Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/21
GAHC010166582018
2019:GAU-AS:20839
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/7686/2018
M/S. AGLOWMED LTD.
A COMPANY INCORPORATED UNDER THE PROVISIONS OF COMPANIES
ACT, 1956 (READ WITH THE COMPANIES ACT 2013) HAVING ITS PLACE OF
BUSINESS AT A.K. AZAD ROAD, REHABARI, GUWAHATI, ASSAM, REP. BY
SHRI GOPAL KUMAR PRASAD.
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND 4 ORS.
REP. BY THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY, TO THE GOVT. OF ASSAM,
DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE AND TAXATION, DISPUR, ASSAM, GUWAHATI
- 781006.
2:THE COMMISSIONER OF STATE TAX
(EARLIER COMMISSIONER OF TAXES)
ASSAM KAR BHAVAN
DISPUR
GUWAHATI- 781006.
3:THE JOINT COMMISSIONER OF STATE TAX
(EARLIER JOINT COMMISSIONER OF TAXES)
ASSAM
GUWAHATI
KAR BHAWAN
GUWAHATI
ASSAM-05.
4:THE SUPERINTENDENT OF STATE TAX
(EARLIER SUPERINTENDENT OF TAXES)
Page No.# 2/21
UNIT -D)
KAR BHAWAN
DISPUR
GUWAHATI-05.
5:THE STATE BANK OF INDIA
A.T. ROAD
BRANCH
GUWAHATI
ASSAM-01
Advocate for the Petitioner
: MS. M L GOPE, MS. N HAWELIA,MS. N GOGOI,MS. N MECH
Advocate for the Respondent : SC, FINANCE AND TAXATION, MS B GOGOI
Linked Case : WP(C)/6728/2018
M/S. AGLOWMED LTD.
A COMPANY INCORPORATED UNDER THE PROVISIONS OF THE
COMPANIES ACT
1956 HAVING ITS PLACE OF BUSINESS AT A K AZAD ROAD
REHABARI
GUWAHATI
ASSAM
REP. BY SRI GOPAL KUMAR PRASAD
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND 5 ORS
REP. BY THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY TO THE GOVT OF ASSAM
DEPT OF FINANCE AND TAXATION
DISPUR
ASSAM
GUWAHATI- 781006
2:THE COMMISSIONER OF STATE TAX (EARLIER COMMISSIONER OF
TAXES)
ASSAM KAR BHAVAN
DISPUR
GUWAHATI- 781006
Page No.# 3/21
3:THE JOINT COMMISSIONER OF STATE TAX (EARLIER JOINT
COMMISSIONER OF TAXES)
ASSAM
GUWAHATI
KAR BHAWAN
GUWAHATI
ASSAM
4:THE SUPERINTENDENT OF STATE TAX (EARLIER SUPERINTENDENT OF
TAXES)
UNIT D
KAR BHAWAN
DISPUR
GUWAHATI
5:THE STATE BANK OF INDIA
A T ROAD BRANCH
GUWAHATI
ASSAM
-----------Advocate for : MS. M L GOPE
Advocate for : SC
TAXES appearing for THE STATE OF ASSAM AND 5 ORS
Linked Case : WP(C)/7582/2018
M/S. AGLOWMED LTD.
A COMPANY INCORPORATED UNDER THE PROVISIONS OF COMPANIES
ACT
1956 (READ WITH THE COMPANIES ACT
2013) HAVING ITS PLACE OF BUSINESS AT A.K. AZAD ROAD
REHABARI
GUWAHATI
ASSAM REPRESENTED BY SRI GOPAL KUMAR PRASAD.
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND 5 ORS.
REP. BY THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY
TO THE GOVERNMENT OF ASSAM
DEPTT. OF FINANCE AND TAXATION
DISPUR
GUWAHATI- 781006.
Page No.# 4/21
2:THE COMMISSIONER OF SALES TAX (EARLIER COMMISSIONER OF
TAXES)
ASSAM KAR BHAVAN
DISPUR
GUWAHATI- 781006.
