Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3385 ]
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
IUONDAY, THE FIFTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE K. SUJANA
APPEAL SUIT
:734 0F 2008
Appeal Under Section 96 of C.P.C. aggrieved by the Decree and Judgment
dated 19-11-2007 in OS.No.116 of 1999 on the file of the Principal Senior Civil
Judge, Warangal.
Between:
1. tr/. Prabhavathi, D/o. Anantha Rao, Aged about 59 yrs, R/o. H.No. 16-101
6338, Shivanagar, Warangal.
2. Neelima, D/o. Ramanaiah, aged about 37 yrs, R/o. H.No. 16-10-1338,
Shivanagar, Warangal.
...Appellants/Defendants 1 & 3
AND
1. R. Pramodh Reddy, S/o. lndrasena Reddy, aged about 44 yrs, Occ: Business
R/o. Siddarthanagar, Kazipet, Warangal.
.. .Respondent No.1 /Plaintiff
2. D Srikar Shetty @ Srikar D. Shetty, S/o. D. Ramanaiah, aged about 39 yrs,
R/o. H.No. 16-10-1338, Shivanagar, Warangal.
(Appeal against Respondent No.2 is dismissed for default vide Court Order dt
25t4t2016)
... Respondent No.2/Defenda nt No.2
l.A. NO: 3 OF 2008(ASMP. NO: 1937 OF 2008)
Petition under Section 151 of CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to stay all
further proceedings in E.P. No. '183 of 2006 in O.S. No. 1 1 6 oI 2007 on the file of the
Principal Senior Civil Judge, Warangal, pending disposal of the above first appeal.
l.A. NO: 4 OF 2008(
P- NO:1988 OF 2008)
Petition under Section 151 of CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filerJ in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased suspend
the operation of the decree as made in O.S.No.116 of 1999 on the file of the
Principal Senior Civil Judge, Warangal dated 19 11.2OO7 in so far as the cancellation
of the Gift Settk;ment Deed (Ex.B-3) executed in favour of the 2nd petitioner by the
1st petitioner herein, pending disposal of the A.S.
l.A. NO: 2 OF 2009(
P. NO:2185 OF 2009)
Petition under Section 148 Riw Section 151 of CPC praying that in the
circumstances s;tated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court
may be pleased to extend the time for complying with the conditions stipulated in the
order dated 23-10-2009 in A.S.lVl.P.No 294 of 2009 in A S fU.P.No 1988 of 2008 in
A.S.No. 734 of i1008 by four weeks.
Counsel for ther Appellants: SRI V RAMCHANDER GOUD
Counsel for ther Respondent No.1: SRI M V RAMA RAO
The Court mad,a the following: JUDGMENT
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE K. SUJANA
APPEAL SUIT No.734 of 2OO8
Date: OS.OL.2o26
Between:
M.Prabhavathi,
And another.
PETITIONERS
R.Pramodh Reddy,
And another.
RESPONDENTS
JUDGMENT
This Appeal Suit is filed challenging the judgment and
decree dated 19.11.2007 made in O.S.No.116 of 1999 on the
file of the Principal Senior Civil Judge, Warangal.
2.
The appellants herein are defendant Nos.1 and 3,
respondent No.1 herein is plaintiff, and respondent No.2
herein is defendant No.2, in O.S.No.116 of 1999.
SKS,J
A.S.No.734 of 2OO8
For the sake of conrrenience, the parties herein are
referrec to as arrayed in suit.
3.
The brief facls of the case are thar the plaintiff
institut,:d the suit on 07.06.1999 against defendants I to 3
seeking recovery of Rs.3,70,0OO l- with future interest,
cancelleLtion of a gift deed executed by defendant No.l (D1) in
favour of defendant No.3 (D3), and a declaration that the said
deed is null and void. The plaintiff alleged that on O1.L0.1997,
clelendants 1 and 2 (Dl and D2) borroned Rs.3,7O,000/- and
executerl trvo promissory notes, one for Rs.2,OO,OO0/- and
another for Rs. L ,7O,OOO I , marked as Ex-A 12 and Ex-A 13, with
D2 as executant and D 1 signing as guarantor. The copies of
these notes were marked as Ex-A4 and Ex-AS respectively. To
dischargle the debt, D1 issued cheque dated 10.10.1998 for
Rs.3,7O,()OOl- in favour of the plaintiff (Bx-Al), which was
dishono'rred on 30.11.1998 with the bank endorsement "Part5/
reported to stop operation in the account and insufficient
funds" (Ex-A2). A torn bank slip evidencing the transaction
was marked as Ex-A3. The plaintiff issued a legal notice
demanding payment (Ex-A6) and also published a notice in
Vaartha Telugu Daily (Ex-A7). A complaint under Section 138
SKS,J
A.S.No.734 of 2008
of the Negotiable Instruments Act was filed and marked as
Ex-A10. The plaintiff relied on an agreement of sale dated
29.04.1998 executed by D2 for transfer of his computer
business (Ex-A1l), and a similar agreement by D1 (Ex-A15).
