Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
signed by SHAMURAILATPAM SUSHIL SHARMA
SHAMURAILATPAM SUSHIL SHARMA Digitally
Date: 2023.06.01 12:40:52 +05'30'
Page |1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022
Ref:- El. Pet. No. 32 of 2022
Leishangthem Susindro Meitei (Yaima), aged about 38
years, S/o Leishangthem Itocha Meitei, resident of
Khurai Sajor Leikai, Tehsil: Sawombung, District:
Imphal East, Manipur- 795010.
….Applicant
(Respondent No. 1 in Election Petition)
-Versus1. Shri Laitonjam Jayananda Singh, aged about 31
years, S/o Laitonjam Inao Singh, resident of Khurai
Konsam Leikai near Chinjroibi, P.O. Lamlong, P.S.
Porompat, Imphal East District, Manipur- 795010
(National People’s Party (NPP) Candidate)
... Respondent
(Petitioner in Election Petition)
2. R.K. Amusana Singh, aged about 57 years, S/o (L)
Rajkumar Balhopsana Singh, resident of Khurai
Sajor Leikai, Ukhrul Road, P.O. Lamlong, P.S.
Porompat, Imphal East District, Manipur – 795010,
Candidate of Communist Party of India.
3. Khuraijam Ratankumar Singh, aged about 67
years, S/o (L) Khuraijam Nimaicharan Singh,
resident of Kangla Sangomshang, P.O. Lamlong,
P.S. Lamlai, Imphal East District, Manipur –
795010, Candidate of Nationalist Congress Party
(NCP).
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
Page |2
4. Khagokpam Khamba Singh, aged about 64 years,
S/o (L) Khagokpam Udhop Singh, resident of
Khurai Awang Kongpal Laishram Leikai, P.O. &
P.S. Porompat, Imphal East District, Manipur –
795005, Candidate of Republican Party of India
(Athawale).
5. Toijam Lokendro Singh, aged about 33 years, S/o
Toijam Achouba Singh, resident of Kongpal
Ningthobung Leikai, P.O. & P.S. Porompat, Imphal
East
District,
Manipur,
Manipur
–
795005,
Candidate of Janata Dal (United).
6. Heisnam Subhas Singh, aged about 56 years, S/o
(L) Heisnam Mani Singh, resident of Kongpal
Kongkham Leikai, P.O. & P.S. Porompat, Imphal
East, Manipur – 795005, Candidate of Lok
Janshakti Party (Ram Vilas).
... Proforma- Respondent
(Respondents No. 2 to 6 in Election Petition)
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M.V. MURALIDARAN
For the Applicant
::
Mr. N. Ibotombi, Sr. Advocate
Mr. A. Golly, Advocate
Mr. H. Suraj, Advocate
For the Respondents
::
Mr. HS Paonam, Sr. Advocate
Mr. A. Arunkumar, Advocate
Mr. M. Tapan Sharma, Advocate
Mr. Ajoy Pebam, Advocate
Date of Hearing and
reserving Judgment & Order ::
20.04.2023
Date of Judgment & Order
01.06.2023
::
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
Page |3
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
(CAV)
This miscellaneous case has been filed by the
applicant, who is the first respondent in the election petition, under
Order 7, Rule 11 and Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure,
1908 read with Sections 81, 83, 86 and 87 of the Representation of
People Act, 1951 for rejection of election petition, as the pleadings
and documents attached to the election petition do not make out a
cause of action or raise any triable issue and the trial would
prejudice, embarrass and cause injustice to the applicant if further
proceedings of the election petition is allowed sans any foundation
and cause of action.
2.
The first respondent herein has filed the election
petition to set aside the election of the applicant to the 12th Manipur
Legislative Assembly Constituency from 3-Khurai Legislative
Assembly Constituency after declaring the election of the applicant
from the said constituency as void on the ground of improper
acceptance of nomination and filing of false affidavit under Form 26;
non-compliance of the provisions of the Constitution or the
Representation of People Act, 1951 or of any Rules and to declare
the election petitioner as the returned candidate from 3-Khurai
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
Page |4
Assembly Constituency for the 12th Manipur Legislative Assembly
Election, 2022.
3.
Resisting
the
election
petition,
the
applicant/respondent no.1 and respondent nos.2 and 4 have filed
written statements.
The election petitioner has also filed
replications to the written statements filed by the respondent nos.1,
2 and 4.
4.
Pending election petition, the applicant has filed Misc.
(Elec. Petn.) No.97 of 2022 to dismiss the election petition stating
that the sum and substance of the allegations against the applicant
qua non-disclosure of moveable assets, non-disclosure of full postal
address, disparity in disclosing highest educational qualification,
swearing of false affidavit dated 5.2.2022 are not well founded and
the election petitioner at his own peril miserably failed to enclose or
attach the contentious Form 26 dated 5.2.2022 of the applicant and
moreover, no nomination paper dated 5.2.2022 of the applicant has
also been filed or enclosed by him along with the election petition.
According to the applicant, there is no cause of action sans the
contentious affidavit dated 5.2.2022. The second ground taken in
the miscellaneous case is the allegation of corrupt practice
allegedly committed by the applicant. The applicant stated that but
for the general allegation of corrupt practice, the election petitioner
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
Page |5
has not pleaded any relevant and pertinent material fact/ground and
particulars in the election petition. Moreover, the affidavit of the
election petitioner under Form 25 is not only defective, but also
vague and cryptic without any material facts and particulars.
5.
According to the applicant, the election petition has
been filed in gross violation of the mandate of Chapter VII-A of the
High Court of Manipur Rules, 2019, more particularly at pages 9,
10, 15, 16, 18, 59, 61, 62, 64, 65 and 67 of the election petition.
Stating that the election petition does not make out any cause of
action or raise any triable issues and, thus, he prayed for dismissal
of the election petition.
6.
Resisting
the
miscellaneous
case,
the
first
respondent/election petitioner filed affidavit-in-opposition stating
that the mentioning of 5.2.2022 as the date of affidavit filed by the
applicant in the election petition is a typographical error and it
should be read as 7.2.2022, as reflected in the affidavit annexed to
the election petition.
Since the first respondent annexed the
affidavit dated 7.2.2022 filed by the applicant under Form 26 and
prayed for quashing of the election of the applicant, this Court may
consider the validity of the election of the applicant on the basis of
the affidavit annexed to the election petition. It is stated that in the
election petition, the first respondent has categorically stated that in
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
Page |6
the affidavit in Form 26 filed along with the nomination paper before
the returning officer, the applicant has not disclosed Hyundai i20
Sportz car having registration No.DL10CA6639 and also the
applicant has changed his highest educational qualification from the
one mentioned in the affidavit filed in connection with the 11 th
Manipur Legislative Assembly Election, 2017.
Moreover, the
applicant has ignored the contention of the election petitioner about
the corrupt practice committed by him in the form of distribution of
Realme tab/tablets to the children of the voters. On this count of
corrupt practice, the election of the applicant is liable to be declared
as null and void. It is stated that since the Registry of the High Court
has accepted the election petition, the same shall be treated to be
in conformity with the mandatory provisions of the Manipur High
Court Rules. Furthermore, the election petition cannot be rejected
on flimsy ground that it is not accordant with the provisions of the
High Court Rules, which is only directory. It is stated that swearing
of false affidavit in Form 26 and indulging in corrupt practice of
distribution of tablets during the election campaign, which has
materially affected the result of the election, are all causes of action
and bundle of facts which are required to be proved in the trial for
declaring the election of the applicant as null and void. Thus, he
prayed for dismissal of the miscellaneous case.
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
Page |7
7.
The applicant filed rejoinder stating that it is on record
that the applicant had submitted three different affidavits in Form 26
dated 5.2.2022, 5.2.2022 and 7.2.2022 along with his nomination
paper which were duly accepted by the returning officer concerned.
The deliberate act of the election petitioner in not challenging or
questioning the two affidavits in Form 26 dated 5.2.2022 and
5.2.2022 is not only fatal, but also goes to the root and foundation
of the entire election petition. The excuse of typographical error of
mentioning the affidavit dated 5.2.2022 instead of 7.2.2022 in the
entire election petition is nothing but an afterthought or the theory
invented by the election petitioner just after filing of the written
statement dated 23.8.2022. It is stated that the applicant was the
absolute owner of the four-wheeler vehicle bearing registration
No.DL10CA6639 and said four-wheeler was legally sold by him to
one Henry Lalremsanga for a consideration of Rs.1.55 lakh on
execution of a registered agreement and signing of relevant Forms.
Therefore, the applicant cannot be the legal and lawful owner of the
said four-wheeler and, therefore, there is no question of nondisclosure of said four wheeler in the affidavit in Form 26 of the
applicant. It is stated that the High Court of Manipur Rules, 2019 is
mandatory in nature and not a mere formality as harped on by the
election petitioner. The acceptance of the defective election petition
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
Page |8
by the Registry cannot be cleansed in the absence of a judicial
order.
8.
Mr. N. Ibotombi, the learned senior counsel assisted
by Mr. A. Golly, learned counsel appearing for the applicant
submitted
that
the
main
ground
taken
by
the
first
respondent/election petitioner to set aside the election of the
application is non-disclosure of moveable assets, non-disclosure of
full postal address, disparity in disclosing highest educational
qualification, swearing of false affidavit dated 5.2.2022. He would
submit that the first respondent/election petitioner has failed to
enclose the contentious affidavit in Form 26 dated 5.2.2022 of the
applicant along with the election petition and on the sole ground of
non-filing of the affidavit dated 5.2.2022, the election petition is
liable to be rejected, as there is no cause of action for filing the
election petition.
9.
The learned senior counsel for the applicant further
submitted
that
the
next
ground
taken
by
the
first
respondent/election petitioner is the corrupt practice committed by
the applicant. He would submit that but for the general allegation
of corrupt practice, the first respondent/ election petitioner has not
pleaded any relevant and material particulars in the election
petition.
According to the learned senior counsel, the election
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
Page |9
petition is not only defective, but also vague and cryptic without any
material facts and particulars.
10.
The learned senior counsel urged that an election
petition which does not disclose any cause of action can be
dismissed summarily either at the threshold of the proceeding or at
any subsequent stage of the proceeding. If after framing of issues
or issuance of summons, the basic defect in the election petition,
namely absence of cause of action, persists, it is always open to the
contesting respondent to raise the objection to maintainability of the
election petition and the Court would be acting within his jurisdiction
in exercise of its power under Order VII, Rule 11 CPC in rejecting
the same even after settlement of issues or issuance of summons.
Thus, it would be in the interest of the parties to the election petition
and to the constituency as well as in public interest to dispose of
preliminary objection and to reject the election petition if it does not
disclose any cause of action or triable issues or no pleading of
material facts and particulars of the alleged corrupt practice or gross
violation of the mandates of Chapter VII-A of the Manipur High
Court Rules, 2019. Arguing so, the learned senior counsel prayed
for rejection of the election petition, as the election petition does not
make out any cause of action or raise any triable issues.
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 10
11.
In support of his submissions, the learned senior
counsel for the applicant relied upon the following decisions:
(i)
Church of North India v. Lavajibhai
Ratanjibhai and others, (2005) 10 SCC
760.
(ii)
Neena Vikram Verma v. Balmukund
Singh Gautam and others, (2013) 5
SCC 673.
(iii)
Dahiben
v.
Arvindbhai
Kalyanji
Bhanusali (Gajra) dead through legal
representatives and others, (2020) 7
SCC 366.
(iv)
Azhar Hussain v. Rajiv Gandhi, 1986
(Supp.) SCC 315.
(v)
Mohan Rowale v. Damodar Tatyaba
and others, (1994) 2 SCC 392.
(vi)
Anil Vasudev Salgaonkar v. Nareh
Kushali Shigaonkar, (2009) 9 SCC 310.
(vii)
Dr. Shipra v. Shantilal Khoiwal, (1996)
5 SCC 181.
(viii) HardwariLal v. Kanwal Singh, (1972) 1
SCC 214.
(ix)
Ravinder Singh v. Janmeja Singh,
(2000) 8 SCC 191.
12.
Per contra, Mr. HS Paonam, the learned senior
counsel assisted by Mr. A. Arunkumar, learned counsel appearing
for the first respondent/election petitioner submitted that due to
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 11
typographical error, the affidavit date has been mentioned as
05.02.2022
instead
of
07.02.2022.
Since
the
first
respondent/election petitioner has filed the affidavit in Form 26
dated 7.2.2022 along with the election petition, the argument of the
learned senior counsel for the applicant that the non-filing of the
affidavit dated 5.2.2022 is not materially affected the election
petition. He would submit that rejection of election petition on
typographical error is incorrect. In fact, in his election petition, the
first respondent has clearly stated that in the affidavit under Form
26 filed along with the nomination, the applicant has not disclosed
Hyundai i20 Sportz car bearing registration No.DL10CA6639 and
also the applicant has changed his highest educational qualification
from the one mentioned in the 11th Manipur Legislative Assembly
Election, 2017.
13.
The
learned
senior
counsel
for
the
first
respondent/election petitioner further submitted that the applicant
has distributed Realme tablets to the children of the voters in the
election of 12thManipur Legislative Assembly Election, 2022 and, as
such, the applicant has involved in corrupt practice during the
election campaign. Therefore, on the ground of indulging in corrupt
practice, the election of the applicant is liable to be declared as null
and void.
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 12
14.
The learned senior counsel added that the annexure
to the nomination paper is not necessary in the election petition.
The whole allegation of the applicant is nothing but to digress the
attention of this Court from non-disclosure of material facts in the
affidavit filed by him. That apart, some misleading statements have
been averred in the miscellaneous case.
15.
The
learned
senior
counsel
for
the
first
respondent/election petitioner further submitted that since the
Registry of this Court accepted the election petition, the same shall
be treated to be in conformity with the mandatory provisions of
Manipur High Court Rules.
Furthermore, the election petition
cannot be rejected on flimsy ground of non-adherence of provisions
of the Manipur High Court Rules. Swearing of false affidavit in Form
26 and indulging in corrupt practice of distribution of tablets during
the election campaign, which has materially affected the result of
the election are all causes of action and bundle of facts which are
required to be proved in the trial.
16.
The learned senior counsel for the election petitioner
urged that the election petition is not liable to be dismissed in limine
so long as the claim discloses some cause of action or raises some
questions fit to be decided by the Court. In the present case, the
election petitioner has raised specific allegation of false affidavit by
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 13
the applicant which requires to be decided by the High Court.
Arguing so, the learned senior counsel prayed for dismissal of the
present miscellaneous case.
17.
To fortify the aforesaid submissions, the learned
senior counsel for the first respondent/election petitioner placed
reliance upon the following decisions:
(i)
Gorelal Shakya v. Maharaj Singh
Yadav, 1995 Supp (3) SCC 407.