3:THE JOINT COMMISSIONER OF STATE TAX (EARLIER JOINT
COMMISSIONER OF TAXES)
ASSAM
GUWAHATI
KAR BHAWAN
GUWAHATI
ASSAM.
4:THE SUPERINTENDENT OF STATE TAX (EARLIER SUPERINTENDENT OF
TAXES)
UNIT-D
KAR BHAWAN
DISPUR
GUWAHATI.
5:THE STATE BANK OF INDIA
A.T. ROAD BRANCH
GUWAHATI
ASSAM.
-----------Advocate for : MS. M L GOPE
Advocate for : SC
FINANCE AND TAXATION appearing for THE STATE OF ASSAM AND 5 ORS.
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE DEVASHIS BARUAH
For the Petitioner(s)
: Mr. N. Hawelia, Advocate
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. M. Bhuiyan, Advocate
Date on which judgment was reserved : NA
Date of pronouncement of judgment
Whether the pronouncement is of the
: 24.02.2026
Page No.# 5/21
Operative part of the judgment?
: NA
Whether the full judgment has been
pronounced?
: Yes
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (ORAL)
Heard Ms. N. Hawelia, the learned counsel appearing on behalf of
the petitioner in the 3 (three) writ petitions. Mr. M. Bhuiyan, the
learned counsel appears on behalf of the State respondents in the 3
(three) writ petitions.
BRIEF FACTS
2.
The petitioner in all 3 (three) writ petitions is one and the same.
The petitioner is a company incorporated under the provisions of the
Companies Act, 1956, and is a registered dealer under the Assam
Value Added Tax Act, 2003 (for short, “the Act of 2003”), as well as
the Central Sales Tax Act, 1956. The petitioner is also a registered
dealer under the Goods and Service Tax Act, 2017.
3.
The petitioner deals in the sale of medicines in the State of
Assam. It is the case of the petitioner that while selling medicines in
the State of Assam, the petitioner also distributed free supplies as
samples to the retailers as a policy of promotion of medicines. It is the
case of the petitioner that for all the 3 (three) assessment years i.e.
2007-2008, 2008-2009, and 2009-2010, the Superintendent of Taxes,
Page No.# 6/21
Unit-D, Guwahati accepted that the free supplies of medicines which
the petitioner distributed amongst the retailers were exempted from
payment of tax and accordingly passed assessment orders.
4.
The grievance of the petitioner herein is that the respondent No.
4, i.e. the Superintendent of Taxes, Unit-D, Guwahati, initiated the
proceedings for re-assessment under Section 40 of the Act of 2003 for
all the 3 (three) assessment years, and thereupon passed reassessment orders thereby levying tax on the free samples and also
the interest accrued thereon. It is pertinent to mention that in respect
to the 3 (three) assessment years, the following amounts were found
payable by the petitioner upon passing re-assessment orders:
5.
1.
2007-2008-
Tax-Rs. 6,74,258/-; Interest-Rs. 9,30,476/-.
2.
2008-2009-
Tax-Rs. 7,91,729/-; Interest-Rs. 9,50,075/-
3.
2009-2010-
Tax-Rs. 7,94,685/-; Interest-Rs.8,10,578/-
The petitioner being aggrieved by the re-assessment orders so
passed by the respondent No. 4 for the 3 (three) assessment years,
thereby imposing a huge tax liability as well as the interest thereupon,
preferred 3 (three) revision applications before the Commissioner of
Taxes, Guwahati and the same was endorsed to the Joint
Commissioner
of
Taxes,
Guwahati
for
disposal.
The
Joint
Commissioner of Taxes, Guwahati vide the common order dated
Page No.# 7/21
10.05.2018 dismissed the 3 (three) revision applications thereby
upholding the orders of re-assessment for the 3 (three) assessment
years and it is under such circumstances, the present writ petitions
have been filed.
6.