The original promissory notes were later received by the
plaintiff through postal cover from the USA, marked as
Ex-A 14.
4.
Dl, in her defence, denied liability and contended that
the cheque was issued to Ushodaya Finance, though no
evidence from the said entity was produced. She asserted that
the house was gifted to D3 through a registered settlement
deed dated 25.04.1998 (Ex-A9), the original of which was
marked as Ex-83. Dl also relied on the complaint filed by the
plaintiff (Ex-B1) and the deposition of PW1 in the criminal
case (Ex-B2). The plaintiff examined himself as PWl and one
attesting witness to the promissory notes, PW2 Indrasena
Reddy, who conlirmed execution and consideration. D 1 was
examined as DWl, while D2 and D3 were set ex parte.
5.
Upon evaluating the oral and documentary evidence,
the trial Court found that D t had indeed signed as guarantor
SKS,J
A.S.No.73-1 of 2008
on Ex-AL2 and Ex-A13, and issued Ex-Al cheque towards
discharge of the debt. The signatures on the cheque and
promis,sory. notes matched those on D 1's written statement
and vakalathnamas. The trial Court rejected the defence of
novation of contract and held that the suit was maintainable
for recovery of the amount. [t rvas further observed that the
gift deecl ([rx-A9/Ex-B3) was executecl with intenr to defraud
creditors and u,as liable to be cancelled. Accordingly, the suit
was der:reed in favour of the plaintiff. Aggrieved thereby, this
Appeal Suit is filed by the appellants who are defendant Nos.1
and 3 in the suit.
6.
Hearcl Sri V.Ramchander Goud, learned counsel for
appellants, and Sri MV. Rama Rao, learned counsel for
respondents.
7.
Le,arned counsel for the appellants submitted that the
impugnt:d judgment is contrary to law, unsupported by
evidence,, and based on conjectures, resulting in grave
injustice . He contended that the registered gift deed dated
25.04.1!)98 executed by appellant No.1 in favour of appellant
No.2 pr:ceded the alleged cheque dated 10.10.199g, and
SKS,J
A.S.No.734 of 2008
hence, the relief of cancellation of the gift 'deed was
unwarranted. He further contended that the trial Court erred
in decreeing the suit beyond the scope of recovery under the
promissory notes, despite having held that the suit was
maintainable only to that extent. He averred that the plaintiff
failed to establish passing of consideration under Exs.A 12 and
A13, and that there were material contradictions between the
oral testimony of PWl and his deposition in Ex.B2. He
divulged that the appellants denied execution of the
promissory notes and asserted that the transaction was
discharged through transfer of the computer business under
Ex.Al1, amounting to novation of contract. He averred that
the reliance of trial Court on signature comparison without
expert opinion was criticized as unjust, especially when
appellant No.1 was not the executant of the promissory notes.
He further averred that appellant No.2 was neither a party to
the transaction nor a guarantor, and her inclusion in the suit
was a case of misjoinder. The acquittal of appellant No.l in
C.C.No.275 of lggg under Section 13S of the Negotiable
Instruments Act, upheld in appeal, was cited to reinforce the
absence of liability. Therefore, he prayed this Court to allow
SKS,J
A.S.No.73-1 of 2OO8
the aplteal suit, setting aside the impugned judgment dated
19.1r .2'OO7.
8.
C,n the other hand, the learned counsel for respondents,
submitl.ed that the appeal filed by defendants 1 and 3 is
devoid of merit and the judgment and decree dated
19.11.2OO7 passed in O.S. No.116 of 1999 by the principal
Senior Civil Judge, Warangal, rightly decreed the suit for
recoverr/ of Rs.3,70,000/- with interest and cancelled the gift
deed executed by defendant No.1 in favour of defendant No.3.
