Judgments
LegalFirms.in Judgments · legalfirms.in/judgments/lingaraj-shivadhani-vs-the-commissioner-of-police-and-anr-20260127/ · Printed 20 Nov 2026
Constitutional

Lingaraj @ Shivadhani vs The Commissioner of Police and Anr

Add to a compilation

Keep judgments in folders, mark the paragraphs you rely on, and print a compilation with an index. It comes with the Research and Advocate Pro judgment plans and with a campus licence. Sign in · See the plans

Court
Karnataka High Court
Date
27 January 2026
Case No.
WP 201093/2024
Result
Allowed
Bench
Pradeep Singh Yerur
Cite this judgment
Citation
Link for your website or blog
Cite the court's own record or the law report in court filings.

Full Judgment Text

Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs, CC BY 4.0). The court's own copy is the authoritative text.

-1- " ! % & # "$ # " ' & ( !" #$ % " $ & Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA " '$ " !" $ $ $ ( " # % " & $ !!* $ ' $$ ' !!) ' $ $ ' ' ' " & -2- % $ $ ! ! & " "! $ & $ + " ,"! !, $ $ $ $ $ ' ' - ' $ $ $ . / " ' $ $ " $ $ '1234 56 378 2148 198 3713 378 :83;3;5<89 ;4 1 =>4;<844?1< 984;@;<A ;< 1B1=>91A;" 3 ;4 25<38<@8@ 3713 1 C14 98A;43898@ 1A1;<43 5" ! ! C;37;< 378 D>9;4@;23;5< 56 313;5< 1B1=>91A;" :83;3;5<89 313;5< ;< 9;?8 1E19 $5B;28 78 2719A8 47883 21?8 35 =8 6;B8@ 1A1;<43 37;4 :83;3;5<89 659 378 5668<284 :><;471=B8 ><@89 823;5<4 *F 1<@ 56 $ " 3 ;4 1B45 25<38<@8@ 3713 378 :83;3;5<89 714 5=31;<8@ 1<3;2;:1359G =1;B ;< 378 1=5H8 41;@ 2148" 148@ 5< 378 98A;43913;5< 56 378 29;?8 1<@ 6;B;<A 56 378 2719A8 47883 984:5<@8<3 :5B;28 5:8<8@ >: 1 95C@G 47883 =819;<A 5"! ! ! 1A1;<43 378 :83;3;5<89 7898;<" -3- !" 3 ;4 25<38<@8@ =G B819<8@ 25><48B 659 378 :83;3;5<89 3713 5< 378 =14;4 56 378 5C@G 8A;4389 984:5<@8<3 :5B;28 714 =88< 698I>8<3BG 4>??5<;<A 378 :83;3;5<89 35 378 :5B;28 4313;5< 1<@ 59@89;<A 7;? 