Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:20338
WP(C) No.10634 of 2010
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE P.M.MANOJ
WEDNESDAY, THE 5TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 14TH PHALGUNA, 1946
WP(C) NO. 10634 OF 2010
PETITIONERS:
M.DIVAKARAN NAIR, S/O.KUNHIKANNAN KIDAVU,
MADATHIL HOUSE,, KOZHUKALLOOR P.O., VIA
MEPPAYUR, KOZHIKODE DIST.
BY ADV SRI.N.K.SUBRAMANIAN
RESPONDENTS:
THE STATE OF KERALA
THE SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT, DEPARTMENT OF,
CO-OPERATION, GOVERNMENT SECRETARIAT,,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM.
THE ADDITIONAL REGISTRARSECRETARY
KERALA STATE EMPLOYEES PENSION BOARD,,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM.
THE JOINT REGISTRAR OF CO-OPERATIVE
SOCIETIES (GENERAL), KOZHIKODE.
THE MEPPAYUR SERVICE CO-OPERATIVE
BANK LTD., NO.D2019, MEPPAYURE P.O.,
KOZHIKODE DISTRICT.
THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS
THE MEPPAYUR SERVICE CO-OPERATIVE BANK LTD.,,
NO.D 2019, MEPPAYURE P.O., KOZHIKODE DISTRICT.
BY ADVS.
SRI.V.C.MADHAVANKUTTY
SRI.K.P.SUDHEER
2025:KER:20338
WP(C) No.10634 of 2010
OTHER PRESENT:
R1 AND 3 - SRI.BINOY DAVIS, GOVERNMENT PLEADER
R2 - SRI.M.SASINDRAN,SC R4 AND 5 SRI.K.P.SUDHEER
THIS WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD
ON 05.03.2025, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE
FOLLOWING:
2025:KER:20338
WP(C) No.10634 of 2010
JUDGMENT
Dated this the 5th day of March, 2025
The writ petition is preferred challenging Exts.P6, P7,
P8, P11 and P14 orders. The petitioner further seeks a direction
to the 2nd respondent to commence the period of enrollment
under the 2nd respondent from 15.04.1974 and grant the
retirement benefits accordingly.
2. It is the case of the petitioner that he retired from
service of the 4th respondent as a Secretary. While in service he
was subjected to disciplinary proceedings and dismissed. That
resulted in a series of litigations and finally Ext.P4 judgment.
Consequently, he was reinstated in service on the basis of
resolution taken by the 5th respondent as per resolution No.5
dated 31.3.2006 and an agreement was entered into between
the petitioner and the 5th respondent, wherein he was allowed
to continue in service from the date of suspension, i.e.,
23.12.1993 forenoon. From that date to 31.01.2003, he was
treated as Assistant Secretary and from 01.02.2003 he was
promoted and designated as Secretary till his retirement on
31.03.2004. His service from 15.04.1974 to 31.03.2004 was
treated as continuous. From 23.12.1993 to 31.03.2004, his
2025:KER:20338
WP(C) No.10634 of 2010
arrears of salary, leave surrender benefit, bonus, medical
allowance and gratuity disbursed at the time of retirement,
which comes to Rs.6,75,000/- were disbursed. Necessary steps
were taken to ensure the disbursement of his benefits by
treating him as having retired as Secretary on 31.03.2004,
with a rider, no further litigation in this regard.
3.
In
accordance
with
the
directions
in
Ext.P4
judgment and as per the agreement entered into between the
5th respondent and the petitioner, the 2nd respondent has, after
hearing the petitioner, fixed the pension from the date
01.07.1977, the date on which the Provident Fund Scheme
commenced.
4. It is the case of the petitioner that he was
sanctioned with provisional monthly minimum pension of
Rs.4,140/- by Ext.P7. That amount of pension was sanctioned
taking into consideration the total length of service as 307
months instead of 359.5 months and thereby his pension has
been reduced considerably. Thereafter, on sanctioning regular
pension, the final pension amount is fixed at Rs.5,529/- per
month from 01.04.2004. According to the petitioner, he is
entitled for an amount of Rs.6,960/- as monthly pension and
2025:KER:20338
WP(C) No.10634 of 2010
thereby occurred a loss of Rs.1,431/- per month. Aggrieved by
the same, the petitioner preferred an appeal before the 2 nd
respondent. On considering the said appeal, by Ext.P11, the 2 nd
respondent
rejected
the
contentions
of
the
petitioner.
