Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:MHC:937
WP(MD) No. 8435 of 2013
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATED: 10-02-2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE DR.JUSTICE ANITA SUMANTH
AND
THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE MUMMINENI SUDHEER KUMAR
WP(MD) No. 8435 of 2013
AND
WMP(MD) Nos. 1, 2 and 3 OF 2013
M.Ponniah
..Petitioner(s)
Vs
1. The Chief Secretary to Government,
Government of Tamil Nadu, Secretariat Chennai.
2. The Secretary to Government
Government of Tamilnadu, Public (Special A )
Department, Secretariat, Chennai.
3. The Registrar General,
Madras High Court, Chennai- 600 104.
Prayer:
..Respondent(s)
Writ Petition filed under article 226 of Constitution of India for
issuance of writ of Certiorarified Mandamus calling for the records relating to
the impugned notification issued by the 2 nd Respondent on 01.05.2013, inviting
application for direct recruitment and appointment for the post of District
Judges (Entry level) and quash the same as illegal and consequently direct the
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP(MD) No. 8435 of 2013
2nd Respondent herein to issue fresh notification in transparent manner
indicating the number of vacancies ear-marked for physically challenged
persons by providing 3% reservation for the post of District Judges (Entry
Level) in accordance with Section 33 of the Persons with Disabilities (Equal
Opportunities, Protection of rights and full participation) Act 1995.
For Petitioner(s):
Mr.NambiAarooran
for M/s. S.Ajmal Associates
For Respondent(s):
Mr.P.Anandakumar
Government Advocate (for R1 & R2)
Mr.P.K.Rajagopal (for R3)
ORDER
(Order of the Court was made by Dr.Anita Sumanth J.)
The petitioner is affected by Polio from the hip downwards, and suffers
from locomotive disability. He had been a petitioner in W.P.(MD)No.1691 of
2011, where the challenge had been to G.O.Ms.No.16 Public (Special.A)
Department dated 05.01.2011 on the ground that no reservation had been
provided for the category of Persons with Disability (PwD). The petitioner had
therein, sought a consequential direction for his appointment as District Judge
(Entry level).
2. That Writ Petition had been taken up along with other Writ Petitions
culminating in decision dated 11.03.2011, wherein the Division Bench, after
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP(MD) No. 8435 of 2013
hearing the rival contentions advanced, was of the opinion that they had to
strike a balance in the situation. They took note of the Constitutional mandate
for provision of reservation for PwD, noting simultaneously that the State
Government had not identified the posts meant for reservation. In the ultimate
analysis, they were of the view that it was not an appropriate case to disturb the
selection of judges already made.
3. The Writ Petitions were thus dismissed making it clear that there shall
be a provision for reservation of PwD in fulfillment of the constitutional
mandate in the immediate next vacancy of District Judges subject to availability
and suitability of the candidate. In the present Writ Petition, the challenge is to
Notification dated 01.05.2013 along lines similar to the earlier Writ Petition, on
the ground of no reservation having been provided for the category of PwD.
4. Mr.Nambi Aarooran, learned counsel who appears for the petitioner
reiterates the relevant events leading to the institution of the earlier writ petition,
stating that Notification dated 24.06.2010 had been issued calling for
applications for appointment of 17 District Judges.
5. The petitioner had been aggrieved by the fact that there was no
reservation provided for PwD as mandated under the Persons with Disabilities
(Equal Opportunities, Protection of rights and full participation) Act 1995 (1995
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP(MD) No. 8435 of 2013
Act), that provides for reservation of 3% to be provided for the category of
PwD, and the State Rules.
6. The petitioner had participated in the process of selection, albeit
unsuccessfully. He challenged his non-selection along with other unsuccessful
candidates, and the Writ Petition had been dismissed, this Court directing R3 in
conclusion, to ensure proper representation of persons in PwD category in the
next selection.
7. The present Writ Petition assails the selection of District Judges (Entry
level) pursuant to Notification dated 01.05.2013 (2013 Notification). The
petitioner had applied for, and participated in the process of selection
unsuccessfully, aggrieved by which, he has challenged the 2013 Notification
and the selection process, on the ground that the selection had not been made in
a transparent manner and was in violation of the constitutional mandate of
providing opportunity for physically challenged persons in employment.
