Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[1]
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RSA No.4 of 2023
1. On the death of Late Nantu Ghosh,
S/O- Late Radha Ballav Ghosh,
His legal heirs and representatives:1(a). Smti. Niva Rani Ghosh,
W/O. late Nantu Ghosh.
1(b). Sri Biki Ghosh, Age 31 years
S/O. Late Nantu Ghosh
1(c). Sri Jeki Ghosh, Age 25 years
S/O Late Nantu Ghosh
All are residents of Dharmanagar,
P.O. & P.S. Teliamura,
District Khowai, Tripura.
---Appellant(s)
Versus
1. Sri Litu Acharjee,
S/O- Late Dinesh Acharjee,
Presently residing at Ward No.10
Algapur, Chararpar, Dharmanagar,
P.O. Dharmanagar, P.S. Dharmanagar,
District North Tripura, PIN-799250.
Represented by son, appointed General
Power of Attorney Sri Raju Acharjee,
S/O. Sri Litu Acharjee of Kali Tilla,
P.O. Teliamura, P.S. Teliamura,
District Khowai, PIN-799205,
As per GPA Deed No.00292 dated 26.03.2016,
Being No.00010, Sub-Registry Office Teliamura,
2. Sri Raju Acharjee,
S/O. Sri Litu Acharjee,
Resident of Kali Tilla, P.O. Teliamura,
P.S. Teliamura, District Khowai, Tripura.
[2]
(son of the deceased Plaintiff).
3. Smti. Doli Acharjee(Nama Das),
D/O. Sri Litu Acharjee,
W/O. Sri Narendra Nama Das,
Resident of Matarbari, P.S. R.K. Pur,
District Gomati.
(daughter of the deceased Plaintiff).
4. Sri Rajib Acharjee,
S/O. Sri Litu Acharjee,
Resident of Kali Tilla, P.O. Teliamura,
P.S. Teliamura, District Khowai, Tripura.
(Son of the deceased Plaintiff).
5. Smti. Rupa Acharjee(Chakraborty),
D/O. Sri Litu Acharjee,
W/O. Late Tapas Chakraborty,
Resident of Ramnagar-8,
P.S. Ramnagar, Agartala,
District West Tripura.
(daughter of the deceased Plaintiff).
6. Sri Sanjoy Acharjee,
S/O- Sri Litu Acharjee
Resident of Kali Tilla, P.O. Teliamura,
P.S. Teliamura, District Khowai, Tripura.
(Son of the deceased Plaintiff).
---Respondent(s)
For the Appellant(s)
:
Mr. P. K. Dhar, Sr. Advocate
Mr. R. Debnath, Advocate
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Ratan Datta, Advocate
Ms. K. Roy Barman, Advocate
Date of hearing and
Delivery of Judgment & Order
:
22.05.2023
Whether fit for reporting
:
Yes
[3]
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
The present second appeal is directed against the judgment
and decree dated 21.12.2022, passed in T.A. No. 13 of 2019 by the Ld.
District Judge, Khowai District, Khowai upholding the judgment and
decree dated 20.04.2019, passed in TS No.06 of 2016 by learned Civil
Judge (Junior Division), Khowai.
2. The facts, as projected by learned first appellate court, may be
produced here-in-below:“2.
Factual backdrop leading to the instant appeal is that the
suit land was allotted to the plaintiff respondent no.1 along with his
deceased wife Anjali Acherjee (plaintiff no.2 of the original suit.
Respondent no. 2 to 5 are the legal heirs of Anjali Acherjee. The
Respondent No. 1 and respondent no 2 to 5 had been residing in the
allotted land by constructing a house. In 2000 when the wife of
respondent no.1 came to know about the second marriage of
respondent no. 1 a matrimonial dispute cropped up between
respondent no. 1 and his wife. Ultimately the respondent no.1 left his
wife and his children. Then plaintiff no. 2 (now deceased) took
shelter at her parental home with her children at Kalitalla,
Teliamura. The house was given on rent to one Tanu Ghosh. Lt.
