Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
SHAMURAILATPAM SUSHIL Digitally signed by SHAMURAILATPAM
SUSHIL SHARMA
SHARMA
Date: 2023.10.30 16:31:41 +05'30'
Page |1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
Criminal Revision Petition No.10 of 2023
1) Loyangamba Thounaojam, aged about 43 years, S/o L.
Brajamani Meitei.
2) Thounaojam Brajamani Meetei, aged about 78 years, S/o
(L) Th. Parijat Singh.
3) Thounaojam Ongbi Ramani Leima, aged about 76 years,
W/o Th. Brajamani Meetei.
-
All are residents of Sagolband Ingudam Leirak,
P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur.
… Petitioners/Appellants
in Cril.Appeal Case No. 1 of 2022
-VERSUS-
Smt. Kshetrimayum (N) Thounaojam (O) Joymati Devi,
aged about 40 years, W/o Loyangamba Thounaojam of
Sagolband Ingudam Leirak, P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal
West
District,
Manipur,
at
present
residing
at
Chingamakha Kshetri Leikai, P.O. & P.S. Singjamei,
Imphal West District, Manipur.
… Respondent/Respondent in
Cril.Appeal Case No. 1 of 2022
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE M.V. MURALIDARAN
For the Petitioners
::
Mr. S. Suresh, Adv.
For the Respondent
.
Date of Hearing and
Judgment & Order
::
None appeared
::
19.10.2023
Criminal Revision Petition No.10 of 2023
Page |2
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
(ORAL)
Heard
Mr.S.Suresh,
learned
counsel
for
the
petitioners. None appears on behalf of the respondent despite
service of notice and her name being published in the cause list.
The respondent, thereafter, called absent and set ex parte.
2.
This Criminal Revision Petition has been filed by the
petitioners under Section 396 read with Section 401 Cr.P.C. to set
aside the order dated 12.4.2023 passed by the learned Sessions
Judge, Imphal West in Criminal Appeal No.1 of 2022.
3.
The learned counsel for the petitioners submitted that
the impugned judgment and order dated 12.4.2023 passed in the
appeal is not sustainable in the eye of law, inasmuch as the same
was passed without application of judicial mind.
The learned
counsel further submitted that the learned Sessions Judge has
committed an error in passing the impugned judgment without
deciding first the issue raised and framed as to the sustainability of
the judgment and order dated 5.8.2019 passed by the learned
Judicial Magistrate First Class, Imphal West.
The conduct of the
respondent is highly depreciable, inasmuch as the Criminal
Complaint Case No.38 of 2014 ought to have been withdrawn by
the respondent in terms of the order dated 14.11.2016 passed in
Criminal Revision Petition No.10 of 2023
Page |3
Mat. (Div.) Suit No.82 of 2014. Instead, the respondent pursued the
matter which led to the passing the judgment and order dated
5.8.2019 by the learned Judicial Magistrate First Class.
4.
The learned counsel further submitted that both the
learned Judicial Magistrate First Class and the learned Sessions
Judge have completely erred in passing the order dated 5.8.2019
in Criminal Complaint Case No.38 of 2014 and the judgment dated
12.4.2023 passed in Cril. Appeal No.1 of 2002 by keeping the order
dated 14.11.2016 in Mat. (Div.) Suit No.82 of 2014 at naught.
5.
According to the petitioners, the act of the respondent
is nothing but abuse of the process of the order dated 5.8.2019
passed in Criminal Complaint Case No.39 of 2014.
According to
the petitioners, to prevent the miscarriage of justice, interference of
this Court in the impugned order is called for. Thus, a prayer has
been made to allow the criminal revision petition and to set aside
the judgment and order dated 12.4.2023 passed in the criminal
appeal.
6.
The point that arises for consideration is whether the
learned Sessions Judge was right in dismissing the appeal
preferred against the order dated 5.8.2019 passed by the learned
Judicial Magistrate, Imphal West.
Criminal Revision Petition No.10 of 2023
Page |4
7.
