Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/16
GAHC040014922025
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
(ITANAGAR BENCH)
Case No. : PIL/15/2025
Likha Rajnik
Son of Shri Likha Tana, resident of Riyo Village, Nirjuli, PO and PS Nirjuli, Papum
Pare District, Arunachal Pradesh.
VERSUS
The State of AP and 10 Ors
represented by the Chief Secretary, Govt of Arunachal Pradesh, Itanagar. 2:The
Secretary
Age: 0
Occupation :
Department of Home
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar.
3:The Secretary
Age: 0
Occupation :
Department of State Lotteries
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar.
4:The Director General of Police
Age: 0
Occupation :
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
PHQ
Chimpu
Itanagar.
5:The Superintending of Police
Age: 0
Occupation :
Page No.# 2/16
Capital Complex
Itanagar Division
Itanagar to be represented by PP
6:The Superintending of Police
Age: 0
Occupation :
Capital Complex
Naharlagun Division
Naharlagun to be represented by the PP
7:The Superintending of Police
Age: 0
Occupation :
Yupia
Papum Pare District
to be represented by the PP
8:The Officer in Charge
Age: 0
Occupation :
Police Station Itanagar
to be represented by the PP
9:The Officer in Charge
Age: 0
Occupation :
Police Station Naharlagun
to be represented by the PP
10:The Officer in Charge
Age: 0
Occupation :
Police Station Doimukh
to be represented by the PP
11:The Officer in Charge
Age: 0
Occupation :
Police Station Papu Hill
Naharlagun to be represented by the P
Page No.# 3/16
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BUDI HABUNG
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE N. UNNI KRISHNAN NAIR
Advocate for the Petitioner
: Mr. L. Perme, ld. Adv.
Advocate for the Respondents
: Mr. S. Tapin, ld. Sr. GA(AP).
Date on which Judgment is reserved
: 13.08.2026
Date of Hearing
: 13.08.2026
Date of Judgment and Order
: 24.09.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of the Operative part of the Judgment? :No
Whether the full Judgment has been pronounced ? : Yes
JUDGMENT & ORDER
(CAV)
[Budi Habung, J]
Heard Mr. L. Perme, learned counsel for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. S.
Tapin, learned Senior Government Advocate for all the State respondents.
2.
The petitioner, claimed to be a public-spirited person, has instituted this
Public Interest Litigation seeking, inter alia, directions to the State authorities
and the police of the District for effective implementation of the Lotteries
(Regulation) Act, 1998, the Lotteries (Regulation) Rules, 2010, and the
Government Notification/Order No. SL/23/2022 dated 06.03.2025 issued by the
State Government of Arunachal Pradesh, including the Government Order No.
LOT-152/97 dated 17.01.2007 issued by the Secretary, Department of State
Page No.# 4/16
Lotteries, Government of Arunachal Pradesh, Itanagar. The petitioner also prays
for taking appropriate action against alleged illegal and unregulated lucky draw,
housie, lotteries, and gift coupon activities being conducted/organized in the
State of Arunachal Pradesh.
3.
The State respondents and the concerned police authorities have filed
their respective affidavits. The affidavits state that wherever specific complaints
regarding the alleged illegal lottery activities were received, the same were
examined and appropriate action was taken in accordance with law. The State
authorities have also stated that directions have been issued from time to time
to the District Magistrates of all Districts and police authorities of Arunachal
Pradesh for strict enforcement and for taking necessary action against illegal
lottery activities in accordance with the applicable provisions of law and
Government Notifications/Orders.
4.
