Tahsil And Ditrict-Bilaspur, Chhattisgarh
... Petitioner
versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through Its Secretary, Public Works Department,
Mantralaya (New Secretariat), Atal Nagar, Nava Raipur, Chhattisgarh
2 - The Engineer In Chief Public Works Department, Nirman Bhawan Sector19, Atal Nagar, Nava Raipur, Chhattisgarh
3 - The Executive Engineer Public Works Department, Division No. 2,
Bilaspur, District : Bilaspur, Chhattisgarh
---- Respondents
(Cause title taken from Case Information System)
For Petitioner
:
Mr. Rajkamal Singh, Advocate along with
Mr. Suryapratap Yuddhveer Singh,
Advocate
For Respondents/State
:
Mr. Prasun Bhaduri, learned Deputy
Advocate General
Hon'ble Shri Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
Hon'ble Shri Ravindra Kumar Agrawal, Judge
Order on Board
Per Ramesh Sinha, C.J.
VED
PRAKASH
DEWANGAN
VED PRAKASH
DEWANGAN
Date: 2026.01.24
14:24:31 +0530
12/01/2026
1.
The present writ petition has been filed by the petitioner against the
order dated 29.08.2024 (Annexure P/1), issued by the respondent
No.3, whereby the respondent authorities denied to release the
earnest money deposit and security deposit/performance security, and
prayed for the following reliefs:“10.1 This Hon'ble Court may please be kind enough
in calling the entire Measurement Books & other
records pertaining to the subject matter.
10.2 This Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased to
quash and set aside the impugned decision vide letter
dated 29.08.2024 issued by the Executive Engineer,
PWD Division No.2, Bilaspur (C.G.).
10.3 This Hon'ble Court may please be kind enough in
directing the respondents to foreclose the work and
release the remaining payments of the petitioner
under running bills for the work already executed with
the commercial interest @24% per anum and also for
releasing the Earnest Money Deposit and Security
Deposit
Performance
Security
with
commercial
interest @24% per anum.
10.4 This Hon'ble Court may please direct the
respondents to pay damages & compensation for the
unreasonable delay and also for delay issuing the
Work Completion Certificate to release the petitioner's
bidding capacity enabling the petitioner to participate
in the other tenders related with work contracts.
10.5 This Hon’ble Court may please direct a detailed
enquiry with regard to the impugned decision vide
letter dated 29.08.2024 issued by the Executive
Engineer,
PWD
Division
No.2,
Bilaspur
(C.G.)
containing false claim of the respondents only
intended to fill the voids, avoid the liabilities under
Contempt Petition (C) No.709 of 2024 & to harass &
deprive the petitioners from their righteous claims.
10.6. This Hon'ble court may please be kind enough in
granting the cost and any other relief to the
petitioner.”
2.
The brief facts of the case are that, the petitioner was awarded the
work under the work agreement No. 10/DL/2017-18 for construction of
Global Category Full Standard (size 400 M x 8 Lane) Synthetic Athletic
Track [International Amateur Athletics Federation (IAAF) approved
class-II category] and Natural Grass Football Ground at State Sports
Training Centre, Outdoor Stadium, Bahatarai, Bilaspur, Chhattisgarh.
The total cost of the work was 885.33 lakhs and the completion period
was 9 months from the date of work order. After completion of initial
work, some impediments occurred due to delay in issuance of custom
duty exemption certificate and difficulties in import of “Rekortan M-99
Synthetic track” from Germany, which resulted in huge financial
repercussions to the petitioner. Various cultural and public events on
the stadium premises are also one of the ground for delay in
completion of the work. The respondent authorities have also informed
the petitioner about the non-availability of revised administrative
sanction and funds. For want of necessary funds, the running bills of
the petitioner for the work, which was already executed, have also not
been paid to him. Despite non-payment of the running bills, the
petitioner continued to work. The petitioner repeatedly requested the
respondent authorities by oral and written communications for release
of the pending payments forcing him to issue a legal notice on
14.09.2022 demanding the payments of dues. Since, the pending
dues were not paid to the petitioner, he filed a writ petition bearing
WPC No. 252 of 2023 for seeking a direction to release the undisputed
dues. The said writ petition was disposed of on 31.10.2023 directing
the respondent authorities to decide the petitioner’s representation for
payment of running bills. Despite the direction, the petitioner kept
silent over the issue and then after issuing another notice on
12.04.2024, the petitioner filed a Contempt Petition (C) No. 709 of
2024. During the hearing of the said contempt petition, the
respondents had submitted that, the representation of the petitioner
has been decided on 29.08.2024 and then the contempt petition was
disposed of on 30.08.2024.
