Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CGHC010506402025
2026:CGHC:30217
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
ARBR No. 63 of 2025
Digitally
signed by
PREETI
PREETI KUMARI
KUMARI Date:
2026.07.20
14:10:21
+0530
Ms Adept Power Private Ltd A-13, Sector - 52, Noida- 201301 U.P. Through
its Director, Mr. Sanjay Kapoor S/o R.K. Kapoor, Aged About 59 Years, 202,
Kumar House, Central Market, Prashant Vihar, Delhi, 110085.
--- Applicant
versus
1. South Eastern Coal Fields Ltd Through, its General Manager (E & M) /
H O D, S E C L Bhawan, Seepat Road, Bilaspur, District- Bilaspur C.G.
495006
2. General Manager (SO - E & M) DA, S E C L Office of The General
Manager, Dipka Area, District – Korba, C.G. 495452
--- Respondents
ARBR No. 66 of 2025
M/s Adept Power Private Ltd. A-13, Sector- 52, Noida- 201301 (U.P.)
Through Its Director, Mr. Sanjay Kapoor S/o R.K. Kapoor, Aged About 59
Years, 202, Kumar House, Central Market, Prashant Vihar, Delhi, 110085
--- Applicant
Versus
1. South Eastern Coal Fields Ltd. Through Its General Manager (E And M)/
Hod, Secl Bhawan, Seepat Road, Bilaspur, District Bilaspur C.G. 495006
2. General Manager (So- E And M) SECL, Office of The General Manager,
Gevra Area, District - Korba C.G. 495452
--- Respondents
For Applicants
: Mr. Shivank Mishra, Advocate.
For Respondents
: Ms. Sameeksha Gupta, Panel Lawyer.
Hon’ble Mr. Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
Order on Board
16.07.2026
1. This is an application under Section 11(6) of the Arbitration and Conciliation
Act, 1996 for appointment of an Arbitrator.
2. Since the instant applications i.e. ARBR No. 63 of 2025 and ARBR No. 66
of 2025 involve common facts and issues, they are being considered and
decided together. ARBR No. 63 of 2025 is taken as the lead case.
3. The facts, in brief, as projected by the applicant are that the applicant Adept
Power Private Limited is a MSME registered with Ministry of Micro, Small
and Medium Enterprises and a private limited company duly incorporated
under the provisions of the Companies Act, 2013 engaged in the works
pertaining to the work Design, Engineering, Construction, Fabrication,
Supply, Erection, Trial Run and Commissioning of the Electric Sub Stations.
Respondent No.1 South Eastern Coal Fields Limited is subsidiary company
of Coal India Limited, which is a Public Sector Undertaking under the
supervision of Ministry of Coal, Government of India, independent to take
decisions pertaining to its administration and growth of Business and
allotment if Tenders in its behalf, being represented through its General
Manager (E&M)/HOD who is the authorized representative of respondent
No.1 for supervision and execution of project. Respondent No.2 is General
Manager (E&M)/SO (E&M)), DA of respondent No.1 SECL who has
represented it in the resolution process through internal settlement
mechanism. Respondent No.1 floated an e-Tender Notice under two parts
on the e-procurement portal of Coal India Limited and invited bids from the
reputed and experienced contractors having prior experience with regard
the kind of work being allotted on 04/05/2018, for carrying on "Design,
Engineering, Construction, Fabrication, Supply, Erection, Trial Run and
Commissioning of (a) 2 x 16 MVA, 33kV/6.6kV Each - 2 Nos. Sub-station
(b) 2 x 5 MVA, 33kV/3.3kV 1 No. Sub-station (Balance work and Additional
work) on turnkey basis along with maintenance of Sub-stations for four
years at Dipka Open Cast Project, Dipka Area Tahsil - Katghora & Pali,
District- Korba Chhattisgarh. The applicant participated in the above
mentioned Tender for carrying on the work mentioned and his bid was
selected and was subsequently awarded the contract. The contract
agreement No. SECL/BSP/GM(E&M)/33KV Sub-stations (Balance work &
additional work) Dipka/Agt/05 dated 15/12/2019 was entered in between
both the parties for a total contract value of Rs.22,30,90,585.00/- (excluding
GST) or of Rs.26,32,46,890.30/- (including GST) with a contract period
amounting to about 2000 days i.e. 540 days for construction and 1460 days
for maintenance. The respondents further issued the LOI No. 618 (Letter of
Intent) to the applicant on 26/10/2018, in pursuance of that the applicant
submitted Bank Guarantee No. 00550100000721 dated 14/11/2011
amounting to Rs.1,31,62,345.00/-, and word order for the project was
issued on 03/12/2018, further the Site Handover Certificate was issued on
15/12/2018. The site was handed over and the project commenced on
15/12/2018 the applicant started executing the work having the construction
deadline of 07/06/2020 and maintenance deadline upto 06/06/2024.