(ii)
Ram Prasad Sarma v. Manikumar
Subba and others, (2003) 1 SCC 289.
(iii)
P.V.Guru Raj Reddy and another v.
P.Neeradha Reddy and others, (2015)
8 SCC 331.
(iv)
Srihari Numandas Totala v. Hemant
Vithal Kamat and others, (2021) 9 SCC
99.
(v)
Dr.Ramachandran
v.
R.V.Janakuraman and others, (1999) 3
SCC 267.
(vi)
Sardar Harcharan Singh Brar v. Sukh
Darhan Singh, (2004) 11 SCC 196.
(vii)
Chandrakan
tUttam
Chodankar
v.
Dayanand Rayu Mandrakar, (2005) 2
SCC 188.
(viii) Umesh
Challiyil
v.
K.P.Rajendran,
(2008) 11 SCC 740.
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 14
18.
The learned counsel appearing for the second
respondent submitted that the improper acceptance of the
nomination paper of the applicant by the returning officer materially
affected the result of the election.
Since the defects in the
nomination paper are substantial in nature, the acceptance of the
nomination of the applicant for the election from 3-Khurai Assembly
Constituency is improper and is liable to be rejected.
19.
The learned counsel appearing for the fourth
respondent submitted that material facts are primary and basic facts
which must be pleaded by the election petitioner, while the details
in support thereof which are meant to amplify, refine and embellish
the material facts give a distinct touch to the basic contours of a
picture already drawn so as to make it more clear and informative.
In the case on hand, the material facts constituting the foundation
of the case set up by the election petitioner have been stated in the
election petition. Therefore, the question of dismissing the election
petition on the ground of no cause of action arose is untenable.
Moreover, the election petitioner has made out a case for trial,
which can be canvassed by adducing evidence.
20.
By placing on record, the decisions of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the cases of Shri Udhav Singh v. Madhav Rao
Scindia, (1977) 1 SCC 511 and Madiraju Venkata Ramana Raju v.
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 15
Peddireddigari Ramachandra Reddy, (2018) 14 SCC 1, the learned
counsel argued that a pleading has to be read as a whole to
ascertain its true import and cannot be dissected sentence-wise or
paragraph-wise to rule that the same does not disclose a cause of
action.
21.
This Court considered the rival submissions and also
perused the materials available on record.
22.
The first respondent/election petitioner has filed the
election petition to set aside the election of the applicant to the 12th
Manipur
Legislative
Assembly
Constituency
from
3-Khurai
Legislative Assembly Constituency after declaring the election of
the applicant as void on the following grounds: (i) improper
acceptance of nomination; (ii) filing false affidavit under Form 26;
and, (iii) non-compliance of the provisions of the Constitution of
India or the Representation of People Act, 1951.
23.
The applicant herein belongs to the Bharatiya Janata
Party (BJP) and the first respondent/election petitioner belongs to
the National People’s Party (NPP).
24.
There is no dispute that the nominations filed by the
candidates along with affidavits under Form 26 are displayed in the
notice board of the returning officer and a set of the nomination
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 16
papers along with affidavit under Form 26 are uploaded on the
website of the Election Commission of India so that the information
furnished by the candidates are reached to the people and any nondisclosure in violation or non-compliance of the Act/Rules thereof
will be liable for rejection of the nomination paper.
25.
It is the specific plea of the first respondent/election
petitioner that the applicant has deliberately not disclosed the
material facts in Form 26, which is a blatant violation of the
Act/Rules and amounts to undue influence by the candidate to the
voters.
26.
According to the first respondent/election petitioner,
earlier when the applicant has filed affidavit along with the
nomination paper for election to the 11th Manipur Legislative
Assembly, 2017, he has mentioned his highest educational
qualification in Column 10 of the affidavit as “passed Diploma in
Electrician from ITI, Imphal”, whereas in the election in question, the
applicant mentioned his highest educational qualification as
“passed Higher Secondary Examination in the year 2001 from Ng.
Mani College under Council of Higher Secondary Education,
Manipur”. Thus, it is the contention of the first respondent/election
petitioner that the applicant has sworn a false affidavit. However,
the applicant contended that realizing the error or mistake in the
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 17
highest educational qualification mentioned in the affidavit dated
14.2.2017, the applicant in his three affidavits dated 5.2.2022,
5.2.2022 and 7.2.2022 corrected the same by stating his highest
education qualification as “passed Higher Secondary Examination”.
The correction of such inadvertent misadvise or error does not
amount to swearing a false affidavit in Form 26 in the recently held
12th Manipur Legislative Assembly Election, 2022.
27.
It would be pertinent to quote Column 10 of the
affidavit filed along with the nomination paper for the election to the
11th Manipur Legislative Assembly, 2017, wherein it has been
stated as under:
“(10) My educational qualification is as under:
Passed Diploma in Electrician from Industrial
Training Institute, Imphal in the Year 2002.”
28.
Column 10 of the affidavit filed along with the
nomination paper for election to the 12th Manipur Legislative
Assembly, 2022, it has been stated as under:
“(10) My educational qualification is as under:Passed Higher Secondary Examination in the year
2001 from Ng. Mani College, under Council of
Higher Secondary Education, Manipur.”
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 18
29.
According to the applicant, it is the wisdom of the
concerned authority to allow or permit to pursue or undergo 2
courses simultaneously and the said issue cannot be the subject
matter of the present election.
As rightly argued by the learned
senior counsel for the applicant, any Class-X passed student can
apply and get admitted for the course of Electrician trade or Diploma
of Electrician. However, after passing such course, one cannot
pursue graduation degree except after passing Class-XII. In other
words, Class-XII certificate is higher in educational qualification
than that of completing/passing of Electrician trade or Diploma of
Electrician.
30.
In this context, a perusal of the affidavit in Form-26
filed by the applicant for the election to 10th General Election from
3-Khurai Assembly Constituency, which was annexed with the
written statement filed by the fourth respondent, it is seen that the
highest educational qualification of the applicant has been stated at
the relevant column as under:
“10+2 with Diploma (Electrical)”
31.
Therefore, there is no concealment of educational
qualification by the applicant while filing affidavit in Form-26 for the
election in question. That apart, in the reply to the letter dated
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 19
29.6.2022 of one Thounaojam Sanaton Singh for furnishing the
information under Section 6 of the RTI Act, 2005, the Principal of
Ng. Mani College, Khurai, it has been clearly stated that “Shri
Leishangthem Susindro Meitei, passed the Hr. Sec. Exam. In the
year 2001 (Conducted by the COHSEM) in 2ndDivn. Under Exam.
Roll No.16637”, which further strengthens the plea of the applicant
that there is no concealment of the educational qualification by the
applicant while filing affidavit in Form-26 for 12th Manipur Legislative
Assembly Constituency Election.
32.
The next ground taken by the first respondent/election
petitioner is that the applicant has not disclosed Hyundai Motor i20
Sportz car having registration No.DL10CA6639 and the name of the
applicant is still registered as the first owner of the vehicle in the
RTO office of Rajouri Garden, New Delhi.
This factum is
substantiated from the App “CarInfo”. However, the applicant has
failed to disclose the said i20 car in his moveable assets at Column
No.7A(vi) in the affidavit filed under Form 26 in connection with 12th
Manipur Legislative Assembly Election.
According to the first
respondent/election petitioner, the applicant has intentionally and
deliberately not disclosed that he is the owner of the said i20 car.
33.
The applicant contended that since he had sold the
said i20 Sportz car on 13.12.2017 to one Henry Lalremsanga, the
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 20
question of concealment and non-disclosure of moveable assets by
the applicant in his affidavit filed under Form 26 in connection with
the 12th Manipur Legislative Election does not arise. In support, the
applicant has produced the original agreement dated 13.12.2017
along with the written statement.
34.
For proper appreciation, Colum 7A(vi) of affidavit and
the relevant paragraphs of the agreement dated 13.12.2017 are
quoted hereunder:
S.
No.
Description
Self
Spouse
HUF
Depend
ent -1
Depen
dent -2
Depen
dent -3
(vi)
Motor
Vehicles/Aircr
aft
Yachts/Ships
(Details
of
Make,
registration
member etc.
year
of
purchase and
amount)
1.
MG
HECTOR
Car Bearing
Registration
No.MN061
B8411 Yeas
of
Manufacturin
g year-2022
@
Rs.20,15,75
8/-
NIL
NIL
NIL
NIL
NIL
“1. That, the Seller hereby sales the aforesaid i20
Sportz (O) bearing Registration No.DL10CA6639
with delivery of possession whereof on favour of
the buyer to HAVE, HOLD and enjoy it as his own
even by transfer of title and the Buyer has also
simultaneously taken into possession of the said
i20 Sportz (O); on the receipt of acknowledgment
of consideration amount of Rs.1,55,000/- (Rupees
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 21
one lakh fifty-five thousand) by the Seller from the
buyer for the sale of the said vehicle.
2. That, the Buyer shall take all responsibility and
steps to transfer the title of the said Vehicle in his
name in the records of RTO/DTO, Delhi or any
other RTO/DTO.”
35.
The next ground taken by the election petitioner to
challenge the election of the applicant is that the applicant has not
provided the full postal address in Form 26 filed in connection with
the 12th Manipur Legislative Assembly Election.
In fact, in the
previous affidavit filed in 2017 election, the applicant has stated his
address as below:
“Khurai Sajor Leikai, Tinsid Road, P.O. & P.S.
Porompat, Imphal East District. Manipur, Pin Code
No.795 005.”
36.
The
first
respondent/election
petitioner
also
challenged the election of the applicant on the ground that in order
to woo the voters of 3-Khurai Assembly Constituency, the applicant
promised to distribute 10,000 i-pads to the students in a meeting
held on 7.2.2022 at his residence at Khurai Sajor Leikai. The said
promise was published in the local daily “The Poknapham” on
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 22
8.2.2022 and the visual information was also aired in the evening
news of the cable network.
37.
Mr. HS Paonam, the learned senior counsel for the
election petitioner contended that in pursuance of the promise, the
applicant in a function held on 23.2.2022 at Khurai Sajor Leikai had
distributed Realme tablets to some of the students who are children
of the electorates of 3-Khurai Assembly Constituency thereby
inducing the parents of such children to vote for the applicant.
According to the learned senior counsel, distribution of tablets to the
students of his constituency has the effect of undue influence by
bribery and the same will attract the provision of Section 100(1)(b)
and Section 123 of the Representation of People Act, 1951. Thus,
the election of the applicant has been tainted with corrupt practice
and is liable to be declared as void.
38.
Denying the aforesaid contentions of the first
respondent/ election petitioner, Mr. N. Ibotombi, the learned senior
counsel appearing for the applicant submitted that there is no
material to prove that the applicant has indulged in corrupt practice.
Further, there is no material facts of visual information furnished by
the election petitioner in the election petition. The learned senior
counsel for the applicant argued that the allegation of distribution of
tablets to the students was complained by the election petitioner
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 23
before the returning officer of 3-Khurai Assembly Constituency and
the returning officer after conducting an enquiry came to the
conclusion that the distribution of tablets to the students of Khurai
Assembly Constituency was by Susindro Foundation, which is not
related to the applicant and there is no violation of Model Code of
Conduct by the applicant.
39.
As stated supra, the sum and substance of the
allegations against the applicant are non-disclosure of moveable
assets, non-disclosure of full postal address, disparity in disclosing
highest educational qualification in the affidavit dated 5.2.2022 and
also allegation of corrupt practice.
Setting out the aforesaid
allegations, the first respondent/election petitioner filed the election
petition by the stating the cause of action as under:
“23. That, the cause of action for filing this Election
Petition arose on 10/03/2022 when the Final
Result Sheet was published and declared that the
respondent no.1 as the elected candidate and the
same is continuing within the jurisdiction of this
Hon’ble High Court.”
40.
Since the learned senior counsel appearing for the
election petitioner and the learned senior counsel appearing for the
returned candidate have touched upon the allegations of non-
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 24
disclosure of material facts and the corrupt practice said to have
been indulged by the applicant, before going into deal with the issue
involved in this miscellaneous case, this Court proceeded to
highlight the contentions of the parties and the prima facie view of
this Court on the aforesaid contentions are as under:
The argument of the learned senior counsel
for the applicant is that nothing has been
produced by the first respondent/election
petitioner along with the election petition to
show that the applicant has deliberately
concealed the educational qualification of
Diploma in Electrician in Form 26 while filing
his nomination paper in connection with the
12th Manipur Legislative Assembly Election.
The alleged concealment stated by the first
respondent/election petitioner relates to the
previous election in the year 2017.
Non-
disclosure of highest qualification of the
applicant for the election held in the year
2017, cannot be gone into at this stage in view
of the delay in raising such an issue.
Prima facie, this Court is of the view that as
rightly argued by the learned senior counsel
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 25
for
the
applicant
the
two
different
qualifications mentioned in the affidavit in
Form 26 during the year 2017 and 2022 does
not materially affect the election of the
applicant, as it is not the case of the first
respondent/election
petitioner
applicant
pursued
has
not
Secondary Examination.
that
his
the
Higher
Therefore, the
applicant has not deliberately concealed the
educational
qualification
of
Diploma
in
Electrician in the affidavit in Form 26 for the
2022 State Assembly Election.
The first respondent/election petitioner stated
that “nomination paper is of dated 05.2.2022”,
which is incorrect.
The learned senior
counsel for the first respondent pleaded that
mentioning of 05.02.2022 as date of affidavit
stated
by the
election
petitioner
is a
typographical error and it should be read as
07.02.2022.
On a perusal of the nomination papers of the
applicant, it is seen that the affidavit in Form
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 26
26 of the applicant for the election in question
is dated 07.02.2022.
The first respondent/election petitioner mainly
relies upon the App “CarInfo” to allege that the
applicant has failed to disclose the i20 Sportz
car in his moveable assets at Column 7A(vi)
in the affidavit in Form 26.
Merely because the name of the applicant in
respect of i20 Sportz (O) bearing registration
No.DL10CA6639 is mentioned in the App, it
cannot be contended that the applicant has
deliberately omitted to disclose the owning of
i20 Sportz car in the affidavit in Form 26.
A perusal of the agreement dated 13.12.2017
produced by the applicant would clearly
shows that the aforesaid i20 Sportz car was
sold to one Henry Lalremsanga of Mizoram
and as rightly contended by the learned
senior counsel for the applicant, it is for the
buyer to take steps to transfer the title of the
said vehicle in his favour. According to the
applicant, the subsequent buyer through his
solemn affidavit dated 18.8.2022 voluntarily
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 27
declares that he is the absolute owner in
possession of the aforesaid i20 Sportz car
since 13.2.2017.
respondent/
The plea of the first
election
petitioner
that
the
applicant has failed to disclose the i20 Sportz
car in his moveable assets at Column 7A(vi)
in the affidavit in Form 26 is not well-founded.