He contended that the promissory notes dated 0i.10. l99T for
Rs.2,0O,0OOl- and Rs.\,7O,OOOl- (marked as Exs.A12 and A13)
were executed by defendant No.2 as borrower and signed by
defendant No.1 as guarantor, and that the cheque dated
1O.10.1')98 for Rs.3,7O,0OO/- (Ex.A1) issued by defendant
No.1 wa s dishonoured with the endorsement "party reported
to stop operation in account and insufficient funds" (Ex.A2),
clearly indicating intent to evade liability. He lamented that
the plea of novation of contract based on the alleged transfer
of computer business under Ex.Al1 was rightly rejected by
the trial court, as there was no evidence of possession or
delivery of the business to the plaintiff. He divulged that the
SKS,J
A.S.No.734 of 2008
trial Court correctly relied on signature comparison across
Ex.A 1, the written statement, and vakalatnamas, and found
the evidence of DW1 (defendant No.i) to be unreliable. The gift
cleed (Ex.B3) was found to be a device to defraud the plaintiff,
executed after the loan transaction and without any genuine
intent. The acquittal of defendant No.I in the criminal
complaint under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments
Act was argued to be irrelevant to the civil claim based on
promissory notes. Therefore, he prayed that the appeal be
dismissed and the decree be upheld.
9.
Having regard to the rival submissions made, and on
going through the material placed on record, the points
determined for consideration by this Court are:
I.
Whether the plaintiff is entitled for recovery of
Rs.3,70,OOO/- with future interest, if
So,
whether appellants herein are liable to pay the
same ?
il.
Wtrether there is any novation of contract ?
III. Whether the grft deed executed by Dl in
favour of D3 is on\r to avoid the payment to
plaintiff ?
SKS,J
A.S.No.734 of 2OO8
I'\/
Whether the judgment of trial Court requires
any interference of this Court ?
POINT Mos.I to IV:
1O. Having considered the rival submissions and upon
perusal of the record, this Court finds that the plaintiff has
not esttrblished his entitlement to recovery of Rs.3,7O,0OOlagainst the appellants. The suit was primarily based on two
promissory notes dated O1.10.1997, marked as Ex.AL2 and
Ex.A13, allegedly executed by defendant No.2 as borrower and
signed try defendant No.1 as guarantor. However, the originals
were nc,t produced contemporaneously with the plaint and
were later received through postal cover from the USA under
Ex.A14. It is contended by appellant herein that the trial
Court's reliance on signature comparison across Ex.A 1
cheque, written statement, and vakalatnamas without expert
opinion is unsafe, particularly when execution and
consideration were specifically denied. Further, defendant
No.l was only a guarantor and not the principal borrower,
and no independent evidence was adduced to prove her
liability. The dishonour of Ex.Al cheque, though proved by
SKS,J
A.S.No.734 of 2008
Ex.A2, cannot by itself establish the underlying debt when the
foundational consideration remains unproven
i.
On the issue of novation, the plaintiff himself relied on
Ex.A11 and Ex.A15, agreements of sale dated 29.O4.1998 for
transfer of the computer business of defendants, which were
executed prior to the cheque Ex.Ai. These agreements, along
with Ex.A13 and Ex.A14 notarized for Rs.5,5O,0OOl-, clearly
indicate that the parties contemplated a new arrangement in
substitution of the earlier promissory notes. Novation does not
require completed performance but requires intention to
substitute the old contract with a new one. The existence of
these agreements demonstrates that the original promissory
notes were not intended to remain enforceable. That being so,
it can be held that the trial Court erred in rejecting the plea of
novation merely on the ground that delivery of business was
not proved, without appreciating the intention behind the
agreements.
12. With respect to the gift deed dated 25.O4.1998
(Ex.A9/Ex.B3) executed by defendant No.1 in favour of
defendant No.3, it is evident that the said deed preceded the
SKS,J
A.S.No.734 of 2008
cheque dated 10.10.1998. There is no evidence to show that
the alleged loan rv\ras secured on the suit property or that the
plaintifl had any agreement creating a mortgage or charge
over the property. In the absence of such securigr
arrangement, the Court cannot cancel a voluntary transfer
merely on the basis of an unsecured debt. Defendant No.3 was
neither a part1, to the borrovi,ing nor a guarantor, and her
inclusion in the suit ',r,as a clear case of misjoinder. The trial
Court's finding that the gift deed was executed to defraud
creditors is unsustainable in law and fact.
13. [n view thereof, this Court holds that the plaintiff failed
to prove, the debt under Ex.Al2 and Ex.A13, that there was
novation of contract through Ex.A11 and Ex.A15, and that the
gift deecl Ex.A9lEx.B3 cannot be cancelled in the absence of
any mortgage or security interest. The trial Court committed
errors in appreciating the evidence and in granting relief
beyond the scope of the suit. Therefore, these points are
answereC.
