Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:MLHC:607
Serial No. 05
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 664 of 2025
Date of Decision:18.06.2026
Smti Legitha D. Sangma,
D/o (L) Hamingstone D. Sangma,
R/o Sunny Hills, Danakgre,
West Garo Hills District, Meghalaya
…. Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. State of Meghalaya represented by
Commissioner & Secretary of Excise Govt. of Meghalaya,
Shillong, East Khasi Hills.
2. The Deputy Commissioner (Excise), Tura,
West Garo Hills District, Meghalaya
3. The Superintendent of Excise,
West Garo Hills Tura, Meghalaya
4. Shri Sujin R. Sangma,
Pastor of Baptist Church Niksengggittim
R/o Niksenggittim, West Garo Hills District, Tura
5. Rev. Jack N. Sangma (Pastor in-charge)
R/o Tura Town, West Garo Hills District, Tura
6. Smti Silme Ch. Marak,
The President of Development Committee,
R/o Walbakgre, West Garo Hills District, Tura
7. Shri Teofield T. Sangma,
Secretary of Development Committee,
R/o Walbakgre, West Garo Hills District, Tura
… Respondent(s)
2026:MLHC:607
_______________________________________________________
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner(s)
: Mr. P.T. Sangma, Adv. with
Ms. J.T. Sangma, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. N.D. Chullai, AAG with
Ms. R. Colney, GA (For R 1-3)
Mr. C.C.T. Sangma, Adv. (For R 4-7)
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
Yes/No
in press:
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (ORAL)
1.
Yes/No
The brief facts are that the petitioner herein is a license
holder for a retail vend of IMFL granted vide Government approval
order dated 13.09.2022 at Jengjal market, West Garo Hills and had
been operating the wine shop at the said location without any
complaint or disturbances. The petitioner due to necessity and
convenience, had prayed before the respondent authority to allow the
shifting of the wine shop from Jengjal market to Danakgre opposite
BSF camp, West Garo Hills. Before making the request for shifting to
the new location, the petitioner obtained a No Objection Certificate
2026:MLHC:607
from the Headman of Danakgre Akhing, and on permission being
granted by the Excise Department vide order dated 29.01.2025, then
shifted her wine store from Jengjal market to Danakgre, Tura in the
month of January, 2025 itself. However, after running the wine store
for some time in spite of being in possession of all valid licensing and
permission, was directed by the respondent No. 3 (Superintendent of
Excise, Tura West Garo Hills) verbally, to close the said shop. Being
compelled to comply with the direction of the respondent No. 3, in
spite of having obtained the NOC from the Headman/Nokma and also
from the owner of the building where the wine store is located and
permission granted for shifting, the petitioner closed the said wine
store and the same has remained closed till date. Aggrieved with the
action of the respondent, the instant writ petition has been filed.
2.
Mr. P.T. Sangma, learned counsel for the petitioner has
submitted that the petitioner being a valid license holder which has
been duly renewed from time to time, and on the permission from the
Excise authorities, who allowed the shifting of the wine store from
Jengjal market to Danakgre, Tura after spot inspection, the action of
the respondent No. 3, due to pressure from certain quarters ,who are
against the sale of liquor, is illegal and has caused great financial loss
to the petitioner, who is a bona fide trader. He thus prays for orders to
2026:MLHC:607
direct the respondents to allow the petitioner to continue her business
without being disturbed.
3.
This Court on being seized of the matter vide order dated
16.12.2025, after noting the circumstances of the case was pleased to
direct as follows: “On hearing the learned counsel for the parties,
it is noted that it is not a case where the petitioner is
operating without any sanction of law, inasmuch as,
due process for transfer has also been allowed by the
Deputy Commissioner i.e., respondent No. 2 himself.
However, it appears due to the objections of certain
individuals, the petitioner’s business has been affected.
Though trade and liquor is not a right, but once having
been issued a valid license, it is expected that the State
respondents themselves will address the situation as not
to cause loss to any person. In the instant case, it is
noted that before the suspension of the activities, the
petitioner was never afforded any opportunity to even
present his case, and it appears the authorities have
acted on the complaints made by certain individuals.