8. Mr.P.K.Rajagopal, learned counsel for the 3rd respondent, i.e., the
Registrar General, High Court, would first argue that much water has flown
under the bridge since the date of the impugned Notification. The process of
selection was complete in 2014 and the appointees have been in service
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP(MD) No. 8435 of 2013
thereafter. Their services are without blemish and their position cannot be
disturbed now.
9. While acceding to the position that 3% reservation has been earmarked for PwD under the 1995 Act, Mr.Rajagopal draws our attention to
Section 32(a) of the 2016 Act that requires identification of the post in which
reservation is to be provided. Referring to the Tamil Nadu State Judicial Service
(Cadre and Recruitment) Rules, 2007 (in short ‘Rules’), he points to Rule 10,
that provides for reservation in appointments. The Rule, at it stood at the
relevant point in time, identified only the post of Civil Judge (Junior Division)
as being eligible for reservation.
10. Thus, according to him, it is only upon identification of the post by
the State that the benefit of reservation would be provided for the post
identified. As a result, though Rules 21(b) and 22 of the General Rules for
Tamil Nadu State and Subordinate Services provide for reservation both for the
posts of District Judge (Entry Level) and Civil Judge (Junior Division), only a
Civil Judge (Junior Division) has been selected for the benefit of reservation
under the category of PwD.
11. It was only in 2023 that Rule 10 had been amended, by virtue of
which the benefit of reservation under the category of PwD was extended to
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP(MD) No. 8435 of 2013
District Judge (Entry level) as well. Hence, according to him, there was no error
in the non-selection of the petitioner, as the Rule position did not permit such
selection. He relies on various judgements that we shall advert to presently.
12. We have heard both learned counsel and perused the case law cited.
13. The petitioner was affected with Polio and has a locomotive disability
rendering him immobile from the hip downwards. He had instituted
W.P.No.1691 of 2011 challenging G.O.Ms.No.16 dated 05.01.2011 that had
been issued for selection of District Judges (Entry level) without providing for
reservation for the physically challenged. The eligibility criteria was 7 years of
practice. The distribution of vacancies was as follows:
General Turn
Scheduled Caste (Arunthathiyars
on Preferential basis)
Most Backward Classes and Denotified
Communities
Backward Classes (other than
Backward Class Muslims)
Scheduled Caste
Backward Class Muslim
4 (1 Woman)
1 (1 Woman)
4 (1 Woman)
4(1 woman)
3 (1 Woman)
1(1 Woman)
-----17
14. There was no reservation provided for the category of PwD and the
Petitioner and four others challenged the same as being a violation of their
fundamental right to employment. The Writ Petition came to be dismissed in
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP(MD) No. 8435 of 2013
P.Senthil Kumaran and others v. The Registrar General and others 1 by order
dated 11.03.2011, the Court making it clear that in the immediate next
recruitment, available vacancies shall be filled in by an appropriate candidate in
the category of PwD.
15. The present Writ Petition, WP(MD) No. 8435 of 2013, assails the
selection of District Judges (Entry level) pursuant to Notification dated
01.05.2013. The distribution of seats under this Notification is as follows:
Backward Classes (Other than Backward
Class Muslims)
General Turn
Scheduled Castes
Most Backward Classes and
Denotified Communities
Scheduled Castes (Arunthathiyars
on preferential basis)
Backward Class Muslims
Total
(women-2)
(women-4)
(women-1)
(women-1)
(women-1)
-----23
16. The Petitioner had applied and gone through the process of selection.
He was not selected, aggrieved by which, he has challenged the 2013
Notification on the ground that the selection was not made in a transparent
manner and was in violation of the Constitutional mandate of providing equal
opportunity for physically challenged persons in employment.
(W.P.No.3087 of 2011 etc. batch dated 11.03.2011)
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP(MD) No. 8435 of 2013
17. The defence of the respondents rests upon Sections 33 and 34 of the
2016 Act that provides for identification of posts for reservation. According to
them, Rule 10 of the Rules had, at the relevant point in time, identified only the
post of Civil Judge for reservation and it was only in 2023 that the post of
District Judge (Entry level) had been identified. Hence there was no avenue
available to have provided for the reservation sought for by the petitioner in the
2013 Notification.
18. Before us, the Petitioner only contests the issue of reservation and
does not advert to the mode and manner of selection or the alleged opaqueness
in such selection. Hence, we restrict ourselves solely to the legal issue
concerning the provision of reservation for the category of PwD. This issue has
been the subject matter of several decisions and we chronicle below relevant
cases dealt with by the Supreme Court and the High Courts, cited by the parties.