35 4;3 378 8<3;98 @1G ;< 378 :5B;28 4313;5< C;375>3 37898 =8;<A 1<G 25?:B1;<3 ' 59 8H8< 1< 1BB8A13;5< 1A1;<43 378 :83;3;5<89 @84:;38 378 6123 3713 78 ;4 <53 98I>;98@ ;< 1<G 2148 659 1<G ;<H843;A13;5< C713458H89" " 3 ;4 6>93789 25<38<@8@ 3713 378 :83;3;5<89 714 =88< ?8<31BBG 7191448@ 1<@ <53 1=B8 35 >3;B;48 7;4 H1B>1=B8 3;?8 C7;27 ;4 <5C 4:8<3 ;< H;4;3;<A 378 :5B;28 4313;5< C;375>3 37898 =8;<A 1<G 25?:B1;<3 98A;43898@ 59 1<G =14;4 C7;27 ;4 ;< 3531B H;5B13;5< 56 378 6><@1?8<31B 9;A734 8<479;<8@ ;< 378 5<43;3>3;5< 56 <@;1 98439;23;<A 1<@ 984391;<;<A 378 6988@5? 56 ?5H8?8<3 1<@ 378 6><@1?8<31B 9;A734 78986598 2;3;E8< <1?8BG :83;3;5<89 7898;<" :83;3;5<89 4>=?;338@ 98:9848<313;5< 5< " ,"! !, 35 98H;8C 1<@ 98?5H8 7;4 <1?8 695? 378 5C@G 8A;4389" >3 984:5<@8<3 5" 714 <53 -4- :1448@ 1<G 59@89 ;< 984:823 56 378 98:9848<313;5< 45 4>=?;338@" 8<28 B863 C;37 <5 53789 1B389<13;H8 866;212;5>4 98?8@G :83;3;5<89 ;4 :8965928@ 35 1::95127 37;4 5>93 659 ;<@>BA8<28" ," 3 ;4 6>93789 25<38<@8@ =G B819<8@ 25><48B 659 378 :83;3;5<89 3713 378 984:5<@8<3 1>3759;3;84 :9;?19;BG ;<H5J8@ 59 5:8<8@ 378 95C@G 47883 1A1;<43 378 :83;3;5<89 C;375>3 65BB5C;<A 378 :95H;4;5<4 56 378 1<>1B F) 19<131J1 $5B;28 ?598 4:82;6;21BBG 431<@;<A 59@89 5" F 1<@ 378 :9528@>98 25<38?:B138@ 37898;< C;37 98A19@ 35 378 ;<39;212;84 8<>?89138@ 37898;< ;<2B>@;<A <1?;<A 378 :83;3;5<89 14 C783789 $193 53789 :9528@>984 $193 25<38?:B138@ 59 $193 1<@ 65BB5C;<A 37898;<" ;4 1B45 25<38<@8@ =G B819<8@ 25><48B 3713 378 984:5<@8<34 198 J88< 35 =91<@ 378 :83;3;5<89 14 1 95C@G" 78986598 C78< 378 :83;3;5<89 ?1@8 1< 1::B;213;5< 59 98:9848<313;5< 378 984:5<@8<3 1>3759;3;84 98:9848<313;5< 1<@ 5>A73 71H8 1228:38@ :95H;@8@ 1< 5::593><;3G :83;3;5<89 35 :>365937 7;4 2148 1<@ 3713 378 ;<2B>4;5< 56 7;4 -5- <1?8 1<@ 25<3;<>;<A 7;4 <1?8 ;< 378 5C@G 8A;4389 ;4 H;5B13;H8 378 :9;<2;:B84 56 <13>91B D>43;28 ;<2B>@;<A 7;4 :8945<1B B;=893G" 3 ;4 6>93789 25<38<@8@ =G B819<8@ 25><48B 3713 37898 ;4 1BB :544;=;B;3;84 3713 378 :83;3;5<89 ?1G =8 ;?:B;2138@ ;< 53789 ><<8284419G 21484 14 :83;3;5<89 ;4 H>B<891=B8 35 =8 @91AA8@ ;<35 378 :5B;28 4313;5< 1<@ 691?8@ ;< 45?8 21484 C7898 78 ;4 <53 8H8< ;<H5BH8@" ::198<3BG 37898 ;4 <5 2148 :8<@;<A 1A1;<43 378 :83;3;5<89 ;< 1<G 56 378 :5B;28 4313;5<4" " 3 ;4 6>93789 25<38<@8@ =G B819<8@ 25><48B 659 378 :83;3;5<89 3713 378 :83;3;5<89 @584 <53 61BB ;<35 378 =912J83 56 431<@;<A 59@89 5" F 56 378 19<131J1 $5B;28 1<>1B 1<@ 78 5>A73 <53 35 71H8 =88< ;<2B>@8@ ;< 378 5C@G 8A;4389 =G 378 984:5<@8<34 37898=G 2>9=;<A 378 6><@1?8<31B 9;A73 56 378 :83;3;5<89 ;<2B>@;<A 93;2B8 1<@ 3 ;4 1B45 93;2B8 ! 