In this view of the matter, the learned AAG is
directed to obtain instructions with regard to the vicinity
of the Retail Vend to any place of worship or
educational institutions, and also the respondent No. 2
is directed to convene a meeting between the petitioner
and the Headman within one week from today to
understand the issue, and to allow the petitioner to
present his case. The Deputy Commissioner is to take
appropriate action on hearing the Headman and the
petitioner, and he is also directed to examine the
feasibility of the shop being open without causing any
law and order problem.
List this matter on 09-02-2026 for further
orders.”
2026:MLHC:607
4.
The State respondents pursuant to the order of the Court
then submitted a Report dated 04.02.2026, enclosing Minutes of a
meeting dated 19.12.2025, which is reproduced hereinbelow: “MINUTES OF THE MEETING ON HIGH COURT
MATTER REGARDING WRIT PETITION OF SMT.
LEGITHA D. SANGMA VRS STATE OF MEGHALAYA &
OTHERS HELD ON THE 19 DECEMBER, 2025 AT 4:30
P.M. IN THE OFFICE CHAMBER OF THE DEPUTY
COMMISSIONER, WEST GARO HILLS, TURA.
Members present at Annexure -1
1.
The Deputy Commissioner welcomed all the attendees
and directed that the attendance of members present be
recorded.
2. The meeting was attended by the Aking Nokma of
Danakgre, Smt. Amanch Ch. Marak, the Licensee, Smt.
Legitha D. Sangma, and officers of the Excise Branch,
including Inspectors and Assistant Inspectors of Excise.
3. The Licensee, Smt. Legitha D. Sangma, submitted that she
has not violated any provisions of the Meghalaya Excise Act
and Rules and requested permission to reopen her IMFL
shop. She stated that the continued closure has caused her
substantial financial loss and hardship, particularly during
the festive season, and has adversely affected her ability to
maintain her family. She further contended that the
complaints lodged against her shop lack merit and may have
been motivated by reasons other than those stated in the
complaints.
4. The Enquiry Officer, Smt. Junshalline Ch. Marak, opined
that the licensee has complied with all statutory requirements
for operation of the wine shop and has not violated any
provisions of the Excise Act or Rules. She further stated that
2026:MLHC:607
the public opinion process was conducted following due
procedure.
5. The Aking Nokma stated that she had issued a No Objection
Certificate (NOC) for the licensed premises situated within her
A'king land at Danakgre. She clarified that the premises falls
within Danakgre locality and not any other locality, that nearby
churches are located well beyond the prescribed distance norms
under the Excise Rules, and that other Excise shops are
operating in the same locality without objection.
6. The Deputy Commissioner informed that a Senior Officer
would be directed to conduct a detailed enquiry into all issues
raised in the complaints. He further stated that the opinion of
the Superintendent of Police would be sought regarding law
and order implications, and that legal opinion would be
obtained. A final decision on reopening of the shop would be
taken strictly in accordance with the directions of the Hon'ble
High Court.
As there are no other matter to be discussed, the meeting
ended with a vote of thanks from the chair.
Sd/Deputy Commissioner (Excise)
West Garo Hills, Tura.”
6.
A perusal of the above noted Report would show that the
factum of the petitioner not violating any provisions of the Meghalaya
Excise Act and Rules has been recorded. However, in the said Report
itself, the Deputy Commissioner had informed that a detailed enquiry
into all issues would be gone into including the aspect of law-andorder implications.
2026:MLHC:607
7.
When the Report came up for consideration before this
Court, the learned counsel for the petitioner then submitted that though
the enquiry was held, a letter of the Inspector of Excise dated
12.08.2025, was not taken into consideration. By the said letter it was
submitted, the fact that the proposed location of the wine shop was at
a distance of 105 meters from another existing Bar, and that many
boot-legging liquor businesses were present in the locality as there was
no wine store, was not taken into account. This Court on the
submission of the learned AAG, then by order dated 02.03.2026,
directed the Deputy Commissioner to revisit the matter and to take all
circumstances into consideration, especially the inputs from the
Excise and Police Departments.
8.