On a perusal of the affidavit in Form 26 filed
by the applicant in connection with the 12th
Manipur Legislative Assembly Election, in
Part “A”, it has been stated as under:
“I,
Leishangthem
Susindro
Meitei
son
of
Leishangthem Itocha Meitei, Aged 38 years,
resident
of
Khurai
Sajor
Leikai,
Tehsil-
Sawombung, District-Imphal East – 795010,
Manipur …..”
In the affidavit in Form 26 filed in connection
with the 11th Manipur Legislative Assembly
Election, in Part “A” beginning, it has been
stated as under:
“I
Leishangthem
Susindro
Meitei
son
of
Lishangthem Itocha Meitei, aged 33 years,
resident of Khurai Sajor Leikai, Tinsid Road, P.O.
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 28
& P.S. Porompat, Imphal East District, Manipur,
Pin No.795005.”
Mere non-mentioning of P.O. & P.S. of the
address in the affidavit filed in respect of the
12thManipur Legislative Assembly Election is
not materially affected the election of the
applicant in question for the reason that there
is no difference in the full postal address of
the applicant.
With regard to allegation against the applicant
that he had distributed tab/tablets to children
of the voters, the pleadings of the parties
reveal that pursuant to the complaint made by
the election petitioner to the returning officer
dated 24.2.2022, the returning officer served
a letter dated 25.2.2022 to the applicant to
submit a reply to the complaint filed by the
election petitioner and in pursuance of the
letter dated 25.2.2022, on 26.2.2022, the
applicant has submitted his reply letter to the
returning officer, wherein it has been stated
as under:
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 29
“The allegation made by Laitonjam Jayananda
Singh in connection with Distribution of I
pad/Tablet for the students of Khurai Assembly
Constituency by Susindro Foundation is not
related to me.
Therefore, his complaint void.”
In
his
election
petition,
the
first
respondent/election petitioner stated that
after calling for explanation from the applicant
regarding distribution of tab/tablets to children
of the voters, no action was taken against the
applicant by the returning officer.
As stated supra, pursuant to the letter
addressed by the returning officer regarding
distribution of tab/tablets to the students, the
applicant has suitably replied that the
distribution of tab/tablets to the students was
by Susindro Foundation, which is not related
to the applicant.
When such being the reply
and after satisfying with the reply submitted
by the applicant, the returning officer had not
precipitated the said issue any further. Prima
facie, there are no details given by the
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 30
election
petitioner
qua
distribution
of
tab/tablets to the students by the applicant
against the Model Code of Conduct in the
election petition.
This Court is of the prima
facie view that the plea of distribution of
tab/tablets to children of the voters canvassed
by the election petitioner is not supported by
any valid proof.
41.
Only for the sake of clarity on the arguments raised by
the learned counsel appearing for the respective parties, this Court
highlighted the aforesaid contentions and expressed its prima facie
view.
42.
Now, coming to the core point that is involved in the
present miscellaneous case, the applicant contended that the
election petition is liable to be rejected, as there is no cause of
action sans the contentious affidavit dated 5.2.2022/7.2.2022 of the
applicant. Further, the election petition is not in proper form as
mandated by the provisions of the Representation of People Act,
1951 and the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 and the election
petition is not in conformity with Chapter VIIA of the High Court of
Manipur Rules, 2019.
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 31
43.
Learned Senior Counsel for the applicant, in support
of the miscellaneous case filed under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC, has
submitted that no cause of action has been made out and no triable
issue arose from the pleadings and, as such, the trial of the election
petition would only be a vexatious and futile exercise and, thus,
prayed that while allowing the present miscellaneous case filed
under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC, the election petition filed by the first
respondent/election petitioner be rejected.
44.
The learned senior counsel for the election petitioner
argued that the cause of action is a bundle of facts which taken with
the law applicable to them gives the plaintiff the right to relief against
the defendant. Every fact which is necessary for the plaintiff to
prove to enable him to get a decree. It is worthwhile to find out the
meaning of the words “cause of action”. A cause of action must
include some act done by the defendant since in the absence of
such an act no cause of action can possibly accrue. In support, the
learned senior counsel placed reliance upon the decision of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of ABC Laminart (P) Ltd. V.
A.P. Agencies, (1989) 2 SCC 163, wherein the Hon’ble Supreme
Court explained the meaning of “cause of action” as under:
“12. A cause of action means every fact, which if
traversed, it would be necessary for the plaintiff to
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 32
prove in order to support his right to a judgment of
the court. In other words, it is a bundle of facts
which taken with the law applicable to them gives
the plaintiff a right to relief against the defendant.
It must include some act done by the defendant
since in the absence of such an act no cause of
action can possibly accrue. It is not limited to the
actual infringement of the right sued on but
includes all the material facts on which it is
founded. It does not comprise evidence necessary
to prove such facts, but every fact necessary for
the plaintiff to prove to enable him to obtain a
decree. Everything which if not proved would give
the defendant a right to immediate judgment must
be part of the cause of action. ….”
45.
By placing on record the decision of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the case of Kunjan Nair Sivaraman Nair v.
Narayan Nair, (2004) 3 SCC 277, the learned senior counsel for
the election petitioner argued that the expression “cause of action”
has acquired a judicially settled meaning and in the restricted
sense, cause of action means the circumstances forming the
infraction of the right or the immediate occasion for the act. In
Kunjan Nair Sivaraman Nair, supra, the Hon’ble Supreme Court
held thus:
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 33
“16. The expression “cause of action” has
acquired a judicially settled meaning.
In the
restricted sense cause of action means the
circumstances forming the infraction of the right or
the immediate occasion for the action. In the wider
sense, it means the necessary conditions for the
maintenance of the suit, including not only
infraction of the right, but the infraction coupled
with
the
right
itself.
Compendiously
the
expression means every fact which would be
necessary for the plaintiff to prove, if traversed, in
order to support his right to the judgment of the
court. Every fact which is necessary to be proved,
as distinguished from every piece of evidence
which is necessary to prove each fact, comprises
in “cause of action”.”
46.
“Cause of action” is a term of art and has been
described by the Hon'ble Supreme Court as also by this Court as a
concise statement of material facts as also full particulars (where
corrupt practice at an election is alleged) on which the election
petitioner relies for making out corrupt practice as a ground for
setting aside an election. A cause of action challenging an election
on the ground of corrupt practice requires as full a statement as
possible of the names of the parties alleged to have committed the
corrupt practice and the details, date and place of the commission
of such corrupt practice.
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 34
47.
This Court at first briefly intends to deal with the law
governing an application under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC, which reads
as under:
“11. Rejection of plaint.—The plaint shall be
rejected in the following cases—
(a) where it does not disclose a cause of
action;
(b) where the relief claimed is undervalued,
and the plaintiff, on being required by the
court to correct the valuation within a time to
be fixed by the court, fails to do so;
(c) where the relief claimed is properly valued
but
the
plaint
is
written
upon
paper
insufficiently stamped, and the plaintiff, on
being required by the court to supply the
requisite stamp paper within a time to be
fixed by the court, fails to do so;
(d) where
the
suit
appears
from
the
statement in the plaint to be barred by any
law;
(e) where it is not filed in duplicate;
(f) where the plaintiff fails to comply with the
provisions of Rule 9:
Provided that the time fixed by the court for
the correction of the valuation or supplying of
the requisite stamp-papers shall not be
extended unless the court, for reasons to be
recorded, is satisfied that the plaintiff was
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 35
prevented by any cause of an exceptional
nature from correcting the valuation or
supplying the requisite stamp-papers, as the
case may be, within the time fixed by the
court and that refusal to extend such time
would cause grave injustice to the plaintiff.”
48.
“Cause of action” means every fact which would be
necessary for the plaintiff to prove, if traversed, in order to support
his right to judgment. It consists of a bundle of material facts, which
are necessary for the plaintiff to prove in order to entitle him to the
reliefs claimed in the suit.
49.
In Swamy
Atmananda v. Sri
Ramakrishna
Tapovanam (2005) 10 SCC 51, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held :
“24. A cause of action, thus, means every fact,
which, if traversed, it would be necessary for the
plaintiff to prove in order to support his right to a
judgment of the court. In other words, it is a bundle
of facts, which taken with the law applicable to
them gives the plaintiff a right to relief against the
defendant. It must include some act done by
the defendant since in the absence of such an
act, no cause of action can possibly accrue. It
is not limited to the actual infringement of the
right sued on but includes all the material facts
on which it is founded.”
[emphasis supplied]
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 36
50.
In T.Arivandandam v. T.V. Satyapal, (1977) 4 SCC
467, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that while considering an
application under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC what is required to be
decided is whether the plaint discloses a real cause of action, or
something purely illusory, in the following words:
“5. … The learned Munsif must remember that if
on a meaningful—not formal—reading of the plaint
it is manifestly vexatious, and meritless, in the
sense of not disclosing a clear right to sue, he
should exercise his power under Order 7 Rule 11
CPC taking care to see that the ground mentioned
therein is fulfilled. And, if clever drafting has
created the illusion of a cause of action, nip it
in the bud at the first hearing.…”
[emphasis supplied]
51.
In ITC Ltd. v. Debts Recovery Appellate Tribunal,
(1998) 2 SCC 70, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that law cannot
permit clever drafting which creates illusions of a cause of action.
What is required is that a clear right must be made out in the plaint.
If, however, by clever drafting of the plaint, it has created the illusion
of a cause of action, the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Madanuri Sri
Rama Chandra Murthy v. Syed Jalal, (2017) 13 SCC 174 held
that it should be nipped in the bud, so that bogus litigation will end
at the earliest stage. The Court must be vigilant against any
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 37
camouflage or suppression, and determine whether the litigation is
utterly vexatious and an abuse of the process of the Court.
52.
It is true that election petition will have to be read as a
whole and cannot be dissected sentence-wise or paragraph-wise to
rule that the same does not disclose a cause of action. Cause of
action embodies a bundle of facts which may be necessary for the
election petitioner to prove in order to get a relief from the Court.
53.
The Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Daulat
Ram Chauhan v. Anand Sharma, (1984) 2 SCC 64, held as under:
“18. We must remember that in order to constitute
corrupt practice, which entails not only the
dismissal of the election petition but also other
serious
consequences
like
debarring
the
candidate concerned from contesting a future
election for a period of six years, the allegations
must be very strongly and narrowly construed to
the very spirit and letter of the law. In other words,
in order to constitute corrupt practices, the
following necessary particulars, statement of
facts and essential ingredients must be
contained in the pleadings:
(i) Direct and detailed nature of corrupt
practice as defined in the Act;
(ii) Details of every important particular
must be stated giving the time, place, names
of persons, use of words and expression etc.;
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 38
(iii) It must clearly appear from the
allegations that the corrupt practices alleged
were indulged in by (a) the candidate himself
(b) his authorized election agent or any other
person with this express or implied consent.
19. A person may, due to sympathy or on his own,
support the candidature of particular candidate but
unless a close and direct nexus is provided
between the act of the person and the consent
given to him by the candidate or his election agent,
the same would not amount to a pleading of
corrupt practice as contemplated by law. It cannot
be left to time, chance or conjecture for the court
to draw an inference by adopting in involved
process of reasoning. In fine, the allegation must
be so clear and specific that the inference of
corrupt practice will irresistibly admit of no doubt
or qualm.
20. As a logical consequence of the principles
enunciated by us, it follows that where the
allegation of fraudulent practice is open to two
equal possible inferences, the pleading of corrupt
practice must fail. For instance, A, or in this case
Sodd or Batish, joined or participated or was
present in an election rally or crown and may have
shouted slogans on his own without taking the
consent of the candidate concerned, this would
not be a corrupt practice within the meaning of
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 39
Section 123(2) because the element of consent is
wholly wanting.”
[emphasis supplied]
54.
The Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of F.A.Sapa
v. Singora, (1991) 3 SCC 375, held as under:
“17. Election of a returned candidate can be
rendered void on proof of the alleged corrupt
practice. In addition thereto he would incur a
subsequent disqualification also. This harshness
is essential if we want our democratic process to
be clean, free and fair. Eradication of corrupt
practice from our democratic process is essential
if we want it to thrive and remain healthy. Our
democratic process will collapse if unhealthy
corrupt practices like appeals to voters on basis of
caste, creed, community, religion, race, language,
etc. are allowed to go unchecked and unpunished.
Use of corrupt practices in elections to secure
short term gains at the cost of purity of our
democratic process must be frowned at by every
right thinking citizen. It is for that reason that the
law has provided for double jeopardy to deter
candidates, their agents and others from indulging
in such nefarious practices. But while there is
sufficient justification for the law to be harsh
with those who indulge in such practices,
there is also the need to ensure that such
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 40
allegations
are
made
with
a
sense
of
responsibility and concern and not merely to
vex the returned candidate. It is with this in
view that the law envisages that the particulars
of such allegations shall be set out fully
disclosing the name of the party responsible
for the same and the date and place of its
commission.
A
simple
verification
was
considered insufficient and, therefore, the
need for an affidavit in the prescribed form.
These procedural precautions are intended to
ensure that the person making the allegation of
corrupt practice realises the seriousness thereof
as such a charge would be akin to a criminal
charge since it visits the party indulging in such
practice with a twofold penalty. That is why this
Court described it as quasi-criminal in nature
in Manphul Singh v. Surinder Singh [(1973) 2
SCC 599, 608] and reiterated the same in K.M.
Mani v. P.J. Antony [(1979) 2 SCC 221 : (1979) 1
SCR 701] . Hence the insistence that each
ingredient of the charge must be satisfactorily
proved before a verdict of guilt is recorded by the
court. In Mani case [(1979) 2 SCC 221 : (1979) 1
SCR 701] this Court held that the allegations
must be established beyond reasonable doubt
and not merely by a preponderance of
probability. It is, therefore, equally essential
that the particulars of the charge or allegation
are clearly and precisely stated in the election
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 41
petition to afford a fair opportunity to the
person
against
whom
it
is
levelled
to
effectively counter the same.
………
29. A charge of corrupt practice has a twodimensional effect: its impact on the returned
candidate has to be viewed from the point of
view of the candidate's future political and
public life and from the point of view of the
electorate to ensure the purity of the election
process. There can, therefore, be no doubt that
such an allegation involving corrupt practice
must be viewed very seriously and the High
Court should ensure compliance with the
requirements of Section 83 before the parties
go to trial. This is quite clear from the
observations of this Court in the case of K.M.