Anjali Acherjee was a maid servant and had to depend on the rent.
Tanu Ghosh resided in that house for a long period. As Lt. Anjali
Acherjee was not financially sound she permitted Tanu Ghosh to
construct a room on the suit land on condition that amount spent for
the construction of the room would be adjusted with the rent. Tanu
Ghosh committed suicide in the said house but his family continued
to stay in the suit land as tenant. When the wife of Tanu Ghosh left
the rented house the present appellant came in the house as tenant.
He took the entire house on rent @ Rs. 2000/- per month. After that
the appellant told the land lady about the urgent repairing works for
which money was required. As the land lady expressed her inability
[4]
to invest money for repairing the house, it was decided that the
tenant would repair the house and the repairing expenses would be
deducted from the monthly rent @ Rs.1000/- and remaining. Rs.
1000/- would be given to the land lady. After completion of repairing
works the appellant showed Rs. 1,25,000/- as expenditure then it
was decided to deduct Rs. 1,000/- from monthly rent. By 1st October
2015 the total investment was adjusted. In November 2015 the
landlady told the appellant to vacate the suit land as it was required
for her elder son for dwelling. On 30.12.2015 the appellant denied to
vacate the house. Hence, the original suit for declaration of right,
title, interest and for recovery of possession against the appellant
Nantu Ghosh. On the other hand the defendant appellant contested
the suit by submitting written statement denying the allegation made
by the plaintiff respondent and stating inter-alia that the suit is hit by
Sec.106 and 111 of the transfer of Property Act (T. P. Act). The
respondents are not the owners of the suit land. The fact is that on
03.08.1994 Sri Litu Acherjee and his deceased wife Anjali Acherjee
transferred the possession of the suit land by executing an
unregistered deed and handed over the physical possession of the
suit land to one Pankaj Kr.Ghosh. After the death of Pankaj Kr.
Ghosh the suit land was transferred by his legal heirs to the
appellant through an unregistered sale deed on 26.05.2005. Since
then the appellant has been possessing the suit land. It is alleged that
the suit land had not been in possession of the respondents from
1994. The respondents sold the suit land in 1994.”
2.1
On the basis of aforesaid facts, the learned trial court had
framed following issues:“(i) Whether the instant suit is maintainable in its present form?
(ii) Who is having the possession of the suit land?
(iii) Whether the defendant was ever the tenant under the plaintiffs or
paid any rent?
(iv) Whether the defendant is liable to be evicted from the suit
land?
(v) Whether the plaintiffs have any title over the suit land?
(vi) Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to possession of the suit
land?
(vi) Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to any other relief / reliefs?”
[5]
2.2.
The learned trial court on consideration of the evidence and
materials on record decreed the suit in favour of the plaintiffs declaring
the right, title and interest in favour of the plaintiffs and also had
passed a decree asking the defendant to handover the possession of the
suit land to the plaintiff.
2.3.
Being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the judgment and
order passed by the learned trial court, the defendant had preferred first
appeal before the court of the learned District Judge, Khowai, Tripura.
2.4.
From the judgment of learned first appellate court, it comes
to fore that while hearing the first appeal, the defendant-appellant had
raised the following grounds to set aside the judgment and decree
passed by the learned trial court:“(i) Ld Trial Court has committed serious error while passing
the impugned judgment. The respondents filed the suit for recovery
of possession under Section 5 of the Specific Relief Act, but in the
plaint, the plaintiffs stated that the defendant-appellant is the tenant
of the respondents. It is the provision of law that section 5 of the
Specific Relief Act would come after termination of lease by the
lessor, in this case lease between the parties was/is not terminated
and the lease between the parties is in force and keeping the said
lease in force, the lessee cannot be evicted by the lessor under
section 5 of the Specific Relief Act.