The record reveals that this Court vide an order dated
09.11.2018 issued notice. However, no interim orders were passed.
7.
Ms. N. Hawelia, the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
petitioner submitted that as there was no interim order passed, the
petitioner had already paid the entire tax as well as the interest
payable thereon.
8.
It is also very pertinent to take note of that as the order dated
10.05.2018 passed by the respondent No. 3, is based upon a
Notification issued by the Government of Assam dated 11.10.2006,
the said Notification has also been put to challenge in the 3 (three)
writ petitions.
9.
The respondents have filed an affidavit-in-opposition wherein it
was stated that the assessments initially carried out by the petitioners
were self-assessments. It was also stated that the petitioner had
claimed to have provided large quantities of medicine free of cost to
the retailers in the form of quantity discount as a common practice of
business, whose value runs into crores of rupees in a financial year.
Page No.# 8/21
These samples were actually not free samples. It was also mentioned
that the petitioner was afforded adequate opportunities before
completion of the proceedings in the matter of turnover escaping the
assessment, but the petitioner did not even bother to produce the
books of account, nor to speak about adducing its case. It was stated
that going through the returns submitted of the audited accounts of
the petitioner, it transpired that the petitioner paid taxes by
multiplying the aggregate of MRP as declared in his returns. The
petitioner did not deduct the tax fraction from the MRP, which implied
that the petitioner threw open to the market its product with a clear
instruction that ultimately the customers have to bear the extra tax in
addition to the MRP printed on the body of the package and those
goods which were given free as quantity discount or whatever name it
may be, ultimately is sold to the public along with other goods.
10.
It was also mentioned in the said affidavit-in-opposition that in
view of such practices being followed of providing free samples, the
Government of Assam in exercise of the powers conferred by Section
110 of the Act of 2003, issued the Notification dated 11.10.2006
directing that free supplies along with the sale at the point of first sale
in the State on MRP also be deemed as sale and shall be liable to pay
tax on the MRP of such goods given free. Accordingly, proceedings
under Section 40 of the Act of 2003, were conducted strictly
confirming to the provisions of law and the relevant Notification issued
Page No.# 9/21
under the Act of 2003. The proceedings were concluded way back on
24.09.2015 and the demand notice thereof was issued and received
on the same date.
11.
It was further mentioned in the said affidavit-in-opposition that
the petitioner never bothered to pay slight importance to it and sat
over it. Resultantly, recovery proceedings were initiated, but the
petitioner exhibited total disregard to those proceedings also, and the
Petitioner woke up after the recovery proceedings took effective turn.
It was also mentioned that Section 10 of the Act of 2003 provides the
method of levy of tax on medicine to be taxed at the first point on
MRP, and the petitioner never contested that point. The petitioner all
along till Drugs and Medicines were brought in the Schedule-II
continued to pay tax on MRP. The levy of tax later on changed and
the tax was levied at all points of sale where even if goods are given
free to retailer, tax is to be deposited by the retailer if the retailer sold
it to the customer. It was also mentioned that the petitioner followed
the earlier system without contesting its validity and ripped all the
benefits of that system and pumped goods into the market amounting
to crores of rupees with a label on it “Local Taxes Extra”. It was stated
that the petitioner knew that though the goods at the first stage were
supplied free of cost to the retailers as promotional measure, the
goods would be sold by the subsequent seller as the goods were
inscripted with “Local Taxes Extra”, as evident from the Petitioner’s
Page No.# 10/21
accounts, thereby burdening the customers to pay tax, and thus the
petitioner cannot avoid the responsibility of the tax burden by
accepting a part of the scheme and avoiding the other part after
invoking the path of professing the dictum “Local Taxes Extra”. The
respondents through the affidavit supported the impugned order
dated 10.05.2018 as well as the Notification, which was impugned in
the instant proceedings.
SUBMISSIONS
MADE
BY
THE
LEARNED
COUNSELS
APPEARING ON BEHALF OF THE PARTIES
12.