Mani v. P.J. Anthony [(1979) 2 SCC 221 : (1979)
1 SCR 701] . While defective verification or a
defective affidavit may not be fatal, the High Court
should ensure its compliance before the parties go
to trial so that the party required to meet the
charge is not taken by surprise at the actual trial.
It must also be realised that delay in complying
with the requirements of Section 83 read with the
provisions of the Code or the omission to disclose
the grounds or sources of information, though not
fatal, would weaken the probative value of the
evidence ultimately led at the actual trial.
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 42
Therefore, an election petitioner can afford to
overlook the requirements of Section 83 on pain of
weakening the evidence that he may ultimately
tender at the actual trial of the election petition.
That is because as held in Mani case [(1979) 2
SCC 221 : (1979) 1 SCR 701] the charge of
corrupt practice has to be proved beyond
reasonable
doubt
and
not
merely
by
preponderance of probabilities. Allegation of
corrupt practice being quasi-criminal in nature, the
failure to supply full particulars at the earliest point
of time and to disclose the source of information
promptly may have an adverse bearing on the
probative value to be attached to the evidence
tendered in proof thereof at the ∼trial. Therefore,
even though ordinarily a defective verification can
be cured and the failure to disclose the grounds or
sources of information may not be fatal, failure to
place them on record with promptitude may lead
the court in a given case to doubt the veracity of
the evidence ultimately tendered. If, however, the
affidavit or the schedule or annexure forms an
integral part of the election petition itself, strict
compliance would be insisted upon.”
[emphasis supplied]
55.
Section 83 of the Representation of the People Act,
1951 reads thus:
“83. Contents of Petition: (1) An election petition –
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 43
(a) shall contain a concise statement of material
facts on which the petitioner relies,
(b) shall set forth full particulars of any corrupt
practice that the petitioner alleges, including as full
a statement as possible of the names of the
parties alleged to have committed such corrupt
practice and the date and place of the commission
of each such practice; and
(c) shall be signed by the petitioner and verified in
the manner laid down in the Code of Civil
Procedure 1908 (5 of 1908) for the verification of
the pleadings.
Provided that where the petitioner alleges any
corrupt practice, the petition shall also be
accompanied by an affidavit in the prescribed form
in support of the allegation of such corrupt practice
and the particulars thereof.
(2) Any schedule of annexure to the petition shall
also be signed by the petitioner and verified in the
same manner as the petition. Without specific
pleading consent, cause of action in an election
petition, based on allegations of corrupt practice is
incomplete and the petition liable to be dismissed.”
56.
Merely stating in the election petition that the cause of
action arose on 10.03.2022 when final result was published is not
enough
to
maintain
the
election
petition
by
the
first
respondent/election petitioner. It is the bounden duty of the election
petitioner to aver the cause of action properly matching the
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 44
allegations levelled against the returned candidate in the
appropriate cause of action paragraph. In the case on hand, this
Court is of the view that there is total absence of mentioning of
proper cause of action for maintaining the election petition by the
first respondent/election petitioner.
57.
For the purpose of determining whether the election
petition discloses cause of action, the Court must take into
consideration the election petition as a whole. It is only if even after
the election petition is read as a whole, no cause of action is found
discernible that the Court can exercise its powers under Order VII,
Rule 11 CPC. In the case on hand, the cause of action is not in
consonance with the allegations leveled.
58.
In Lavajibhai Ratanjibhai, supra, the Hon’ble
Supreme Court held:
“39. A plea of bar to jurisdiction of a civil court must
be considered having regard to the contentions
raised in the plaint. For the said purpose,
averments disclosing cause of action and the
reliefs sought for therein must be considered in
their entirety. The court may not be justified in
determining the question, one way or the other,
only having regard to the reliefs claimed dehors
the factual averments made in the plaint. The rules
of pleadings postulate that a plaint must contain
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 45
material facts. When the plaint read as a whole
does not disclose material facts giving rise to a
cause of action which can be entertained by a civil
court, it may be rejected in terms of Order 7 Rule
11 of the Code of Civil Procedure.”
In Neena Vikram Verma, supra, the Hon’ble Supreme
59.
Court held:
“30. We have noted the submissions of both the
counsel. As can be seen, the application under
Order 7 Rule 11 is required to be decided on the
face of the plaint or the petition, whether any
cause of action is made out or not. Once it is
accepted by a party by consent that a particular
petition (in the instant case the recrimination
petition) is to be heard by the Court, by giving up
the objection under Order 7 Rule 11, the very party
cannot be subsequently permitted to seek the
striking off the pleadings containing the cause of
action under the garb that the pleadings containing
the cause of action are unnecessary, vexatious or
scandalous. One is expected to take all necessary
pleas at the same time. The party concerned is
expected to raise such a contention at the time of
passing of the court order (consent order in the
present case) or seek the liberty to raise it at a later
point of time that some of the pleadings are
unnecessary or vexatious or scandalous. No court
is expected to permit any matter to be raised which
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 46
might and ought to have been made ground of
defence or attack, once the same is relinquished
by the party concerned. The learned Single Judge
ought to have noted this basic principle of any
litigation. Reliance on the judgment in K.K.
Modi [(1998) 3 SCC 573] is quite apt in this
behalf.”
In Dahiben, supra, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held:
60.
“23. …
23.2. The remedy under Order 7 Rule 11 is an
independent and special remedy, wherein the
court is empowered to summarily dismiss a suit at
the threshold, without proceeding to record
evidence, and conducting a trial, on the basis of
the evidence adduced, if it is satisfied that the
action should be terminated on any of the grounds
contained in this provision.
23.3. The underlying object of Order 7 Rule 11(a)
is that if in a suit, no cause of action is disclosed,
or the suit is barred by limitation under Rule 11(d),
the court would not permit the plaintiff to
unnecessarily protract the proceedings in the suit.
In such a case, it would be necessary to put an
end to the sham litigation, so that further judicial
time is not wasted.
….
23.5. The power conferred on the court to
terminate a civil action is, however, a drastic one,
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 47
and the conditions enumerated in Order 7 Rule 11
are required to be strictly adhered to.
23.6. Under Order 7 Rule 11, a duty is cast on the
court to determine whether the plaint discloses a
cause of action by scrutinising the averments in
the plaint [Liverpool & London S.P. & I Assn.
Ltd. v. M.V. Sea Success I, (2004) 9 SCC 512] ,
read in conjunction with the documents relied
upon, or whether the suit is barred by any law.
23.7. Order 7 Rule 14(1) provides for production of
documents, on which the plaintiff places reliance
in his suit, which reads as under:
“14. Production of document on which plaintiff
sues or relies.—(1) Where a plaintiff sues upon a
document or relies upon document in his
possession or power in support of his claim, he
shall enter such documents in a list, and shall
produce it in court when the plaint is presented by
him and shall, at the same time deliver the
document and a copy thereof, to be filed with the
plaint.
(2) Where any such document is not in the
possession or power of the plaintiff, he shall,
wherever possible, state in whose possession or
power it is.
(3) A document which ought to be produced in
court by the plaintiff when the plaint is presented,
or to be entered in the list to be added or annexed
to the plaint but is not produced or entered
accordingly, shall not, without the leave of the
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 48
court, be received in evidence on his behalf at the
hearing of the suit.
(4) Nothing in this Rule shall apply to document
produced for the cross-examination of the
plaintiff's witnesses, or, handed over to a witness
merely to refresh his memory.”
23.8. Having regard to Order 7 Rule 14 CPC, the
documents filed along with the plaint, are required
to be taken into consideration for deciding the
application under Order 7 Rule 11(a). When a
document referred to in the plaint, forms the basis
of the plaint, it should be treated as a part of the
plaint.
23.9. In exercise of power under this provision, the
court would determine if the assertions made in
the plaint are contrary to statutory law, or judicial
dicta, for deciding whether a case for rejecting the
plaint at the threshold is made out.
23.10. At this stage, the pleas taken by the
defendant in the written statement and application
for rejection of the plaint on the merits, would be
irrelevant, and cannot be adverted to, or taken into
consideration. [SopanSukhdeo Sable v. Charity
Commr., (2004) 3 SCC 137]
23.11. The test for exercising the power under
Order 7 Rule 11 is that if the averments made in
the plaint are taken in entirety, in conjunction with
the documents relied upon, would the same result
in a decree being passed. This test was laid down
in Liverpool & London S.P. & I Assn. Ltd. v. M.V.
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 49
Sea Success I [Liverpool & London S.P. & I Assn.
Ltd. v. M.V. Sea Success I, (2004) 9 SCC 512]
which reads as : (SCC p. 562, para 139)
“139. Whether a plaint discloses a cause of action
or not is essentially a question of fact. But whether
it does or does not must be found out from reading
the plaint itself. For the said purpose, the
averments made in the plaint in their entirety must
be held to be correct. The test is as to whether if
the averments made in the plaint are taken to be
correct in their entirety, a decree would be
passed.”
23.12. In Hardesh
Ores
(P)
Ltd. v. Hede&
Co. [Hardesh Ores (P) Ltd. v. Hede& Co., (2007)
5 SCC 614] the Court further held that it is not
permissible to cull out a sentence or a passage,
and to read it in isolation. It is the substance, and
not merely the form, which has to be looked into.
The plaint has to be construed as it stands, without
addition or subtraction of words. If the allegations
in the plaint prima facie show a cause of action,
the court cannot embark upon an enquiry whether
the
allegations
are
Ramachandran v. R.V.
true
in
fact. D.
Janakiraman [D.
Ramachandran v. R.V. Janakiraman, (1999) 3
SCC 267; See also Vijay Pratap Singh v. Dukh
Haran Nath Singh, AIR 1962 SC 941] .
23.13. If on a meaningful reading of the plaint, it is
found that the suit is manifestly vexatious and
without any merit, and does not disclose a right to
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 50
sue, the court would be justified in exercising the
power under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC.
23.14. The power under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC
may be exercised by the court at any stage of the
suit, either before registering the plaint, or after
issuing summons to the defendant, or before
conclusion of the trial, as held by this Court in the
judgment
of Saleem
Maharashtra [Saleem
Bhai v. State
of
Bhai v. State
of
Maharashtra, (2003) 1 SCC 557] . The plea that
once issues are framed, the matter must
necessarily go to trial was repelled by this Court
in Azhar Hussain case [Azhar Hussain v. Rajiv
Gandhi,
Supp
SCC
315.
in Manvendrasinhj
Followed
Ranjitsinhji
Jadeja v. Vijaykunerba, 1998 SCC OnLine Guj
281 : (1998) 2 GLH 823] .
23.15. The provision of Order 7 Rule 11 is
mandatory in nature. It states that the plaint “shall”
be rejected if any of the grounds specified in
clauses (a) to (e) are made out. If the court finds
that the plaint does not disclose a cause of action,
or that the suit is barred by any law, the court has
no option, but to reject the plaint.
….”
61.
The first respondent/election petitioner contended that
the averments in the election petition have to be read as a whole to
find out whether it discloses a cause of action or whether the
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 51
election petition is barred by any law and that at the stage of
exercise of power under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC, the stand of the
returned candidate in the written statement or in the application for
rejection of the election petition is wholly immaterial. The election
petition can be rejected only if the averments made therein ex facie
do not disclose the cause of action or on a reading thereof the
election petition appears to be barred by law.
62.
In P.V.Guru Raj Reddy, supra, the Hon’ble Supreme
Court held thus:
“5. Rejection of the plaint under Order 7 Rule 11
of CPC is a drastic power conferred in the court to
terminate a civil action at the threshold. The
conditions precedent to the exercise of power
under Order 7 Rule 11, therefore, are stringent
and have been consistently held to be so by the
Court. It is the averments in the plaint that have to
be read as a whole to find out whether it discloses
a cause of action or whether the suit is barred
under any law. At the stage of exercise of power
under Order 7 Rule 11, the stand of the
defendants in the written statement or in the
application for rejection of the plaint is wholly
immaterial. It is only if the averments in the plaint
ex facie do not disclose a cause of action or on a
reading thereof the suit appears to be barred
under any law the plaint can be rejected. In all
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 52
other situations, the claims will have to be
adjudicated in the course of the trial.
6. In the present case, reading the plaint as a
whole and proceeding on the basis that the
averments made therein are correct, which is what
the Court is required to do, it cannot be said that
the said pleadings ex facie disclose that the suit is
barred by limitation or is barred under any other
provision of law. The claim of the plaintiffs with
regard to the knowledge of the essential facts
giving rise to the cause of action as pleaded will
have to be accepted as correct. At the stage of
consideration of the application under Order 7
Rule 11 the stand of the defendants in the written
statement would be altogether irrelevant.”
63.
In Srihari Numandas Totala, supra, the Hon’ble
Supreme Court held:
“19. At this stage, it would be necessary to refer to
the decisions that particularly deal with the
question whether res judicata can be the basis or
ground for rejection of the plaint. In Kamala v. K.T.
Eshwara Sa [Kamala v. K.T. Eshwara Sa, (2008)
12 SCC 661] , the trial Judge had allowed an
application for rejection of the plaint in a suit for
partition and this was affirmed by the High Court.
S.B. Sinha, J. speaking for the two-Judge Bench
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 53
examined the ambit of Order 7 Rule 11(d) CPC
and observed : (SCC 668-69, paras 21-22)
“21. Order 7 Rule 11(d) of the Code has
limited application. It must be shown that the
suit is barred under any law. Such a
conclusion must be drawn from the
averments made in the plaint. Different
clauses in Order 7 Rule 11, in our opinion,
should not be mixed up. Whereas in a given
case, an application for rejection of the plaint
may be filed on more than one ground
specified in various sub-clauses thereof, a
clear finding to that effect must be arrived at.
What would be relevant for invoking clause
(d) of Order 7 Rule 11 of the Code are the
averments made in the plaint. For that
purpose, there cannot be any addition or
subtraction. Absence of jurisdiction on the
part of a court can be invoked at different
stages and under different provisions of the
Code. Order 7 Rule 11 of the Code is one,
Order 14 Rule 2 is another.
22. For the purpose of invoking Order 7 Rule
11(d) of the Code, no amount of evidence
can be looked into. The issues on merit of the
matter which may arise between the parties
would not be within the realm of the court at
that stage. All issues shall not be the subjectmatter of an order under the said provision.”
20. The Court further held : (Kamala
case [Kamala v. K.T. Eshwara Sa, (2008) 12 SCC
661] , SCC p. 669, paras 23-25)
“23. The principles of res judicata, when
attracted, would bar another suit in view of
Section 12 of the Code. The question
involving a mixed question of law and fact
which may require not only examination of
the plaint but also other evidence and the
order passed in the earlier suit may be taken
up either as a preliminary issue or at the final
hearing, but, the said question cannot be
determined at that stage.
