Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
W.P.(C)No.32980 of 2024
2025:KER:8986
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE ANIL K. NARENDRAN
&
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE MURALEE KRISHNA S.
MONDAY, THE 3
RD
DAY OF FEBRUARY 2025 / 14TH MAGHA, 1946
W.P.(C)NO.32980 OF 2024
PETITIONER:
LITTO JOSEPH,
AGED 43 YEARS
S/O JOSEPH, THENGUMKUDIYIL HOUSE, SINGUKANDOM,
SINGUKANDOM P.O., IDUKKI, KERALA, PIN - 685618
BY ADVS.
R. NANDAGOPAL
ASWIN KUMAR M J
ALBIN GEORGE
JEEVADAS H.
RESPONDENTS:
KERALA STATE ELECTRICITY BOARD - KSEB
RAJAKUMARI SECTION, RAJAKUMARI, IDUKKI DISTRICT
REPRESENTED BY ASSISTANT ENGINEER, PIN - 685619
CHINNAKANAL VILLAGE OFFICE
CHINNAKANAL VILLAGE, KERALA, REPRESENTED BY VILLAGE
OFFICER, PIN - 685618
CHINNAKANAL GRAMA PANCHAYAT
CHINNAKANAL, IDUKKI, REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY, PIN
- 685618
FOREST RANGE OFFICE
DEVIKULAM, MUNNAR, KERALA, REPRESENTED RANGE OFFICER,
PIN - 685613
ADDL. R5 (THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY)
REVENUE DEPARTMENT, GOVERNMENT SECRETARIAT,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM 695001.
W.P.(C)No.32980 of 2024
2025:KER:8986
ADDL R6 DISTRICT COLLECTOR
COLLECTORATE, KUYILIMALA, PAINAV P.O., IDUKKI 685603
(ADDL. R5 AND R6 ARE IMPLEADED AS PER ORDER DATED
22/10/24 IN IA 1/24 IN WPC 32980/24).
[ THE DESCRIPTION OF THE ADDITIONAL 5TH RESPONDENT IS
SUO MOTO CORRECTED AS " STATE OF KERALA, REPRESENTED
BY THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT, REVENUE
DEPARTMENT" INSTEAD OF ‘THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY,
REVENUE DEPARTMENT" AS PER ORDER DATED 22/10/24 IN
WP(C) 32980/2024]
OTHER PRESENT:
SRI. NAGARAJ NARAYANAN, SPL. GP (FOREST)
SRI. K. R. PRATHISH, SC, CHINNAKANAL GRAMAPANCHAYAT
SRI. B. PREMOD, SC, KSEB
THIS WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON
03.02.2025, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
W.P.(C)No.32980 of 2024
2025:KER:8986
“C.R”
JUDGMENT
Anil K. Narendran, J.
The petitioner, who claims to be in possession and enjoyment
of 16.47 Ares (40.68 cents) of Government Puramboke in
Sy.No.34/1 of Chinnakanal Village from 14.05.2024, has filed this
writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, seeking
a writ of mandamus commanding the 4th respondent Range Forest
Officer, Devikulam Range, to issue No Objection Certificate,
forthwith to the 1st respondent Kerala State Electricity Board,
Electrical
Section,
Rajakumari;
and
a
writ
of
mandamus
commanding the 1st respondent Board to provide approval for
electricity connection to the building located in the said land
forthwith.
2.
The averments in paragraphs 1 and 2 of the writ
petition regarding the possession and enjoyment of the aforesaid
land by the petitioner, read thus;
“1. Petitioner is in possession and enjoyment of 16.47 Ares
(40.68 cents) of Government puramboke land in Survey No.
34/1 of 2nd respondent village office from 14.05.2024. A
true copy of the BTR issued by the 2nd respondent dated nil
is produced herewith and marked as Ext.P1. A true copy of
W.P.(C)No.32980 of 2024
the tax receipt dated 21.08.2024 issued by
2025:KER:8986
the 2 nd
respondent is produced herewith and marked as Ext.P2.