(ii) Section 106 (1) of the Transfer of Property Act, mandates
that in the absence of a contract or local law or usage to the
contrary, a lease of immovable property for agricultural or
manufacturing purposes shall be deemed to be a lease from year to
year, terminable, on the part of either lessor or lessee, by six months
notice, and a lease of immovable property for any other purpose
shall be deemed to be a lease from month to month, terminable, on
the part of either lessor or lessee, by fifteen days, notice but in this
case no notice terminating the lease between the parties was served
by the respondents. Therefore, the judgment passed by the Ld trial
[6]
Court finding the suit is maintainable as per law is perverse in the
eye of law.
(iii) Section 106(4) of the Transfer of Property Act also
mandates the every notice under sub-section (1) must be in writing,
signed by or on behalf of the person giving it, and either be sent by
post to the party who is intended to be bound by it or be tendered or
delivered personally to such party, or to one of his family or servants
at his residence, or not practicable affixed to a conspicuous part of
the property but in this case, the said mandatory provision was not
complied with. So, the finding of the learned trial court below that
the suit is maintainable is perverse in the eye of law.
(iv) It is stated by the respondents in their plaint that the
defendant-appellant was their tenant and he has been possessing the
premises of long period but they have not given any notice under
Section 106 of the Transfer of Property Act before instituting the
suit. It is mandatory provision of law that without any notice when
such suit is instituted, the suit should have been shot down at the
threshold but the learned court has completely misconstrued the
provision of issuance of notice under section 106 of the Transfer of
Property Act is concerned and reluctantly the said suit has been held
to be maintainable but the said finding is totally erroneous against
law.
(v) Ld trial court has erroneously found that the suit is maintainable
and no notice under section 106 of the Transfer of Property Act is
required as it is not merely a suit for eviction of tenant or
determination of tenancy, rather it is a suit for declaration of right,
title and interest of the plaintiff-respondents and recovery of
possession of the suit land but the learned trial court below failed to
understand that unless the tenancy/lease between the parties is
terminated the tenant cannot be evicted and the leasehold premises
cannot be vacated from the hands of the tenants by applying section
5 of the Specific Relief Act.
”
2.5.
At para-5 of the said judgment, the first appellate court had
observed thus:“5.
that :-
The striking points as appear from the evidence on record
[7]
i)The main plea of the appellant is that he is the owner of the
suit land as he purchased it from D.W.2 by way of an unregistered
sale deed.
ii)From the Khatian no.2652(Exbt.1) it appears that the suit
land was allotted to the respondent no. 1 Litu Acherjee and his
deceased wife Anjali Acherjee and it could not be transferred
without the permission of the collector.
As per Sec. 43(3) of the Tripura Land Revenue and Land
Reforms Act, 1960 (TLR & LR Act) every entry in the finally
published Khatian (Record of Rights) shall be presumed to be
correct unless the contrary is proved. There is no evidence on record
which shows that there was permission of the collector to transfer
the allotted land.
So, in view of the discussion made above specially in view
of Section 43 (3) of the TLR & LR Act, the Ld Trial Court rightly
decided that the respondents were the real owners and possessors of
the suit land.
iii) As the suit land could not be transferred without the
permission of the collector, any kind of sale is void. So, the plea of
the appellant as to the fact that the suit land was transferred to the
appellant by way of unregistered sale deed cannot be considered.
iv) The appellant also took the plea that the instant suit is hit by
Sec. 106 of T.P Act as according to the respondents the appellant
was their tenant. So, a notice should have been issued U/S 106 of T.P
Act.
Here, the judgment passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court
in Rattan Lal Vs Vardesh Chander (AIR 1976 SC 588) is very
much relevant. Hon’ble apex court clearly said that in a suit for
the ejectment of tenant, where the landlord obtains decree for
ejectment, it amounts to the termination of tenancy. Notice under
S. 106 is not necessary.
So, in the instant case no notice U/S 106 of T.P Act is
necessary.