After filing their affidavit, the State respondent No. 3, by filing an
additional affidavit, has clarified the stand of the State Government regarding
the applicability of the Lotteries (Regulation) Act, 1998. At paragraph 2 of the
additional affidavit of the State respondent No. 3, it has been stated that the
earlier stand of the respondent requires correction. It is stated that the Lotteries
(Regulation) Act, 1998 does not govern local lotteries conducted by private
individuals. However, it is clarified that Notification No. LOT-152/97 dated
17.01.2007 issued by the State Government prohibits the conduct of local
lotteries within the State of Arunachal Pradesh. Paragraph 2 of the additional
affidavit filed by respondent No. 3 being relevant is reproduced below:
“2. That the present respondent has taken a stand that the Lotteries
(Regulation) Act, 1998 is applicable to the local lotteries being organized by the
Page No.# 5/16
individuals in the State of Arunachal Pradesh, though the clear stand has not been
taken as such but accepted the claimed made by the petitioner as to applicability of
the Lotteries (Regulation) Act, 1998 over the subject matter of the PIL. After filling of
the affidavit-in-opposition, the matter has been re-examined again and it has been
found that Lotteries (Regulation) Act, 1998 prohibits the conduct of lotteries by the
State Government as provided under Sections 3 and 5 of the Act but the same do not
cover the local lotteries being organized by the private individuals. As such, this
additional affidavit is being filed to bring in the notice of this Hon’ble High Court that
the Lotteries (Regulation) Act, 1998 is not applicable over local lotteries conducted by
the private individuals. However, the Notification No.LOT-152/97 prohibits the conduct
of local lotteries in the State of Arunachal Pradesh.”
5.
In view of the aforesaid clarification given by the State respondent, it is
now necessary to consider the legal position declared by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in the judgment rendered in State of Karnataka & Anr. Vs. State of
Meghalaya & Ors., reported in (2022) 14 SCC 697. In the said case, the
Hon’ble Supreme Court examined the constitutional distribution of legislative
power relating to lotteries. It was held that lotteries, including private lotteries,
are treated as a form of betting and gambling and that lotteries organized by
private parties or entities fall under Entry 34 of List II of the Seventh Schedule
to the Constitution. Therefore, the State Legislature has the power to make laws
concerning them. It was also clarified in the said judgment that lotteries
organized by the Government of India or a State Government are covered by
Entry 40 of List I and, therefore, Parliament has the power to legislate in respect
of such lotteries.
6.
The relevant paragraph of State of Karnataka vs. Meghalaya
(supra) is reproduced below:
Page No.# 6/16
“124. In view of the aforesaid discussion, we come to the following summary of
conclusions: - State of Karnataka vs. Meghalaya
(i)
That the subject ‘betting and gambling’ in Entry 34 of List II is a State subject.
(ii)
From the judgments of this Court, it is now clear that ‘lotteries’ is a species of
gambling activity and hence lotteries is within the ambit of ‘betting and gambling’ as
appearing in Entry 34 List II.
(iii)
The expression ‘betting and gambling’ is relatable to an activity which is in the
nature of ‘betting and gambling’. Thus, all kinds and types of ‘betting and gambling’
fall within the subject of Entry 34 of List II. The expression ‘betting and gambling’ is
thus a genus it includes several types or species of activities such as horse racing,
wheeling and other local variations/forms of ‘betting and gambling’ activity. The
subject ‘lotteries organised by the Government of India or the Government of a State’
in Entry 40 of List I is a Union subject. It is only lotteries organised by the Government
of India or the Government of State in terms of Entry 40 of List I which are excluded
from Entry 34 of List II. In other words, if lotteries are conducted by private parties or
by instrumentalities or agencies authorized, by Government of India or the
Government of State, it would come within the scope and ambit of Entry 34 of List II.
(iv)
Thus, the State legislatures are denuded of their powers under Entry 34 of List
II only to the extent of lotteries organised by the Government of India or the
Government of a State, in terms of Entry 40 of List I. In other words, except what is
excluded in terms of Entry 40 of List I, all other activities which are in the nature of
‘betting and gambling’ would come within the scope and ambit of Entry 34 of List II.
Thus, ‘betting and gambling’ is a State subject except to the extent of it being
denuded of its powers insofar as Entry 40 of List I is concerned.