2. Petitioner had purchased this land for doing cardamom
farming. For the same, he had to build a small 350 Sq.ft.
temporary steel structure for the purpose of storage, light,
motor, temporary shelter for the person looking after the
land, etc. It is needless to say that for cardamom farming,
water is required in high quantity. The temporary building
structure was erected, and the same was numbered 150/UA
in ward 9 of the 3rd respondent Panchayat. A true copy of
the ownership certificate issued by the 3rd respondent
Panchayat dated 07.08.2024 is produced herewith and
marked as Ext.P3. A true copy of the building tax receipt
issued by the 3rd respondent Panchayat with respect to
building No.150/UA in ward 9 of the 3rd respondent
Panchayat dated 14.06.2024 is produced herewith and
marked as Ext.P4.”
3.
On 13.09.2024, when this writ petition came up for
consideration, the matter was directed to be placed before the
Division Bench dealing with matters relating to the land in Munnar
Region, after obtaining orders of the Honourable the Acting Chief
Justice. Thereafter, this writ petition was listed before this Division
Bench.
4.
On 30.09.2024, when this writ petition came up for
consideration, after arguing for some time, the learned counsel for
the petitioner sought time to file an application to implead the
W.P.(C)No.32980 of 2024
2025:KER:8986
State of Kerala, represented by the Principal Secretary to
Government, Revenue Department and the District Collector,
Idukki District as additional respondents. On a query made by this
Court, the learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that the
building in question was constructed in June 2024, without
obtaining a building permit from the Secretary of Chinnakanal
Grama Panchayat.
5.
By the order dated 22.10.2024 in I.A.No.1 of 2024,
State of Kerala, represented by the Principal Secretary to
Government, Revenue Department and the District Collector,
Idukki were impleaded as additional respondents 5 and 6. The
learned
Special
Government
Pleader
sought
time
to
get
instructions and file a counter affidavit of the 4th respondent Forest
Range Officer, Devikulam.
6.
The 4th respondent has filed a counter affidavit dated
03.12.2024, opposing the reliefs sought for in this writ petition,
producing therewith Ext.R4(a) to R4(c) documents. In paragraph
8 of that counter affidavit, the 4th respondent pointed out that the
document marked as Ext.P2 is not a tax receipt, as stated in the
writ petition. It is only a receipt issued from the office of the Village
Officer, Chinnakanal, collecting the fee for obtaining a copy of the
W.P.(C)No.32980 of 2024
2025:KER:8986
BTR. Regarding the averments in paragraph 2 of the writ petition,
it is stated in paragraph 9 of the counter affidavit that the
petitioner is an encroacher on Government land. The land claimed
to be in possession of the petitioner in Sy.No.34/1 of Chinnakanal
Village of Devikulam Taluk is an area situated within the
jurisdiction of the Divisional Forest Range, Munnar Forest Division.
Sy.No.34/1 of Chinnakanal Village. The Government land in the
said survey numbers spreads over an extent of 2122.88 Acres. In
some areas in Sy.No.34/1, the Government has granted pattas.
Except for such areas, most of the Government land in in
Sy.No.34/1 is under the control and possession of the Forest
Department, wherein various plantations have been raised. The
petitioner has not stated the exact details of the land claimed to
be in his possession. Only a part of the said land is now under the
control of the Forest Department since the said area is proposed
as a reserve forest. The Forest Department has control and
possession of major portions of Government land in Sy.No.34/1
and old Sy.No.20/1, excluding the proposed reserve forest. In the
counter affidavit dated 03.12.2024, the 4th respondent has denied
various averments in the writ petition. The Secretary of the 3 rd
W.P.(C)No.32980 of 2024
2025:KER:8986
respondent Chinnakanal Grama Panchayat has also filed a counter
affidavit dated 08.01.2025.
7.