Thereafter the petitioner preferred a representation before the
Minister of the Department as per Ext.P12. In the meanwhile,
the 5th respondent granted the benefit of higher grade to the
petitioner with retrospective effect from 01.02.2003 and
requested to the 2nd respondent to enhance the pension in
accordance with the new rate of salary paid to the petitioner.
However, that was declined as per Ext.P14 on the ground that
the higher grade was sanctioned with retrospective effect and
only a nominal amount was paid as contribution. Hence, the
payment of huge amount as arrears with retrospective effect
would cause an unnecessary financial burden. Therefore, only
applications which received within one year from the date of
retirement alone will be considered.
5.
Thereafter the Society has taken a decision to
remit the contribution from 15.4.1977 and had taken sufficient
steps to enable the 2nd respondent to calculate and arrive at
the pension amount legally eligible to the petitioner from the
2025:KER:20338
WP(C) No.10634 of 2010
date of entry in service. In support of the above contention,
the petitioner produced certain additional documents to show
that the Society has paid its contribution to the Kerala State
Co-operative Employees’ Pension Board from 05.04.1974. The
petitioner is reiterating the stand that he is entitled to the
pensionary benefits calculating the benefits from 15.04.1974
and also to take into account the higher grade granted with
retrospective effect after his retirement.
6. In support of the contentions, the learned counsel
for the petitioner brought my attention to the reported decision
in
Narayana
Kuruppu
v.
Kerala
State
Co-operative
Employees Pension Board [2012 (2) KLT 207] wherein it is
held that if an employee is not eligible for pension, it should be
made clear before receiving contribution under the Scheme and
not after a considerable period of time.
The Pension Board
cannot adjudicate whether the appointment was bad for any
reason.
7.
Per
contra,
the
learned
counsel
for
the
2 nd
respondent submitted that the petitioner had entered into the
service of the 4th respondent Society on 15.04.1974. The
Contributory Provident Fund in the name of the petitioner
2025:KER:20338
WP(C) No.10634 of 2010
started only with effect from 01.07.1977. As per clause 19 (1)
(a) of the Kerala Co-operative Societies Employees Self
Financing Pension Scheme, 1994, qualifying service is defined
as follows;
“(1)(a) in the case of an employee who was in
service of a Society or a Board constituted under
the Act on the date of application of the Scheme to
that Society or such Board the length of the service
commencing
from
the
date
of
joining
the
Contributory Provident Fund.”
8.
Therefore, qualifying service of the petitioner can
be taken from 01.07.1977, the date on which the Contributory
Provident Fund Scheme was implemented. It is also contended
that the higher grade granted after the retirement with
retrospective effect cannot be taken into consideration for
revising the pensionary benefits.
Since the contribution paid
towards the Self Financing Pension Scheme is a meager one, in
accordance with the then available monetary value of the
salary, the 2nd respondent Pension Fund Board did not receive
proportionate contribution in accordance with the revised
salary taking into consideration the higher grade granted with
2025:KER:20338
WP(C) No.10634 of 2010
retrospective effect.
If such revision is effected in pension,
that will ultimately affect the resources of the Pension Fund
Board and it may affect its future capability to grant pension to
the retired employees. Hence, the prayer in the writ petition
cannot be granted, the counsel argued.
9. On the other hand, the learned counsel for the
respondent in its statement mentioned various decisions to
substantiate that, the qualifying service of an employee can
only be reckoned from the date of joining the Contributory
Provident Fund, which are Sukumaran N. v. Kerala State
Co-operative
Employees’
Pension
Board,
Thiruvananthapuram [2010 (4) KHC 859], Pushpam C. v.
State of Kerala and others [2015 (4) KLT 265] and also
Purushothaman K. and another v. Kerala State Cooperative Employees’ Pension Board [2011 (3) KHC 325]
wherein it was specifically held that Clause (1)(a) of para 19
stipulates that in the case of an employee who was in the
service of a society on the date of application of the scheme to
that society, the length of the service commencing from the
date of joining the Contributory Provident Fund shall be the
qualifying service for the purpose of grant of pension. The first
2025:KER:20338
WP(C) No.10634 of 2010
proviso however stipulates that the qualifying service shall be
limited to the period for which the employer’s contribution
towards the Provident Fund has been fully paid by the society
in respect of that employee.