56 378 5<43;3>3;5< 56 <@;1" F 25<38<@8@ =G B819<8@ 25><48B 3713 378 :83;3;5<8904 <1?8 714 =88< ;<2B>@8@ ;< 378 95C@G 47883 C;375>3 25<@>23;<A 1<G 8<I>;9G <59 :95H;@;<A 1< 5::593><;3G 56 7819;<A 59 -6- 21BB;<A 659 1<G 8K:B1<13;5< 59 65BB5C;<A 378 :9528@>98 25<38?:B138@ ><@89 378 19<131J1 $5B;28 4:82;6;21BBG 431<@;<A 59@89 @84:;38 5" F" 98:9848<313;5< 1<>1B ?598 3 ;4 1B45 25<38<@8@ =8;<A ?1@8 :83;3;5<8904 <1?8 ;4 <53 439>2J 566 695? 378 8<39G ;< 378 98A;4389 56 95C@;84 37898=G 21>4;<A ><35B@ 719@47;: 1<@ H;5B13;5< 56 7;4 6><@1?8<31B 9;A73 56 6988 ?5H8?8<3 1<@ 7;4 B;=893G" 78 984:5<@8<3 :5B;28 714 =88< ><<8284419;BG 21BB;<A 378 :83;3;5<89 35 378 D>9;4@;23;5<1B :5B;28 4313;5< 1<@ J88:;<A 7;? 659 <5 98145< C713458H89 C7;27 ;4 1A1;<43 5<43;3>3;5<1B 6><@1?8<31B 9;A734" >9;<A 378 25>948 56 19A>?8<3 B819<8@ 25><48B 659 378 :83;3;5<89 4>=?;34 3713 78 ;4 <53 :9844;<A :91G89 5"%;& 35 2B548 378 8A;4389 1A1;<43 7;? 1<@ 98I>8434 37;4 :91G89 5"%;;& @;9823 5C@G 5>93 35 25<4;@89 984:5<@8<3 1>3759;3G 25<4;@89 7;4 98:9848<313;5< C;37;< 1 98145<1=B8 3;?8 :89;5@" )" $89 25<391 B819<8@ @@;3;5<1B @H52138 98:9848<3;<A 378 984:5<@8<3 5H89<?8<3 3138 25<38<@4 3713 -7- 5< 378 =14;4 56 378 29;?;<1B 2148 98A;43898@ 1A1;<43 378 :83;3;5<89 8A;4389" 7;4 <1?8 C14 ;<2B>@8@ ;< 378 5C@G 78 6123 98?1;<4 3713 78 71@ =88< 2719A8 478838@ ;< 1 2148 1<@ 378 2148 ;4 ><@89 39;1B" 78986598 37898 ;4 <5 ;BB8A1B;3G 25??;338@ 59 :9528@>91B B1:48 =G 378 984:5<@8<34 ;< ;<2B>@;<A 378 <1?8 56 378 :83;3;5<89 ;< 378 95C@G 47883 ?1;<31;<8@ =G 378 984:5<@8<34" 378 :83;3;5< 6;B8@ =G 378 :83;3;5<89 78986598 @8489H84 35 =8 @;4?;448@ 14 378 D>@A?8<3 98B;8@ =G 378 :83;3;5<89 ;< 378 2148 56 98:5938@ ;< C5>B@ <53 8<<>98 35 7;4 =8<86;3" *" 71H8 7819@ B819<8@ 25><48B 659 378 :83;3;5<89 1<@ B819<8@ @@;3;5<1B 5H89<?8<3 @H52138 659 378 984:5<@8<34" " 3 ;4 1 