19. In Kunal Singh v. Union of India and another2 (2003) the Supreme
Court, adumbrating the statutory provisions of the Act, noted the salutary object
for which the 1995 Act had been enacted, and emphasized the necessity for
proper implementation of the provisions and the reservation provided
thereunder.
2003 (4) SCC 524
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP(MD) No. 8435 of 2013
20. In Government of India through Secretary and another Vs. Ravi
Prakash Gupta and another3 (2010), the aspirant was visually handicapped and
the handicap was 100%. Though he had cleared the preliminary and main
examinations, and was at serial number five of the merit list prepared for
visually handicapped persons, since there was only one vacancy in that
category, he was not appointed. The questions that were formulated for
resolution were as follows:
(a) whether on account of the failure of the petitioner to
identify posts for persons falling within ambit of Section 33 of the
Disabilities Act, 1995, the first respondent namely, Mr.Ravi
Prakash Gupta should be deprived of the benefit of his selection
purportedly on the ground that there were no available vacancies
in the said category?
(b) whether the reservation provided for in Section 33 of the
Disabilities Act, 1995, was dependent on identification of posts
suitable for appointment in such categories, as has been sought to
be contended on behalf of the Government of India in the instant
case?
21. The answer to the questions were in the following terms:
“27.It is only logical that, as provided in Section 32 of
the aforesaid Act, posts have to be identified for reservation
for the purposes of Section 33, but such identification was
meant to be simultaneously undertaken with the coming into
operation of the Act, to give effect to the provisions of
Section 33. The legislature never intended the provisions of
Section 32 of the Act to be used as a tool to deny the benefits
of Section 33 to these categories of disabled persons indicted
therein. Such a submission strikes at the foundation of the
(2010) 7 SCC 626
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP(MD) No. 8435 of 2013
provisions relating to the duty cast upon the appropriate
Government to make appointments in every establishment
(emphasis added).
29. While it cannot be denied that unless posts are
identified for the purposes of Section 33 of the aforesaid Act,
no appointments from the reserved categories contained
therein can be made, and that to such extent the provisions
of Section 33 are dependent on Section 32 of the Act, as
submitted by the learned ASG, but the extent of such
dependence would be for the purpose of making
appointments and not for the purpose of making reservation.
In other words, reservation under Section 33 of the Act is
not dependent on identification, as urged on behalf of the
Union of India, though a duty has been cast upon the
appropriate Government to make appointments in the
number of posts reserved for the three categories mentioned
in Section 33 of the Act in respect of persons suffering from
the disabilities spelt out therein. In fact, a situation has also
been noticed where on account of non-availability of
candidates some of the reserved posts could remain vacant
in a given year. For meeting such eventualities, provision
was made to carry forward such vacancies for two years
after which they would lapse. Since in the instant case such
a situation did not arise and posts were not reserved under
Section 33 of the Disabilities Act, 1995, the question of
carrying forward of vacancies or lapse thereof, does not
arise.”
22. In K.Appadurai v. Secretary to Government, Public (Special.A)
Department and others4 (2010) a batch of writ petitions challenging Notification
dated 01.07.2010 calling for applications for the post of District Judge (Entry
Level) on various grounds had been heard. In W.P.No.16383 of 2010 and W.P.
(MD) No.9119 of 2010, the challenge was on the specific ground that the
number of vacancies earmarked for disabled candidates was not indicated in the
2010 (5) CTC 1
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP(MD) No. 8435 of 2013
Notification. It had hence been contended that the Notification was liable to be
withdrawn.
23. The defence of the respondents was that the reservation in recruitment
in respect of PwD was governed by G.O.Ms.No.87 dated 17.07.2008. That G.O.
provided that a 200 point roster would be divided into 6 classifications and an
equal ratio of 1:1:1 would be provided for the three categories of blindness,
deafness and orthopaedically challenged.