Heard the learned counsel for the petitioner, the
learned Standing Counsel for KSEB for the 1st respondent, the
learned Standing Counsel for Chinnakanal Grama Panchayat for
the 3rd respondent and the learned Special Government Pleader
(Forest) for respondents 2, 4 and also for additional respondents
5 and 6.
8.
The issue that requires consideration in this writ
petition is as to whether the petitioner is entitled to any of the
reliefs
sought
for
in
this
writ
petition,
by
invoking
the
extraordinary jurisdiction of this Court under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India.
9.
In Bharat Singh v. State of Haryana [(1988) 4
SCC 534] the Apex Court held that, when a point which is
ostensibly a point of law is required to be substantiated by facts,
the party raising the point, if he is the writ petitioner, must plead
and prove such facts by evidence which must appear from the writ
petition and if he is the respondent, from the counter affidavit. If
the facts are not pleaded or the evidence in support of such facts
is not annexed to the writ petition or to the counter affidavit, as
W.P.(C)No.32980 of 2024
2025:KER:8986
the case may be, the Court will not entertain the point. The Apex
Court held further that there is a distinction between a pleading
under the Code of Civil Procedure Code, 1908 and a writ petition
or a counter affidavit. While in a pleading, i.e., a plaint or a written
statement, the facts and not evidence are required to be pleaded,
in a writ petition or in the counter affidavit not only the facts but
also the evidence in proof of such facts have to be pleaded and
annexed to it.
10.
In M/s.Larsen and Toubro Ltd. v. State of Gujarat
[(1998) 4 SCC 387] the Apex Court was dealing with a case
arising out of the proceedings initiated for the acquisition of land
for M/s.Larsen and Toubro Ltd. under the provisions of the Land
Acquisition Act, 1894. The Apex Court noticed that, in the absence
of any allegation that Rule 3 the Land Acquisition (Companies)
Rules, 1963 had not been complied and there being no particulars
in respect of non compliance of Rule 4 also, it is difficult to see as
to how the High Court could have reached the finding that
statutory requirements contained in these Rules were not fulfilled
before issuance of notification under Section 4 and declaration
under Section 6 of the Land Acquisition Act. High Court did not
give any reason as to how it reached the conclusion that Rules 3
W.P.(C)No.32980 of 2024
2025:KER:8986
and 4 had not been complied in the face of the record of the case.
Rather, it returned a finding which is unsustainable that it was "not
possible on the basis of the material on record to hold that there
was compliance with Rules 3 and 4". The Apex Court held that, it
is not enough to allege that a particular Rule or any provision has
not been complied. It is a requirement of good pleading to give
details, i.e., particulars as to why it is alleged that there is non
compliance with a statutory requirement. Ordinarily, no notice can
be taken on such an allegation which is devoid of any particulars.
No issue can be raised on a plea, the foundation of which is
lacking. Even where rule nisi is issued, it is not always for the
department to justify its action when the court finds that a plea
has been advanced without any substance, though ordinarily
department may have to place its full cards before the court. On
the facts of the case, the Apex Court found that the State has
more than justified its stand that there has been compliance not
only with Rule 4 but with Rule 3 as well, though there was no
challenge to Rule 3 and the averments regarding non compliance
with Rule 4 were sketchy and without any particulars whatsoever.
High Court was, therefore, not right in quashing the acquisition
proceedings.
W.P.(C)No.32980 of 2024
11.
2025:KER:8986
In Narmada Bachao Andolan v. State of Madhya
Pradesh [(2011) 7 SCC 639] a Three-Judge Bench of the Apex
Court held that it is a settled proposition of law that a party has
to plead its case and produce/adduce sufficient evidence to
substantiate the averments made in the petition and in case the
pleadings are not complete the Court is under no obligation to
entertain the pleas. Pleadings and particulars are required to
enable the court to decide the rights of the parties in the trial.
Thus, the pleadings are more to help the court in narrowing the
controversy involved and to inform the parties concerned to the
question(s) in issue, so that the parties may adduce appropriate
evidence on the said issue. It is settled legal proposition that as a
rule relief not founded on the pleadings should not be granted.