6.
During argument Ld Advocate of the respondents Mr. D
Debnath submitted that in the written statement the appellant
claimed that he is the owner of the suit land. In 1994 the plaintiffrespondent sold the suit land in consideration of money. In 2005 the
appellant purchased the suit land from one Sabita Rani Ghosh by
way of unregistered sale deed and accordingly he has been
possessing the suit land from 2005. If it is so, why the appellant is
taking the plea that the case is hit by Section 106 of Transfer
of Property Act as according to the appellant there is no tenancy
between the appellant and the respondents.
[8]
7.
The point raised by Ld. Advocate of the appellant is a mere
technicality.
Hence, I am of the view that Ld. Civil Judge (Jr. Div),
Khowai rightly declared that the plaintiffs have right, title and
interest over the suit land measuring 06 satak under Khatian
No.2652, Mouja-Krishnapur (described specially in the schedule to
the judgment) and also declared that the plaintiffs are entitled to
recover their possession over the suit land measuring 06 satak under
Khatian No.2652, Mouja-Krishnapur (declared specially in the
schedule to the judgment) & the defendant is directed to vacate his
illegal possession over the suit land at his own cost at the earliest.”
Having held so, the first appellate court had dismissed the
appeal.
3.
Feeling aggrieved by the judgment and decree passed by
learned first appellate court, the defendant/appellant has preferred the
instant second appeal before this Court.
4.
At the time of admission of this appeal, this Court vide order
dated 29.03.2023 had formulated the following substantial question of
law:“Whether the findings of both the courts are perverse?”
5.
On the basis of aforesaid substantial question of law, both the
learned counsel appearing for the parties have agreed to proceed with
the hearing of this appeal.
6.
by
I have heard Mr. P. K. Dhar, learned senior counsel assisted
Mr.
R.
Debnath,
learned
counsel
appearing
for
the
defendant/appellant. Also heard Mr. Ratan Datta, learned counsel and
Ms.
K.
Roy
Barman,
plaintiff/respondents.
learned
counsel
appearing
for
the
[9]
7.
Mr. Dhar, learned senior counsel for the defendant/appellant
has submitted that in the instant suit the plaintiff have not sought for
declaration of right, title and interest over the suit land and for this
reason the suit for recovery of possession is not maintainable at all.
Another question, Mr. Dhar, learned senior counsel has raised
that learned trial court has not framed any issue as regards the validity
of the sale deed under which the defendant/appellant has claimed title.
Mr. Dhar, learned senior counsel has further submitted that
the plaintiff has failed to establish their title over the suit land and for
that reason they are not entitled for a declaration of right, title and
interest over the suit land and cannot seek recovery of Khas possession
of the said land from the defendant/appellant.
Mr. Dhar, learned senior counsel most emphatically
submitted that Record of Right/Khatian does not confer title upon
anyone.
8.
On the other hand, Mr. Datta, learned counsel for the
plaintiff/respondents has submitted that plaintiff/respondents have
acquired the title of the suit on the basis of allotment. In the Khatian
itself, the plaintiff/respondents have been shown as allottee.
9.
It is apparent on the face of the record that learned trial court
had framed specific issues as regards the title of the parties that
“Whether the defendant was ever the tenant under the plaintiffs or paid
[10]
any rent?” and “Whether the plaintiff have any title over the suit
land?”.
10.
On the basis of above issues, I have taken into consideration
the submission of Mr. Dhar, learned senior counsel as regards his plea
which he raised in this second appeal that learned trial court had not
framed any issue to substantiate the title of the defendant/appellant.
11.
In my opinion, this question raised by learned senior counsel
for the defendant/appellant is well covered within the issues “Whether
the defendant was ever the tenant under the plaintiffs or paid any rent”
and “Whether the plaintiffs have any title over the suit land”.
12.