24. Hence, the authority intended to ensure 3% reservation by appointing
one individual belonging to each category in each of the six blocks in the 200
point Communal Roster. They contended that reservation for differently abled
persons comes under horizontal reservation and hence the accommodation
would be to a person who had qualified on merit who would be absorbed under
his respective communal quota.
25. The Registrar General of this Court towed the same line. This stand
was accepted by the Court that held that, in light of the aforesaid G.O., there
was nothing to indicate that the stipulation therein would not be followed by the
appointing authority at the time of appointment. The Writ Petitions thus came
to be dismissed.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP(MD) No. 8435 of 2013
26. In the case of P.Senthil Kumaran5(2011), where this petitioner was
also a party, the challenge was to a Notification of the year 2010. The Court
took cognizance of the position that the appointees were in office, and was not
inclined to disturb them. However, they were equally clear that the nonprovision of the reservation for candidates with PwD constituted a violation of
the constitutional mandate. In fine, they say,
24. In such view of the matter, looking into any angle, we are of
the firm view that the contentions raised by the petitioners and
their respective counsel are not tenable and the writ petitions fail
and the same are dismissed. However, we make it clear that
inasmuch as providing appointment to physically challenged
person is a constitutional mandate and all directive principles
are in tune with the fundamental rights, in the event of any
vacancy arising out of 17 appointments, or otherwise in the
immediate next vacancy of the District Judges (Entry Level), the
same shall be filled up by a person with disability by fulfilling the
constitutional mandate, of course, subject to the availability of
the candidates and the suitability therefor. No costs. Connected
miscellaneous petitions are closed.
27. There is thus a positive direction to the Registrar General to make
good the error that had occasioned in the 2010 Notification by providing
reservation in the category of PwD in the next ensuing recruitment.
28. In T.M.N.Deepak V. State of Tamil Nadu6 (2011), Public Interest
Litigation had been initiated before the Madras High Court praying for
Foot Note Supra (1)
2011 (2) CTC 353
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP(MD) No. 8435 of 2013
appropriate directions to ensure 3% reservation for persons with disabilities.
Again, the argument of identification of posts was taken. The Tamil Nadu
Public Service Commission cited G.O.Ms.No.105 dated 20.06.2000 and
G.O.Ms.No.53 dated 11.04.2005, that 3% reservation had been specifically
provided for under the former, and a list of 117 posts had been identified under
Group A and B categories under the purview of Teachers Recruitment Board
and Tamil Nadu Public Service Commission as suitable for persons with
disabilities, in the latter.
29. Consequently, there was a direction to carve out 3% reservation in the
posts as identified, and at paragraph 17, the High Court issued the following
directions:
“17.Further, the Government should also explore the
possibility and arranging recruitment of the differently abled
persons in Government companies and public sector undertakings
and regular recruitment drives could be conducted, where the
Government companies and public sector undertakings should be
directed to participate. Likewise the Government shall also explore
for organizing special recruitment drive for the differently abled in
association with Corporate sector on a regular basis at frequent
intervals, so that there is a wider spectrum of the job opportunities
available to such persons. Immediate steps shall be taken to clear
the backlog vacancies and the Government should ensure that the
rule of reservation of 3% shall be adhere to strictly in accordance
with Section 27 33 of the Act and as stated in the report submitted
by the State Commissioner for disabled to give full and effective
implementation to the provisions of the Act.”
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP(MD) No. 8435 of 2013
30. The defence of the Respondent in the present case is premised on
Section 33(a) of the 1995 Act, and the fact that the post of District Judge (Entry
level) had not been identified for the purpose of reservation. This very defence
had been considered and rejected by the Supreme Court in Union of India and
another V. National Federation of the Blind and others7(2013).
31. The Supreme Court in the judgment in National Federation of the
Blind8 (2013) has specifically deprecated the attempt to truncate reservation
under PwD category and have cautioned against abusing the language of
Section 32 which provides for ‘identification’, as a tool to exclude persons with
disabilities from their constitutional and fundamental right to reservation in
employment.