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 54
24. It is one thing to say that the averments
made in the plaint on their face discloses no
cause of action, but it is another thing to say
that although the same discloses a cause of
action, the same is barred by a law.
25. The decisions rendered by this Court as
also by various High Courts are not uniform
in this behalf. But, then the broad principle
which can be culled out therefrom is that the
court at that stage would not consider any
evidence or enter into a disputed question of
fact or law. In the event, the jurisdiction of the
court is found to be barred by any law,
meaning thereby, the subject-matter thereof,
the application for rejection of plaint should
be entertained.”
21. The above view has been consistently
followed in a line of decisions of this Court.
In Church of Christ Charitable Trust & Educational
Charitable Society v. Ponniamman Educational
Trust [Church
of
Christ Charitable
Trust
&
Educational Charitable Society v. Ponniamman
Educational Trust, (2012) 8 SCC 706 : (2012) 4
SCC (Civ) 612] , P. Sathasivam, J. (as the learned
Chief Justice then was), speaking for a two-Judge
Bench, observed that : (SCC pp. 713-14, paras
10-11)
“10. … It is clear from the above that where
the plaint does not disclose a cause of action,
the relief claimed is undervalued and not
corrected within the time allowed by the
court, insufficiently stamped and not rectified
within the time fixed by the court, barred by
any law, failed to enclose the required copies
and the plaintiff fails to comply with the
provisions of Rule 9, the court has no other
option except to reject the same. A reading
of the above provision also makes it clear
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 55
that power under Order 7 Rule 11 of the
Code can be exercised at any stage of the
suit either before registering the plaint or after
the issuance of summons to the defendants
or at any time before the conclusion of the
trial.
11. This position was explained by this Court
in Saleem
Bhai v. State
of
Maharashtra [Saleem
Bhai v. State
of
Maharashtra, (2003) 1 SCC 557] , in which,
while considering Order 7 Rule 11 of the
Code, it was held as under : (SCC p. 560,
para 9)
‘9. A perusal of Order 7 Rule 11 CPC makes
it clear that the relevant facts which need to
be looked into for deciding an application
thereunder are the averments in the plaint.
The trial court can exercise the power under
Order 7 Rule 11 CPC at any stage of the suit
— before registering the plaint or after
issuing summons to the defendant at any
time before the conclusion of the trial. For the
purposes of deciding an application under
clauses (a) and (d) of Rule 11 of Order 7
CPC, the averments in the plaint are
germane; the pleas taken by the defendant in
the written statement would be wholly
irrelevant at that stage, therefore, a direction
to file the written statement without deciding
the application under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC
cannot but be procedural irregularity
touching the exercise of jurisdiction by the
trial court.’
It is clear that in order to consider Order 7
Rule 11, the court has to look into the
averments in the plaint and the same can be
exercised by the trial court at any stage of the
suit. It is also clear that the averments in the
written statement are immaterial and it is the
duty of the court to scrutinise the
averments/pleas in the plaint. In other words,
what needs to be looked into in deciding such
an application are the averments in the
plaint. At that stage, the pleas taken by the
defendant in the written statement are wholly
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 56
irrelevant and the matter is to be decided only
on the plaint averments. These principles
have been reiterated in Raptakos Brett & Co.
Ltd. v. Ganesh Property [Raptakos Brett &
Co. Ltd. v. Ganesh Property, (1998) 7 SCC
184] and Mayar (H.K.) Ltd. v. Vessel M.V.
Fortune Express [Mayar (H.K.) Ltd. v. Vessel
M.V. Fortune Express, (2006) 3 SCC 100] .”
22. Similarly, in Soumitra Kumar Sen [Soumitra
Kumar Sen v. Shyamal Kumar Sen, (2018) 5 SCC
644 : (2018) 3 SCC (Civ) 329] , an application was
moved under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC claiming
rejection of the plaint on the ground that the suit
was barred by res judicata. The trial Judge
dismissed the application and the judgment of the
trial court was affirmed in revision by the High
Court. A.K. Sikri, J., while affirming the judgment
of the High Court held : (Soumitra Kumar Sen
case [Soumitra Kumar Sen v. Shyamal Kumar
Sen, (2018) 5 SCC 644 : (2018) 3 SCC (Civ) 329] ,
SCC p. 649, para 9)
“9. In the first instance, it can be seen that
insofar as relief of permanent and mandatory
injunction is concerned that is based on a
different cause of action. At the same time
that kind of relief can be considered by the
trial court only if the plaintiff is able to
establish his locus standi to bring such a suit.
If the averments made by the appellant in
their written statement are correct, such a
suit may not be maintainable inasmuch as,
as per the appellant it has already been
decided in the previous two suits that
Respondent 1-plaintiff retired from the
partnership firm much earlier, after taking his
share and it is the appellant (or appellant and
Respondent 2) who are entitled to manage
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 57
the affairs of M/s Sen Industries. However, at
this stage, as rightly pointed out by the High
Court, the defence in the written statement
cannot be gone into. One has to only look
into the plaint for the purpose of deciding
application under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC. It is
possible that in a cleverly drafted plaint, the
plaintiff has not given the details about Suit
No. 268 of 2008 which has been decided
against him. He has totally omitted to
mention about Suit No. 103 of 1995, the
judgment wherein has attained finality. In that
sense, the plaintiff-Respondent 1 may be
guilty of suppression and concealment, if the
averments made by the appellant are
ultimately found to be correct. However, as
per the established principles of law, such a
defence projected in the written statement
cannot be looked into while deciding
application under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC.”
23. Referring to Kamala [Kamala v. K.T. Eshwara
Sa, (2008) 12 SCC 661] , the Court further
observed
that
:
(Soumitra
Kumar
Sen
case [Soumitra Kumar Sen v. Shyamal Kumar
Sen, (2018) 5 SCC 644 : (2018) 3 SCC (Civ) 329] ,
SCC p. 650, para 12)
“12. … The appellant has mentioned about
the earlier two cases which were filed by
Respondent 1 and wherein he failed. These
are judicial records. The appellant can easily
demonstrate the correctness of his
averments by filing certified copies of the
pleadings in the earlier two suits as well as
copies of the judgments passed by the courts
in those proceedings. In fact, copies of the
orders passed in judgment and decree dated
31-3-1997 passed by the Civil Judge (Junior
Division), copy of the judgment dated 31-31998 passed by the Civil Judge (Senior
Division) upholding the decree passed by the
Civil Judge (Junior Division) as well as copy
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 58
of the judgment and decree dated 31-7-2014
passed by the Civil Judge, Junior Division in
Suit No. 268 of 2008 are placed on record by
the appellant. While deciding the first suit, the
trial court gave a categorical finding that as
per MoU signed between the parties,
Respondent 1 had accepted a sum of Rs
2,00,000 and, therefore, the said suit was
barred by principles of estoppel, waiver and
acquiescence. In a case like this, though
recourse to Order 7 Rule 11 CPC by the
appellant was not appropriate, at the same
time, the trial court may, after framing the
issues, take up the issues which pertain to
the maintainability of the suit and decide the
same in the first instance. In this manner the
appellant, or for that matter the parties, can
be absolved of unnecessary agony of
prolonged proceedings, in case the appellant
is ultimately found to be correct in his
submissions.”
While holding that “recourse to Order 7 Rule 11”
by the appellant was not appropriate, this Court
observed that the trial court may, after framing the
issues, take up the issues which pertain to the
maintainability of the suit and decide them in the
first instance. The Court held that this course of
action would help the appellant avoid lengthy
proceedings.
24. In a more recent decision of this Court
in Shakti Bhog Food Industries Ltd. v. Central
Bank
of
India [Shakti
BhogFood
Industries
Ltd. v. Central Bank of India, (2020) 17 SCC 260] ,
a three-Judge Bench of this Court, speaking
though A.M. Khanwilkar, J., was dealing with the
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 59
rejection of a plaint under Order 7 Rule 11 by the
trial court, on the ground that it was barred by
limitation. The Court referred to the earlier
decisions including in Saleem Bhai v. Stateof
Maharashtra [Saleem
Bhai v. State
of
Maharashtra, (2003) 1 SCC 557] , Church of
Christ
Charitable
Charitable
Trust
Trust [Church
of
&
Charitable
Educational
Christ
Society v. Ponniamman Educational Trust, (2012)
8 SCC 706 : (2012) 4 SCC (Civ) 612] , and
observed that : (Church of Christ Charitable Trust
case [Church
of
Christ
Charitable
Trust
&
Educational Charitable Society v. Ponniamman
Educational Trust, (2012) 8 SCC 706 : (2012) 4
SCC (Civ) 612] , SCC p. 714, para 11)
“11. … It is clear that in order to consider
Order 7 Rule 11, the court has to look into the
averments in the plaint and the same can be
exercised by the trial court at any stage of the
suit. It is also clear that the averments in the
written statement are immaterial and it is the
duty of the court to scrutinise the
averments/pleas in the plaint. In other words,
what needs to be looked into in deciding such
an application are the averments in the
plaint. At that stage, the pleas taken by the
defendant in the written statement are wholly
irrelevant and the matter is to be decided only
on the plaint averment. These principles
have been reiterated in Raptakos Brett & Co.
Ltd. v. Ganesh Property [Raptakos Brett &
Co. Ltd. v. Ganesh Property, (1998) 7 SCC
184] and Mayar (H.K.) Ltd. v. Vessel M.V.
Fortune Express [Mayar (H.K.) Ltd. v. Vessel
M.V. Fortune Express, (2006) 3 SCC 100] .”
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 60
25. On a perusal of the above authorities, the
guiding principles for deciding an application
under Order 7 Rule 11(d) can be summarised as
follows:
25.1. To reject a plaint on the ground that the
suit is barred by any law, only the averments
in the plaint will have to be referred to.
25.2. The defence made by the defendant in
the suit must not be considered while
deciding the merits of the application.
25.3. To determine whether a suit is barred
by res judicata, it is necessary that (i) the
“previous suit” is decided, (ii) the issues in the
subsequent suit were directly and
substantially in issue in the former suit; (iii)
the former suit was between the same parties
or parties through whom they claim, litigating
under the same title; and (iv) that these
issues were adjudicated and finally decided
by a court competent to try the subsequent
suit.
25.4. Since an adjudication of the plea of res
judicata requires consideration of the
pleadings, issues and decision in the
“previous suit”, such a plea will be beyond the
scope of Order 7 Rule 11(d), where only the
statements in the plaint will have to be
perused.
……
27. Be that as it may, on a reading of the plaint, it
is evident that the first respondent has not made
an attempt to conceal the fact that a suit regarding
the property was pending before the civil court at
the time. It is also relevant to note that at the time
of institution of the suit (OS No. 138 of 2008) by
the first respondent, no decree had been passed
by the civil court in OS No. 103 of 2007. Thus, the
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 61
issues raised in OS No. 103 of 2007, at the time,
had not been adjudicated upon. Therefore, the
plaint, on the face of it, does not disclose any fact
that may lead us to the conclusion that it deserves
to be rejected on the ground that it is barred by
principles of res judicata. The High Court and the
trial court were correct in their approach in holding,
that to decide on the arguments raised by the
appellant, the court would have to go beyond the
averments in the plaint, and peruse the pleadings,
and judgment and decree in OS No. 103 of 2007.
An application under Order 7 Rule 11 must be
decided within the four corners of the plaint. The
trial court and the High Court were correct in
rejecting the application under Order 7 Rule
11(d).”
In Dr. Ramachandran, supra, the Hon’ble Supreme
64.
Court held:
“8. We do not consider it necessary to refer in
detail to any part of the reasoning in the judgment;
instead, we proceed to consider the arguments
advanced before us on the basis of the pleadings
contained in the election petition. It is well settled
that in all cases of preliminary objection, the test is
to see whether any of the reliefs prayed for could
be granted to the appellant if the averments made
in the petition are proved to be true. For the
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 62
purpose of considering a preliminary objection, the
averments in the petition should be assumed to be
true and the court has to find out whether those
averments disclose a cause of action or a triable
issue as such. The court cannot probe into the
facts on the basis of the controversy raised in the
counter.
…..
10. On the other hand, Rule 11 of Order 7 enjoins
the court to reject the plaint where it does not
disclose a cause of action. There is no question of
striking out any portion of the pleading under this
Rule. The application filed by the first respondent
in OA No. 36 of 1997 is on the footing that the
averments in the election petition did not contain
the material facts giving rise to a triable issue or
disclosing a cause of action. Laying stress upon
the provisions of Order 7 Rule 11(a), learned
Senior Counsel for the first respondent took us
through the entire election petition and submitted
that the averments therein do not disclose a cause
of action. On a reading of the petition, we do not
find it possible to agree with him. The election
petition as such does disclose a cause of action
which if unrebutted could void the election and the
provisions of Order 7 Rule 11(a) CPC cannot
therefore be invoked in this case. There is no merit
in the contention that some of the allegations are
bereft of material facts and as such do not disclose
a cause of action. It is elementary that under Order
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 63
7 Rule 11(a) CPC, the court cannot dissect the
pleading into several parts and consider whether
each one of them discloses a cause of action.
Under the Rule, there cannot be a partial rejection
of
the
plaint
or
petition.
See Roop
Lal
Sathi v. Nachhattar Singh Gill [(1982) 3 SCC 487].
We are satisfied that the election petition in this
case could not have been rejected in limine
without a trial.
65.
Admittedly, as per the ratio propounded by the Hon'ble
Supreme Court, the first respondent/election petitioner is not able
to make out a case of corrupt practice in his pleadings and the
necessary particulars, statement of facts and essential ingredients
are missing and a mere averment of corrupt practice, without there
being any material available on record, is not sustainable in the eye
of law.
66.
In Ravinder Singh, supra, the Hon’ble Supreme Court
held:
“7. The election petition is singularly silent about
any such averment that the returned candidate,
even if, it be assumed for the sake of the
arguments, had published and distributed certain
documents (Annexures A-1 to A-7), as alleged in
the election petition either himself or through any
other persons with his consent, that those
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 64
statements were false and that the returned
candidate either believed them to be false or did
not believe them to be true, though in para 9 of the
election petition, which has been verified as
correct on the basis of legal advice, this
requirement emanating from Section 123(4) has
been mentioned but without any assertion that the
returned candidate in this case published the false
statements knowing them to be false and/or not
believing them to be true. The submission of
Mr.Talwar that at the trial the petitioner could have
said so in his evidence, is futile. It is an established
proposition that no evidence can be led on a plea
not raised in the pleadings and that no amount of
evidence can cure defect in the pleadings.
…..