Therefore, a decision of a case cannot be based on grounds
outside the pleadings of the parties. The object and purpose of
pleadings and issues is to ensure that the litigants come to trial
with all issues clearly defined and to prevent cases being
expanded or grounds being shifted during trial. If any factual or
legal issue, despite having merit, has not been raised by the
parties, the court should not decide the same as the opposite
counsel does not have a fair opportunity to answer the line of
W.P.(C)No.32980 of 2024
2025:KER:8986
reasoning adopted in that regard. Such a judgment may be
violative of the principles of natural justice.
12.
The averment in the writ petition is that the petitioner
had purchased land having an extent of 16.47 Ares (40.68 cents)
in Sy.No.34/1 of Chinnakanal Village, which is a Government
Puramboke, for cardamom cultivation and has built a 350 sq.ft.
temporary steel structure for the purpose of storage, etc. and as
a temporary shelter for persons looking after the land. The
document placed on record in support of the said claim is Ext.P2
receipt
dated
21.08.2024
issued
from
the
Village
Office,
Chinnakkanal. Though the said document is marked as a tax
receipt dated 21.08.2024, as stated in the counter affidavit dated
03.12.2024 filed by the 4th respondent Range Forest Officer,
Devikulam Range, Ext.P2 receipt issued from the office of the
Village Officer, Chinnakanal, is only a receipt for the fee collected
for obtaining a copy of Ext.P1 BTR. The document marked as
Ext.P3 is an ownership certificate dated 07.08.2024 obtained by
the petitioner in respect of building bearing No.150/UA in Ward
No.9 of Chinnakanal Grama Panchayat. The said building is the
temporary shed (350 sq. ft.) referred to in paragraph 2 of the
statement of facts of the writ petition. Though the averments in
W.P.(C)No.32980 of 2024
2025:KER:8986
paragraph 2 of the statement of facts are that the said shed is
intended for the purpose of storage, etc. and as a temporary
shelter for persons looking after the land, the averment in Ext.P6
application dated 09.08.2024 made by the petitioner before the
4th respondent Forest Range Officer is that he is residing in
building bearing No.9/150/UA in Chinnakanal Grama Panchayat,
which is one constructed for residential purpose. In the writ
petition, the petitioner has not disclosed the date on which he got
possession and enjoyment of Government land having an extent
of 16.47 Ares (40.68 cents) in Sy.No.34/1 of Chinnakanal Village
or the date on which he had put up the temporary shed (350 sq.
ft.) in the said land. From the pleading and materials on record, it
prima facie appears that the petitioner had put up the said shed
on the property only in the year 2024.
13.
pending
In W.P.(C)Nos.34095 of 2007 and 1801 of 2010
before
this
Court,
which
relates
to
large
scale
encroachment of revenue and forest lands, issuance of forged
patta, etc., adversely affecting even the upkeep of the terrain of
Munnar, a Division Bench of this Court passed an order dated
21.01.2010, after recording the submission made by the learned
Additional Advocate General, on behalf of the State of Kerala, that
W.P.(C)No.32980 of 2024
2025:KER:8986
no construction could be carried out in Munnar without No
Objection Certificate from Revenue Department and without
permission from the Grama Panchayat. Paragraphs 15 to 21 and
also the last paragraph of the order dated 21.01.2010 read thus;
“15. Environmental Laws, Laws relating to Mining and
Geology and various other aspects are required and are
in place to ensure that Nature is preserved and she is
subjected only to such necessary intrusion, for sustaining
development. Mining of even ordinary earth, as also
laterite, rocks etc. could have been had only with proper
permissions through competent officers in accordance
with the relevant Rules and Regulations. If large scale
excavation of soil, as reported by the Principal Secretary
and by the Additional Director General of Intelligence,
have happened, obviously, that is in violation of the laws.