32. Three Hon’ble Judges of the Supreme Court in the case of National
Federation of the Blind9 record the history by which equal opportunity was
sought to be extended to persons with disability from 1977 onwards when the
first attempt of reservation had been made in favour of three categories of
persons in Group C and D posts i.e., those with visual impairment, hearing and
speech impairment, and persons with locomotor disability.
(2013) 10 SCC 772
Foot Note Supra (7)
Foot Note Supra (7)
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP(MD) No. 8435 of 2013
33.
Referring to the 1995 Act, the Bench issued directions to the
Governments to compute the number of vacancies available in all
establishments, identify posts for differently abled persons and implement their
order within three months from the date of that judgment without default.
34. Coming down strongly upon all Departments, Public Sector
Undertakings and Government Companies, the Court declared that the nonobservance of the scheme of reservation for persons with disabilities should be
considered as an act of non-obedience and the Nodal Officer in the concerned
Department/organisation, who was fastened with the responsibility for proper
and strict implementation of the Reservation Policy, should be departmentally
proceeded with, in the event of default.
35. We extract relevant portions of the judgment in National Federation
of the Blind10 below:
“27.It is only logical that, as provided in Section 32
of the aforesaid Act, posts have to be identified for
reservation for the purposes of Section 33, but such
identification was meant to be simultaneously undertaken
with the coming into operation of the Act, to give effect to
the provisions of Section 33. The legislature never intended
the provisions of Section 32 of the Act to be used as a tool to
deny the benefits of Section 33 to these categories of
disabled persons indicted therein. Such a submission strikes
at the foundation of the provisions relating to the duty cast
Foot Note Supra (7)
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP(MD) No. 8435 of 2013
upon the appropriate Government to make appointments in
every establishment (emphasis added).
29. While it cannot be denied that unless posts are
identified for the purposes of Section 33 of the aforesaid Act,
no appointments from the reserved categories contained
therein can be made, and that to such extent the provisions
of Section 33 are dependent on Section 32 of the Act, as
submitted by the learned ASG, but the extent of such
dependence would be for the purpose of making
appointments and not for the purpose of making reservation.
In other words, reservation under Section 33 of the Act is
not dependent on identification, as urged on behalf of the
Union of India, though a duty has been cast upon the
appropriate Government to make appointments in the
number of posts reserved for the three categories mentioned
in Section 33 of the Act in respect of persons suffering from
the disabilities spelt out therein. In fact, a situation has also
been noticed where on account of non-availability of
candidates some of the reserved posts could remain vacant
in a given year. For meeting such eventualities, provision
was made to carry forward such vacancies for two years
after which they would lapse. Since in the instant case such
a situation did not arise and posts were not reserved under
Section 33 of the Disabilities Act, 1995, the question of
carrying forward of vacancies or lapse thereof, does not
arise.”
36. In V.Surendra Mohan v. State of Tamil Nadu and two Ors. 11, (2015)
too, the question related to reservation for persons with disabilities, but the
disability was one of total blindness and hearing impairment. The Writ Petition
was dismissed and the matter travelled to Supreme Court, which confirmed 12 the
said dismissal.
W.P.No.10582 of 2015 dated 05.06.2015
Civil Appeal No.83 of 2019 arising out of SLP(Civil).No.17223 of 2015) dated 22.01.2019
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP(MD) No. 8435 of 2013
37. The High Court had advertised that the range of disability would be
40 to 50% and on a challenge to that criteria, both the High Court and Supreme
Court felt that the prescription of 40 to 50% was reasonable and did not violate
any statutory provision.
38. The Court noted that a judicial officer had to possess reasonable
faculties of hearing, sight and speech in order to effectively discharge the roles
of a Civil Judge. Hence, they felt that stipulating a limit of 50% disability as a
condition of eligibility to the post of a Judge in judicial service is a legitimate
restriction that was fair, logical and reasonable. Taking note of the functions and
duties performed by the Civil Judge, the Court upheld the order of the High
Court in that matter.
39. In Thanggakolanchinathan v. The Registrar General, High Court of
Madras and 2 others13(2016) case, the challenge was to the 2013 Notification
on the ground that the petitioner who was physically challenged was denied
equal opportunity for such recruitment. The argument now advanced before us,
that the State has to identify the post under Section 32(a) of the 1995 Act, and it
is only those identified posts in which reservation can be accorded, was made in
that case as well.