L4. Accordingly, this Appeal Suit is allowed, setting aside
the imlrugned judgment dated 19.11 .2OOT passed in
SKS.J
A.S.No.734 of 200ti
o.S.No.116 of 1999 on the file of the principal Senior civil
.Itrdge, Warangal. There shall be no order as to costs.
IVliscellanc-'<>rrs applications, if' any pcnding, shall also
sLancl closcd
SD/. A.V.S.S.C.S.M.SARMA
JOINT REGISTRAR
l
Note: This Judgment is amended as per Court
Order dated 28.01 .2026 made ip lA No.2 of
2026 in A.S.NO.734 of 2008 to the effect in the
Judgement dated 05.01 .2026 irr A.S.NO.734 of
2008 in paragraph Nos.1 ,2 & 14 "O.S.No.119 of
1999" is replaced with O.S.NO.l16 of 1999" and
also header portion in all pages is replaced with
"A.S.No.734 of 2008 " instead of "Crlp No.734 of
2008".
SD/- A.V.S.S.C.S.M.SARMA
JOINT REGISTRAR
i/TRUE COPY//
SECTION OFFICER
To,
The Principal Senior Civil Judge, Warangal.
One CC to Sri V Ramchander Goud, Advocate [OPUC]
One CC to Sri lV'l V Rama Rao, Advocate [OPUC]
one
to Registrar Judicial-ll, High court for the State of relangana, at
Hyderabad
one cc to VR section, High court for the state of relangana, at Hyderabad
Two CD Copies
cc
ABK /PSL
Y(
HIGH COURT
DATED: 05101112026
zglotl wt
v $TF,. TF
q
i)
,"J
fiL(ENEEOJUDGMENT
AS.No.734 ot 20O8
ALLOWING THE APPEAL SUIT
WITHOUT COS].S
B
.e{"lt
&,
Z
10 urH ?s6
iJ
*
*
or:;i-
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
MONDAY, THE FIFTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE K. SUJANA
APPEAL SUIT NO: 734 OF 2008
Between:
1. lV. Prabhavathi, D/o. Anantha Rao, Aged about 59 yrs, R/o. H.No. 16-101
6338, Shivanagar, Warangal.
2. Neelima, D/o. Ramanaiah, aged about 37 yrs, R/o. H.No. 16-10-1338,
Shivanagar, Warangal.
...Appellants/Defendants 1 & 3
AND
1. R. Pramodh Reddy, S/o. lndrasena Reddy, aged about 44yrs, Occ: Business
R/o. Siddarthanagar, Kazipet, Warangal.
...Respondent No.1 /Plaintiff
2 D. Srikar Shetty @ Srikar D. Shetty, S/o. D. Ramanaiah, aged about 39 yrs,
R/o. H.No. 16-10-1338, Shivanagar, Warangal.
(Appeal against Respondent No.2 is dismissed for default vide Court Order dt
2st4t2016)
...Respondent No.2/Defendant No.2
Appeal Under Section 96 of C.P.C. aggrieved by the Decree and Judgment
dated 19-11-2007 in O.S.No.116 of 1999 on the file of the Principal Senior Civil
Judge, Warangal.
This appeal coming on for hearing and upon perusing the grounds of appeal,
the Judgment and Decree of the Court below and the material papers and upon
hearing the arguments of Sri V Ramchander Goud, Advocate for the Appellants and
of Sri M V Rama Rao, Advocate for the Respondent No.1.
This Court doth Order and Decree as follows
1. That the Appeal Suit be and the same is hereby allowed by setting aside the
Judgment and decree passed by the Principal Senior Civil Judge, Warangal.
That thrlre sha ll be no order as to costs
in this appeal
SD/- A.V.S.S.C.S.M.SARMA
JOINT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPYII
To,
ON OFFICER
1. The prinr;ipal Senior Civil Judge,
Warangal.
2'
Registrai luoi.ll rr Hish
6;urt for the state of reransana,
ff;",-:8,,:"
i ?ff 33 li"X[.t"ttion' Hish court ror the stare or reransana, at Hyderabad
z\[]K ,psl
Yy
at
I
E-;
I
F
I
I
HIGH COURT
I
I
DATED: 05/01 i2O26
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
DECREE
AS.No.734 of 2008
ALLOWING 'iHE APPEAL SUIT
WITHOUT COSTS
G d(a
Xft;
.:
,, ,j] J-
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review