Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/14
GAHC040020542025
undefined
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/587/2025
Lumane Mello
PI G-I, Son of Late Kadu Mello, Singa Village, Camp Singa, PO and PS Tuting,
Upper Siang District, Arunachal Pradesh.
VERSUS
The State of AP and 2 Ors
represented by the Chief Secretary, Govt of Arunachal Pradesh, Itanagar.
2:The Secretary
Age: 0
Occupation :
General Administration
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar.
3:The Deputy Commissioner
Age: 0
Occupation :
Yingkiong
Upper Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh
Advocate for the Petitioner
: Tabit Tapak, Y Pangu,T Tabing,Bebeng Siboh,Aso Dalbong
Advocate for the Respondent : GA (AP),
Page No.# 2/14
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ROBIN PHUKAN
JUDGMENT
24.03.2026
Heard Mr. T. Tapak, learned counsel for the petitioner and Mr. S. Tapin,
learned Senior Government Advocate for the respondents.
Prayers:2.
In this petition, under Article 226/227 of the Constitution of India, the
petitioner has challenged the order No. YKG-555/2023, dated 14.07.2025,
passed by the Deputy Commissioner, Yingkiong, Upper Siang District (DC
hereinafter), whereby the petitioner herein was declared as not eligible to be
promoted to the post of Political Assistant (PA hereinafter) and further, prayed
for issuing direction to the respondent authorities to appoint the petitioner as PA
before constitution of regular Departmental Promotion Committee (DPC
hereinafter) in compliance of the Recruitment Rules.
Background facts:3.
The background facts, leading to filing of this petition, are briefly stated as
under:“The petitioner has been working as senior most Public Interpreter
(PI hereinafter) in the Office of the DC.
He was initially appointed to the post of PI Grade – III, on
17.02.1993 and thereafter, he was promoted to the post of PI Grade – I.
The petitioner being the most senior member of PIGrade – I,
working in the Office of the DC, is the fittest and most qualified candidate
Page No.# 3/14
to be promoted to the post of PA, in terms of Recruitment Rules, dated
18.10.1976, he was under legitimate expectation to be promoted to the
post of PA in the department of the respondents.
But, the respondent authorities have not promoted the petitioner to
the post of PA and being aggrieved,he had filed one writ petition, being
W.P.(C) No. 557/2023, before this Court and the said writ petition was
disposed of with a direction to dispose of the pending representation of
the petitioner in accordance with law.
Thereafter, the DC, being respondent No. 3, had disposed of the
pending representation of the petitioner in terms of the order dated
14.07.2025, wherein the promotion of the petitioner to the post of PA has
been denied on the ground that the petitioner cannot be promoted to the
post of PA in terms of the standing Recruitment Rules, as because he has
lack educational qualification of graduation, in term of the Office
Memorandum (OM hereinafter) No. AR-74/2013/Vol-II, dated 29.08.2019
and its subsequent corrigendum, vide OM No. AR/85/2024/SECT-1-AR,
dated 11.07.2024.”
Being aggrieved with the aforesaid order, the petitioner has approached this
Court by filing the present petition with the aforementioned reliefs.
Submissions:4.
Mr. Tapak, learned counsel for the petitioner, submits that while the
Recruitment Rules is holding the field, the respondent authorities cannot issue
Executive Order or OM to supersede/override the fundamental rules, when the
appointment procedure of PA is clearly laid down in the Recruitment Rules.
4.1. Mr. Tapak has pointed out that the feeder cadre for the post of PA is PI
Page No.# 4/14
Grade – I and that the petitioner has been working as PI Grade – I since long
and he is the most suitable person for being promoted to the post of PA.