Most importantly, the defendant/appellant in his pleadings
and evidence has clearly stated that he purchased the suit land from one
Sabita Rani Ghosh by an unregistered sale deed and, by dint of that
unregistered sale deed he became the owner and possessor of the suit
land
and
denied
his
possession
as
tenant
under
the
that
the
plaintiff/respondents.
13.
After
perusal
of
the
records,
I
find
defendant/appellant has failed to adduce any evidence that Sabita Rani
Ghosh acquired any title at any point of time over the suit land.
No document had been introduced to substantiate the fact that
Sabita Rani Ghosh was the owner of the suit land. On the other hand,
[11]
Plaintiff/respondents had introduced the Record of Right where their
names have been shown as „allottee‟.
14.
Furthermore, on these issues, both the courts below held that
the defendant/appellant cannot claim title on the basis of an
unregistered sale deed because Section 17 of the Registration Act
clearly provides that a document having consideration money of more
than Rs.100/- must be registered.
15.
Mr. Dhar, learned senior counsel for the defendant/appellant
has tried to persuade this Court that under Section 49 of the
Registration Act, an unregistered sale deed can be used for collateral
purpose to prove ones title.
16.
I respectfully disagree with this submission of learned senior
counsel for the reason that this aspect has specifically dealt with by the
legislature in Section 49 of the Registration Act itself. By way of
inclusion of proviso under Section 49 of the Registration Act,
legislatures have made it clear that such unregistered document can be
used for collateral purpose in a case of specific performance of
contract, but not to use it for claiming title because of clear bar
embodied in Section 17 of the Registration Act.
17.
Both the Courts below held that Rule 12 of Tripura Land
Revenue and Land Reforms(Allotment of Land) Rules, 1980 states that
the allotted land will be heritable and not alienable without the written
[12]
consent of the collector granted on the recommendation of the advisory
committee that may be set up by the Government . In the instant case
the suit land is an allotted land and the Collector has not cancelled the
said allotment within a reasonable period of time, that is, within
3(three) years from the date of allotment as held by this Court in a
catena of judgments, hence, it cannot be transferred without the process
of law as mentioned above.
18.
In view of above discussion, I find no force in the submission
of learned senior counsel appearing for the defendant/appellant that
both the courts below failed to deal with the issue of title as regards
plaintiff/respondents as well as defendant/appellant. Accordingly, this
submission is repelled.
19.
Now, coming to the question about the legal status of Record
of Rights/Khatian, needless to say, Khatian is not a document of title,
but, it provides a presumption of possession on behalf of a party unless
and until it is rebutted by appropriate evidence. However, in the case at
hand,
in
the
Khatian
there
is
clear
mention
that
the
plaintiff/respondents are the allottee of the suit land. Section 43(3) of
the Tripura Land Revenue and Land Reforms Act, 1960 clearly states
that every entry in the Record of Rights as finally published shall be
presumed to be correct unless the contrary is proved. Section 43(3) of
TLR and LR Act may be reproduced hereunder:-
[13]
“(3) Every entry in the record of rights as finally published
shall, until the contrary is proved, be presumed to be correct.”
There is absolutely no evidence that this record of right
created in favour of plaintiffs/respondents has ever challenged by the
defendant/appellant to dispute the title of the plaintiffs/respondents.
20.
In the light of above discussion, I may unhesitantly come to a
conclusion that the defendant/appellant herein has failed to adduce any
evidence to controvert or dispute the Record of Right created in favour
of the plaintiffs/respondents. As such, it can easily be said that the
plaintiffs/respondents have acquired title by dint of allotment.
For the reasons stated and the analysis made on legal issues
here-in-above, I do not find any material in the instant case, to interfere
with the judgments and decrees passed by the courts below.
Accordingly, the instant second appeal stands dismissed.
However, there shall be no order as to costs.
Send down the LCRs forthwith.
JUDGE
Rohit
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review