The present revision is arising out of the judgment and
order dated 12.4.2023 passed in Criminal Appeal No.1 of 2022,
which was preferred against the judgment and order dated 5.8.2019
passed in Criminal Complaint Case No.38 of 2014. The Criminal
Complaint Case No.38 of 2014 has been filed by the respondent
herein under Section 12 of the Protection of Women from Domestic
Violence Act, 2005 for passing appropriate order under Sections 18,
19, 21, 22 and 23 of the said Protection of Women from Domestic
Violence Act, 2005.
8.
The petitioners are husband, father-in-law and
mother-in-law of the respondent.
The first petitioner and the
respondent are husband and wife and they were married on
5.7.2012. From the wedlock, one daughter, namely Thounaojam
Lanchenbi Chanu, was born on 9.5.2013. The first petitioner and
the respondent had been living together as husband and wife at the
shared household till 27.5.2014. It is stated that the respondent left
the matrimonial home on 27.5.2014. The first petitioner filed Mat.
(Div) Suit No.82 of 2014 before the Family Court, Manipur against
the respondent for dissolution of marriage. Pending Mat. (Div) Suit
No.82 of 2014, the respondent filed Cril. (Maintenance) Case No.33
of 2014 and later on she had also filed Criminal Complaint Case
No.38 of 2014 against the petitioners.
Criminal Revision Petition No.10 of 2023
Page |5
9.
As could be seen from the records, during the
pendency of Criminal Complaint Case No.38 of 2014, a settlement
was arrived at between the petitioners and the respondent in Mat.
(Div) Suit No.82 of 2014 and both the parties have filed a joint
application before the Family Court, Manipur praying to allow them
to compromise the case in terms of amicable settlement arrived at
between them. Based on the compromise arrived at between the
parties, the Family Court disposed of Mat. (Div) Suit No.82 of 2014
vide order dated 14.11.2016.
10.
The terms of the compromise have been quoted in the
decree dated 14.11.2016 in Mat. (Div) Suit No.82 of 2014. For
proper appreciation, the said terms and conditions as extracted in
the decree in Mat. (Div) Suit No.82 of 2014 is quoted hereunder for
ready reference:
“i) That, the plaintiff will make necessary
arrangement for a separate residence of their
own and until a separate residence can be
arranged the defendant along with their minor
daughter namely Lanchenbi now aged 3 and a
half years, will stay at her parental house.
Criminal Revision Petition No.10 of 2023
Page |6
ii) That, while the defendant is staying in her
parental house as aforesaid she will allow the
plaintiff to visit him and to stay with her as and
when necessary.
iii) That, the plaintiff will always look after the
defendant and his daughter and he will bear
their necessary expenditure. For this the plaintiff
will deposit necessary amount in the Bank
Account
No.20131335268
of
S.B.I.
M.G.
Avenue, from time to time.
iv) That, the defendant will withdraw (a) Cril. (C)
Case No.38 of 2014 before the Judicial
Magistrate First Class, Imphal West-I, (b) Cril.
Misc. Case No.25 of 2016 Ref; Cril. (M) 33 of
2014 now pending in the Family Court, Manipur
and for this the defendant will file necessary
application in the concerned court.
v) That, for the immediate expenditure of the
defendant, the plaintiff has this day handed over
a sum of Rs.50,000/- (Rupees fifty thousand)
Criminal Revision Petition No.10 of 2023
Page |7
only to the defendant and the defendant has
also acknowledged the receipt of the same.
vi) That, both parties will not do anything against
the compromise now brought between the
parties.”
11.
Pending Criminal Complaint Case No.38 of 2014, the
respondent filed Cril. Misc. Case No.37 of 2017 before the Judicial
Magistrate First Class, Imphal West praying to issue direction
against
the
first
petitioner
herein
to
pay
the
monetary
relief/expenditure i.e. medical expenditures and educational
expenditures of the minor daughter of the respondent. The learned
Judicial Magistrate, by the order dated 17.8.2017, disposed of the
said case. While disposing of the Cril. Misc. Case No.37 of 2017,
the learned Judicial Magistrate observed that “as the respondent
(present first petitioner) had given a sum of Rs.50,000/- (Rupees
Fifty thousand only) only on 14.11.2016 and the operation of the
minor daughter being taken place on 4.1.2017 which expenses a
sum of Rs.35,000/- (Rupees Thirty five thousand only), this Court is
of the view that since the respondent had given for expenditure, the
said amount may be adjusted. However, the respondent is directed
to deposit the necessary expenditure monthly for the minor
Criminal Revision Petition No.10 of 2023
Page |8
daughter in the Bank Account of the complainant including the
educational expenses before 10th of every calendar month.”