3.
It is also the case of the petitioner that, vide letter dated 29.08.2024,
the respondent authorities have wrongly informed the petitioner that,
the work agreement No. 10/DL/2017-18 still subsists and the petitioner
has to perform the remaining work and without completing the
remaining work, the return of security deposit, performance deposit
and work completion certificate is not possible. The petitioner has
submitted his reply on 04.09.2024 by placing the details of executed
work, payments made and financial losses incurred due to the
department lapses including the payment of custom and IGST duty of
Rs. 92,47,226/-, demurrage detention and CFS charges. The petitioner
has further submitted his reminder representations on 17.09.2024,
01.12.2024, 09.01.2025 and 13.02.2025, but all his efforts went in
vain. The failure to issue work completion certificate and withholding
the legitimate dues are the arbitrary and mala fide action on the part of
the respondent authorities and the huge capital of the petitioner has
been blocked, therefore, he filed the present petition.
4.
Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner would submit that, the
work order was issued in the year 2017 and due to the lapses on the
part of the respondent authorities, the work could not be concluded.
The work agreement has already been expired, because of the
lethargy on the part of the respondents/department and the petitioner
cannot be compelled to resume the work under the agreement. The
respondent authorities have failed to consider the verified quantities of
work executed. The petitioner had categorically pointed towards the
requirement of importing the athletic track in the name of Executive
Engineer (PWD) and the liability to arrange the custom duty exemption
and IGST payments, which was the liability of the department under
clause 9.2 of the agreement. Due to lapse of the authorities, the Astro
Turf was dumped at the custom clearance and no one come forward
to get it released after payment of relevant taxes. The said Astro Turf
was required to be imported from the IAAF. After lapse of longtime, the
quality cannot be maintained and guarantee cannot be provided. The
impugned order dated 29.08.2024 violates the principles of natural
justice and fairness and the petitioner cannot be compelled to resume
the work under the work agreement No. 10/DL/2017-18. By the
impugned order dated 29.08.2024, the bidding capacity of the
petitioner is blocked and he is facing huge financial crises by retaining
his amount by the respondent authorities under the work contract. The
grievance of the petitioner has not been considered by the respondent
authorities despite making repeated representations, therefore, the
respondent authorities may be directed to foreclose the work
agreement, issue the work completion certificate, so that the petitioner
may participate in other tenders and also to release the remaining
payments under the running bills for the work already executed by
quashing the order dated 29.08.2024.
5.
Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the State opposes the
submissions made by learned counsel for the petitioner and would
submit that, clause 11 of the work agreement would provide that the
payments can be made only after administrative clearance. In the
agreement, it has specifically provided that the payment will be done
only after completion activity and the activities have been categorized
stage-by-stage. A large number of work is required to be performed by
the petitioner, which is still not performed. On 21.08.2024, the
administrative sanction was issued by the State Government and in
the impugned order also the administrative sanction dated 21.08.2024
have been disclosed and said by the respondents that, the work
agreement No. 10/DL/2017-18 is still subsists. Since, the work has not
been completed and therefore, payments have not been made, and
the petitioner may complete the work and receive his payment. Since,
the petitioner had to purchase the advance machinery and other
articles from abroad and for that, he has to pay custom duty and other
taxes, etc. the department has paid advance amount to him subject to
adjustment against the work done by him under the contract. In the
impugned order dated 29.08.2024, the payment details have been
made. It is not that the State is compelling the petitioner for the work
and they have not debarred the petitioner from his bidding capacity.