4.2. Mr. Tapak further submits that in the Recruitment Rules, which is annexed
with the petition, as Annexure No. 5, at page No. 24, it is provided that
appointment to the cadre of PA will be made from the serving interpreters
Grade – I and area superintendents belonging to NEFA tribes on the agency
level, taking due care that districts and tribes are duly represented in the service
as far as possible on the basis of merit cum seniority, on the recommendation of
the DPC and determining the inter-se seniority of the incumbents, service
rendered as interpreter Grade – II and III and other equivalent posts as the
case may be, will be taken into consideration. There will be no direct
recruitment to this cadre.
4.3. Mr. Tapak further submits that the procedure for appointmentis that there
should be recommendation from the recommending authority, in respect of the
persons who are of outstanding merit and ability and there should be screening
board constituted by Governor/DC and the board has to recommend the suitable
candidate for promotion to PA, taking into consideration of the following aspects
of the candidates, i.e. (a) personality and character; (b) tact, energy, general
intelligence; (c) integrity; (d) influence on his own tribe as well as on other
tribe; (e) his service can more profitably be utilized by appointment to the cadre
of PA; (f) physical fitness; (g) executive ability; and (h) any special weight-age
for a more backward or sensitive area within NEFA/now Arunachal Pradesh.
4.4. Mr. Tapak also submits that the Recruitment Rules may be treated as a
Rule framed under Article 309 of the Constitution of India, as because the said
Recruitment Rules has been used by the department of the respondent
authorities as fundamental rule for appointment of PA and therefore, the
Page No.# 5/14
Om/Executive Order issued under Article 162 of the Constitution of India (Extent
of Executive Power of State) cannot prevailed when the procedure of
appointment of PA is clear and lucid and unambiguous.
4.5. Mr. Tapak further submits that the education qualification criteria are not
only the sole criteria for appointment in public office, under democratic setup of
governance and therefore, in practice, the procedures laid down in the
Recruitment Rules,may it be the case of political leaders for contesting Election
of MPs &MLAs or appointment as chairman in various post, where educational
qualification has not been prescribed.
4.6. Mr. Tapak has also pointed out that the OM in question does not
specifically mentioned that it will be applicable for appointment of PA. The
standing appointment procedure of PA is being followed by the department of
the respondent authorities till date, without any amendment in the Principal
Rule/Fundamental Rule and therefore, the Rule making power of the
department cannot be mortgaged or supplemented by the Administrative
Reformed Department, when the intent and purpose of the Recruitment Rules is
clear with regard to appointment of PA, because the executive order can only fill
up the gaps or supplement, but not to change or alter the procedure of
recruitment as per law or introduce new eligibility criteria, such as educational
qualification without any formal amendment in the RecruitmentRules.
4.7. In that view of the matter, Mr. Tapak submits that the executive
ordercannot prevail over the Recruitment Rules in case of conflict of law,
because it has no statutory force and merely an administrative direction.
Moreover, silence over the educational qualification cannot be the sole ground to
deny appointment, when procedure of appointment of PA is clear in the
Recruitment Rules, because in terms of the settled principle of law Recruitment
Page No.# 6/14
Rules cannot bebrush aside by issuing executive order or OM, that too without
amending the principal/fundamental rules.
4.8. In support of his submission, Mr. Tapak has referred following decisions:(i)
Union
of
India
vs.
Sh.
Somasundaram
Viswanath
and
Others, reported in AIR 1988 SC 2255;
(ii)
Ajay Kumar Das vs. State of Orissa and Others, reported in
2009 supp AIR (SC) 1739;
(iii)
The
District
Registrar
Palghat
and
Others
vs.
MB
Koyyakutty and Others, reported in 1979 AIR (SC) 1060; and
(iv) Tabak Hanker vs. State of Arunachal Pradesh, W.P.(C) No.
319(AP)/2016.
5.
Per-contra, Mr. Tapin, learned Senior Government Advocate for the
respondents submits that the Recruitment Rules, dated 18.10.1967, which is
annexed with the petition, as Annexure No. 5, at page No. 24, does not provide
any educational qualification for being promoted to the post of PA. Mr. Tapin
also submits that the post of PA is a Group – B post.