12.
On perusal of the said order dated 17.8.2017, the
learned Judicial Magistrate has passed the order by relying upon
the terms and conditions of the compromise recorded in Mat.
(Divorce) Suit No.82 of 2014.
Aggrieved by the order dated
17.8.2017, the respondent herein also filed Criminal Appeal No.9 of
2017 before the learned Sessions Judge, Imphal West and, by the
judgment dated 21.2.2018, the said appeal was dismissed as
devoid of merits. Challenging the dismissal of the criminal appeal,
the respondent has filed Criminal Revision Petition No.11 of 2018
before this Court.
This Court, by the order dated 30.5.2019,
dismissed the Criminal Revision Petition. While dismissing the
Criminal Revision Petition, this Court granted liberty to the
respondent to file appropriate petition before the Family Court for
enforcing the order made in Mat. (Div) Suit No.82 of 2014, dated
14.11.2016.
13.
In the present case, contrary to the terms of withdrawal
of the Criminal Complaint Case No.38 of 2014, the respondent had
pursued the said case. The learned Judicial Magistrate, by the
order dated 5.8.2019, held that the respondents (the petitioners
herein) have committed domestic violence against the complainant
Criminal Revision Petition No.10 of 2023
Page |9
(the respondent herein) and the respondents were restrained from
committing any form of domestic violence against the complainant.
The learned Judicial Magistrate further ordered that the first
respondent (first petitioner herein) shall pay a sum of Rs.3.00 lakh
as compensation to the complainant for committing the domestic
violence against the complainant within three months from the date
of the order.
In the said order, the learned Judicial Magistrate
recorded that the respondents 1 and 2 examined themselves as
D.W.1 and D.W.2 in chief, but no document was produced.
Thereafter, the learned Judicial Magistrate treated the petitioners
as ex parte and proceeded to pass orders. The aforesaid clearly
indicates that the chief examination of D.W.1 and D.W.2 was done
before recording the compromise in Mat. (Div) Suit No.82 of 2014
and the factum of compromise not bringing to the notice of the
learned Judicial Magistrate by the respondent is not appreciable. In
fact, she ought to have brought to the knowledge of he learned
Judicial Magistrate about the compromise, which contains the
withdrawal of the Criminal Complaint Case No.38 of 2014.
14.
According to the petitioners, both the learned Judicial
Magistrate and the learned Sessions Judge have completely erred
in passing the judgment and order dated 5.8.2019 passed in
Criminal Complaint Case No.38 of 2014 and the judgment and
Criminal Revision Petition No.10 of 2023
P a g e | 10
order dated 12.4.2023 passed in Criminal Appeal No.1 of 2022
respectively by keeping the order dated 14.11.2016 passed in Mat.
(Div) Suit No.82 of 2014 aside.
15.
From the impugned judgment dated 12.4.2023, it is
evident that the learned Sessions Judge framed the issue - whether
the impugned order of the trial Court can be sustainable when both
the parties settled their dispute in connection with Mat. (Div) Suit
No.82 of 2014 before the Family Court in which one of the
conditions is that the respondent shall withdraw the case?
16.
The learned Sessions Judge has reproduced the
terms and conditions entered between the parties and, after
extracting the terms and conditions, held as under:
“6.3
Admittedly,
the
defendant,
now
Respondent has not withdrawn Cril. (C) Case
No.38 of 2014 before the Judicial Magistrate
First Class, Imphal West-I which is one of the
condition of the Terms and Conditions of the
parties culminating into compromise. It is not
known whether other Terms or Conditions No.I&
II have been complied with. It is also not brought
into the record whether the defendant has
withdrawn Cril. (M) Case No.33 of 2014.