The petitioner had to challenge the administrative sanction dated
21.08.2024, but he did not challenge it. He would further submit that,
the petitioner is claiming the damages and compensation, for which he
is having an alternative remedy, even the petitioner can very well
invoke the arbitration clause, which is provide under clause 16 of the
work agreement, therefore, no relief can be granted to the petitioner in
the present writ petition and the same is liable to be dismissed.
6.
We have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
documents annexed with the writ petition.
7.
It is the settled law that, the High Court should not exercise its
jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, when it raises
disputed questions of facts. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of
“Subhash Jain v. Rajeshwari Shivam and others” 2021 SCC Online
SC 562, has held in para 26 that:“26. Moreover, the High Court has overlooked the
Notes and Limitations mentioned in the report of
Shetgiri and Associates, set out hereinbelow:
"(1) The report is based on visual inspection
done as on date, of an accessible area and data
provided by client and ND tests results. This
report serves a basis of preliminary health
heck-up of structure and should not be treated
as stability certificate of the building.
(2) ***
(3) Inspection of substructure was not possible
and hence condition of structure below plinth
cannot be commented on.
(4) The observations made in structural audit
report are made during the time of audit. We
shall not be held responsible for any changes
in structural condition and/or damages to the
structure and/or overloading, at any point of
time in case observed.
(5) It is requested that the authority concerned
must carry out regular maintenance of the
structures, sewer lines & premises to avoid any
further severe damage to the structure at a later
stage.
(6) ***
(7) It is extremely important to add here that the
structure is almost more than 45 years old and
has majorly outlived its economic life. In olden
days, especially in 1900's, the Indian Standard
codes were basic in nature as compared with
what is adopted in the present time. Even if the
decision of restoration is adopted, uplifting the
structure to an extent that it would be at par
with
modern
structures
in
terms
of
the
strength, design & safety standards and also
the I.S. codal provisions especially seismic and
wind analysis would be practically ruled-out
and possible only if entire structural upliftment
is carried out within each and every corner of
the structure, which is extremely difficult in
case of repair works considering the massive
repairs
cost
foundations
of
involved.
the
Moreover,
structure
cannot
the
be
restored.
(8) ***
(9) The report is only limited to the captioned
suit building and no other flat(s), building,
structure or plot of land, premises, room, unit,
site, area, division, subdivision or any other
surrounding area of the plot or structure has
been given any weightage or has been covered
in the report.
(10) The documents presented before us, if any,
are considered while furnishing the said report
as
mentioned.
underlying
However,
documents,
the
which
supporting
are
not
mentioned in our report and unknown to us,
could not be examined or analysed. As such,
our report is based only on the documents if
any perused by us and not on any underlying
supporting documents if any, not produced
before us."
8.
Subsequently, in the case of “Union of India v. Puna Hinda” 2021
(10) SCC 690, the Hon'ble Supreme Court has held in para 24 that:“24. Permanent works to be executed under CA No.
CE/VTK/03/2009-10 are as under:
(a) R/Wall: R/Walls balance between Km 26.800
and Km 31.000 and provisioned between Km
31.000 and Km 40.000 at locations mentioned in
Annexure-I to Appendix ‘B’ are recommended
for
execution
on
ground
under
RCC
Culverts
CA
No.
CE/VTK/03/2009-10.
(b)
RCC
Culverts:
balance
between Km 26.800 and Km 31.000 including
two incomplete RCC culverts at locations Km
28.300 and Km 29.000 and those provisioned
between Km 31.000 and Km 47.850 at locations
mentioned in Annexure-II to Appendix “B” are
recommended for execution on ground under
CA No. CE/VTK/03/2009-10.
(c) T/Walls Below RCC Culverts: T/Walls below
RCC Culverts balance between Km 26.800 and
Km 31.000 and those provisioned between Km
31.000 and Km 47.850 at locations mentioned in
Annexure-III to Appendix ‘B’ are recommended
for
execution
on
ground
under
CA
No.
CE/VTK/03/2009-10.
(d) T/Walls below R/Walls: T/Walls below
R/Walls provisioned between Km 26.800 to Km
31.000 and Km 31.000 to Km 47.850 at locations
mentioned in Annexure IV to Appendix ‘B’ are
recommended for execution on ground under
CA No. CE/VTK/03/2009-10.
