Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
W.P. (C) No.403 of 2026
(An application under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India)
***
Smt. Lili Meher
….
Petitioner
….
Opposite Parties
-VersusState of Odisha and others
Advocates appeared in this case:
For Petitioner
:
Mr. Prabodha Chandra Nayak,
Advocate
For Opposite Parties :
Ms.Biswabara Dash,
Additional Standing Counsel
CORAM:
HON’ BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
AND
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE MURAHARI SRI RAMAN
JUDGMENT
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------Date of hearing and judgment: 17th March, 2026
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------HARISH TANDON, CJ.1.
The seminal point involved in the instant writ petition pertains to
the Demand Notice dated 9th June, 2025 issued by the Mining
Officer, Nuapada (opposite party No.7) vide Annexure-1 upon
W.P.(C) No.403 of 2026
the petitioner claiming the outstanding dues for the Financial
Years 2022-23 to 2025-26 towards the Royalty and other dues as
the quarry operation remained idle for more than a continuous
period of six months which is violative of Rule 32 and Rule 33
(15) of the Odisha Minor Minerals Concession Rules, 2016 (in
short, ‘the OMMC Rules”) and the amendment having brought in
the meantime.
2.
The primary contention against the said Demand Notice is
founded upon an assertion that the payment of Royalty can only
be demanded if any minor mineral is removed or consumed by
him or his agent, the manager and employees or the contractor
from the leased area. According to the petitioner, if the quarry
remained non-operational, it does not attract the consummation
and/or removal of the sand, and, therefore, the incidence of
payment of Royalty has not germinated. Such being the question
involved in the instant writ petition, which, in our opinion, strikes
at the root of the issues and of a legal nature, it would be an idle
exercise to invite the parties to exchange the affidavits.
3.
The facts are undisputed and can be reasonably gathered and/or
inferred from the language and expressions used in the said
Demand Notice. Before we proceed to decide the point urged
before us, it would be relevant to quote the said Demand Notice
in extenso, which runs thus:
“Office of the Mining Officer, Nuapada
At: Sirtol, P.O.: Nuapada, District: Nuapada, PIN: 766105
E-mail:-mo.nuapada@gmail.com
No.664/Minor Mines
Date:09.06.2025
W.P.(C) No.403 of 2026
To
Smt. Lili Meher,
Wife of Debeswadatta Meher,
At/P.O./P.S.: Sinapali, District: Nuapada,
Pin: 766 108.
Sub.: Demand Notice for Deposition of Outstanding dues for the
F.Y.2022-23, 2023-24, 2024-25 & 2025-26 in respect of
Gandabahali Sand Quarry.
Sir,
With reference to the subject cited above, I am to say that, you
were instructed to deposit the outstanding dues towards Royalty
and other dues for the F.Y.2022-23 to 2025-26. You have also
kept your quarry operation in idle for more than a continuous
period of six months violating the Rule 32 and 33 (15) of OMMC
Rule 2016 and Amendment Rule 2023.
The detail of pending dues against Quarry are as follows:Sl No. Financial
Year
Amount of
Outstanding
Dues
No.of
days Delayed
Interest @24%
Till 31.05.2025
2022-23
Rs.2,85,572/-
Rs.1,86,272/-
Rs.4,71,844/-
2023-2024
Rs.4,88,197/-
Rs.2,53,916/-
Rs.7,42,113/-
2024-2025
Rs.4,88,197/-
Rs.1,36,428/-
Rs.6,24,625/-
2025-2026
Rs.4,88,197/-
Continuing
-
Rs.4,88,197/-
Grand Total
Total
Rs.23,26,779/-
So, you are hereby show caused for not depositing the aforesaid
dues which violates the Rule 32 and 33 (15) of OMMC Rule 2016
and you are also directed to deposit the same within 07 days
from the receipt of this letter positively failing which your lease
will be liable for cancellation under Rule 33 (5) of OMMC Rule
2016.
This may be treated as Top Priority.
W.P.(C) No.403 of 2026
Yours faithfully,
Sd/Mining Officer, Nuapada”
4.
The above quoted Demand Notice indicates that the amount so
demanded on the pretext of the outstanding dues includes within
its folds - Royalty and the other dues relating to the financial
years mentioned therein. The penultimate paragraph of the said
notice exposits that the aforesaid dues become payable for
violation having committed by the petitioner as envisaged in
Rule 32 and Rule 33 (15) of the OMMC Rules, 2016. Such being
an impression gathered by this Court, on a meaningful reading of
the contents of the said notice, we invited the attention of the
learned Addl. Standing Counsel and it is sought to be clarified on
instruction received from the responsible officer that the
aforesaid dues relate to a pre-stage of the execution of a lease and
not subsequent thereto. In other words, it is sought to be
contended that since the Royalty and other dues are to be paid in
terms of the Rules before the execution of the lease deed, having
committed a bona fide mistake by the competent authority in not
ensuring such payment and executing the lease deed, the said
demand was made.
5.