(v)
Entry 62 of List II is a specific taxation Entry on ‘luxuries, including taxes on
entertainments, amusements, betting and gambling’. The power to tax is on all
activities which are in the nature of ‘betting and gambling,’ including lotteries. Since,
there is no dispute that lotteries, irrespective of whether it is conducted or it is
organised by the Government of India or the Government of State or is authorized by
the State or is conducted by an agency or instrumentality of State Government or a
Central Government or any private player, is ‘betting and gambling’, the State
Legislatures have the power to tax lotteries under Entry 62 of List II. This is because
the taxation contemplated under the said Entry is on ‘betting and gambling’ activities
which also includes lotteries, irrespective of the entity conducting the same. Hence,
the legislations impugned are valid as the Karnataka and Kerala State Legislatures
possessed legislative competence to enact such Acts.
Page No.# 7/16
(vi)
Thus, the scope and ambit of lotteries organised by Government of India or
Government of State under Entry 40 of List I is only in the realm of regulation of such
lotteries. The said Entry does not take within its contours the power to impose
taxation on lotteries conducted by the Government of India or the Government of
State.
(vii) We also hold that lottery schemes by the Government of other States are
organised/conducted in the State of Karnataka or Kerala and there are express
provisions under the impugned Acts for registration of the agents or promoters of the
Governments of respective States for conducting the lottery schemes in the State of
Karnataka and the State of Kerala. This itself indicates sufficient territorial nexus
between the respondents– States who are organising the lottery and the States of
Karnataka and Kerala.
(viii) In view of the aforesaid conclusions, we find that Division Benches of the High
Courts of Kerala and Karnataka were not right in holding that the respective State
Legislatures had no legislative competence to impose tax on the lotteries conducted by
other States in their State (in the State of Karnataka and Kerala respectively).”
7.
Thus, it stands that the Lotteries (Regulation) Act, 1998 cannot be treated
as the sole statutory basis for regulating or prohibiting every lottery or draw
conducted by a private individual or community organization. Accordingly, the
subject and field concerning private lotteries, as a species of betting and
gambling, fall within the legislative competence of the State. This, however,
does not mean that private lotteries or similar activities are permissible as a
matter of right. Their legality would have to be examined with reference to the
applicable law, rules, notifications and orders issued by the concerned State
authority from time to time.
8.
In the present case, the State Government has relied upon Notification No.
LOT-152/97 dated 17.01.2007, whereby the sale, conduct and holding of onetime lotteries and housie within the territory of Arunachal Pradesh were
prohibited. The State has also relied upon the State law, rules, notifications and
executive orders issued by the State authorities from time to time applicable in
Page No.# 8/16
the State of Arunachal Pradesh relating to prohibition of gambling. Therefore,
we are of the opinion that, at this stage, it is not necessary for this Court, in the
present PIL, to decide the legality of every form of gift coupon or draw as to
whether a particular gift coupon scheme is, in substance, a lottery, gambling
activity or merely a voluntary contribution scheme involving gifts. This is a
question which depends upon the actual terms and manner of operation of that
particular scheme.
9.
Further, the factual circumstances with regard to the allegation made by
the petitioner in his complaint before the police station and the subsequent
action taken by the police pursuant to the FIR/complaint received are also
material and require consideration.
10. The affidavit filed on behalf of respondent No. 11, the Officer-in-Charge,
Police Station Papu Hill, Naharlagun, discloses that upon receipt of the complaint
dated 05.07.2025 regarding the proposed/conducted Dree Festival Gift Coupon
Draw, the same was entered as a GD Entry being GDE No. 13/2025 and an
inquiry was immediately initiated. During the course of the inquiry, notices
under Section 35(3) of the BNSS, 2023 were issued to the organizers, namely,
(i) Michi K. Tabing, (ii) Shri Habung Tapa, (iii) Shri Duyu Doilang, and (iv) Shri
Nani Pollo, and their statements were recorded in accordance with law.