W.P.No.17998 of 2013 dated 24.06.2016
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP(MD) No. 8435 of 2013
40. The Court took note of several judgments of the Supreme Court on
this point, ultimately dismissing the Writ Petition subject to certain observations
made in paragraph 48 of the decision. We extract below paragraph 48 of that
judgement:
48.Therefore, for all the above reasons, considering the spirit
and purport of the Disabilities Act coupled with the judgment
rendered by the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India reported in (2013)
10 Supreme Court Cases 772 cited supra, we are of the considered
view that High Court on its administrative side, is to take a final
call/ respond to the clarification sought for by the State Government
as to the eligibility/ minimum standards of physical disablement and
with reference to the hearing and orthopaedic fitness which are
required for the efficient discharge of the duties of the posts in the
Tamil Nadu State Judicial Service (Cadre and Recruitment) Rules,
2007, as expeditiously as possible before the next recruitment to the
posts of Civil Judge and District Judge (Entry Level).
41. The Court had expressed the view that it is for the Court on its
administrative side to take a final call as to what the eligibility or minimum
standard of physical disablement would be with reference to hearing and
orthopaedic fitness to ensure efficient discharge of the duties of Judges under
the Tamil Nadu State Judicial Service (Cadre and Recruitment) Rules, 2007.
Realizing the urgency of the matter, the Bench states that such a decision must
be taken before the next recruitment to the post of Civil Judge and District
Judge (Entry Level).
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP(MD) No. 8435 of 2013
42. The specific question that had been framed by the Supreme Court in
National Federation of Blind and others14 as to ‘whether the reservation
provided for the disabled persons under Section 33 of the Act, is dependent
upon the identification of posts as stipulated by Section 32’ had been noted by
this Court in the case of Thanggakolanchinathan15 and we extract their
conclusions hereunder.
“31.In the light of the above 28 pronouncement, it is clear
that the scope of identification comes into picture only at the time
of appointment of a person in the post identified for disabled
persons and is not necessarily relevant at the time of computing
3% reservation under Section 33 of the Act. In succinct, it was
held in Ravi Prakash Gupta that Section 32 of the Act is not a
precondition for computation of reservation of 3% under Section
33 of the Act rather Section 32 is the following effect of Section
33.
32.Apart from the reasoning of this Court in Ravi Prakash
Gupta, even a reading of Section 33, at the outset, establishes
vividly the intention of the legislature viz. reservation of 3% for
differently abled persons should have to be computed on the basis
of total vacancies in the strength of a cadre and not just on the
basis of the vacancies available in the identified posts. There is no
ambiguity in the language of Section 33 and from the construction
of the said statutory provision only one meaning is possible.
33.A perusal of Section 33 of the Act reveals that this
section has been divided into three parts:
33.1.The first part is:
“33.Reservation of posts.-Every appropriate
Government shall appoint in every establishment such
Foot Note Supra (7)
Foot Note Supra (13)
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP(MD) No. 8435 of 2013
percentage of vacancies not less than 3% for persons
with disability.....”
It is evident from this part that it mandates every
appropriate Government shall appoint a minimum of 3%
vacancies in its establishments for persons with disabilities. In this
light, the contention of the Union of India that reservation in
terms of Section 33 has to be computed against identified posts
only is not tenable by any method of interpretation of this part of
the section.
33.2.The second part of this section starts as follows:
“... of which one per cent each shall be reserved for persons
suffering from(i)blindness or low vision;
(ii)hearing impairment; and
(iii)locomotor disability or cerebral palsy,
in the posts identified for each disability:”
From the above, it is clear that it deals with distribution of
3% posts in every establishment among 3 categories of
disabilities. It starts from the word “of which”. The word “of
which” has to relate to appointing not less than 3% vacancies in
an establishment and, in any way, it does not refer to the identified
posts. In fact, the contention of the Union of India is sought to be
justified by bringing the last portion of the second part of the
section viz. “... identified posts” in this very first part which deals
with the statutory obligation imposed upon the appropriate
Government to “appoint not less than 3% vacancies for the
persons or class of persons with disabilities”. In out considered
view, it is not plausible in the light of established rules of
interpretation. The minimum level of representation of persons
with disabilities has been provided in this very first part and the
second part deals with the distribution of this 3% among the three
categories of disabilities. Further, in the last portion of the second
part the words used are “in the identified posts for each
disability” and not “of identified posts”. This can only mean that
out of minimum 3% of vacancies of posts in the establishments 1%
each has to be given to each of the 3 categories of disability viz.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP(MD) No. 8435 of 2013
Blind and low vision, hearing impaired and locomotor disabled or
cerebral palsy separately and the number of appointments
equivalent to the 1% for each disability out of total 3% has to be
made against the vacancies in the identified posts. The attempt to
read identified posts in the first part itself and also to read the
same to have any relation with the computation of reservation is
completely misconceived.