10. This position has been upheld by the Division
Bench in Purushothaman K. v. Kerala State Co-operatives
Employees’ Employees’ Pension Board [2011 (4) KLT 455].
11. In response to that the learned counsel for the
petitioner submitted that the 2nd respondent has accepted the
contribution made by the Society as per Ext.P16 Resolution
even prior to the date of implementation of the scheme in the
Society.
In
response,
the
learned
counsel
for
the
2 nd
respondent submitted that they are ready to refund the excess
amount paid to them by the Society as per Ext.P16.
12. I have heard Sri.N.K.Subramanian, the learned
counsel
for
the
petitioner,
Sri.M.Sasindran,
the
learned
Standing Counsel for the 2nd respondent, Sri. K.P.Sudheer, the
learned
counsel for respondents 4 and 5 and also Sri. Binoy
Davis, the learned Government Pleader for the 1st respondent.
13. Having considered the submissions made across
the Bar, it appears that the petitioner joined the service of the
2025:KER:20338
WP(C) No.10634 of 2010
4th respondent Society with effect from 15.04.1974. The name
of the petitioner was included in the Contributory Provident
Fund with effect from 01.07.1977. In fact, during his tenure,
the petitioner was subjected to disciplinary proceedings.
Initially he was suspended and later terminated. Litigation
ended up in Ext.P4 judgment. In the light of Ext.P4 judgment,
an agreement has been entered into between the petitioner
and the 5th respondent Society.
service
14.
As per the terms of the agreement, petitioner's
has
been
regularised
with
effect
from
date
of
suspension 22.12.1993 and later he was permitted to continue
as Assistant Secretary upto 31.01.2003.
Thereafter
on
01.02.2003 he was promoted as Secretary and allowed to
retire from service on 31.03.2004. A decision was also taken to
treat the entire period of service till the retirement as a
continuous service. The entire benefits pertaining to the said
period were decided to be granted to the petitioner. Further
steps have been ensured to provide pension to the petitioner
treating that he was retired on 31.03.2004 after a continuous
service. It is also decided that in future no legal steps will be
taken pursuant to the matter involved in the litigation.
2025:KER:20338
WP(C) No.10634 of 2010
Accordingly Ext.P5(a) agreement was signed between the 5 th
respondent and the petitioner.
15. However, as per Ext.P6, the Pension Board has
sanctioned pension to the petitioner calculating the pension
from the date of joining the pension scheme, i.e., on
01.07.1977, and the Society was directed to remit the arrears
of pension contribution with effect from 01.07.1977. When the
Society effects the payment of arrears, it was decided to
sanction the arrears to the petitioner. However, the Board has
taken a decision that it cannot grant any concession in
collecting the interest on the arrears paid to Society. As per the
Pension Payment Order, which is produced as Ext.P7, it can be
seen that the petitioner’s date of joining to the Contributory
Provident Fund Scheme is only from 01.07.1977, though he
entered into service with effect from 01.07.1974.
16. Under such circumstances, considering Clause
19(1)(a) of the Kerala Co-operative Societies Employees’ Self
Financing
Pension
Scheme,
the
petitioner
is
entitled
to
pensionary benefits from the date on which he entered into the
pension scheme, i.e., from 01.07.1977, the date on which the
scheme was made applicable to the 4 th respondent Society.
2025:KER:20338
WP(C) No.10634 of 2010
However, the Society as per Ext.P16 decided to remit the
contribution with retrospective effect from 15.04.1974 to the
Contributory Provident Fund and the 2 nd respondent has also
accepted the amount.
17. Taking into consideration, Clause 19(1)(a) of the
Scheme, I do not find any merit in the contention of the
petitioner that he is entitled to get pension from the date on
which the payment is effected to the Board. However, I cannot
defer
with
the
plea
raised
by
the
petitioner
that
the
contribution has been paid to the Society much prior to the
implementation of the Scheme with retrospective effect. But
that cannot be a reason for granting pension to the petitioner
taking into account the fact that the amount was paid
retrospectively. That too, prior to the date of commencement
of the Scheme.
18. I have also considered the contentions of the
petitioner that he is entitled to the revised pensionary benefits
taking into account the grade given to him after his retirement
with retrospective effect. I cannot concede to the contention of
the petitioner since the contribution paid by the Society on
behalf of the petitioner was meagre and grade was given one
2025:KER:20338
WP(C) No.10634 of 2010
year after the retirement; that too, with retrospective effect.