(e) Breast Walls: Breast Walls provisioned
between Km 26.800 to Km 31.000 and between
Km 31.000 to Km 47.850 at locations mentioned
in
Annexure
V
to
Appendix
‘B’
are
recommended for execution on ground under
CA No. CE/VTK/03/2009-10.
(f) Lined drain: Lined drain for 13271.00 Mtr
length of trapezoidal shape in plum concrete
between Km 26.800 and Km 47.850 at locations
as arrived at after Joint Survey and mentioned
at
Annexure-VI
to
Appendix
‘B’
are
recommended for execution on ground under
CA No. CE/VTK/03/2009-10.
(g) Road Furniture: Road furniture provisioned
between Km 26.800 and Km 47.850 as per
Annexure-VII to Appendix ‘B’ are recommended
for providing/fixing on ground under CA No.
CE/VTK/03/2009-10.”
9.
Further, in the matter of “M.P. Power Management Co. Ltd. v. Sky
Power Southeast Solar India (P) Limited” 2023 (2) SCC 703, the
Hon'ble Supreme Court has observed in its judgment that:“82.7. The existence of an alternate remedy, is,
undoubtedly, a matter to be borne in mind in declining
relief in a Writ Petition in a contractual matter. Again,
the question as to whether the Writ Petitioner must be
told off the gates, would depend upon the nature of
the claim and relief sought by the petitioner, the
questions, which would have to be decided, and, most
importantly, whether there are disputed questions of
fact,
resolution
of
which
is
necessary,
as
an
indispensable prelude to the grant of the relief sought.
Undoubtedly, while there is no prohibition, in the Writ
Court even deciding disputed questions of fact,
particularly when the dispute surrounds demystifying
of documents only, the Court may relegate the party to
the remedy by way of a civil suit.”
10.
A reading of the aforesaid judgments, makes it clear that it is well
settled preposition of law that, when there are disputed questions of
fact involved in the case, the High Court should not exercise its
jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India. From perusal
of the pleadings, it appears that the petitioner has prayed for quashing
of the order dated 29.08.2024 (Annexure P/1) issued by the
respondent No.3 and direction to release the remaining payments of
running bills under the work agreement and also claimed the damages
and compensation. The petitioner also claimed for an inquiry with
respect to issuance of order dated 29.08.2024 by the respondent
No.3.
11.
Clause 11 of the work agreement provided the schedule of running
payments, which is necessary to reproduce here:“Clause: 11 Payment:Schedule of running payment:- Schedule of running payment
may be based on the following break up of the cost quoted in
form-G subject to the stipulations of conditions of contract.
S.
No.
Activity Details
Percentag
e of Total
cost for
payment
Remarks
Excavation Constriction of Sub Grade,
Granular Sub-brae, wet mix Macadam
as per BOQ
7.00%
Providing Prime coat, Tack coat,
Bituminous Macadam and Bituminous
concrete as per BOQ.
7.00%
Payment
will be
done only
after
completion
of activity
Construction of R.C.C Drain with
Concrete cover including reinforcement
and paving around field Construction of
Grossy Field Rest Area, Sump well,
Pump House as per BOQ
12.00%
Supplying,
Fitting,
testing
and
commissioning of required capacity
pump and Laying of Sprinkler system
complete as per BOQ
3.00%
Providing and placing of Chain link
fencing complete as per BOQ:
2.00%
Supplying & Laying Athletic track surface
Full PUR type approved by IAAF as per
BOQ.
55.00%
Any other work required to complete the
Synthetic Athletic track surface as per
IAAF norms.
9.00%
Payment
after
completion
performance/maintenance period
5.00%
of
Note:(1) Above activities are inclusive of all required test from departmental
lab, IAAF accredited laboratory and field test.
(2) Successful bidder must provide all the structural design and working
drawings of work.
(3) The sprinkler system, laid pipe lines, drainage system and Laying of
turf must be checked and accepted by committee, before final payment
of that activity.
(4) Payment is done only after completion of activity.