Ms. N. Hawelia, the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
petitioner referred to the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case
of State of Rajasthan & Another Vs. Rajasthan Chemist Association
reported in (2006) 6 SCC 773 and submitted that the imposition of the
tax on the MRP was not permissible and therefore the impugned
Notification dated 11.10.2006 cannot be sustained in law. The learned
counsel, further referring to Section 11 of the Act of 2003, submitted
that for the purposes of the Act of 2003, the taxable turnover in
relation to a dealer liable to pay tax on the sale of goods means that
part of the dealer's gross turnover during the prescribed period which
remains after deducting the permissible deductions mentioned in
Section 11 of the Act of 2003, and includes the turnover of such other
Page No.# 11/21
sales or such other amounts as may be prescribed. The learned
counsel, referring to Rule 9 of the Assam Value Added Tax Rules,
2005 (for short, “the Rules of 2005”) submitted that in determining
the taxable turnover as per the provisions of Section 11 of the Act of
2003, the various amounts specified in Clauses (a) to (h) of Rule 9 of
the Rules of 2005 are required to be deducted which includes
amounts allowed as discount, provided that such discount is allowed
in accordance with the regular practice of the dealer or in accordance
with the terms of any contract or agreement entered into in a
particular case having a bearing on the price consideration, and
provided further that the accounts show that the purchaser has paid
only the sum originally charged less the discount.
13.
The learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that the free
sample provided by the petitioner was intact a discount, and as such,
the price of the free samples had to be excluded while determining
the taxable turnover. In that regard, the learned counsel referred to
the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Deputy
Commissioner of Sales Tax (Law), Board of Revenue (Taxes),
Ernakulam Vs. M/s Motor Industries Co., Ernakulam reported in
(1983) 2 SCC 108. The learned counsel referring to the said judgment
submitted, that the Supreme Court categorically observed that the
service discount is an integral part of the transaction of sale itself
which
incidentally
confers
on
the
assessee
the
benefit
of
Page No.# 12/21
popularization of the assessee is goods in the market. The discount so
allowed is merely a percentage of the price of the goods sold, which
has nothing to do with any other goods supplied or other sub-service
rendered by the buyers to the assessee. The learned counsel
appearing on behalf of the petitioner therefore submitted that the free
samples were provided in lieu of a trade discount, and as such, the
same should be construed as a part of a trade discount, thereby
entitling the said amount to be deducted while determining the
taxable turnover.
14.
Per contra, Mr. M. Bhuiyan, the learned counsel appearing on
behalf of the State respondents submitted that drugs and medicines
were brought within the fold of the Fourth Schedule of the Act of
2003. Explanation 3 to Section 10 of the Act of 2003 makes it clear
that when goods are brought within the fold of Fourth Schedule, tax
at the first point of sale has to be paid on the MRP. The learned
counsel submitted that neither Explanation 3 to Section 10 of the Act
of 2003 nor Entry 21 of the Fourth Schedule have been put to
challenge. The learned counsel therefore submitted that under such
circumstances, the petitioner cannot be allowed to question the
mandate of the Explanation 3 to Section 10 of the Act of 2003, as well
as Entry 21 to the Fourth Schedule.
15.
The learned counsel for the respondents submitted that the
Page No.# 13/21
Notification which was issued on 11.10.2006 and impugned in the
instant proceedings, is more like a clarificatory Notification which have
been issued to obviate the difficulties arising on account of the
common practice followed in the medicine trade to offer free units on
sale, which results, not only in the loss to the State Exchequer, but
also permits the retailers to collect tax on sale on such free units. The
learned counsel therefore submitted that without the challenge to
Explanation 3 to Section 10 of the Act of 2003 as well as Entry 21 of
the Fourth Schedule, the Notification dated 11.10.2006 being a part of
the said provisions cannot be put to challenge. The learned counsel
further submitted that the judgment in the case of Rajasthan Chemist
Association (supra) cannot be made applicable to the present dispute
as the facts involved in the said judgment are completely different
from the facts involved in the present proceedings.
