Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010605482025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA
PRADESH
[3311]
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
Tuesday, the seventeenth day of February two thousand and twenty six
Present
The Honourable Ms. Justice B. S. Bhanumathi
Civil Revision Petition No.3217 of 2025
Between:
Lingala Venkata Reddy
...Petitioner
and
Anke Koteswaraiah and others
Counsel for the petitioner:
1. Ineni Venkata Prasad
Counsel for the respondents:
espondents:
Nil
The Court made the following:
...Respondents
BSB, J
C.R.P.No.3217 of 2025
ORDER:
This revision petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India
is filed against the order, dated 23.10.2025, allowing I.A.No.390 of 2025
in O.S.No.54 of 2012 on the file of the Court of the Civil Judge (Senior
Division), Kadiri, filed under Order I, Rule 10 C.P.C. to implead the
petitioner therein, by name, Anke Koteswaraiah, as plaintiff No.7,
seeking the following consequential amendment.
Proposed plaintiff No.7:
7)
Anke Koteswaraiah S/o Anke Musalappa, aged
about 50 years
Agriculturist, residing at Door No.3-127-
A, Ankevaripalli, H/o.
Bonala. Lingala Mandal, YSR
District.
List of Document:
Registered sale deed dated 21-12-2011 vide document
No.9501/2011 executed by the respondent No.1 (plaintiff
No.1) in favour of the petitioner (proposed plaintiff No.7).
2.
Initially, the sole plaintiff filed a suit in O.S.No.54 of 2012 on the
file of the Court of the Civil Judge (Senior Division), Kadiri. On the
death of the sole plaintiff, the plaintiffs Nos.2 to 5 were brought on
record as her legal representatives. The plaintiff No.6 and defendant
No.2 were brought on record as the legal representatives of the
deceased plaintiff No.4.
The suit was filed against the revision
petitioner / defendant No.1 seeking cancellation of the gift deeds
bearing Nos.8707 of 2011, 8708 of 2011, both dated 28.11.2011,
executed by the plaintiff No.1 in favour of the defendant No.1 in respect
of the plaint schedule property of Ac.1.02 cents in Sy.No.87 within the
limits of Mukkandlavari Kothapalle revenue, Mukkandlavari Kothapalle
BSB, J
C.R.P.No.3217 of 2025
Grama Panchayat, Obuladevara cheruvu Mandal, Ananthapur district.
The gift deeds were executed by the plaintiff No.1 in favour of the
defendant No.1 on 28.11.2011, but the plaintiff No.1 again executed
deeds of cancellation of the gift deeds on 29.11.2011 vide documents
Nos.8720 of 2011 and 8721 of 2011. In spite of execution of the deeds
of cancellation, the suit was filed stating that these documents have to
be cancelled through Court.
3.
The respondent No.1 herein who filed I.A.No.390 of 2025
contended that the plaintiff No.1 sold the suit schedule property to him
for valid consideration under a registered sale deed, dated 21.12.2011
and inducted him in possession of the property and therefore, he is a
party interested in the relief claimed in the suit and that he had come to
know about the suit recently before filing the petition in the year 2025.
Claiming himself to be a bona fide purchaser, to safeguard his rights
and interest in the property, he claimed to be advised to file the petition.
4.
The respondents Nos.1 to 6 reported no counter while the petition
was opposed by filing counter of revision petitioner / respondent No.7 /
defendant No.1 as follows:
The allegations in the affidavit of the petitioner are false. The
petition was filed suppressing all the material facts and without having
any right and title in the property.
The alleged sale deed, dated
21.12.2011 is false, fictitious and created. The plaintiff No.1 has no
right or title to execute the registered sale deed in favour of the
petitioner after execution of the registered gift deeds in favour of the
defendant No.1. The petition is filed only to drag on the suit.
petition is liable to be dismissed.
The
BSB, J
C.R.P.No.3217 of 2025
5.
The other respondents have not filed counter.
6.
After hearing the petitioner and the respondent No.7 / defendant
No.1, the trial Court allowed the petition observing that the petitioner is a
proper party and that unless he is impleaded as a party to the suit, it
would lead to multiplicity of proceedings and cause prejudice to the
rights of the petitioner.
7.
Aggrieved by the order, this revision petition was filed contending
that the affidavit of the petition itself clearly shows that pending the
documents for cancellation, the proposed party purchased the suit
schedule property under the alleged sale deed, but the trial Court failed
to properly appreciate and that the order impugned in the revision is
devoid of merit.
8.
In spite of service of notice on the respondent No.1, there has
been no appearance.
9.
No notice was ordered to the other respondents as they have not
contested the petition.
10.
The learned counsel for the revision petitioner submitted that the
revision petitioner had filed a suit in O.S.No.222 of 2007 against the
plaintiff No.1 before the Court of Principal Junior Civil Judge, Kadiri, for
perpetual injunction regarding the very same schedule property and that
the said suit was pending as on the date of filing of the present suit, yet,
the false suit for cancellation of the gift deeds was filed by the plaintiffs
only to drag on the issue. He further submitted that the son of the
plaintiff No.1 who is also a party to the suit as plaintiff No.3 is the son-inlaw of the revision petitioner, but he is behind the entire litigation in
getting the gift deeds cancelled or filing the suit or creating the sale
BSB, J
C.R.P.No.3217 of 2025
deed in favour of the respondent no.1 herein. He further submitted that
the petition was filed only to drag on the proceedings though it is said
that the petitioner obtained the sale deed well before filing of the suit
itself. It is pertinent to mention that though the sale was said to be
made on 21.12.2011 and the suit was filed in March, 2012, the
proposed party was not made a party to the suit along with the sole
plaintiff by then. Of course, the proposed party says that he came to
know about filing of the suit recently before filing the petition but failed to
state how he had come to know about the pendency of the suit. If the
entries in the revenue account indicate the name of the defendant No.1
for such long period and the name of the proposed party had not been
entered in the revenue account since December, 2011, till the date of
filing of the petition, why the proposed party kept silent is not apparent
from the record. Therefore, the assertion that he had no knowledge of
the suit is not believable.