5.1. Drawing attention of this Court to the Annexure No. 6 of the petition, Mr.
Tapin submits that vide order dated 24.11.2000, the Government of Arunachal
Pradesh had issued an order that the post of PA shall continue to be Group –
‘B’Gazetted and the pay structure attached to the said post falls under Group –
‘C’ after the revision of pay scale under 5 th pay commission. Mr. Tapin also
submits that since the post of PA is a Group – ‘B’ Gazette post and since no
educational qualification is prescribed in the Recruitment Rules, the respondent
authorities have issued the OM dated 29.08.2019, prescribing the educational
Page No.# 7/14
qualification for Group - ‘A’ and ‘B’ posts and the said OM also covers the
category of PA, since it is a Group – ‘B’ post.
5.2. Further, drawing attention of this Court to the Annexure No. 15, the OM
dated 29.08.2019, Mr. Tapin submits that vide said OM, the basic educational
qualification for being appointed in Group – A & B posts is fixed as
Graduate/Bachelor Degree.
5.3. Mr. Tapin has referred to a judgment and order of this Court, passed in
W.P.(C) No. 105/2021, dated 15.06.2022, especially paragraph Nos. 12 &
13,which was upheld in a appeal, being W.A. No. 18/2022 and submits that this
Court was pleased to deal with the said OM dated 29.08.2019, wherein it is
stated that if the Government felt that there is an immediate need for making
rules/overriding all existing recruitment rules to have minimum educational
qualification as graduation or Bachelor Degree in the entry grade for all Group –
A & B posts/services in the State of Arunachal Pradesh and when the
Recruitment Rules is silent, the respondent authorities can issue executive order
to supplement the same. Mr. Tapin also submit that, therefore, relying upon the
said OM, the respondent No. 3, the DC, had issued the impugned order, dated
14.07.2025, rejecting the representation of the petitioner, dated 06.12.2024.
5.3. Under such circumstances, Mr. Tapin submits that the said impugned order
suffers from no infirmity or illegality requiring any interference of this Court and
therefore, he has contended to dismiss this petition.
Consideration of this Court:6.
Having heard the submissions of learned counsel for both the parties, this
Court has carefully gone through the petition as well as the documents placed
on record and also perused the Recruitment Rules, dated 18.10.1967 and also
Page No.# 8/14
the order of the Chief Secretary to the Government of Arunachal Pradesh, dated
24.11.2000, (Annexure No. 6) and also the impugned order dated 14.07.2025,
passed by the DC.
7.
In view of the pleadings of the parties and also in view of the submissions,
so advanced by learned counsel for both the parties, the issues, to be decided
by this Court are formulated as under:(a)
Whether the State respondents can issue OM/Executive Order
prescribing educational qualification while the Recruitment Rules is in
force and the field is occupied?
(b)
Whether the impugned order, dated 14.07.2025, Annexure No. 14 is
illegal or arbitrary requiring any interference of this Court?
8.
It is not in dispute that the Recruitment Rules for the post of PA is already
in force, which was enacted on 18.10.1967. It is also not in dispute that in the
said Recruitment Rules, the educational qualification has not been prescribed for
being promoted the Public Interpreter to the post of PA.
8.1. Further, it appears from the Annexure No. 6, the order of the Chief
Secretary to the Government of Arunachal Pradesh, that the post of PA is a
Group – ‘B’ Gazetted post, although the pay structure attached to the said post
falls under Group – ‘C’, after the revision of pay scale under 5 th pay commission.
8.2. It also appears that the OM, dated 29.08.2019, the respondent authorities
have fixed Graduation/Bachelor Decree as the basic educational qualification for
appointment in Group – A & B posts/services. Notably, the said OM is not
challenged in this petition.