16.
The learned counsel for the respondents submitted that Section
11 of the Act of 2003 stipulates the permissible deductions while
determining the taxable turnover and further, at Clause (d) of Section
11 of the Act of 2003, it stipulates that permissible deductions would
be available in the Rules of 2005. The learned counsel submitted that
Rule 9 of the Rules of 2005 provides the permissible deductions.
Referring to Rule 9(b) of the Rules of 2005, the learned counsel
submitted that for getting the benefit under the said Rule, there are
certain prerequisites to be satisfied, which includes that the amount
Page No.# 14/21
allowed is as a discount and not as a free sample. Secondly, such
amounts allowed as discount is in accordance with the regular
practice of the dealer or in accordance with the terms of any contract
or agreement entered into in a particular case having a bearing on the
price consideration, provided the accounts show that the purchaser
has paid only the sum originally charged less discount. The learned
counsel further submitted that when it is a case of free samples, the
said samples are not accounted for, and accordingly Rule 9(b) of the
Rule of 2005 cannot be said to be satisfied in the present case.
ANALYSIS AND DETERMINATION
17.
At the outset, it is relevant to observe that the impugned order
dated 10.05.2018 is based upon the impugned notification dated
11.10.2006 and as such, it is only in the circumstance, this Court
holds that the impugned Notification is contrary to law, the impugned
order can be interfered with.
18. The impugned Notification is challenged on the ground that it is
contrary to the judgment of the Supreme Court in Rajasthan Chemist
Association (supra). In the opinion of this Court, the judgment in the
case of Rajasthan Chemist Association (supra) is not applicable. The
reasons are that the issue involved in the case of Rajasthan Chemist
Association (supra) was whether the taxable turnover of the
wholesale distributor is to be calculated on the basis of the maximum
Page No.# 15/21
retail price or on the basis of the price at which the wholesaler had
sold the medicines to the retailers. The issues, as to whether free
samples are permissible deductions in terms with Section 11 of the
Act of 2003 for determination of the taxable turnover is not an issue
involved in the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of
Rajasthan Chemist Association (supra).
19.
Apart from the above, it is also very pertinent to take note of
that in the case before the Supreme Court in the case of Rajasthan
Chemist Association (supra), Section 4A of the Rajasthan Sales Tax
Act, 1994, was put to challenge, whereas in the instant case, neither
Explanation 3 to Section 10 of the Act of 2003 nor Entry 21 of the
Fourth Schedule of the Act of 2003 have been put to challenge.
20.
Under such circumstances, as neither there is challenge to the
vires of Explanation 3 to Section 10 nor Entry 21 of Fourth Schedule
to the Act of 2003, the question of challenging the impugned
Notification dated 11.10.2006 on the ground that the Supreme Court
in the case of Rajasthan Chemist Association (supra) held that there
cannot be charging of tax on the MRP is completely misconceived. It
is apposite herein to mention that both Section 11 of the Act of 2003
as well as Rule 9 of the Rules of 2005 provide permissible deductions
which includes trade discounts which was not an aspect before the
Supreme Court.
Page No.# 16/21
21. Let this Court now take into consideration whether free samples
can be regarded as trade discounts. This aspect is taken into
consideration in view of the submission made by the learned counsel
appearing on behalf of the petitioner to the effect that free samples
being a form of a trade discount, the petitioner is entitled to the
benefit in terms with Rule 9(b) of the Rules of 2005 while
determination of the taxable turnover in terms with Section 11 of the
Act of 2003 and as such, the impugned Notification dated 11.10.2006
is contrary to Section 11 of the Act of 2003 read with Rule 9(b) of the
Rules of 2005.