6><@1?8<31B 9>B8 56 B1C 3713 C78< 1 :8945< ;4 ;?:B;2138@ 14 1 95C@G 4788389 =G ;<2B>@;<A 7;4 <1?8 ;< 378 B;43 56 95C@G 47883 378 5<>4 ;4 >:5< 378 35 65BB5C 378 @>8 :9528@>98 25<38?:B138@ ><@89 378 -8- 98B8H1<3 9>B84 1<@ 98A>B13;5<4" 19<131J1 $5B;28 < 378 :9848<3 2148 378 1<>1B ?598 4:82;6;21BBG 378 5C@;84 ?1;<31;<8@ ;< 59@89 5" 8A;4389 56 F C7;27 @81B4 C;37 7;4359G 478834 1<@ 95C@G 478834 1<@ 8<95BB?8<3 59 98A;43913;5< 56 :8945<4 ;< 378 41;@ 47883 659 98A;4389 659 25<3;<>5>4 ?5<;359;<A =G 378 :5B;28 1>3759;3;84 65BB5C8@" 31<@;<A 56 95C@;84" 9@89 5" ;4 <53 F @81B4 C;37 98A;43913;5< 78 @86;<;3;5< :95H;@8@ ;4 3713 1 95C@G ?1G =8 @86;<8@ 14 1 A><@1 1<@ ;<2B>@84 1 755B;A1< 35>A7 H1A1=5<@ 59 1<G :8945< C75 ;4 @1<A895>4 35 :>=B;2 :8128 1<@ 391<I>;B;3G" 7898 198 ?1<G 659?4 56 95C@;4? C7;27 198 @8429;=8@ 37898;< 1<@ 378 :952844 1<@ :9528@>98 25<38?:B138@ 35 =8 ?1;<31;<8@ ;< @;66898<3 :1934 <1?8BG $193 $193 1<@ $193 C7;27 A5H89< 378 ?1;<38<1<28 56 1 98A;4389 1<@ 378 <1?84 56 378 95C@;84 ;< 378;9 984:823;H8 :1934" 3 ;4 378 @>3G 1<@ 5=B;A13;5< 2143 >:5< 378 984:5<@8<34 C7;27 ;4 <53 5:3;5<1B 35 65BB5C 378 @>8 :9528@>98 25<38?:B138@ ><@89 378 431<@;<A 59@894 56 378 19<131J1 $5B;28 1<>1B C7;B8 8<389;<A 378 <1?8 56 1 -9- :8945< ;< 95C@G 47883 1<@ 37898 28931;< :9528@>984 35 =8 ?1<@1359;BG 65BB5C8@ =86598 8<389;<A 378 <1?84" 4 25<38<@8@ =G B819<8@ 25><48B 659 378 :83;3;5<89 378 :952844 1<@ :9528@>98 14 25<38?:B138@ ><@89 378 431<@;<A 9@89 5" F 56 378 19<131J1 $5B;28 1<>1B 714 <53 =88< 65BB5C8@ 1<@ <5 5::593><;3G C14 A;H8< 35 378 :83;3;5<89 35 6;B8 7;4 98:BG 59 8K:B1<13;5< 659 98?5H;<A 7;4 <1?8 ;< 378 5C@G 8A;4389 1<@ ?898BG =821>48 78 C14 ;<H5BH8@ ;< 1 29;?;<1B 2148" 3 ;4 1B45 25<38<@8@ 3713 375>A7 378 :83;3;5<89 714 ?1@8 1 98:9848<313;5< 35 378 984:5<@8<3 1>3759;3;84 16389 378 12I>;331B 5< " ,"! !, 378 98:9848<313;5< 714 <53 =88< 25<4;@898@" F" 5 59@;<138 378 2148 56 A>;@8B;<84" 8<27 56 37;4 5<0=B8 5>93 ;< %4>:91& B1;@ @5C< 28931;< 78 A>;@8B;<84 B1;@ @5C< =G 37;4 5>93 198 14 65BB5C4 ! " !# $ % &! %' (# %! ) $ * $) % $$ - 10 - ) $$ ) ) ! ) $$ $ ) ! % + %% , + * ! " !