11. It has been stated in the affidavit that, during the inquiry, the organizers
explained that the Dree Festival Gift Coupon Draw was not a lottery but an
adaptation of the traditional Apatani system of ‘MIHI’ (donation), namely, a
voluntary household contribution traditionally collected by the Miido Bulyang,
popularly known as Gora. According to the explanation recorded during the
inquiry, the gift coupon system was introduced as a modern adaptation of the
Page No.# 9/16
said practice. It is stated that the persons making voluntarily contributing
through the coupon then get a chance to receive the returned gift. It was
further stated that there was no compulsion upon any person to participate and
that there was no officially endorsed open-market sale of the coupons as it was
basically meant for distributing amongst the person belonged to the said
community.
12. It is further stated that, upon examination of the persons concerned, they
were released on personal bonds in accordance with law. The police affidavit
further states that, having regard to the facts ascertained during the inquiry,
preventive action permissible under law was taken to ensure that such activity
was not repeated. The police also ensured that the matter continued to remain
under watch. It has also been stated that, if any further material indicating the
commission of any cognizable offence is brought on record, necessary legal
action, including registration of an FIR, would be initiated.
13. The aforesaid materials demonstrate that the complaints made by the
petitioner were not ignored by the police authorities. On the contrary, the
complaints were entertained and an inquiry was initiated, notices were issued,
statements were recorded, and preventive action was taken. During hearing, the
petitioner has not been able to demonstrate any specific subsequent instance,
supported by material, where an alleged violation of law was brought to the
notice of the police/competent authority and it was deliberately ignored and
have not taken any action.
14. Similarly, the other respondents have also filed their respective affidavits.
The affidavits filed by respondent Nos. 8, 9 and 10 also show that the police
authorities of the respective police stations have taken necessary action on the
Page No.# 10/16
complaints received by them. The affidavits filed by the respondents indicate
that the complaint received at Naharlagun Police Station on 10.06.2025 was
registered in the General Diary. It was then forwarded to Ziro Police Station, as
the alleged occurrence took place within the jurisdiction of Ziro Police Station.
Another complaint regarding the proposed lottery at Seijosa was similarly
entered in the General Diary and the same was forwarded to the concerned
Police Station at Seizosa.
15. Likewise, the complaint received at Itanagar Police Station regarding the
alleged lucky draw at Namsai was entered in the General Diary and the same
was forwarded to Namsai Police Station for necessary action. In yet another
instance, upon receipt of information regarding the alleged lucky draw at
Doimukh, the police party visited the spot and conducted an inquiry, but it came
out that no lottery or other illegal activity was found at the location.
16. Thus, the affidavit filed by the respective respondents amply indicates that
the police authorities have acted upon the complaints received by them and
they have taken necessary action in accordance with law within their respective
jurisdictions.
17. There is, however, another circumstance which has emerged from the
affidavit of respondent No. 11. This fact disclosed in the affidavit of respondent
No. 11 requires consideration while examining the bonafides of the petitioner in
filing the present PIL. During the inquiry in connection with the FIR lodged by
the petitioner, it came to the notice of the police/inquiry officer that the
petitioner, namely, Shri Likha Rajnik, himself had been associated with a ‘ Pre
New Year Gift Coupon, 2024’ organization under the name and banner of
Jegeyoma Multipurpose Cooperative Society Limited.
Page No.# 11/16
18. The gift coupon placed on record as Annexure-1 to the affidavit bears
the name of the organization and contains, inter alia, a ticket price of Rs. 500/-.
The contents of the coupon promise substantial prizes, including a plot of land,
cash prizes and consolation prizes (in cash). The venue mentioned on the
coupon is Nikum Niya Hall, Nirjuli, and the draw was stated to be scheduled for
27.12.2024 at 2:00 P.M. onwards.