However the project encountered substantial delays due to not supplying of
critical equipment (Transformers, VCB's and other essential items).
However, despite our continuous followups and communication, the required
equipment was not handed over to us in timely manner, which made it
impossible for us to adhere to the original contractual schedule. Due to not
providing of essential/critical equipment the applicant has suffered huge
financial loss on the account of loss of business due to abnormal delays in
clearing dues by the SECL, Idle Manpower Expenses, Retention amount
owing to about 5% of the original tender value, Additional expenses on
purchasing extra warranties, Bank Guarantee renewal charges, Escalation
of cost due to extension of time by SECL, etc. In order to resolve the above
mentioned issues the applicant issued a formal notice to the respondent SECL under Section 21 of Arbitration And Conciliation Act, 1996 on
19.07.2025 read with clause 42A of General Terms And Conditions of
Contract which are reproduced herein as under :"21. Commencement of arbitral proceedings.-Unless
otherwise agreed by the parties, the arbitral
proceedings in respect of a particular dispute
commence on the date on which a request for that
dispute to be referred to arbitration is received by the
respondent."
4. Clause 42A of General Terms and Conditions of Contract is as follows:42A. SETTLEMENT OF DISPUTES THROUGH ARBITRATION
"If the parties fail to resolve the disputes/differences by
in house mechanism, then, depending on the position of
thecase, either the employer/owner or the contractor
shall give notice to other party to refer the matter to
arbitration instead of directly approaching Court. The
contractor shall, however, be entitled to invoke
arbitration clause only after exhausting the remedy
available under the clause 42.”
5. In case of parties other than Gout, agencies, the redressal of
disputes/differences shall be sought through Sole Arbitration as under:“Sole Arbitration:
In the event of any question, dispute or difference arising under
these terms & conditions or any condition contained in this
contract or interpretation of the terms of, or in connection with this
Contract (except as to any matter the decision of which is
specially provided for by these conditions), the same shall be
referred to the sole arbitration of a person, appointed to be the
arbitrator by the Competent Authority of CIL / CMD of Subsidiary
Company (as the case may be). The award of the arbitrator shall
be final and binding on the parties of this Contract.
(a) In the event of the Arbitrator dying, neglecting or
refusing to act or resigning or being unable to act for any
reason, or his/her award being set aside by the court for
any reason, it shall be lawful for the Competent Authority of
CIL / CMD of Subsidiary Company (as the case may be) to
appoint another arbitrator in place of the outgoing arbitrator
in the manner aforesaid.
b) It is further a term of this contract that no person other
than the person appointed by the Competent Authority of
CIL /CMD of Subsidiary Company (as the case may be) as
aforesaid should act as arbitrator and that, if for any reason
that is not possible, the matter is not to be referred to
Arbitration at all.
Subject as aforesaid, Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996
as amended by Amendment Act of 2015, and the rules
thereunder and any statutory modification thereof for the time
being in force shall be deemed to apply to the Arbitration
proceedings under this clause.