We are unable to comprehend such notion derived by the learned
Addl. Standing Counsel on the basis of an instruction received
from the officials. The moment a written notice is issued by the
authority which contains the words and expressions, if there is no
ambiguity in ascertaining the meaning and the intention
underlying such expressions, it hardly invites any other
interpretations to be borrowed.
W.P.(C) No.403 of 2026
6.
Had the authorities intended that the said Royalty and the other
dues pertain to a pre-execution stage of the mining lease, it could
be clearly and precisely expressed in words and languages and
the thing which cannot be reasonably gathered and/or inferred
from the plain and simple meaning, cannot be imported at the
bar.
7.
Let us proceed on the basis of the said Demand Notice and the
language employed therein to ascertain whether the Royalty is
payable on happening of an incident or is payable without any
act, deed or thing to be done. It would be apposite to reproduce
the provisions contained in Rule 32 and sub-rule (15) of Rule 33
of the OMMC Rules, 2016, which run thus:
“32. Liability for payment of royalty, dead rent, surface rent,
additional charge, amount of contribution payable to the
District Mineral Foundation, amount of contribution
payable to the Environment Management Fund.—
(1)
All the lessees for minor minerals other than specified
minor minerals shall be liable to pay royalty or dead rent,
surface rent, additional charge, amount of contribution
payable to the District Mineral Foundation, amount of
contribution payable to the Environment Management
Fund and fees for compensatory afforestation.
(2)
The lessee shall pay to the State Government every year
dead rent and surface rent at the rates specified in
Schedule-I for all the areas included in the lease deed and
royalty at the rates specified in Schedule-II:
Provided that the rates specified in Schedule-I and
Schedule-II may be revised by the Government, from time
to time, by an amendment made to the said Schedules, but
W.P.(C) No.403 of 2026
no revision shall be made before the expiry of three years
from the date when the rates were last fixed:
Provided further that where the lessee becomes liable for
payment of royalty for any minor mineral removed or
consumed by him or his agent, manager and employees or
the contractor from the leased area, he shall be liable to
pay either such royalty or the dead rent whichever is
higher.
(3)
In addition to the surface rent, dead rent or royalty, as the
case may be, the lessee shall be liable to pay additional
charge, amount of contribution payable to the District
Mineral Foundation and an amount of contribution
payable to the Environment Management Fund in
advance, on annual basis on the minimum guaranteed
quantity of minor minerals even if the actual extraction
falls short of such quantity.
(4)
In case the actual extraction exceeds the minimum
guaranteed quantity, such mineral may be removed from
the lease area only after payment of royalty, additional
charge, amount of contribution payable to the District
Mineral Foundation and an amount of contribution
payable to the Environment Management Fund on prorata basis.
(5)
The royalty, additional charge, amount of contribution to
the District Mineral Foundation and amount of
contribution payable to the Environment Management
Fund for the period up to commencement of the next year
shall be paid on a pro-rata basis before the execution of
lease deed.
(6)
For the purpose of determination of minimum guaranteed
quantity in the cases where the lease has been executed on
or after the 1st April, the minimum guaranteed quantity for
the first financial year shall be equal to the minimum
W.P.(C) No.403 of 2026
guaranteed quantity divided by twelve and multiplied by
the number of months remaining in the first year of the
lease, treating part of any month as full month.
(7)
The lessee shall pay, in addition to the surface rent, dead
rent or royalty, additional charge, amount of contribution
payable to the District Mineral Foundation and to the
Environment Management Fund, fees for compensatory
afforestation at rates as may be specified by the
Government from time to time.
33.
Conditions of quarry lease.—
***
(15) The lessee shall keep correct accounts of minor minerals
other than specified minor minerals quarried and
dispatched and shall furnish a quarterly return in Form-P
and annual return in Form-K to the Competent Authority
and the Director.”
8.
Sub-rule (1) of Rule 32 creates a liability on the lessees of minor
mineral other than the specified minor minerals to pay royalty,
dead rent, surface rent, additional charge, amount of contribution
payable to the District Mineral Foundation and Environmental
Management Fund and fees for compensatory afforestation. Subrule (3) postulates that in addition to the above, the lessee shall
also pay the additional charges, the DMF and EMF in advance on
annual basis on a minimum guaranteed quantity of minor
minerals even if the actual extraction falls short of such quantity.
Sub-rule (5) of Rule 32 encompasses within its folds the payment
of royalty, additional charges, the DMF and EMF for a period up
to the commencement of the next year on a pro rata basis before
execution of a lease deed.
W.P.(C) No.403 of 2026
9.
We have no quarrel to the stand that if the statute provides the
payment of those amounts to be paid before the execution of the
lease deed on a pro rata basis, it has to be paid and if there is any
omission or mistake, such does not confer any inchoate right into
a lessee. If the intention of the authority was to recover the
amount on such incidences, it could have been clearly spelt in the
Demand Notice. It is trite law that if the intention can be safely
and reasonably gathered from the unambiguous meaning of the
words and expressions used in the notice or the other documents
issued by the authority, any grounds or other interpretation
attempted to be assigned at the bar or subsequent thereto is not
permissible. (see Mohinder Singh Gill and another Vrs. Chief
Election Commissioner and others: (1978) 1 SCC 405.