33.3.The third part of the section is the proviso which reads
thus:
“Provided that the appropriate Government may, having
regard to the type of work carried on in any department or
establishment, by notification subject to such conditions, if any, as
may be specified in such notification, exempt any establishment
from the provisions of this section.”
The proviso also justifies the abovesaid interpretation that
the computation of reservation has to be against the total number
of vacancies in the cadre strength and not against the identified
posts. Had the legislature intended to mandate for computation of
reservation against the identified posts only, there was no need for
inserting the proviso to section which empowers the appropriate
Government to exempt any establishment either partly or fully
from the purview of the section subject to such conditions
contained in the notification to be issued in the Official Gazette in
this behalf. Certainly, the legislature did not intend to give such
arbitrary power for exemption from reservation for persons with
disabilities to be exercised by the appropriate Government when
the computation is intended to be made against the identified
posts.”
43. Having noted all these points, the Court dismissed the Writ Petition
on the basis that Rule 10 of the Tamil Nadu State Judicial Service (Cadre and
Recruitment) Rules, 2007 had not been put to challenge.
44. In light of the discussion as above, we are left in no doubt that the
observations, conclusions and directions in the case of National Federation of
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP(MD) No. 8435 of 2013
the Blind16, of 2013 vintage, are liable to be implemented in full. The position as
on date, is thus that the requirement of ‘identification’ of post, would, and
should not serve as a means by which the benefit of reservation could be
delayed, denied or even restricted. R3 has clearly taken undue advantage of
Section 33 that provides for identification of posts for reservation and reads as
follows:
33.Identification of posts for reservation.- The appropriate
Government shall –
i) identify posts in the establishments which can be held
by respective category of persons with benchmark
disabilities in respect of the vacancies reserved in
accordance with the provisions of section 34;
ii) constitute an expert committee with representation of
persons with benchmark disabilities for identification of
such posts; and
iii) undertake periodic review of the identified posts at an
interval not exceeding three years.
45. It is true that in 2010, Rule 10 dealing with Reservation of
Appointments, extracted below, provided for, or rather, identified only the post
of Civil Judge (Junior Division) for the benefit of reservation in PwD category.
The Rule, as it stood then, reads as follows:
10. Reservation of Appointments.— Rules 21(b) and 22 of the
General Rules for the Tamil Nadu State and Subordinate
Service relating to reservation of appointment shall apply to
the selection for appointment to the posts of District Judge
Foot Note Supra (7)
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP(MD) No. 8435 of 2013
(Entry Level) and Civil Judge (Junior Division) by direct
recruitment
(2) Candidates with the following disabilities, namely,
blind deaf/orthopaedically handicapped can seek for
recruitment for the post of Civil Judge (Junior Division):
(I) 3 percent of the vacancies in the post of Civil Judge
(Junior Division) in direct recruitment has to be filled by
physically
handicapped,
namely,
blind
deaf/orthopaedically handicapped. In the event of only
one vacancy, the rule of reservation for physically
handicapped shall not apply:
Provided that the candidate must produce a certificate
from the Medical Board to the effect that the disability will not
affect the performance of the Job, namely Civil Judge (Junior
Division) before appointment.
46. It is only in 2023 that Rule 10 was amended to include District Judge
(Entry level) for reservation for PwD category. However, in light of the law laid
down in the case of National Federation of the Blind17, it is no longer open to
the respondents to adopt selective identification of posts, thereby limiting the
constitutional mandate for reservation.