On the next date of hearing i.e. 25.03.2026, the learned
AAG submitted the Minutes of the meeting of a Report dated
19.03.2026, which was conducted pursuant to the order 02.03.2026,
and the matter was then fixed on 26.03.2026. This Report being very
relevant is reproduced hereinbelow:“Minutes of the meeting on High Court matter regarding writ
petition of Smt. Legitha D. Sangma Vrs State of Meghalaya &
others held on 19 March 2026 in the office chamber of the
Deputy Commissioner, West Garo Hills, Tura at 4:00 PM.
Members Present in Annexure-1
2026:MLHC:607
The meeting was chaired by Shri Vibhor Aggarwal,
IAS, Deputy Commissioner, West Garo Hills, Tura who at the
outset welcomed all the members present in the meeting. He
then informed that the purpose of convening a meeting is to
discuss on the High Court Order No WP 9(C) No. 664 of 2025,
Dated 02-03-2026 pertaining to writ Petition Smt. Legitha D.
Sangma Vs State of Meghalaya & Others
The Deputy Commissioner. Tura then stated that as per
the direction received from the Hon'ble High Court, the
Deputy Commissioner (Excise) has to revisit the matter and
take all circumstances into consideration that needed to
complete within the period of three weeks with the inputs from
the Excise and Police Department. This time, along with Wine
shop owner. Excise officials, Tura Municipal representatives
and SP, complainants against the shop were also invited to
have a discussion and take their views into account.
The Deputy Commissioner started by informing the
complainants certain facts of matter including that the said
shop has not violated any norms of the Excise Rule and have
procured the permission as per the requirement for opening
of wine shop. He also mentioned about the report of Excise
officials which suggested that the re-opening of legal wine
shop can control the illegal selling of liquor of the area since
lot of boot-legging business has been going on in the area. The
Chairman then opened up the floor to the house to share their
views and suggestions on the matter.
The Representatives Members of the Locality
Development Committee of Walbakgre and Niksenggittim
Church and Tura Town Church complaint against the reopening of the wine shop and expressed the sentiments of the
local resident under Walbakgre Area were hurt. They
mentioned that the shop was opened without consultation with
their locality and stated that they do not want any wine shop
in the area.
Regarding the matter of shop already given permission
as per norms, the locality and church leaders stated that there
is the requirement of taking public opinion into consideration
2026:MLHC:607
and that the public opinion was clearly not in favour of the
shop and all people of that area are vehemently against
opening of the shop. The Excise officials were asked as to how
the people were invited in the original meeting to take public
opinion for shifting the shop, to which they replied that the
original meeting was called through Nokma of Danakgre
under whose jurisdiction the shop falls.
The Representative of the Tura Municipal Board, Tura,
has clarified that Walbakgre locality does not fall under the
municipal area and, therefore, is not under the jurisdiction of
any development committee. The shop is approximately 200
meters away from Tura Town Church and Niksengittim
Church and the nearest educational institution and atleast
300 metres away from nearest development committee, the
Walbakgre Dev Committee whose members were present in
the meeting as complainants against the shop.
Regarding the question of boot-legging being rampant
in the area, the complainants acknowledged the problem.
Addressing the matter the Superintendent of Police, Tura also
shared that in the area of the existing location of the wine
shop, complaint has been reported for many boot legging
businesses in the area and asked the locality leaders to give
written complaint against the illegal businesses for police to
take necessary action on the illegal selling and stop the black
market in and around the adjoining area. The Chairman also
suggested that re-opening of legal wine shop can control the
illegal selling of liquor. However, the complainants still stood
their ground that they do not want any wine shop in the area.
Regarding the question of another IMFL 'On' shop
present in the area just 105 metres from the wine shop in
question, the locality members claimed that the restaurant
cum bar was opened with the blessings and prayer of church.
The Representative Members then request Smt. Legitha
D. Sangma to shift the wine shop to another location. They
also expressed their objection to re-opening of the wine shop
in the locality to avoid chances of coming up of more wine
shop in the area. They also requested the shop owner to
2026:MLHC:607
provide written assurance for shifting of wine shop with
specific time
Smt. Legitha D. Sangma (Licensee) urged that the
IMF1. shop was open as per the norms under Meghalaya
Excise Act and Rules and requested to the Development
Committee Members to not to disrupt the opening of her
wineshop as sustainable financial loss has incurred due
continuous closure of the shop for last 13 months. She further
informed that the wine shop was opened without violating the
provisions of the Excise Act or Rule and after obtaining NOC
From Danakgre Nokma and meeting was convened as
required under Excise Norms.