19. The affidavit filed by police respondent No. 11 further states that the
petitioner, Shri Likha Rajnik, was the Organizing Chairman of the said gift
coupon scheme. It further stated that in this regard an FIR/complaint dated
16.09.2025 was lodged by Shri Mom Apang and Shri Khoda Tapa, alleging, inter
alia, cheating, criminal breach of trust and violation of the Arunachal Pradesh
Gambling (Prohibition) Act, 2012 and the Lotteries (Regulation) Act, 1998. The
investigation in the said case is stated to be still in progress.
20. This Court has perused the complaint dated 16.09.2025 as well as the
coupon placed on record. The complaint alleges that the tickets were sold for
Rs. 500/- each, promising substantial prizes, including cash awards, but that the
draw was not conducted, the prizes were not distributed, nor was any refund
made. The complainant also alleged that the petitioner, Shri Likha Rajnik, was
the organizing Chairman of the said gift coupon scheme.
21. In this regard, we make it clear that the Court is not expressing any
opinion on the truth or otherwise of the allegations contained in the said
FIR/complaint against the petitioner. The criminal investigation shall proceed
independently, and the guilt or otherwise of the petitioner shall be determined
by the competent authority/Court strictly in accordance with law.
Page No.# 12/16
22. However, the petitioner’s own involvement in organizing a gift coupon
scheme having similar characteristics to the one allegedly organized by the
other community disclosed in the record, in our view, is directly relevant to the
subject matter of the present PIL. Therefore, it became necessary to ascertain
from the petitioner whether the fact that he organized the gift coupon was
disclosed in the petition and, if not, why such material fact was not brought to
the notice of the Court at the first instance.
23. The petitioner, by filing a rejoinder affidavit, has fairly admitted that he
was involved in organizing the said gift coupon. However, while admitting his
involvement in organizing the said gift coupon, the petitioner has explained that,
in view of the alleged rampant conduct of lotteries and housie activities in the
State, he himself attempted to organize the ‘Pre New Year Gift Coupon-2024’
under the belief that such activity was not illegal.
24. The petitioner states that he approached the Deputy Commissioner,
Capital Complex, Itanagar, by submitting a representation dated 04.04.2024
seeking permission to conduct the lottery at Nikum Niya Hall, Nirjuli. However,
he was informed by the concerned authorities that the conduct of lotteries was
prohibited. It was further informed that, if they organized one, all persons
involved in organizing such lottery, including the petitioner, would be arrested.
25. The petitioner stated that, thereafter he approached the Secretary, Law
Department, and Secretary, Lotteries. It is stated that upon being approached,
the Secretary, Law Department, and Secretary, Lotteries, also gave him the
same warning as given by the Deputy Commissioner. The petitioner states that,
consequently, he withdrew the gift coupon scheme and announced through
social media that organizing a lottery was illegal and that he would refund the
Page No.# 13/16
amounts collected from the purchasers.
26. The petitioner has further stated that the FIR dated 16.09.2025 was
lodged against him by persons indirectly connected with the Dree Festival Gift
Coupon activity, against whom he had earlier lodged a complaint. It is further
contended that the said FIR against him was motivated by retaliation. The
petitioner also stated that he had made complaints against several other
persons, communities and organizations allegedly conducting lottery activities.
The petitioner clarifies in the affidavit that his complaints were not directly
against any particular tribe or community.
27. This Court has considered the aforesaid explanation given by the
petitioner. This Court does not propose to record any finding that the PIL was
instituted out of personal vengeance against any particular tribe or community.
We find that there is insufficient material to draw any conclusive finding
regarding such alleged ill motive against any particular tribe or community.
Further, the petitioner’s assertion that he had made complaints against persons
belonging to different communities cannot also be brushed aside.
28. However, at the same time, the petitioner’s own involvement in organizing
a similar gift coupon scheme and the criminal complaint lodged against him
before the police station are relevant facts which needs to be taken into
consideration. These facts appear to have been within the knowledge of the
petitioner when the instant PIL was filed. Undern the circumstances, the
petitioner ought to have candidly disclosed the same to the Court. A person
approaching the Court invoking the extraordinary jurisdiction of the Court in
Public Interest Litigation is expected to disclose all material facts relevant to the
case and to demonstrate his bona fides.