The concept of the Government collecting royalty and
even imposing fine or both, would in no manner
substitute the harm, for, it is seldom possible to restore
earth to her original situation, even with abundant
human effort made with the aid of funds.
16. In the aforesaid circumstances, the Government will
place on record, without fail, reports on the entire action
taken on the basis of the reports which are Exts.P2 to P4
in W.P.(C)No.34095 of 2007, more particularly, regarding
the action taken against the identified officers who were
duty bound to discharge duties and responsibilities as
noted above and have not done so. It shall be stated as
to whether action has been taken against any particular
W.P.(C)No.32980 of 2024
2025:KER:8986
officer. The total number of criminal cases registered and
preventive action, if any, taken shall be reported.
17. For the time being, we record the submission of the
learned Additional Advocate General on behalf of the
State that no construction activity could be carried out in
Munnar without No Objection Certificate from the
Revenue Department and without permission of the
Panchayat.
18. Hence, it is hereby ordered that the Revenue
Officials, Local Self Government Authorities, the Police
and Forest Authorities shall ensure that no construction
activity takes place in Munnar without No Objection
Certificate being issued by the Revenue Department and
without permission being given by the Panchayat
authorities, except in cases which are governed by Court
orders.
19. It is further ordered that the revenue authorities and
police officials of Munnar shall forthwith see that there is
no mining of any type of sand, earth, rocks, granite,
laterite etc. from any part of Munnar for a period of two
months until otherwise ordered by this Court.
20. It shall also be ensured that encroachment, if any, in
river puramboke are immediately identified and action
taken in terms of the appropriate laws for getting back
possession of such parcels. It is further ordered that no
construction activity would be permitted on the shores of
rivers and riverbeds.
21. Having regard to the different provisions of the
Panchayat Raj Act, the different laws and also the
requirement that the entire Munnar area requires to be
W.P.(C)No.32980 of 2024
2025:KER:8986
immediately looked into by the Revenue Department, the
Revenue Department and the Forest Department will
place reports as are necessary for further management
of the situation by the next date of posting.”
14.
‘Munnar area’ as defined in clause (g) of Section 2 of
Munnar Special Tribunal Act, 2010 mean all lands comprised in the
villages of Chinnakkanal, Kannan Devan Hills, Santhanpara,
Vellathooval, Aanavilasam, Pallivasal, Aanaviratty and Bison Valley
in Devikulam and Udumbanchola Taluks in Idukki District. [Kannan
Devan Hills Village later bifurcated to Edamalakkudy Village and
Mankulam Village].
15.
The order dated 21.01.2010 in W.P.(C)No.34095 of
2007 and W.P.(C)No.1801 of 2010 was followed by a series of
orders in those writ petitions and also the tagged matters. In view
of the prohibitory orders issued by the Division Bench, which is in
force from 21.01.2010 onwards, any constructions in Munnar
region, which fall within the purview of the aforesaid orders, is
permissible only after obtaining a No Objection Certificate from
the Revenue Department.
16.
In the judgment dated 23.04.2024 in W.P.(C)No.16230
of 2024, this Court noticed the submission made by the learned
Special Government Pleader that in the process of verification, the
W.P.(C)No.32980 of 2024
2025:KER:8986
genuinity of the patta and other aspects are also being considered
by the Revenue officials and it is only thereafter that a No
Objection Certificate is being granted.
17.
In the instant case, the land in question falls in
Chinnakannal Village, which is an area within the purview of the
order dated 21.01.2010 of the Division Bench in W.P.(C)No.1801
of 2010. As already noticed, from the pleading and materials on
record, it prima facie appears that the petitioner had put up the
shed on the property in question only in the year 2024.
by
18.
On a query made by this Court, the submission made
the
learned
Standing
Counsel
for
Chinnakanal
Grama
Panchayat is that, as stated in the counter affidavit
dated
08.01.2025 filed by the 3rd respondent, based on the application
made by the petitioner on 22.05.2024 for assigning building
number, the Secretary of the Grama Panchayat assigned only ‘U.A.
number’ for the shed, in view of the circular No.48297/RA.1/
09/LSGD dated 10.08.2009 issued by the Local Self Government
(R.A.) Department for the purpose of issuing temporary building
numbers to residential huts situated in Puramboke lands.