Without getting any proportionate contribution, if the 2 nd
respondent effects revision taking into consideration of the
grade granted to the petitioner with retrospective effect, that
will ultimately affect the resources of the 2 nd respondent,
especially the process of effecting payment of other employees.
Hence, that prayer of the petitioner cannot be accepted based
on the finding that the stand taken by the Board is correct.
Under such circumstances, I do not find any merit to
interfere with the matter. However, the Pension Board is not
entitled to retain the contribution made by the Society, which is
in excess of the required amount since the amount is paid from
15.04.1974 prior to the date of implementation. The excess
payment made shall be refunded to the Society with statutory
interest. If the Society desires to disburse the same to the
petitioner, the Society is free to do the same.
The writ petition is disposed of accordingly.
sd/-
P.M.MANOJ
JUDGE
das
2025:KER:20338
WP(C) No.10634 of 2010
APPENDIX OF WP(C) 10634/2010
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
EXHIBIT P1
EXHIBIT P2
EXHIBIT P3
EXHIBIT P4
EXHIBIT P5
EXHIBIT P6
EXHIBIT P7
EXHIBIT P8
EXHIBIT P9
EXHIBIT P10
EXHIBIT P11
EXHIBIT P12
EXHIBIT P13
EXHIBIT P14
EXHIBIT P15
EXHIBIT P16
EXHIBIT P17
EXHIBIT P18
EXHIBIT P19
EXHIBIT P20
EXHIBIT P21
Exhibit P22
Exhibit P23
TRUE COPY OF APPOINTMENT LETTER
DT.15.4.74
TRUE COPY OF ORDER NO.MSB/1/7/97/
DT.28.7.97
TRUE COPY OF GO(RT) NO.639/2003/CO-OP.
DT.3.11.03
TRUE COPY OF JUDGMENT IN WPC NO.39379/03
DT.4.4.06
TRUE COPY OF RESOLUTION DT.31.3.06
TRUE COPY OF ORDER NO.PB/P3/891/KKD
DT.15.1.07
TRUE COPY OF PENSION PAYMENT ORDER
NO.417/KKD DT.23.2.07
TRUE COPY OF ORDER NO.PB.PPO.417/KKD
DT.26.7.07
TRUE COPY OF APPEAL DATED 14.2.08
TRUE COPY OF LETTER DATED 3.4.08
TRUE COPY OF ORDER NO.PB/P3/417/KKD
DT.13.6.08
TRUE COPY OF REPRESENTATION DT.22.7.08
TRUE COPY OF ORDER NO.MSB/GR.1/09
DT.10.7.09
TRUE COPY OF ORDER NO.PB/P3/417/KKD
DT.13.10.09
TRUE COPY OF LETTER NO.2.11.09
TRUE COPY OF RESOLUTION DT.15.5.06
TRUE COPY OF LETTER DT.31.5.06
TRUE COPY OF LETTER DT.31.5.06
TRUE COPY OF LETTER 10.3.10
TRUE COPY OF REPRESENTATION DATED
9.6.2014
TRUE COPY OF COMMUNICATION DATED
17.6.2014
THE TRUE COPY OF PAY IN SLIP DATED
31.05.2006.
THE TRUE COPY OF PAY IN SLIP DATED
17.11.2006.
2025:KER:20338
WP(C) No.10634 of 2010
Exhibit P24
THE TRUE COPY OF PAY IN SLIP DATED
26.05.2007.
Exhibit P25
THE TRUE COPY OF PAY IN SLIP DATED
28.06.2007.
Exhibit P26
THE TRUE COPY OF PAY IN SLIP DATED
18.07.2007.
Exhibit P27
CONSOLIDATED STATEMENT OF DETAILS OF
PAYMENT INCLUDING THE ADDITIONAL PAYMENT
OF GRANTING THE HIGHER GRADE ISSUED BY
THE 4TH RESPONDENT.
Exhibit P28
THE CALCULATION OF MY PENSION FUND
CALCULATED FROM 01.08.1974, WHICH IS THE
DATED OF MY JOINING DUTY TILL MY
RETIREMENT.
RESPONDENT EXHIBITS
Exhibit R2(a)
True copy of the judgment dated
06.02.2014 in WP(C) No.2805/2010
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review