11.1 Recovery at source:- As per rules the Income Tax, Commercial
Tax, Labour welfare cess, form each running bill/final bill will be
deducted at source as per rules.
11.2 Security Deposit @ 5% will be deducted from each running bill
& it will be refunded after satisfactory completion of work and
taken over by Director, Sports & Youth Welfare, Govt. of
Chattisgarh.
11.3 The price quoted by the Contractor shall be deemed to be inclusive
of all taxes i.e. sales/VAT tax and other levies, duties, royalties, cess,
toll, taxes of central and State Governments. Local bodies and
authorities that the contractor will have to pay for the performance of this
contract. The Govt. will perform such duties in regard to the deduction of
such taxes at source as per applicable law.”
12.
Clause 13.1 of the work agreement provided that the executive
engineer while executing a contract with the contractor shall have the
full right to see that the terms and conditions, specifications, quality,
workmanship of the work assigned to the contractor is fully complied
and are satisfactory/acceptable before payments are released. As per
the impugned order dated 29.08.2024 (Annexure P/1), an amount of
Rs. 20,92,634/- have been excess paid to the petitioner under the
work agreement and the schedule of payments have been disclosed in
the said order. It has also been mentioned in the order dated
29.08.2024 that:“उपरो क्त त लि का ेሰ वቓኌ त विववरो
रो शि
का अनुसा रो आपका अनुबंध ेሰ
रूपये 2002634.00 का भुगत नु अलिधका हुआ है# तथा अनुबंलिधत
का ये% प& % कारोनु अभु' रो ष है#।
ष का ये* का प& % कारोनु का पቐኋ त
आपका% देगका- ेሰ सा उक्त रो शि
रूपये 2092634.00 (G) का
अवितरिरोक्त भुगत नु विकाये गये है# जि0साका साेሰ ये 0नु विकाये 0 नु है#।
इसा अनुबंध ेሰ आपका
का विनुेሰ %
विवभु ग ቛኋ रो का ई भु' भुगत नु
ष नुहै' है#।
सादेቓኌभुत प ्ቔ का. 03 का साबंध ेሰ
पनुरो'शि7त ्ቚ
ख है# विका दिदेनु का 21.08.2024 का
साका9ये स्व'का;वित ्ቚ प्त है चुका9 है#। चु&विका अनुबंध ्ቅ.
10/डी'.ए ./2017-18 0'विवत है#. अतA अनुबंध नुसा रो
ष का ये%
आपका ቛኋ रो प& % विकाये 0 नु है#। का ये% अप& % है नु का का रो
अनुबंध
सा साबंलिधत सारो7 विनुलिध परोफा रोेሰसा विनुलिध, का ये% प& %त ्ቚेሰ
-प्ቔ
आदिदे अनुबंध प& % है नु का प&व% दिदेये 0 नु साभुव नुहैC है#।”
13.
During the course of hearing, learned counsel for the respondents
submitted the copy of the order dated 21.08.2024 issued by the State
Government, which is in respect of the administrative sanction of the
work and it is also necessary to take notice of the said order dated
21.08.2024, which is reproduced hereinunder:छቈኍ सगढ़ शा सन
खेल एवं युवं कल्यु ण विवंभा ग
::मंቔኋ लयु::
मंहा नदी भावंन, नयु रा युपुरा अटन नगरा
//आदीशा//
नयु रा युपुरा अटल नगरा, विदीन क 21/08/2024
्ቅमं क एक 4-13/2006/न" :: रा ज्यु शा सन एतदी% ቛኋ रा जि(ल वि)ल सपुरा अतग* त )हातरा ई मं, रा ज्यु खेल
्ቚविशा्ቌण कन््ቖ मं, भावंन विनमं *ण क यु* क पुनरा वि्ቌत ल गत क आधा रा पुरा रा विशा रूपुयु 11454.24 ल खे क3
विቛኋत यु पुनरा वि्ቌत ्ቚशा सक3यु स्वं वि5 विनम्न नस रा ्ቚदी न करात हा7:-
Ø-
क यु* क विवंवंराण
्ቚथमं पुनरा वि्ቌत ्ቚशा .
