Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
V PADMAVATHI
Date: 2026.01.27
12:46:47 +0530
2026:CGHC:3257-DB
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
WPC No. 26 of 2026
M/s Aman Construction Through Its Proprietor Bharti Bhanpuria, W/o Aman Sinha, R/o
Bunglow No. 36 Royal Green, Junwani, Bhilai, Motilal Nehru Nagar, Durg, DistrictDurg, Chhattisgarh
... Petitioner(s)
versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through Secretary, Department, Of Urban Administration
And Development, 4th Floor, Indrawati Bhawan, Naya Raipur, District- Raipur
Chhattisgarh
2 - Directorate (Subsidy), Office Of Urban Administration And Development, Durg,
District- Durg, Chhattisgarh
3 - Chief Municipal Officer Municipal Council Ahiwara, Division Durg, District- Durg,
Chhattisgarh
...Respondent(s)
(Cause-title taken from Case Information System)
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------For Petitioner
: Shri Shikhar Bhaktiyar, Advocate
For Respondent/State
: Shri SS Baghel, GA
For Respondent-3
: Shri RS Marhas, and Shri SB Pandey,
Advocates
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Hon'ble Shri Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
Hon'ble Shri Justice Ravindra Kumar Agrawal
Order on Board
Per Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
20.01.2026
Heard Shri Shikhar Bhaktiyar, learned counsel for the petitioner.
Also
heard
Shri
SS
Baghel,
learned
GA,
appearing
for
the
respondent/State, and Shri RS Marhas, and Shri SB Pandey, learned
counsel for respondent-3.
Wpc 26 of 2026
1.
Petitioner has filed the present writ petition against the order dated
02.12.2025 (Annexure P1), issued by respondent-3 by which the work
order issued in favour of the petitioner was cancelled, and the petitionerfirm has been debarred for a period of one year. Petitioner has filed this
petition for the following reliefs:
“10.1 That this Hon’ble Court may kindly be pleased to issue
an appropriate writ, order or direction quashing and setting
aside the impugned communication / order dated 02.12.2025
issued by respondent No.3, whereby the work orders issued in
favour of the petitioner have been cancelled.
10.2 That this Hon’ble Court may kindly be pleased to issue
an appropriate writ, order or direction quashing and setting
aside the impugned communication / order dated 02.12.2025
issued by respondent No.3, whereby the petitioner-firm has
been blacklisted / debarred for a period of one year.
10.3 That any other relief which this Hon’ble Court deems fit
and proper may also be granted in favour of the petitioner
safeguarding their interest.”
2.
Brief facts of the case are that on 16.10.2024, a tender was floated
by the respondent authorities for 34 different works within the
municipalities of Ahiwara, district-Durg for construction of Garden,
Building, CC Roads etc. Petitioner applied for tender for 8 different works
on 23.10.2024, which relates to construction of Garden, installation of
pavers, and construction of CC road, etc.
On 06.11.2024, petitioner
Wpc 26 of 2026
deposited the security amount of Rs.74,250/-. After opening of tender
bids, petitioner was found to be the least bidder. Despite being the L1
bidder, petitioner was not allotted the work order, and then, on
04.01.2025, he raised his grievance before the respondent authorities.
After cancelling the said tender, amount of security deposit was also not
returned to him. Hence, the petitioner has filed this petition for a direction
to the respondent authority to issue work order to him as he has been
declared as L1 bidder in the tender process.
3.
It is further case of the petitioner that earlier, petitioner has filed
WPC-2452 of 2025 for issuing work order, which was issued on
18.08.2025, during pendency of that petition. Thereafter, on 15.09.2025,
and on 28.10.2025, respondent-3 asked the petitioner to collect the lay
out of the construction plan, and when the petitioner had gone to collect
the same, respondent authorities have denied to give the said lay out
plan, asked for some extraneous considerations, and thereby, petitioner
could not start his work, and the respondent authorities cancelled the
work order and debarred the petitioner for one year, which is under
challenge in the petition.
4.
Learned counsel for the petitioner would submit that cancelling of
work order, as well as debarring the petitioner from participating in any
further tender process amounts to stigma upon the petitioner, which
would
result
into
civil
and
pecuniary
consequences.
Order
of
blacklisting/debarring from any tender process cannot be passed without
Wpc 26 of 2026
affording opportunity of hearing him. Petitioner is ready to carry out the
work, however, the authorities have not provided the lay out plant, and for
want of the same, work could not be started. Petitioner is not at all at
fault for respondents’ non-cooperation, due which he could not start the
work. Cancelling the work order, and debarring the petitioner for one
year from participating would adversely affect the future of the petitioner,
and the order dated 02.12.2025 is liable to be quashed.
5.
Learned counsel for respondent-3 would submit that the petitioner
has made allegations against the Chief Municipal Officer that for
extraneous favour, he has not given the lay out plan to the petitioner but
the authority against who allegations have been made has not been
made as party respondent in the petition, and on this ground alone,
petition is liable to be dismissed. He would also submit that petitionerfirm is in proprietorship of one Smt Bharti Phanpuria and Mr Aman Sinha
is not the authorized signatory. He is only a surveyor, working under the
Pradhan Mantri Awas Yojana in the year 2024, and was found involved in
large scale manipulations. An enquiry was conducted against him and
report was submitted before the Collector. Petitioner was allotted five
works, out of which, four works were not completed. Ultimately, his work
order was cancelled vide order dated 02.12.2025, and he was
blacklisted. Before taking action against the petitioner, he was provided
sufficient opportunity to complete the work but he failed to do so. On
18.08.2025, he signed 8 agreements to complete the work under the
terms, and conditions mentioned therein and when the petitioner did not
Wpc 26 of 2026
start the work, and even he did not obtain the lay out, though he was
asked by a letter dated 15.09.2025 to collect the layout of the
construction work from the Sub-Engineer and start the work. Despite the
efforts making by the respondent authorities, and repeated letters issued
to him, petitioner did not pay any heed, and therefore, the work order was
cancelled by taking a decision in the meeting of President -in-Council as
well as the directions of the State Government contained in letter dated
23.03.2025. Therefore, the petitioner cannot claim equity as the work
has been suffered for his fault and the impugned order of cancellation of
work order as well as his debarring for one year from participating any
further tender is justified, and the petition filed by the petitioner-firm is
liable to be dismissed.