47. Learned counsel appearing for the respondents really have no
defence, or any scientific basis to justify the exclusion of District Judge (Entry
level) from the ambit of PwD reservation till 2023. The fact that Rule 10 was
amended only in 2023 thus does not support or advance the case of the
Respondents as necessary action in this regard ought to have been taken by the
Foot Note Supra (7)
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP(MD) No. 8435 of 2013
Respondents in a timely fashion, post the pronouncement of the Supreme Court
in 2013. There is no explanation for the delay of 10 years in bring the Rules upto-speed with the Constitutional mandate.
48. The Supreme Court in the judgment in National Federation of the
Blind18 has specifically deprecated the attempt to truncate reservation under
PwD category and have cautioned against abusing the language of Section 33
which provides for identification, as a tool to exclude persons with disabilities
from their constitutional and fundamental right to reservation.
49. The position today, is thus unambiguous to the effect that the
reservation provided in the category of PwD is to be strictly implemented across
the board and the mere fact that the State had omitted to identify District Judge
(Entry level) as a post for provision or reservation in Rule 10, cannot be used as
a tool to exclude the petitioner from the benefit of the same.
50. This is all the more for the reason that this Court, in the 2011
decision, had specifically directed R3 to ensure that necessary provision for
PwD was made in the next recruitment. That decision had become final and R3
has not challenged the same, despite which the violation was perpetrated and
Foot Note Supra (7)
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP(MD) No. 8435 of 2013
the 2013 selection came and was finalised, in utter contempt of the Court’s
direction.
51. This Writ Petition is, hence, liable to be allowed on the question of
law raised by the petitioner, and as a result, impugned Notification dated
01.05.2013 is found to be bad in law, both for not having provided for
reservation for the category of PwD, and contravening the specific direction of
this Court under order dated 11.03.2011.
52. We hasten to add that the appointments made under the 2013
Notification remain untrammeled and undisturbed. The District Judges
appointed under that Notification have been in service since January, 2014, and
we do not intend to upset their position in 2026, after a gap of 12 years, that too,
for no fault of theirs. However, there is a way out for the State, both to
implement the directions under order dated 11.03.2011, as well as to make
amends.
53. The provision for reservation would entail selection of one physically
challenged person with statutory benchmark disabilities, out of every 33
persons. 12 persons have been selected in the 2010 selection and 23 persons in
the 2013 selection, and a total of 45 appointments have been made. As a result,
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP(MD) No. 8435 of 2013
there ought to have been as on date, one post of District Judge (Entry level)
filled in by a person with disability.
54. Hence, in the ensuing selection, as and when that may transpire, in
addition to the reservation to be provided in that selection, there shall be an
additional post ear-marked for a person with benchmark disability, to provide
for the omission on that account, in the 2010 and 2013 selections.
55. As far as the present petitioner is concerned, his success in this matter
is only psychological, as he is over the age limit for appointment in the District
Judiciary as on date, and hence cannot pursue his aspiration for appointment as
a District Judge.
56. Though in the order passed on 11.03.2011, the Bench has mandated
the State to provide for the reservation under PwD category in the subsequent
Notification, the direction has simply been ignored by the respondents and
amounts to contempt of this Court’s order. As a means of recompense and to
avoid further proceedings for contempt, the respondents will jointly pay a sum
of Rs.5,00,000/- (Rupees five lakhs only) to the petitioner within a period of
four (4) weeks from date of receipt of this order.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP(MD) No. 8435 of 2013
57. This Writ Petition is allowed on the question of law with the direction
as above. No costs. Connected Miscellaneous Petitions are closed.
(A.S.M.,J.)
(M.S.K.,J.)
10-02-2026
Index: Yes
Speaking order
sl
To
1. The Chief Secretary to Government,
Government of Tamil Nadu, Secretariat Chennai.
2. The Secretary to Government
Government of Tamilnadu, Public (Special A ) Department, Secretariat,
Chennai.
3. The Registrar General,
Madras High Court, Chennai- 600 104.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP(MD) No. 8435 of 2013
DR.ANITA SUMANTH J.
AND
MUMMINENI SUDHEER KUMAR J.
sl
WP(MD) No. 8435 of 2013
AND
WMP(MD) NOs. 1, 2 and 3 OF 2013
10-02-2026
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review