विቛኋत यु पुनरा वि्ቌत ्ቚशा .
विवंቈኍ विवंभा x ቛኋ रा
स्वं क9वित क3 रा विशा
स्वं क9वित हात विवंभा ग
स्वं क9त jkf'k (रुपुयु
(रुपुयु ल खे मं,)
ቛኋ रा ्ቚस्त विवंत रा विशा
ल खे मं,)
(रुपुयु ल खे मं,)
आउटडो=रा स्टविडोयुमं baMksj स्टविडोयुमं ्ቚशा . भावंन,
9109 00
7811.22
7811:22
373.00
381.51
381.51
Nk=kokl, ) लक Nk=kokl]
ckm.Mªh e; vkarfjd विवंቕत क यु* क
) जिलक
विनमं *ण क यु*
@)वंल iEi ckg~; विवंቕत क यु* lh-,l-bZ-ch
'kqYd
Iy s xzkm.M fuekZ.k gsrq vkmVMksj
LVsfM;e ,oa baMksj LVsfM;e es a eSnku
leryhdj.k ,oa 8x400 eh- ,FkysfVd
Vsªd ,oa ih-;w- csLM Q~yksfjax ifjlj esa
gkWdh [ksy gsrq flaFksfVd VQZ] xSyjh
fuekZ.k ,oa vkmVMksj es a ns’kh ?kkl ls
IykUVs’ku dk;Z bR;kfn
,Ldsys’ku 'kqYd ¼ewY; o`f)½
vkarfjd lM+d dk fuekZ.k
izkDdyu esa izLrkfor FkkA½
;ksx&
¼ewy
1402.00
(1365.46+
0.00+36.54)
1830.72
1659.91
(1383.15+
(1363.04+
167.72+279.85) 95.34+201.53)
300.00
1401.90
1401.90
199.70
199.70
11184.00
11625.04
11454.24
2/ उपुरा=5 क यु* क3 ्ቚगवित/पु@ण*त क स)धा मं, शा सन क= अवंगत करा यु ( यु।
3/ उपुरा=5 ्ቚशा सक3यु स्वं क9वित विवंቈኍ विवंभा ग क ( वंक कमं क 1007/स . एन./ )(ट-2/विवंቈኍ/चा रा 2024,
विदीन क 13.08.2024 क मं ध्युमं स ्ቚ ् सहामंवित क आधा रा पुरा स्वं क9वित ्ቚदी न क3 गई हा7।
छቈኍ सगढ़ क रा ज्युपु ल क न मं स
तथ आदीशा नlkरा
lgh@gLrk{kj
(आरा. एल. पुቔኋ)
अवंरा सविचावं
छቈኍ सग<+ शा सन
खेल एवं युवं कल्यु ण विवंभा ग
14.
When the administrative sanction has already been made on
21.08.2024 and the respondent authorities have considered that the
work agreement No. 10/DL/2017-18 is still subsists and the petitioner
is required to complete the work under the work agreement, the
petitioner cannot claim the refund of his security deposit/performance
security and work completion certificate, particularly in absence of
challenge to the administrative sanction dated 21.08.2024. The
payment of excess amount under the work agreement has also been
explained by the respondents that, the petitioner had to import the
advance machinery and equipments from abroad and to pay the
custom duty and other taxes, they have paid the said amount to the
petitioner subject to adjustment in the final/running bills.
15.
Further, clause 16 of the work agreement provided the arbitration
clause, which is available in page No. 36 of the writ petition, which
reads as under:“Clause 16: Arbitration
16.1 Except where otherwise provided in the
contract, all questions and disputes relating to
the meaning of the specifications, designs,
drawings
mentioned
and
and
instructions
as
to
herein
the
before
quality
of
workmanship or materials used on the work or
as to any other question, claim, right, matter or
thing whatsoever. In any way arising out of or
relating to the contract, designs, drawings,
specifications, estimates, instructions, orders
or conditions of the contract or otherwise
concerning the works or the execution or
failure to execute the same whether arising
during the progress of the work or after the
cancellation,
termination,
completion
or
abandonment thereof shall be settled amicably
between the parties. If amicable settlement
cannot be reached, disputes or differences
shall be referred for adjudication through
arbitration by a sole arbitrator appointed by the
Government of Chhattisgarh, P.W.D. If the
arbitrator so appointed is unable or unwilling to
act or resigns his appointment or vacates his
office due to any reason whatsoever, another
sole arbitrator shall be appointed in the manner
aforesaid. Such person shall be entitled to
proceed with the reference from the stage at
which it was left by his predecessor.