22. This Court finds it very pertinent to take note of that Rule 9(b) of
the Rules of 2005 is almost pari materia to Rule (9)(a) of the Kerala
General Sales Tax Rules, 1963. The said Rule 9(a) of the Kerala
General State Tax Rules, 1963 came up for interpretation before the
Supreme Court in the case of M/s Motor Industries Co., Ernakulam
(Supra). A perusal of paragraph No. 5 of the said judgment would
show that the Supreme Court observed that all amounts allowed in
discount where such discount is allowed in accordance with the
regular practice of the dealer or in accordance with the terms of the
contract or agreement entered into in a particular case have to be
deducted from the total turnover in determining the taxable turnover,
provided the accounts of the assessee show that the purchaser has
paid only the sum originally charged less the discount. It is further
Page No.# 17/21
seen that in the said case trade discounts were allowed and such
discounts were also shown in the books of accounts. Paragraph Nos. 5
and 6 of the said judgment being relevant are reproduced herein
under:
“5.
We shall first deal with the claim made in respect of “service discount”. Under
clause (a) of Rule 9 of the Rules all amounts allowed as discount where such discount
is allowed in accordance with the regular practice of the dealer or is in accordance
with the terms of contract or agreement entered into in a particular case have to be
deducted from the total turnover in determining the taxable turnover provided the
accounts of the assessee show that the purchaser has paid only the sum originally
charged less the discount. In the instant case the “service discount” in respect of
which the deduction was claimed by the assessee was the additional trade discount
allowed by it to its main distributors (purchasers) namely the T.V. S. group of
companies which constitute a prestigious group of commercial concerns over and
above the normal trade discount in consideration of the extra benefit derived by the
assessee by reason of the marketing of its goods through them. This additional trade
discount is allowed in accordance with the trade agreement subject to periodical
variation depending upon the cost structure and changes in market conditions. It is
not disputed that there were such agreements between the assessee and the
purchasers and the accounts of the assessee truly reflected the actual discount
allowed to the purchasers. What is however urged by the Department is that the said
additional discount allowed by the assessee could not strictly be termed as discount as
it was in lieu of services rendered by its main distributors by way of popularisation of
the sales and consumption of the products sold by the assessee. We find it difficult to
accept the submission made on behalf of the Department. Rule 9(a) says that all
amounts allowed as discount either in accordance with regular practice or in
accordance with agreement would be deductible from the total turnover provided they
are duly supported by the entries in the accounts of the assessee. Ordinarily any
concession shown in the price of goods for any commercial reason would be a trade
Page No.# 18/21
discount which can legitimately be claimed as a deduction under clause (a) of Rule 9
of the Rules. Such a concession is usually allowed by a manufacturer or a wholesale
dealer in favour of another dealer with the object of improving prospects of his own
business. It is common experience that when goods are marketed through reputed
companies, firms or other individual dealers the demand for such goods increases and
correspondingly the business of the manufacturer or the wholesaler would become
more and more prosperous and its capacity to withstand competition from other
manufacturers or other dealers dealing in similar goods would also improve. Hence
any concession in price shown in such circumstances by way of an additional incentive
with a view to promote one’s own trade does qualify for deduction as a trade discount.
It cannot be termed as a service charge as is attempted to be termed in this case. In
fact in this case apart from buying the products of the assessee, no other service is
being rendered by the T.V.S. group of companies to the assessee. In the circumstances
the additional discount or “service discount” as it is called in this case is no other than
the discount referred to in Rule 9(a) of the Rules.
6. We are not inclined to accept the submission that the “service discount” in question
is in the nature of a set-off on account of reciprocal promises or amounts to
consideration for an agreement styled as “trading-in”. “Trade-in” contracts are those
where goods are transferred by the seller for consideration partly in money and partly
in exchange of some other goods to be sold by the buyer to the seller. In such cases
there may be one contract of sale only of the principal goods coupled with a subsidiary
agreement that if the buyer delivers to the seller the other goods, an agreed allowance
will be made. There may also be cases where the buyer may become entitled to an
extra allowance for some service unconnected with the sale of the goods in question
being rendered to the seller. In such cases the allowance in the price of the goods sold
given by the seller to the buyer either by way of consideration for the goods supplied
by the buyer to the seller or for services rendered by the buyer to the seller would not
be a trade discount as such which would qualify for deduction in the determination of
the taxable turnover. In the instant case the service said to have been rendered by the
buyers for securing the “service discount” is an integral part of the transaction of sale
Page No.# 19/21
itself which incidentally confers on the assessee the benefit of popularisation of the
assessee’s goods in the market. The discount so allowed is merely a percentage of the
price of the goods sold which has nothing to do with any other goods supplied or
other service rendered by the buyers to the assessee. The fact that the discount is not
allowed at the time of sale but on a later date at the end of the month would not
make it any-the-less a trade discount.”