11.
As per Rule 28 of the A.P. Civil Rules of Practice & Circular
Orders, 1990, an application filed under Order I Rule X C.P.C., shall
also contain a prayer for all consequential amendments and the
application shall be dismissed if it is not in accordance with the law or
the rules.
12.
This Court in V. Madhuri Vs. B. Bala Naidu and Ors.1 held as
follows:
2023(3) ALD 360
BSB, J
C.R.P.No.3217 of 2025
“…To avoid multiplicity of proceedings, omissions and
delay, Rule 28 of the Civil Rules of Practice, 1990,
mandates that an application for amendment made under
Order I Rule 10, Order 6 Rule XVII or Order XXII CPC
shall also contain a prayer for all consequential
amendments and that the Presiding Officer shall reject
the application if it is not in accordance with the law or
these rules, though as a normal rule different reliefs
cannot be sought in a single petition by virtue of Rule 55
of the Civil Rules of Practice. However, it is a very
common vexed lapse noticed in many petitions that
either no consequential amendment is sought or
inadequate, improper or inappropriate amendments are
sought in the applications referred in the Rule 28. In fact,
such amendment or lack of consequential amendment is
causing delay and much trouble to the parties and courts.
In spite of mandatory condition in Rule 28, petitions
under Order I and Order XXII CPC are being registered
without proper verification at the threshold. Just because
some
or
other
amendment
is
mentioned
as
consequential amendment, that may not be sufficient or
proper. Many times, whenever any party is proposed to
be impleaded, amendment only to short and long cause
title are sought, without seeking any further amendment
to the pleadings with regard to the party to be impleaded.
All such facts are usually stated only in the affidavit filed
in support of the petition seeking impleadment, but not as
proposed consequential amendments. Since facts stated
in the affidavit do not form part of the pleadings in the
BSB, J
C.R.P.No.3217 of 2025
main proceedings, it is very essential to specifically seek
them. Just for the sake of complying Rule 28, improper or
inadequate consequential amendments are sought, at
times, like in the present case. It is sometimes asked by
petitioner(s) that permission may be given to make
consequential amendments without revealing what it/they
is/are. It cannot be treated as due compliance of Rule 28.
Once pleadings or averments are filed before Court, no
part of it can be amended without permission of court.
Unless what amendment to be made is stated, nobody
knows what will be amended. Under the guise of
amendment, it is possible to make amendments which
are otherwise not permissible. Therefore, unless the
specific amendments proposed are stated in the petition,
court or other party do not have an opportunity to verify
whether such amendments can be permitted or not.
If impleadment of a party whose presence in a suit
or proceedings is necessary, is refused on the technical
ground for not asking any consequential amendment or
asking only improper amendment, a matter cannot be
completely adjudicated and dispute cannot be resolved.
As such, it is very much essential to check the petition(s)
mentioned in rule 28 before registering it and see that all
proper consequential amendments are sought in the
same petition and register the petition only if adequate
and proper amendments are proposed.”
BSB, J
C.R.P.No.3217 of 2025
It was further held therein as follows:
“Rule 28, unlike other rules or statutes which refer
to 'court', casts duty on the 'Presiding Officer'. So it is felt
necessary to instruct all the judicial officers in this state to
ensure thorough and proper checking of the petition
before registering the petition to avoid multiplicity of
proceedings, delays and unwilling dismissal.”
13.
A perusal of the petition shows that except seeking amendment
of the short and long cause title by incorporating the name and other
details of the proposed party in the cause title, there is no other
amendment of the pleadings as stated by the petitioner in his affidavit.
Therefore, even if he is allowed to come on record, except his name in
the cause title, there would be no pleading in the plaint regarding his
interest in the suit schedule property.
Consequently, the defendant
No.1 would have no opportunity of taking any pleading against the
proposed party. As a result, no evidence can be let in regarding the
alleged sale by the plaintiff No.1 in favour of the proposed party, as it is
settled principle of law that no amount of evidence can be received
without there being a supporting pleading. Under these circumstances,
even if the proposed party is allowed to come on record, no purpose
would be served. In any case, the interest of the proposed party in the
suit schedule property is dependent on the right of the plaintiff No.1 and
the result in the suit is binding on the proposed party. If the proposed
party can only be a witness to give evidence for the plaintiffs, he need
not be a party to the suit.
14.
Normally, as a purchaser, he could have been a necessary or
proper party to the suit. Apart from such eligibility, other considerations
BSB, J
C.R.P.No.3217 of 2025
which are noted above shall also be taken into account. The trial Court
failed to examine the above aspects and allowed the petition only on the
ground that he is a proper party to the suit. Therefore, the impugned
order requires to be interfered with.
15.
In the result, the revision petition is allowed. The order, dated
23.10.2025, passed by the learned Civil Judge (Senior Division), Kadiri,
in I.A.No.390 of 2025 in O.S.No.54 of 2012 is set aside. Consequently,
I.A.No.390 of 2025 is dismissed.
There shall be no order as to costs.
Pending miscellaneous applications, if any, shall stand closed.
Dt.17.02.2026
RAR
__________________
B.S. BHANUMATHI, J
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review