16.2 It is a term of this contract that the party
invoking arbitration shall give a list of disputes
with amounts claimed in respect of each such
dispute along with the notice for appointment
of arbitrator.
16.3 It is also a term of this contract that no
person other than a person appointed by the
Government
of
Chhattisgarh,
P.W.D.
as
aforesaid, should act as arbitrator and if for any
reason that is not possible, the matter shall not
be referred to arbitration at all.
16.4 It is also a term of this contract that if the
contractor does not make any demand for
appointment of arbitrator in respect of any
claim in writing as aforesaid within 120 days of
receiving the intimation from the committee,
that the final bill is ready for payment, the claim
of the contractor shall be deemed to have been
waived and absolutely barred and the Executive
Engineer shall be discharged and released of
all liabilities under the contract in respect of
these claims.
16.5 The arbitration shall be conducted in
accordance
with
the
provisions
of
the
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (26 of
1996) or any statutory modifications or reenactment thereof and the rules made there
under and for the time being in force shall
apply to the arbitration proceedings under this
clause. It is also a term of this contract that the
arbitrator
shall
adjudicate
on
only
such
disputes as are referred to him by the
appointing authority and give separate award
against each dispute and claim referred to him
and in all cases, the arbitrator shall give
reasons for the award.
16.6 It is also a term of the contract that if any
fees are payable to the arbitrator and any other
expenses incurred for arbitration proceedings,
these shall be paid equally by both the parties.
16.7 It is also a term of the contract that
arbitrator shall be deemed to have entered on
the reference on the date he issues notice to
both the parties calling them to submit their
statement of claims and counter statement of
claims.
The
venue
of
the
arbitration
proceedings shall be such place as may be
fixed by the arbitrator in his sole discretion.
The fees, if any, to the arbitrator shall, if
required to be paid before the award is made
and published, be paid half and half by each of
the parties. The cost of the reference and of the
award (including the fees, if any, of the
arbitrator) shall be in the discretion of the
arbitrator who may direct to and by whom and
in what manner, such costs or any part thereof
shall be paid and fix or settle the amount of
costs to be so paid.
16.8 Notwithstanding anything contained in this
contract, the parties shall not be entitled to
invoke reference of dispute to the arbitration
after acceptance of the final payment until it is
so recorded on the bill that the same was being
received under protest.
16.9 The award shall be final and binding on
both parties. Arbitration proceedings shall be
conducted in English language and in India
only.”
16.
In the instant case, there are various disputed questions of fact
involved, including whether the delay in completion of work was
caused due to any lapses on the part of the authorities or by the
petitioner himself, what works were completed by the petitioner, for
which running bills have been paid, what works remain incomplete,
whether the petitioner is acting in violation of the terms of the work
agreement or it is the respondent authorities, who have violated the
terms of the work agreement, what quantity of work has actually been
executed. The petitioner’s claim for damages and compensation is a
pure question of fact, which requires further determination based on
the relevant facts. In the present case, the reliefs sought by the
petitioner are contingent upon the resolution of these disputed
questions of fact, which cannot be adjudicated under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India.
17.
Considering the rival submissions advanced by learned counsel for the
parties, further considering the disputed questions of facts involved in
the present writ petition, the reliefs sought by the petitioner and in view
of the law laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the above stated
judgments, we do not find any scope for interference in the present
writ petition.
18.
Accordingly, the writ petition is liable to be and hereby dismissed.
However, liberty is reserved in favour of the petitioner to take recourse
to other alternate remedies available to him under the law.
19.
No order as to costs.
Sd/(Ravindra Kumar Agrawal)
Judge
ved
Sd/(Ramesh Sinha)
Chief Justice
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review