23.
From the above quoted paragraphs of the said judgment, it is
clear that the Supreme Court was dealing with a case of trade
discount and not free samples.
The question therefore arises as to whether free samples can be
equated to trade discounts for allowing deduction on the taxable
turnover in terms with Rule 9(b) of the Rules of 2005.
24.
This Court finds it relevant to take note of the concept of free
samples vis-à-vis trade discount. A free sample is a sample of an
offered product that is given to existing or potential customers for
promotional purposes and is not charged to the customers. Such free
samples are usually given out to promote the product’s quality,
promote the brand or market a new product. In effect, a free sample
is a sample which is provided to the end customer free of cost for
promotion of the product. On the other hand, a trade discount is a
percentage reduction from the listed price, given to the intermediaries
(wholesalers/retailers) for bulk purchase thereby reducing the invoice
value. In that perspective, if this Court takes note of Rule 9(b) of the
Page No.# 20/21
Rules of 2005, it would show that it refers to trade discount but not
free samples. This Court therefore is of the opinion that Rule 9(b) of
the Rules of 2005 only refers to trade discount and not to free
samples.
25.
This Court now finds it very pertinent to take note of the
rationale behind the Notification dated 11.10.2006 which is impugned
in the instant proceedings. The contents of the Notification itself show
that there is a common practice in the medicine trade to offer free
units on sale, but these free units which have been provided to the
retailers are sold by the retailers to the consumers at the M.R.P. and
tax is charged above the M.R.P. This aspect is apparent from the
materials on record that these free samples so provided not only
mentions the MRP, but also mentions “Local Taxes Extra”, thereby
permitting the retailers to collect tax from the consumers but such tax
collected do not make its way to the State Exchequer. It is under such
circumstances, vide the impugned Notification dated 11.10.2006, it
was clarified that the free samples along with the sale at the point of
first sale in the State on MRP basis shall also be deemed to be sale of
such goods, and the dealer providing such free samples at the point
of first sale in the State shall calculate and pay tax on the MRP of
such goods given free. Taking into account the said Notification dated
11.10.2006, it cannot therefore be said that the impugned Notification
is contrary to Rule 9(b) of the Rules of 2005 inasmuch as Rule 9(b) of
Page No.# 21/21
the Rules of 2005 only refers to trade discount.
26.
This Court also finds it very pertinent to take note of that the
various assessment years are the subject matter of dispute in the 3
(three) writ petitions are 2007-2008, 2008-2009 and 2009-2010 and
the petitioner being in the trade of medicine ought to have known
about the Notification dated 11.10.2006 which was holding the field at
least till 31.10.2009. The petitioner never challenged the said
notification till filing of the present proceedings in the year 2018.
Under such circumstances also, the impugned notification cannot be
interfered with.
27.
The notification dated 11.10.2006 in view of the above analysis
cannot be said to be contrary to Section 11 of the Act of 2003 and
Rule 9(b) of the Rules of 2005.
28.
It is pertinent to observe that the impugned order dated
10.05.2018
is
based
upon
the
impugned
notification
dated
11.10.2006. It is the opinion of this Court that the notification dated
11.10.2006 is in accordance with law. Accordingly, the impugned
order dated 10.05.2018 requires no interference.
29. The writ petitions accordingly stand dismissed. No costs.
JUDGE
Date: 2026.03.06 07:40:55 +05'30'
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review