The venue of arbitration shall be the place from which the
contract is issued or such other place as the Competent
Authority of CIL/ CMD of Subsidiary Company (as the case
may be) at his discretion may determine.”
6. Learned counsel for the applicant submits that the notice of the applicant
under Section 21 of Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 on 19.07.2025
was acknowledged by SECL vide letter dated 22.07.2025 and a suggestion
was given regarding the constitution of the committee to address and
resolve the disputes related to bona fide financial claims raised in our notice.
To which the applicant company communicated consent vide letter dated.
28/07/2025 reserving the right for the appointment of the arbitrator in event
of the failing of the committee to resolve the disputes. To attend the meeting
pertaining to resolving the disputes raised in notice under Section 21 by the
applicant to respondent, an authorization letter was sent by applicant on
26/08/2025 authorizing Mr. Amit Kumar and Mr. Masood Khan Site incharge (Electrical & Civil) to represent the applicant company and raise its
concerns on meeting to be held on 28/08/2025. Consequently a meeting
was organized between the authorized representatives of the applicant and
respondent company on 28/08/2025 and minutes of the meeting was
prepared where by which the respondent denied all the claims of the
applicant company. The respondent are proceeding in a prejudiced and
biased manner who are taking benefits of their own wrongs. The Critical
equipment necessary for execution of contract was never handed over to the
petitioner as per the contractual timelines yet are being subjected to baring
the extra costs and financial troubles. The General Condition of the contract
agreement clause 42 A provides for settlement of disputes through the
mechanism of Arbitration. The respondent SECL has failed to appoint
Arbitrator after sending of Notice under Section 21 for invocation of
arbitration on 19/07/2025 and more than 77 days have been elapsed
excluding the statutory mandate giving 30 days to from the date of the
receipt of notice under Section 21 of the act of 1996. He further submits that
it was the responsibility of the SECL to provide for the critical equipment and
SECL by not providing the same within stipulated period of time has
committed breach of contract. The SECL is solely responsible for delay in
completion of work. In support of his contentions, Mr. Mishra places reliance
on the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Demerara Distilleries
Private Limited and Another v. Demerara Distillers Limited, reported in
(2015) 13 SCC 610.
7. Ms. Sameeksha Gupta, learned Panel Lawyer appearing for the
respondents relying on the return filed on behalf of the respondents,
opposes the present arbitration request application, however she submits
that the respondents shall have no objection if this Court appoints any
Arbitrator for resolving the dispute between the parties.
8. Leanred counsel for the respondents produced a copy of the letter dated
16.07.2026, informing the Court that a meeting was held between the
applicant and the respondents on 10.07.2026, and that, at the request of the
applicant, 20.07.2026 has been fixed as the final opportunity for an amicable
and reasoned resolution of all pending issues.
9. Learned counsel for the applicant vehemently disputed the said submission.
10. I have heard learned counsel appearing for the parties, perused the
pleadings and documents appended thereto.
11. A query was put to learned counsel appearing for the parties as to whether
they are agreeable for a common name who can be appointed as Arbitrator,
learned counsel for the parties submitted that they would have no objection
if any retired Judge of this High Court is appointed as the Sole Arbitrator.
They further submit that Hon'ble Mr. Justice Arvind Kumar Verma, who is a
retired Judge of this High Court may be appointed as the Sole Arbitrator.
12. In view of the above consensus between the learned counsel for the parties,
Hon'ble Mr. Justice Arvind Kumar Verma, a retired Judge of this High
Court is appointed to act as the Sole Arbitrator to resolve the dispute
involved in this arbitration request between the parties.
13. The Registry is directed to communicate this order to Hon'ble Mr. Justice
Arvind Kumar Verma in the proper address.
14. The remuneration of the Arbitrator shall be settled with the mutual consent of
the parties.
15. The arbitration request petition, accordingly, stands allowed.
Sd/(Ramesh Sinha)
Chief Justice
Preeti
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review