The locality leaders and Church members continued
their opposition to the wine shop till the end and at the
insistence of Deputy Commissioner if they want to go back and
discuss the matter again with public, said that the public has
already expressed their opposition to the wine shop and no
further discussion was required with public.
As there is no more agenda to discuss the meeting ended
with a vote of thanks by the Chairman.
Sd/(Vibhor Aggarwal, IAS),
Deputy Commissioner (Excise).
West Guro Hills, Tura.”
(Emphasis supplied)
9.
This Court then by order dated 26.03.2026, which is
reproduced hereinbelow, apart from noting that the wine store was
within the prescribed legal parameters, also directed the impleadment
of the persons who had been mentioned in the Report as they were the
ones who had raised objections: -
2026:MLHC:607
“Mr. N.D.Chullai, learned AAG assisted by Ms.
R.Colney, learned GA for the respondents, today has apprised
the Court that as per the Meghalaya Excise Act, the distance
as per Rule 183 (2) (a), No IMFL and Beer retail ‘OFF’ and
“ON’ license shall be established in any area within a distance
of 200 (two hundred) meters from any place of public worship
or educational institution or hospital.
In the instant case, it is noted that in the Minutes of the
meeting held on 19-03-2026, it has been categorically
recorded that the wineshop of the petitioner is approximately
200 meters away from Tura Town Church and the
Niksenggittim Baptist Church, and also the nearest
educational institution is at least 300 metres away from the
nearest development committee i.e. the
Walbakgre
Development Committee, whose members were present in the
meeting. It appears therefore, that the petitioner, apart from
possessing a valid license to operate the wineshop also comes
within the exemptions provided under the Meghalaya Excise
Act. However, as objections in the meeting have been raised
by the persons who have been noted at page 3 of the report at
Sl. No. 3, 4 & 5, before the matter is disposed of, the petitioner
is directed to put in an appropriate application for impleading
the said persons.
List this matter on 09-04-2026.
Mr. N.D.Chullai, learned AAG also prays for and is
allowed to bring the Minutes of the meeting on record by way
of an affidavit.”
10.
The petitioner in compliance with this Court’s directions
in order dated 26.03.2026, then filed a Misc. Case being MC (WPC)
No. 112 of 2026 for impleadment of 3(three) persons who had
objected to the wine store, as respondents Nos. 4, 5, 6 & 7, which was
allowed by this Court by order dated 09.04.2026, passed in the said
2026:MLHC:607
Misc. Case. The newly impleaded respondents thereafter, entered
appearance on 21.05.2026, and were allowed 2(two) weeks’ time to
file affidavit.
11.
On oral arguments, Mr. N.D. Chullai, learned AAG
assisted by Ms. R. Colney, learned GA for the respondents Nos. 1, 2
& 3, has submitted that the wine store of the petitioner fulfills the legal
requirements as per the Meghalaya Excise Act and Rules, and that the
fact that the location of the wine store is not within a distance of 200
meters from any place of worship, educational institution or hospital,
has well been established in the enquiry, and as such it conforms to
the requirement of Rule 183 (2)(a). It is further submitted that even as
per Rule 191, which is with regard to ascertainment of local public
opinion regarding the number and location of excise shop, the location
of the wine store not being under the Tura Municipality, Rule 191
(i)(a) will not be applicable, and as such objections from local bodies
therein, would not come into play and rather Rule 191 (ii) (a) would
be attracted, wherein only the objections of the owners or occupiers of
land are to be considered. The learned AAG then also submits that the
Minutes of the meeting dated 19.03.2026 being taken into record, this
Court may be pleased to pass necessary orders.
2026:MLHC:607
12.