10.
Once the authorities have demanded on a specified ground, the
other ground not germinating therefrom cannot be permitted to
be allowed, more particularly, at the time of the hearing, and,
therefore, we do not accept the contention of the State in this
regard. The Royalty and the other dues are demanded because of
the violation of Rule 32 and Rule 33 (15) of the OMMC Rules,
2016, and, therefore, the determination has to be squeezed within
its circumference and not beyond the same.
Sub-rule (2) of Rule 32 of the OMMC Rules, 2016 gains
significant importance in ascertaining the liability to make the
payment towards the Royalty. Though the said sub-section
ordained the lessee to pay to the State Government yearly dead
rent and surface rent at the rate specified in Schedule-1 and the
Royalty at the rate specified in Schedule-II, but the 2nd proviso
W.P.(C) No.403 of 2026
appended thereto appears to be contingent so far as the liability to
make payment of Royalty. In order to arrive at the decision that
the payment of Royalty is contingent, we can safely look upon
the language employed therein. The expression “lessee becomes
liable for payment of Royalty”, has to be understood in a general
sense that the liability is contingent and depends upon the
happening of an event. If the payment of Royalty is not
dependent upon any contingency, the legislature could not have
used the expression “becomes liable for payment of Royalty” in
the said statutory provisions. Once the expression “becomes
liable” is used, it eradicates the liability in all situations even
non-happening of any event, and, therefore, has to be understood
in such sense. The said expression “lessee becomes liable for
payment of Royalty” is further qualified and brings the concept
of contingency by using the expression “any minor minerals
removed or consumed”.
11.
A conjoint reading of the aforesaid expressions, conveys a
laudable intention of the authorities that the moment the minor
mineral is removed or consumed, the lessee “becomes liable for
payment of Royalty”. Once the liability is controlled by a
contingency to happen, such liability cannot be imposed unless
there is an eminent existence of such contingency. We are
conscious that the enabling provision of sub-rule (2) of Rule 33
mandates the payment of Royalty as specified in Schedule-II, but
once the proviso is appended, it not only controls the
applicability of the main portion of the Section or the provision,
but also at times be used as clarificatory and/or explanatory. The
W.P.(C) No.403 of 2026
importance of using the proviso into the statutory form is to
eradicate any ambiguity to happen in applicability thereof, and
therefore, if the liability to make payment of the Royalty is
dependent upon, the removal and conjunction on the minor
mineral, it has to be understood as a contingent liability and not
otherwise. Even sub-rule (15) of Rule 33 of the OMMC Rules,
2016, relied upon by the authorities relates to maintenance of a
correct account of the minor minerals, so quarried/extracted and
dispatched and an obligation is cast on the lessee to furnish the
quarterly and annual return in the prescribed form to the
competent authority. That provision certainly attracts the
responsibilities, the obligations and the liability of the lessee in
not only maintaining but also furnishing the details and/or
information(s) in the prescribed form. However, it cannot be
corelated even remotedly in relation to the charging of the
Royalty. The cumulative effect of the provisions contained under
Rule 32 and Rule 33 (15) of the OMMC Rules, 2016 appears to
us that apart from the liability, the other dues being not
contingent, the petitioner cannot escape from its liability to make
the payment thereof.
12.
Since the amount appears to have been charged bearing in mind
that the quarry is kept idle for more than six months which
attracts the other consequences that is the cancellation of the
lease deed, there is no provision for charging the Royalty on such
account. The amount so demanded in the said notice appears to
be a composite one, as it includes not only the Royalty, but also
other statutory dues and/or liability. The same cannot be said to
W.P.(C) No.403 of 2026
be absolutely illegal or in contravention to the provisions of the
OMMC Rules, 2016. The only discrepancy which we have found
in the said Demand Notice is that the authorities have included
the amount of Royalty within the said demanded amount, and,
therefore, justice demands that the authorities must recalculate
the dues so demanded in the light of the observation (s) made
hereinabove.
13.
The Demand Notice dated 9th June, 2025 issued by the Mining
Officer, Nuapada (opposite party No.7) under
Annexure-1 is
hereby quashed and set aside. The Mining Officer, Nuapada is
directed to recalculate the said amount in the light of the
observations made hereinabove and on the basis of the relevant
provisions, within a period of four weeks from the date of
communication of this order. In the event, the Demand Notice is
issued after making a recalculation of the other dues, the
petitioner shall pay the said amount without putting any
hinderances and/or objections thereto.
14.
With the aforesaid observations and direction, the writ petition
stands disposed of.
Digitally Signed
Signed by: BICHITRANANDA SAHOO
Designation: Secretary
Reason: Authentication
Location: Orissa High Court, Cuttack
Date: 07-Apr-2026 13:44:51
(HARISH TANDON)
CHIEF JUSTICE
(M.S. RAMAN)
JUDGE
High Court of Orissa, Cuttack
The 17th March, 2026//Bichi/Aswini
W.P.(C) No.403 of 2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review