19.
As already noticed hereinbefore, in the order dated
21.01.2010 in W.P.(C)No.1801 of 2010 the Division Bench
W.P.(C)No.32980 of 2024
2025:KER:8986
recorded the submission made by the learned Additional Advocate
General, on behalf of the State of Kerala, that no construction
could be carried out in Munnar without No Objection Certificate
from Revenue Department and without permission from the
Grama Panchayat. As noticed in the judgment dated 23.04.2024
in W.P.(C)No.16230 of 2024, in the process of verification, the
genuinity of the patta and other aspects are also being considered
by the Revenue officials and it is only thereafter that a No
Objection Certificate is being granted. Therefore, when the area in
question is in Munnar region covered by the prohibitory orders
issued by the Division Bench in W.P.(C)No.1801 of 2010 and
connected matters, in the absence of a No Objection Certificate
issued by the Revenue Department, the Secretary of the 3 rd
respondent Chinnakanal Grama Panchayat should not have
assigned ‘UA number’ to the shed put up by the petitioner in the
property in question. Further, the said shed, which is intended for
the purpose of storage, etc. and as a temporary shelter for persons
looking after the land would not fall under the category of ‘huts
for residential purpose’ referred to circular No.48297/RA.1/
09/LSGD dated 10.08.2009 issued by the Local Self Government
(R.A.) Department.
W.P.(C)No.32980 of 2024
20.
2025:KER:8986
The specific stand taken in the counter affidavit filed by
the 4th respondent Range Forest Officer, Devikulam Range is that
Ext.P3 ownership certificate dated 07.08.2024 and Ext.P4 building
tax receipt dated 14.06.2024 issued by the 3rd respondent
Chinnakanal Grama Panchayat in respect of the shed put up by
the petitioner in the property in question are collusive and illegal
acts, for creating documents for trespassers and encroachers of
Government land, so as to enable such persons to make claim in
respect of encroached Government land. A perusal of Ext.P4
receipt would show remittance of building tax for the first and
second half of the year 2024-25. It is immediately after the
issuance of Ext.P4 receipt dated 14.06.2024 that the Secretary of
the 3rd respondent Grama Panchayat issued Ext.P3 ownership
certificate dated 07.08.2024 to the petitioner, in respect of the
shed bearing No.150/UA in Ward No.9, put up in the property in
question. In the counter affidavit dated 08.01.2025 filed on behalf
of the 3rd respondent Grama Panchayat, which is one sworn to by
the Assistant Secretary, who is holding charge of the Secretary,
nothing has been stated as to the date on which the petitioner has
put up that structure on the property in question and whether it is
W.P.(C)No.32980 of 2024
2025:KER:8986
for the first time that the building tax in respect of that shed was
collected during the first half of 2024-25.
21.
The learned Special Government Pleader (Forest)
would point out the specific stand taken in the counter affidavit
filed by the 4th respondent Range Forest Officer, Devikulam Range
that the area where the petitioner had put up an illegal
construction is in Singukandam area of Chinnakanal where there
are several issues of other encroachments and human-wild
elephant conflict. The petitioner, who claims to have purchased the
Government Puramboke on 30.05.2024, has put up a home stay
type house with two rooms by erecting iron pipes and the roof is
covered with tint sheets. In the surrounding area there are
eucalyptus trees. The other houses and cardamom cultivation
found in the adjacent areas are illegal. None of the encroachers in
Singukandam area are issued with patta. In the said area humans
died due to attack by elephants on 19.11.2012, 09.06.2017 and
07.12.2017. About 100 meters from the shed put up by the
petitioner, a person by name Babu was stamped to death by a wild
elephant on 30.03.2021. The area where a home stay is being
constructed by the petitioner and its surroundings are elephant
corridors and elephant habitat.