# $ ) %#+ ! * % & " * % $ ) % & . * % % & % * % & ! ! ! ) % % ) % ) $ % ! & % & + % % $$ + & #$! ' % $ !) " % /) * ! %* ) * % $ + -% % % &!. * % . $ + ! ! &! % # $' "% % 0$ #% #* ! $ 8 $) % ) % &! % & +( ) " $. ) %! ) % ! % - ) *. 123' ! 8 $) $$ ! ** ! " !# $ ) ) ! # ) $$ % )) % " . ! % % $$ + $. ! ** " $ ! & 8 $) 0 ' & *$ % $. $ 8 $) % $$ ) *#$% - * !) " & %' # ! % % &! % %# * "! ! # ! 0$ #% 193' # $ ' * & " !% % (# %! ) & " $ ) ! " !# $ .' ) #+ )) .* ,# % ! #' 452: " !' % - 11 - - * % ' % &!. % ) )# % ) % %#) % ) $ ) % . - # ; ) %! ! $ % ) .% ") ' ) * % ! +. $ " $ & . % # ) % ) ! % #* ! 8 $) ) 42 ! .% " & % $$ + $ & ) ! # )$ % (# %! ) #+ $ "% & $ $ 8 $) * % ) $$ ) ! $ #) & %! %#$ * # ) !#) ' % $$ + ! ) ! ) + % $ ) #! ' <5 ! .%' !# . + = ! ! *# % ' & ) $ 8 $) " $ +$ ) + %% (# %! ) * ) %% . ! % % ! " !# $ ) ) $$ + ! & / 42 ! .% % " , . * % % ,# * ! %* % ! ) +. ) ! # +. % $$ ) ! <5 ! .% " $ ) % *# % ! # . * % >5 ! .%' ( ) % 8 $) $. & $ $ " ! +. . * . % ! " !# $ *$ % & " ' % $$ + % & # %! $ . + ?# % !' - 12 - " * ) %% % ) ! % %* ) % .' % . " $ +$ " !' . # ( * %) % ,# . $$ + ") % # + $$ + **$ ) +$ # " /) * % % % $$ % . %) *$ . ! % #! $ ! !" +. ) $ ) *. # #! $ % % $$ + % % - ! . ' + " $ !! & ) % !% - 8 $) 7 147?;9 1<@ % . ! %#+( ) % % * "% % # $' 46>2 A 78 D>@A?8<3 56 378 1??> 1<@ ! % $ ! ) " .! $ . " @ 5"* - % % &!. / & $$' ! ") ! & !#) *$ $$ + ! %)$ % ! ' ! " $ . * % $ % . $$ + " % ) % ! % %%# $. ! **$ ) * 8 $) ! % ) + " ' #* $$ + ) !# ) %%# * ,# * ! &!. 5<0=B8 1@1J7 13 ;A7 5>93 56 1??> ;< * @81B3 C;37 ;44>8 56 @861?13;5< 98BG;<A >:5< 378 ;<61?5>4 2148 56 - 13 - ! & " #$ % 1<@ 78B@ 3713 1 LA55@ 98:>313;5<M ;4 1< 8B8?8<3 56 :8945<1B 482>9;3G 1<@ ;4 :9538238@ =G 378 5<43;3>3;5< 8I>1BBG C;37 1 9;A73 35 8<D5G?8<3 56 B;68 B;=893G 1<@ :95:893G" 5 ;3 714 35 =8 78B@ 35 =8 8448<3;1B 25?:5<8<3 H;4 1 H;4 9;A73 35 B;68 56 1 2;3;E8< ><@89 93;2B8 ! 5H8<1<3 5< 56 378 5<43;3>3;5< 56 <@;1" <389<13;5<1B ;H;B 1<@ $5B;3;21B ;A734 F)) 9825A<;E84 378 9;A73 35 71H8 5:;<;5<4 1<@ 378 9;A73 56 6988@5? 