10. Proviso to Section 83(1) of the Act lays down,
in mandatory terms, that where an election
petitioner alleges any corrupt practice, the election
petition shall also be accompanied by an affidavit,
in the prescribed form, in support of the allegations
of such practice and the particulars thereof. The
affidavit, which has been filed in support of the
election petition, does not at all deal with the
charge of bribery falling under Section 123(1) of
the Act. Leaving aside the questions that the
affidavit is not even in the prescribed form — Form
25 of the Conduct of Elections Rules, the
allegations of corrupt practice made in the election
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 65
petition are not supported by the otherwise
defective affidavit either. All the names of the
informants which have been given in the affidavit
relate to the corrupt practice under Section 123(4)
and the affidavit in this respect is a verbatim
reproduction of the verification clause of the
election petition concerning corrupt practice under
Section 123(4). No name of any informant has
been mentioned in respect of the allegations of
corrupt practice under Section 123(1) in the
affidavit. In the absence of the requisite affidavit
filed in support of the allegation of corrupt practice
under Section 123(1) of the Act, as detailed in the
election petition, no issue could be raised for trial.
11. Section 83 of the Act is mandatory in character
and requires not only a concise statement of
material facts and full particulars of the alleged
corrupt practice, so as to present a full and
complete picture of the action to be detailed in the
election petition but under the proviso to Section
83(1) of the Act, the election petition levelling a
charge of corrupt practice is required, by law, to be
supported by an affidavit in which the election
petitioner is obliged to disclose his source of
information in respect of the commission of that
corrupt practice. The reason for this insistence is
obvious. It is necessary for an election petitioner
to make such a charge with full responsibility and
to prevent any fishing and roving inquiry and save
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 66
the returned candidate from being taken by
surprise. In the absence of proper affidavit, in the
prescribed form, filed in support of the corrupt
practice of bribery, the allegation pertaining
thereto, could not be put to trial — the defect being
of a fatal nature.
……
13. The learned Single Judge of the High Court
dismissed the election petition on deciding Issue
5, which was treated as a preliminary issue and
reads thus:
“Whether the election petition lacks in material
facts and particulars, necessary to constitute
complete cause of action for setting aside of the
election of Respondent 1, within the meaning of
Section 83, read with Sections 100(1)(d)(iv) and
123 of the Representation of People Act?”
For what we have said above, the order of
dismissal of the election petition, without putting it
to trial, cannot be faulted with.
14. For our reasons, which are somewhat different
from the ones given by the High Court, we find that
the decision of the High Court to non-suit the
election petitioner by deciding the preliminary
issue against him is well merited. There is no merit
in this appeal. It, consequently, fails and is hereby
dismissed. There shall, however, be no order as to
costs.”
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 67
67.
Right to elect, though it is fundamental to democracy,
is neither a fundamental right nor a common law right. It is purely a
statutory right. So is the right to be elected. So is the right to dispute
an election. De hors the statute, there is no right to elect, no right to
be elected and no right to dispute an election. They are statutory
creations and, therefore, subject to statutory limitation.
68.
An election petition is neither an action at common law
nor in equity. It is a statutory proceeding to which neither the
common law nor the principles of equity apply, but only those rules
which the statute makes apply. It is a special jurisdiction and a
special jurisdiction has always to be exercised in accordance with
the statute creating it. Concepts familiar to common law and equity
always remain strangers to election law. In the trial of election
dispute, Court is put in a straight jacket.
69.
The entire election process commencing from the
issuance of the notification calling upon a constituency to elect a
member or members right upto the final resolution of the dispute, if
any, concerning the election, is regulated by the Representation of
the People of Act, 1951. The election law being statutory in
character must be adhered to strictly. The election petition must
conform to the requirements of election law. Unless grounds under
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 68
section 100 of the Representation of People Act of 1951 are proved,
no election of a successful candidate can be set aside.
In Mohan Rowale, supra, the Hon’ble Supreme Court
70.
held:
“6. This, we are afraid, is not the correct
perception of the matter. The view fails to take
note of and give effect to the substitution of the
definition of the expression “candidate” in Section
79(b). All sub-sections of Section 123 of the Act
refer to the acts of a ‘candidate’ or his election
agent or any other person with the consent of the
candidate or his election agent. The substituted
definition completely excludes the acts by a
candidate up to the date he is nominated as a
candidate. Shri Sanghi, therefore, asks us to take
this position to its logical conclusions and strike
out these allegations in the election petition.
….
8. We hold that all the averments in paragraphs 1
to 20 of the memorandum of election petition
insofar as they refer to a period prior to April 23,
1991 cannot amount to allegations of corrupt
practice. But on the question whether they are
relevant and admissible for other purposes for the
reasons submitted by Shri Nariman we abstain
from expressing any opinion. This aspect did not
engage the attention of the High Court and was
not considered by it. It is for the High Court to
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 69
consider them at the appropriate time. We,
therefore, declare that the allegations in paras 1 to
relating
to
the period
anterior
to
the
commencement of the candidature cannot be
relied
upon
to
establish
corrupt
practice propriovigore.”
71.
In Haridwari Lal v. Kanwal Singh, (1972) 1 SCC 214,
the Hon’ble Supreme Court held:
“17. The provisions of the aforesaid section
indicate these heads of corrupt practices. First, the
obtaining by a candidate or his agent or by any
other person any assistance (other than the giving
of vote) for the furtherance of the prospects of that
candidate's election from any person in the service
of the Government as mentioned in the section.
Second, the procuring by a candidate or his agent
or by any other person with the consent of the
election petitioner any assistance (other than the
giving of vote) for the furtherance of the prospects
of that candidate's election. Third, the abetting by
a candidate or his agent or by any other person
with the consent of the candidate or his election
agent any assistance (other than the giving of
vote) for the furtherance of the prospects of that
candidate's election as mentioned. Fourth, the
attempting to obtain or procure by a candidate or
his agent, or by any other person with the consent
of a candidate or his election agent any assistance
(other than the giving of vote) for the furtherance
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 70
of the prospects of that candidate's election. Fifth,
the assistance that is forbidden or prohibited by
the statute is any assistance other than the giving
of vote. It is clear that the four different heads of
corrupt practices are (a) obtaining, (b) procuring,
(c) abetting, and (d) attempting to obtain or
procure assistance.
……
19. The requirements in an election petition as to
material facts and the consequences of lack of
such allegation of material facts came up for
consideration in this Court in the recent decision
in Samant
N.
Balkrishna, v. George
Fernandez [(1969) 3 SCC 238 : (1969) 3 SCR
603] . In that case reference was made to Sections
81, 83 and 86 of the Act as the procedure
provisions of election petition. Section 81 deals
with presentation of petitions. Section 83 deals
with contents of petitions. Section 86 deals with
trial of petitions. Hidayatullah, C.J., speaking for
the Court laid down these propositions. First,
Section 83 of the Act is mandatory and requires
first a concise statement of material facts and then
requires the fullest possible particulars. Second,
omission of a single material fact leads to an
incomplete cause of action and the statement of
claim becomes bad. Third, the function of
particulars is to present in full a picture of the
cause of action to make the opposite party
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 71
understand the case he will have to meet. Fourth,
material facts and particulars are distinct matters.
Material facts will mention statements of fact and
particulars will set out the names of person with
the date, time and place. Fifth, material facts will
show the ground of corrupt practice and the
complete cause of action and the particulars will
give the necessary information to present a full
picture of the cause of action. Sixth, in stating the
material facts it will not do merely to quote the
words of the section because then the efficacy of
the material facts will be lost. The fact which
constitutes a corrupt practice must be stated and
the fact must be correlated to one of the heads of
corrupt practice. Seventh, an election petition
without the material facts relating to a corrupt
practice is no election petition at all. A petition
which merely cites the sections cannot be said to
disclose a cause of action where the allegation is
the obtaining or procuring of assistance unless the
exact type and form of assistance and the person
from whom it is sought and the manner in which
the assistance is to further the prospects of the
election are alleged as statements of facts.
……
21. The necessity of clear and precise allegations
to support a plea of corrupt practice was
emphasised by this Court in Harish Chandra
Bajpai v. Trilok
Singh [12
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
ELR
P a g e | 72
461] .VenkataramaAyyar, J., speaking for the
Court in dealing with the powers of the Court to
allow amendment in respect of illegal or corrupt
practice said that where the allegation in the
election petition in regard to the corrupt practice
was that the respondents could in furtherance of
their election enlist the support of government
servants, the words “could enlist” did not amount
to an averment that in fact they enlisted their
support. In other words, it was observed that the
words “could enlist” did not allege a fact which
happened. Therefore, the happening of a fact as
well as the fact itself is material. Judged by that
test in the present case there is no allegation
which will amount to any averment of any
assistance as a fact in the absence of the kind of
assistance being set out as a fact.
22. The allegations in para 16 of the election
petition do not amount to any statement of material
fact of corrupt practice. It is not stated as to what
kind or form of assistance was obtained or
procured or attempted to obtain or procure. It is not
stated from whom the particular type of assistance
was obtained or procured or attempted to obtain
or procure. It is not stated in what manner the
assistance was for the furtherance of the
prospects of the election. The gravamen of the
charge of corrupt practice within the meaning of
Section 123(7) of the Act is obtaining or procuring
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 73
or abetting or attempting to obtain or procure any
assistance other than the giving of vote. In the
absence of any suggestion as to what that
assistance was the election petition is lacking in
the most vital and essential material fact to furnish
a cause of action.
……
25. For these reasons the judgment of the High
Court is set aside. The appeal is allowed. The
election petition shall stand dismissed. The parties
will pay and bear their costs in this appeal.”
72.
Section 100 of the Representation of the People Act,
1951 speaks about grounds for declaring election to be void and
the election of returned candidate can only be declared void if (a)
on the date of his election a returned candidate was not qualified,
or was disqualified, to be chosen to fill the seat under the
Constitution or this Act; or (b) any corrupt practice has been
committed by a returned candidate, or his election agent or by any
other person with the consent of a returned candidate or his election
agent; or (c) any nomination has been improperly rejected; or (d)
the result of the election, in so far as it concerns a returned
candidate, has been materially affected (i) by the improper
acceptance or any nomination, or (ii) by any corrupt practice
committed in the interests of the returned candidate (by an agent
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 74
other than his election agent), or (iii) by the improper reception,
refusal or rejection of any vote or the reception of any vote which is
void, or (iv) by any non-compliance with the provisions of the
Constitution or of this Act or of any rules or order made under this
Act.
73.
At this juncture, by placing on record the decision of
the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Sardar Harcharan Singh
Brar v. Sukh Darhan Singh, (2004) 11 SCC 196, the learned
senior counsel for the election petitioner argued that it cannot be
said that the charge of corrupt practice lacks material facts and
particulars. Even if this Court thinks that there is deficiency of
material particulars, instead of dismissing the election petition, it
would be just and proper to direct the election petitioner to furnish
more detail particulars in support of his allegation.
74.
As discussed herein above, while dealing with the
corrupt practice, the first respondent/election petitioner was unable
to make out his case of corrupt practice as pleaded in the election
petition and the ingredients of corrupt practice is missing in the
election petition for want of details of corrupt practice giving time,
place, names of persons, use of words and expression etc. Thus,
the ground which is available to the election petitioner under
Section 100 of the Representation of People Act of 1951, is not
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 75
available as held by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of
F.A.Sapa Singora, supra, as the Hon'ble Supreme Court in that
case has held that while there is sufficient justification for the law to
be harsh with those who indulge in such practices, there is also the
need to ensure that such allegations are made with a sense of
responsibility and concern and not merely to vex the returned
candidate. It is with this in view that the law envisages that the
particulars of such allegations shall be set out fully disclosing the
name of the party responsible for the same and the date and place
of its commission. A simple verification was considered insufficient
and, therefore, the need for an affidavit in the prescribed form.
Merely because the allegation that the applicant distributed
tab/tablets during the election campaign does not constitute cause
of action. As far as election petition is concerned, particulars must
be given in the election petition qua the alleged distribution of
tab/tablets to children of the voters. As stated supra, there is total
absence of material particulars and bereft of such particulars trial of
an election petition cannot be conducted and every minute
allegation, without an averment and proof thereof, cannot be tested
in trial. In view of the above, the decision in the case of Sardar
Harcharan Singh Brar, supra, relied upon by the learned senior
counsel for the election petition is not helpful to the case of the
election petitioner.
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 76
75.
It is also the argument of the learned senior counsel
for the election petitioner that where the defects in copies were
curable, the election petition cannot be dismissed at the threshold
for non-compliance with Section 81(3) of the Representation of
People Act, 1951 on the basis of such defects.
In support, the
learned senior counsel placed reliance upon the decision of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Chandrakant Uttam
Chodankar v. Dayanand Raya Mandrakar, (2005) 2 SCC 188.
76.
In Chandrakant Uttam Chodankar, supra, the
Hon’ble Supreme Court held:
“35. The difference of opinion was settled by the
Constitution Bench in Jacob case [(1999) 4 SCC
274] by enunciating the principles as noted
hereinabove. We have carefully examined the
defects as noted herein earlier and on a careful
examination of the defects we cannot be
persuaded to the view that the defects in the
present case also are material or it was vital in
nature or the absence of stamp of attestation could
be treated to be a ground for rejection of the
election petitions under Section 81(3) of the Act. It
may be mentioned herein that the decision of this
Court in Anil R. Deshmukhcase [(1999) 2 SCC
205] was approved by the Constitution Bench and
in which it already distinguished the case of Dr.
Shipra [(1996) 5 SCC 181] . It must not be
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 77
forgotten that in the Constitution Bench decision of
this Court, it was evident that:
“(a) the expression ‘copy’ in Section 81(3) of
the Act means a copy which is substantially
the same as the original, variation if any from
the original should not be vital in nature or
should not be such that can possibly mislead
a
reasonable
person
in
meeting
the
allegation; (b) if the copy differs in material
particulars from the original the same cannot
be cured after the period of limitation.” [Ed.:
As
quoted
Phungzathang v. Hangkhanlian,
from T.
(2001)
SCC 358 at pp. 367-68, para 13.]
The same principle was enunciated following a
Constitution Bench's decision of this Court in T.
Phungzathang v. Hangkhanlian [(2001) 8 SCC
358]. In this decision also it was held that the
defects indicated in these cases for which
dismissal of the election petition was sought for did
not attract Section 86(1) of the Act for dismissal of
the election petitions for non-compliance with
Section 81(3) of the Act. For the reasons aforesaid
and applying the principles laid down in the
aforesaid decisions of this Court, we are of the
view that the High Court ought not to have rejected
the election petitions for non-compliance with the
provisions of Section 81(3) of the Act as the
defects shown by Respondent 1 cannot be said to
be fatal and the copies which were alleged to have
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 78
been served or supplied to Respondent 1 were
wholly and substantially the same as the original.