8.3. Further, from the impugned order, dated 14.07.2025, it appears that the
Page No.# 9/14
respondent No. 3, the DC had disposed of the representation filed by the
petitioner by holding that the petitioner is not eligible for being promoted to the
post of PA (Group – B Gazette) for want of minimum prescribed educational
qualification as notified by the Government, in its OM dated 29.08.2019 and its
subsequent corrigendum dated 11.07.2024.
9.
The first issue, so formulated herein above arises, that whether the
Government can issue such OM, while the Recruitment Rules is already in force
and the filed is occupied.
10. In this context, this Court feels it necessary to refer to some of the
decisions of Hon’ble Supreme Court, at this point.
10.1. In the case of A.B. Krishna and Others vs. State of Karnataka
and Others, reported in (1998) 3 SCC 495, Hon’ble Supreme Court has held
that as a matter of fact, under Article 309 of the Constitution, once a legislature
intervenes to enact a law regulating the conditions of service, the power of the
Executive, including the President or the Governor, as the case may be, is totally
displaced on the principle of "doctrine of occupied field" and if, however, any
matter is not touched by that enactment, it will be competent for the executive
to either issue executive instructions or to make a rule under Article 309 of the
Constitution of India in respect of that matter.
10.2. In the case of P.H. Paul Manoj Pandian vs. P. Veldurai, reported
in (2011) 5 SCC 214, Hon’ble Supreme Court has held that once a law
occupies the field, it will not be open to the State Government in exercise of its
executive power under Article 162 of the Constitution of India to prescribe in the
same field by an executive order. However, it is well recognized that in matters
relating to a particular subject in absence of any parliamentary legislation on the
Page No.# 10/14
said subject, the State Government has the jurisdiction to act and to make
executive orders.
10.3. Again in the case of Satya Narain Shukla vs. Union of India and
Others, reported in (2006) 9 SCC 69, Hon’ble Supreme Court has held as
under:“19.
The appellant contended that the provision of the
Central Staffing Scheme is ultra vires under Articles
309 and 312 of the Constitution of India. Amplifying
this, it is urged by the appellant that several rules
have
been
framed
by
the
Central
Government
in
exercise of its statutory powers under the AIS Act,
1951 i.e. the Indian Administrative Service (Cadre)
Rules,
1951;
the
Indian
Administrative
Service
(Fixation of Cadre Strength) Regulations, 1955;Indian
Administrative
Service
(Pay)
Administrative
Service
(Regulation
Rules,
Indian
Administrative
1987;
Rules,
1954;
of
Indian
Seniority)
Service
h
(Probation) Rules, 1954; and that these rules occupy
the
whole
field
of
executive
discretion,
and,
therefore, by the doctrine of occupied field there
isno scope left for exercise of executive action
outside the purview of these rules. It is difficult
to accept this contention. Each one of these rules is
intended to take care of a specific facet of IAS. No
set of these rules is a exhaustive by itself of all
the service conditions applicable to the IAS. It is,
Page No.# 11/14
therefore, incorrect to contend that the field of
possible executive action is completely occupied by
the statute or the statutory rules framed thereunder,
deriving force from Article 309 read with Article 312
of
the
Constitution.
We
have
not
been
shown
any
provisions in these Rules which deal specifically
with the subject of the procedure for selection of
officers
from
the
said
cadre
for
the
post
of
Additional Secretary/Secretary to the Government of
India. This is a subject in respect of which the
field does not appear to be occupied. Consequently,
it was very much open to the executive to resort to
executive instructions by way of an office memo for
dealing with this subject. The contention, therefore,
must fail.”
10.4. It is to be noted here that a Division Bench of this Court, in the case of
Mahendra Nath Mudoi and Others vs. State of Assam and Others,
reported in (2017) 6 GLR 381, has also echoed similar principle by holding
that if any matter is not touched by that enactment, it will be competent for the
executive to either issue executive instructions or to make a rule under Article
309 of the Constitution of India in respect of that matter.