Mr. C.C.T. Sangma, learned counsel for the respondents
Nos. 4 to 7, has submitted that as there was public opposition to the
opening of the wine store of the petitioner, the All Walbakgre
Development Committee, held a meeting on 21.01.2025, wherein it
was resolved that a formal petition or complaint, be filed before the
Deputy Commissioner (Excise)/respondent No. 2. Thereafter, he
submits a meeting had been convened by the respondent No. 3 on
20.08.2025, and that in the said meeting it was ascertained that only
21 persons are in favour and 73 persons against the opening of the
wine store. With regard to the fact that in the Report dated 19.03.2026,
it was recorded that there was another IMFL ‘ON’ (Restaurant-cumBar) shop present in the area just 105 meters away from the wine shop
in question, which the locality members had stated was opened with
the blessings and prayer of the Church, the learned counsel has
submitted that the blessings had been given by Church members and
elders of the locality, as they were not aware that the said Restaurant
would be serving alcoholic beverages. Learned counsel submits that
the same Development Committee had resolved on 14.05.2026, for
necessary measures to be taken against the said Restaurant-cum-Bar
by filing a complaint and that this has been done on 04.06.2026. He
therefore, submits that the prayer of the petitioner be rejected and the
2026:MLHC:607
writ petition dismissed in consideration of the objections from the
local bodies and individuals. The learned counsel has relied upon a
Judgement of this Court in the case of Rishan Pariat vs. State of
Meghalaya & Ors. reported in 2025 SCC OnLine Megh 1223 to
contend that such matter deserves the consideration of the local
community in terms of Rule 191 of the Meghalaya Excise Act, as
adopted.
13.
In the backdrop of the facts, events and submissions that
has been discussed and narrated above, firstly from the aspect of the
statutory requirement as stipulated by Rule 183 (2)(a) of the
Meghalaya Excise Rules, as amended, which strictly prohibits the
setting up of a Retail Liquor Vend within a 200 meter radius from
places of public worships, hospitals or educational educations, the
petitioner’s wine store as per the Reports is in compliance with the
provision. The second aspect is that the wine store has been
established by the petitioner by obtaining a valid license under the
Rules and an NOC also obtained from the land owner in question, as
per requirement of Rule 191 (b)(ii)(a), which provides that in cases of
areas not situated in a Municipality/Town Committee, the objections
of the owners or occupiers were to be considered. Thirdly, is the fact
that the shifting of the location from Jengjal to Danakgre was duly
2026:MLHC:607
sanctioned and allowed by the competent authority, vide order dated
29.01.2025. Thus, the wine store of the petitioner fulfilled all the
conditions necessary for operating the wine store at the new location.
14.
The other aspect which however has given rise to the present
issue, is the complaints and objections raised by the respondents Nos.
4 to 7, which prima facie show are based on moral grounds, rather than
legal or other substantial grounds, that would warrant the revocation
of the license and permission accorded to the petitioner by the Excise
authorities. The Reports dated 19.12.2025 and 19.03.2026, which have
been quoted earlier in this judgment apart from other facts, have
however also revealed the existence of another establishment i.e. a
Restaurant-cum-Bar at a distance of 105 meters away from the wine
store of the petitioner, and also the rampant illegal sale of liquor in the
area itself. The objections therefore, of the respondents Nos. 4 to 7,
appear to be unsustainable as first even factually, from the proximity
view point, the Churches which they represent are located more than
200 meters away, coupled with the fact that an establishment with an
‘ON’ license is doing business in the vicinity legally. A further
consideration that the presence of a legal Retail Vend would surely
curb the illegal sale of liquor in the area, also appears to have been
overlooked.
2026:MLHC:607
15.
In the circumstances of the case therefore, though a citizen
has no fundamental right to trade or do business in liquor, the same
however, being regulated by the State under the Meghalaya Excise Act
and Rules, which places restrictions and limitations on such trade of
business, the satisfaction or fulfillment of conditions as prescribed,
would surely vest the petitioner with a legal right which cannot be
taken away except by due process. In the instant case, the petitioner
having the requisite licence and permission as stipulated under the
Rules, and the objections of the respondents Nos. 4 to 7, being
unsustainable in law, there is no reason that they should be a
prohibition by the authorities in allowing the petitioner, to operate the
wine store at the new location.
16.
It is thus ordered accordingly and the writ petition is
allowed and disposed of.
JUDGE
Meghalaya
18.06.2026
“V. Lyndem-AR-PS”
VALENTINO LYNDEM
Date: 2026.06.19 19:49:32 IST
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review