That apart, it is an admitted position, as noted
herein earlier, true copies of the election petitions
were duly served or supplied to Respondent 1.
The question that was raised by the learned
counsel for Respondent 1 before us was whether
subsequent supply of such true copies on
Respondent 1 could be treated to be a sufficient
compliance with Section 81(3) of the Act. Apart
from the conclusions made hereinbefore, we are
also of the view that in view of the decision of this
Court
in Anil
R.
Deshmukh v. Onkar
N.
Wagh [(1999) 2 SCC 205] this question needs to
be decided in favour of the appellant and against
Respondent 1. In para 17 of the aforesaid decision
this Court observed as follows: (SCC p. 212)
“We have already referred to the fact that
even before arguments were heard on the
preliminary objection by the High Court in this
case, the true copies of the affidavits had
been served on the first respondent and his
counsel. In the facts and circumstances of
this case, we have no doubt that there was
sufficient compliance with the provisions of
Section 81(3) read with Section 83(1)(c) of
the Act even if it could be said that the copies
served in the first instance on the first
respondent were not in conformity with the
provisions of the Act.”(emphasis supplied)
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 79
77.
In the instant case, the averments made in the election
petition are not supported by an affidavit in the prescribed form as
per the requirements of Section 83 of the Representation of People
Act of 1951, which provides that an election petition (a) shall contain
a concise statement of the material facts on which the petitioner
relies; (b) shall set forth full particulars of any corrupt practice that
the petitioner alleges including as full a statement as possible of the
names of the parties alleged to have committed such corrupt
practice and the date and place of the commission of each such
practice; and (c) shall be signed by the petitioner and verified in the
manner laid down in the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 for the
verification of the pleadings, provided that where the petitioner
alleges any corrupt practice, the petition shall also be accompanied
by an affidavit in the prescribed form in support of the allegation of
such corrupt practice and the particulars thereof as prescribed
under Rule 94-A of the Conduct of Election Rules, 1961 in the
format provided for in Form 25 of the forms appended to the Rules
of 1961.
78.
In Dr.Shipra, supra, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held:
“12. The contention that the election petition
cannot be dismissed under Section 86 at the
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 80
threshold on account of the omission on the part
of the Registry of the High Court to point out the
same
as
per
its
procedure,
cannot
be
countenanced. Lapse on the part of the Registry is
not an insurance to deny to the returned candidate
the plea that the attestation of the affidavit and its
certification to be a true copy is an integral part of
the pleadings in the election petition. Sections 81,
83(1)(c) and 86 read with Rule 94-A of the Rules
and Form 25 are to be read conjointly as an
integral scheme. When so read, if the court finds
on an objection, being raised by the returned
candidate, as to the maintainability of the election
petition, the court is required to go into the
question and decide the preliminary objection. In
case the court does not uphold the same, the need
to conduct trial would arise. If the court upholds the
preliminary objection, the election petition would
result in dismissal at the threshold, as the court is
left with no option except to dismiss the same.”
79.
Admittedly, the affidavit under Form 25 filed by the
petitioner in support of the averments made in the election petition
in the prescribed form as prescribed under Rule 94-A of the
Conduct of Election Rules, 1961 is vague and bereft of material
particulars. Further as per Section 86 (Trial of election petitions) of
the Representation of People Act, 1951, in case the election petition
does not comply with the provisions of Section 81 or Section 82 or
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 81
Section 117, the High Court shall dismiss the same without
proceeding with the trial of the election petition.
80.
The Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Azhar
Hussain v. Rajiv Gandhi, 1986 (Supp) SCC 315 has held that we
consider it appropriate to restate the settled position of law as it
emerges from the numerous decisions of this Court which have
been cited before us in regard to the question as to what exactly is
the content of the expression 'material facts and particulars' which
the election petitioner shall incorporate in his petition by virtue of
Section 83(1) of the Representation of People Act, 1951.
Paragraphs 8, 9, 11, 12, 18, 21, 22, 25 and 28 are relevant and the
same are quoted hereunder:
“8. The argument is that inasmuch as Section
83(1) is not adverted to in Section 86 in the context
of the provisions, non-compliance with which
entails dismissal of the election petition, it follows
that non-compliance with the requirements of
Section 83(1), even though mandatory, do not
have lethal consequence of dismissal. Now it is
not disputed that the Code of Civil Procedure
(CPC) applies to the trial of an election petition by
virtue of Section 87 of the Act [ 87. Procedure
before the High Court.—(1) Subject to the
provisions of this Act and of any rules made
thereunder, every election petition shall be tried by
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 82
the High Court, as nearly as may be, in
accordance with the procedure applicable under
the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (5 of 1908) to
the trial of suits: Provided that the High Court shall
have the discretion to refuse, for reasons to be
recorded in writing, to examine any witness or
witnesses if it is of the opinion that the evidence of
such witness or witnesses is not material for the
decision of the petition or that the party tendering
such witness or witnesses is doing so on frivolous
grounds or with a view to delay the proceedings.
(2) The provisions of the Indian Evidence Act,
1872 (1 of 1872), shall, subject to the provisions of
this Act, be deemed to apply in all respects to the
trial of an election petition.] . Since CPC is
applicable, the court trying the election petition can
act in exercise of the powers of the Code including
Order 6 Rule 16 and Order 7 Rule 11(a) which
read thus:
“Order 6, Rule 16: Striking out pleadings.—
The court may at any stage of the
proceedings order to be struck out or amend
any matter in any pleading—
(a) which may be unnecessary, scandalous,
frivolous or vexatious; or
(b) which may tend to prejudice, embarrass
or delay the fair trial of the suit; or
(c) which is otherwise an abuse of the
process of the court.
Order 7, Rule 11: Rejection of plaint.—The
plaint shall be rejected in the following cases:
(a) where it does not disclose a cause of
action;....”
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 83
9. The fact that Section 83 does not find a place in
Section 86 of the Act does not mean that powers
under the CPC cannot be exercised.
…..
11. In view of this pronouncement there is no
escape from the conclusion that an election
petition can be summarily dismissed if it does not
furnish cause of action in exercise of the powers
under the Code of Civil Procedure. So also it
emerges
from
the
aforesaid
decision
that
appropriate orders in exercise of powers under the
Code of Civil Procedure can be passed if the
mandatory requirements enjoined by Section 83 of
the Act to incorporate the material facts in the
election petition are not complied with. This Court
in Samant case [Samant N. Balkrishna v. George
Fernandez(1969) 3 SCC 238] has expressed itself
in no unclear terms that the omission of a single
material fact would lead to an incomplete cause of
action and that an election petition without the
material facts relating to a corrupt practice is not
an election petition at all. So also in Udhav Singh
case [Udhav Singh v. Madhav Rao Scindia(1977)
1 SCC 511] the law has been enunciated that all
the primary facts which must be proved by a party
to establish a cause of action or his defence are
material facts. In the context of a charge of corrupt
practice it would mean that the basic facts which
constitute the ingredients of the particular corrupt
practice alleged by the petitioner must be specified
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 84
in order to succeed on the charge. Whether in an
election petition a particular fact is material or not
and as such required to be pleaded is dependent
on the nature of the charge levelled and the
circumstances of the case. All the facts which are
essential to clothe the petition with complete
cause of action must be pleaded and failure to
plead even a single material fact would amount to
disobedience of the mandate of Section 83(1)(a).
An election petition therefore can be and must be
dismissed if it suffers from any such vice. The first
ground of challenge must therefore fail.
12. Learned counsel for the petitioner has next
argued that in any event the powers to reject an
election petition summarily under the provisions of
the Code of Civil Procedure should not be
exercised at the threshold. In substance, the
argument is that the court must proceed with the
trial, record the evidence, and only after the trial of
the election petition is concluded that the powers
under the Code of Civil Procedure for dealing
appropriately with the defective petition which
does not disclose cause of action should be
exercised. With respect to the learned counsel, it
is an argument which it is difficult to comprehend.
The whole purpose of conferment of such powers
is to ensure that a litigation which is meaningless
and bound to prove abortive should not be
permitted to occupy the time of the court and
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 85
exercise the mind of the respondent. The sword of
Damocles need not be kept hanging over his head
unnecessarily without point or purpose. Even in an
ordinary civil litigation the court readily exercises
the power to reject a plaint if it does not disclose
any cause of action. Or the power to direct the
concerned party to strike out unnecessary,
scandalous, frivolous or vexatious parts of the
pleadings. Or such pleadings which are likely to
cause embarrassment or delay the fair trial of the
action or which is otherwise an abuse of the
process of law. An order directing a party to strike
out a part of the pleading would result in the
termination of the case arising in the context of the
said pleading. The courts in exercise of the powers
under the Code of Civil Procedure can also treat
any point going to the root of the matter such as
one pertaining to jurisdiction or maintainability as
a preliminary point and can dismiss a suit without
proceeding to record evidence and hear elaborate
arguments in the context of such evidence, if the
court is satisfied that the action would terminate in
view of the merits of the preliminary point of
objection. The contention that even if the election
petition is liable to be dismissed ultimately it
should be so dismissed only after recording
evidence is a thoroughly misconceived and
untenable argument. The powers in this behalf are
meant to be exercised to serve the purpose for
which the same have been conferred on the
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 86
competent court so that the litigation comes to an
end at the earliest and the concerned litigants are
relieved of the psychological burden of the
litigation so as to be free to follow their ordinary
pursuits and discharge their duties. And so that
they can adjust their affairs on the footing that the
litigation will not make demands on their time or
resources, will not impede their future work, and
they are free to undertake and fulfil other
commitments. Such being the position in regard to
matter pertaining to ordinary civil litigation, there is
greater reason for taking the same view in regard
to matters pertaining to elections. So long as the
sword of Damocles of the election petition remains
hanging an elected member of the legislature
would not feel sufficiently free to devote his wholehearted attention to matters of public importance
which clamour for his attention in his capacity as
an elected representative of the concerned
constituency. The time and attention demanded by
his elected office will have to be diverted to
matters pertaining to the contest of the election
petition. Instead of being engaged in a campaign
to relieve the distress of the people in general and
of the residents of his constituency who voted him
into office, and instead of resolving their problems,
he would be engaged in campaign to establish that
he has in fact been duly elected. Instead of
discharging
his
functions
as
the
elected
representative of the people, he will be engaged in
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 87
a struggle to establish that he is indeed such a
representative, notwithstanding the fact that he
has in fact won the verdict and the confidence of
the electorate at the polls. He will have not only to
win the vote of the people but also to win the vote
of the court in a long drawn out litigation before he
can wholeheartedly engage himself in discharging
the trust reposed in him by the electorate. The
pendency of the election petition would also act as
hindrance if he be entrusted with some public
office in his elected capacity. He may even have
occasion to deal with the representatives of
foreign powers who may wonder whether he will
eventually succeed and hesitate to deal with him.
The fact that an election petition calling into
question his election is pending may, in a given
case, act as a psychological fetter and may not
permit him to act with full freedom. Even if he is
made of stern mettle, the constraint introduced by
the pendency of an election petition may have
some impact on his subconscious mind without his
ever being or becoming aware of it. Under the
circumstances, there is greater reason why in a
democratic set-up, in regard to a matter pertaining
to an elected representative of the people which is
likely to inhibit him in the discharge of his duties
towards the nation, the controversy is set at rest at
the earliest, if the facts of the case and the law so
warrant. Since the court has the power to act at
the threshold the power must be exercised at the
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 88
threshold itself in case the court is satisfied that it
is a fit case for the exercise of such power and that
exercise of such powers is warranted under the
relevant provisions of law. To wind up the
dialogue, to contend that the powers to dismiss or
reject an election petition or pass appropriate
orders should not be exercised except at the stage
of final judgment after recording the evidence even
if the facts of the case warrant exercise of such
powers, at the threshold, is to contend that the
legislature conferred these powers without point or
purpose, and we must close our mental eye to the
presence of the powers which should be treated
as non-existent. The court cannot accede to such
a proposition. The submission urged by the
learned counsel for the petitioner in this behalf
must therefore be firmly repelled.
….
18. The averments contained in para 4 pertaining
to Ground I do not satisfy the test prescribed
in ManubhaiAmorsey v. PopatlalManilal
Joshi and HardwariLal v. Kanwal Singh [(1972) 1
SCC 214 : AIR 1972 SC 515 : (1972) 2 SCR 742] .
The
most
important
test
which
remained
unsatisfied is as regards the omission to satisfy in
what manner the assistance was obtained and
procured by the election candidate for promoting
the prospects of his election. All that has been
stated is:
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 89
“His services were procured and obtained by
the respondent, his agents and other
persons with the consent of the respondent
with a view to assist the furtherance of the
prospects of the respondent's election....”
It is not mentioned as to who procured or obtained
the services of Shri Beg, in what manner he
obtained the services and what were the facts
which went to show that it was with the consent of
the respondent. Unless these “essential facts”
which would clothe the petition with a cause of
action and which will call for an answer from the
returned candidate are pleaded as per the law laid
down in Manubhai Nandlal Amorsey v. Popatlal
Manilal
Joshi [Manubhai
Nandlal
Amorsey v. Popatlal Manilal Joshi(1969) 1 SCC
372 : AIR 1969 SC 734 : (1969) 3 SCR 217] it
cannot be said that the petition discloses a cause
of action in regard to this charge. In the absence
of these material facts and particulars court could
not have rendered a verdict in favour of the
election petitioner in case the returned candidate
had not appeared to oppose the election petition.
It is not sufficient to show that a government
servant had appeared on the public media to
praise one of the candidates. It must also be
shown that the assistance of the government
servant was obtained either by the respondent or
his agent or by any other person with the consent
of the election candidate or his election agent. The
averments made in the petition do not show (i)
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 90
who had obtained or procured the assistance of
Shri Beg; (ii) how he had obtained or procured the
assistance of Shri Beg; and (iii) how it was said
that it was with the consent of the respondent or
his election agent. Nor is it shown which, if any,
facts went to show that it was in furtherance of the
prospects of the respondent's election. In the
absence of material facts and particulars in regard
to these aspects, the petition would not disclose
the cause of action. The High Court was therefore,
perfectly justified in reaching this conclusion. The
petition also does not disclose the exact words
used in the speech; or the time and date of making
such a speech. Now, unless the relevant or
offending passage from the speech is quoted, it
cannot be said what exactly Shri Beg had said,
and in what context, and whether it was calculated
to
promote
the
election
prospects
of
the
respondent. Be that as it may, inasmuch as these
material facts and particulars to show that the
services of Shri Beg were procured by someone
with the consent of the respondent or his election
agent are not there, the averments pertaining to
the charge do not disclose a cause of action.