11. Thus, what can be crystallized from the aforementioned discussions is that
when the field is occupied, with the enactment of the Act and Rules, then the
State respondents has no authority to issue any Executive Order/OM to
supplement the same, by exercising its jurisdiction, under Article 162 of the
Constitution of India. But, when any matter is not touched by that
Page No.# 12/14
enactment/rule, it will be competent for the executive to either issue executive
instructions or to make a rule under Article 309 of the Constitution of India in
respect of that matter, as held by Hon’ble Supreme Court in the cases of A.B.
Krishna (supra);P.H. Paul Manoj Pandian (supra); and Satya Narain
Shukla (supra).
12. As in the instant case, the Recruitment Rules is silent in respect of the
‘educational qualification’ for PI, which is the feeder cadre of the post of PA,
being promoted to the post of PA, which is indisputably a Group – ‘B’Gazetted
post, the respondents authorities herein are competent to supplement the
matter, which is not covered by the enactment. In that view of the matter, the
Notification (which is not challenged in this petition) cannot be said to be devoid
of any force.
12.1. On such count, the submission, so advanced by Mr. Tapak, learned
counsel for the petitioner, cannot be accepted.
12.2. This Court has gone also through the decisions referred by him. In the
case of Sh. Somasundaram Viswanath (supra), Hon’ble Supreme Court has
held that when there is conflict between an OM/Executive Instruction and Rules,
then the fundamental rules framed under Article 309 of the Constitution of India
will prevail over the supplementary rules/OM/Administrative Instructions where
rule is clear.
12.3. In the case of Ajay Kumar Das (supra), Hon’ble Supreme Court has
held that Executive Notification/Instruction (including policy decision or OMs)
cannot override or supersede statutory rules framed under Article 309 of the
Constitution of India.
12.4. In the case of The District Registrar Palghat (supra), Hon’ble
Page No.# 13/14
Supreme Court has held that the gap, on any point, in statutory rules or law
enacted under Article 309 of the Constitution of India, can be filled up by
Government by administrative instructions, provided these are not inconsistent
with rules or law.
12.5. Again, in the case of Tabak Hanker (supra), this Court has held that
OM cannot prevail over the Recruitment Rules unless amended.
12.6. There is no quarrel at the bar about the propositions laid down in the said
cases. But, this Court afraid that said propositions would not advance the
argument of Mr. Tapak, learned counsel for the petitioner, in view of the fact
that in the instant case there is no conflict in the Recruitment Rules and OM as
nothing is provided in the Recruitment Rules regarding educational qualification.
It is not the case of the petitioner that something is provided in the Rule
regarding educational qualification and something else is provided in the OM,
which cannot be reconciled and only in that case, the Rule will prevail.
13. In view of the discussion and finding so recorded by this Court in the
foregoing paragraphs, the submission of Mr. Tapak, learned counsel for the
petitioner, cannot be accepted and also the same would not advance his
argument.
14. Accordingly, the issue No. (i), so formulated by this Court, is answered in
affirmative.
14.1. In view of the affirmative decision on the issue No. (i) and also examining
the impugned order, dated 14.07.2025, in the light of the principles discussed
herein above, this Court is of the view that the impugned order, whereby the
representation filed by the petitioner was disposed of and thereby, rejected his
claim for being promoted to the post of PA, the issue No. (ii) has to be
Page No.# 14/14
answered in negative and accordingly, the same stands answered.
15. This Court is inclined to reiterate again, even at the cost of repetition also
that, the OM, by which minimum qualification for being appointed in the post of
Group– A & B post, has not been challenged in this petition by the petitioner.
However, this OM was challenged in W.P.(C) No. 105/2021 and W.P.(C) No.
99/2021, but the same was upheld in the common judgment and order dated
15.06.2022 and also the same was affirmed in W.A. No. 18/2022, vide judgment
and order dated 04.01.2023.
16. Under the given facts and circumstances on the record, this Court finds no
merit in this petition. Accordingly, the same stands dismissed, leaving the
parties to bear their own costs.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review