56 8K:9844;5< ><@89 93;2B8 F 56 378 5<43;3>3;5< 56 <@;1 ;4 4>=D823 35 9;A73 35 98:>313;5< 56 537894" 8:>313;5< ;4 L<53 5<BG 1 41B3 56 B;68 =>3 378 :>9843 39814>98 1<@ 378 ?543 :982;5>4 :896>?8 56 B;68M" 5 59@;<138 5>93 ;< 378 2148 56 8<27 56 37;4 %4>:91& 714 B1;@ @5C< A>;@8B;<84 C7;27 198 35 =8 65BB5C8@ C7;B8 98A;4389;<A 378 <1?8 56 1 :8945< ;< 378 5C@G 8A;4389 C7;27 8H8< :9;59 35 378 41;@ D>@A?8<3 C14 1 ?1<@138 659 378 984:5<@8<34 35 71H8 65BB5C8@ 439;23BG ;< 12259@1<28 35 378 431<@;<A 59@89 F F * , 5" F 56 378 19<131J1 $5B;28 1<>1B - 14 - C7;27 ;< ?G 5:;<;5< 25<4;@89;<A 61234 1<@ 2;92>?431<28 56 378 :9848<3 2148 714 <53 =88< 65BB5C8@" 78 25<3;<>13;5< 56 378 <1?8 56 1 :8945< ;< 1 95C@G 47883 C;375>3 37898 =8;<A 1<G 25A8<3 98145< @584 <53 1>A>9 C8BB C;37 378 3138 14 1 :198<4 :139;18 C7;27 ;4 1 A>19@;1< 56 378 2;3;E8<4 56 37;4 25><39G" 3138 714 35 :95H;@8 1< 5::593><;3G 35 378 2;3;E8< 35 98659? 7;?48B6 35 B81@ 1 <59?1B B;68 1<@ ?;K C;37 378 452;83G 35 B81@ 1 B;68 56 1 <59?1B 2;3;E8<" 91<@;<A 7;? 35 =8 1 95C@G =G 5:8<;<A 95C@G 47883 ;4 <53 378 45B>3;5< 1<@ ;3 1@@4 35 378 :95=B8? 56 29813;5< 56 ?;<@483 56 1 95C@G 1 29;?;<1B 1<@ B81@;<A 35 D5;<;<A 56 A1<A4 1<@ 29813;5< 56 A1<A C194 C7;27 ;4 @839;?8<31B 35 378 452;83G" " < H;8C 56 378 <5< 25?:B;1<28 56 378 :9528@>98 25<38?:B138@ ><@89 19<131J1 $5B;28 431<@;<A 59@89 5" F 1<>1B 1<@ <5< 25<4;@8913;5< 56 378 98:9848<313;5< A;H8< =G 378 :83;3;5<89 37;4 5>93 ;4 56 378 5:;<;5< 3713 378 :83;3;5<89 714 ?1@8 5>3 1 H1B;@ 2148 35 25<4;@89 61H5>91=BG" 2259@;<ABG :144 378 65BB5C;<A - 15 - ;" 78 C9;3 :83;3;5< ;4 ;;" 84:5<@8<3 98:9848<313;5< @138@ 5" ' " ;4 @;98238@ 35 25<4;@89 378 " ,"! !, H;@8 <<8K>98 ;< 12259@1<28 C;37 B1C 1<@ :144 4>;31=B8 59@894 C;37;< 1 :89;5@ 56 ! ?5<374 695? 378 @138 56 9828;:3 56 2893;6;8@ 25:G 56 37;4 59@89" )* ' " # ;43 5" B 5" ! (

This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.

Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong? Request a review

All Karnataka HC judgments →
LegalFirms.in Directory
Find an advocate for this matter
Dealing with a similar case? Find an advocate who handles this kind of matter on LegalFirms.in.
Find an advocate →