Unless the nexus between the appearance of Shri
Beg on the media and the prior consent of the
respondent or his election agent in regard to what
he was going to say and the purposes for which
he was going to say is set out in the material
particulars it cannot be said that it disclosed a
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 91
cause of action and the test laid down in Manubhai
Nandlal case [(1972) 1 SCC 214 : AIR 1972 SC
515 : (1972) 2 SCR 742] as also Hardwari Lal
case [(1972) 1 SCC 214 : AIR 1972 SC 515 :
(1972) 2 SCR 742] is satisfied. The High Court
was therefore justified in taking the view that it has
taken. We may, in passing, mention a point made
by learned counsel for the respondent. It was
submitted that the averment must also mention
whether the interview was a live one telecast after
the date of filing of the nomination. If it was one
recorded prior to the said date it may not be of any
consequence.
This
argument
also
requires
consideration but we do not propose to rest our
conclusion on this aspect as it is not necessary to
do so.
…..
21. There is a glaring omission to mention the
names of the workers said to have been employed
by the respondent or his agents who have
allegedly painted the slogans. So also no material
particulars are given as regards the vehicles on
which the said slogans have been said to have
been painted. There are no material particulars or
facts. We are of the view that inasmuch as the
material facts and particulars in regard to this
alleged practice were not mentioned the High
Court was justified in taking the view that it had
taken. The averments contained in regard to this
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 92
charge also do not satisfy the test laid down by the
various
decisions
of
this
Court
adverted
hereinabove. A Division Bench of this Court
in Nihal Singh v. Rao Birendra Singh [(1970) 3
SCC 239] speaking through Bhargava, J. has
observed: (SCC p. 244, para 8)
“The pleading was so vague that it left a wide
scope to the appellant to adduce evidence in
respect of a meeting at any place on any date
that he found convenient or for which he
could procure witnesses. The pleading, in
fact, was so vague and was wanting in
essential particulars that no evidence should
have been permitted by the High Court on
this point.”
22. The principle laid down is that the pleading in
regard to matters where there is scope for
ascribing an alleged corrupt practice to a returned
candidate in the context of a meeting of which
dates and particulars are not given would
tantamount to failure to incorporate the essential
particulars and that inasmuch as there was a
possibility that witnesses could be procured in the
context of a meeting at a place or date convenient
for adducing evidence, the High Court should not
even have permitted evidence on that point. In
other words, no amount of evidence could cure the
basic defect in the pleading and the pleading as it
stood must be construed as one disclosing no
cause of action. In the light of the aforesaid
principle laid down by the Supreme Court which
has held the field for more than 15 years, the High
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 93
Court was perfectly justified in reaching the
conclusion called into question by the appellant.
….
25. In this case also, no time, date and place of the
speeches delivered by the respondent have been
mentioned. No exact extracts from the speeches
are quoted. Nor have the material facts showing
that such statements imputed to the respondent
were indeed made been stated. No allegation is
made to the effect that it was in order to prejudice
the election of any candidate. Or in order to further
the prospects of the election of the respondent.
The essential ingredients of the alleged corrupt
practice have thus not been spelled out. So far as
the meeting is concerned, the principle [ “... The
pleading was so vague that it left a wide scope to
the appellant to adduce evidence in respect of a
meeting at any place on any date that he found
convenient or for which he could procure
witnesses. The pleading, in fact, was so vague
and was wanting in essential particulars that no
evidence should have been permitted by the High
Court on this point....”] laid down in Nihal Singh
case [(1970) 3 SCC 239] discussed in the context
of the charge contained in ground II(i) is attracted.
The view taken by the High Court is therefore
unexceptionable.
……
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 94
28. It will be noticed that in the election petition it
has been mentioned that a copy of the poster
would be subsequently filed, and the cuttings of
some newspaper reports would also be filed later
on. The election petitioner sought an amendment
to delete the averments on both these aspects.
The High Court rejected the prayer in regard to
poster (Ex. B), but granted the prayer in respect of
the cuttings. The High Court has taken the view
that the poster was claimed to be an integral part
of the election petition and since it was not filed
(much less its copy furnished to the respondent)
the pleading suffered from infirmity and noncompliance with Section 83(1) read with Section
86(1) of the Act. Non-filing of the poster is fatal to
the election petition as in the absence thereof the
petition suffers from lack of material facts and
therefore the statement of cause of action would
be incomplete. Nothing turns on the fact whether
or not the words “a copy of the said poster would
be filed as Ex. B” are allowed to be retained in the
election petition or are deleted as prayed for by the
appellant. The fact remains that no copy of the
poster was produced. It must also be realized that
the election petitioner did not seek to produce the
copy of the poster, but only wanted a reference to
it deleted so that it cannot be said that the
accompaniments were not produced along with
the election petition. The fact remains that without
the production of the poster, the cause of action
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 95
would not be complete and it would be fatal to the
election petition inasmuch as the material facts
and particulars would be missing. So also it could
not enable the respondent to meet the case. Apart
from that the most important aspect of the matter
is that in the absence of the names of the
respondent's workers, or material facts spelling
out the knowledge and consent of the respondent
or his election agent, the cause of action would be
incomplete. So much so that the principle
enunciated
by
this
Court
in Nihal
Singh
case [(1970) 3 SCC 239] would be attracted. And
the court would not even have permitted the
election petitioner to lead evidence on this point.
The High Court was therefore fully justified in
taking the view that it has taken.”
81.
It is settled law that if the election petition is based
solely on the allegations which suffer from lack of material facts, the
election petition is liable to be summarily rejected for want of a
cause of action. Only material facts will show the ground of corrupt
practice and the complete cause of action. Only such particulars will
give the full picture of the cause of action. In the case on hand, the
election petition is bereft of material particulars.
82.
Pleadings do not merely define the issues between the
parties for the final decision of the Court at the trial, they manifest
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 96
and exert their importance throughout the whole process of the
litigation. They show on their face whether a reasonable cause of
action or defence is disclosed. They provide a guide for the proper
mode of trial and particularly for the trial of preliminary issues of law
or fact. They demonstrate upon which party the burden of proof lies,
and who has the right to open the case. They act as a measure for
comparing the evidence of a party with the case which he has
pleaded. They determine the range of the admissible evidence
which the parties should be prepared to adduce at the trial.
83.
Ordinarily, an application for rejection of election
petition in limine, purportedly under Order VII, Rule 11 CPC for nondisclosure of cause of action, ought to be considered at the
threshold.
For, it has to be considered only on the basis of
institutional defects in the election petition, in reference to the
grounds specified in clauses (a) to (f) of Rule 11.
Indeed, non-
disclosure of cause of action is covered by clause (a) therein.
Concededly, Order VII of the CPC generally deals with the
institution of a plaint. It delineates the requirements regarding the
particulars to be contained in the plaint, relief to be specifically
stated, for relief to be founded on separate grounds, procedure on
admitting plaint, and includes return of plaint.
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 97
84.
As held by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the cases of
Mayar (H.K.) Ltd. V. Vessel M.V. Fortune Express, (2006) 3 SCC
100 and Virender Nath Gautam v. Satpal Singh, (2007) 3 SCC
617, only the pleadings of the plaintiff/petitioner can be looked into
at the threshold.
85.
The power bestowed in the court in terms of Rule 11
of Order VII may also be exercised by the Court on a formal
application moved by the defendant after being served with the
summons to appear before the Court.
Be that as it may, the
application under Order VII Rule 11 deserves consideration at the
threshold.
86.
An election petition can be rejected under Order VII
Rule 11(a) CPC if it does not disclose a cause of action. Pleadings
could also be struck out under Order VI Rule 16, inter alia, if they
are scandalous, frivolous or vexatious.
87.
As discussed supra, election petition must contain a
concise statement of material facts on which the election petitioner
relies. It should also contain full particulars of any corrupt practice
that the election petitioner alleges including a full statement of
names of the parties alleged to have committed such corrupt
practice and the date and place of commission of such practice.
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 98
Such election petition shall be signed by the election petitioner and
verified in the manner laid down in the CPC for the verification of
pleadings.
It should be accompanied by an affidavit in the
prescribed form in support of allegation of such practice and
particulars thereof. All materials facts, therefore, in accordance with
the provisions of the Act, have to be set out in the election petition.
If the material facts are not stated in a petition, it is liable to be
dismissed on that ground as the case would be covered by clause
(a) of sub-section (1) of Section 83 of the Act read with clause (a)
of Rule 11 of Order 7 of the Code.
88.
In Anil Vasudev Salgaonkar, supra, the Hon’ble
Supreme Court held:
“50. The position is well settled that an election
petition can be summarily dismissed if it does
not furnish the cause of action in exercise of
the power under the Code of Civil Procedure.
Appropriate orders in exercise of powers
under the Code can be passed if the
mandatory requirements enjoined by Section
83 of the Act to incorporate the material facts
in the election petition are not complied with.
51. This
Court
in Samant
N.
Balkrishna
case [(1969) 3 SCC 238] has expressed itself in
no uncertain terms that the omission of a single
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 99
material fact would lead to an incomplete cause of
action and that an election petition without the
material facts relating to a corrupt practice is not
an
election
petition
at
all.
In Udhav
Singh v. Madhav Rao Scindia [(1977) 1 SCC 511]
the law has been enunciated that all the primary
facts which must be proved by a party to establish
a cause of action or his defence are material facts.
In the context of a charge of corrupt practice it
would mean that the basic facts which constitute
the ingredients of the particular corrupt practice
alleged by the petitioner must be specified in order
to succeed on the charge. Whether in an election
petition a particular fact is material or not and as
such required to be pleaded is dependent on the
nature
of
the
charge
levelled
and
the
circumstances of the case. All the facts which are
essential to clothe the petition with complete
cause of action must be pleaded and failure to
plead even a single material fact would amount to
disobedience of the mandate of Section 83(1)(a).
An election petition therefore can be and must be
dismissed if it suffers from any such vice. The first
ground of challenge must therefore fail.
…..
57. It is settled legal position that all “material
facts” must be pleaded by the party in support of
the case set up by him within the period of
limitation. Since the object and purpose is to
enable the opposite party to know the case he has
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 100
to meet with, in the absence of pleading, a party
cannot be allowed to lead evidence. Failure to
state even a single material fact will entail
dismissal of the election petition. The election
petition must contain a concise statement of
“material facts” on which the petitioner relies.
…..
61. The legal position has been crystallised by a
series of the judgments of this Court that all those
facts which are essential to clothe the election
petitioner with a complete cause of action are
“material facts” which must be pleaded, and the
failure to place even a single material fact amounts
to disobedience of the mandate of Section
83(1)(a) of the Act.”
[emphasis supplied]
In Shri Udhav Singh, supra, the Hon’ble Supreme
89.
Court held:
“42. All the primary facts which must be proved at
the trial by a party to establish the existence of a
cause of action or his defence, are “material facts”.
In the context of a charge of corrupt practice,
“material facts” would mean all the basic facts
constituting the ingredients of the particular
corrupt practice alleged, which the petitioner is
bound to substantiate before he can succeed on
that charge. Whether in an election petition, a
particular fact is material or not, and as such
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 101
required to be pleaded is a question which
depends on the nature of the charge levelled, the
ground relied upon and the special circumstances
of the case. In short, all those facts which are
essential to clothe the petitioner with a
complete cause of action, are “material facts”
which must be pleaded, and failure to plead
even a single material fact amounts to
disobedience of the mandate of Section
83(1)(a).”
[emphasis supplied]
90.
It is the duty of the Court to examine the plaint and it
need not wait till the defendant files written statement and points out
the defects. If the Court on examination of the plaint or the election
petition finds that it does not disclose any cause of action it would
be justified in striking out the pleadings.
91.
The object of the provisions of the Representation of
People Act, 1951 and the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 is to ensure
that meaningless litigation, which is otherwise bound to prove
abortive, should not be permitted to occupy the judicial time of the
Courts. If that is so in matters pertaining to ordinary Civil litigation,
it must apply with greater vigour in election matters where the
pendency of an election petition is likely to inhibit the elected
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 102
representative of the people in the discharge of his public duties for
which the electorate have reposed confidence in him.
92.
The entire election petition speaks about the affidavit
in Form 26 dated 05.02.2022 of the applicant and no nomination
paper dated 05.02.2022 of the applicant has been filed or enclosed
by the election petitioner in the election petition. On the other hand,
the election petitioner enclosed the affidavit in Form 26 of the
applicant dated 07.02.2022 and the entire pleadings of the election
petition speaks about the affidavit dated 05.02.2022 only.
Therefore, as rightly argued by learned senior counsel for the
applicant, the election petition of the election petitioner is liable to
be rejected, as there is no cause of action sans the contentious
affidavit dated 05.02.2022. The lacuna for deliberate mistake of not
enclosing the affidavit and nomination form dated 05.02.2022 and
another affidavit dated 05.02.2022 may not be allowed or rectified
under any circumstances as per the Representation of People Act,
1951. Thus, the argument of the learned senior counsel for the
election petitioner that in any case non-filing of material particulars
or non-filing of proper verification of violation of Chapter VII-A of the
Manipur High Court Rules, 2019 is a technical defect which is
curable and dismissal of the election petition under Order VII, Rule
11 CPC at the threshold on the aforesaid ground is not warranted,
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 103
cannot be countenanced. As stated supra, it is the bounden duty
of the election petitioner to furnish material particulars coupled with
proper verification.
93.
When this Court considers the case of the first
respondent/ election petitioner in the light of the contentions on
either side and the decisions supra, it is of the firm view that there
is no cause of action for filing the instant election petition. As stated
supra, the cause of action stated by the election petitioner in the
election petition is publication of result dated 10.03.2022 and no
other details have been mentioned in the cause of action
paragraph. The date of publication of result of the election alone
will not constitute the cause of action for challenging the election of
the applicant/returned candidate.
94.
This Court has also thoroughly considered the
averments made in the application under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC filed
on behalf of the applicant/returned candidate Leishangthem
Susindro Meitei (Yaima). As discussed herein above, since the first
respondent/election petitioner has utterly failed to disclose prima
facie triable issue and is not able to make out any cause of action
by way of pleadings from the pleadings made in the election petition
and in absence of material facts no cause of action is made out
which is essentially required as per the mandatory provisions of
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
P a g e | 104
Sections 100 and Section 83(1)(b) and other provisions of the
Representation of People Act, 1951 as well as the provisions of the
Code of Civil Procedure, the application under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC
filed by the applicant deserves to be allowed.
95.
In the result,
(a)
MC (Ele.Pet.) No.97 of 2022 is allowed.
(b)
Election Petition No.32 of 2022 stands rejected
on the ground that it does not make out any
cause of action or triable issue.
(c)
There will be no order as to costs.
ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE
FR/NFR
Sushil
MC(El.Pet.) No. 97 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 32 of 2022)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review