W.P.(C)No.32980 of 2024
22.
2025:KER:8986
The specific stand taken in the counter affidavit filed by
the 4th respondent Range Forest Officer is that the land in question
is under his jurisdiction. As per Section 66 of the Kerala Forest Act,
1961, every forest officer and police officer shall prevent and may
interfere for the purpose of preventing the commission of any
forest offence and shall have power to evict all encroachers and
squatters from reserved forest or other lands under the control of
the Forest Department and to confiscate or demolish any sheds or
other structures put up in such lands. Forest officers shall have
the powers of the police officers for the purpose of investigation
or prevention of forest offences and the collection of evidence.
Therefore, the 4th respondent Range Forest Officer and also the
Deputy Range Officer, who is the subordinate officer of the 4 th
respondent, who are empowered to prevent commission of offence
in respect of reserved forest or other lands under the control of
the Forest Department, is not legally bound to issue a no-objection
certificate to the petitioner for getting electric connection to the
shed put up by him after encroaching the Government land. In
paragraph 25 of the counter affidavit, the 4th respondent has
stated that the disputed land is a prime elephant habitat and a
herd of 18 wild elephants are roaming in the said habitat.
W.P.(C)No.32980 of 2024
2025:KER:8986
Therefore, unscientific drawing of power lines by the 1 st
respondent Kerala State Electricity Board, without consulting the
Forest Department, could be detrimental to the aforesaid 18
elephants roaming in the area, which is their primary habitat,
causing danger to the lives of those elephants. In the counter
affidavit it is pointed out that any consequential danger to the wild
elephants will attract the offence of hunting, punishable under the
Wildlife (Protection) Act, 1972.
23.
Along with the counter affidavit filed by the 4th
respondent, Ext.R4(a) notification dated 20.09.2023 issued by the
Forest and Wildlife (C) Department under Section 4 of the Kerala
Forest Act, 1961 notifying 364.89 hectares (901.66 acres) of land
comprised in various survey numbers of Chinnakanal Village, as
proposed reserve forest, is placed on record. The documents
marked as Exts.R4(b) and R4(c) are occurrence reports filed
before the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court, Nedumkandam as
O.R.Nos.28/2019 and 22/2021 of the Devikulam Forest Range in
connection with the killing of two elephants by electrocution from
the illegal power fences drawn and connected directly from the
electric posts erected by KSEB near 301 colony.
W.P.(C)No.32980 of 2024
24.
2025:KER:8986
In Bihar Eastern Gangetic Fishermen Cooperative
Society Ltd. v. Sipahi Singh [(1977) 4 SCC 145], a ThreeJudge Bench of the Apex Court held that a writ of mandamus can
be granted only in a case where there is a statutory duty imposed
upon the officer concerned and there is a failure on the part of
that officer to discharge the statutory obligation. The chief
function of a writ is to compel performance of public duties
prescribed by statute and to keep subordinate tribunals and
officers exercising public functions within the limit of their
jurisdiction.
25.
In Oriental Bank of Commerce v. Sunder Lal Jain
[(2008) 2 SCC 280] the Apex Court held that in order that a writ
of mandamus may be issued, there must be a legal right with the
party asking for the writ to compel the performance of some
statutory duty cast upon the authorities. In the said decision, the
Apex Court noticed that the principles on which a writ of
mandamus can be issued have been stated in 'The Law of
Extraordinary Legal Remedies' by F. G. Ferris and F. G. Ferris, Jr.
that, mandamus is, subject to the exercise of a sound judicial
discretion, the appropriate remedy to enforce a plain, positive,
specific and ministerial duty presently existing and imposed by law
W.P.(C)No.32980 of 2024
2025:KER:8986
upon officers and others who refuse or neglect to perform such
duty, when there is no other adequate and specific legal remedy
and without which there would be a failure of justice.
26.