Page No.# 14/16
29. Before disposing of the PIL, the Court considered it necessary to seek
certain clarifications from the petitioner. Accordingly, the following questions
were put to the petitioner through his learned counsel:
(i)
In view of the additional affidavit filed by respondent No. 3, wherein
the State has clarified the applicability of the Lotteries (Regulation) Act,
1998, what provision of the 1998 Act does the petitioner rely upon for
seeking
a
mandamus
against
private
individuals
or
community
organizations conducting alleged local lotteries/gift coupons?
(ii)
If the petitioner himself had sought permission to conduct a gift
coupon scheme in 2024 and thereafter stated to have withdrawn the same
upon being informed by the authorities that such activity was illegal and
prohibited. Why was the said fact, as well as the subsequent criminal
complaint lodged against the petitioner for organizing a similar gift
coupon, not disclosed in the petition?
(iii)
In view of the affidavits filed by the State respondents and the
police authorities showing that specific complaints have been acted upon
by registration and investigation/inquiry. Can the petitioner point out any
specific instance where an illegal lottery, in violation of the applicable
State notification or law, was brought to the notice of the competent
authority but no action was taken?
30. The petitioner has not been able to point out any specific provision of the
Lotteries (Regulation) Act, 1998 which requires the authorities to take action
against private persons or community organisations conducting local lotteries or
Gift Coupons. The petitioner, however, contends that respondent No.3 cannot
withdraw or change the stand taken in its earlier affidavit without an order of
Page No.# 15/16
this Court. It is also contended that the two affidavits of respondent No.3
contain contradictory stands which, according to the learned counsel for the
petitioner, is impermissible.
31. However, in view of the constitutional position explained and the law
declared by the Supreme Court in State of Karnataka & Ors. v. State of
Meghalaya & Ors. (supra), activities and grievance relating to private lotteries
fall within the State’s legislative field relating to betting and gambling. Their
legality has, therefore, to be examined under the applicable State law, rules,
notifications and orders.
32. This Court finds that the respondents have shown that the complaint
regarding the Dree Festival Gift Coupon was acted upon. The police conducted
an enquiry, examined the persons concerned and took preventive action. The
petitioner has not shown any specific instance of deliberate inaction by the
authorities. There is, therefore, no ground for issuing a general writ of
mandamus.
33. The prayer for a blanket prohibition of all Gift Coupons, Lucky Draws,
Housie or festival-related activities also cannot be granted as sought for.
Whether a particular scheme is a lottery, gambling activity or any other
prohibited activity depends upon its nature, terms and manner of operation and
the applicable law. Such an issue cannot be decided in the abstract in the
present PIL.
34. Moreover, the persons and community organizations who may be directly
affected by a blanket order of prohibition had not been impleaded as parties
respondent to the present proceeding. In such a situation, no adverse or
prohibitory order affecting their rights and activities can be passed behind their
Page No.# 16/16
back.
35. In view of the aforesaid facts and circumstances, this court finds no
ground is made out for issuing the general mandamus as prayed for by the
petitioner.
36. It is, however, clarified that dismissal of this PIL does not permit any
person, society, community organisation or other body to violate the applicable
law. The competent authorities shall continue to examine specific complaints
and shall take appropriate action, in accordance with law, against any person
found conducting a lottery, gambling activity or similar prohibited scheme.
37. The Court has also considered the question of costs. The petitioner has
offered his explanation regarding his involvement in the Gift Coupon scheme,
and the allegation against him is a subject matter of investigation. Although the
non-disclosure of the material fact is matter which is relevant while considering
the petitioner’s bona fides, however, in the facts and circumstances of the case,
the Court does not consider it necessary to impose exemplary costs.
38. Accordingly, the writ petition is dismissed. No order as to costs.
JUDGE
Sabnam Mepo (SPA)
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review