6.
Learned counsel appearing for the State would submit that State is
a formal party, and it is a dispute between the petitioner and
respondent-3.
7.
We have heard learned counsel for the parties, and perused the
material annexed with the writ petition by the parties.
8.
There are allegations and counter allegations having disputed
questions of fact, as to who is at fault in handing over the layout plan of
the tender work as to whether the petitioner himself was negligent in
obtaining the said lay out, or the respondent authorities refused to
provide the same to the petitioner.
Wpc 26 of 2026
9.
From the return filed by respondent-3, and the documents
appended thereto, it transpires that notice was issued on 22.05.2025 to
the petitioner that time limit to complete certain works under the work
order has been elapsed, yet, the petitioner has not completed his work
and not submitted its report. In that letter, he has been debarred for
participating in further tender process for one year. The Notice dated
25.04.2025 Annexure R-3-6 also shows that before passing the order
dated 22.05.2025, notice was issued to the petitioner to obtain lay out
plan and to complete the work. Therefore, opportunity was provided to
the petitioner before cancelling the work order allotted to him.
10.
Be that as it may, from the entire sequence of the events, and
conduct of the petitioner-firm that despite issuance of notice to obtain the
lay out and to start/complete the work allotted to him, he failed to either to
start or to complete the work. Cancellation of work order of the petitioner
was decided in the meeting of President-in-Council on 25.07.2025, which
in the opinion of this Court, appears to be the steps correctly taken by
respondent-3. When the petitioner, despite notice, has not started the
work, he cannot claim equity in his favour and the authorities concerned
are constrained to take such steps, particularly, when the public interest
is involved in the allotted work.
11.
Considering the entirety of facts and circumstances of the case, we
do not find any arbitrariness in the decision making process of
respondent authorities.
Wpc 26 of 2026
12.
With respect to submission of learned counsel for the petitioner that
black listing/debarring the petitioner to participate in further tender
process for one year is too harsh and the Hon’ble Supreme Court has
held that blacklisting is in the nature of penalty, and therefore, it cannot
be passed without giving opportunity of hearing to the petitioner in that
respect.
13.
Hon’ble Supreme court in case of M/S Kulja Industries Ltd v.
Chief Gen. Manager, W.T. Proj., BSNL & Ors (decided on October 4,
2013) AIR 2014 SC 9 refers to the authority of state entities to blacklist
contractors for improper conduct. This landmark judgment affirmed that
state entities have the authority to blacklist contractors for improper
conduct but that such blacklisting must be proportional, not permanent,
and subject to judicial review, and it has observed in para-26 as under:
“26. The next question then is whether this Court ought to
itself determine the time period for which the appellant should
be blacklisted or remit the matter back to the authority to do so
having regard to the attendant facts and circumstances. A
remand back to the competent authority has appealed to us to
be a more appropriate option than an order by which we may
ourselves determine the period for which the appellant would
remain blacklisted. We say so for two precise reasons. Firstly,
because blacklisting is in the nature of penalty the quantum
whereof is a matter that rests primarily with the authority
Wpc 26 of 2026
competent to impose the same. In the realm of service
jurisprudence this Court has no doubt cut short the agony of a
delinquent employee in exceptional circumstances to prevent
delay and further litigation by modifying the quantum of
punishment but such considerations do not apply to a
company engaged in a lucrative business like supply of optical
fibre/HDPE
pipes
to
BSNL.
Secondly,
because
while
determining the period for which the blacklisting should be
effective the respondent-Corporation may for the sake of
objectivity and transparency formulate broad guidelines to be
followed in such cases. Different periods of debarment
depending upon the gravity of the offences, violations and
breaches may be prescribed by such guidelines. While, it may
not be possible to exhaustively enumerate all types of
offences and acts of misdemeanour, or violations of
contractual obligations by a contractor, the respondentCorporation may do so as far as possible to reduce if not
totally eliminate arbitrariness in the exercise of the power
vested in it and inspire confidence in the fairness of the order
which the competent authority may pass against a defaulting
contractor.”
14.
Considering the aforementioned facts and decision of Hon’ble
Supreme Court, this Court is of the opinion that black listing /debarring of
Wpc 26 of 2026
the petitioner for one year from participating in furhter tender appears to
be hard, and it is liable to be quashed.
15.
Accordingly, that part of the order dated 02.12.2025 that ‘petitioner
M/s Aman Construction Through Its Proprietor Bharti Bhanpuria shall be
debarred for one year from 02.12.2025’ is hereby quashed. However,
cancellation of work order of the petitioner through order dated
02.12.2025 is affirmed.
16.
Petition is partly allowed to the extent indicated herein above.
Sd/(Ravindra Kumar Agrawal)
Judge
padma
Sd/(Ramesh Sinha)
Chief Justice
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review