The 4th respondent Range Forest Officer, who has a
statutory duty under Section 66 of the Kerala Forest Act, 1961 to
prevent commission of any forest offence and the power to evict
all encroachers from the reserve forest or other lands under the
control of the Forest Department and to confiscate or demolish
any sheds or other structures put up in such lands, cannot be
directed by way of a writ of mandamus, to issue a no-objection
certificate, as sought for in Ext.P6 application dated 09.08.2024,
in respect of the shed unauthorisedly put up by the petitioner in
the land in question, so as to enable him to get electric connection
from the 1st respondent KSEB. Since the said land falls within
Munnar
region,
in
view
of
the
orders
of
this
Court
in
W.P.(C)No.1801 of 2010, the petitioner who have put up such a
structure in the year 2024, without obtaining No Objection
Certificate from the Revenue Department, cannot obtain electric
connection to the said shed, on the strength of Ext.P3 ownership
certificate dated 07.08.2024 issued by the Secretary of the 3rd
W.P.(C)No.32980 of 2024
2025:KER:8986
respondent Chinnakanal Grama Panchayat and Ext.P4 building tax
receipt dated 14.06.2024.
27.
In such circumstances, the petitioner is not entitled to
any of the reliefs sought for in this writ petition. In the result, this
writ petition fails and the same is accordingly dismissed.
Registry to incorporate a copy of this judgment in the judges'
papers of W.P.(C)No.1801 of 2010, in which this Court noticed
indiscriminate issuance of building permits by the Secretary of
Chinnakanal Grama Panchayat, openly flouting the prohibitory
orders issued by this Court in that writ petition and connected
matters. By the order passed in W.P.(C)No.1801 of 2010, the
Secretary of the Grama Panchayat was directed to be personally
present in Court. Before the date of appearance, the Secretary of
the Grama Panchayat was placed under suspension and at
present, the Assistant Secretary, who has sworn to the counter
affidavit dated 08.01.2025 of the 3rd respondent, is holding charge
of the Secretary.
Sd/ANIL K. NARENDRAN, JUDGE
Sd/MURALEE KRISHNA S., JUDGE
MIN
W.P.(C)No.32980 of 2024
2025:KER:8986
APPENDIX OF WP(C) 32980/2024
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
EXHIBIT P1
TRUE COPY OF THE BTR ISSUED BY 2ND
RESPONDENT DATED NIL
EXHIBIT P2
TRUE COPY OF THE TAX RECEIPT DATED
21/08/2024 ISSUED BY THE 2ND
RESPONDENT
EXHIBIT P3
TRUE COPY OF THE OWNERSHIP
CERTIFICATE ISSUED BY THE 3RD
RESPONDENT PANCHAYATH DATED
07.08.2024
EXHIBIT P4
TRUE COPY OF THE BUILDING TAX
RECEIPT ISSUED BY THE 3RD RESPONDENT
PANCHAYATH WITH RESPECT TO BUILDING
NUMBER 150/UA IN WARD 9 OF 3RD
RESPONDENT PANCHAYATH DATED
14.06.2024
EXHIBIT P5
A CUSTOMER COPY OF THE APPLICATION
DATED NIL MADE TO THE 1ST RESPONDENT
BOARD
EXHIBIT P6
A TRUE COPY OF THE APPLICATION DATED
09/08/2024 MADE BY THE PETITIONER
WITH THE 4TH RESPONDENT
EXHIBIT P7
A TRUE COPY OF THE CERTIFICATE
NO.42/2024 DATED 30/08/2024 ISSUED
BY THE 2ND RESPONDENT
RESPONDENT EXHIBITS
EXHIBITR4(A)
TRUE COPY OF THE NOTIFICATION ISSUED
VIDE GO(P)19/2023/F AND WLD DATED
20.09.2023
EXHIBITR4(B)
TRUE COPY OF THE FORM NO.1 IN OA
28/2019
EXHIBITR4(C)
TRUE COPY OF FORM NO.1 IN OA 22/2021
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review