Whaever the case may be, the case settled by
the parties is Mat. (Div) Suit No.82 of 2014 and
Criminal Revision Petition No.10 of 2023
P a g e | 11
before the Ld. Family Court. The Terms and
Conditions under which the case was settled
were binding between the parties as if the same
was contract between them. Thus, in the event
of breaching any Term and Condition by any of
the
parties,
the
other
Execution/Enforcement
of
Party
may
file
the
Terms
&
Conditions of their agreement. In short, in this
case, the settlement was brought before the Ld.
Family Court and in case of breach of any of the
term and condition made by one party, the other
party is to approach the Ld. Family Court.
6.5 Further, it is seen that the case before the
Ld. Trial Court proceeded the case ex-parte on
the failure of the appearance of the present
appellant who appeared before the Ld. Trial
Court through Counsel even after the passing of
the compromise order. It is also seen that the
Respondent communicated the order of the Ld.
Family Court to the Ld. Trial Court who had
knowledge of the existence of the order but
proceeded apparently on the breach of the
condition.
I also find the Ld. Trial Court
considered the case minutely before giving its
decision on merit.”
17.
Despite formulating the issue referred supra, the
learned Sessions Judge without giving a finding as to the
Criminal Revision Petition No.10 of 2023
P a g e | 12
sustainability of the order impugned before him has disposed of the
appeal leaving the question of law raised and the issue framed
therein undecided.
The said finding arrived at by the learned
Sessions Judge is not legally sustainable.
Once the issue is
framed, the learned Sessions Judge ought to have answered the
issue. However, the learned Sessions Judge failed to do so. On
the other hand, the learned Sessions Judge in paragraph 6.6. held
that “the Sessions Court has no jurisdiction for executing/enforcing
the order passed by the learned Family Court in Mat. (Div) Suit
No.82 of 2014”.
18.
It is apposite to note that it is not the claim of the
petitioners as appellants before the learned Sessions Judge for
enforcement of the order passed in Mat. (Div) Suit No.82 of 2014.
As stated supra, the learned Sessions Judge ought to have
answered the issue once the issue is framed.
19.
Once the respondent agreed to withdraw the Criminal
Complaint Case No.38 of 2014 on compromise in another
proceedings, which is related to the matrimonial dispute, she should
honour the undertaking given in the compromise. On the contrary,
the respondent has pursued the said case. The act of respondent
in proceeding further the Criminal Complaint Case No.38 of 2014
before the learned Judicial Magistrate without intimating the Court
Criminal Revision Petition No.10 of 2023
P a g e | 13
as to the compromise entered by her with the petitioners is nothing
but abuse of process of law. The said fact has not been clearly
analysed by the learned Sessions Judge while delivering the
impugned judgment even though the compromise entered between
the respondent and the petitioners and the terms and conditions
made thereon was brought to the notice of the Court. In fact, the
learned Sessions Judge erred in holding that the Judicial Magistrate
has not committed any mistake. The further finding of the learned
Sessions Judge that there is no error either on law or facts in
arriving the impugned order by the learned trial Court is also
erroneous.
20.
As stated supra, despite service, the respondent has
not entered appearance in this matter.
21.
Upon considering the grounds of revision canvassed
by the appellants and also taking into consideration the overall
given facts and circumstances of the case, this Court is of the view
that the order of the learned Judicial Magistrate First Class as well
as the learned Sessions Judge impugned herein are not legally
sustainable and the same are liable to be set aside.
22.
In the result,
Criminal Revision Petition No.10 of 2023
P a g e | 14
(i)
The Criminal Revision Petition No.10
of 2023 is allowed.
(ii)
The order of the learned Sessions
Judge dated 12.4.2023 in Criminal
Appeal No.1 of 2022 and the order of
the learned Judicial Magistrate, First
Class, Imphal West dated 5.8.2019 in
Criminal Complaint Case No.38 of
2014 are set aside.
(iii)
No costs.
JUDGE
FR/NFR
Sushil
Criminal Revision Petition No.10 of 2023
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review